who is the most talented actor among these...a discussion!!
Thread started by raghavendran on 6th August 2009 12:25 PM
Responses:
-
From: viraajan on 6th August 2009 12:30 PM [Full View]
Maddy... Maddy.... Oh Oh Maddy...
-
From: NOV on 6th August 2009 12:51 PM [Full View]
SP, please come campaign for maddy; thats the only way Surya can win.
-
From: Sourav on 6th August 2009 12:57 PM [Full View]
athan surya side neenga irukkeengala...tough-a than irukkum...
Originally Posted by NOV
SP, please come campaign for maddy; thats the only way Surya can win.
-
From: NOV on 6th August 2009 01:00 PM [Full View]
enna pandradu, there are guys who sincerely think that Surya is better than Maddy but are forced to vote for Maddy.
-
From: Sourav on 6th August 2009 01:04 PM [Full View]
ippo feel panni enna use, athai neenga maddy-ku vote panrathukku munnadiye yosichirukkanum... Originally Posted by NOV
there are guys who sincerely think that Surya is better than Maddy but are forced to vote for Maddy.
-
From: viraajan on 6th August 2009 01:05 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by NOV
enna pandradu, there are guys who sincerely think that Surya is better than Maddy but are forced to vote for Maddy.
FCFS basis 
-
From: Appu s on 6th August 2009 01:07 PM [Full View]
Re: who is themost talended actor among these...a discussion
Maddy was Hero when he done a movies like Minnale ,Run.he failed to sustain that Hero image. how ever he is better natural actor than surya . Originally Posted by raghavendran
Theerppu solliyachu
-
From: Shakthiprabha on 6th August 2009 01:12 PM [Full View]
All guys are JEALOUS OF MADDY. over and out. I aint gonna talk esp when nov is around
-
From: NOV on 6th August 2009 01:14 PM [Full View]
you too have voted for Surya
p/s: I am not jealous of Maddy; in fact he is in my good books.
-
From: NOV on 6th August 2009 01:16 PM [Full View]
and thanks for the subtle campaign.
I hope it will work
-
From: MADDY on 6th August 2009 01:42 PM [Full View]
hey the title should read Maddy v Surya.....
......Madhavan Trailing - come on guys 
adhu yean ella kamal fansum surya-kku dhaan vote poduraanga??? its infact a surprise that more rajini fans prefer madhavan (or is it just a negligible trend?)
-
From: NOV on 6th August 2009 01:46 PM [Full View]
I disagree. Originally Posted by MADDY
Maddy is not disagreeable for me.
-
From: MADDY on 6th August 2009 01:51 PM [Full View]
Thanks NOV, pls vote for Maddy Originally Posted by NOV
I disagree. Originally Posted by MADDY
Maddy is not disagreeable for me.
-
From: P_R on 6th August 2009 01:54 PM [Full View]
indha panjAyathai eththanai thadavai pEsuradhunnu thalaimaRaivA irundhEn.
kazhaga kaNmaNigaL niRaiya pEr vote paNNi nilamaiya maathittaanga pOla irukke.
-
From: MADDY on 6th August 2009 01:55 PM [Full View]
madhavan is looking at a drubbing here (as well)
-
From: viraajan on 6th August 2009 01:56 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by MADDY
Thanks NOV, pls vote for Maddy Originally Posted by NOV
I disagree. Originally Posted by MADDY
Maddy is not disagreeable for me.
-
From: NOV on 6th August 2009 01:59 PM [Full View]
edhuku enakku thanks. are you maddy?
I may like madhavans acting, but also think that surya is much more superior to him in many ways. :P
-
From: MADDY on 6th August 2009 02:04 PM [Full View]
yea, we know :P Originally Posted by NOV
-
From: NOV on 6th August 2009 02:06 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by Prabhu Ram
it will be good to see views of ppl who have not posted their opinions.
-
From: NOV on 6th August 2009 02:09 PM [Full View]
cant view in office? Originally Posted by MADDY
has it got anything to do with his saying something about IR?
-
From: P_R on 6th August 2009 02:15 PM [Full View]
Oho Originally Posted by MADDY
mattum-ngra vaarthaiyai konjam adakki vaasichirukkalaam.
-
From: P_R on 6th August 2009 02:16 PM [Full View]
bayappadaadheenga. indha thadavai naan essay ezhudha maattEn Originally Posted by NOV
Originally Posted by Prabhu Ram
it will be good to see views of ppl who have not posted their opinions.
-
From: Appu s on 6th August 2009 02:23 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by Prabhu Ram
Oho Originally Posted by MADDY
mattum-ngra vaarthaiyai konjam adakki vaasichirukkalaam. athey athey, romba urukittapla
-
From: jaaze on 6th August 2009 02:23 PM [Full View]
nalla discussionabba.. athulayum choices paarunga.. muthalla ozhunga spell pannungabaa.. talendedaam..
aa oo na thread aarambikkaravangala vittudunga.. eppavachum thread thirantha athaye puzhappunnu mudivu pannida vendiyathu..
-
From: NOV on 6th August 2009 02:25 PM [Full View]
PR
I think yours, mine, Groucho's, Thirumaran's Vivasayi's, Maddy's, Venkiraja's opinions are widely known. There is going to be nothing much different from what we had said in the past.
If you have something new to say, please, by all means. :P
p/s: appadi enna thaan irukku andha video la?
-
From: P_R on 6th August 2009 02:30 PM [Full View]
NK audio release. ஒரு உருக்கமான மேடைப்பேச்சு. இடம் பொருள் ஏவல் சேவலை மனதில் வைத்துக்கொண்டு பேசியது கொஞ்சம் அதிகம் ஆயிடுச்சு. Originally Posted by NOV
அதைத்தான் வள்ளுவர் அன்றே சொன்னார்
கக்கக்க காகாவென
கொக்கொக்க கோகோவென
-
From: groucho070 on 6th August 2009 02:33 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by Prabhu Ram
-
From: NOV on 6th August 2009 02:35 PM [Full View]
ok, still a puzzle.
does that make him any less talented? that is the relevant question....
-
From: Appu s on 6th August 2009 02:36 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by Prabhu Ram
NK audio release. ஒரு உருக்கமான மேடைப்பேச்சு. இடம் பொருள் ஏவல் சேவலை மனதில் வைத்துக்கொண்டு பேசியது கொஞ்சம் அதிகம் ஆயிடுச்சு. Originally Posted by NOV
அதைத்தான் வள்ளுவர் அன்றே சொன்னார்
கக்கக்க காகாவென
கொக்கொக்க கோகோவென
-
From: MADDY on 6th August 2009 02:36 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by Prabhu Ram
NK audio release. ஒரு உருக்கமான மேடைப்பேச்சு. இடம் பொருள் ஏவல் சேவலை மனதில் வைத்துக்கொண்டு பேசியது கொஞ்சம் அதிகம் ஆயிடுச்சு. Originally Posted by NOV
அதைத்தான் வள்ளுவர் அன்றே சொன்னார்
கக்கக்க காகாவென
கொக்கொக்க கோகோவென
matter mails-ellam anuppumbodhu "warning" "careful" nnu pottu anuppuvaanga , andha madhiri annan-oda dialogue solren-nnu sollittu anuppungappa - office-la asingama povudhu
:P
-
From: Vivasaayi on 6th August 2009 03:15 PM [Full View]
marubadiyum mudhallarundhaaaaaaaaaaaa
-
From: hamid on 6th August 2009 03:23 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
marubadiyum mudhallarundhaaaaaaaaaaaa
-
From: sankara1970 on 6th August 2009 03:28 PM [Full View]
Surya is better than Maddy
Eachone is different in their own way
Maddy could not maintain his physique and he went to Bollywood and lost his place.
His body language is not suitable for tamil masses. He is always heart throb for college students.
Surya is doing different movies and taken over fm Maddy, Vikram, Prashant. He is close or equal to Ajith and Vijay
-
From: crajkumar_be on 6th August 2009 03:32 PM [Full View]
Maddy's attack is two-pronged. His boycott of Suriya and his films are irrespective of his talents and purely based on that medai pechu. Apart from that, in his opinion, Suriya is not a good actor. idha rendum vevvera nu Maddy valiyurutharaar. Idhu dhaan avar karuthu. Corrt-a Maddy? Originally Posted by NOV
ok, still a puzzle.
does that make him any less talented? that is the relevant question....
-
From: viraajan on 6th August 2009 03:35 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by sankara1970
-
From: P_R on 6th August 2009 03:43 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by MADDY
public public
Yeah.mike kidaichA pOdhum ovvoruthanum dham katti pEsurAn. adhaan quote paNNEn. Originally Posted by MADDY
andha madhiri annan-oda dialogue solren-nnu sollittu anuppungappa - office-la asingama povudhu :P
adhukkaaga andha kuzhandhaippayyanai neenga odhukki vaikkalaama.
-
From: MADDY on 6th August 2009 03:59 PM [Full View]
oh yes.... Originally Posted by crajkumar_be
Maddy's attack is two-pronged. His boycott of Suriya and his films are irrespective of his talents and purely based on that medai pechu. Apart from that, in his opinion, Suriya is not a good actor. idha rendum vevvera nu Maddy valiyurutharaar. Idhu dhaan avar karuthu. Corrt-a Maddy? Originally Posted by NOV
ok, still a puzzle.
does that make him any less talented? that is the relevant question.... ...
btw, one sumal correction - surya is not a good actor-nnu naa sollave illaye.....he is good, infact very good, but not the best......
-
From: P_R on 6th August 2009 04:13 PM [Full View]
Margin kuranjikkittE varudhu. Gloves will be off any time
-
From: jaiganes on 6th August 2009 04:25 PM [Full View]
gnaan maddy'ku vote senju!!
'enna design idhu' Innum soorya ee dialogue matching performance cheidhilla.
-
From: Raikkonen on 6th August 2009 04:30 PM [Full View]
not necessarily a maddy fan... but seeing who is he facing...
maddy en aalu..
anbe sivam..
noone can match....
edit: adv maddy..
-
From: MADDY on 6th August 2009 04:38 PM [Full View]
adra sakka adra sakka Originally Posted by Raikkonen
edit: adv maddy..
PR - mannippu enakku endha languvej dictionary-layum pudikkadha ore vaarthai
:P
-
From: P_R on 6th August 2009 04:46 PM [Full View]
ninaichA easy-A seivaapla Originally Posted by jaiganes
aanaa ....
(high pitch) ..kEttuttAryA Bill Gates-u.....
-
From: Shakthiprabha on 6th August 2009 04:49 PM [Full View]
Hah! Where is nov
-
From: Vivasaayi on 6th August 2009 05:15 PM [Full View]
ella id -yayum use panniteengala? Originally Posted by Shakthiprabha
-
From: Vivasaayi on 6th August 2009 05:20 PM [Full View]
pinnitAnyA billgatesu Originally Posted by Prabhu Ram
ninaichA easy-A seivaapla Originally Posted by jaiganes
aanaa ....
(high pitch) ..kEttuttAryA Bill Gates-u.....
-
From: Vivasaayi on 6th August 2009 05:21 PM [Full View]
idhellam oru thErdhal
-
From: P_R on 6th August 2009 05:21 PM [Full View]
Exactly Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
vetri vetri enbadhellAm manidhanukku nilaiyA
-
From: Anban on 6th August 2009 05:22 PM [Full View]
Madhavan .. i dunno why.. but he is more natural ..
-
From: crajkumar_be on 6th August 2009 05:26 PM [Full View]
Maddy, idha neenga edhirpaarthirukka maatteenga! Originally Posted by Anban
-
From: NOV on 6th August 2009 06:01 PM [Full View]
thamizh dhrOghi Originally Posted by Anban
-
From: NOV on 6th August 2009 06:08 PM [Full View]
just watched the video link sudhir posted. I dont see anything wrong.
why is sudhir so angry?
-
From: Nerd on 6th August 2009 06:08 PM [Full View]
ennadhu surya-kkku 13 votes-A? Tamil films section-la oru 4-5 pEr dhaan Surya fans-nu ninaichEn. NOV, neenga kAppi kaarner-la irunthu aaL pudichitteengaLA?
-
From: NOV on 6th August 2009 06:11 PM [Full View]
thats where you are wrong nerd. the whole world and his sister loves surya now.
in fact I am at the votes maddy has received - most of which I think are not from pro-maddy guys, but anti-surya guys
-
From: P_R on 6th August 2009 06:14 PM [Full View]
adhE ! Originally Posted by NOV
in fact I am at the votes maddy has received - most of which I think are not from pro-maddy guys, but anti-surya guys
Adhuvum many anti-Surya not because he is 'bad' but because he allegedly receives 'disproportionately more' applause.
So, eppidi paarthaalum...
-
From: viraajan on 6th August 2009 06:16 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by Prabhu Ram
adhE ! Originally Posted by NOV
in fact I am at the votes maddy has received - most of which I think are not from pro-maddy guys, but anti-surya guys
Adhuvum many anti-Surya not because he is 'bad' but because he allegedly receives 'disproportionately more' applause.
So, eppidi paarthaalum...
-
From: Anban on 6th August 2009 06:21 PM [Full View]
why???? surya is good but somehow not upto the levels of maddy.. take aayutha ezuthu for example.. Originally Posted by crajkumar_be
Maddy, idha neenga edhirpaarthirukka maatteenga! Originally Posted by Anban
maddy didnt have the sani-stamp as much as others had in the movie..
-
From: Anban on 6th August 2009 06:22 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by NOV
thamizh dhrOghi Originally Posted by Anban
-
From: NOV on 6th August 2009 06:24 PM [Full View]
naa unna angE vandhu gavanichikkirEn
-
From: Raikkonen on 6th August 2009 06:47 PM [Full View]
fundamentally wrong... gotcha.. Originally Posted by NOV
thats where you are wrong nerd. the whole world and his sister loves surya now.
in fact I am at the votes maddy has received - most of which I think are not from pro-maddy guys, but anti-surya guys
-
From: VinodKumar's on 6th August 2009 06:52 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by NOV
thats where you are wrong nerd. the whole world and his sister loves surya now.
in fact I am at the votes maddy has received - most of which I think are not from pro-maddy guys, but anti-surya guys 
- anti surya avalava illa athaan suryavoda plus ... mathapadi onnum illa ...
-
From: NOV on 6th August 2009 06:56 PM [Full View]
how come vijay fans generally get the message wrong? 
-
From: VinodKumar's on 6th August 2009 07:08 PM [Full View]
unmai veppanganiyai pola kasakum Originally Posted by NOV
how come vijay fans generally get the message wrong?
NOV ithukku munnadi neenga yarukavathu fan ah irunthingala ?
unga signature ah patha yarkodaya sanda potu bayangara frustration la eluthi vatchuruka mari irruku ?
-
From: Raikkonen on 6th August 2009 07:12 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by VinodKumar's
unmai veppanganiyai pola kasakum Originally Posted by NOV
how come vijay fans generally get the message wrong?
NOV ithukku munnadi neenga yarukavathu fan ah irunthingala ?
unga signature ah patha yarkodaya sanda potu bayangara frustration la eluthi vatchuruka mari irruku ?
-
From: Nerd on 6th August 2009 07:16 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by Raikkonen
fundamentally wrong... gotcha.. Originally Posted by NOV
thats where you are wrong nerd. the whole world and his sister loves surya now.
in fact I am at the votes maddy has received - most of which I think are not from pro-maddy guys, but anti-surya guys Good one bro!
Maddy leading by 3 now and I am yet to vote
-
From: Sourav on 6th August 2009 07:19 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by Raikkonen
Originally Posted by VinodKumar's
unmai veppanganiyai pola kasakum Originally Posted by NOV
how come vijay fans generally get the message wrong?
NOV ithukku munnadi neenga yarukavathu fan ah irunthingala ?
unga signature ah patha yarkodaya sanda potu bayangara frustration la eluthi vatchuruka mari irruku ?
-
From: P_R on 6th August 2009 07:34 PM [Full View]
MADDY, ungaLukku orE kuzhappamA illai Originally Posted by Anban
-
From: MADDY on 6th August 2009 07:45 PM [Full View]
assuming, u meant me as maddy - hahaha Originally Posted by crajkumar_be
Maddy, idha neenga edhirpaarthirukka maatteenga! Originally Posted by Anban
yea......
btw, Madhavan wonderful turnaround......
-
From: Sarna on 6th August 2009 07:46 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
-
From: Raikkonen on 6th August 2009 07:52 PM [Full View]
appuram ethukku vottu potteenga? Originally Posted by Sarna
Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
-
From: Sarna on 6th August 2009 07:56 PM [Full View]
aamaanga, idhu thErdhal dhaanganu sonnEn Originally Posted by Raikkonen
appuram ethukku vottu potteenga? Originally Posted by Sarna
Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
-
From: Vivasaayi on 6th August 2009 08:19 PM [Full View]
mods,
Whats the need of this thread really?
we already have threads on surya and maddy..right?
if the thread is about "best actor of this generation" ..then vijay,ajith and vikrams name must be added ..adhana nyayam..
vvijaya sekkalaina..podaskieyoda "2000 posts"ku oru arthame illama poyidum..aaamaa
-
From: villan007 on 6th August 2009 08:21 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
-
From: Vivasaayi on 6th August 2009 08:23 PM [Full View]
oru doubtu Originally Posted by villan007
Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
adheppadi vijaya pathi post pannumbodhu mattu "taannu" odane aajarayidreenga
-
From: villan007 on 6th August 2009 08:24 PM [Full View]
avaru muga raasi apdi
-
From: MADDY on 6th August 2009 08:34 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by villan007
avaru muga raasi apdi
vikki, this thread is for "who is talented among surya and Maddy" - come on, lets slug it out....
-
From: Vivasaayi on 6th August 2009 08:46 PM [Full View]
maddy, Originally Posted by MADDY
Originally Posted by villan007
avaru muga raasi apdi
vikki, this thread is for "who is talented among surya and Maddy" - come on, lets slug it out....
ethana vote-ngradhu mukkiyam illa...yen potangannuthan mukkiyam
Anti-surya gang develop aagudhunna enna artham..mm..enna artham?..
surya develop aayachunnu artham...
mudivu engalukuthan sadhagama vandhiruku
-
From: MADDY on 6th August 2009 08:51 PM [Full View]
appadi irundha sandhosa padunga, yen complain panrel Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
maddy, Originally Posted by MADDY
Originally Posted by villan007
avaru muga raasi apdi
vikki, this thread is for "who is talented among surya and Maddy" - come on, lets slug it out....
ethana vote-ngradhu mukkiyam illa...yen potangannuthan mukkiyam
Anti-surya gang develop aagudhunna enna artham..mm..enna artham?..
surya develop aayachunnu artham...
mudivu engalukuthan sadhagama vandhiruku
-
From: Raikkonen on 6th August 2009 09:04 PM [Full View]
oo anti group vantha hero popular ayiitara???
apdi paatha vijay thanga werld star...
-
From: Vivasaayi on 6th August 2009 09:07 PM [Full View]
vijay ajith ku apuram anti hero gang develop aayirukaradhu suryavukuthane.. Originally Posted by Raikkonen
oo anti group vantha hero popular ayiitara???
apdi paatha vijay thanga werld star...
-
From: Raikkonen on 6th August 2009 09:09 PM [Full View]
he has lot of positive fanbase.. women, intelligent, internet, kamal fans..
vijay only has hc fans... very few hate surya.. enakku terinja inga naan mattumthan..
-
From: Vivasaayi on 6th August 2009 09:13 PM [Full View]
Vijayku koodathan inga yarum hate panla... Originally Posted by Raikkonen
he has lot of positive fanbase.. women, intelligent, internet, kamal fans..
vijay only has hc fans... very few hate surya.. enakku terinja inga naan mattumthan..
-
From: Sourav on 6th August 2009 09:16 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
oru doubtu Originally Posted by villan007
Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
adheppadi vijaya pathi post pannumbodhu mattu "taannu" odane aajarayidreenga
-
From: HonestRaj on 6th August 2009 09:16 PM [Full View]
ada neenga yenga Vijay Ajith'nu ellam pesikittunirukeenga.. avangalayellam inge yarum madhikkiradhe illai.. adutha Vijayakanth levelukku vandhuttanga....... Originally Posted by viraajan
Originally Posted by sankara1970
-
From: HonestRaj on 6th August 2009 09:17 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by Nerd
ennadhu surya-kkku 13 votes-A? Tamil films section-la oru 4-5 pEr dhaan Surya fans-nu ninaichEn. NOV, neenga kAppi kaarner-la irunthu aaL pudichitteengaLA?
oru idea... Comedian poll-la Nagesh oda vote ellam count oannunga.. Surya vote-oda tally aanalum aagum
-
From: HonestRaj on 6th August 2009 09:17 PM [Full View]
kandhaga vaasanaya gappunu pudichuduvaru villain Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
oru doubtu Originally Posted by villan007
Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
adheppadi vijaya pathi post pannumbodhu mattu "taannu" odane aajarayidreenga
-
From: Nerd on 6th August 2009 09:22 PM [Full View]
Vaanga Honest, apdiyE vote pOttrunga. Yaarukkunu solla thEvai illai.. :P
-
From: Raikkonen on 6th August 2009 09:22 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by HonestRaj
ada neenga yenga Vijay Ajith'nu ellam pesikittunirukeenga.. avangalayellam inge yarum madhikkiradhe illai.. adutha Vijayakanth levelukku vandhuttanga....... Originally Posted by viraajan
Originally Posted by sankara1970
vote kumiyumnu paatha kadasile vote pirikira level ku vanthutangale..
-
From: jaiganes on 6th August 2009 09:27 PM [Full View]
Basic of any actor is facial expressions and body language. Maddy stands tall and scores on this front heavily over surya - whose funny antics are already hangover of his loud mouthed acts from Pithamagan and serious ones a generous contribution from Nanda and Kakka Kakka. beyond that - what is his new expression? or new modulation - Maddy on the other hand - is thankfully armed with neat expressions appropriate for all situations. No need for a Bala or Gautham Menon to reinvent or invent an actor in him.
-
From: Vivasaayi on 6th August 2009 09:29 PM [Full View]
first of all whats different that maddy has offerednu sollunga.. Originally Posted by jaiganes
-
From: HonestRaj on 6th August 2009 09:33 PM [Full View]
Done!!!!!!! Originally Posted by Nerd
-
From: Anban on 6th August 2009 09:40 PM [Full View]
maddy,
your signature is stuff.. madhavan's fav MD is obviously ARR.. athukkaaga naanga avara othikkkittomaa?
-
From: crajkumar_be on 6th August 2009 09:48 PM [Full View]
Pottaachu pottaachu!
15-20... Dharmathin vaazhvu thanai........
-
From: Vivasaayi on 6th August 2009 09:59 PM [Full View]
point! Originally Posted by Anban
maddy,
your signature is stuff.. madhavan's fav MD is obviously ARR.. athukkaaga naanga avara othikkkittomaa?
-
From: HonestRaj on 6th August 2009 10:03 PM [Full View]
aama aama... nan avarukku vote-inanen Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
point! Originally Posted by Anban
maddy,
your signature is stuff.. madhavan's fav MD is obviously ARR.. athukkaaga naanga avara othikkkittomaa?
-
From: MADDY on 6th August 2009 10:03 PM [Full View]
ok, let me eloborate my point in my signature.... :P
-
From: Appu s on 6th August 2009 10:04 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
point! Originally Posted by Anban
maddy,
your signature is stuff.. madhavan's fav MD is obviously ARR.. athukkaaga naanga avara othikkkittomaa?
ennanga Point, fav nnu solrathulaam mattare illai , avarukku yaaru fav iruntha enna aana antha antha matrum ngira vaarthai than 
-
From: jaiganes on 6th August 2009 10:05 PM [Full View]
Alaipayudhe smile enna Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
first of all whats different that maddy has offerednu sollunga.. Originally Posted by jaiganes
minnale chicken saapidra scene expression enna?
Run padathula shutter izuthu moodradhenna
Nala damayanthi - innocence enna
Aaidha ezuththu - mood and intensity enna - final scene Jail scene - sitting expression enna
Kannathil muthamittaal - 'revelation in the beach' scene enna
Anbe sivam 'enna design idhu' scene enna
idhula edhulayume padam director theriyara maadhiri illai - we see what maddy the actor does. Surya on the other hand is a balloon in which Bala or Goutham menon gave the air. Kaathu pochunna, Balloon surungi chinnadhaa aidum.
If you see naan kadavul, andha chinna payyan dialogue delivery is the same what Surya delivered in Pithamagan and Mayavi courtesy director Singam puli totally. solli koduthadhai samatha seiraar pola. solli kudukkalainaa? sondha sarakku innaama keedhu ungaalukitte?
-
From: Nerd on 6th August 2009 10:08 PM [Full View]
SOK times-la Surya pEsaadhadhaa, Rahman paththi. Surya avunga daddy maadhiri mic-a pAthA uNarchivasappaduraar
-
From: Sarna on 6th August 2009 10:09 PM [Full View]
Jaiganesh, pinreenga
-
From: VinodKumar's on 6th August 2009 10:13 PM [Full View]
ella pakkathaiyum positive ah eduthukara ungala nenatcha pulla arikuthu ... Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
vijay ajith ku apuram anti hero gang develop aayirukaradhu suryavukuthane.. Originally Posted by Raikkonen
oo anti group vantha hero popular ayiitara???
apdi paatha vijay thanga werld star...
sivakumar kitta solli oru chicken briyani order pannuraen ungaluku
-
From: Vivasaayi on 6th August 2009 10:17 PM [Full View]
alaipayuthe,run,minnale lam differentNA
NAAN KOODA SOLLUVEN
sivakasila auto drivera vandha azhagu enna
thirupathi doctora vandhu dialogue pesuna azhagu enna
enna enna enna ennaaaaa...
enna?
-
From: VinodKumar's on 6th August 2009 10:19 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by Raikkonen
he has lot of positive fanbase.. women,intelligent, internet, kamal fans.. appuram mathavanga nammala thappa pesira koodathunu safer side irrukara fans
hit kudukalaenalum fans ah irupangavijay only has hc fans ...
very few hate surya..
na namakkum aagathunganaenakku terinja inga naan mattumthan..
-
From: Vivasaayi on 6th August 2009 10:22 PM [Full View]
jaiganesh,
maddy has been maddy in most of his movies
urban guy talking tamil with the tip of his tongue,romancing the heroine
at times hitting the goondas.
But he is more spontaneous than surya..definitea..adhu podhuma?
-
From: MADDY on 6th August 2009 10:25 PM [Full View]
ok for the final time(hopefully)
watch this video
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bS5CH69kdVg
Surya told the following:
1. IR paadalgal mattume manasukkule eppavume odittuirukkum....he had earlier said he cant sleep/eat without newyork nagaram song......he approached rahman of all people for his first production venture - SOK....
2. ella paattayum pudikkalam, dance ellam aadalaam, but ivaroda paadalgal mattume azha veikkum, sandhosha pada veikkum....
hence i would stop watching his movies as a show of my angst over such flip-flop for occasions and obvious dig at my thalaivar's music in second point...but this doesent affect my judgement of him as a actor...he is a very good actor in my books....i also have no problems in people praising IR to the hilt - pls do not mix these both........in case of further questions/generalisations please PM me....
-
From: P_R on 6th August 2009 10:39 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
-
From: jaiganes on 6th August 2009 10:49 PM [Full View]
I think - you are taking your anti Maniratnam thingy on Maddy. Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
jaiganesh,
maddy has been maddy in most of his movies
urban guy talking tamil with the tip of his tongue,romancing the heroine
at times hitting the goondas.
But he is more spontaneous than surya..definitea..adhu podhuma?
Dialogue delivery wise Suryavoda 'Naan onnu solliye aaganum Malini' is all the more cringe worthy in VA. Pls go through the examples I gave and tell me honestly if he did only romancing the heroine all along speaking tip of the tongue thamizh.
-
From: Appu s on 6th August 2009 10:50 PM [Full View]
Maddy well put, cant say anything better than this Originally Posted by MADDY
still i remember the SOK vijay Tv show with ARR , ayya appdiye kooni kurugi... sir unga paattu... sir neenga vanthu.. haaan... ..pothum da pothum da nnu thalaivarrkku thonirukkum
-
From: Vivasaayi on 6th August 2009 11:03 PM [Full View]
anti-maniratnama?idhenna pudhukadha Originally Posted by jaiganes
I think - you are taking your anti Maniratnam thingy on Maddy. Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
jaiganesh,
maddy has been maddy in most of his movies
urban guy talking tamil with the tip of his tongue,romancing the heroine
at times hitting the goondas.
But he is more spontaneous than surya..definitea..adhu podhuma?
Dialogue delivery wise Suryavoda 'Naan onnu solliye aaganum Malini' is all the more cringe worthy in VA. Pls go through the examples I gave and tell me honestly if he did only romancing the heroine all along speaking tip of the tongue thamizh.
I dint complain about madhavans "tip tongue tamill" at all ... if madhavan had acted in goutham menon films it would had sounded better in those romantic scenes..
What Im saying is madhavan has mostly done those type of roles..while surya has tried a lot of varied roles comparitively.
-
From: P_R on 6th August 2009 11:15 PM [Full View]
ennAtha nee koNdu vandhe ennAtha nee koNdu pOppOre .....thideer thaththuvam to idli kadaikkAran in mAyAvi
idhellAm Madhavanukku remba kastappadum.
-
From: Nerd on 6th August 2009 11:18 PM [Full View]
sonnadhaiyE thiruppi sonnA epdi? ThiruppAchi Sivakasi example neenga dhaanE kudutheenga. Apdi pArthA annan anjAsingam dhaan very versatile. Idhaiyum naan munnAdiyE sollirukkEn. It does not matter how many different roles one has done, how effective they were was the point. Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
Evano Oruvan, Yaavarum Nalam - Suryakku kasttappattAlum varaadhu. Not to mention the others in Jaiganes' list.
-
From: Anban on 6th August 2009 11:22 PM [Full View]
surya-kku vote-a potturukkanum pola irukke.. Originally Posted by MADDY
btw, surya once said that he reads the newspapers only to look out for the announcement of rajini's new movies..
-
From: Wibha on 6th August 2009 11:24 PM [Full View]
Naan vote podardhuku munnadi MADDY had 21 votes, vote potaavutum maddy has only 21 votes. WTH
Duh its just obvious
Maddy Maddy Oh Oh Maddy
-
From: P_R on 6th August 2009 11:27 PM [Full View]
Disagree. Originally Posted by Nerd
Even if one were to cede the projected gap between what Surya would achieve in Madhavan's best roles, it is with the complete assurance that it is only a matter of time before he seals the gap.
On the other hand the yawning gap between what Madhavan is likely to achieve in trying to match in some of Surya's performances is something that is likely to remain.
Madhavan is good, enjoyable and one I follow with great interest but I just don't see him to be capable of doing some kind of roles.
-
From: viraajan on 6th August 2009 11:27 PM [Full View]
Nice list Originally Posted by jaiganes
'Aayida Ezhuthu' Maddy na enakku instanta ninaivukku varra scene - Surya hospital la irukkumbodhu, maddy vandhu pappaapla. Kannadi vazhiya kannu mattum theriyum parunga. kannula oru veri kind of expression irukkum parunga.... Amazing....
Minnale - Happy birthday nu solli vazhiyura scene
Kannathil Muththamittal - kadhai mattum illa. udhaiyum koduppen, then "piravilaye oru spark irukkanum'nu solluvanga. SUTHTHA POI"
Specs damage aagura scene'a his expression
I can list out, 100s of such scenes with subtle expression (many of them are not palnned. Naturala've varum). Maddy
-
From: P_R on 6th August 2009 11:29 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by Anban
-
From: Nerd on 6th August 2009 11:45 PM [Full View]
Disagree on all counts. Anyway let's wait Originally Posted by Prabhu Ram
-
From: jaiganes on 7th August 2009 12:28 AM [Full View]
indha dosayai apadiye thiruppiyum podalaam. 6 pack ethikinu cooling glass pottukinaa ellarume nalla actor dhaan. Regarding mayavi defense, I say the credit belongs to Singampuli and not to surya. avarai velai vaangaradhukkulla verthu viru viruthu pona vasanth engira sirandha iyakkunar irukkaaru. simplaa solla ponaa, avar ippo panradhu sanangalukku pudichirukkunnu venumnaalum sollalaam. Approach to craft and acting out is rather obvious and simple thing to perceive - I think, Maddy is far superior in terms of acting - hype, jabardhasthu - vetti bandhaa idhu venumnaa suryavukku irukkalaam. Adhu kooda irukkalaam dhan. This is not to say he is a bad actor - he is a vastly improved actor - He still pales in comparison with his own brother's paruthiveeran act - let alone a comparison with Maddy. Originally Posted by Prabhu Ram
Disagree. Originally Posted by Nerd
Even if one were to cede the projected gap between what Surya would achieve in Madhavan's best roles, it is with the complete assurance that it is only a matter of time before he seals the gap.
On the other hand the yawning gap between what Madhavan is likely to achieve in trying to match in some of Surya's performances is something that is likely to remain.
Madhavan is good, enjoyable and one I follow with great interest but I just don't see him to be capable of doing some kind of roles.
-
From: P_R on 7th August 2009 01:18 AM [Full View]
heh heh Originally Posted by jaiganes
While makeover don't make a case it shouldn't be an eyesore either.
Originally Posted by jaiganes
nallA vandhA directorukku bocquet, nalla varalainnA Suryakku brickbat-A. Idhai thaan Mani-RamaNi -nnuvOm.
MadhavanaalE siththan/mAyAvi paNNavE mudiyAdhungarEn. illai mudiyumnu yaarAvadhu orutharAvadhu solveengaLAnnu naanum paakkurEn.
appidi sonneengannA unga nErmaiyai naan sandhEgappaduvEn 'gradhu vEra vishayam.
-
From: crajkumar_be on 7th August 2009 01:19 AM [Full View]
Originally Posted by Prabhu Ram
-
From: crajkumar_be on 7th August 2009 01:21 AM [Full View]
By the by, Suriya-Kamal fan equation podravanga Maddy-um miga periya Kamal fan-garadha marakka koodadhu (i think he holds him in a position next only to Mani Sir)
-
From: P_R on 7th August 2009 01:22 AM [Full View]
vAraNam Ayiram airport crying scene
I am trying to imagine if anyone else can pull that off. Dhanush perhaps..
-
From: crajkumar_be on 7th August 2009 01:23 AM [Full View]
Case in point: Suriya in AE and Maddy in AE. Thella thelivu! Originally Posted by Prabhu Ram
-
From: Nerd on 7th August 2009 01:36 AM [Full View]
Surya (or maddy) Kamal fan-A irunthaalum Rajini fan-A irunthaalum, nyaayam-nu onnu irukku. And in my observation, Surya Kamal-a evLO nakkinaalum, Kamal likes Maddy better. Originally Posted by crajkumar_be
PR, siththan dhaanE, Bala-ta 1 year irundhA Maddy seithirukkalaam. UyirilE kalanthathu Surya nandhA seyyalaiyaa? Mayavi ellAm seyyavE vENdAm. Maddy moonjikku adhellaam suit aagaadhu enbadhu vEra vishayam. Poyum pOyum VA-kku kodi pidippadhanaal unga nErmai out
I am eagerly waiting for AO. Karthi oru natural!
-
From: jaiganes on 7th August 2009 03:58 AM [Full View]
hello sir? Originally Posted by Prabhu Ram
heh heh Originally Posted by jaiganes
While makeover don't make a case it shouldn't be an eyesore either.
Originally Posted by jaiganes
nallA vandhA directorukku bocquet, nalla varalainnA Suryakku brickbat-A. Idhai thaan Mani-RamaNi -nnuvOm.
MadhavanaalE siththan/mAyAvi paNNavE mudiyAdhungarEn. illai mudiyumnu yaarAvadhu orutharAvadhu solveengaLAnnu naanum paakkurEn.
appidi sonneengannA unga nErmaiyai naan sandhEgappaduvEn 'gradhu vEra vishayam.
simbil point.
Naan kadavul chinna payyan, diction, wit, nakkal ellamE ditto what surya did as sakthi in pithamagan. Adhe padathula vikram acting ellame by admission of bala and vikram, improvisation done by vikram.
Surya performance ellaame director vizundhu aal vechu vaangunadhu. Maddy vikram pondravargal iyalbaagave nadippu therindhavargal, nadikkum talent inbornaaga iruppavargaL enbadhe em karuthu, naam sollum poruL. Surya vin nadippu thiramaikku, perumpaalum udhavi purivadhu iyakkunargaLe,
enavE Suryavirku iyarkayileye nadippu enbadhu 'Talent' illai enbadhe emadhu karuththu.
-
From: rajan on 7th August 2009 06:35 AM [Full View]
I like surya. he is a very good and versatile actor.
-
From: NOV on 7th August 2009 06:39 AM [Full View]
I disagree COMPLETELY with Surya. Originally Posted by MADDY
the only songs that makes one feel all kinds of emotion are MSV's
every other MD since then are followers.
no more discussions.
-
From: Vivasaayi on 7th August 2009 08:16 AM [Full View]
nerd,
sivakasi,thirupachi example sonnadhu vera contextla
-
From: Nerd on 7th August 2009 08:30 AM [Full View]
OK OK Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
21 - 24
-
From: Thirumaran on 7th August 2009 09:22 AM [Full View]
Oh.. Ippa Maddy kku vote poattavanga ellaamae girls thaanaa Originally Posted by Shakthiprabha
All guys are JEALOUS OF MADDY. over and out. I aint gonna talk esp when nov is around
-
From: MADDY on 7th August 2009 09:23 AM [Full View]
waattt Originally Posted by Wibha
Naan vote podardhuku munnadi MADDY had 21 votes, vote potaavutum maddy has only 21 votes. WTH indha case-ayum neenga dhaan investigate pannanum NOV .....
VA airport scene oru scene-kaaga adhu super performance-nnu solradhu - i cant agree....many more unconvincing scenes in the movie just killed it......."oh my god" scene ellam - height of artificial acting.......i mean , u cud hear "lights, camera, action" before " maalini unga kitta idha solliye aaganum" ......i know he takes lots of efforts, but i've never been a fan of "effort" guys as much as the "natural" guys esp in the field of art......
-
From: NOV on 7th August 2009 09:25 AM [Full View]
thoonilum iruppEn thurimbilum iruppEn, so vasadhi eppadi? Originally Posted by Shakthiprabha
-
From: Thirumaran on 7th August 2009 09:25 AM [Full View]
NOV ithu unga post..
Originally Posted by NOV
Ithukku naan appavae sirichirukalaam Ippa neengalae purinjittu irupeenga :P
-
From: NOV on 7th August 2009 09:27 AM [Full View]
quite impossible maddy, voting cannot be manipulated. its already inbuilt in the system. Originally Posted by MADDY
waattt indha case-ayum neenga dhaan investigate pannanum NOV ......
-
From: NOV on 7th August 2009 09:29 AM [Full View]
nerd, your point being?
-
From: Thirumaran on 7th August 2009 09:36 AM [Full View]
Originally Posted by Prabhu Ram
BTW As far the polling i would have preferred Dhanush in place of Madhavan..
It is not that i am against Madhavan.. He is very good no doubt. But i dont think there is place for Madhavan in Tamil at least.
If at all for Perf + Popularity there going to be a competition considering the situation now.. It should be Surya vs Dhanush..
IMO :P
-
From: Srimannarayanan on 7th August 2009 09:41 AM [Full View]
Sudhir Kamal Fanaa? Originally Posted by crajkumar_be
-
From: Nerd on 7th August 2009 09:44 AM [Full View]
Which post? 21-24?? I am just surprised that Maddy is leading by a *slender* margin. Originally Posted by NOV
nerd, your point being?
-
From: NOV on 7th August 2009 09:46 AM [Full View]
wait, the poll hasnt reached its maturity yet. Originally Posted by Nerd
friday la nalla koottam varum,
already two reputable hubbers have pmed me to say they prefer Surya and have voted for him. :P
-
From: Thirumaran on 7th August 2009 09:46 AM [Full View]
I suppose he talks abt actor Maddy Originally Posted by Srimannarayanan
Sudhir Kamal Fanaa? Originally Posted by crajkumar_be
BTW namma Maddy yum kamal fan thaan.. mostly he wont say openly .. that is all
-
From: MADDY on 7th August 2009 09:53 AM [Full View]
oru kaalthula :P .....but bala here refers to actor Maddy Originally Posted by Srimannarayanan
Sudhir Kamal Fanaa? Originally Posted by crajkumar_be
.......in interviews of maddy, he holds both mani and kamal on highest pedestal......
-
From: Wibha on 7th August 2009 10:08 AM [Full View]
maddy Signature
-
From: Benny Lava on 7th August 2009 10:21 AM [Full View]
Idhu enna kelvi... without a doubt it is Maddy
-
From: Thirumaran on 7th August 2009 10:28 AM [Full View]
another ARR fan Originally Posted by Benny Lava
Idhu enna kelvi... without a doubt it is Maddy
-
From: Benny Lava on 7th August 2009 10:31 AM [Full View]
Appo NOV ARR fan kedayadhunu solreengala, illati CR ARR fan'nu solreengala Originally Posted by Thirumaran
another ARR fan Originally Posted by Benny Lava
Idhu enna kelvi... without a doubt it is Maddy
-
From: Thirumaran on 7th August 2009 10:39 AM [Full View]
But they know to differentiate things Originally Posted by Benny Lava
Appo NOV ARR fan kedayadhunu solreengala, illati CR ARR fan'nu solreengala Originally Posted by Thirumaran
another ARR fan Originally Posted by Benny Lava
Idhu enna kelvi... without a doubt it is Maddy
Sari sari. jk. :P
ekkedo kettu poanga
-
From: Benny Lava on 7th August 2009 10:42 AM [Full View]
Adhey madhiri thaa nanum differentiate panni solrenu solla vandhen :P
I thought you were just a vishal fan... surya fan veraya
-
From: Thirumaran on 7th August 2009 10:46 AM [Full View]
Oh yeah like u.. Who is ARR as well as JKR fan Originally Posted by Benny Lava
I thought you were just a vishal fan... surya fan veraya
-
From: P_R on 7th August 2009 11:15 AM [Full View]
Originally Posted by Benny Lava
CR ARR fan'nu solreengala
-
From: groucho070 on 7th August 2009 11:21 AM [Full View]
There's something that bugs me. Oorey solluthaam, ulagame pugazhuthaam that Surya is next to Kamal-nu.
Next to which Kamal? Brilliant Actor Kamal? A natural Director Kamal? Or the gifted scriptwriter Kamal? Entha qualification? He can't even accomplish what Kamal did in his first five years as a lead star, let alone the roles he did with K.B (don't tell me K.B moulded him, K.B also moulded many others and what happened to them?).
To say Surya is next to Kamal is basically insulting the entire reputable oeuver of Kamal's. Everything Kamal stood for, fought for, succeded in and bled for is now reduced to a fanboy's yardstick. I am surprised that Kamal fans never protested this comparison.
Madhavan on the other side, though refers to Kamal as guru, never claims to be a great actor himself. He knows his limitation and works around it even though he is capable of stretching himself, quietly marketing himself in the industries of other language, and aiming to be an international star. He is not the next Kamal. He doesn't have to be. He is Madhavan, a wonderful actor who can bring something extra to every roles he does...not just be a director's clay.
And to pit Madhavan against Surya? I say find him a stronger opponent will you.
-
From: Vivasaayi on 7th August 2009 11:23 AM [Full View]
groucho,
surya is best among younger generationa ctorsnu than soldrom...
not "next kamal".. but like kamal who is the best actor among his generation..he seems to be the best of the lot among the younger generationa actors as of now..
adhu veru..idhu veru
-
From: Thirumaran on 7th August 2009 11:50 AM [Full View]
Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
groucho,
surya is best among younger generationa ctorsnu than soldrom...
not "next kamal".. but like kamal who is the best actor among his generation..he seems to be the best of the lot among the younger generationa actors as of now..
adhu veru..idhu veru
No one can fill the place of Kamal as multi personality person to the perfection.
It is just that Surya we say is good in terms of Acting alone.. There are still areas for improvement for him but with his hard work and commitment he will be improve in those :P
Going forward in future... Kamal illaama irukka poara kuraya theerka koodiya vaaipulla Actor a thaan I consider him to certain extent :P
U mean among the general Public of Tamils Originally Posted by groucho070
If that is ur view .. no way 
Even our Maddy wont accept that :P
-
From: P_R on 7th August 2009 11:57 AM [Full View]
Not actually.It only talks about the sad state of affairs that is all. Originally Posted by Groucho070
-
From: groucho070 on 7th August 2009 11:59 AM [Full View]
Originally Posted by Prabhu Ram
Not actually.It only talks about the sad state of affairs that is all. Originally Posted by Groucho070
-
From: Raikkonen on 7th August 2009 12:02 PM [Full View]
yow prasanth thaanya jeipparu..
// reminded of prabhu's sivaji thanya jeipparu line from guru sishyan...
-
From: groucho070 on 7th August 2009 12:03 PM [Full View]
That's one of many differences between the two. Madhavan knows of and works around his limitation. While Surya is still growing. Originally Posted by Thirumaran
I recall doing a translation of an interview transcription when he was like five years in the industry, and Surya was talking about how his fans advised him to wear his pants below his belly button. Yes, he is a great listener. I also recall Surya being one of the pioneers of a double dancing for him. Then he improved himself. Then fans must have warned him that he's scrawny looking kid, and voila! six pack comes-a-knocking so great that it was only recently rivaled Vishal. And he is the next best thing? Right.
-
From: groucho070 on 7th August 2009 12:05 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by Raikkonen
yow prasanth thaanya jeipparu..
// reminded of prabhu's sivaji thanya jeipparu line from guru sishyan... The last torch bearer of Prashant. With all these glorifying of Surya I am - and this is sin in my religion - beginning to appreciate Prashant :P
-
From: Querida on 7th August 2009 12:12 PM [Full View]
What really? Originally Posted by groucho070
Can you please name a movie in which he has done this...I want to see for myself... 
Vishal should have never shaved his head for the ending scene of Satyam...it made me notice his ears for the first time....
-
From: littlemaster1982 on 7th August 2009 12:17 PM [Full View]
Irava Pagala song in Poovellam Kettuppaar. Originally Posted by Querida
What really? Originally Posted by groucho070
Can you please name a movie in which he has done this...I want to see for myself...
-
From: NOV on 7th August 2009 12:21 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
the ONLY light at the end of the tunnel.
madhavan is good but far from stepping into Kamal's shoes. In the interim there's jeeva. maybe bharath and why not, even danush.
Rakesh, why is self-improvement being looked down upon? Kamal himself couldnt have done a Hey Ram or an Anbe Sivam in the early 80s. People must progress or they will remain in the same rut forever.
Your arguments are turning shallow with your sudden appreciation for Prashanth. This doesnt augur well for a film fan.
-
From: Wibha on 7th August 2009 12:22 PM [Full View]
Raaja sundaram dances right? Originally Posted by littlemaster1982
Irava Pagala song in Poovellam Kettuppaar. Originally Posted by Querida
What really? Originally Posted by groucho070
Can you please name a movie in which he has done this...I want to see for myself...
-
From: littlemaster1982 on 7th August 2009 12:23 PM [Full View]
Answer therinjukitte kelvi kekkaradhu thappu Originally Posted by Wibha
Raaja sundaram dances right? Originally Posted by littlemaster1982
Irava Pagala song in Poovellam Kettuppaar. Originally Posted by Querida
What really? Originally Posted by groucho070
Can you please name a movie in which he has done this...I want to see for myself...
-
From: Wibha on 7th August 2009 12:24 PM [Full View]
no adhe maadhiri innoru paatum iruku and I thought raaja sundaram dances for it. Originally Posted by littlemaster1982
Answer therinjukitte kelvi kekkaradhu thappu
-
From: groucho070 on 7th August 2009 12:30 PM [Full View]
Come on, he is not stepping in anyone shoe. He got his own pair and is of different size. Originally Posted by NOV
I am banking on them. Great bunch at very young age. Originally Posted by NOV
Kamal did not improve himself. He came prepared and went on experimenting, introducing new stuff to TFI. HR or AS did not come to him at that age. Films like Swathy Muthyam, 16 VAyathinile, and others did (please refer to his fav films, scene thread). Originally Posted by NOV
Next time when I am kidding, do I have to put "Kidding, please laugh your rear off at this part, the very part I end the sentence, yes, there, yes, right"? Originally Posted by NOV
Your arguments are turning shallow with your sudden appreciation for Prashanth. This doesnt augur well for a film fan.
-
From: raghavendran on 7th August 2009 12:34 PM [Full View]
for me surya doesnt come in the unique category...he is followin foot steps of kamal...
-
From: raghavendran on 7th August 2009 12:35 PM [Full View]
m-a-d-d-y
-
From: Raikkonen on 7th August 2009 12:44 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by raghavendran
thread start panni aalungala adichukka vittutu, ippa vanthu nice-ah postal vote veraya??
keep it up
-
From: NOV on 7th August 2009 12:45 PM [Full View]
kamal stepped into sivaji's shoes and now probably, and in all likelihood, surya will step into kamal's shoes. can you imagine a TFI without Kamal in the 80s 90s?
I am happy that Kamal has an heir. its actually quite bleak like what PR said.
I dont really care whether its Surya, Jeeva, Bharath, Madhavan or Danush. I want to see good films with good acting!
-
From: groucho070 on 7th August 2009 12:49 PM [Full View]
Me too. Shruthi is a heck of a musician Originally Posted by NOV
-
From: Shakthiprabha on 7th August 2009 12:54 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by groucho070
Me too. Shruthi is a heck of a musician Originally Posted by NOV
-
From: sivank on 7th August 2009 12:54 PM [Full View]
in my opinion both are talented, as of now Surya is a bit ahead.
Maddy for a very long time was contented to don his chocolate hero image but after Maniratnams Ayudha ezhuthu there seems to be a change inhim. He started acting in films like thambi, evano oruvan.
Maddy´s biggest advantage is that we are able to see him as one of our own family members or friends
Surya after delivering desasters seemed to be a changed person after finishing Nandha. He decided to take the hard route, like kamal and NT before him. I can´t imagine any present day heroes deforming themselves as a koonu kunjan. I think this Jekyll and hyde role gave him experience to do later films like ghajini and VA.
I am happy to have them both in TFI
-
From: groucho070 on 7th August 2009 01:01 PM [Full View]
NT and Kamal did not decide to take hard route. They were well equipped to tackle roles that came to them because they were able to do it, not because they decided enough is enough let's improve further by having six pack and do difficult roles. Originally Posted by sivank
NT & Kamal tackled roles that will not be offered to others. They did not give VPK to SSR. They did not give Salanggai Oli to Mohan.
Check the Malayalam original. I think Kalyan Kumar already tackled that in Mani Osai. Originally Posted by sivank
Yeah, I agree. Gives variety. At least the ladies, and mothers who want their son-in-law to be like Surya are helping to sell the tickets in an ailing industry. Originally Posted by sivank
-
From: NOV on 7th August 2009 01:02 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by sivank
there is consistency in our thinking.
I am happy to have them both in TFI
outside of Hub I dont think anyone sees them as rivals.
-
From: Prabo on 7th August 2009 01:05 PM [Full View]
Ore shoe'va ethana peru use pannuvanga Originally Posted by NOV
I will vote for madhavan if it's a tie
-
From: NOV on 7th August 2009 01:09 PM [Full View]
Rakesh, I think you are missing a point. No one is expecting Kamal to be a carbon copy of NT and for Surya to be a carbon copy of Kamal. Each will do it in thier own ways.
That Suriya has a six pack or that he took roles declined by others doesnt affect his taents an iota bit.
Whats important is that TFI gets an actor who will be spoken about for a long time and used as a referal point for future actors. Surya fits into this while Madhavan doesnt. Simple as that.
-
From: groucho070 on 7th August 2009 01:10 PM [Full View]
I don't. No way. Madhavan is a class of his own, avar range-um market-um veera. I am not sure who Surya's rival is. That is why initially I didn't want to participate in this thread. To quote Pacino again, "Just when I thought I was out....they pulled me back in" and had an heart attack. Originally Posted by NOV
outside of Hub I dont think anyone sees them as rivals.
-
From: NOV on 7th August 2009 01:13 PM [Full View]
frankly speaking, as of now, Surya has no rival.
reiterating Prabhu Ram, thats not good news.
-
From: groucho070 on 7th August 2009 01:22 PM [Full View]
I took PR's statement differently. In the absence of a lion, a domestic cat too can claim to be the king of the jungle. The thing is, the lion is still around and is going to continue to roar its greatness for a long time. There is no heir yet. Not now. Not for the next ten or fifteen years at least. There are some pretenders around, but the lion just brushes their pretension off because he got big responsibilities in front of him.
-
From: NOV on 7th August 2009 01:23 PM [Full View]
You are speaking out of hatred, while I am speaking out of hope.
Therein lies the difference.
-
From: groucho070 on 7th August 2009 01:26 PM [Full View]
What hatred?
-
From: kid-glove on 7th August 2009 01:41 PM [Full View]
Maddy is taller, better looking, got a suave sense of dressing.
-
From: P_R on 7th August 2009 02:11 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by Raikkonen
yow prasanth thaanya jeipparu..
// reminded of prabhu's sivaji thanya jeipparu line from guru sishyan...
-
From: crajkumar_be on 7th August 2009 02:18 PM [Full View]
Benny Lava,
Naan Suriya-vukku vote pottenga
-
From: crajkumar_be on 7th August 2009 02:24 PM [Full View]
[quote="Querida"] Originally Posted by groucho070
Vishal should have never shaved his head for the ending scene of Satyam...it made me notice his ears for the first time....
-
From: MADDY on 7th August 2009 02:39 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by groucho070
Come on, he is not stepping in anyone shoe. He got his own pair and is of different size. Originally Posted by NOV
nachhu Originally Posted by groucho070
.......i think that pretty much sums up the arguements from our side- we dont bank on "being" someone who is already there......surya fans too agreed that he has limitations - avanga enna solradhu - VA DVD naa annuppuren........they have accepted that he has a limited range and it is a fact that he hasnt given knock out roles like anbe sivam or kaadhal.......and how did people come to this conclusion - like surya is the best available resource?? considering everyone has limitations from madhavan to surya to Dhanush
btw, gap is closing again
.....i think the poll should have a deadline - preferably expiring in next 10 minutes.....raghavendra - did u set poll with deadline or without deadline :P .....
-
From: MADDY on 7th August 2009 02:43 PM [Full View]
shanmugi maami: avan kaadha kadikkadhingo, ore pusu-pusu-nnu ****** Originally Posted by crajkumar_be
Originally Posted by Querida
Vishal should have never shaved his head for the ending scene of Satyam...it made me notice his ears for the first time....
-
From: groucho070 on 7th August 2009 02:47 PM [Full View]
Poor Querida, Post Vishalauralvisual Trauma-lirunthu eppa meelapooranggalooo
-
From: P_R on 7th August 2009 02:54 PM [Full View]
irunga...innum evvaLavO irukku Originally Posted by MADDY
-
From: jaiganes on 7th August 2009 05:03 PM [Full View]
ennna evvalavO?
naangalum irukkamla.
-
From: Nerd on 7th August 2009 05:42 PM [Full View]
appO naangaLLAm thuppu ketta hubbers-A? Originally Posted by NOV
wait, the poll hasnt reached its maturity yet. Originally Posted by Nerd
friday la nalla koottam varum,
already two reputable hubbers have pmed me to say they prefer Surya and have voted for him. :P
neenga, evLO pEra PM panni vote pOda sonnAlum, Maddy > Surya always
-
From: P_R on 7th August 2009 05:46 PM [Full View]
aayiram kaigaL maRaithaalum Adhavan maRaivathillai
-
From: Plum on 7th August 2009 05:47 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by MADDY
innoru murai sollunga Originally Posted by Wibha
Naan vote podardhuku munnadi MADDY had 21 votes, vote potaavutum maddy has only 21 votes. WTH
(polishing vs spontaneity - idaiye isai field-la apdiye kondu pOneengannA...naan enna solla varaennu purinjirukkumnu nenaikkarEn
waattt indha case-ayum neenga dhaan investigate pannanum NOV .....
VA airport scene oru scene-kaaga adhu super performance-nnu solradhu - i cant agree....many more unconvincing scenes in the movie just killed it......."oh my god" scene ellam - height of artificial acting.......i mean , u cud hear "lights, camera, action" before " maalini unga kitta idha solliye aaganum" ......i know he takes lots of efforts, but i've never been a fan of "effort" guys as much as the "natural" guys esp in the field of art......
-
From: Plum on 7th August 2009 05:49 PM [Full View]
innoru murai sollunga Originally Posted by MADDY
waattt Originally Posted by Wibha
Naan vote podardhuku munnadi MADDY had 21 votes, vote potaavutum maddy has only 21 votes. WTH indha case-ayum neenga dhaan investigate pannanum NOV .....
VA airport scene oru scene-kaaga adhu super performance-nnu solradhu - i cant agree....many more unconvincing scenes in the movie just killed it......."oh my god" scene ellam - height of artificial acting.......i mean , u cud hear "lights, camera, action" before " maalini unga kitta idha solliye aaganum" ......i know he takes lots of efforts, but i've never been a fan of "effort" guys as much as the "natural" guys esp in the field of art......
(polishing vs spontaneity - idaiye isai field-la apdiye kondu pOneengannA...naan enna solla varaennu purinjirukkumnu nenaikkarEn
-
From: Nerd on 7th August 2009 05:50 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by Prabhu Ram
-
From: Plum on 7th August 2009 05:52 PM [Full View]
Appo prabhuvukku sivaji maadhiri ungaLukku Prashanth? Originally Posted by Raikkonen
yow prasanth thaanya jeipparu..
// reminded of prabhu's sivaji thanya jeipparu line from guru sishyan...
-
From: NOV on 7th August 2009 06:55 PM [Full View]
adha eppadi naa en vaayala sollradhu Originally Posted by Nerd
-
From: P_R on 7th August 2009 07:06 PM [Full View]
s.v. Sangeedha: neenga mahArAsanA irukkaNum Originally Posted by Nerd
appO naangaLLAm thuppu ketta hubbers-A?
Supervisor subramani: appo naangellAm maanangkettu road-la alaiyaNumA <censored>
-
From: P_R on 7th August 2009 07:06 PM [Full View]
yEn ? Originally Posted by Nerd
Originally Posted by Prabhu Ram
-
From: Sarna on 7th August 2009 07:33 PM [Full View]
do u mean Sakthi from PM ? or Sithan itself Originally Posted by Prabhu Ram
Bala dhaana director Vishal nadichchirundhaakooda Surya level'ku vandhirukkum Bala kallayum nadikkavappaar
Prashanth'a kooda Bala nadikkavappaar if Prashanth co-operates
-
From: Nerd on 7th August 2009 07:46 PM [Full View]
PR,
I meant to quote "supervisor" but andha dialaak-a (Ippo NOV) sonnathu Sangeetha dhAn-nu enakku idhu varaikkum theriyAdhu. Note pannadhE illai.
Socked because I dint expect that from you. It was a typical fan-boy quote. I don't know how to explain but another example is your Ayan revu. So unlike PR :P
Sarna, Kamal or even Karthik-Oda Muga amaippum, Maddy or Arvindswamy-Oda muga amaippum comletely different. But as I said earlier and like you have said now, only Bala fossible
-
From: Sarna on 7th August 2009 07:58 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by Prabhu Ram
Disagree. Originally Posted by Nerd
Even if one were to cede the projected gap between what Surya would achieve in Madhavan's best roles, it is with the complete assurance that it is only a matter of time before he seals the gap.savaal vidura maadhiri irukku ? Originally Posted by Prabhu Ram
-
From: P_R on 7th August 2009 08:01 PM [Full View]
appidindreenga. sari konjam socks-ai pull paNNi stiff upper-lip aayiruvOm. Originally Posted by Nerd
This one is more a timing rebuttal designed to use his next movie title. Chance kidaichudhu sollittEn. idhellAm naan maRandhuruvEn. neengaLum maRandhuraNum. Long time divorce between felicity of expression and intensity of opinion.
btw my leaning towards Surya goes back a long way so it shouldn't be surprising. I remember Cinefan mentioning he was disappointed with Ghajini and saw it largely because I had nice things to say about it.
avunga avunga sudhaarippA irukka vENaamA.
-
From: P_R on 7th August 2009 08:05 PM [Full View]
I don't buy this. IMNSHO his success with Arya was moderate. But he masked Arya's weaknesses by adopting some clever tactics. Originally Posted by Sarna
Bala dhaana director Vishal nadichchirundhaakooda Surya level'ku vandhirukkum Bala kallayum nadikkavappaar
-
From: crajkumar_be on 7th August 2009 08:07 PM [Full View]
Exactly PR! Was about to post this.
-
From: crajkumar_be on 7th August 2009 08:10 PM [Full View]
Apparam yen PM la Laila and her father-a nadikka veikka mudiyala. Abitha in Sethu, etc... Not to mention the fundamental problem with Sithan's character (ok, many would disagree here)
-
From: MADDY on 7th August 2009 08:13 PM [Full View]
oscar winning score SDM was composed in 3 weeks - yes u r right Originally Posted by Plum
innoru murai sollunga
(polishing vs spontaneity - idaiye isai field-la apdiye kondu pOneengannA...naan enna solla varaennu purinjirukkumnu nenaikkarEn
*oscar-nna ennannu theriyuma???
-
From: Nerd on 7th August 2009 08:13 PM [Full View]
Well, Arya-kku "scope" rembbba kammi in NK and I m talking about the "role". Siththan character though it was more raw/unrefined the "scope" was much greater. He even did "romaans". Arya was one-dimensional and for that character, Bala dint need a Vikram or a Surya. But, nobody can say Arya was bad in NK and that is Bala's strenth. He can make anyone act by casting them cleverly and Bala films ellAm rejetted when it comes to measuring good ferformanses.
CR, main matter-a pEsuvOm. Side character ellAm free. And I thought Laila did a good job in PM.
-
From: Sarna on 7th August 2009 08:13 PM [Full View]
Arya's charactor was written(by Bala) like that Originally Posted by Prabhu Ram
I don't buy this. IMNSHO his success with Arya was moderate. But he masked Arya's weaknesses by adopting some clever tactics. Originally Posted by Sarna
Bala dhaana director Vishal nadichchirundhaakooda Surya level'ku vandhirukkum Bala kallayum nadikkavappaar andha charactor apdidhaan irukkanum adha kora koodaadhu
btw adhu enna NS
-
From: crajkumar_be on 7th August 2009 08:15 PM [Full View]
Sarna, "Not so"
-
From: P_R on 7th August 2009 08:16 PM [Full View]
Agree paNNumbOdhu kooda panjAyathai kiLappuraarEyya Originally Posted by Plum
innoru murai sollunga
(polishing vs spontaneity - idaiye isai field-la apdiye kondu pOneengannA...naan enna solla varaennu purinjirukkumnu nenaikkarEn
EdhO oNNu..andha camp-la kuzhappam irundhaa sari.
-
From: crajkumar_be on 7th August 2009 08:16 PM [Full View]
Appo Anbe Sivam, Nala Damayanthi, Kannathil, Alaifayudhe, AE-um rejecta? Originally Posted by Nerd
-
From: Nerd on 7th August 2009 08:19 PM [Full View]
Nala Damayandhi include panniyE aaganum. Adhu kamal padam illaiyE!
Mani/KH/Bala films ellAm oru bracket
GVM film oru bracket - only because they both have acted in one.
MathadhellAm oru bracket.
Sariyaa?!
-
From: Sarna on 7th August 2009 08:21 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by crajkumar_be
btw, on repeated viewings also , Laila's acting(shEshtaigal) was completely enjoyable unlike Surya's acting(comedy)
I never got bored of Laila in PM
padam paaththu romba naal aagudhu, poor memory Originally Posted by crajkumar_be
but I dont think she was bad
-
From: crajkumar_be on 7th August 2009 08:22 PM [Full View]
Indha alavukku bracket podreenga! (BTW, hate that expression along with "correct", "compare" but i digress )
- Andha madhiri discount panna mudiyadhu nu solla varen. There are some actors whom even the best directors cannot save.
ND - Sir oli naada moolama paadam nadathinaar, Palakkad baashai
-
From: P_R on 7th August 2009 08:22 PM [Full View]
Sithan and Sakthi were not successes because of casting but cases of casting actors against their types. Originally Posted by Nerd
-
From: P_R on 7th August 2009 08:23 PM [Full View]
( Originally Posted by crajkumar_be
Indha alavukku bracket podreenga! (BTW, hate that expression along with "correct", "compare" but i digress ))
-
From: P_R on 7th August 2009 08:25 PM [Full View]
Oh appidi solraarA.. mudhalla kuzhambittEn Originally Posted by crajkumar_be
Appo Anbe Sivam, Nala Damayanthi, Kannathil, Alaifayudhe, AE-um rejecta? Originally Posted by Nerd
-
From: Nerd on 7th August 2009 08:29 PM [Full View]
neenga solra maadhiriyum sollalAm, but one should not expect an actor to play "all" kinds of roles. I am including everyone here, physical appearance/build-E thadaiyaa irukkum Originally Posted by Prabhu Ram
Sithan and Sakthi were not successes because of casting but cases of casting actors against their types. Originally Posted by Nerd
-
From: crajkumar_be on 7th August 2009 08:30 PM [Full View]
Absolutely, no exceptions!
-
From: villan007 on 7th August 2009 08:41 PM [Full View]
Sakthi charcter-a Vijay nadichirintha innum nalla pannirupaapla ....
-
From: Vivasaayi on 7th August 2009 08:43 PM [Full View]
indha postoda uLnokkam puriyudhu.. Originally Posted by villan007
Sakthi charcter-a Vijay nadichirintha innum nalla pannirupaapla ....
-
From: villan007 on 7th August 2009 08:45 PM [Full View]
ada serious-a solrenunga Bala's first choice was Vijay
-
From: Nerd on 7th August 2009 08:45 PM [Full View]
27-29. Ermmn... Innum close-A vandhaal naanum Prabo-vum enga Vito power-a use pannuvOm :P
-
From: Raikkonen on 7th August 2009 08:45 PM [Full View]
podaskie ya vida athigama vijay pathi post pannathu neengathan.. Originally Posted by villan007
Sakthi charcter-a Vijay nadichirintha innum nalla pannirupaapla ....
-
From: villan007 on 7th August 2009 08:48 PM [Full View]
aaga
-
From: Vivasaayi on 7th August 2009 08:48 PM [Full View]
groucho's argument that Maddy does what really comes to him and surya tries to fit in someones shoes does sort of OK
On those lines .. we can say delhi ganesh is a better actor than all other actors in tamil cinema
I dont find anyone playing their charecter as good and easily as the "avvai shanmugi" or "mmkr"
kounder also did what came to him and how?can we call him the best actor?
its not about doing 2 or 3 roles excellently time and again
its about doing challenging roles in an acceptable manner.
U cant ask why he is trying to prove.. a person like kamal haasan who has proved everything in Tamilcinema did dasavatharam to prove himself again
who is a better student in a class
"a guy who gets 100 marks in two subjects and skips all other subjects"
or "a guy who passes every subjects?"
-
From: Anban on 7th August 2009 09:22 PM [Full View]
surya was superb in perazhagan.. and some portions of VA.. Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
groucho's argument that Maddy does what really comes to him and surya tries to fit in someones shoes does sort of OK
On those lines .. we can say delhi ganesh is a better actor than all other actors in tamil cinema
I dont find anyone playing their charecter as good and easily as the "avvai shanmugi" or "mmkr"
kounder also did what came to him and how?can we call him the best actor?
its not about doing 2 or 3 roles excellently time and again
its about doing challenging roles in an acceptable manner.
U cant ask why he is trying to prove.. a person like kamal haasan who has proved everything in Tamilcinema did dasavatharam to prove himself again
who is a better student in a class
"a guy who gets 100 marks in two subjects and skips all other subjects"
or "a guy who passes every subjects?"
avvalavu thaann.. nothing SPECIAL apart from that...
-
From: Anban on 7th August 2009 09:22 PM [Full View]
madhavan is excelling in "normal" roles.. very natural..
-
From: Vivasaayi on 7th August 2009 09:32 PM [Full View]
normal roles? Originally Posted by Anban
urban guy roles..
normal rolesna neraya irukku..
he does what comes to him..so obviously it would be natural and spontaneaous
versatility is inversely proportional to ease in acting ..
-
From: Vivasaayi on 7th August 2009 09:33 PM [Full View]
perazhagan,VA anabanukku pidicha madhiri pithamagan was liked by many...gajni was liked by many
he was able convince people by doing those roles
Maddy try-e panla..adhaan vishayam..
-
From: complicateur on 7th August 2009 09:36 PM [Full View]
This is essentially a contest between earnestness and intelligence. As always, over the course of time intelligence wins. Count one more vote for Maddy.
-
From: Nerd on 7th August 2009 09:40 PM [Full View]
Director Saar-E sollittAr... Originally Posted by complicateur
And kid-glove, vote pOttuttIngalla?!
-
From: MADDY on 7th August 2009 09:42 PM [Full View]
aama aama..... Originally Posted by Nerd
(aana idha blanket "agreement"a vechhu, music arguements-kkum eduthhuruvaar oruthhar )
-
From: complicateur on 7th August 2009 09:50 PM [Full View]
This is a too much! Originally Posted by Nerd
Machchi Machchi too muchi! Originally Posted by MADDY
(aana idha blanket "agreement"a vechhu, music arguements-kkum eduthhuruvaar oruthhar )
By the way my compliments to whoever used the spelling of "see my mAppLai talends" in the thread title!
-
From: MADDY on 7th August 2009 09:56 PM [Full View]
cha cha, naa ungala sollalainga Originally Posted by complicateur
Machchi Machchi too muchi! Originally Posted by MADDY
(aana idha blanket "agreement"a vechhu, music arguements-kkum eduthhuruvaar oruthhar )
-
From: jaiganes on 7th August 2009 09:58 PM [Full View]
I think compli has summed up succintly what I have been trying to say. Talent wise Maddy scores over easily. opportunities have not been coming his way. It is grossly insulting to say that only a surya could do a Gasini (what a piece of crap) or kakka kakka or varanam aayiram . madhavan has been stereotyped by directors of thamizh cinema as the middle class urban guy. It is not his fault and lets hypothesize for a moment that such a role comes to him, being a gifted and natural actor he would excel and bring more to the role than a Surya who needs extensive video footage and konar guide for preparation and still end up giving only a fraction of what is required. not to stress too much, but a Karunas is a far more free flowing natural actor compared to surya - but he will not get the opportunity to play a anbuselvan - that does not mean the person playing anbuselvan is a far superior actor or a 'talented actor' in comparison.
-
From: viraajan on 7th August 2009 10:04 PM [Full View]
Nice Originally Posted by complicateur
-
From: P_R on 7th August 2009 10:11 PM [Full View]
ippo dhaan gavanichchEn Originally Posted by complicateur
By the way my compliments to whoever used the spelling of "see my mAppLai talends" in the thread title!
-
From: P_R on 7th August 2009 10:21 PM [Full View]
ippo enna ellArum surya paNra role ellAm Madhavan paNNiruvaarundreengaLA ?
(same tone as GM to manager in the post-election scene)
Surya requires extensive prep-ngreenga. Sari irundhuttu pOgattum.It is not his fault and lets hypothesize for a moment that such a role comes to him, being a gifted and natural actor he would excel and bring more to the role than a Surya who needs extensive video footage and konar guide for preparation and still end up giving only a fraction of what is required
He will still not be able to do full justice to the role -ndreenga. sari adhuvum irundhuttu pOgattum.
But in such a role Madhavan pirichu mEynjuruvaarnu solreenga paarunga. anga dhaan objectionE. Slightly out of comf zone, thambi-nu oru padam...... adhai paththi thEvayaana aLavukku yErkanavE alasittOm.
Anyway the margin persistance is testing patience. mudslinging eppo aarambikkalaam.
-
From: jaiganes on 7th August 2009 10:29 PM [Full View]
he requires extensive prep - and still he is just passnnu dhaan naan solren. Karnataka statela 35 eduthaale pass dhaan - andha scale padi surya class A, but Maddy endha state scale apply panninaalum 'distinction' apdingradhu en thaazhmayaana karuththu. Originally Posted by Prabhu Ram
Thambi paththi pesanumnaa - I would say the precursor to that role would be what he did in 'Kannaththil' - angry young writer - he effortlessly personified an amalgamation of atleast three to four renowned thamizh writers. Thambi worked inspite of konashtai ideas of seeman thanks largely to Maddy. Suryavai potrundhaa innum 'unbearable' aagi irukkum. - solla pona sanjay ramasamee sarbath kudichaapola aagi irukkum.
-
From: Nerd on 7th August 2009 10:32 PM [Full View]
AthOda converse-a paththi konjam alasungaLEn. (EO, YN, AE for example). adhellAm surya-kku current kambi-la ukkArra maadhiri. Surya would attempt them *earnestly* but sock adichu vizhunthuruvaaru. OTOH, Maddy indha vishayathula NarasimmA maadhiri :P Originally Posted by Prabhu Ram
-
From: jaiganes on 7th August 2009 10:33 PM [Full View]
As far as maddy doing roles that surya does, I dare say evan venumnaalum seyyalaam. Maddy innum nallaave seivaar. Maths la puli accountancylayun pinnuvaan, Engineeringayum poLandhu kattuvaan. Adhu pola.
-
From: P_R on 7th August 2009 10:43 PM [Full View]
EO - I don't think much of it Originally Posted by Nerd
AthOda converse-a paththi konjam alasungaLEn. (EO, YN, AE for example). adhellAm surya-kku current kambi-la ukkArra maadhiri. Surya would attempt them *earnestly* but sock adichu vizhunthuruvaaru. OTOH, Maddy indha vishayathula NarasimmA maadhiri :P Originally Posted by Prabhu Ram
YN - Surya will struggle. Only a matter of time.
AE - Maddy's best performance IMO. Only a matter of some more time.
PErazhagan/Pithamagan/Mayavi - jenmaththula mudiyadhu. Congenital drawbacks
VA - Where Surya slipped Madhavan would certainly do better. Where Surya excelled I doubt if Madhavan can match up.
I am consciously avoiding mentioning Gajini because it will distract.
There are certain scenes even in Ayan which I doubt Madhavan can do as impressively.
-
From: complicateur on 7th August 2009 10:45 PM [Full View]
Surya, whether his supporters would like to hear this or not, has a niche. I think the bald Ghajini character was beyond salvation so lets disregard that. His Sanjay Ramaswamy was just about as incongruous as the name when he was playing corporate head honcho. The reason he worked so resoundingly was the earthiness he displayed when round Kalpana. Every woman's dream of a type A go getter man who has a chocolatey nugatey inside. So unfortunately he got credit for playing a character he didnt actually play. The Ayan role was more up his sleeve.
Madhavan on the other hand was spectacular even in intolerable movies like ReNdu. Wait I'm talking about Anushka... Well he was tolerable in some pretty unremarkable movies. His 'weakness' is essentially the language and his unconscious urbanization of the same. But if acting is what you do when words aren't required then Maddy's deficiency is inherently handled.
-
From: jaiganes on 7th August 2009 10:48 PM [Full View]
Ala Guru sishyan - PR sir - Ipppo enna seiveenga ippo enna seiveenga javalakidi ippo enna seiveenga. Originally Posted by complicateur
-
From: P_R on 7th August 2009 10:56 PM [Full View]
Basically don't you even see Surya is getting better by leaps and bounds. KK v VA ?
I psychonanalyze that the problem in appreciating Surya () is that one if always conscious that he is not perfect and certainly not the great-thing that the junta now celebrates him to be. It takes effort to not miss what he is doing amid all that.
For instance the old man's role in VA. Very ordinary, very studied body-language, rigor mortis in motion etc. This had to be granted, atleast as a bargaining point to establish Surya Jr. performance.
But is the old man's role unselected en masse ? Far far from.
Telephone booth scenes in VA.
<personal digression: MADDY enge ? "calling parents from a small booth in a lonely distant country..that is me ..">
-"pudichittAn" with a naughty twinkle in his eye.
-the disappointment he shows in that one scene in Anjalai
- that vacant stare looking around for help in the opening scene in the bathroom
and many such as this.
-
From: jaiganes on 7th August 2009 11:03 PM [Full View]
neenga enna sivakumar family well wisheraa? Originally Posted by Prabhu Ram
Basically don't you even see Surya is getting better by leaps and bounds. KK v VA ?
I psychonanalyze that the problem in appreciating Surya () is that one if always conscious that he is not perfect and certainly not the great-thing that the junta now celebrates him to be. It takes effort to not miss what he is doing amid all that.
For instance the old man's role in VA. Very ordinary, very studied body-language, rigor mortis in motion etc. This had to be granted, atleast as a bargaining point to establish Surya Jr. performance.
But is the old man's role unselected en masse ? Far far from.
Telephone booth scenes in VA.
<personal digression: MADDY enge ? "calling parents from a small booth in a lonely distant country..that is me ..">
-"pudichittAn" with a naughty twinkle in his eye.
-the disappointment he shows in that one scene in Anjalai
- that vacant stare looking around for help in the opening scene in the bathroom
and many such as this.
indha scene ellaamE nalla thaan irukku. nijamaave surya mattamaa nadikkalai - but what is the point - maddyai compare pannaa - avar innum EFFFORT podanum. yaanai paduththaalum kudhirai mattam dhaanya (till u find a ayyanaar koil kudhirai).
Andha senior role in VA - nesamaave oru gourava nadigarai koottittu vandhirukkalaam. innum nalla thathroobamaa irundhirukkum (Rajesh, Vinu chakravarthi anyone?)
-
From: P_R on 7th August 2009 11:06 PM [Full View]
I won't defend Gajini here because I don't remember being put off at all. But the consensus on your side is so overwhelming that I should atleast pay it a revisit. I found the character kinda caricatured and too loud. But the movie itself was that way. Originally Posted by complicateur
I'd like to draw attention to you statement of Surya being on the ball in Ayan. Well I say he is getting better and better.
nalla muyarchi. Originally Posted by complicateur
Words, how they are spoken, how convincing characteristic they are is an essential component of acting. It is the very basis on which I have misgivings on a whole lot.
-
From: jaiganes on 7th August 2009 11:08 PM [Full View]
Dont put someone's words in my mouthsu... Originally Posted by Prabhu Ram
I won't defend Gajini here because I don't remember being put off at all. But the consensus on your side is so overwhelming that I should atleast pay it a revisit. I found the character kinda caricatured and too loud. But the movie itself was that way. Originally Posted by jaiganes
I'd like to draw attention to you statement of Surya being on the ball in Ayan. Well I say he is getting better and better.
nalla muyarchi. Originally Posted by complicateur
Words, how they are spoken, how convincing characteristic they are is an essential component of acting. It is the very basis on which I have misgivings on a whole lot.
-
From: P_R on 7th August 2009 11:09 PM [Full View]
Reporter: Indian thAthAvaaga ungaL aNNan charuhAsanai nadikka vaichurakkalaamEAndha senior role in VA - nesamaave oru gourava nadigarai koottittu vandhirukkalaam. innum nalla thathroobamaa irundhirukkum (Rajesh, Vinu chakravarthi anyone?)
Kamal: oru mandhiravaadhi...kaathulErndhu muttaiya varavazhaikkaraar...adhisayam muttaiyilayA irukku
-
From: kid-glove on 7th August 2009 11:12 PM [Full View]
Yep. Originally Posted by Nerd
-
From: jaiganes on 7th August 2009 11:13 PM [Full View]
jaiganes: Indha 'slang' vechu actingai edai podaradhai naama niruththanumnaen.
andha vagayai vechchu paaththaa - Rasini kanthu maadhiri periya nadigargaLayum odhukkittu kanja karuppu dhaan sirandha kalaimaamaninnu sollavendi irukkumdov.
Vivs : yov vennai kanja karuppu kalaimamani dhaan..
jaiganes: adongokkamakka - thamizhnaadu uruppadadhu!!
viva: idhe dialogai eththanai paer eththanai naaLa solveenga - modhalla neenga uruppadara vazhiyai paarunga.
PR: inge dhaan enakku idikkudhu - Kanja karuppoda pin naveenaththuva nadippila thathuvaarthamaana pala vishayangaL irukku. udhaaranamaa sollaponaa..
NOV: venaam naama niruthikkalaam. Indha threadai naan podhumakkaL nalankarudhi naane thaali aruththuRRen.
Nerd: habaada!!
-
From: Plum on 7th August 2009 11:16 PM [Full View]
Andha accent pogaadhu polirukkE! Originally Posted by crajkumar_be
Appo Anbe Sivam, Nala Damayanthi, Kannathil, Alaifayudhe, AE-um rejecta? Originally Posted by Nerd
-
From: jaiganes on 7th August 2009 11:17 PM [Full View]
Reporter: Saar muttai odanju poiduththu. odanja muttaikku ownerkku neenga badhil solliye aaganum. Originally Posted by Prabhu Ram
Menaka Gandhi: muttaikkulla kozhi irundhadhaal Indhian padaththai release panna koodadhu!!
Am.Rathnam : naanga erkanave release panni Raj TV layum kaatitome.
Vinu chakravarthi: Ippo enna seiveenga ippo enna seiveenga.
-
From: Plum on 7th August 2009 11:22 PM [Full View]
Saringa. 3 weeks paNdradhu dhaan ungaLukku spontaneity_nA shake hands, walks off. Besides, is 3 weeks a rule or excewption. Vidai ungalukkE theriyum Originally Posted by MADDY
oscar winning score SDM was composed in 3 weeks - yes u r right Originally Posted by Plum
innoru murai sollunga
(polishing vs spontaneity - idaiye isai field-la apdiye kondu pOneengannA...naan enna solla varaennu purinjirukkumnu nenaikkarEn
*oscar-nna ennannu theriyuma???
P.S: actually, spontneity-A, polished-A shouldn't matter. But aruvA aruvA dhaan, maNN vetii maNN vetti dhaan
P.p.s.s: oscaar toyota carlaam engalukku theriyadhungo. Educeet illengo
-
From: complicateur on 7th August 2009 11:27 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by Prabhu Ram
I'll admit the adulation is blinding me. But what is also blinding is my awareness of his effort. VA as a film I didn't find memorable at all, due in no small part to "is bandhA-nE bahuth fight ladAyA hai bhai" comments from my hindi speaking brethren in the theatre. So I'll hold from commenting on the senior role except to say that to unselet actors on their verbal diction and condone Krishnan's MalayaLam is quite contradictory.
Let us take the case of close-up shots some of the toughest for an actor to do. There are none specifically I can remember of Surya but there are at least 2 I can remember of Maddy's from YN alone.
-
From: P_R on 7th August 2009 11:53 PM [Full View]
nEkku adhu theriyAdhuand condone Krishnan's MalayaLam
enakku therinjadhellAm "appo horn-ai kaNdupudichavan maLayALiyA ?" range dhaan.
His brow is wet with honest sweat. Accepted
I will the end the day with bonhomie without a clamour for the last word.
irundhaalum.....
-
From: ArulprakasH on 8th August 2009 12:04 AM [Full View]
Originally Posted by jaiganes
-
From: NOV on 8th August 2009 07:49 AM [Full View]
half the ppl who voted for Maddy would fall in this category while the remaining have agendas up thier sleeve. Originally Posted by complicateur
-
From: MADDY on 8th August 2009 08:24 AM [Full View]
roobaaroo from RDB was composed in 45 minutes, pal pal bhari from swades was composed in 1 day - wat i meant was thalaivar is a "master" and its his choice to be spontaneous or polish it to his satisfaction......polishing in music is "only" effort-nnu nenaikkradhu , enakku eedubaadu illa........adhum vera, i didnt mean surya takes time to complete his shots and rahman's works=surya's works ngra adhi bayangara analogy ellam enakku out-of-syllabus......i mean i wouldnt say a SV.Shekar is a ilayaraja just bcos both of them are spontaneous.... Originally Posted by Plum
-
From: NOV on 8th August 2009 08:35 AM [Full View]
innumaa 7 days aagala?
-
From: Benny Lava on 8th August 2009 09:11 AM [Full View]
To me it doesn't matter whether Surya has to do undergo lot of preparation or whether Maddy is spontaneous, the bottomline is when I watch Surya's movies I get the feeling "paravala, surya nalla nadichirukaaru/nadikka try panni irukaaru" whereas with Maddy, many times I forget that he is acting, instead subconsciously start feeling that he is the character itself. There have been exceptions to the above like Surya in pithamagan and Maddy in KM (Maddy did a good job in KM, yet I felt his acting was a bit conscious and visible).
-
From: kid-glove on 8th August 2009 10:17 AM [Full View]
Surya is probably the most improved actor around, and I look forward to his films. I liked 'Ayan' a lot, and thought Surya has come leap and bounds. But I don't think Surya could ever render a role like Inba, Manohar, Nikhil Agarwal, or Shyam, um, what is that word again, yeah - intrinsically. Moreover, Maddy could hold his own against likes of Naseer in 'Sunglass', and Aamir khan (who I had argued to be overrated in a different thread, in fact Surya will end up being a better actor than Aamir) in 'Three idiots' (to a better extent than he did with a limited role in RDB). That's a great quality to have. And as for him not able to do a Perazhagan, pithamagan, etc, it's more physicality than talent. And yeah, 'accent'. But that is no end-all scale to gauge 'acting'. Even Mohanlal couldn't do such roles with complete authenticity, but I'm not sure it would belittle his ability any less. Madhavan has his own range and ability (his physicality and upbringing plays a major part here), and I believe that is enough substance to dismiss the purported inferiority to his peers.
-
From: Plum on 8th August 2009 10:38 AM [Full View]
Maaddy, idhu sriyana vidai. My favourite line "don't extend an analogy". VENumnE dhaan unga sponatneity comment-ai extended analogy paNNinEn. Arguably, sv sekar in his field might be compared to IR in his field in as much as gounds in his. I have no problems with that as long as you are not comparing 'venkat' or 'heron' ramasamy with IR
Sari, on surya vs maddy, some solomon papiah has to step in now and say that vazha vazha kozha kozha "rendu side-um correct dhaan hence drawn " theerppu.yaarum illaina I'll volunteer...
-
From: raghavendran on 8th August 2009 12:25 PM [Full View]
its for 10 days
the poll is for 10 days...let the battle continue
-
From: P_R on 8th August 2009 01:46 PM [Full View]
Hmmm... my ground slightly shaking. Help. Originally Posted by kid-glove
-
From: Roshan on 8th August 2009 02:38 PM [Full View]
ippOthAn intha thread'a pArthEn .. .
SURYA -all the way.. !! idhil enakku entha santhEgamO, kuzhappamO, thadumARRamO illai.. illavE illai .
-
From: crajkumar_be on 8th August 2009 04:42 PM [Full View]
Adhavadhu injury time goal madhiri kadaisi la crucial nerathula vandhu vote potteenga paarunga, adhu! Originally Posted by Roshan
-
From: kid-glove on 8th August 2009 04:48 PM [Full View]
Yeah, Let's take it to Extra time and penalties.
-
From: MADDY on 8th August 2009 05:03 PM [Full View]
hope Nerd hasnt voted yet .....
honestly i'm flattered with so much of love showered at Madhavan here.....i thot it would be a landslide win for sivakumar's son....
-
From: Vivasaayi on 8th August 2009 05:09 PM [Full View]
madhavan appa pera naanum thedi vekkaren Originally Posted by MADDY
hope Nerd hasnt voted yet .....
honestly i'm flattered with so much of love showered at Madhavan here.....i thot it would be a landslide win for sivakumar's son....
madhavan fans,sila pala ahith/vijay fans sendhum 50 50 than vara mundiyukunna enna artham???
-
From: Vivasaayi on 8th August 2009 05:10 PM [Full View]
PR...noted??? Originally Posted by Roshan
-
From: Vivasaayi on 8th August 2009 05:11 PM [Full View]
enekkennamo idhu IPL matches maadhiri fixed nu thonudhu..
31 - 31
kadaisi bandhula sixer kanakka poyitrukku
-
From: P_R on 8th August 2009 05:13 PM [Full View]
thilagar romba nallA sonnAru adhaan mindu bar viLayANduchchu. Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
PR...noted??? Originally Posted by Roshan
Anyway..veRRiyai nOkki munnEruvOm thOzhargaLE
Viv, the name is ranganathan
-
From: Vivasaayi on 8th August 2009 05:14 PM [Full View]
Noted! Originally Posted by Prabhu Ram
thilagar romba nallA sonnAru adhaan mindu bar viLayANduchchu. Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
PR...noted??? Originally Posted by Roshan
Anyway..veRRiyai nOkki munnEruvOm thOzhargaLE
Viv, the name is ranganathan
-
From: MADDY on 8th August 2009 05:32 PM [Full View]
HUB-la kamal fans jaasthi-nnu artham Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
madhavan fans,sila pala ahith/vijay fans sendhum 50 50 than vara mundiyukunna enna artham???
-
From: Vivasaayi on 8th August 2009 05:36 PM [Full View]
anban,compli ellam maddykuthana kuthunanga.. Originally Posted by MADDY
HUB-la kamal fans jaasthi-nnu artham Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
madhavan fans,sila pala ahith/vijay fans sendhum 50 50 than vara mundiyukunna enna artham???
-
From: MADDY on 8th August 2009 05:37 PM [Full View]
PR vandhu solra alavukku yaarukkum theriyaadha( Originally Posted by Prabhu Ram
) evaro oruvar......
-
From: P_R on 8th August 2009 05:39 PM [Full View]
puriyalai. background, foreground appidinnu EdhAvadhu sollappOreengaLA. Originally Posted by MADDY
PR vandhu solra alavukku yaarukkum theriyaadha( Originally Posted by Prabhu Ram
) evaro oruvar......
-
From: Appu s on 8th August 2009 05:41 PM [Full View]
rengathanathan sir mela inga yaarukkum paasam illa.. Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
Noted! Originally Posted by Prabhu Ram
thilagar romba nallA sonnAru adhaan mindu bar viLayANduchchu. Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
PR...noted??? Originally Posted by Roshan
Anyway..veRRiyai nOkki munnEruvOm thOzhargaLE
Viv, the name is ranganathan
-
From: MADDY on 8th August 2009 05:41 PM [Full View]
yabba, ungalakku aalungala kammi??? enakku therinju sourav-lam surya avatar-e sport pannaru.....ella ajith/vijay fans ellam irukka vaippu illa.....appadiye irundhalum ajith/vijay fans remba kammi ippa ellam...... Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
anban,compli ellam maddykuthana kuthunanga.. Originally Posted by MADDY
HUB-la kamal fans jaasthi-nnu artham Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
madhavan fans,sila pala ahith/vijay fans sendhum 50 50 than vara mundiyukunna enna artham???
btw, i know selva would have voted for surya if he was there in hUB, joe would have probably voted for madhavan - would have been a great judge too for this debate
-
From: Appu s on 8th August 2009 05:43 PM [Full View]
there are very less vijay\ajith fans here as far as i see in last 4-5 months, i don think they even consider this poll to vote. Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
madhavan appa pera naanum thedi vekkaren Originally Posted by MADDY
hope Nerd hasnt voted yet .....
honestly i'm flattered with so much of love showered at Madhavan here.....i thot it would be a landslide win for sivakumar's son....
madhavan fans,sila pala ahith/vijay fans sendhum 50 50 than vara mundiyukunna enna artham???
-
From: MADDY on 8th August 2009 05:45 PM [Full View]
PR, this is what i meant .......i mean, madhavan fans are exclusively for him u know Originally Posted by Appu s
-
From: NOV on 8th August 2009 05:52 PM [Full View]
what now? surya having an actor father is a sin?
PR, note thilak's point - he said "dont consider maddy as a lesser actor." thats all.
and I can safely say all those who voted for Surya, have no qualms in accepting that.
-
From: crajkumar_be on 8th August 2009 05:55 PM [Full View]
"nee kalla aattam aadra.. modhallerndhu 50 parotta kondu vaa" Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
-
From: viraajan on 8th August 2009 05:56 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by crajkumar_be
"nee kalla aattam aadra.. modhallerndhu 50 parotta kondu vaa" Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
-
From: Appu s on 8th August 2009 05:57 PM [Full View]
NOV for u he is talent just 'coz he is ur fav. but for maddy people see him really talends. Originally Posted by NOV
what now? surya having an actor father is a sin?
PR, note thilak's point - he said "dont consider maddy as a lesser actor." thats all.
and I can safely say all those who voted for Surya, have no qualms in accepting that.
-
From: crajkumar_be on 8th August 2009 06:00 PM [Full View]
Appu,
Idhu enna anyayam. Maddy ku vizhundha vote la neraya vote anti-incumbency vote dhaan.. Suriya va pidikkadhavanga...
-
From: NOV on 8th August 2009 06:02 PM [Full View]
sorry, I dont have any favourites; I will discard him as easily as a soiled handkerchief, if he does not continue doing what he has been doing. Originally Posted by Appu s
ok, enough of this shadow boxing. kid gloves coming off next.
-
From: Appu s on 8th August 2009 06:04 PM [Full View]
viraajan,Sp,groucho,jai,anban,nerd,compli,kig glove,sourav,honest raj... majority surya hatred illaye Cr...
-
From: Rocky89 on 8th August 2009 06:04 PM [Full View]
Suryaaaaaa
People are saying that Maddy is briliant at his debut while Surya needs 5-6 films to establish himself. Look, Surya enters the field at the age of 22 without any experience, while Maddy had a few years as a TV actor with himself and he's 29 years old when he did Alaipaayuthe.
Im not denying that Maddy is a good actor but Surya is just better than him for he's utilizing his talent when it really matters.
-
From: NOV on 8th August 2009 06:15 PM [Full View]
1. "Natural" Actor vs "Acquired" Actor
No one can be natural unless they do roles of themselves. Anything else has to be observed, learnt, practiced and then perfected. When Madhavan does Kannathil Muthamittal, you see Madhavan in that role, not the poet. Why? Simply because Madhavan has no actual clue as to how a poet would behave. He plays the role on how he perceives a modern day poet would act. Nothing really wrong with that as 99% of us won't know the difference. But therein lies the difference.
What about Sivaji Ganesan and Kamalahasan? Werent they "natural" actors? Of course not; if they were, we won't be still talking about them. They studied the characters they played, rehearsed and then "acted out" the role.
Unless you are not a "real" fan of NT, you would know that he sought out real-life characters, observed them, took lessons from them and then became the character themselves on screen. Did you really think that he just turned up at the studio one bright morning and transformed into Barrister Rajni Kanth?
Kamal? Why do you think he spent a month in a mental institution before doing Guna? Because being a psycho is not natural to him!
Likewise for Hey Ram, have you any idea how much research went into it before it became celluloid?
Hard work will pay off and the success you see in Surya today is NOT accidental. Among the many actors today, he is the only true professional.
-
From: NOV on 8th August 2009 06:19 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by Appu s
-
From: villan007 on 8th August 2009 06:19 PM [Full View]
adade
-
From: MADDY on 8th August 2009 06:22 PM [Full View]
oh, i thot he was the "vibudhi vechha ullen ayya" first bencher whom the whole world with its sisters/brothers/aunties/uncles/parents except me liked...... Originally Posted by crajkumar_be
surya breaks into lead .......kadaisila, anbe sivathula vara A.Ars madhiri polamba porom.........2-3 days lead-la irundhu, compli, jaiganes ellam support panni, jeikkura hope kuduthhu apram thothhu poradhu, enna madhiri design idhu .....
-
From: MADDY on 8th August 2009 06:25 PM [Full View]
heeiii look at me.....if the poll was vikram v surya , i would have definitely voted for surya.....(notwithstanding vikram is a "kazhaga udanpirappu" Originally Posted by Appu s
)
-
From: viraajan on 8th August 2009 06:26 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by MADDY
oh, i thot he was the "vibudhi vechha ullen ayya" first bencher whom the whole world with its sisters/brothers/aunties/uncles/parents except me liked...... Originally Posted by crajkumar_be
surya breaks into lead .......kadaisila, anbe sivathula vara A.Ars madhiri polamba porom.........2-3 days lead-la irundhu, compli, jaiganes ellam support panni, jeikkura hope kuduthhu apram thothhu poradhu, enna madhiri design idhu .....
indha maadiri samayathula thaan maddy'ku fans irukkangala illaya'nu...
-
From: Appu s on 8th August 2009 06:26 PM [Full View]
ok when u trying to say there is no qualm from your side to agree that maddy is not a lesser actor, people(not all exactly) from other side holding the same for surya too, atleast me. Originally Posted by NOV
Originally Posted by Appu s
so just simply finish ( )the poll with anti-surya tekniks.
-
From: viraajan on 8th August 2009 06:27 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by Appu s
surya hater? me? you must be joking!
-
From: crajkumar_be on 8th August 2009 06:28 PM [Full View]
Good point NOV. Kamal has stressed many times the importance of 'training'. 'Born with it' nu irundhaalum practice, *preparation* remba mukkiyam nu neraya masters sollirukkaanga. Namma vazhikaatti NT utpada. Originally Posted by NOV
-
From: Appu s on 8th August 2009 06:29 PM [Full View]
mannichukkonga maddy, naan innum antha "matrum" la irunthu meelala, irunthalum naan theatre vaasal kooda mithikka maatennu mudivu edukkala :P athan list la miss aayiduchu Originally Posted by MADDY
heeiii look at me.....if the poll was vikram v surya , i would have definitely voted for surya.....(notwithstanding vikram is a "kazhaga udanpirappu" Originally Posted by Appu s
)
-
From: crajkumar_be on 8th August 2009 06:31 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by MADDY
enna madhiri design idhu .....
-
From: Appu s on 8th August 2009 06:32 PM [Full View]
aama neenga illaye , athai thane naanum solren, ennada ore kuzhappama irukku Originally Posted by viraajan
Originally Posted by Appu s
surya hater? me? you must be joking!
-
From: NOV on 8th August 2009 06:33 PM [Full View]
2. English as she is spoken by Surya and Madhavan
I didnt want to comment on this earlier but since it keeps coming up frequently, let me address this too.
Please see this from a perspective of a person who was born, bred and educated outside India.
Indian English is generally heavily accented and people outside India would have some difficulty in comprehending it. I am sure some of you would have been asked to speak slowly or repeat yourselves during conversations with non Indians. I usually kid my TN friends, "thamizla pEsungappaa," because its easier to understand.
As for the cinema, the present generation's spoken English is clearer than the previous' while the previous' is better than the earlier generation. Could be because the world is shrinking.
To those outside India, Surya's, Madhavan's, Ajith's, Vijay's English are more or less the same - none is better than the other.
Ask a non Tamil film fan and you will understand why I am saying this.
So, there you are.
-
From: viraajan on 8th August 2009 06:34 PM [Full View]
sumal kanpeesan. got it right, now Originally Posted by Appu s
aama neenga illaye , athai thane naanum solren, ennada ore kuzhappama irukku Originally Posted by viraajan
Originally Posted by Appu s
surya hater? me? you must be joking!
-
From: MADDY on 8th August 2009 06:36 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by viraajan
Originally Posted by MADDY
oh, i thot he was the "vibudhi vechha ullen ayya" first bencher whom the whole world with its sisters/brothers/aunties/uncles/parents except me liked...... Originally Posted by crajkumar_be
surya breaks into lead .......kadaisila, anbe sivathula vara A.Ars madhiri polamba porom.........2-3 days lead-la irundhu, compli, jaiganes ellam support panni, jeikkura hope kuduthhu apram thothhu poradhu, enna madhiri design idhu .....
indha maadiri samayathula thaan maddy'ku fans irukkangala illaya'nu... hayyo thappu thappu, naa ungala madhiri fans illainnu solla maatten - 31 deivangal namakku vote pottiurkke :P
-
From: P_R on 8th August 2009 07:19 PM [Full View]
Ennanga idhu..Sivakumarukku Edhu fans ? EllAm suya uzhaippula sambaadhichadhu dhaan. Originally Posted by MADDY
PR, this is what i meant .......i mean, madhavan fans are exclusively for him u know Originally Posted by Appu s
In fact (Plum pOnRa) silar andha negative pedigree-ai emphasize paNradhai neenga gavanithirukkalaam
-
From: MADDY on 8th August 2009 07:28 PM [Full View]
idhellam konjam overu partner...... Originally Posted by Prabhu Ram
btw, i'm not raking that issue at all........makkalukku "star-kids, celeb-kids" ellam periya vishayame illainnu enakku nalla purijidichhu......na mattum, "ambi" madhiri kolachikittu ........
-
From: Sarna on 8th August 2009 07:35 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by complicateur
Anonymous : hayyO maadhavan fans poll'a paarunga
me : pOdaa , enga pakkam Deepauk'E irukkaaru
(read it as Rajini dialogue "pOdaa, namma pakkam aandavanE irukkaaru" )
-
From: NOV on 8th August 2009 07:38 PM [Full View]
absolutely bala. Originally Posted by crajkumar_be
Read elsewhere in Hub that Cheran is "growing a beard" for his next action-oriented role. This is the kind of effort shown in TFI now and thats why what Surya is doing offers some hope.
Kamal, at an audio launch yesterday, said that to arrest the deterioration fo standards in Tamil films, "It has to be corrected by the film buffs. Fans have to raise their voice. They should demand quality films from filmmakers."
Unfortunately what we see are some fans celebrating mediocre work such as Thambi, Yavarum Nalam and making fun of good efforts.
-
From: kid-glove on 8th August 2009 07:39 PM [Full View]
Yes, my last post is to say Maddy is no lesser talent. I don't like to compare actors anymore, but I voted for Madhavan. It's not all conclusive. It could change, but in 'talent', I feel Maddy got a weeny bit more about him (all things considered). Surya has attuned to the craft with practice. Surya might eventually be better. To make more sense, speaking figuratively, Surya is more likely to get a 7/10 in different 'versatile' roles, while Maddy might be a solid 9/10 in a slightly limited range of roles. Above all, It's not that incisive, estimating 'talent' of an actor with different methods, style and execution.
-
From: MADDY on 8th August 2009 07:55 PM [Full View]
nah Originally Posted by kid-glove
1. look at Maddy's future projects and surya's projects
2. look at maddy's path which is free flowing - nobody cares sort of, and surya's path that holds promise for distributor's dreams and their wives' thaalis.....madhavan has greater scope for qualitative improvement.....
3. madhavan keeps raising the bar......its not as if madhavan has stopped growing as a actor and surya is the only bloke growing.......yavarum nalam, mumbai meri jaan, evano oruvan are testimony to this fact.......
i would be "dead" disappointed if surya moves ahead of madhavan as a better actor in my books after all these
-
From: jaiganes on 8th August 2009 08:11 PM [Full View]
This is frivolous!!
The question is not who has performed in more author backed roles. The Q is who has more talent. hair to toe Maddy is a giant and surya is a midget. Everytime Surya tries to cry on screen I am like 'What the...'. As far as Maddy's talent(d)s are concerned, look no further than Mumbai Meri Jaan. Easily thousand VAs by surya can't touch a truly talented performance like that and that was just a freaking part in a ensemble. Also try to observe the continuous/long shots and closeups directors allocate for an actor. There is not a single closeup of Surya that stays in my mind - except when his face is shown in the jute bag in Pithamagan (thanks to Bala for that shot). Maddy had memorable memorable shots in Alai payudhe(A film I hated to the core), Minnale, Kannathil, thambi (another film I hated to the core), Run (Ok film), Anbe sivam (so many scenes) and ofcourse MMJ. Talent need not be proven in any other means in maddy's case(gimmicky six packs or konashtai slangs).
-
From: Plum on 8th August 2009 08:16 PM [Full View]
NOV, I'm not taking sides in this poll but this is probably one of the best posts in this thread. Originally Posted by NOV
Agree on your points - oru naaL ipdi unga kitta solvEnnu naanE nenachidhilla
-
From: Plum on 8th August 2009 08:18 PM [Full View]
neenga vEra ennai 'bracket pOttu' Originally Posted by Prabhu Ram
Ennanga idhu..Sivakumarukku Edhu fans ? EllAm suya uzhaippula sambaadhichadhu dhaan. Originally Posted by MADDY
PR, this is what i meant .......i mean, madhavan fans are exclusively for him u know Originally Posted by Appu s
In fact (Plum pOnRa) silar andha negative pedigree-ai emphasize paNradhai neenga gavanithirukkalaam target paNNadheenga
Idhuvum point dhaan - Surya has made it fighting his genes - periya vishyam dhaan!
-
From: Plum on 8th August 2009 08:21 PM [Full View]
idhuvum point dhaan (PR, indha indecisive backing of both sideskum edhavadhu quote vechuruppEngaLE Originally Posted by MADDY
nah Originally Posted by kid-glove
1. look at Maddy's future projects and surya's projects
2. look at maddy's path which is free flowing - nobody cares sort of, and surya's path that holds promise for distributor's dreams and their wives' thaalis.....madhavan has greater scope for qualitative improvement.....
3. madhavan keeps raising the bar......its not as if madhavan has stopped growing as a actor and surya is the only bloke growing.......yavarum nalam, mumbai meri jaan, evano oruvan are testimony to this fact.......
i would be "dead" disappointed if surya moves ahead of madhavan as a better actor in my books after all these )
Ayan might be the beginning of Surya's end - sort of taking him into the well, asith path. Innum KS Ravikumar Hari ellaam next in line pola as directors of his films. Hope ledhandi.
Whereas Madhavan has an impressive array of forthcoming films, thavira Manirathnam chella puLLa. Dice is loaded in his favour
-
From: kid-glove on 8th August 2009 08:21 PM [Full View]
A close-up to an actor is a lot like director flexing his muscles for a long take. Better the talent, an impression is fixated in memory.
-
From: Plum on 8th August 2009 08:26 PM [Full View]
hmm. the chief reason Ia m not able to take sides in this poll. Oru pakkam, Surya fans make a big deal of Ayan Originally Posted by jaiganes
Innoru pakkam, Maddy fans ennamo Alai Paayudhae Minnal RUn ellaathaiyum Ethi vudarAnga....
-
From: Roshan on 8th August 2009 08:28 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by crajkumar_be
Adhavadhu injury time goal madhiri kadaisi la crucial nerathula vandhu vote potteenga paarunga, adhu! Originally Posted by Roshan
-
From: Roshan on 8th August 2009 08:29 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by NOV
-
From: kid-glove on 8th August 2009 08:29 PM [Full View]
Last post is meant as a nod to VPJ's post. And one other way to gauge talent is simplicity, and in my book, Madhavan has an indigenous way to (facially) articulate an emotion than Surya, who seems to have a 'method'.
-
From: Roshan on 8th August 2009 08:36 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by Plum
NOV, I'm not taking sides in this poll but this is probably one of the best posts in this thread. Originally Posted by NOV
Agree on your points - oru naaL ipdi unga kitta solvEnnu naanE nenachidhilla
-
From: MADDY on 8th August 2009 08:53 PM [Full View]
true Originally Posted by jaiganes
......i dont think surya can ever do a MMj....totally out of scope for him .......lets wait for future now, maddy shouldnt squander his second chance.....as Anuragji says, life is sometimes, all about a second chance
very disappointed to see surya increasing his lead .....
-
From: Vivasaayi on 8th August 2009 08:55 PM [Full View]
dharmame vellum! Originally Posted by crajkumar_be
-
From: kid-glove on 8th August 2009 09:04 PM [Full View]
Proof having a couple of mods would help.
-
From: Sarna on 8th August 2009 09:10 PM [Full View]
gajini, KK maadhiri kuppa movie ellaam classic'nu sollvaanga Originally Posted by NOV
Unfortunately what we see are some fans celebrating mediocre work such as Thambi, Yavarum Nalam and making fun of good efforts. but Thambi medicore'aam
-
From: Roshan on 8th August 2009 09:30 PM [Full View]
Thambi was simply horrible ... adhai ellAm natural - effortless acting'la sEthupAngalA Originally Posted by Sarna
gajini, KK maadhiri kuppa movie ellaam classic'nu sollvaanga Originally Posted by NOV
Unfortunately what we see are some fans celebrating mediocre work such as Thambi, Yavarum Nalam and making fun of good efforts. but Thambi medicore'aam Even the few scenes I have seen of EO - reminded me of Thambi.
Surya simply scores with his eye expressions. That's one of his biggest pluses I would say.
-
From: Nerd on 8th August 2009 09:43 PM [Full View]
avarukku Selective Amnesia freeyA vidunga. Second best horror film in the history of Tamil films has now become mediocre.. Originally Posted by Sarna
gajini, KK maadhiri kuppa movie ellaam classic'nu sollvaanga Originally Posted by NOV
Unfortunately what we see are some fans celebrating mediocre work such as Thambi, Yavarum Nalam and making fun of good efforts. but Thambi medicore'aam Haven't seen Thambi but as MOST surya fans here acknowledged, Suryakku YN varaadhu, vandhaalum kasstappadum.
And can NOV deny that he's been campaining in CC/PP threads? naan idhukkAgavE 50 pages CC kooda padichu prove pannuvEn. Not to mention NOV's PMs to non-TF hubbers. If ONLY thamizh films hubbers had voted, Maddy-kku indha nilamai vandhirukkAdhu.
Maddy (hubber), unga influence-a use panni Rahman fans-a vote panna vayyunga. thappE illainREn. indha poll behind the scenes maadhiri vERa endha poll-kkum (Wait a minute, GM-Nagesh ) nadanthirukkAdhu.
-
From: P_R on 8th August 2009 09:44 PM [Full View]
Ennadhu !!!!! Originally Posted by NOV
Unfortunately what we see are some fans celebrating mediocre work such as Thambi, Yavarum Nalam and making fun of good efforts.
YN is far from mediocre. And Madhavan's performance is particularly good.
-
From: Raikkonen on 8th August 2009 09:45 PM [Full View]
terthal-le ennamo oozhal nadanthirukku..
recount pannanumnu solravanga ellam konja toorama poi kai tookunga..
-
From: Nerd on 8th August 2009 10:09 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by villan007
adade Timing "slightly" miss aayiduchubA.
I like Surya.
ThErthal oozhal dhaan, no two ways about it. Maddy thread Part 3-la irukku, Surya thread part 1-la 10 page mudinjirukku
-
From: Benny Lava on 8th August 2009 10:12 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by Raikkonen
-
From: Sarna on 8th August 2009 10:23 PM [Full View]
Thambi padaththula , madhavan romba natural'aa nadichchirukkaarnu yaarumE sollalayE Originally Posted by Roshan
Thambi was simply horrible ... adhai ellAm natural - effortless acting'la sEthupAngalA Even the few scenes I have seen of EO - reminded me of Thambi.
For me watching Madhavan as thambi is almost equal to watching Rajini as Alexpandian ungalukku dhaan Rajini'ya pidikkaadhE :P ungalukkaaga vEra example sollurEn....
engula pengalukku nee manjal araiththaayaa... maamanaa machchaanaa maanangettavanE'nu Nadigar thilagam dialogue pEsi nadichcha azhaga endha alavukku mei-silirththu rasichchEnO... adhEy alavukku meisilirththu rasichchEn wn madhavan says ippa enna seyya @ pooja in Thambi
Surya has improved a lot... today he is very good ...adhula endha sandhEgamumE illa Originally Posted by Roshan
MP and Ayan are Surya's best I liked VA(partly).
When it comes who is best among Madhavan and Surya, my vote is for Madhavan
other than ennavalE, I never hated one movie or even a scene of Madhavan....
-
From: Sarna on 8th August 2009 10:25 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by Benny Lava
Originally Posted by Raikkonen
-
From: Plum on 8th August 2009 10:41 PM [Full View]
Sarna, thirumba thirumba vpk comparison with thambi. NOV, Edhvadhu seiyunga...
-
From: Sarna on 8th August 2009 10:41 PM [Full View]
oh.... Gilli was a record-break then and liked by multi-many.... A centre'la irundhu x y z varaikkum Mega-blockbuster... Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
perazhagan,VA anabanukku pidicha madhiri pithamagan was liked by many...gajni was liked by many
he was able convince people by doing those roles
Kushi, KM, PU were all super hits(near to BB) and liked by multi-many... even Pokiri was BB(Ottappadala... unamayil Odiyadhu) and like by multi-many :P ...
He convinced multi-many peoples
So will u agree that Vijay is better than Surya ?
multi-many = many many more
-
From: VENKIRAJA on 8th August 2009 10:43 PM [Full View]
ithukkellAm oru thread-A? enna koduma Hub ithu?
-
From: Sarna on 8th August 2009 10:44 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by Plum
-
From: Nerd on 8th August 2009 10:45 PM [Full View]
Ada.. vote-a pOdunga.. namma nilamai konjam sariyillai Originally Posted by VENKIRAJA
-
From: crajkumar_be on 8th August 2009 10:45 PM [Full View]
Pala Originally Posted by VENKIRAJA
-
From: Raikkonen on 8th August 2009 10:48 PM [Full View]
yen avaru yerkanave senjathu pattatha?? Originally Posted by Sarna
Originally Posted by Plum
-
From: Prabo on 8th August 2009 10:52 PM [Full View]
Surya leading
pORA pOkkA pArththA iyalbAna nadippA iyanthirathanamAna nadippu jeyichchudum pOlirukkae
-
From: MADDY on 8th August 2009 11:01 PM [Full View]
aw my god - the gap is just widening......terrible
-
From: Sarna on 8th August 2009 11:03 PM [Full View]
dharmaththin vaazhvudhannai soodhu kavvidichchu Originally Posted by MADDY
-
From: MADDY on 8th August 2009 11:05 PM [Full View]
no problem - its a good lesson to understand how "critical" polls work in HUB Originally Posted by Sarna
dharmaththin vaazhvudhannai soodhu kavvidichchu Originally Posted by MADDY
.....
-
From: ArulprakasH on 8th August 2009 11:16 PM [Full View]
voteduppula iruttadippu nadanthiruchu.. so intha voting method sari illa.. :P
Manuala list thayaar pannuvOm.. enna sollreenga..
-
From: Vivasaayi on 8th August 2009 11:45 PM [Full View]
naan "different"roles nadichu accept panna vechadha sonnen.. Originally Posted by Sarna
oh.... Gilli was a record-break then and liked by multi-many.... A centre'la irundhu x y z varaikkum Mega-blockbuster... Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
perazhagan,VA anabanukku pidicha madhiri pithamagan was liked by many...gajni was liked by many
he was able convince people by doing those roles
Kushi, KM, PU were all super hits(near to BB) and liked by multi-many... even Pokiri was BB(Ottappadala... unamayil Odiyadhu) and like by multi-many :P ...
He convinced multi-many peoples
So will u agree that Vijay is better than Surya ?
multi-many = many many more
-
From: Vivasaayi on 8th August 2009 11:47 PM [Full View]
rightu..adhaan panjayathu mudinjudhulla...ellam kelambunga..
aa oooona koodida vendiyadhu
-
From: ArulprakasH on 9th August 2009 12:11 AM [Full View]
aang neenga kallaattam aaditinga.. kOttellam alainga.. mothalla irunthu aaduvOm... Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
-
From: P_R on 9th August 2009 01:01 AM [Full View]
'EdhAvadhu' paNNi indha thread-ku poottu pOdura nilaimaiyai koNdu vandhuruvomA Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
-
From: crajkumar_be on 9th August 2009 01:27 AM [Full View]
Oru velai indha anti-Suriya wave saadhi saayam sammandhappattadha irukkumo? Originally Posted by Prabhu Ram
'EdhAvadhu' paNNi indha thread-ku poottu pOdura nilaimaiyai koNdu vandhuruvomA Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
-
From: jaiganes on 9th August 2009 01:36 AM [Full View]
seriously thinking of creating couple of new ids to vote for Maddy..
oozhalukku oozhal - ore adi!!
-
From: crajkumar_be on 9th August 2009 01:40 AM [Full View]
Originally Posted by jaiganes
-
From: kid-glove on 9th August 2009 01:51 AM [Full View]
Memory can change the shape of a room; it can change the color of a car. And memories can be distorted. They're just an interpretation, they're not a record, and they're irrelevant if you have the facts. Originally Posted by MADDY
true Originally Posted by jaiganes
......i dont think surya can ever do a MMj....totally out of scope for him
And the fact is, I'd not do be pushed to do such a compilation for any of the Surya films till date. Says a lot, really.
-
From: crajkumar_be on 9th August 2009 01:56 AM [Full View]
Memento? And why does it (you doing a compilation) say a lot? Originally Posted by kid-glove
-
From: kid-glove on 9th August 2009 02:02 AM [Full View]
Nothing of Surya's work has impressed me as much. That said, I'm planning to do a compilation of Janakaraj in Guna. Perhaps there is an underlying inconsistency in that statement. Originally Posted by crajkumar_be
Sounds like Memento. And why does it (you doing a compilation) say a lot? Originally Posted by kid-glove
-
From: crajkumar_be on 9th August 2009 02:08 AM [Full View]
Illainga, facts-ngara realm la andha comment a sonnadhukku dhaan andha kelvi. I mean yeah, its a fact that you are not pushed to do a compilation for Suriya.. anyway lets chuck it... Originally Posted by kid-glove
//Dig: Janakaraj was brilliant in Guna.. wonder why Thalaivar kind of pushed the topic of Janakaraj under the carpet in a Malaysian interview, when asked by a member of audience on Kamal film constants Nasser and Janakaraj (andha kostiner ku)...
-
From: kid-glove on 9th August 2009 02:13 AM [Full View]
Facts - There is a full video of all the frames with Madhavan in it. Now, people like Maddy and Jaiganes passed off such an elucidating statement based on the film. It's a memory. But when you have the video, they could point it out as a fact. Say, 22.30 minute of the video, the way Madhavan uses subtle reactions to bring out mood swings, etc.
-
From: kid-glove on 9th August 2009 02:16 AM [Full View]
Yep, I personally think that chithappa role is Janakaraj's best. I remember the interview quite well. It was weird.
-
From: crajkumar_be on 9th August 2009 02:18 AM [Full View]
There are two "facts" in your post. One as an evidence presented as a video. Ramarajan's milking video would be no less a fact! What we infer/feel/opine from it is opinion/analysis/subjective material and which is what all the fuss in this thread is about Originally Posted by kid-glove
[I mean i'm lazy as usual to fetch a link for Suriya - VA airport scene enough, competition finis!]
The second fact is what i replied to in my last post.
"And the fact is, I'd not do be pushed to do such a compilation for any of the Surya films till date. Says a lot, really."
-
From: crajkumar_be on 9th August 2009 02:22 AM [Full View]
Avara madhiri thaane interview-um irukkum! Originally Posted by kid-glove
-
From: kid-glove on 9th August 2009 02:27 AM [Full View]
Yeah, I agree that it comes down to opinion. Originally Posted by crajkumar_be
There are two "facts" in your post. One as an evidence presented as a video. Ramarajan's milking video would be no less a fact! What we infer/feel/opine from it is opinion and which is what all the fuss in this thread is about Originally Posted by kid-glove
At least, with a video, it's a factual evidence. There is something tangible to point out, and pass off the statement 'Surya couldn't ever do that'. That has more relevance than a video of say, Surya praising IR, quoting sycophantic statements, stake a claim over Kamal fans, and speculate Surya overcoming Sivakumar's genes.
-
From: kid-glove on 9th August 2009 02:31 AM [Full View]
Hmmm ok. I don't have VA Dvd, dvdrip or CD. If i get one, I will try to upload it. Originally Posted by crajkumar_be
-
From: crajkumar_be on 9th August 2009 02:32 AM [Full View]
Agree but Originally Posted by kid-glove
Suriya praising IR - Maddy just used it as a personal thing.. nothing to do with this thread
staking a claim over Kamal fans - this must be the Vijay TV thing.. whats that got to do with this thread?
Overcoming Sivakumar's genes: That was Plum in kalaaayal mode.. avar unga katchi-nga!
-
From: crajkumar_be on 9th August 2009 02:36 AM [Full View]
"Surya praising IR, quoting sycophantic statements"
Where does one draw the line between heartfelt truth and sycophancy? Sycophancy is manifest everywhere isn't it?
In Suriya's case IMO there are two possibilites:
He genuinely admires(d) Rahman's music and was thus pammufying in his house in the SOK promotion. Or he was just doing lip service.. so sycophancy anga dhaan nadandhuchu...
-
From: kid-glove on 9th August 2009 02:40 AM [Full View]
a) Thought Maddy might have used it in this thread. Originally Posted by crajkumar_be
Agree but Originally Posted by kid-glove
Suriya praising IR - Maddy just used it as a personal thing.. nothing to do with this thread
staking a claim over Kamal fans - this must be the Vijay TV thing.. whats that got to do with this thread?
Overcoming Sivakumar's genes: That was Plum in kalaaayal mode.. avar unga katchi-nga!
b) all Kamal fans favor Surya and what not.
c) I don't know about Plum. With respects to the mods, I have a lot of catching up to do with new posters, and their brand of humour/kalaay. A gap to be bridged.
What I mean to say is there are lot of digressive posts and then texts, more texts, which states opinion(s). So at least a video like that would add a bit of substance to back up a statement, which might have looked to be sweeping statements for the uninitiated and opposition.
-
From: kid-glove on 9th August 2009 02:46 AM [Full View]
I agree. Firstly, I don't endorse the view. It was bandied around here. Think you get what I'm trying to say. Originally Posted by crajkumar_be
-
From: crajkumar_be on 9th August 2009 02:56 AM [Full View]
Ellame purinjidhunga.. (my earlier posts will be self explanatory)... Originally Posted by kid-glove
correct, ivvalavu pesaradhukku oru video a potta that will make everything clear nu solreenga.. no two ways about it.. was just arguing about the nitty-gritty's of the previous posts...
Its a better way to slug it out but video kuduthaalum reactions will be the same more or less i'm afraid...
-
From: jaiganes on 9th August 2009 04:24 AM [Full View]
SP madam, Querida ivangallam pottangala? vote..
-
From: Prabo on 9th August 2009 06:36 AM [Full View]
I have made it even
-
From: NOV on 9th August 2009 08:07 AM [Full View]
to all those who said nice things on my post.
plum, appadina naanum unga parama edhiri aagittEnaa?
to all those lost souls who claim that the poll has been rigged only when Surya topped the poll in 4-5 days, what can I say? Don't be sore losers! enna idhu chinna pulla thanamaa irukku?
Be graceful like Surya fans who did not question the poll results even when he was trailing for most of the time.
Anyway, the results have always been close and my feeling is that it could go either way.
As for Nerd, yes I dont remember campaigning in PP and CC - go check all 100 pages.
Also I think Raja Chinna Roja is the best film that has animation inter-twined with the film.
So, do you insist that I must say RCR is a good film? enna idhu chinna pulla thanamaa irukku?
PR, I have a easy scale to check whether a film is really good. All one has to do is ask a simple question - will it feature in the best of so and so's?
Ayan will not feature in Surya's
Dasavatharam, not in Kamal's
Yavarum Nalam, not in Maddy's
-
From: NOV on 9th August 2009 08:09 AM [Full View]
Originally Posted by Bob Brown
-
From: NOV on 9th August 2009 08:10 AM [Full View]
yes, they cancelled each other out. :P Originally Posted by jaiganes
-
From: MADDY on 9th August 2009 08:22 AM [Full View]
ADHU.... Originally Posted by Prabo
I have made it even
no, i was never trying to make any point with these....... Originally Posted by kid-glove
1. i put that video in my signature much before this thread started......it has got nothing to do with me judging surya, the actor......i mean i would vote for him if there is a surya v vikram or surya v dhanush thread, inspite of vikram being a rahman fan......i dont know wat else to say.......maybe i have to stop opining on any thing other than rahman bcos i have so much explaining to do each time
2. kamal fans favor surya - yea, i saw and felt a trend and it was a reply in jest to vikki........that was no way trying to garner support for maddy
3. sivakumar's genes - i withdrew prematurely and plum kooda made these points out of jest if im not wrong
thilak, there are 2 things here , this topic was discussed extensively in many other threads and we provided evidence as much as we can......this thread is just a rehash of all discussions, so u'll find lesser "actual stuff" here, and also being a hubber u wud understand that its very tuf not to reply to a disgression :P ....i mean , thats why u find so many irrelevant posts... thanks for the vid anyways......
surya fans, please watch that video and give that undiyal to us.......
-
From: Nerd on 9th August 2009 09:13 AM [Full View]
NOV, as far Maddy fans crying now, check this and this. Not to mention the Anti-Surya claims.
Aahaa Tie-breakear-la onnu ippOvE out aayiduchu. naan mattum dhaan irukkEn ippO. Calling Sinthiya and Anoop, engE irunthAlum dhayavu senju vandhu vote-a pOttuttu pOyirunga. Poll 10 days-kku dhaanaa? Originally Posted by Prabo
I have made it even
Thilak, million thanks for the MMJ video. I saw that film on a big screen so I don't have a downloaded copy or a DVD. It was refreshing watching those scenes. Maddy is simply spectacular. Indha padathilEyum close-ups dhaan, something which Surya can't handle. The last scene is brilliant, both the scene and Maddy's performance.
-
From: jaiganes on 9th August 2009 09:34 AM [Full View]
@nerd
appo unga ottu maddykku dhaane!!
-
From: Sanguine Sridhar on 9th August 2009 09:36 AM [Full View]
Surya easily!! Maddy-a? ada pongappa!!
-
From: cuty2sweety on 9th August 2009 10:20 AM [Full View]
Seri edho ennala mudinjadhu TIE aakiyaachu
-
From: Raikkonen on 9th August 2009 10:53 AM [Full View]
Originally Posted by cuty2sweety
Seri edho ennala mudinjadhu TIE aakiyaachu
so cute... so sweet..
-
From: Wibha on 9th August 2009 11:34 AM [Full View]
Are there so many hubbers around who vote
-
From: Plum on 9th August 2009 12:22 PM [Full View]
kid-glove, vudunga vudunga. naanga remba serious-A-llam eduthukka mattOm - i mean all the protagonists here from maddy, nerd on one side to PR, CR, Vivs on other side. As CR said in another thread, thiNNainu vandha thamizhan vetti pEchu pEsi thaane aagaNum. Adhaan enga policy. I do believe both sides arent against Surya/Maddy - and that all the quoted members and the ones arguing here in general hold both Surya and Maddy in high esteem. Mathbadi, relative supremacy-ku argue paNdradhellaam "chumma chumma" dhaan. Originally Posted by kid-glove
a) Thought Maddy might have used it in this thread. Originally Posted by crajkumar_be
Agree but Originally Posted by kid-glove
Suriya praising IR - Maddy just used it as a personal thing.. nothing to do with this thread
staking a claim over Kamal fans - this must be the Vijay TV thing.. whats that got to do with this thread?
Overcoming Sivakumar's genes: That was Plum in kalaaayal mode.. avar unga katchi-nga!
b) all Kamal fans favor Surya and what not.
c) I don't know about Plum. With respects to the mods, I have a lot of catching up to do with new posters, and their brand of humour/kalaay. A gap to be bridged.
What I mean to say is there are lot of digressive posts and then texts, more texts, which states opinion(s). So at least a video like that would add a bit of substance to back up a statement, which might have looked to be sweeping statements for the uninitiated and opposition.
If anyone of the quoted(and non-quoted) protagonists differ from me, and want to be part of serious discussion gang, ippOvE sollidunga
-
From: Plum on 9th August 2009 12:25 PM [Full View]
Ennanga, "naanum"-nu sonna? - vera yaarunga inga enakku parama edhiri? Naan madhavan thread-la "edhiri"-kku vote pOttadhu uNmai dhaan adhukkaaga ipdiyaa solradhu? Originally Posted by NOV
to all those who said nice things on my post.
plum, appadina naanum unga parama edhiri aagittEnaa?
-
From: P_R on 9th August 2009 12:34 PM [Full View]
I differ-nu sonna nambavA pOreenga
-
From: Plum on 9th August 2009 12:42 PM [Full View]
mhmm...your arguments for Surya lack conviction
-
From: Vivasaayi on 9th August 2009 12:54 PM [Full View]
<dig>sooper avatar</dig> Originally Posted by Prabhu Ram
-
From: Vivasaayi on 9th August 2009 12:58 PM [Full View]
IMHO IMO ellathayum thookitu.."universal truth" maadhiri sollanum-greengala? Originally Posted by Plum
mhmm...your arguments for Surya lack conviction
-
From: P_R on 9th August 2009 01:05 PM [Full View]
Thank You. Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
<dig>sooper avatar</dig> Originally Posted by Prabhu Ram
Brilliant film. Surely one of the best ever.
7 varusham ukkAndhu padikkaNumnu ninaichikkittu irundha oru vishayaththai innikku light-A suraNdi paaththEn.
-
From: Vivasaayi on 9th August 2009 01:07 PM [Full View]
It would make people laugh and feel even after 100 years. Originally Posted by Prabhu Ram
Thank You. Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
<dig>sooper avatar</dig> Originally Posted by Prabhu Ram
Brilliant film. Surely one of the best ever.
-
From: Nerd on 9th August 2009 01:23 PM [Full View]
Of course. Originally Posted by jaiganes
Btw, Maddy is leading now
-
From: Vivasaayi on 9th August 2009 01:25 PM [Full View]
potacha? Originally Posted by Nerd
Of course. Originally Posted by jaiganes
Btw, Maddy is leading now
-
From: Nerd on 9th August 2009 01:31 PM [Full View]
naan "Sudden death" vandhaa dhaan pOduvEn :P
-
From: jaiganes on 9th August 2009 01:41 PM [Full View]
Edhiraniyinar enna beram pesugiraargal? Originally Posted by Nerd
Inge kooda oru kalyana mandabathula sila hubbersai padhukki vechirukaradhaa namma biriyani kadai ganesan sonnaan.
Everyone be alert!!!
-
From: Vivasaayi on 9th August 2009 01:43 PM [Full View]
-
From: complicateur on 9th August 2009 01:49 PM [Full View]
1. Preparation is absolutely necessary. But if you are evaluating performance based on preparation then you've already compromised judgement. A lot of good acting is in the moment. Preparation just lets you capitalize on it. The very fact that few people know what Madhavan did to prepare for YN (All that time he spent with occultists! Really paid off! - Oh wait...) but can still appreciate the scenes is the entire point.
2. SuryA is extremely believable in Ayan. What lets the movie down is the haphazard scripting.
3. YN is a half-decent film that is grade inflated due to the subpar nature of the class. But Maddy is excellent in the film.
-
From: Plum on 9th August 2009 03:04 PM [Full View]
AhA, AhA, idhuvallavO analysis. compli, excellent post. Originally Posted by complicateur
Surya vs Maddy can only be a starting point for a discussion like this - as a who is better argument, it serves no purpose, atleast for me. Indha line-la pOnOmna nalla irukkum...
-
From: Sanguine Sridhar on 9th August 2009 03:18 PM [Full View]
Exactly Roshan!! Originally Posted by Roshan
Thambi was simply horrible ... adhai ellAm natural - effortless acting'la sEthupAngalA Originally Posted by Sarna
gajini, KK maadhiri kuppa movie ellaam classic'nu sollvaanga Originally Posted by NOV
Unfortunately what we see are some fans celebrating mediocre work such as Thambi, Yavarum Nalam and making fun of good efforts. but Thambi medicore'aam Even the few scenes I have seen of EO - reminded me of Thambi.
Surya simply scores with his eye expressions. That's one of his biggest pluses I would say.
Poor acting-ku ingga neraya per pala pudhu definitions kodukuraanga!
Surya is extremely good among the current bunch, for sure! Indha thread-ey waste-u!
Maddy is good in few movies, mitha ellame avg to poor thaan.
Some one said that he is good in Nala Damayanthi ... He simply acted like MMKR - Kamal thats it!
To me he is good in AS [Because of Kamalji], KM [Mani sir] and YN [Plot & Direction].
-
From: littlemaster1982 on 9th August 2009 03:23 PM [Full View]
Idhu Mani-Ramani dialogue maadhiri irukku Originally Posted by Sanguine Sridhar
-
From: Roshan on 9th August 2009 04:27 PM [Full View]
Sridhar, Originally Posted by Sanguine Sridhar
Exactly Roshan!! Originally Posted by Roshan
Thambi was simply horrible ... adhai ellAm natural - effortless acting'la sEthupAngalA Originally Posted by Sarna
gajini, KK maadhiri kuppa movie ellaam classic'nu sollvaanga Originally Posted by NOV
Unfortunately what we see are some fans celebrating mediocre work such as Thambi, Yavarum Nalam and making fun of good efforts. but Thambi medicore'aam Even the few scenes I have seen of EO - reminded me of Thambi.
Surya simply scores with his eye expressions. That's one of his biggest pluses I would say.
Surya's movies are full of varieties and he is the only one from the contemporary lot has managed to do that successfully (I had a lot of hopes on Ajith some years back but.... ) Variety paNNumpOthu - home work paNNithAn paNNanum - just like that - nadikka mudiyAthu.
Where as Madhavan so far has tried to play it safe - with mostly ordinary roles. Few exceptions are there of course - like KM, AE, Thambi, ND, and AS. BUT his struggle was quite obvious in all this flicks except in AS. As Prabhu said, Mayavi, Pitha Magan, VA roles ellAm Maddy paNNa mudiyAthu.
And of course eye expressions - kaNNa vechE pala scenes'a easiya samAlichirukkAr Surya. But for Madhavan when it comes to eye expressions - I am only reminded of Thambi muzhi.
Having said that, I dont have anything against Madhavan. I like him and he definitely qualifies as a good actor. But Surya by all means is ahead of Madhavan IMHO.
-
From: NOV on 9th August 2009 05:06 PM [Full View]
As I have mentioned before, in real life Surya's competition is NOT Madhavan. In the reality of things, Madhavan needs to compete first with the likes of Jeeva and Bharath before he enters into the race with Surya. Originally Posted by Sanguine Sridhar
The way I see it, this competition here has nothing to do with Madhavan. Its simply those who think Surya is going places against those who dislike Surya for a variety of reasons.
Its Surya all the way.
Nerd, now that Madhavan is leading again, what happened to your gang's accusations of mod-intervention and poll rigging?
-
From: Appu s on 9th August 2009 05:19 PM [Full View]
you mean to say Top 2 Originally Posted by NOV
The way I see it, this competition here has nothing to do with Madhavan. Its simply those who think Surya is going places against those who dislike Surya for a variety of reasons.
Its Surya all the way. , NOV we have world beyond this hub. i don think so surya will ever have those fan base in his life time , in trade he is still at 5th place.
TN election range kku aakkitenga Originally Posted by NOV
Nerd, now that Madhavan is leading again, what happened to your gang's accusations of mod-intervention and poll rigging?
-
From: directhit on 9th August 2009 06:33 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by NOV
Originally Posted by Appu s
NOV we have world beyond this hub. i don think so surya will ever have those fan base in his life time
btw 36 votes kali muthiduchu!! ellaam rendu moderators panra goodhal
-
From: NOV on 9th August 2009 06:34 PM [Full View]
appu and anoop, we are not talking about BO or fan base.
anoop, besides a handful of people, I hardly see any Madhavan fans in the Hub. Where did this 39 ppl come from?
-
From: directhit on 9th August 2009 06:39 PM [Full View]
pesittaalum.... :P Originally Posted by NOV
appu and anoop, we are not talking about BO or fan base.
Nov, besides a handful of people, I hardly see any Surya fans in the Hub. Where did this 36 ppl come from?
-
From: NOV on 9th August 2009 06:46 PM [Full View]
beautiful. Originally Posted by directhit
Nov, besides a handful of people, I hardly see any Surya fans in the Hub. Where did this 36 ppl come from?
spoken like a true vijay fan
-
From: Vivasaayi on 9th August 2009 06:49 PM [Full View]
madhavan fans 39?.....lets see who those chocalate boy lovers are...enga konjam 39 peru yarunnu sollunga paapom? Originally Posted by directhit
pesittaalum.... :P Originally Posted by NOV
appu and anoop, we are not talking about BO or fan base.
Nov, besides a handful of people, I hardly see any Surya fans in the Hub. Where did this 36 ppl come from?
-
From: Vivasaayi on 9th August 2009 06:52 PM [Full View]
recent timingsla yaru consisteta irukka?..adhaan matter. Originally Posted by Appu s
you mean to say Top 2 , NOV we have world beyond this hub. i don think so surya will ever have those fan base in his life time , in trade he is still at 5th place.
1000 fans irundhalum...1000000 fans irundhalum..hit KUDUKANUM..
odane 10 varushathukku nmunadi kudutha hitsoda lista kudukadheenga
-
From: Appu s on 9th August 2009 06:55 PM [Full View]
vivasayi i have not talked anything abt hit/flop, i just telling he is still below those 2 in trade. Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
recent timingsla yaru consisteta irukka?..adhaan matter. Originally Posted by Appu s
you mean to say Top 2 , NOV we have world beyond this hub. i don think so surya will ever have those fan base in his life time , in trade he is still at 5th place.
1000 fans irundhalum...1000000 fans irundhalum..hit KUDUKANUM..
odane 10 varushathukku nmunadi kudutha hitsoda lista kudukadheenga
-
From: Vivasaayi on 9th August 2009 06:58 PM [Full View]
tradea pathi naama yenga pesanum?...have u seen the paycheck of those heroes?or does it really matter to us? Originally Posted by Appu s
vivasayi i have not talked anything abt hit/flop, i just telling he is still below those 2 in trade. Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
recent timingsla yaru consisteta irukka?..adhaan matter. Originally Posted by Appu s
you mean to say Top 2 , NOV we have world beyond this hub. i don think so surya will ever have those fan base in his life time , in trade he is still at 5th place.
1000 fans irundhalum...1000000 fans irundhalum..hit KUDUKANUM..
odane 10 varushathukku nmunadi kudutha hitsoda lista kudukadheenga
If it is a discussion between producers and distributors - I accept.
-
From: directhit on 9th August 2009 06:59 PM [Full View]
vivs - neenga 36 'fans' pera kudunga, i'd give the 39 :P appo vishal hit kuduthaa avarum nesstu kamalhassan aa oh 'variety' kudukkanum la... ok ok!
Nov - thx for not speaking like a bharath/jeeva and now surya fan. and edhirkaalathula if sam anderson (btw he is acting his second movie now) comes up with a non masala movie which appeals to u, am sure u might go campaining for him and even get the 36 odd votes in favor of him
-
From: Vivasaayi on 9th August 2009 07:03 PM [Full View]
ippo yaru nextu kamalahaasangradhu peche illaye... ? Originally Posted by directhit
vivs - neenga 36 'fans' pera kudunga, i'd give the 39 :P oh appo vishal hit kuduthaa avarum nesstu kamalhassan aa oh 'variety' kudukkanum la... ok ok!
vishayam ennanaa...both kamal and rajni havent given continuous flops as these younger generation stars did.
So putting it as -Top 4 just like that is absurd.
-
From: Vivasaayi on 9th August 2009 07:09 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by directhit
aarambichutangappa..childhearted masala movie fans...who watch movies only to be entertained
mathavaingellam enna "kottaavi" vidradha padam paakurainga?
-
From: directhit on 9th August 2009 07:11 PM [Full View]
oh, i thought it was established in the 'hub' and hub being a reflection of the world and its sisters and brothers it became a fact Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
neenga dhan trade pathi pesalainu sonneenga. top 4 yaarunnu solli theriya vendiya avasiyame illai. one hit and he breaks into that? Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
u can wait and watch. even continuous hits by vikram in dhil/dhool/gemini/saamy didnt change that!! lets see what a ksr movie and his other 'commercial' movies to follow does.
as for his 'performances' and acting, its my opinion that maddy and dhanush are far better than him. i find him odd in many scenes donno why, even that cell fone scene in ayan i found traces of vaali ajith scene in him and ajith was n times better in that scene. remember reading some raving views on his perazhagan performance, having watched dileep in the original, didnt even strike a chord with me.
-
From: Vivasaayi on 9th August 2009 07:15 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by directhit
dileep nadichadha naangalum pathom...
-
From: directhit on 9th August 2009 07:15 PM [Full View]
vivs - i am talking abt nov. he was the one who had given kamal's shoes to barath once and then perarasu padam sign pannadhu adha thirudi jeeva veetu vaasal la pottar. thenavattu mattrum sila paathu ippo surya vootaanda pottirukkaar nesstu yaaro! Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
Originally Posted by directhit
aarambichutangappa..childhearted masala movie fans...who watch movies only to be entertained
mathavaingellam enna "kottaavi" vidradha padam paakurainga?
neenga ungaalu padam paathu kottavi vidreengalo entertain avareengalo not my concern
-
From: directhit on 9th August 2009 07:16 PM [Full View]
and... Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
-
From: Appu s on 9th August 2009 07:16 PM [Full View]
vivs the trade reply to NOV, avaru etho intention oda oru post, same anti surya..
-
From: Vivasaayi on 9th August 2009 07:17 PM [Full View]
okok...podhuva hubla "naangellam masala movie fans.we only like to be entertained.not like others" apdinu collara thooki viduvanga..adhaan. Originally Posted by directhit
vivs - i am talking abt nov. he was the one who had given kamal's shoes to barath once and then perarasu padam sign pannadhu adha thirudi jeeva veetu vaasal la pottar. thenavattu mattrum sila paathu ippo surya vootaanda pottirukkaar nesstu yaaro! Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
Originally Posted by directhit
aarambichutangappa..childhearted masala movie fans...who watch movies only to be entertained
mathavaingellam enna "kottaavi" vidradha padam paakurainga?
neenga ungaalu padam paathu kottavi vidreengalo entertain avareengalo not my concern
I understtod the context in which u told that..fine
-
From: Vivasaayi on 9th August 2009 07:19 PM [Full View]
both were good Originally Posted by directhit
and... Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
-
From: directhit on 9th August 2009 07:20 PM [Full View]
:P enna panradhu hub la vijay (or any other actor) fans ellaam ore madhiri dhaan sattai pant poduvom, ore madhiri dhaan saapadu sapduvom nu establish pannitanga. adhaan nanum korean movies ellam paaka arambichiten Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
okok...podhuva hubla "naangellam masala movie fans.we only like to be entertained.not like others" apdinu collara thooki viduvanga..adhaan.
I understtod the context in which u told that..fine
-
From: Vivasaayi on 9th August 2009 07:20 PM [Full View]
suryavoda competitors maddy illaithane? Originally Posted by Appu s
its definitely ajith/vijay/vikram..neenga othukutlum othukatiyum!
-
From: NOV on 9th August 2009 07:21 PM [Full View]
anoop, dont put words in my mouth.
-
From: directhit on 9th August 2009 07:23 PM [Full View]
i defnly wont say surya was bad in that. but therla having seen someone do it (i saw malayalam first) and then to see this, didnt feel original (rather shud say cudnt appreciate it more). that character scores particularly coz of the oozing optimism and the 'soona paana' ness coupled together, felt dileep fit into it perfectly. Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
both were good Originally Posted by directhit
and... Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
-
From: directhit on 9th August 2009 07:23 PM [Full View]
Nov - s viteenga Originally Posted by NOV
anoop, dont put words in my mouth.
-
From: Appu s on 9th August 2009 07:24 PM [Full View]
we r talking abt talends.. Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
suryavoda competitors maddy illaithane? Originally Posted by Appu s
, apapdi paatha Maddy yaarukkum inga competitor illa
Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
he is trying for that nnu solren.. :P intha list la Vikram enga irunthu vantharu
-
From: Vivasaayi on 9th August 2009 07:27 PM [Full View]
vikram na ellarukkum avlo elakarama pocha?
-
From: Appu s on 9th August 2009 07:32 PM [Full View]
elakkaramnnu yaarunga sonnathu? gap la avarai sorukittenga :P Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
-
From: Benny Lava on 9th August 2009 07:45 PM [Full View]
-
From: Prabo on 9th August 2009 08:00 PM [Full View]
TheerpPu solliyAchchu thread'a poottunga Originally Posted by Benny Lava
-
From: villan007 on 9th August 2009 08:14 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by directhit
-
From: Sanguine Sridhar on 9th August 2009 08:28 PM [Full View]
Adhaane! Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
-
From: villan007 on 9th August 2009 08:34 PM [Full View]
Ajith/vijay/sam anderson thavira ellarum mukkiam than Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
-
From: Plum on 9th August 2009 08:47 PM [Full View]
I strongly object to the correction of the spelling of 'talend' in the thread's title.
-
From: Appu s on 9th August 2009 10:07 PM [Full View]
i secand this Originally Posted by Plum
-
From: P_R on 9th August 2009 10:09 PM [Full View]
Given Madhavan is winning, I think the spelling change is appropriate
-
From: jaiganes on 9th August 2009 10:29 PM [Full View]
Can we take this as a concession? Originally Posted by Prabhu Ram
BTW thanks for working as the 5th force in their team!!
-
From: Nerd on 9th August 2009 10:37 PM [Full View]
NOV, unga first paragraph *whining* dhaanE Originally Posted by NOV
The way I see it, this competition here has nothing to do with Madhavan. Its simply those who think Surya is going places against those who dislike Surya for a variety of reasons.
Its Surya all the way.
Nerd, now that Madhavan is leading again, what happened to your gang's accusations of mod-intervention and poll rigging? No matter who wins at the end, its unbelievable that almost 80 people have voted so far. Kamal's favorite scenes thread, the threads started by Plum etc. have < 40 votes and this thread is just 5 days old.
Btw, unga Maddy Vs Jeeva/Bharath is fifty-thousand-ROTFL-worthy. I respect Bharath very much and I think his kAdhal performance is as good as Maddy's AS or AE and Surya's PM. But adhu onnu dhaanE irukku. OK veyyil pattiyal but he still has a long way to go.
-
From: Raikkonen on 9th August 2009 10:48 PM [Full View]
78 votes..
aale illatha hubla ethana tadava vote potteenga???
btw.. dh nailed it. it's really hard to see a genuine surya fan here.. that means if ppl ask about one's fav hero, surya's name should come out first.. here, surya's name is appended with kamal's name (mostly).
i've seen ppl calling madhavan as their fav (maddy).. ajith, superstar, kamal pathi solla tevai illai.. even vijay has that 'kind' of fans (here)..
-
From: Vivasaayi on 9th August 2009 10:51 PM [Full View]
second fav mattum ticketukku kammiyava kaasu kuduka porom.. Originally Posted by Raikkonen
78 votes..
aale illatha hubla ethana tadava vote potteenga???
btw.. dh nailed it. it's really hard to see a genuine surya fan here.. that means if ppl ask about one's fav hero, surya's name should come out first.. here, surya's name is appended with kamal's name (mostly).
i've seen ppl calling madhavan as their fav (maddy).. ajith, superstar, kamal pathi solla tevai illai.. even vijay has that 'kind' of fans (here)..
"nee kamal fan..apuramthan surya fan"..so ticketukku paadhi kaasu kudu..podhumna solla poranga?
-
From: P_R on 9th August 2009 10:56 PM [Full View]
Talend is THE spelling I say Originally Posted by jaiganes
Can we take this as a concession? Originally Posted by Prabhu Ram
-
From: P_R on 9th August 2009 10:57 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
indha dealing romba nallA irukku
idhaiyE maaththi evvaLo pudikkudhO avvaLo kaasu kuduthA pOdhum-nu koNdu varalaam.
Namma LM varusham muzhukka free-ya padam paarppAr.
-
From: Vivasaayi on 9th August 2009 10:59 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by Prabhu Ram
Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
indha dealing romba nallA irukku
idhaiyE maaththi evvaLo pudikkudhO avvaLo kaasu kuduthA pOdhum-nu koNdu varalaam.
Namma LM varusham muzhukka free-ya padam paarppAr.
-
From: littlemaster1982 on 9th August 2009 11:00 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by Prabhu Ram
Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
indha dealing romba nallA irukku
idhaiyE maaththi evvaLo pudikkudhO avvaLo kaasu kuduthA pOdhum-nu koNdu varalaam.
Namma LM varusham muzhukka free-ya padam paarppAr.
-
From: Nerd on 9th August 2009 11:07 PM [Full View]
I think they did this (or were thinking to) for a film a few years back. adhaavadhu, padam freeyA pArthuttu veLila varumbOdhu oru uNdiyal irukkum, adhula evLo vENAlum pOdalaam.
-
From: Raikkonen on 9th August 2009 11:09 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by Nerd
padam bayangara mokkaya irunthuchunna undiya-laye eduthuttu poyida vendithan..
-
From: Nerd on 9th August 2009 11:12 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by Raikkonen
Originally Posted by Nerd
padam bayangara mokkaya irunthuchunna undiya-laye eduthuttu poyida vendithan..
-
From: Vivasaayi on 9th August 2009 11:13 PM [Full View]
thamizhagala pacha mannaa nenacha namma Thangarpachan thaan apdiyoru plan vechirundharunnu nenaikiren. Originally Posted by Nerd
for sathyaraj movie I guess.
-
From: Vivasaayi on 9th August 2009 11:16 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by Raikkonen
Originally Posted by Nerd
padam bayangara mokkaya irunthuchunna undiya-laye eduthuttu poyida vendithan..
thanni kudikara tumblerukke chain potu vekurainga..
undiyalukku ulavuthurai paadhugappuththaan!
-
From: groucho070 on 10th August 2009 07:24 AM [Full View]
Nov, I never hated Surya. Avar enna, en veettu sombu tirudunaaraa?
I just don't have interest in him as an actor. He is bland. He takes time to grow. I've said it before and I say it again. Actors has to come in prepared. Whether stage or TV as training ground, they are going to appear on big screen, fer Lumiere's sake. And that mug that's being shoved into unsuspecting viewers like us better tell a story. His just does not work for me. That's all. Granted, I've said that he is better than Vikram. Better than Vijay in Neerukku Neer and is one of the most good looking actors in TFI...alongside Madhavan & Ajith, I mean.
Right, true. Jeeva and Bharath are now working with important directors and are appearing and have appeared along the luminaries like Amir Khan, Amitabh and Ben Kingsley. Not wo mention working two films with the very talent Surya is claimed to be heir of, Kamal. Damn, lots of hard work Madhavan has to put. Originally Posted by NOV
-
From: MADDY on 10th August 2009 08:00 AM [Full View]
Originally Posted by groucho070
raghavendra - poll-a mudichhiduppa - tenson thaangala
-
From: NOV on 10th August 2009 09:00 AM [Full View]
Rakesh - Amir Khan, Amitabh, Ben Kingsley ellaam periya kombugalO?
The fact that you guys have to bring in non Tamil films and actors, underlines the fact that Madhavan has nothing much to offer in Tamil.
Kovai Sarala also acted with Kamal. So that makes her a great actress?
Why I said Bharath and Jeeva specifically is becos both of them have done varied roles; Kaathal, Chellame, Emttan Magan, Veyyil, Katradhu Thamizh, Dishoom, Eee, etc.
Compared to these younger two, Madhavan has shown less variety. This is what I have been saying all these while - not that Madhavan is not a good actor.
How many times is he going to play himself, before he wears us out completely?
-
From: groucho070 on 10th August 2009 09:06 AM [Full View]
Unggalukku illaya? Sari. Originally Posted by NOV
Rakesh - Amir Khan, Amitabh, Ben Kingsley ellaam periya kombugalO?
Kamal-um quote pannunene. Avar enna Ukranian actor-ah? Originally Posted by NOV
Not great, but good. Can't think of anyone else in that role. Originally Posted by NOV
Agreed. Ithey argument I'd say they are better than Surya when Surya was of that age. What the heck, they are better than Surya now. Originally Posted by NOV
See my comment above. We are saying the same thing but referring to different actor. Originally Posted by NOV
Eh? You mean, in real life he is also Inba, Thambi, Bottle Mani, etc. In real life? Crikey, if that's the case, R. Madhavan is suffering from multiple split personality (no, not the Shankar Version). Originally Posted by NOV
-
From: NOV on 10th August 2009 09:09 AM [Full View]
So, it all ends with tit for tat.
While your humor may bring in some laughs, it cannot mask facts.
So much for a good discussion.
-
From: groucho070 on 10th August 2009 09:13 AM [Full View]
What is the fact? It's all matter of opinion and what makes up for majority of it. It's not as if scientist did some lab work on Surya's performance and concluded that he is the best of his gen? Or came up with archeological evidence that he is in possession of magic acting potion that only Kamal possessed? Fact? What fact?
-
From: NOV on 10th August 2009 09:15 AM [Full View]
variety in roles.
-
From: Nerd on 10th August 2009 09:18 AM [Full View]
Originally Posted by NOV
Variety in roles? Anjasingam annan Goundamani I say.
-
From: groucho070 on 10th August 2009 09:18 AM [Full View]
I see guys in Sun TV's top ten doing spoof week after week, playing variety of roles. If you want to compare Surya with them, by all means go ahead
-
From: Benny Lava on 10th August 2009 09:21 AM [Full View]
NOV.. see the title Originally Posted by NOV
variety in roles. It is about talent, if you have anything to show that Madhavan is less talented than Surya, plead ur case.
Otherwise why do you have to bring in TFI, non-TFI demarcation? Not like if we go along those lines, Maddy's case will get weaker
-
From: Vivasaayi on 10th August 2009 09:25 AM [Full View]
ohh..now bottle mani was added to the elite list of "Madhavan's best performances" eh? Originally Posted by groucho070
-
From: Vivasaayi on 10th August 2009 09:28 AM [Full View]
did u watch "thambi" spoof? Originally Posted by groucho070
I see guys in Sun TV's top ten doing spoof week after week, playing variety of roles. If you want to compare Surya with them, by all means go ahead
Movie had better moments than the spoof itself
-
From: NOV on 10th August 2009 09:28 AM [Full View]
emu, talent is in performing different roles with success.
if its merely acting out the same thing film after film, Vijay will be the best actor of all time.
Many of us have already given plenty of instances where Madhavan is severely lacking. Its all over this thread and many others too.
-
From: Benny Lava on 10th August 2009 09:28 AM [Full View]
It certainly shows versatility Vivs. Kamal comedy roles panna naama adha kondaadradhu illaya? Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
ohh..now bottle mani was added to the elite list of "Madhavan's best performances" eh? Originally Posted by groucho070
-
From: Vivasaayi on 10th August 2009 09:30 AM [Full View]
look in what context it was told...as a different personality madhavan has exhibited. Originally Posted by Benny Lava
It certainly shows versatility Vivs. Kamal comedy roles panna naama adha kondaadradhu illaya? Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
ohh..now bottle mani was added to the elite list of "Madhavan's best performances" eh? Originally Posted by groucho070
-
From: groucho070 on 10th August 2009 09:32 AM [Full View]
That is in response to NOV saying Madhavan plays himself films after films. Not the best list. But Bottle Mani is a good role. Shows his comic side. How's that for versatility? Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
ohh..now bottle mani was added to the elite list of "Madhavan's best performances" eh? Originally Posted by groucho070
-
From: NOV on 10th August 2009 09:32 AM [Full View]
you mean the other way round I suppose. :P Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
-
From: Vivasaayi on 10th August 2009 09:33 AM [Full View]
No...what are the better moments in spoof? Originally Posted by NOV
you mean the other way round I suppose. :P Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
-
From: Vivasaayi on 10th August 2009 09:34 AM [Full View]
I understood the context.Read the post above ur post Originally Posted by groucho070
That is in response to NOV saying Madhavan plays himself films after films. Not the best list. But Bottle Mani is a good role. Shows his comic side. How's that for versatility? Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
ohh..now bottle mani was added to the elite list of "Madhavan's best performances" eh? Originally Posted by groucho070
-
From: Vivasaayi on 10th August 2009 09:35 AM [Full View]
Bottle mani ellam versatilitikku example nu sonna.. aamaa...adhula haircut panni...soundddddaaaaaa pesunaru...
It seems the other side is seriously lacking roles to prove his versatility
By the way he was so funny in the movie(one of my fav roles of MADDY)...But it was Maddy in the movie.
-
From: Benny Lava on 10th August 2009 09:56 AM [Full View]
Really? Originally Posted by NOV
How did I miss that... it would have been a nice read Ofcourse the term successful is relative and you would have to accept that we are all talking about opinions here not solid facts 
You are exactly right NOV, talent is performing different roles with success. We say Surya has played different roles but not that successfully, whereas Maddy has played roles with great deal of success in whatever he performs.. does that make sense?
The Comedy is the hallmark of any capable actor and in this Maddy wins hands down. He has shown impeccable timing and dialog delivery in comedy roles/scenes. Surya had a decent performance in perazhagan but he was "just pass" whereas Maddy passed with flying colors (except for ND I would say )
Why, even Kamal and his Godfather KB showed faith in Maddy and casted him in their films... does it not say something?
-
From: Vivasaayi on 10th August 2009 10:01 AM [Full View]
We say it was quite good..and at times extraordinary.Thats it. Originally Posted by Benny Lava
You are exactly right NOV, talent is performing different roles with success. We say Surya has played different roles but not that successfully, whereas Maddy has played roles with great deal of success in whatever he performs.. does that make sense?
pithamagan Originally Posted by Benny Lava
The Comedy is the hallmark of any capable actor and in this Maddy wins hands down. He has shown impeccable timing and dialog delivery in comedy roles/scenes. Surya had a decent performance in perazhagan but he was "just pass" whereas Maddy passed with flying colors (except for ND I would say )
mayavi
perazhagan
Maddy was nowhere surya in comedy...I mean NOWHERE!
I havent watched Maddy evoking "roll on the floor and laughing" type of comedies.They are funny..thats it.
U know what kamal got to say abt surya in many functions and interviews. Originally Posted by Benny Lava
Why, even Kamal and his Godfather KB showed faith in Maddy and casted him in their films... does it not say something?
-
From: NOV on 10th August 2009 10:02 AM [Full View]
Originally Posted by Benny Lava
suryavukku comedy varala, and kamal doesnt know how to act.
-
From: Nerd on 10th August 2009 10:08 AM [Full View]
Ha ha! Its even again
Raghavendra can you please confirm if the poll is just for 10 days???
Solla maRandhuttEn, Maddy comedy > Surya's.
Btw, how was ParthAlE paravasam Maddy fans? I ve seen it but don't remember much. I thought Maddy did quite OK, but nobody has talked about that film so far
-
From: Vivasaayi on 10th August 2009 10:08 AM [Full View]
One doubt to Maddy fans and surya haters
U say "thambi" is a wonderful performance..one of the maddys best or infact the maddy's best etc?
and then u argue that Maddy was more natural than surya
Is Thambi a spontaneous or uninhibited or natural performance?
U could see the difficulty madhavan was undergoing when he was slightly out of his comfort zone asking to his director .."ippo naan enna seyya"
-
From: Benny Lava on 10th August 2009 10:08 AM [Full View]
Indha madhiri statements laam pottu ungala neengaley kevala paduthikalaamapithamagan
mayavi
perazhagan
Maddy was nowhere surya in comedy...I mean NOWHERE!
Perazhagan was decent, in pithamagan u could almost see him sweating trying to do comedy.. andha alavuku muyarchi panni irukaarnu theriyudhu... Mayavi is a case in our favour.. thanks for pointing it out
As I said Maddy has better sense of timing and dialogue delivery than Surya. In perazhagan u could see that he is like waiting for cues from Vivek to deliver his dialogues, oru slight hesitation naan feel pannen. Maddy's performances were effortless AFAIF.
-
From: Benny Lava on 10th August 2009 10:10 AM [Full View]
neenga urundaalum, perandaalum, sirichaalum avanga avanga talent levels maara poradhilla Originally Posted by NOV
Originally Posted by Benny Lava
-
From: Vivasaayi on 10th August 2009 10:13 AM [Full View]
I consider pithamagan surya performance as the funniest performance by any young actors..inact better than any comic performances given by heroes other than "RAJNI and KAMAL"...ahh...may be prabhu in few movies. Originally Posted by Benny Lava
Indha madhiri statements laam pottu ungala neengaley kevala paduthikalaamapithamagan
mayavi
perazhagan
Maddy was nowhere surya in comedy...I mean NOWHERE!
[b]pithamagan u could almost see him sweating trying to do comedy[/b
-
From: Raikkonen on 10th August 2009 10:14 AM [Full View]
50% right.. athu ethunnu neengale decide pannikunga.. Originally Posted by NOV
Originally Posted by Benny Lava
suryavukku comedy varala, and kamal doesnt know how to act.
-
From: Nerd on 10th August 2009 10:16 AM [Full View]
Pithamagan first time funny, granted. Next time vizhunthu puRaNdu sirikkira maadhiriyaa irundhuchu? I mean measuring "funniness" in absolute terms. I like Surya's acting in PM, I think thats his best performance ever but it's so not funny, IMO.
-
From: villan007 on 10th August 2009 10:17 AM [Full View]
Mayavi ellam comedy ku ejjamble-a
-
From: Vivasaayi on 10th August 2009 10:18 AM [Full View]
aama..examplethaan... Originally Posted by villan007
Mayavi ellam comedy ku ejjamble-a
neenga godfather ajith actinga..."thoooooookki vechu pesaradhillaya"..andha maadhirithaan
-
From: Benny Lava on 10th August 2009 10:20 AM [Full View]
Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
Ippo elarkum thelivu aagi irukkumnu nenaikren.. evlo theramaya eda podraanga paarunga
-
From: hamid on 10th August 2009 10:21 AM [Full View]
Intha panchaayathu innum mudiyaliyaa??
Poll end date munnadiye sollidungappa.. vote podanum
Reg Comedy.. I think Maddy is better than Surya.
Surya puts hard work.. and he is commercially better.. but if we talk about talent I think Maddy is the one..
as an example just look at both of their first films and compare their acting....
-
From: Vivasaayi on 10th August 2009 10:21 AM [Full View]
Naan edhukunga asingapadanum Originally Posted by Benny Lava
Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
Ippo elarkum thelivu aagi irukkumnu nenaikren.. evlo theramaya eda podraanga paarunga
"thambi" madhavan perfarmansa ...best ....aahaa ohoonu soldravangale dhairiyima pesumbodhu...
pithamagan is one of the very best I say !
-
From: Benny Lava on 10th August 2009 10:23 AM [Full View]
Ada po'pa... GM kooda andha alavuku comedy pannadhillanu solvaaru paaru Originally Posted by villan007
Mayavi ellam comedy ku ejjamble-a
-
From: Vivasaayi on 10th August 2009 10:23 AM [Full View]
Logically You should compare Maddy's first hindi serial and suryas first movie Originally Posted by hamid
but if we talk about talent I think Maddy is the one..
as an example just look at both of their first films and compare their acting....
Maddy was an experienced actor before alaipayuthe
-
From: NOV on 10th August 2009 10:23 AM [Full View]
nerd, emu, rakesh - i think our views are very different - like two tracks of the train that will not meet. even in fundamental matters like who does comedy better.
I will not argue with you if you say Madhavan is taller that Surya, but in talents, sorry to say, Madhavan has not shown satisfactory evidence, closeups and all.
so, lets agree to disagree and move on.
p/s: on the poll. shall we stop now.
-
From: hamid on 10th August 2009 10:23 AM [Full View]
Viv,
I think nobosy claims "Thambi" as natural.. But that kind of acting was necessary for that role to be effective..
I do remember somebody quoting it is similar to Veerapandiya kattabomman role.. quite true..
-
From: Appu s on 10th August 2009 10:24 AM [Full View]
NOV Vivasayi kku inga ajith/vijay illainna post panrathukku romba kastam pola
-
From: Vivasaayi on 10th August 2009 10:24 AM [Full View]
shabaaaa.... Originally Posted by Benny Lava
Ada po'pa... GM kooda andha alavuku comedy pannadhillanu solvaaru paaru Originally Posted by villan007
Mayavi ellam comedy ku ejjamble-a
-
From: Nerd on 10th August 2009 10:25 AM [Full View]
aahaa Hamid neengaLum irukkeengaLA. Enga set-la innoru Tie-breaker spessalist
-
From: Vivasaayi on 10th August 2009 10:25 AM [Full View]
yenga neenga kavundamaniyapathi pesadhillaya..andha maadhirithan Originally Posted by Appu s
NOV Vivasayi kku inga ajith/vijay illainna post panrathukku romba kastam pola
-
From: hamid on 10th August 2009 10:26 AM [Full View]
Viv, acting in serial and acting in Big screen.. are totally different.. anyway I havent seen his serial.. so cant comment on it.. Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
Logically You should compare Maddy's first hindi serial and suryas first movie Originally Posted by hamid
but if we talk about talent I think Maddy is the one..
as an example just look at both of their first films and compare their acting....
Maddy was an experienced actor before alaipayuthe
If that is the case, Surya is supposed to know about acting better having Sivakumar as his father
-
From: hamid on 10th August 2009 10:27 AM [Full View]
Originally Posted by Nerd
aahaa Hamid neengaLum irukkeengaLA. Enga set-la innoru Tie-breaker spessalist
-
From: Benny Lava on 10th August 2009 10:27 AM [Full View]
A vast improvement from your earlier stance that we, all Maddy supporters, are with either some agenda or hatred Originally Posted by NOV
-
From: Vivasaayi on 10th August 2009 10:28 AM [Full View]
Originally Posted by hamid
Viv, acting in serial and acting in Big screen.. are totally different.. anyway I havent seen his serial.. so cant comment on it.. Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
Logically You should compare Maddy's first hindi serial and suryas first movie Originally Posted by hamid
but if we talk about talent I think Maddy is the one..
as an example just look at both of their first films and compare their acting....
Maddy was an experienced actor before alaipayuthe
If that is the case, Surya is supposed to know about acting better having Sivakumar as his father
An actors son(in his first movie) must act better than an "experienced actor" in serials
sooobarabbu
-
From: NOV on 10th August 2009 10:29 AM [Full View]
a simple question to hamid - whats the difference in Surya's acting between KaadhalE Nimmadhi and Varanam Aayiram?
similar question - whats the difference in Madhavan's acting between Minnale and Yaavarum Nalam?
-
From: NOV on 10th August 2009 10:32 AM [Full View]
not all, some. Originally Posted by Benny Lava
]A vast improvement from your earlier stance that we, all Maddy supporters, are with either some agenda or hatred
and isnt it evident?
-
From: villan007 on 10th August 2009 10:33 AM [Full View]
aamanga athu ellam nadippa... surya than toppu Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
neenga godfather ajith actinga..."thoooooookki vechu pesaradhillaya"..andha maadhirithaan
-
From: littlemaster1982 on 10th August 2009 10:33 AM [Full View]
Surya's improvement in acting doesnt necessarily mean he is better than Maddy. Anything from Surya's initial film is an improvement actually. Originally Posted by NOV
-
From: hamid on 10th August 2009 10:33 AM [Full View]
Viv, Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
Originally Posted by hamid
Viv, acting in serial and acting in Big screen.. are totally different.. anyway I havent seen his serial.. so cant comment on it.. Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
Logically You should compare Maddy's first hindi serial and suryas first movie Originally Posted by hamid
but if we talk about talent I think Maddy is the one..
as an example just look at both of their first films and compare their acting....
Maddy was an experienced actor before alaipayuthe
If that is the case, Surya is supposed to know about acting better having Sivakumar as his father
An actors son(in his first movie) must act better than an "experienced actor" in serials
sooobarabbu
Acting in serial is totally different from acting in Big screen.. thats the main point.. summa supplementarya sonnatha perisa kandukka kuudaathu aama.. see the bold lines
-
From: Vivasaayi on 10th August 2009 10:34 AM [Full View]
ungalukku adhu wonderful actingnu paduthu..enaku mayavi performance "funny"-ia irukkku Originally Posted by villan007
aamanga athu ellam nadippa... surya than toppu Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
neenga godfather ajith actinga..."thoooooookki vechu pesaradhillaya"..andha maadhirithaan
avlothan
-
From: Vivasaayi on 10th August 2009 10:35 AM [Full View]
Whats the difference?...between acting in serials and movies?
enga konjam sollunga...
-
From: hamid on 10th August 2009 10:35 AM [Full View]
Nov.. I think LM answered it better.. so no need to add anything to it Originally Posted by NOV
-
From: NOV on 10th August 2009 10:35 AM [Full View]
aah... good. Originally Posted by littlemaster1982
Surya's improvement in acting doesnt necessarily mean he is better than Maddy. Anything from Surya's initial film is an improvement actually. Originally Posted by NOV
lets use this as the starting point.
-
From: Raikkonen on 10th August 2009 10:36 AM [Full View]
ya one took years to improve and the other is just as good as he's ever been. Originally Posted by NOV
-
From: hamid on 10th August 2009 10:38 AM [Full View]
ss...abba.. u mean both are equal.. The kind of director, kind of acting required, script, effort etc. etc... Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
:handshake: :end of discussion:
-
From: Vivasaayi on 10th August 2009 10:38 AM [Full View]
adhepedingnaaaa...6 masathula improve aagaradhukku idhenna six packunglaangnaaaaa Originally Posted by Raikkonen
ya one took years to improve and the other is just as good as he's ever been. Originally Posted by NOV
-
From: Vivasaayi on 10th August 2009 10:39 AM [Full View]
U talk as though acting in serial doesnt help acting in mvoe at all adhaan.. Originally Posted by hamid
ss...abba.. u mean both are equal.. The kind of director, kind of acting required, script, effort etc. etc... Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
:handshake: :end of discussion:
script,directorlam namakedhukku?..
acting is acting....then why do people get trained in "koothu patarai" before coming to cinema...
-
From: groucho070 on 10th August 2009 11:07 AM [Full View]
Viv,
I am among the few here who rate his performance in Thambi highly. Even some Madhavan fans are not used to that performance.
Plus, I've never said that he's a good natural performer. I don't know what "natural" acting is. Much earlier I accused Surya of trying too hard, calling it LMIA stuff, sparking protests from others. While Madhavan's is effortless. Surya tries. Madhavan just do it. Surya grows (valarnthu varum Kalaignar, innum valarnthu kondirukkiraar), while Madhavan is well equipped with his own unique features and applies them well on the roles chosen.
The days of playing variety of characters in many films and one film has been done and over with by NT, and later Rajini and Kamal. Nowadays these kinda stunt is favoured for Eddie Murphy and is countless crappy comedies that he has been churning out of recent. That's variety too.
-
From: groucho070 on 10th August 2009 11:10 AM [Full View]
I liked the performance. This and Priyasaghi are hardly mentioned, and I thought he gave fine performances. The kind of roles that current heroes'd be scared to approach. Originally Posted by Nerd
-
From: Vivasaayi on 10th August 2009 11:25 AM [Full View]
how can u say that? Originally Posted by groucho070
-
From: groucho070 on 10th August 2009 11:28 AM [Full View]
Sorry viv, there was supposed to be two sentences there, mannichikoongga :P
Doing multiple characters in one film has been done and over with by NT, and later Rajini and Kamal. All that came after that seemed just a rewrite, or recycling of what they accomplished before. Some to the point of making fool of themselves (Sarath in 1977).
So, if you do it now, you are subjected to comparison to what the trio and also, don't forget MGR, did in the past.
It's now time to stick to what you can do best with one character and give it all. I believe Madhavan is doing just that.
Athellam sari, where's Hulkster?
-
From: NOV on 10th August 2009 11:34 AM [Full View]
OK performance. But really, Simran outshone him. Originally Posted by Nerd
He was really good in Ayudha Ezhuththu and Evano Oruvan. Thats about the only couple of variety that I can think of.
-
From: Vivasaayi on 10th August 2009 11:35 AM [Full View]
multiple roles in one movie ok..But showing versatile talent itself have been done and dustednu neenga solla mudiyuma?
-
From: groucho070 on 10th August 2009 11:36 AM [Full View]
With a borrowed voice. Right. Originally Posted by NOV
-
From: groucho070 on 10th August 2009 11:40 AM [Full View]
Okay, I admit that was a bad statement. Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
What I was trying to say is they have done pretty much thoroughly varied characters and they managed it because they were capable.
-
From: NOV on 10th August 2009 11:44 AM [Full View]
so dub pannittaa, she becomes less talented? :roll2: Originally Posted by groucho070
With a borrowed voice. Right. Originally Posted by NOV
-
From: Vivasaayi on 10th August 2009 11:48 AM [Full View]
we think surya also manages do it well to a certain extent... Originally Posted by groucho070
Okay, I admit that was a bad statement. Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
What I was trying to say is they have done pretty much thoroughly varied characters and they managed it because they were capable.
-
From: Vivasaayi on 10th August 2009 11:48 AM [Full View]
point! Originally Posted by NOV
so dub pannittaa, she becomes less talented? :roll2: Originally Posted by groucho070
With a borrowed voice. Right. Originally Posted by NOV
appo dialogue delivery is an important criteria..isnt it groucho
-
From: groucho070 on 10th August 2009 11:49 AM [Full View]
I like those words. I am saying the same thing about Madhavan, except Madhavan's certain extent is better than Surya's certain extent. Ithu eppadi irukku! Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
we think surya also manages do it well to a certain extent...
-
From: Vivasaayi on 10th August 2009 11:50 AM [Full View]
but the area covered by surya is much more than maddynu naanga soldrom Originally Posted by groucho070
I like those words. I am saying the same thing about Madhavan, except Madhavan's certain extent is better than Surya's certain extent. Ithu eppadi irukku! Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
we think surya also manages do it well to a certain extent...
-
From: groucho070 on 10th August 2009 11:51 AM [Full View]
Very much. She got help from the voice over artiste. She sounded like most other actresses who uses the same artistes services. Wherelse Madhavan worked with what he got, his own voice. I wouldn't say he stole the show or what (I'd say Sneha did that whenever she appeared in PP), but did well within the parameters. Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
point! Originally Posted by NOV
so dub pannittaa, she becomes less talented? :roll2: Originally Posted by groucho070
With a borrowed voice. Right. Originally Posted by NOV
appo dialogue delivery is an important criteria..isnt it groucho
-
From: NOV on 10th August 2009 11:54 AM [Full View]
madhavan samplingE pOdhaadhunu thaan sollrEn, to be even compared with Surya. Originally Posted by groucho070
I like those words. I am saying the same thing about Madhavan, except Madhavan's certain extent is better than Surya's certain extent. Ithu eppadi irukku! Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
we think surya also manages do it well to a certain extent...
-
From: NOV on 10th August 2009 11:55 AM [Full View]
whatever Rakesh. fact is she outshone Madhavan. Originally Posted by groucho070
-
From: groucho070 on 10th August 2009 11:58 AM [Full View]
There you go again. I don't want to delve in this again...might anger some Madhavan fans themselves, particularly Nerd. Okay, solla vendiyathu solliyachu. From beginning I felt that Son of Sivakumar will win seeing that he has more fans here. If he does, so what? Originally Posted by NOV
whatever Rakesh. fact is she outshone Madhavan.
We are looking at their careers themselves. Let their success in the future judge for themselves. Here's to both of them...may the best talent prevail and give us fantastic films!
-
From: NOV on 10th August 2009 12:07 PM [Full View]
I'll drink to that! Originally Posted by groucho070
And lets not limit to just them; lets wish that greater talents will flourish in TFI.
-
From: littlemaster1982 on 10th August 2009 07:27 PM [Full View]
Nerd, Hamid and last minute parties,
Seekiram vote podunga!!!
-
From: Vivasaayi on 10th August 2009 07:28 PM [Full View]
vera yaravadhu indu idukku sandhu pondhula irundha suryavukku vote potutu poyidunga..
-
From: crajkumar_be on 10th August 2009 07:29 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
-
From: Raikkonen on 10th August 2009 07:34 PM [Full View]
madhavanukku vote podupavargalukku oru vengala sombu ilavasam...
poduga..poduga.. sarakku teernthu kondirukirathu..
-
From: MADDY on 10th August 2009 07:39 PM [Full View]
thalafanz too - come on .......
-
From: Vivasaayi on 10th August 2009 07:43 PM [Full View]
thalafansayellam edhukku koopidreenga? Originally Posted by MADDY
thalafanz too - come on .......
maddy fansa mattum koopidunga
-
From: P_R on 10th August 2009 07:45 PM [Full View]
Mano about Michael jackson thangachchi: moonjiyai paaru Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
thalafansayellam edhukku koopidreenga? Originally Posted by MADDY
thalafanz too - come on .......
maddy fansa mattum koopidunga
Drums Mani: ....
-
From: Vivasaayi on 10th August 2009 07:46 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by Prabhu Ram
Mano about Michael jackson thangachchi: moonjiyai paaru Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
thalafansayellam edhukku koopidreenga? Originally Posted by MADDY
thalafanz too - come on .......
maddy fansa mattum koopidunga
Drums Mani: ....
-
From: littlemaster1982 on 10th August 2009 07:47 PM [Full View]
PR
-
From: Raikkonen on 10th August 2009 07:49 PM [Full View]
tie breaker is in..
ahng.. thread close pannidungappa..
edit: cheh.. shame of india
-
From: MADDY on 10th August 2009 07:51 PM [Full View]
adhavadhu, sivakumar payanukku ivalavu fans-aaana porama ellarukkum..... Originally Posted by Prabhu Ram
Mano about Michael jackson thangachchi: moonjiyai paaru Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
thalafansayellam edhukku koopidreenga? Originally Posted by MADDY
thalafanz too - come on .......
maddy fansa mattum koopidunga
Drums Mani: ....
-
From: crajkumar_be on 10th August 2009 07:58 PM [Full View]
Who is the white sheep?
-
From: Vivasaayi on 10th August 2009 08:04 PM [Full View]
soobarabu
-
From: jaiganes on 10th August 2009 08:05 PM [Full View]
wait venkatesa kalyana mandabaththai police pootiduchu - uLLAra enga aalunga sikkikitangadov!!!
-
From: Nerd on 10th August 2009 08:06 PM [Full View]
Edhu epdi irunthAlum since we ( I mean Maddyans) insulted the mod, surya win pannra varaikkum avar Oya mAttAr.
Naanum sollikkirEn, idhellAm oru thErthal.
-
From: Shakthiprabha on 10th August 2009 08:07 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by Raikkonen
cha! enakku vera ids illaama pochE
-
From: Vivasaayi on 10th August 2009 08:07 PM [Full View]
nerd shoot outlam mudinuju cup kudukumbodhuthan poduvaru pola...
-
From: Appu s on 10th August 2009 08:08 PM [Full View]
yen 2 sombu vaangalamnna ? Originally Posted by Shakthiprabha
Originally Posted by Raikkonen
cha! enakku vera ids illaama pochE
-
From: Vivasaayi on 10th August 2009 08:08 PM [Full View]
"suryaa sarr...orasaadheenga" Originally Posted by Nerd
-
From: Nerd on 10th August 2009 08:09 PM [Full View]
pOttAchu pOttAchu. I yaam #41. Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
-
From: P_R on 10th August 2009 08:15 PM [Full View]
திரண்டுவந்த திரியை திட்டமிட்ட தடுத்துவிட்டதாக திட்டவட்டமாக திரித்துக்கூறிய திருவாளர்களே. திறமையாளர் திமிரியெழுந்து திரைகடலில் தீரனெனத் திகழ்வது திண்ணமென்றுணர்வீர்.
-
From: crajkumar_be on 10th August 2009 08:16 PM [Full View]
Ada ada
-
From: Nerd on 10th August 2009 08:18 PM [Full View]
"Kakkakka kAkAvena kokkokka kOkOvena"
-
From: cuty2sweety on 10th August 2009 09:29 PM [Full View]
Adhu eppadi naan vote podravangalaam thothudaraanga?
-
From: jaiganes on 10th August 2009 09:38 PM [Full View]
vote panninaa mattum podhaadhu - canvas pannanum, poster ottnum, kalyana mandabam book pannanum, biriyani pottalam vaanganum, Autos with poruL ready pannanum, thoathutta recount kaettu kOattai varai oorvalam poganum - Thaerdhalnna summaava? Originally Posted by cuty2sweety
Adhu eppadi naan vote podravangalaam thothudaraanga?
-
From: hamid on 10th August 2009 09:43 PM [Full View]
Jananaayaka kamamaiya aathiyaachu.
I am 42.
-
From: Shakthiprabha on 10th August 2009 09:50 PM [Full View]
athE gathi thaan enakkum Originally Posted by cuty2sweety
Adhu eppadi naan vote podravangalaam thothudaraanga?
enakku vera vaay samarthyam porathu. Hence dont know how to campaign
-
From: Plum on 10th August 2009 09:53 PM [Full View]
middle-age. adhukkenna ippo? Originally Posted by hamid
-
From: cuty2sweety on 10th August 2009 09:54 PM [Full View]
Athuku thaane neengalaam irukeenga Originally Posted by jaiganes
vote panninaa mattum podhaadhu - canvas pannanum, poster ottnum, kalyana mandabam book pannanum, biriyani pottalam vaanganum, Autos with poruL ready pannanum, thoathutta recount kaettu kOattai varai oorvalam poganum - Thaerdhalnna summaava? Originally Posted by cuty2sweety
Adhu eppadi naan vote podravangalaam thothudaraanga?
Naangalaam vote potutu vandhu katchi saarbaa OCla soda kudikaravanga
-
From: jaiganes on 10th August 2009 10:59 PM [Full View]
irukkira nidhi nelamaiyile soda order veraya? Originally Posted by cuty2sweety
Athuku thaane neengalaam irukeenga Originally Posted by jaiganes
vote panninaa mattum podhaadhu - canvas pannanum, poster ottnum, kalyana mandabam book pannanum, biriyani pottalam vaanganum, Autos with poruL ready pannanum, thoathutta recount kaettu kOattai varai oorvalam poganum - Thaerdhalnna summaava? Originally Posted by cuty2sweety
Adhu eppadi naan vote podravangalaam thothudaraanga?
Naangalaam vote potutu vandhu katchi saarbaa OCla soda kudikaravanga
atchikku vandhu idhaiyellaam recover panrathukku kai vasam niraya plan irukku.
ala puyal in soona paana
'nee baattukku un paadhaila poitte irudaa'.
-
From: jaiganes on 10th August 2009 11:00 PM [Full View]
orutharukku 50% nna innorutharukku 50% irukkanume - 49% nnu kaamikkudhe EVM????
indha latchanathula sellaadha vote verayaa? eppidi? kanakku thalai suththudhudaa saaammee.
-
From: HonestRaj on 10th August 2009 11:01 PM [Full View]
Y there shud not be Dhanush & others in this list.... whats the big diff between Surya & Dhanush / Simbhu
ellorum < 25 films'dhan... (simbhu - just 25 with Silambattam)
-
From: jaiganes on 10th August 2009 11:09 PM [Full View]
"KALAI" machcheee. kalaikku vayasu, pada ennikkaai edhuvum kidayaadhu. Aanaal idhu hub- indha vambu velaila rules ellaam kidayadhu. Originally Posted by HonestRaj
-
From: hamid on 11th August 2009 09:41 AM [Full View]
ennamo nadakkuthu, marmamaai irukkuthu
-
From: Balaspike on 11th August 2009 01:04 PM [Full View]
yen?
-
From: hamid on 11th August 2009 01:20 PM [Full View]
athellam detaila solla mudiyaathu.. ban panniduvaanga
-
From: HonestRaj on 11th August 2009 07:52 PM [Full View]
vayasu kidayadhunnu solreenga aana across te gen. compare panna koodadhunnu solreenga Originally Posted by jaiganes
"KALAI" machcheee. kalaikku vayasu, pada ennikkaai edhuvum kidayaadhu. Aanaal idhu hub- indha vambu velaila rules ellaam kidayadhu. Originally Posted by HonestRaj
nan poyi micha 3 pakkata fill panna try panraen
-
From: Movie Cop on 12th August 2009 12:36 AM [Full View]
Madhavan thaan-nga although Surya is surely catching up and trying to narrow the gap. Our friend Rakesh has already said enough.
-
From: jaiganes on 12th August 2009 02:33 AM [Full View]
inga enna katchiyaa nadakkudhu? Originally Posted by hamid
athellam detaila solla mudiyaathu.. ban panniduvaanga
soththu kanakkayaa kekkarom?
illai Katchi nidhi evvalonnu kekkaroma?
Indha chappai matterukkellaam yaarum ban panna maattangappa.
-
From: app_engine on 12th August 2009 03:11 AM [Full View]
digression
"We have 107367 registered users"
அப்பிடீன்னு ஹப் சொல்லுது, இதுல ஆயிரத்துக்கு ஒருத்தர் கூட இந்தத்தேர்தல்ல ஓட்டுப்போடல்ல, பின்ன ஏன் கணக்கு, வழக்கு, கள்ள ஓட்டுன்னு அடிச்சுக்கிறீங்க?
end-digression
-
From: Sarna on 12th August 2009 06:14 PM [Full View]
adiyEn dhaan Originally Posted by hamid
plum'a nenachchaadhaan
-
From: bingleguy on 18th August 2009 02:06 AM [Full View]
voting mudinju pocha .... sorry NOV
-
From: NOV on 18th August 2009 05:26 AM [Full View]
oru 10 naal munnaadi vandhirukka koodaadhaa vasanth?