|
The Hub : Tamil Films Archived | Hello Guest, Login to post. |
Which rival competetion excites/interests you a lot
Topic started by Thirumaran on Wed May 24 9:25:45 2006. |
Poll |
From: Unicorn on Wed May 24 9:28:31 2006. |
From: Hulkster on Wed May 24 9:40:29 2006. |
From: ansa400 on Wed May 24 10:00:47 2006. |
From: Justice on Wed May 24 10:10:03 2006. |
ansa400 wrote: |
Wonder what are the points to discuss on this issue |
From: selvakumar on Wed May 24 10:10:53 2006. |
From: great on Wed May 24 10:14:10 2006. |
From: selvakumar on Wed May 24 10:17:32 2006. |
great wrote: |
I wont agree to this POLL
WHERE IS NAYANTARA V/S TRISHA |
From: ansa400 on Wed May 24 10:19:31 2006. |
From: selvakumar on Wed May 24 10:21:56 2006. |
ansa400 wrote: |
Rajini Vs Kamal is no more a competition. Its no more interesting. The much hyped Chadramukhi Vs MXpress turned out to be nothin. Vikram Vs Surya also doesn't excite me much. I can say that Ajith Vs Vijay is the only lively battle right now. |
From: great on Wed May 24 10:23:21 2006. |
selvakumar wrote: | ||
I strongly object this.. NAYANTARA engae.. trisha engae. |
From: selvakumar on Wed May 24 10:23:37 2006. |
From: selvakumar on Wed May 24 10:24:28 2006. |
great wrote: | ||||
seri Trisha V/S __________ |
From: great on Wed May 24 10:27:08 2006. |
From: selvakumar on Wed May 24 10:28:35 2006. |
great wrote: |
Asinukku nadikka theriyum
Trisha V/S Charmee |
From: ansa400 on Wed May 24 10:31:05 2006. |
selvakumar wrote: |
ANSA machan !
In that past, RK vs KH was like a BATTLEFIELD just like AJITH VS VIJAY |
From: ansa400 on Wed May 24 10:33:42 2006. |
great wrote: |
Asinukku nadikka theriyum
Trisha V/S Charmee |
From: terminator on Wed May 24 10:38:27 2006. |
great wrote: |
Asinukku nadikka theriyum
Trisha V/S Charmee |
From: ansa400 on Wed May 24 10:40:01 2006. |
terminator wrote: | ||
Trisha vs Diya... |
From: sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar on Wed May 24 10:40:15 2006. |
From: great on Wed May 24 10:42:14 2006. |
From: sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar on Wed May 24 10:43:27 2006. |
From: ansa400 on Wed May 24 10:43:37 2006. |
sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar wrote: |
The last clash of KHvsRK is mentioned wrong, right order follows
2005 - MXvsCM - CM won. MX total flop 1996 - Kuruthippunal vs Muthu - Balance - bcos KP had quality and Muthu had mass elements, and not viceverse 1992 - DevarMagan vs Pandian - DM won, pandian went without any trace Guna Vs Dalapathi - Dala had average win ang Guna a flop at BO Singaravelan vs Annamalai - SV didi decently and annamalai a blockbuster Sathi Leelavathi & Baadsha came at 95 pongal but not compared as clash, still SAtileelavati did its job promptly, and baadshaa is still a milestone hit Naayagan vs Manithan - near Balance at BO and high impalance at quality. |
From: ansa400 on Wed May 24 10:49:15 2006. |
sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar wrote: |
Suppose for 2006 Diwaali, if dasaavathaaram clashes with Shivaaji, with Ajith and vijay joining the list, then some distributors may think to postpone ajith and viay's movies as biggies clash may crush out the other films.
but if ajith and vijay, alone clashes, and if vikram\ soorya or aarya or barath releases their films no one will complain |
From: sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar on Wed May 24 10:50:14 2006. |
From: sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar on Wed May 24 10:51:35 2006. |
ansa400 wrote: |
They wouldn't see it as a rivalry these days as in the case of Ajith Vs Vijay. |
From: alwarpet_andavan on Wed May 24 10:51:56 2006. |
From: Thirumaran on Wed May 24 10:53:29 2006. |
sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar wrote: |
Suppose for 2006 Diwaali, if dasaavathaaram clashes with Shivaaji, with Ajith and vijay joining the list, then some distributors may think to postpone ajith and viay's movies as biggies clash may crush out the other films.
but if ajith and vijay, alone clashes, and if vikram\ soorya or aarya or barath releases their films no one will complain |
From: ansa400 on Wed May 24 10:54:08 2006. |
sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar wrote: |
current situation is
Rajni - rajni uses his brain only once. that is while deciding his director. He shows high excellence by joining with Shankar at right time. Shivaji is a sure 200 days Kamal - he has an zeal - which translateds to Anayaa neruppu. This feiey man is now making Dasaavathaaram, so Rajni has to be very careful if kamal releases this at time of Shivaaji Vijay - his future is now solely in the hands of the director he is going to choose. Ajith - personally very good character which doesn't translate into BO hits. Godfather and Naan kadavul show some hope. has to wait and see. at this point of time, there cannot be any clash as interesting as Dasaavathaaram vs Shivaaji Sakalakalaa vallavar vs Paayum Puli |
From: great on Wed May 24 10:55:38 2006. |
From: great on Wed May 24 10:57:32 2006. |
ansa400 wrote: |
I don't think these 2 films will release at the same time. Dasavatharam - not yet started( Hope it doesn't turn out to be another Alavandan ), Sivaji might release this year. |
From: Thirumaran on Wed May 24 11:00:45 2006. |
From: sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar on Wed May 24 11:01:31 2006. |
ansa400 wrote: |
I don't think these 2 films will release at the same time. Dasavatharam - not yet started, Sivaji might release this year. |
ansa400 wrote: |
( Hope it doesn't turn out to be another Alavandan ) |
From: ansa400 on Wed May 24 11:01:39 2006. |
great wrote: | ||
Even if Sivaji releases whats the chances it will hit the bulls eyes . what made you think Dasavatharam will be like Alavandan |
From: ansa400 on Wed May 24 11:04:24 2006. |
From: great on Wed May 24 11:04:31 2006. |
From: Thirumaran on Wed May 24 11:07:51 2006. |
ansa400 wrote: |
.... with kamal giving the hopeless MX recently, I've all the reasons to think that way. |
From: sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar on Wed May 24 11:09:11 2006. |
ansa400 wrote: |
.... with kamal giving the hopeless MX recently, I've all the reasons to think that way. |
From: ansa400 on Wed May 24 11:11:12 2006. |
Thirumaran wrote: | ||
So according to you MX and Aalavandaan are hopeless films comparing to PSM and Tirupathi? Is that so ? |
From: great on Wed May 24 11:13:25 2006. |
ansa400 wrote: |
No , my point was with Kamal dissappointing with these 2 films, one cannot be 100% sure of this film. I mean, do u ever think that Alavandan & MX was worth the hype? |
From: ansa400 on Wed May 24 11:16:02 2006. |
great wrote: |
////kiddish film.
funny what made u think like that is it due to usage of 2-d tech, there were some flaws in screenplay but its not bad film when compared to many tamil films. |
From: sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar on Wed May 24 11:19:31 2006. |
From: Thirumaran on Wed May 24 11:20:57 2006. |
ansa400 wrote: | ||||
No , my point was with Kamal dissappointing with these 2 films, one cannot be 100% sure of this film. I mean, do u ever think that Alavandan & MX was worth the hype? |
From: ab_123 on Wed May 24 11:31:16 2006. |
From: great on Wed May 24 11:34:23 2006. |
From: ab_123 on Wed May 24 11:41:25 2006. |
great wrote: |
Hi Ab
is that karunya in ur avtaar |
From: great on Wed May 24 11:44:46 2006. |
ab_123 wrote: | ||
Hi Great! No his cousin, Hemachandra. (SRGMP contestant) |
From: sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar on Wed May 24 11:50:30 2006. |
From: kidils on Wed May 24 11:50:55 2006. |
From: Thirumaran on Wed May 24 12:02:52 2006. |
From: Thirumaran on Wed May 24 12:04:52 2006. |
From: Thirumaran on Wed May 24 12:06:12 2006. |
kidils wrote: |
vikram vs surya interests me. |
From: alwarpet_andavan on Wed May 24 12:09:24 2006. |
From: Justice on Wed May 24 12:11:23 2006. |
From: alwarpet_andavan on Wed May 24 12:13:30 2006. |
From: Justice on Wed May 24 12:18:24 2006. |
sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar wrote: |
Suppose for 2006 Diwaali, if dasaavathaaram clashes with Shivaaji, with Ajith and vijay joining the list, then some distributors may think to postpone ajith and viay's movies as biggies clash may crush out the other films.
but if ajith and vijay, alone clashes, and if vikram\ soorya or aarya or barath releases their films no one will complain |
From: ajithfederer on Wed May 24 12:24:21 2006. |
From: Raikkonen on Wed May 24 12:27:41 2006. |
From: ansa400 on Wed May 24 12:33:00 2006. |
ajithfederer wrote: |
but my preception rajni vs kamal clashes are losing thier previous shine.....as thier fans are no more fighting and both are good friends on and off screen........ Coming on to the main fight i would rate Ajith vs Vijay as a bigger fite...as they are known to be arch rivals and thier fans deadly enemies of each oher ........he he....... |
From: ajithfederer on Wed May 24 12:35:19 2006. |
Raikkonen wrote: |
Apart from Rajni Kamal and Vijay Ajith, others are just to make numbres i guess...
Simbhu Dhanush is total fluke While Vikram and Surya are very good heroes, but they dont have hardcore fans like RKVA (Rajn....Ajith).... |
From: Justice on Wed May 24 12:36:26 2006. |
Thirumaran wrote: |
Exactly.
Just Since the CM and ME did not met the expectations does not mean that their competition is less worthy. since the Paramasivan and Aathi competition does not live upto expectation, can we say that, this competition is no more worthy. In my opinion, still the Rajini and Kamal combination excites a lot. |
From: Thirumaran on Wed May 24 12:43:31 2006. |
Justice wrote: | ||
so did CM vs MX competition lived upto expectation?. Read your post point which answers your second point. If it did not live upto YOUR expecation that does not mean it's not worthy. |
From: ajithfederer on Wed May 24 12:46:25 2006. |
From: Thirumaran on Wed May 24 12:51:55 2006. |
ajithfederer wrote: |
cm and mx competition wasnt that good anna........ boh films were of different genre....comparing them is waste.......
mx was a Totally different and as usual brave attempt from kamal hasan if shivaji and suppose(summa solrein) vv clash aachunaa...............athu COMPETITION |
From: ansa400 on Wed May 24 12:55:09 2006. |
Thirumaran wrote: | ||
Of Course, I know that. Ansa was saying that since MX was a flop that competion does not make much worth. MX is not a kind of movie to clash with CM. As u said if VV or 10V and Shivaji comes together, that will be an explosive than any other rivalry.. |
From: Thirumaran on Wed May 24 12:59:30 2006. |
ansa400 wrote: | ||||
So what MX releases with CM? U mean to say that Devar magan & Pandian were of the same categorY? or for that matter Kurudhipunal and Muthu.. |
From: villan007 on Wed May 24 13:02:03 2006. |
From: sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar on Wed May 24 13:02:58 2006. |
ansa400 wrote: |
So what MX releases with CM? U mean to say that Devar magan & Pandian were of the same categorY? or for that matter Kurudhipunal and Muthu.. |
From: sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar on Wed May 24 13:04:02 2006. |
villan007 wrote: |
Ajith vs Vijay
pOrkalam |
From: ansa400 on Wed May 24 13:04:27 2006. |
Thirumaran wrote: |
You first answer this. You said since MX flopped that combination does not worth here after. I am asking the same thing. Since Aathi flopped badly does that make Ajith and Vijay combo less worthy? Then i will answer yours |
From: ajithfederer on Wed May 24 13:06:00 2006. |
sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar wrote: | ||
kamal VS rajni Thiruvizhaa |
From: villan007 on Wed May 24 13:06:33 2006. |
sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar wrote: | ||
kamal VS rajni Thiruvizhaa |
From: ansa400 on Wed May 24 13:07:25 2006. |
sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar wrote: | ||
MX was a comedy film, not like Cm. CM had a very strong climax. Devar magan was more serious and interesting than Pandian. |
From: ansa400 on Wed May 24 13:09:32 2006. |
sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar wrote: | ||
kamal VS rajni Thiruvizhaa |
From: villan007 on Wed May 24 13:12:03 2006. |
From: ansa400 on Wed May 24 13:13:22 2006. |
villan007 wrote: |
feddy u were in cbe when citizen was released
bhadri cut-out was into bits n pieces in ganga and even worser battles for bagavathy-villan , thirumalai-anjaneya , dheena-friends |
From: Nerd on Wed May 24 13:14:09 2006. |
From: Thirumaran on Wed May 24 13:19:52 2006. |
ansa400 wrote: | ||
I never said that since MX flopped that combination is not worth. What I was referring was that kamal films recently failed to match the hype. Thats it. Now answer my question. |
From: Nerd on Wed May 24 13:22:53 2006. |
From: great on Wed May 24 13:25:17 2006. |
From: ajithfederer on Wed May 24 13:26:03 2006. |
villan007 wrote: |
feddy u were in cbe when citizen was released
bhadri cut-out was into bits n pieces in ganga and even worser battles for bagavathy-villan , thirumalai-anjaneya , dheena-friends |
From: Thirumaran on Wed May 24 13:26:27 2006. |
Nerd wrote: |
TM,
nice way to name Rajini Vs Kamal For me its always Rajini Vs Kamal Actually I neither like ajith/vijay nor hate them. They both were doing very good until ajith came up with RED and vijay came up with thirumalai and the likes. After that I dont bother to watch their movies. Vikram Vs Surya is an interesting competition. But I rate maddy as a better actor than both of them btw, manithan out-did naayagan in terms of collections, which I think was the force behind Rajini becoming a superstar. Imagine a movie like naayagan losing to manithan! |
From: Thirumaran on Wed May 24 13:29:04 2006. |
Nerd wrote: |
Just a small correction, TM.
DM was not a total class movie, it had its own mass elements. Thats my most fav KH movie. Compare DM with the likes of Hey raam or anbE sivam. Those were complete class movies with zero mass elements. In DM we have gowthami, a silambu fight etcc.., which satisfied the masses. |
From: great on Wed May 24 13:29:33 2006. |
From: villan007 on Wed May 24 13:29:53 2006. |
ajithfederer wrote: |
one more thing all a class theatres like archana ragam ganga .....thier 1st choice is ajith.....vijays films mainly release in shanthi thanam and if place is there darsana |
From: ansa400 on Wed May 24 13:30:07 2006. |
Thirumaran wrote: |
However for u...
Pandiyan Vs Devar Magan Pandiyan and Thevar Magan came with great expectations. As usual Pandiyan is a typical masala entertainer like many other Rajini films. Consider the common people mind set. They prefer Masala films than Class films. You know among the two which is a class and which was for mass. Since Devar Magan was extra ordinary it became huge succcess. Definetly that was worth an combination considering the kind of movies they act.. Kuruthi punal vs Muthu These two once again came with great expectations and Muthu was a superhit and Kuruthi punal was a hit. Actually it was Kuruthi punal which was leading in first 2 weeks. Even in sun tv top 10 movies they could not hide this. First 2 weeks they kept KP in top, inspite of being Muthu was against JJ. That itself will show. however Since there were no elements in KP to attract ladies, it did not do that much well like Muthu. Saying that KP was a hit. And Muthu at that time came with other controversies too. But see MX and CM.. CM has all the elements to attract the mass. But MX, nothing to attract people and it was an experiment with a different type of comedy. but the movies u mentioned had all the elements to make people to come for the theatres. |
From: villan007 on Wed May 24 13:32:35 2006. |
Thirumaran wrote: |
I would like to see Surya Vs Vikram combo which so far nothing.. But in the future i believe this pair can come in headlines . |
From: Nerd on Wed May 24 13:33:35 2006. |
Thirumaran wrote: |
You got it
|
From: great on Wed May 24 13:34:02 2006. |
From: Thirumaran on Wed May 24 13:39:35 2006. |
ansa400 wrote: |
See, the expectations from a Kamal movie now is different from those times. As Kamal chooses off-beat themes more often now, ppl do not expect much from the Rajini-Kamal competition. Rajini has maintained the commercial formula till date. Its like only when Kamal acts commercial films like VV, 10A that he can compete with Rajini. As he does not do this often now,hence there is no competition between them. |
From: ansa400 on Wed May 24 13:41:07 2006. |
great wrote: |
////ansa: As Kamal chooses off-beat themes more often now, ppl do not expect much from the Rajini-Kamal competition
Thats ur perception you cannot generalise things whether people expect from this combo or not |
great wrote: |
if you take 2005 april competion though the outcome was one sided RK movie did well at BO but both the movie were able to set BO on fire atleast on initial days. This is not the case with younger generation actors |
From: great on Wed May 24 13:43:36 2006. |
From: ajithfederer on Wed May 24 13:44:50 2006. |
From: Thirumaran on Wed May 24 13:45:22 2006. |
villan007 wrote: | ||
0 %... vikram has already announced that he l do only one movie per year..... and surya lost his interest in masala films after 6...... so they both are kinda class hero wannabes.... I don find any sort of rivalry |
From: Nerd on Wed May 24 13:47:21 2006. |
From: ansa400 on Wed May 24 13:48:29 2006. |
great wrote: |
////I can't agree with it. Infact Sachein which released with these 2 films fared better than MX I beleive
Sachin was total washout !!!! Dont ever compare with MX |
From: villan007 on Wed May 24 13:50:03 2006. |
Thirumaran wrote: |
See in the past if u see.. Rajini and Kamal movies came together with masala elements. And sometimes Kamal's class movies clashed with Rajini's mass movies. Generally we can say this as class vs Mass Vijay and Ajith... Both do commercial kind of movies only.. So Mass vs Mass.. Surya and Vikram.. Though they were involved in many commercial movies, they both are trying in class movies.. Now i would to see something like class Vs class.. Proabably may not happen also.. But could be intersting if people's mindset changes in course of time... |
From: ajithfederer on Wed May 24 13:50:14 2006. |
Nerd wrote: |
oh common guys.. dont be hypocritical. Sachein got better reviews than MX and even CM from a few magazines and even from vijay TV, I believe. Also it had a 200 days run and I dont think that anyone would fake more then 100 days. AFAIK its a 100 days movie, atleast. MX dint cross 100 days in any theatre |
From: great on Wed May 24 13:50:36 2006. |
Nerd wrote: |
oh common guys.. dont be hypocritical. Sachein got better reviews than MX and even CM from a few magazines and even from vijay TV, I believe. Also it had a 200 days run and I dont think that anyone would fake more then 100 days. AFAIK its a 100 days movie, atleast. MX dint cross 100 days in any theatre |
From: villan007 on Wed May 24 13:51:53 2006. |
Nerd wrote: |
oh common guys.. dont be hypocritical. Sachein got better reviews than MX and even CM from a few magazines and even from vijay TV, I believe. Also it had a 200 days run and I dont think that anyone would fake more then 100 days. AFAIK its a 100 days movie, atleast. MX dint cross 100 days in any theatre |
From: great on Wed May 24 13:52:28 2006. |
ansa400 wrote: | ||
what I meant was the collections were better. Infact both the films bombed badly at the BO. |
From: ansa400 on Wed May 24 13:53:46 2006. |
Thirumaran wrote: |
See in the past if u see.. Rajini and Kamal movies came together with masala elements. And sometimes Kamal's class movies clashed with Rajini's mass movies. Generally we can say this as class vs Mass Vijay and Ajith... Both do commercial kind of movies only.. So Mass vs Mass.. Surya and Vikram.. Though they were involved in many commercial movies, they both are trying in class movies too.. Now i would like to see something like class Vs class.. Proabably may not happen also.. But could be intersting if people's mindset changes in course of time... |
From: Thirumaran on Wed May 24 13:59:39 2006. |
villan007 wrote: |
not always ....... may be the movies came in recent years made you think so... vaali , mughavari , KKKK were not mass movies and much awaited GF is said to be a Class+mass movie and naan kadavul will be class movie... |
From: villan007 on Wed May 24 14:01:38 2006. |
Thirumaran wrote: |
In my opinion, all these movies were kind of mass movies only but with class elements included. The movies u mentioned had classy performances but as a whole the mass factors are more than the class factors in my opinion. Of course that is the case with many other movies too. I too hope GF with Mass+ class. However even if we consider that as class movies, general opinion is they are refered as mass actors i believe. |
From: Thirumaran on Wed May 24 14:04:03 2006. |
villan007 wrote: | ||
Even KH was touted to be a mass hero once |
From: Thirumaran on Wed May 24 14:06:46 2006. |
ansa400 wrote: | ||
It is not that surya & vikram are not interested in doing mass movies. They r trying desperate for mass support, but its not as easy to get mass support like how Rajini-Kamal had and now AJith - vijay has. |
From: ansa400 on Wed May 24 14:06:59 2006. |
villan007 wrote: | ||
Even KH was touted to be a mass hero once |
From: ansa400 on Wed May 24 14:09:06 2006. |
Thirumaran wrote: |
We have to wait for few more years. They came into limelight just few years ago.. Already Surya had great openings for Ghajini and Aaru and both became hit.. |
From: ajithfederer on Wed May 24 14:10:54 2006. |
ansa400 wrote: | ||
I think Vikram is not as popular among the mass as Surya is. |
From: villan007 on Wed May 24 14:11:57 2006. |
ansa400 wrote: |
I think Vikram is not as popular among the mass as Surya is. |
From: Thirumaran on Wed May 24 14:49:47 2006. |
From: Thirumaran on Wed May 24 14:51:07 2006. |
selvakumar wrote: |
THIRU ANNA... Except the first TWO OPTIONS, other things are |
From: ansa400 on Wed May 24 14:51:21 2006. |
Thirumaran wrote: |
No one has anything to say abt Simbu and Dhanush |
From: ajithfederer on Wed May 24 14:52:46 2006. |
From: Thirumaran on Wed May 24 14:56:59 2006. |
ajithfederer wrote: |
what if vallavan and pp clashes?
|
From: ab_123 on Wed May 24 15:06:53 2006. |
From: ajithfederer on Wed May 24 15:30:15 2006. |
From: Justice on Wed May 24 15:48:55 2006. |
From: Thirumaran on Wed May 24 17:30:37 2006. |
ab_123 wrote: |
Help me understand this:
Surya and Vikram Or Ajith and Vijay are they considered actors of the same genre/category? Vikram has been around a lot longer than Surya, for one. Ajit has been around a lot longer than Vijay. So aren't their fan bases a little different? Is there really a rivalry? (AF, which movie is your AV from ?) |
From: ab_123 on Wed May 24 17:43:43 2006. |
From: Sanguine Sridhar on Wed May 24 18:35:07 2006. |
From: Surya on Wed May 24 18:44:28 2006. |
From: Sanguine Sridhar on Wed May 24 18:48:04 2006. |
From: Surya on Wed May 24 18:51:01 2006. |
From: m_23_bayarea on Wed May 24 19:35:32 2006. |
From: Thirumaran on Wed May 24 19:43:22 2006. |
ab_123 wrote: |
Thanks TM, for clarifying. Ajith's first movie was Amaraavathi right?
Vijay's was Naalaya Theerpu? (I kind of missed the first few Vijay movies, that's why I had the wrong impression). |
From: Thirumaran on Wed May 24 19:52:54 2006. |
m_23_bayarea wrote: |
Talkin abt competition, ever since I remember in school and college, whenever there was a Rajini vs Kamal argument, my name just would come up from out of the blue ... However, after gaining some maturity, I started liking both actors, and now I only look at them as ASSETS to tamil cinema, and not competitors ... Maybe professionally they had a great competition, but the output only benefitted Tamil cinema as a whole ... So these days, I dont get into that argument ... Also, I beleive it involuntary goes to pulling down one, just to elevate the other ... So I guess it's also not worth it !!! |
From: m_23_bayarea on Wed May 24 20:00:51 2006. |
Thirumaran wrote: |
That is true Tell one thing, Does not you get excited when Rajini and Kamal movies release together? |
From: Hulkster on Wed May 24 20:07:50 2006. |
From: Ghlli on Wed May 24 20:10:16 2006. |
From: Thirumaran on Wed May 24 20:42:10 2006. |
m_23_bayarea wrote: |
TM, Of Course I'd get excited ... But to be honest, the movies have to be in the same genre ... To be on the same scale you know ... For example, CM vs MX, I knew the outcome right when I read that MX was gonna be a comedy movie ... I'd be super-excited if SIVAJI and VV had been released together, cos both the movies have an equally balanced team and are both action/thriller oriented ... Or mass movies like Kaaki Chattai/Guru Sishyan or something like that ... I'm sure you'd be a part of the Kamal yahoo groups ... In there, they have a great collection of Rajini/Kamal movies released together, and how they did at the BO ... Check it out, if you have a chance .. I copied/pasted that a LONG TIME back in the Rajini vs Kamal thread !!! |
From: Raikkonen on Thu May 25 2:24:35 2006. |
From: Aryaz on Thu May 25 3:17:43 2006. |
From: manmadan on Thu May 25 5:21:42 2006. |
From: selvakumar on Thu May 25 8:25:20 2006. |
From: m_23_bayarea on Thu May 25 11:16:20 2006. |
Thirumaran wrote: |
However one thing i could not agree. You said once u heard MX was a comedy movie, the outcome u could predict. Comedy movies are no way lesser than any other types of movies in mu opinion. There are several great hit comedy movies in the history of TN. It is how the film was executed and how much it attracts the people what matters i believe. |
From: Surya on Thu May 25 11:22:17 2006. |
From: Raikkonen on Thu May 25 11:23:08 2006. |
From: Surya on Thu May 25 11:26:04 2006. |
From: Raikkonen on Thu May 25 11:28:11 2006. |
From: Surya on Thu May 25 11:31:56 2006. |
From: Aravind_06 on Thu May 25 11:47:30 2006. |
From: romio on Thu May 25 11:51:16 2006. |
From: Surya on Thu May 25 11:54:55 2006. |
From: Raikkonen on Thu May 25 11:56:59 2006. |
From: Thirumaran on Thu May 25 13:10:09 2006. |
Surya wrote: |
What was the Last Comedy Movie that was a good hit?
Vasool Raja right? That was about 3 years ago. After that, there have been a string of Comedy movies that have flopped like: Charilie Chaplin London Majaa (Easy Going, Mainly Comedy) Mayaavi (Same Thing) Mumbai Express etc i've often wondered why Comedy Movies don't tend to make it as big as they used to anymore... |
From: great on Thu May 25 13:14:10 2006. |
From: Thirumaran on Thu May 25 13:18:11 2006. |
m_23_bayarea wrote: | ||
Yeah TM, I agree that comedy movies have become big hits in the past ... But still, I believe in a complete package ... That's when it becomes blockbuster material !! |
From: Thirumaran on Thu May 25 13:27:04 2006. |
great wrote: |
///Siva i think this movie is an average movie and not a hit. I dont know whether they remade this movie in telugu or not. But they remade this movie in Hindi as "NO ENTRY" and it became a superhit there
It was remade in telugu it was a hit. In hindi it was block buster. This movie was well received in the 3 languages |
From: great on Thu May 25 13:33:22 2006. |
Thirumaran wrote: |
I liked the hindi version more than the tamil. |
From: Thirumaran on Thu May 25 13:42:18 2006. |
great wrote: |
I havent seen both the versions !!! Only second half of the hindi version i have seen. Tamil i didnt like bcoz of the star cast |
From: m_23_bayarea on Thu May 25 13:43:32 2006. |
Thirumaran wrote: |
Hmm. Right. However we cannot expect a CM kind blockbuster every time. It is more than enough if the movies comes out as a bigger hit.
However i believe the comedy movies like... Avvai Shanmugi, Ullathai allithaa and some more could be considered among blockbusters And if something like Shivaji and VV clashes or.. 10V and Shivaji clashed.. it could be a bigger treat for many, more than any other clashes. If that kind thing happens both the movies could be super hits and one movie becoming a bigger hit than the other. |
From: Villan on Sun May 28 7:17:43 2006. |
From: Shakthiprabha. on Thu Jun 1 4:54:38 2006. |
From: Unicorn on Thu Jun 1 8:54:25 2006. |
Villan wrote: |
Ajith & Vijay 've gud competition between them...that attracts me...
Anyhow if thr is not a gud competitor...the match dont sound pretty fun....so this pair dont have much fun....cuz vijay is not the perfect match to compete with Thala... Thala Rocks |
From: selvakumar on Thu Jun 1 8:57:46 2006. |
From: Thirumaran on Thu Jun 1 10:08:14 2006. |
selvakumar wrote: |
Why there is no place for veterans like
MGR AND NT... I think this will bring veteran hubbers also into the discussion. Esp elders would have loved this combo.. |
From: tfmlover on Fri Sep 22 1:19:42 2006. |
selvakumar wrote: |
Why there is no place for veterans like
MGR AND NT... I think this will bring veteran hubbers also into the discussion. Esp elders would have loved this combo.. |
From: selvakumar on Fri Sep 22 2:03:22 2006. |
tfmlover wrote: | ||
|
From: raaja_rasigan on Fri Sep 22 7:37:27 2006. |
selvakumar wrote: | ||||
Exactly ! We don't know much about this combo. I think veteran's can share their knowledge with us (and ofcourse without comparing the two) |
From: Raghu on Fri Sep 22 8:56:21 2006. |
raaja_rasigan wrote: |
Since CAPTAIN VIJAYAKANTH does one man show, they haven't mentioned him in the list. Appadiyaa, idhu unmaiyya |
From: MADDY on Fri Sep 22 16:51:48 2006. |
From: Thirumaran on Fri Sep 22 17:08:48 2006. |
MADDY wrote: |
i dunno whether this can be included here or not - ARRahman vs Ilayaraja is the fiercest battle that i have ever seen in my life......i still can see many IR fans consider ARR as their personal enemy and there are many ARR fans (like me) who dont listen much to his songs and hate his family.......i guess after MGR vs Shivaji this is the fiercest fought battle in tamil film history.... |
From: Nerd on Fri Sep 22 17:11:51 2006. |
From: MADDY on Fri Sep 22 17:12:37 2006. |
Thirumaran wrote: | ||
|
From: MADDY on Fri Sep 22 17:19:27 2006. |
Nerd wrote: |
But RK Vs KH battle has been going on for like 20+ years now. IR Vs ARR started in 92. So some 15 years. But both of them have reached their saturation point I think. |
From: Nerd on Fri Sep 22 17:27:09 2006. |
From: P_R on Fri Sep 22 17:39:45 2006. |
Nerd wrote: |
CM for RK VV for KH They still are way ahead of their juniors in the respective fields !! |
From: Thirumaran on Fri Sep 22 18:10:47 2006. |
MADDY wrote: |
y shocked???maybe this generation guys dont know but i'm sure all the guys who were in 90's know this......and ask our MODS they will tell u stories of how ARR vs IR threads have put the old tfmpage into troubles.......boss this is a epic battle.... |
From: MADDY on Fri Sep 22 18:23:31 2006. |
Thirumaran wrote: |
Let us come to the common people away from hub/internet. Specifically Villages and moderate towns. I dont think any kind of street fights happens comparing these 2. Even in the cities it will be never like fighting for actors. |
From: m_23_bayarea on Sat Sep 23 11:28:31 2006. |
From: selvakumar on Sat Sep 23 11:53:55 2006. |
m_23_bayarea wrote: |
Wow, VJ and Ajith rivalry completely takin over Rajini vs Kamal !!! I donno how to react !!! |
From: Thirumaran on Sat Sep 23 12:35:27 2006. |
m_23_bayarea wrote: |
Wow, VJ and Ajith rivalry completely takin over Rajini vs Kamal !!! I donno how to react !!! |
From: imsai on Sat Sep 23 12:39:12 2006. |
selvakumar wrote: |
Bay, You can react with posts like this -- That one is Freaking awesome !! |
From: m_23_bayarea on Sat Sep 23 13:08:50 2006. |