The best ever MD for Kamal movies

The Hub : Tamil Films Archived

Hello Guest, Login to post.

Topic started by Nakeeran on Tue May 23 6:46:20 2006.

IMHO, MSV and IR come first to my thoughts. Probably MSV scores over IR overall. Not sure about others. Probably ARR also
Lets discuss here.

Poll
Best ever MD for Kamal movies
MSV [ 1 ]
IR [ 31 ]
ARR [ 9 ]

| RSS Feed | Email me when a reply is posted

Responses:

From: swathy on Tue May 23 6:57:18 2006.

Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja Raja
From: Nakeeran on Tue May 23 7:00:35 2006.

Swathy

can you elaborate pls ?
From: alwarpet_andavan on Tue May 23 7:02:51 2006.

There is no question about it.
ILAIYARAAJA
End of discussion!
From: Nakeeran on Tue May 23 7:05:25 2006.

alwarpet_andavan wrote:

There is no question about it.
ILAIYARAAJA
End of discussion!

Nice if you can put forth your views with justification, we can have some interesting sharing of thoughts

Salangai oli is one gem from IR but I could immediately recollect Varumayin niram sigappu also equally
From: great on Tue May 23 7:07:54 2006.

Manithar unarthu kolla ithu manitha kaathal alla athaiyum thaandi

potripadadi penne

naam ganga nathiyai kaanum pozhuthu

annathey adurar othhikko

unnai naan arivean

azhagae azhage

vara solli inneram

viru virumandi virumandi

ipdi sollikutae pogalam
From: Nakeeran on Tue May 23 7:10:20 2006.

Moonram pirai is another classic from IR

Enakkul oruvan is another

Ofcourse sakalakala vallavan was a commercial movie but IR was there as well

Kaaki sattai was one more

MSV :

Avargal

Manmadha leelai

APOORVA RAGANGAL !
From: Nakeeran on Tue May 23 7:11:57 2006.

Lets not forget MSV in :

Moondru mudichu &

NIZAL NIJAMAGIRADHU !

Also Simla Special ( almost at the end of his career )
From: great on Tue May 23 7:11:58 2006.

But topic here is BEST
From: Nakeeran on Tue May 23 7:13:41 2006.

great wrote:

But topic here is BEST

Lets analyse their stellar performances

Moondram pirai and Salangai oli stands tall for IR IMHO

Apoorva ragangal & Varumayin niram sigappu - MSV

Lot more
From: alwarpet_andavan on Tue May 23 7:14:52 2006.

Nakkeeran,
If i were to say to you that Bradman is the worlds best ever, would you ask for justification?
Or if i were to say honey is sweet, would you ask for justification?

Please go through Aandavar's filmography and imagine the column MD next to it, with the respective MD for each film. Reflect for a few seconds. You will get your justification

From: Nakeeran on Tue May 23 7:27:10 2006.

alwarpet_andavan wrote:

Nakkeeran,
If i were to say to you that Bradman is the worlds best ever, would you ask for justification?
Or if i were to say honey is sweet, would you ask for justification?

Please go through Aandavar's filmography and imagine the column MD next to it, with the respective MD for each film. Reflect for a few seconds. You will get your justification Smile

In terms of quality of songs, IMHO, both MSV and IR stand equal footing. What do you think ?

From: swathy on Tue May 23 7:28:38 2006.

alwarpet_andavan wrote:

There is no question about it.
ILAIYARAAJA
End of discussion!
From: Nakeeran on Tue May 23 7:32:46 2006.

swathy wrote:

alwarpet_andavan wrote:

There is no question about it.
ILAIYARAAJA
End of discussion!

Ayyo pavam Swathy neenga. Unga ariyamaya ninacha siripu dhan varudhu
Mudhalla raja raja rajanu poteenga. Details ketta escapu ayuteenga
Ippa AA soona commentukku thumbs up kodukareenga

Yen , vera edhuvum solla theriyalaya !
From: alwarpet_andavan on Tue May 23 7:38:46 2006.

Nakeeran wrote:

In terms of quality of songs, IMHO, both MSV and IR stand equal footing. What do you think ?

1) In terms of quality of songs, IMO IR is peerless, be it MSV or anyone else. I repeat, IMO.
2) However, this is not the topic. The topic is specific to Aandavar-MD combination, which IMO is all the more a forgone conclusion.
I repeat, just look at the list of "great" movies (musically = BGM, songs) Aandavar has done with IR. Its a no-contest actually. The quantity of quality movies of IR-Aandavar outweighs everything else in sight. Here, we are talking about great musicals churned out consistently in good numbers over a period of time.

As great has said above, its not like MSV hasnt given great music with the Aandavar combo, the question is WHO IS THE BEST
From: Nakeeran on Tue May 23 7:39:47 2006.

AVARGAL is another gem of a movie for MSV .

wonderful songs .

KAMAL WILL NEVER FORGET JUNIOR JUNIOR JUNIOR !
From: alwarpet_andavan on Tue May 23 7:42:15 2006.

And here's the clincher, straight from the horse's mouth!
Aandavar himself ranks IR above everybody else. So there.....
From: Nakeeran on Tue May 23 7:47:43 2006.

alwarpet_andavan wrote:

And here's the clincher, straight from the horse's mouth!
Aandavar himself ranks IR above everybody else. So there.....

AA, Kamal's friendship with IR is well known and he is one of those few guys around who still support IR even today.
Leave alone Kamal, lets not weigh on someone else's ( including Kamal's ) views.
IMHO, both MSV and IR have done extremely well and some of the MSV songs are real class apart .

KAMBAN EMANDHAN - GAVE A NEW YOUTHFUL FACE TO KAMAL
ADHISAYA RAGAM - REDEFINED KAMAL IN TF INDUSTRY
From: Justice on Tue May 23 7:50:07 2006.

There's no second thought, it's Ilayaraja
From: umaramesh on Tue May 23 7:56:49 2006.

Even AVAL ORU THODAR KATHAI. single song made everyone sit and watch .
Even though kamal was not in lead role.

Avargal/abroova Ragal/Moondru mudichu/nizalkagal nijamakirathu/Manmathalelai
Simla special/Maro charithra/Varumaiyin niram sivappu

Even though MSV scored less number of movies but each movie had super hit and evergreen songs. Even kamal reiterated that UNNAKENNA MELAYAE NIRYAI .outstanding and most number of time repeated everywhere.

VASANTHA KALA NATHIGALEELAY/ILLAKANAM MAARUTHOO/KAMBAN EEMANTHAN /MANAIVEE AMAIVATHELLAM/ATHSAYA RAGAM may be tuned decade back but still compete with any other songs composed after and recently.

ramesh
From: Thirumaran on Tue May 23 8:07:44 2006.

No doubt MSV is great and his movies with Kamalhasan had wonderful songs.
If we see overall IR worked with KH for around 80% of the movies, and the comparision is not fair.

Take for eg.. some of the best movies of KH..

1. 16 vayathinlilae
2. Sigappu Rojakkal
3. Moondram Pirai
4. Salangai Oli
5. Sippikkul muthu
6. Nayagn
7. Thevar Magan
8. Mahanadi..
9. Pesum Padam
10 . MMKR..

Without any doubt all these movies except Pesum Padam had great songs. Coming to the other thing.
For any movie to be complete, and an actor's performance to get its completeness BGM is a must and IR is king in that. Think abt all these movies without IR's BGM, then these movies may not be complete in my opinion.
So IR the best ever MD for KH for me.
From: Nakeeran on Tue May 23 8:11:09 2006.

MARO CHARITHRA !

GOD, KAMAL CAN NEVER FORGET THIS MOVIE & SONGS
From: great on Tue May 23 8:12:26 2006.

list continues

Hey Raam
Raaja parvai
Aboorva sagothargal
Guna
Sathileelavathi
Virumandi

From: Nakeeran on Tue May 23 8:12:41 2006.

umaramesh wrote:

Even AVAL ORU THODAR KATHAI. single song made everyone sit and watch .
Even though kamal was not in lead role.

Avargal/abroova Ragal/Moondru mudichu/nizalkagal nijamakirathu/Manmathalelai
Simla special/Maro charithra/Varumaiyin niram sivappu

Even though MSV scored less number of movies but each movie had super hit and evergreen songs. Even kamal reiterated that UNNAKENNA MELAYAE NIRYAI .outstanding and most number of time repeated everywhere.

VASANTHA KALA NATHIGALEELAY/ILLAKANAM MAARUTHOO/KAMBAN EEMANTHAN /MANAIVEE AMAIVATHELLAM/ATHSAYA RAGAM may be tuned decade back but still compete with any other songs composed after and recently.

ramesh

True & well said Ramesh.

KADAVUL AMAITHU VAITHA MEDAI song is still popular and Kamal is being recollected through this song !

From: Nakeeran on Tue May 23 8:14:17 2006.

Rajaparvai
Guna
Apoorva sagotharargal

3 OUTSTANDING MOVIES OF IR !
From: alwarpet_andavan on Tue May 23 8:14:48 2006.

Great,
Please allow me to make a couple of small corrections in your sig.

nam ganga nathiyaie kaaNum pozhuthu unmaiye viLanguthu
ada inge kuLikkum manithan azhukkil gangai kalanguthu
From: rami on Tue May 23 8:15:19 2006.

Kamal's best came out with IR's Best..

IR- Kamal combo rocks..

From: great on Tue May 23 8:16:42 2006.

alwarpet_andavan wrote:

Great,
Please allow me to make a couple of small corrections in your sig.

nam ganga nathiyaie kaaNum pozhluthu unmaiye viLanguthu
ada inge kuLikkum manithan azhukkil gangai kalanguthu

Thanks andavare

From: rami on Tue May 23 8:19:06 2006.

...hey Raam BG made ppl, who started talking abt IRs worth, shut their mouth...

He reestablished himself as MAESTRO...

Andhi mazhai - Raaja paarvai
Nee paartha ... Hey Raam
Unnai vida .. Virumaandi

are few of the jewels in the crown.. Of course there are many such diamonds..
From: rami on Tue May 23 8:19:48 2006.

These songs take me to a different world...

From: Nakeeran on Tue May 23 8:24:12 2006.

rami wrote:

...hey Raam BG made ppl, who started talking abt IRs worth, shut their mouth...

He reestablished himself as MAESTRO...

Andhi mazhai - Raaja paarvai
Nee paartha ... Hey Raam
Unnai vida .. Virumaandi

are few of the jewels in the crown.. Of course there are many such diamonds..

Ungalala oru SIPPI YIRUKKUDHU MUTHUM IRUKKUDHU paata mention panna mudiyaadhu.
BECAS YOU ARE ALL SO BIASED

What I am going through is a SERIES OF ONE SIDED , UNILATERAL THOUGHTS .
Very few guys like Thirumaran , Ramesh are appreciating the music of both

THIS SHOWS HOW LIMITED / IGNORANT KNOWLEDGE WE ALL HAVE !
IGNORANCE IS BLISS

From: great on Tue May 23 8:30:15 2006.

Nakeerar anne, your topic is on best MD for KH

if you take whole package IR steals the show

DOnt just go by single song.

I do agree sippi irrukuthu songs and avargal songs are good

But on the whole IR is the BEST FOR KH

No second thought in this regards
From: rami on Tue May 23 8:30:30 2006.

Honestly speaking I am not at all biased towards any MD.
I do like Aboora raagangal songs..
But IR - Kamal combo has given the best.. Since the topic states "BEST", I told IR is best..
From: bingleguy on Tue May 23 8:31:19 2006.

in my view ... i feel the Maestro makes an excellent combo with Kamal !
From: rami on Tue May 23 8:33:45 2006.

BG , did u receive the song

(ella threadlayum itha thaan ketkaren)
From: Nakeeran on Tue May 23 8:36:01 2006.

The ideal way to analyse is to list the movies of those who had been MD for KH and then highlight some special songs and BGM and then finally conclude . This is my definition of assessing the best MD but alas, what i go through he are some hardcore kamal fans who once again because their idol is attached to IR, they are supporting IR.

NOT EVEN A SINGLE WORD HAS BEEN SPOKEN ABOUT OTHER MDs other than Ramesh and Thirumaran.

For me other than IR,

MSV comes to mind immediately as he had given some time immemorial songs for kamal during his youthful formative years !
but noone seem to even know about such songs.

ITS BECAUSE MSV IS A MD OF YESTERYEAR AND A FORGOTTEN LEGEND

SAD SAD
From: umaramesh on Tue May 23 8:36:38 2006.

MSV associated with kamal when he was in the growing stage. Each song made him to establish and his character. No one can deny it(even kamal fans). MSV was fag end of his career where kamal got his star image, still MSV gave VAARUMAYIN NIRAM to the extent of NINAITHALE INNIKUM(I used extent of due to Rajini presence). We can compare with IR if MSV scored more number of movies .

it is natural that kamal fans wont like to see or appreciate his movies/songs when he was not in star image or growing stage.
I dont know how many of them would have seen AVARGAL/MOONDUR MUDICHU/SOLLATHAN NINAIKERAN/MANMATHA LEELAI/ABROOVA RAGANGAL/AVAL ORU THODARKATHI /MAROCHARITHRA ETC.

RAMESH
From: great on Tue May 23 8:37:34 2006.

Nakkeerar anne enna solla vareenga

Neengalum than Mahesh MD pathi sollala

Vidyasagar-a sollala

ARR pathi sollala

HJ pathi sollala
From: sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar on Tue May 23 8:37:37 2006.

mumbai express \ soora samhaaram \ sati leelaavathi

which is the wors film of the 3, in Kamal-IR combo ??

From: Nakeeran on Tue May 23 8:40:14 2006.

umaramesh wrote:

MSV associated with kamal when he was in the growing stage. Each song made him to establish and his character. No one can deny it(even kamal fans). MSV was fag end of his career where kamal got his star image, still MSV gave VAARUMAYIN NIRAM to the extent of NINAITHALE INNIKUM(I used extent of due to Rajini presence). We can compare with IR if MSV scored more number of movies .

it is natural that kamal fans wont like to see or appreciate his movies/songs when he was not in star image or growing stage.
I dont know how many of them would have seen AVARGAL/MOONDUR MUDICHU/SOLLATHAN NINAIKERAN/MANMATHA LEELAI/ABROOVA RAGANGAL/AVAL ORU THODARKATHI /MAROCHARITHRA ETC.

RAMESH

Another thoughtful post Ramesh. Fortunately, I could see both the earlier movies of kamal and today's virumandi etc etc
I think the melody in AADI VELLI THEDI UNNAI in Moondru mudichu , I havent found yet from IR till date !
Though I am a IR fan, I still cherish songs of other MDs especially MSV.
What you said is right. The kamal fans of today might not be willing to accept those movies which were released during his earlier days
THEY MAY NOT BE EVEN AWARE OF SUCH MOVIES

From: Nakeeran on Tue May 23 8:43:23 2006.

umaramesh wrote:

ramesh

SIMLA SPECIAL endru oru padam vandhadhu. Adhu Kamal rasigar mandrangalukku theriyumo theriyadho

It was composed by MSV only when he was at the fag end of his career ! but i could see the youth in his composition !

From: rami on Tue May 23 8:45:44 2006.

Ramesh, Nakkeeran,

We do appreciate the songs of VMS, NI, AR etc by MSV...
As u said, might be if MSV had done more films, it cud have been a better comparison. Since IR has done 8 out of 10 films with Kamal, its natural that he has more credit in his part... with memorable and ever lasting songs..

IR - Kamal combo was the best...

But u cannot compare IR and MSV based on this...

IMO, MSVs best was "Maalai pozhuthin mayakkathile"
A song which always leaves me in tears..
From: umaramesh on Tue May 23 8:46:32 2006.

Nakeeran

Still I will rate NAAYEERU OLI MAZHAYIL as best song sung by kamal composed by one more LEGEND. Most of the kamal fans wont be aware about this song.

Fans of particular star will support based on number of movies only.
same way if you ask who is best MD for shivaji&MGR ultimately every one will jump on MSV i.e they will forget KVM/Ramanathan .

Net net if particular MD gets more movies he gets more opportunity to prove .

From: Nakeeran on Tue May 23 8:50:24 2006.

umaramesh wrote:

Nakeeran

Still I will rate NAAYEERU OLI MAZHAYIL as best song sung by kamal composed by one more LEGEND. Most of the kamal fans wont be aware about this song.

Fans of particular star will support based on number of movies only.
same way if you ask who is best MD for shivaji&MGR ultimately every one will jump on MSV i.e they will forget KVM/Ramanathan .

Net net if particular MD gets more movies he gets more opportunity to prove .

True ramesh

I have also heard YAARUKKU YAAR SONDHAM NAAN SOLLAVA from V.Kumar I think! lovely song !
Kamal rasigargalay, indha paadal theriyuma ungalukku ?

From: rami on Tue May 23 8:53:16 2006.

film : Maalai soodava
MD - Devarajan
From: sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar on Tue May 23 8:53:16 2006.

"Next super star Ajit"

nakkeerar, your signature, shown above shows how bad your taste would be

so we discard your points about IR
From: rami on Tue May 23 8:53:43 2006.

sung by KJY and one of his best songs..
From: Sanjeevi on Tue May 23 10:26:40 2006.

Nakeeran @ pshyco

What is wrong with you man?.

Ilaiyaraja oru 1000 rupees vangikitta unna eemathittara

The poll look like

Which combo is best?

1) Air & Ship
2) Air & Aeroplane
3) Air & Train

From: ajithfederer on Tue May 23 10:44:45 2006.

Sanjeevi wrote:

Nakeeran @ pshyco ROTFL

What is wrong with you man?.

Ilaiyaraja oru 1000 rupees vangikitta unna eemathittara Laughing

The poll look like

Which combo is best?

1) Air & Ship
2) Air & Aeroplane
3) Air & Train

Laughing

From: svaisn on Tue May 23 11:08:31 2006.

Deleted
From: svaisn on Tue May 23 11:08:53 2006.

C;Mon

is there any competition going on?? Who creates the more number of threads

75% of KH movies were by IR...... Who else can give a better music....

On top of this... A Poll also for this.....

Change the name of the forum... to Come Lets Fight that is the sole aim right??

From: Nakeeran on Tue May 23 11:24:40 2006.

Sanjeevi wrote:

Nakeeran @ pshyco ROTFL

What is wrong with you man?.

Ilaiyaraja oru 1000 rupees vangikitta unna eemathittara Laughing

The poll look like

Which combo is best?

1) Air & Ship
2) Air & Aeroplane
3) Air & Train

Laughing

Sanjeevi Anne,

Romba thelivana alu neenga pola

Air & sea appdinu podanumilla ? English thagarara anne

Appadi enna Isaignaiyai avvalavu kuraichi potuteenga ? 100 rubaaai ella. 1000 kodee vanginaar

Ungalala mudinja edhavadhu urupadiya post pannunga parpom inga. Endha alavukku ungalidam sarakku irukku parpomay ?

From: Nakeeran on Tue May 23 11:29:33 2006.

Some time back I heard the song IRAIVAN IRANDU BOMMAIGAL SEIDHAAN THAAN VILAYADA

This is from UYARNDHAVARGAL another lovely movie from Kamal and Sujatha both deaf & dumb characters.

I havent heard such an emotional number from IR .

Incidentally, the composer is MSV only.
From: selvakumar on Tue May 23 11:47:44 2006.

sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar wrote:

"Next super star Ajit"

nakkeerar, your signature, shown above shows how bad your taste would be

so we discard your points about IR

What is the logic behind this comment sakala

We did explain here everyone the TRUE MEANING OF SUPERSTAR .. Right
From: villan007 on Tue May 23 12:03:35 2006.

sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar wrote:

"Next super star Ajit"

nakkeerar, your signature, shown above shows how bad your taste would be

so we discard your points about IR

...cud u pls eloborate sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar.......

and u hav no rights to comment on others taste..
From: ajithfederer on Tue May 23 12:06:12 2006.

sakala...ithu seri illeyae.......
From: terminator on Tue May 23 12:14:51 2006.

sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar wrote:

"Next super star Ajit"

nakkeerar, your signature, shown above shows how bad your taste would be

so we discard your points about IR

sakalakala vallavare enna ithu..
From: sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar on Tue May 23 12:16:53 2006.

MSV could hav been good at kamal film but IR was phenomenal.........but nakeran was painting a diff pic, i wantedto provoke him on his own way to make him accept th fact of IR

btw i know ajith is a good actor, personally i like ajith mooooooooooooore than the "Ilaya Thalaivali"

From: villan007 on Tue May 23 12:19:05 2006.

sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar wrote:

MSV could hav been good at kamal film but IR was phenomenal.........but nakeran was painting a diff pic, i wantedto provoke him on his own way to make him accept th fact of IR

btw i know ajith is a good actor, personally i like ajith mooooooooooooore than the "Ilaya Thalaivali"

cool cool

From: sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar on Tue May 23 12:19:12 2006.

btw u ppl din't bang on me, instead u decently reqested a reply from me.......this shows the quality of ajith fans.....(any pullarips ???!!!)
From: villan007 on Tue May 23 12:20:41 2006.

sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar wrote:

btw u ppl din't bang on me, instead u decently reqested a reply from me.......this shows the quality of ajith fans.....(any pullarips ???!!!)

..... light-ah.....
From: terminator on Tue May 23 12:21:41 2006.

we know ur intension.. but if people come and read, they will mistake it.. so we want a reply from u.. thats all..

From: terminator on Tue May 23 12:23:23 2006.

villan007 wrote:

sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar wrote:

btw u ppl din't bang on me, instead u decently reqested a reply from me.......this shows the quality of ajith fans.....(any pullarips ???!!!)

..... light-ah..... Razz

enakkum thaan..

From: sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar on Tue May 23 12:24:12 2006.

termi,

many pullarips !!!!(for me)

signing off.....

From: Nakeeran on Tue May 23 12:24:35 2006.

sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar wrote:

Oh appidaya !

Unga muyarchila vetri adainjeengala Sakalakakalaalak anne

Pala per kitta kuttu vangi irupeenga neenga. Pavam neenga.
Ungalai pondravargal ellam kamal fans endru solvadhu KAMALUKKU DHAAN KETTA PEYAR .

Ippadipatta rasigargalum thanakku irukirargal endru avar pullarithu povar .
Avarukendru oru intellectual group of fans irukaanga. Neenga yen peyarai kedukareenga. Avangalai naan thalai vanangugiren for having faith over their idol . Ana neenga ?????

From: ajithfederer on Tue May 23 12:27:34 2006.

nenjae nakeeteenga ....

sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar wrote:

btw u ppl din't bang on me, instead u decently reqested a reply from me.......this shows the quality of ajith fans.....(any pullarips ???!!!)
From: terminator on Tue May 23 12:32:06 2006.

sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar wrote:

termi,

many pullarips !!!!(for me)

signing off.....
From: ajithfederer on Tue May 23 12:33:34 2006.

sakala is a true kamal fan........
From: great on Tue May 23 12:36:41 2006.

NAKKEERAR ANNE THEERPU SOLLIYACHU

MSV IS THE BEST MD FOR KAMALHASSAN

NO APPEAL EVEN IF YOU GO TO SUPREME COURT THE CASE WILL NOT BE TAKEN.

Nakeerar anne you have kept the title as MSV Best music composer for Kamal Haasan

From: Nakeeran on Tue May 23 12:43:12 2006.

great wrote:

NAKKEERAR ANNE THEERPU SOLLIYACHU

MSV IS THE BEST MD FOR KAMALHASSAN

NO APPEAL EVEN IF YOU GO TO SUPREME COURT THE CASE WILL NOT BE TAKEN.

Nakeerar anne you have kept the title as MSV Best music composer for Kamal Haasan

Great Anne,

En ippadi colour coloura unarchi vasapadareenga

Naan onnumay sollalayay innum

Infact, I have listed some of the best movies of both MSV and IR and has only invited others for further discussion but most of the guys around here are SO UNILATERAL that they are not even willing to hear some of MSV classics

Idhu muraiya ,neengalay sollunga pls

From: ajithfederer on Tue May 23 12:43:20 2006.

nattamai theerpaa ithu....
From: Nakeeran on Tue May 23 12:56:56 2006.

KAMBAN EMAANDHAAN from Nizal nijamagiradhu is one of the evergreen hits of Kamal. Oru young kamalukku, idhai vida arumayana paadal kidaikuma ?

At the same time, I recollect Ennadi meenatchi from Ilamai oonjaladugiradhu !

both outstanding numbers from MSV and IR respectively
From: great on Tue May 23 13:27:57 2006.

Nakkerar anne its simple,

Lets get this way

If a person gets 95% in his subject like Maths, phys, chem and Bio in XII th stand

and gets 80 marks in English and Hindi

If you ask how much you got in main subject he would say 95%.
(its Illayaraja)

Though English and Hindi marks are required to add up to the total
(here its MSV) witout these his total would not be complete (kamals filmography)

Pothuma
From: kb on Tue May 23 13:29:58 2006.

great 12th result velila vantha effect unga postla theriyuthu.

From: Nakeeran on Tue May 23 13:32:42 2006.

great wrote:

Nakkerar anne its simple,

Lets get this way

If a person gets 95% in his subject like Maths, phys, chem and Bio in XII th stand

and gets 80 marks in English and Hindi

If you ask how much you got in main subject he would say 95%.
(its Illayaraja)

Though English and Hindi marks are required to add up to the total
(here its MSV) witout these his total would not be complete (kamals filmography)

Pothuma Wink

Konnuteenga anne

So unga kanippil, MSV music enbadhu verum ANCILLARY SUBJECTS dhaana anne ! neenga unmayilayay GREAT DHAAN

pazya kamal padangal paarka maateengala anne ?
parunga anne, unmai vilangum

From: great on Tue May 23 13:35:49 2006.

Ayyo ayyo unga alavukku ennakku ariva andavan kudukala

if i flunk in that ancillary subject, Govindha thaane

MSV is the best for KH

Nakkerar anne vaazha

avar kulam oNguga

avar needudi vaazha ellam valla eraivainai prarthikirean

From: Nakeeran on Tue May 23 13:39:30 2006.

great wrote:

Ayyo ayyo unga alavukku ennakku ariva andavan kudukala Banging Head

if i flunk in that ancillary subject, Govindha thaane Laughing

MSV is the best for KH Not Worthy

Nakkerar anne vaazha Not Worthy

avar kulam oNguga :noworthy:

avar needudi vaazha ellam valla eraivainai prarthikirean Not Worthy

Anne idhu too much...
too too much

( chandramukhi Rk stylil padikkavum )

Enna namma dialogue thiruppi namma kitte adikireenga

amma , notworthy notworthy podureenga.
Idayila E add pannunga pls.
Neenga romba isai nyanam ullavar anne. vaazga valamudan

From: Sanjeevi on Tue May 23 14:13:58 2006.

Nakeeran wrote:

Ungalala mudinja edhavadhu urupadiya post pannunga parpom inga. Endha alavukku ungalidam sarakku irukku parpomay ?

Sorry this time i did not give "uruppadi" post.

BTW any "uruppadi" post posted for you from others will become a waste answer automatically. Don't answering to you is mega "Uruppadi".

Nakeeran avargala purAna kAlam mudhal intha kAlam varai unga paramparaiyula ellArume ippadithAna
From: villan007 on Tue May 23 14:29:02 2006.

Sanjeevi wrote:

Nakeeran avargala purAna kAlam mudhal intha kAlam varai unga paramparaiyula ellArume ippadithAna

From: Nakeeran on Tue May 23 14:47:13 2006.

Sanjeevi wrote:

Nakeeran wrote:

Ungalala mudinja edhavadhu urupadiya post pannunga parpom inga. Endha alavukku ungalidam sarakku irukku parpomay ? Wink

Sorry this time i did not give "uruppadi" post.

BTW any "uruppadi" post posted for you from others will become a waste answer automatically. Don't answering to you is mega "Uruppadi".

Nakeeran avargala purAna kAlam mudhal intha kAlam varai unga paramparaiyula ellArume ippadithAna Very Happy

Sanjeevi anne,

Ungalidam enakku pidithathey indha gunam dhaan. Eppodhumay nagaichuvayodu thaan unga karuthukalai poduveenga

En anne, onnu ketkanum unga kitte . Eppavum IR pugaz paadinaa dhaan avarudaya Rasigar pattiyalil vara vendum endra critereona ??
Endha MDyaga irundhalum avar nanraaga isai amaithal paratta koodadha anne ? Enna namma IR kobichupara anne ?

From: kb on Tue May 23 14:51:22 2006.

aaha.. inga vera oru discussion nadakkuthaa..

i never heard people comparing MSV and IR.. gud to discuss. but i dont know much about MSV songs...

enaku therunja rendu vishayam..

samboo siva sambovum

naan thappu pannitaen maapuley thappu pannitaen

From: Nakeeran on Tue May 23 14:57:44 2006.

kb wrote:

aaha.. inga vera oru discussion nadakkuthaa..

i never heard people comparing MSV and IR.. gud to discuss. but i dont know much about MSV songs...

enaku therunja rendu vishayam..

samboo siva sambovum

naan thappu pannitaen maapuley thappu pannitaen

Anne,

MSV sir oru arumayana paadal Kamalukku koduthar

ENGEYUM EPPODHUM SANGETHAM SANDHOSHAM.

Indha padalin bodhu MSV's musical days were virtually over .

IMHO, this song was a perfect representation of Kamal DURING HIS YOUTHFUL DAYS !

Anaa namma kamal rasigargal ethaiellam vittu vittu latest songa rasikiranga. Siripu dhaan varudhu .

Kamal with a rap song in 1980 I think this movie was a musical hit

NINAITHALAY INIKKUM

From: Justice on Tue May 23 22:47:56 2006.

Sanjeevi wrote:

Nakeeran avargala purAna kAlam mudhal intha kAlam varai unga paramparaiyula ellArume ippadithAna

mighty sanjeevi malaiya asaika mudiyaathu

voted for the great IR
From: umaramesh on Wed May 24 1:19:45 2006.

Did shankar ganesh/chandrabose/V.kumar scored any movie for kamal. I think vijaya bhaskar composed one movie. beautiful number VANNUKU THANTHAI EVANNO.

Leave it , why shuld we break our head. I am convinced only IR gave best songs for kamal , rest of them did only cut and paste.

ramesh
From: umaramesh on Wed May 24 1:33:51 2006.

yes i can recollect two movies of shankar ganesh:

THAYILLAMAL NAN ILLAI- SONG NADIGANIN KATHALI NADAGAM ENNAID BY SPB- DAPPA PADAM. BUT SONG WAS SUPER HIT

NEEYA: beautiful number KATTIL MALAYEE KANDEN VENNILA .
I think main character against kamal was PAAMBU(SNAKE)

Ramesh

From: sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar on Wed May 24 1:46:22 2006.

Nakeeran wrote:

Oh appidaya !

Unga muyarchila vetri adainjeengala Sakalakakalaalak anne Laughing

Pala per kitta kuttu vangi irupeenga neenga. Pavam neenga.
Ungalai pondravargal ellam kamal fans endru solvadhu KAMALUKKU DHAAN KETTA PEYAR . Laughing

................

Nakkeerar Anne, rajaram anne appadinnu oru Anne irunthaaru, ippo aval illaatha kurai ungalaal theernthu pochchu

romba nanri Anne

From: rami on Wed May 24 2:08:45 2006.

great wrote:

Ayyo ayyo unga alavukku ennakku ariva andavan kudukala Banging Head

if i flunk in that ancillary subject, Govindha thaane Laughing

MSV is the best for KH Not Worthy

Nakkerar anne vaazha Not Worthy

avar kulam oNguga Not Worthy

avar needudi vaazha ellam valla eraivainai prarthikirean Not Worthy

I second great...

Add this to it..

Innum Best Heroine with Kamalnnu oru thread avar arambithu...

Athula.. Best heroine with Kamal - Sujatha (Sridevinnu namma sonna avarukku kobam varum) thaannu theerpu vazhangavum aandavana praarthikkiren

From: swathy on Wed May 24 2:16:15 2006.

Nakeeran wrote:

swathy wrote:

alwarpet_andavan wrote:

There is no question about it.
ILAIYARAAJA
End of discussion!

Ayyo pavam Swathy neenga. Unga ariyamaya ninacha siripu dhan varudhu Laughing

Mudhalla raja raja rajanu poteenga. Details ketta escapu ayuteenga Confused

Ippa AA soona commentukku thumbs up kodukareenga Laughing

Yen , vera edhuvum solla theriyalaya ! Embarassed

mannichidunga unga alavakku naan genius illainga.

ammavoda anbu than bestnnu sonna yen yedhukunnu kaaranam kekkuradhu madhiri thanga idhuvum siladhukku explanations thevai illai.

From: selvakumar on Wed May 24 2:22:49 2006.

NakeeRan,
SakaLa has made his stand very clear. Don't push him to the corner of coming up withsomething against ajith (simply coz of your replies)

The topic is about KAMAL & MD. But the poll is unnecessary. I think it should be KAMAL & HIS MDs.

I second SakaLa in this case. Please keep your personal kidding on others's post and opinions apart. If u continue that, then people will (unlike Sakala -- who was more generous in his approach) jump towards ajith (just coz that u like ajith)

Most of the KH fans discuss in a polite way and they never ever indulge in attack on other actors unless it is called for Please understand it and stick to the topic (& remove the poll)

From: Nakeeran on Wed May 24 3:18:24 2006.

swathy wrote:

Nakeeran wrote:

swathy wrote:

alwarpet_andavan wrote:

There is no question about it.
ILAIYARAAJA
End of discussion!

Ayyo pavam Swathy neenga. Unga ariyamaya ninacha siripu dhan varudhu Laughing

Mudhalla raja raja rajanu poteenga. Details ketta escapu ayuteenga Confused

Ippa AA soona commentukku thumbs up kodukareenga Laughing

Yen , vera edhuvum solla theriyalaya ! Embarassed

mannichidunga unga alavakku naan genius illainga.

ammavoda anbu than bestnnu sonna yen yedhukunnu kaaranam kekkuradhu madhiri thanga idhuvum siladhukku explanations thevai illai.

Ammavodda anbu pathi pesareengala neenga.

Oho adhu neenga dhaana. Edho oru idathil ennai IDIOT AVAN endru migavum PANBODUM , KANIVODUM, CULTURODUM kuripiteergalay, ANDHA SWATHY DHAANAY NEENGA !
Very good, orupuram Vivekanandar padam pottukolveenga for image building AND ON THE OTHER SIDE, YOU WILL ALSO CURSE OTHERS AS IDIOTS ETC.

Neenga migavum panbullavar dhaan Swathy . Keep it up

From: Nakeeran on Wed May 24 3:22:33 2006.

selvakumar wrote:

NakeeRan,
SakaLa has made his stand very clear. Don't push him to the corner of coming up withsomething against ajith (simply coz of your replies)

The topic is about KAMAL & MD. But the poll is unnecessary. I think it should be KAMAL & HIS MDs.

I second SakaLa in this case. Please keep your personal kidding on others's post and opinions apart. If u continue that, then people will (unlike Sakala -- who was more generous in his approach) jump towards ajith (just coz that u like ajith)

Most of the KH fans discuss in a polite way and they never ever indulge in attack on other actors unless it is called for Smile

Please understand it and stick to the topic (& remove the poll)

Selva Anne,

I have better things to do & not simply triggering 3rd grade guys like Sakalaakakakallaa whose only intention is to poke their nose on irrelevant threads and pass unwarranted comments.
I think he was forced to retreat because of reaction from others . else he would have continued to create disrepute for kamal followers by exposing himself.

On personal kidding, if you go through the posts, most of them WERE RESPONSES TO WHAT THEY WERE UTTERING TO ME !
SO, WHERE IS THE QUESTION OF KIDDING HERE ?

From: Nakeeran on Wed May 24 3:24:17 2006.

sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar wrote:

Nakeeran wrote:

Oh appidaya !

Unga muyarchila vetri adainjeengala Sakalakakalaalak anne Laughing

Pala per kitta kuttu vangi irupeenga neenga. Pavam neenga.
Ungalai pondravargal ellam kamal fans endru solvadhu KAMALUKKU DHAAN KETTA PEYAR . Laughing

................

Nakkeerar Anne, rajaram anne appadinnu oru Anne irunthaaru, ippo aval illaatha kurai ungalaal theernthu pochchu

romba nanri Anne Laughing

Look at the ignorance ! Who is this Rajaram to be compared with me. Can you pls enlighten me ?

From: great on Wed May 24 3:24:53 2006.

NakkeeRar anna vannakkam`Na

Innaikku day start agiducha

MSV vaazgha

Nakeerar vaazgha

From: Nakeeran on Wed May 24 3:28:23 2006.

rami wrote:

great wrote:

Ayyo ayyo unga alavukku ennakku ariva andavan kudukala Banging Head

if i flunk in that ancillary subject, Govindha thaane Laughing

MSV is the best for KH Not Worthy

Nakkerar anne vaazha Not Worthy

avar kulam oNguga Not Worthy

avar needudi vaazha ellam valla eraivainai prarthikirean Not Worthy

Oru threadil ennai KAZUDHAI ENDRU MARAIMUGAMAGA KURIPITTA RAMI DHANAY NEENGA. UNGAL KITTA PANBU EPPADI EDHIRPARKALAM.
Ungallukku eppavumay orginality kidayadhu pola. Always second someone or put thumbs up for someone .

If you are having limitations in analysing about music, better stay away or refrain instead of forming a cotorie to be a back up for others

If you really have any interest in participating in this thread, you should have cited some good songs of all MDs , leave alone IR and then come up with how you have concluded on IR. Pavam , onnum theryalana vitudunga pls

From: Nakeeran on Wed May 24 3:29:49 2006.

great wrote:

NakkeeRar anna vannakkam`Na

Innaikku day start agiducha

MSV vaazgha

Nakeerar vaazgha

Ozunga projecta mudinga great Anne

Adhenna namma stylay follow panreenga.

Indha vaazga , valarga ellam enakku than sondham
From: great on Wed May 24 3:30:48 2006.

Enna Nakeerar anne orey panbu, paasam nesam pathi pesureenga

Panbu = Nakeerar
From: Nakeeran on Wed May 24 3:32:39 2006.

great wrote:

Enna Nakeerar anne orey panbu, paasam nesam pathi pesureenga

Panbu = Nakeerar

Kusumu mannar Great annan avargalay

Innaiku stock market eppadi irukku ? erumuga alladhu downa ?
From: VENKIRAJA on Wed May 24 3:33:29 2006.

"கம்பன் ஏமந்தான் ....",

exxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxcellent!

"அண்ணாச்சி ஆடுறான்......."

ssssssssssssssssssssplendid!
(if this song would have featured in any ajit movie-waare waah)
From: rami on Wed May 24 3:34:07 2006.

Enakku originality kidayathu enru sonna Nakeerarukku Thanks
Thanks again for pointing out that
I have limitations in analysing about music..

So I wud like to stay away and refrain instead of forming a cotorie to be a back up for others ...

Bye ppl Enjoy..

From: Nakeeran on Wed May 24 3:37:35 2006.

rami wrote:

Enakku originality kidayathu enru sonna Nakeerarukku Thanks
Thanks again for pointing out that
I have limitations in analysing about music..

So I wud like to stay away and refrain instead of forming a cotorie to be a back up for others ...

Bye ppl Enjoy..

Buddhar eppodhu matravargalay KAZUDHAI endru kuripida chonnar. Adhai patri migavum samarthiyamaga avoid seivadhil irundhu therigiradhu ungal thiramai.
Vaazga neengal.

From: romio on Wed May 24 3:43:39 2006.

Ilayaraja/kamal/yesudas combo

Partha Vizhi Partha(Guna)

another one

Film - mahanadhi

sriranga ranga naadhanin paadham vandhanam seyyadi
sridhaevi ranga naayagi naamam sandhadham solladi
From: Nakeeran on Wed May 24 3:54:36 2006.

I love watching Kanmani anbodu kadhalan

A very poetic song . IR gave the Church organ effect all through the song and created another wonder !
From: romio on Wed May 24 4:01:04 2006.

Yup That was Great Song
From: selvakumar on Wed May 24 4:54:34 2006.

WHO STARTED IT

NakeeRAn,
Don't act smart.. I am following this thread right from the first page.
Here is the explanation

1. First, You ridiculed SWATHY for saying her OPINION.. that IR is the best. She is a fan of IR. She has EVERY RIGHT TO CONVEY HER THOUGHT. She didn't explain it.. coz everyone knows (IR albums) that she loves the works of IR and she has accepted that she doesn't have music knowledge. That means she never made any unwarranted statement. But

what was your reply to her.. You are ridiculing every post of her.. "நீங்க என்ன பெரிய ஐன்ஸ்டீனா? மத்தவங்களை குறை சொல்லுறதை விட்டுட்டு அவங்களோட கருத்தை மதிங்க.. பிடிக்கலேன்னா, விளக்கம் கொடுங்க! அதவிட்டுட்டு நிங்க "நேத்து தயிர்சாதம் சாப்டீங்க, இன்னைக்கு சாம்பார் சாதம் சாப்பிடுங்க.. அய்யோ.. உங்கள நினைச்சா சிரிப்பு வருது" சொல்லுறது நல்லா இல்லை

2. Just HAVE A LOOK AT YOUR REPLY TO RAMI HERE (who was posting on IR's works like HeyRam)

http://forumhub.mayyam.com/hub/viewtopic.php?t=7044&postdays=0&postorder=asc&start=30

Ain't you not insulting her withyour .........? post....... It was YOU WHO SPOILED THE DECENT ARGUEMENT AND BASHED IR RIGHT FROM THE STARTING PAGE.. Now, I doubt whether you have created this thread JUST TO SPOIL THE GOOD NAME OF IR.. (this happens with all your responses to IR..)

3. SAKALA is a COOL GUY.. He is humble and polite and restricts himself to decent arguements without personal attack.. You have provoked him with your BASHING ON IR (through your reply to RAMI's post)

Check your Response to SWATHY to the very first page and THE PREVIOUS PAGE.

P.S: Don't insult others just coz that they convey their opinion.

Other people are just asking you simple question.. reg your threads.. (Seems you are creating threads for RIDICULING LEGENDS LIKE KH, IR etc

Your threads
1. MOHANLAL BETTER THAN KH (Even hardcore fans of ML will accept that the comparison was odd)

2. IR VS MSV VS ARR >> Your Threads (indirect ones) for this

2.1. YOUR POSTS on MD FOR RAJINI in TFM section
2.2. THIS THREAD..

IMO,
It is like asking GAVASKAR(MSV) WAS GOOD AT THAT TIME..
SACHIN (IR) is still playing.
ARR (Lara) is still playing.

But SACHIN is more effective towards some teams.. Similar to THAT IR

WAS

THE GOD WHEN IT COMES TO KAMAL.. (THE MAJECTIC MAN .. be iT GODFATHER @ NAYAGAN, HEY RAM etc)

"பூக்கடைக்கு விளம்பரம் தேவையில்லை"

Everyone is conveying this message to you only !

FULL STOP
From: rami on Wed May 24 5:06:25 2006.

Thanks Selva
From: Nakeeran on Wed May 24 5:15:26 2006.

Selva Anne,

Thanks for the detaild analysis about me.
But you have also SMARTLY , UNILATERALLY avoided the DEGORATORY COMMENTS PASSED BY THEM IN ANOTHER THREAD CALLING ME AS :

1. IDIOT
2. KAZUDHAI

Do you have any explanations for this ?

wish to hear from you as you seem to champion their cause as a mediator !

Now, lets take up this thread itself as a case :

CAN YOU PROVE ON ANY POST , THAT I HAD RIDICULED IR ? All I was saying to have a look at other MDs especially MSV who had been instrumental in giving some wonderful songs during Kamal's formative years
I am not sure whether you were born during ( me as well but I have been fortunate to see and hear those songs which make me come out with confidence that atleast there was a MD by name Mr. MSV who did equally well.

ALL HUBBERS HERE HAVE THE UNILATERAL THINKING . IR IS THE BEST . WHY ? IN MY OPINION, THIS IS ABSOLUTE PREJUDICE.

Some of the respondents here even DID NOT WANT TO MENTION ABOUT OTHER MDs BECAUSE THEY HAVENT HEARD THOSE SONGS YET !

The tamash that you have been playing with me in Mohanlal thread is history. WHAT KIND OF JOKES THAT YOU HAVE PLAYED OVER ME ARE ALL RECORDED FOR YOUR EASY REFERENCE. Pls visit the thread and you will get EXPOSED.

Despite all your childish pranks, I have been calling you respectfully as ANNE only AS I STILL CONSIDER YOU AS ANNE

Onnu nichayam Selva Anne .

Ellarum nalla oru groupa , collectiva form panni irukkeenga. Yaaravadhu oru thread open panninaa , udanay PM anupuveenga and then decide to target one individual !

I really appreciate it .

By the way, instead being a naatamai, why dont you come up with something really useful in this thread if you have any idea on other MDs who composed for Kamal ?

I am looking forward to it.
From: Nakeeran on Wed May 24 5:43:29 2006.

rami wrote:

Thanks Selva

Selva Anne

Idhai thaan naan kuripiten satru munnar ! paarunga indha postai !
Neenga edhaavadhu post pannuveenga . Udanay with emoticon varum ( kaithattal ) alladu ( SIRIPPU ) alladhu parattukkal

Idhai thaan naan groupism endru kuripitten

Parugan thaana varudhu parunga

Can I list the other faithfulls of your group ? Vendam. Lets stick to the topic pls.
From: selvakumar on Wed May 24 6:28:53 2006.

19569

Nakeean, NAAAATTU AAMAI ! ( I wanted to avoid personal attack .. but you have referred me with words like naattaamai.. so couldn't resist)

We go from here.

FIRST,

Quote:

CAN YOU PROVE ON ANY POST , THAT I HAD RIDICULED IR ?

Please REVISIT YOUR POSTS IN RK - MD COMBO thread.. The way you have bashed him as a BIG HEADED PERSON.. MaRanthuducha !! The posts are still there. We have ALSO SAVED IT. Just for YOUR REFERENCE

I don't need a single post to prove it.. coz I have several posts.

Quote:

1. IDIOT
2. KAZUDHAI
Do you have any explanations for this ?

"Paambin kaaL paaMbariyum" IT WAS YOU WHO RIDICULED THE HUBBERS AS SHORT - SIGHTED, NARROW MINDED.. Compared to that their comments are mere reply to YOU..

DON'T ACT SMART.. DON'T ACT AS IF YOU ARE PERFECT IN ALL DEPARTMENTS.

"IYATHA PAARTHU ILICHATHAAM.. etho......."

Quote:

IN MY OPINION, THIS IS ABSOLUTE PREJUDICE.

Read your explanation again.. IMO..........That means just like you MANY HERE FEEL THAT HAILING MSV IS ALSO A (compared with the no. of projects these two had done) from ALL GENERATIONS OF TAMIL CINEMA

Nakeera I don't care whether you have saved my jokes on you.. FOR YOU, PLEASE SAVE THIS POST ALSO.. for your reference

We have also saved some of your pathetic replies to NILAVU'S QUERIES.. WITHOUT KNOWING ANYTHING ON ML, You said something which was

which were worser than THE CHILDISH PRANK
From: Nakeeran on Wed May 24 7:10:21 2006.

Selva anne

ippadi color colora unarchi vasapadama edhavadhu matra MD patri sollunga. Atleast IR patriyavadhu sollunga.
Neenga eppavum oru muzu pakatha pidikireenga anaa ulla enna irukkunu padichi paartha ------- ????????

Neenga sonna andha Nilavupriyar pavam marubadiyum Mohanlal threadukku vandhaar periya savaloda . Anaa pavam , naan kodutha oru movie referecai parthu avar adharku appuram ESCAPU !!
Even before I could summarise my posts on ML, it was locked and you all CELEBRATED .

Anyway, if you anything positive to say here about music, pls do it Anne.

Engay sollunga parpom pls .
From: great on Wed May 24 7:38:59 2006.

From: Nakeeran on Wed May 24 7:56:38 2006.

selvakumar wrote:

Quote:

IN MY OPINION, THIS IS ABSOLUTE PREJUDICE.

Read your explanation again.. IMO..........That means just like you MANY HERE FEEL THAT HAILING MSV IS ALSO A ROTFL

(compared with the no. of projects these two had done) from ALL GENERATIONS OF TAMIL CINEMA
:

Selva anne,

en sitrarivuku puriyavillai. Enna solreenga ? IR msvyavida niraya potar Kamalukku. Adhanal avar dhan best. Idhu dhan unga conclusiona Anne ?!
Sirippu varudhu enakku. So in your assessment, somebody who does more movies is the best ever ! pramadham anne

SOMEONE WHO GIVES MORE QUALITY SONGS ALSO SHOULD BE CONSIDERED. This is my Humble opinion anne

In terms of quality , I dont think MSV was far behind IR on Kamal movies .

Periya list irukku anne. Atleast I have listed most of the movies of MSV but from your side , only dishoom dishoom dishoom

From: selvakumar on Wed May 24 8:09:39 2006.

NakeeRa,

We have to analyse everything.. KAMAL did many movies with IR.

This shows that many directors preferred him over MSV.

Unfortunately, MSV couldnot regain his lost form. (place)

That is why we are telling that MSV is a GAVASKAR and IR is sachin.

idu uNga PERIYA ARIVUKKU eppa puriyumoe..

You can give very few quality songs from MSV - KH combination.

But We can give several quality songs from IR combination.

coz IR tried several things while he worked with KH.. Be it

KUTHU - ANNAATHA AADURAAR endless.......
MELODY - POONGATRU en paer sollum , nee paarthe etc
COMEDY SONG - SOME MOVIES.

etc

I MEAN IR - KH COMBINATION was more versatile whereas for MSV it was

From: Nakeeran on Wed May 24 8:35:21 2006.

selvakumar wrote:

NakeeRa,

We have to analyse everything.. KAMAL did many movies with IR.

This shows that many directors preferred him over MSV. Crying or Very sad

Unfortunately, MSV couldnot regain his lost form. (place)

That is why we are telling that MSV is a GAVASKAR and IR is sachin.

idu uNga PERIYA ARIVUKKU eppa puriyumoe..

You can give very few quality songs from MSV - KH combination.

But We can give several quality songs from IR combination.

coz IR tried several things while he worked with KH.. Be it

KUTHU - ANNAATHA AADURAAR endless.......
MELODY - POONGATRU en paer sollum , nee paarthe etc
COMEDY SONG - SOME MOVIES.

etc

I MEAN IR - KH COMBINATION was more versatile whereas for MSV it was
Crying or Very sad

Nice to see this Anne !

you said everyone preferred IR over MSV & ur theory is based on the fact that Kamal did more movies with IR .

During the formative years of Kamal, it was MSV and other composers who did for him. This period I mean the early 70s to the end 70s ( probably 78 or 79 )

It was MSV who gave gem of compositions to Kamal for :

1. Apoorva ragangal
2. Avargal
3. Nizal nijamagiradhu
4. Manmadha leelai
5. Moondru mudichu
6. Aval oru thodar kathai
7. Uyarndhavargal

and by the end 70s he did :

1. Varumayin niram sigappu
2. Simla special
3. Idhu irava pagala ( Dont remember the movie )
4. Saval

Like you said , it was not that directors preferred IR over MSV.

PLS NOTE THAT BY THAT TIME, MSV ERA WAS COMING TO AN END . I mean the late 70s.

BUT STILL HE COULD COME UP WITH AN OUTSTANDING MOVIE CALLED NINAITHALAY INIKKUM

This movie was released when MSV was at the fag end of his career. After this he didnt compose many movies.

PL APPRECIATE ONE FACT. NO ONE CAN BE THE CHAMPION ALWAYS . THERE WILL BE A SUCCESSOR TO EVERYONE IN LIFE.

IT WAS IR WHO SUCCEEDED MSV AND HE WAS RULING LIKE AN EMPEROR IN THE 80s AND UP TO MID 90S.

Naturally, when some one is getting aged and TIRED after a MAGNIFICIENT MUSICAL JOURNEY, MSV should be admired for his contributions to kamal movies when he was young and was coming up in life.

What you said was RIGHT IN ONE WAY. MSV WAS LIKE GAVASKAR, HAVING PLAYED A LOOOOOOOOONG INNINGS AND RETIRED GRACEFULLY.
TODAY WE SEE SACHIN. BUT IT DOESNT MEAN THAT GAVASKAR WAS INFERIOR TO SACHIN IN ANYWAY.

This is what I expected from all the Dfers here AND NOT PURE ONE SIDED THEORY THAT IR IS THE BEST ETC

From: selvakumar on Wed May 24 8:46:59 2006.

But unfortunately SACHIN REMAINS AS THE "GOD OF CRICKET"

whereas GAVASKAR is still prefers to PLAY A VERY LONNNNNNNG INNINGS rather than what is much needed as per the dynamic MUSIC WORLD.

MSV gave those music in his period. He never came out of it.

Whereas, IR still rules .. be it 80's or 90's or THE NEW MILLENIUM..

Be it HEYRAAM or SINGAARAVELAN or ABOORVA SAGODARARGAL

IR gave music that will suit different set of audience (beyond generation gap)

whereas MSV operated within his own circle. and he never came out of it.

Ask any young boy BOYS generation.. Definitly he will enjoy ARR style of songs.. But at the same he would love to hear IR evergreen melodies.
It still rules beyond generations.whereas in the case of MSV
From: svaisn on Wed May 24 9:00:44 2006.

what a diplomatic fight.......

Cool... No one is abusing any one directly.... but behind the words everything is explicit b

Nakkeran,
None of us here deny that MSV songs were good for KH.... But the question is who is better.... and then the obvious choice would be IR.....

Just compile IR-KH collection in a MP3.... start listening,,/...... than u will coe to lknow the VERSATALITY which these guys are talking about.....

Point out on Duet likke - Nee paartha paarvaikk
Nee orui kaathal, Andhi mazhai..... Poongaatru unn per, ABCD nee vaasi, Neela kuyile solai kuyile, Unna Vida, Gemaniyin sen then malare.,.... OMG the list is endless..

Folk songs like: annathey aduraar, singari sarakku, vaan pole vannam klondu......

Matter Songs Nila kaayuthu, nethu raathiri, p[on meni, poo potta thavani, vanitha mani.......

Melody: enna satham intha nera, kanne kalaimaane, naanaga naan illa, kanmaniye pesu....

Beats: pottu veitha kaathal thittam., rum bum bum, p-eru vechaalum vekkamaa.....

Your Highness, TRhis is what they call as versatalikty.......

I ake y point clear, MSV isgood..... for KH
but IR is the Best
From: Hulkster on Wed May 24 9:30:47 2006.

I will not get into this argument but i will have to say MSV did give some innovative songs in ninaithaalay inikkum and some soulful melodies for kamal in his pre star days...IR is more apt because he gave alot of varities.

WCM Melody - Andi Mazhai Pozhiguruthu
Hard rock indian koothu song - Varuthu Varuthu
Classical Music - Nadha Vinodha
Tamil folk melodies - Onna Vida
Different genre melody - Poo poothadu, Nee Paartha
Racey songs(intro) - Raja Kaiyai Veicha
Hip Hop(disco style) Racey songs - Illamai Itho Itho

theres alot to name but i just cant really find the time to put all of them...ARR himself has done brilliantly for kamal...some of ARR's soothing melodies in thenali and the western and indian rural styled folk songs in Indian were also interesting and innovative. So far ARR has never disappointed in a kamal movie although ARR's best songs are usually varied with no significance on a actor....same goes for IR who at times reserves his innovative best for Kamal...
From: Nakeeran on Wed May 24 12:54:44 2006.

Hulk

I think ARR was outstanding in INDIAN . The songs were heard for looooooooong time.
From: great on Wed May 24 13:21:07 2006.

Nakeeran wrote:

Hulk

I think ARR was outstanding in INDIAN . The songs were heard for looooooooong time.

Man !!! what is ur stand . Do you want us to accept MSV is the best for Kamal Hassan if so cant we adjust for Nakeerar anne !!!

Whatever you say is perfectly rite !!!

Who will forgot the golden melodies rendered by MSV.
From: villan007 on Wed May 24 13:22:25 2006.

Nakeeran wrote:

Hulk

I think ARR was outstanding in INDIAN . The songs were heard for looooooooong time.

Instead of IR , MSV cud've been in u r avatar
From: ab_123 on Wed May 24 16:09:03 2006.

IR and KH!

IMO, the quaity of movies in the 80s, for the most part, vs these days, was better. That might be another reason why the music was also more memorable.
From: Justice on Wed May 24 16:26:55 2006.

Nakeeran wrote:

Hulk

I think ARR was outstanding in INDIAN . The songs were heard for looooooooong time.

IR was outstanding^10 in 99% of his movies with Kamal. I know you. Aren't we experiencing the effect of your patriotism toward ARR. You want to argue that ARR is the most suited for Kamal but you know that'll be innapropriate. Now you are trying to prove us MSV was the most suited for Kamal. Shall I remind you that we are able to detect problems. Your problem is that you will do anything to bury IR's reputation. We aren't as stupid as you think.
From: nickraman on Thu May 25 0:55:32 2006.

Mumbai Xpress (hindi-tamil) as well as Mouna Raagam
From: umaramesh on Thu May 25 1:19:29 2006.

Selva
[b]whereas GAVASKAR is still prefers to PLAY A VERY LONNNNNNNG INNINGS rather than what is much needed as per the dynamic MUSIC WORLD.

MSV gave those music in his period.He never came out of it

What are you talking. MSV not come out of the circle. THE ONE WHO INVENTED LIGHT MUSIC FROM CLASSICAL SCORE. That is big evolution in terms of creativity. As said by nakeeran you guys not wiling to appreciate or listen other MD's.

Okay. You heard songs of VENNIRA AADAI/KARNAN/PUDHIYA PARAVAI/AARATHIL ORUVAN/ANBE VAA/ULAGAM SUTTRUM VALIBAN/
NEJIL OOR AALAYAM ETC . You know how effectively MSV used Jazz rhythem in his music? Try to understand that each MD has his own style. You need to listen all these and understand how effectively he mixed different style in his composistion then comment. Dont comment just like that he never came out of it.

MSV never proclaimed that he did symphony kind of music which was not released even after decade?

What happened to his dynamism when ARR stormed TFM with one film? Every one knows what quality IR is up to nowadays.

Dont tell just like that HE IS TENDULKAR. YOU KNOW TENDULKAR IS OUT OF FORM NOW AND EVERY ONE IS WAITING FOR HIS RETIREMENT. (GRACEFULLY)

ramesh
From: villan007 on Thu May 25 2:04:57 2006.

umaramesh wrote:

YOU KNOW TENDULKAR IS OUT OF FORM NOW AND EVERY ONE IS WAITING FOR HIS RETIREMENT. (GRACEFULLY)
ramesh
From: great on Thu May 25 2:10:55 2006.

umaramesh wrote:

YOU KNOW TENDULKAR IS OUT OF FORM NOW AND EVERY ONE IS WAITING FOR HIS RETIREMENT. (GRACEFULLY)
ramesh

Pirapu Irappu vazhkayil sagagam !!!!

Inbam thumban vazhkayil undu.

We humans cannot be consistent all along

Tendulkar has proved his potential and has made the country proud which nobody can decline.

Dont you guyz think its funny saying MSV is the best combo for KH when MSV has done only few movies with KH. Here i am not talking about the quality .

all

From: Hulkster on Thu May 25 2:17:09 2006.

umaramesh wrote:

Selva
[b]whereas GAVASKAR is still prefers to PLAY A VERY LONNNNNNNG INNINGS rather than what is much needed as per the dynamic MUSIC WORLD.

MSV gave those music in his period.He never came out of it

What are you talking. MSV not come out of the circle. THE ONE WHO INVENTED LIGHT MUSIC FROM CLASSICAL SCORE. That is big evolution in terms of creativity. As said by nakeeran you guys not wiling to appreciate or listen other MD's.

Okay. You heard songs of VENNIRA AADAI/KARNAN/PUDHIYA PARAVAI/AARATHIL ORUVAN/ANBE VAA/ULAGAM SUTTRUM VALIBAN/
NEJIL OOR AALAYAM ETC . You know how effectively MSV used Jazz rhythem in his music? Try to understand that each MD has his own style. You need to listen all these and understand how effectively he mixed different style in his composistion then comment. Dont comment just like that he never came out of it.

MSV never proclaimed that he did symphony kind of music which was not released even after decade? Laughing

What happened to his dynamism when ARR stormed TFM with one film? Every one knows what quality IR is up to nowadays.

Dont tell just like that HE IS TENDULKAR. YOU KNOW TENDULKAR IS OUT OF FORM NOW AND EVERY ONE IS WAITING FOR HIS RETIREMENT. (GRACEFULLY)

ramesh

Uma akka, the symphony is a reality and has been confirmed by sir john scott..the conductor of his symphony..and it is in the rpo's list of film credits..this is not a claim and its proven...the reason why raja never released is explained in john scotts website.

MSV is a genius in his own right churning out brilliant melodies and at times different styles of music...engae nimmadhi is a masterpiece and he has also given us songs like mayakkama kalakkama...the tune and orchestration is just mesmerising. But when you want to talk about a even more wider range of versatility and more input you can talk abt IR...if you were to describe IR in terms of MSV...a more versatile and more WCM styled MSV is what i would say.

From: NOV on Thu May 25 2:22:02 2006.

neenga pOdura sandaiyila En MSV'a izhukkareenga?
He doesnt need to prove anything to anybody and neither does his fans.

the biggest joke I read here was youngsters don't know/like MSV songs. adhunaala thaan todays MDs are remixing all MSV songs like as if there was no tomorrow.

avara vittudungalEn please.

From: NOV on Thu May 25 2:24:13 2006.

Hulkster wrote:

But when you want to talk about a even more wider range of versatility and more input you can talk abt IR...if you were to describe IR in terms of MSV...a more versatile and more WCM styled MSV is what i would say.

a 19 year old boy commenting on the genius of MSV.

this is probably what someone meant by youngsters not knowing MSV

True MSV fans, nay music fans, MUST stay away from this silly argument.

From: great on Thu May 25 2:25:24 2006.

NOV wrote:

avara vittudungalEn please.

NOV we are not badmouthing MSV ,we know this genius but when it come to Kamalhassan movies there is no second thought its IR who steals the show.

From: Hulkster on Thu May 25 2:26:04 2006.

NOV wrote:

neenga pOdura sandaiyila En MSV'a izhukkareenga? Shocked

He doesnt need to prove anything to anybody and neither does his fans.

the biggest joke I read here was youngsters don't know/like MSV songs. adhunaala thaan todays MDs are remixing all MSV songs like as if there was no tomorrow. Rolling Eyes

avara vittudungalEn please.

Yeah he has already proven himself...naanum MSV paatai rasikkiravan thaan although i like KV Mahadevan more(perhaps his usage of indian raagas interests me). I guess this fight started when someone might have praised MSV to the extent of angering the IR fans....and this itself boiled over into MSV vs IR fight...ARRai vittu veichathae periya vishayam..

From: Hulkster on Thu May 25 2:31:07 2006.

NOV wrote:

Hulkster wrote:

a 19 year old boy commenting on the genius of MSV. Banging Head

this is probably what someone meant by youngsters not knowing MSV Rolling Eyes

True MSV fans, nay music fans, MUST stay away from this silly argument. Mad

isai vayasakku kattupaduvethu ellei...isai keika ishtam irunthaal athu yentha roobathil irunthaalum keikulaam..

Naan thaan sollitaenae..im not downgrading MSV...if you read my comments again im just saying IR is a more advanced version of MSV...MSV is of course the most versatile composer in those days..from the motivational and racey music of MGR's intro songs to sweet and evergreen melodies in sivaji movies..he has done it all....Hello miss hello miss engae poraenge...is a classic westernisation of a indian song...his usage of violins and flute in his melodies is what impresses me most...

From: rami on Thu May 25 2:35:20 2006.

NOV wrote:

True MSV fans, nay music fans, MUST stay away from this silly argument.

NOV, I think u misunderstood..

MSV and IR are two separate legends and are not comparable... Both are best in their own ways...

Can anyone compare Aboorva Raagangal with Sindhu Bhairavi
Music lovers love both...

But here the topic is "Best MD for KH".. As MSV has relatively a few movies with KH, when compared with IR, the comparison goes onesided towards IR.

But this point is not understood by Thiruvalar Nakkeerar..
From: selvakumar on Thu May 25 2:57:02 2006.

Ramesh,
First of all, My opinion is based on IR - KH combo based on the number of albums and the quality of music this combo has given.

Compared to that, MSV - KH combo looks odd. If you could read the previous pages, you can understand the point. My intention here is : To prove the "BEST" part associated with KH - IR combo over KH - MSV combo.

This is not IR vs MSV (just like how you people were doing in RK thread too)

I don't want to compare these two legends. I don't have anyone as my favorite MD. I enjoy all type of songs. I can comment on the greatness associated with this combo.

At the same time, if u ask me MSV's versatile nature with the legends like MGR, SHIVAJI etc I will agree with you definitly.

But with KH, The question is out of the blue. Suddenly an atmosphere was created here to RIDICULE IR'S WORKS WITH KH with the works of MSV. As per the thread title, IR - KH IS THE BEST.

Any neutral observer will agree with it. I am batting for IR - KH and not MSV VS IR.

Reg your comments on the form of Sachin, Can you name anyone in the INDIAN team who is performaing consistently nowadays?

Can anyone surpass the RECORD of the GOD OF CRICKET?

Just like that, be it ARR OR anyone.. no one CAN BREAK THAT RECORD..

Even if KH wants to go with the same for any new MD, Do u think he can break the ACHIVEMENTS OF THIS COMBO?

YOu are pulling me towards IR VS MSV.. (I was just replying to a post which was made with this intention and which was ridiculing IR to the core. It is my reply)

I am not here for MSV vs IR. bUt for IR - KH.. Hope you got it !
From: umaramesh on Thu May 25 3:15:57 2006.

Ramesh,
First of all, My opinion is based on IR - KH combo based on the number of albums and the quality of music this combo has given.

Compared to that, MSV - KH combo looks odd. If you could read the previous pages, you can understand the point. My intention here is : To prove the "BEST" part associated with KH - IR combo over KH - MSV combo.

This is not IR vs MSV (just like how you people were doing in RK thread too)

I don't want to compare these two legends. I don't have anyone as my favorite MD. I enjoy all type of songs. I can comment on the greatness associated with this combo.

At the same time, if u ask me MSV's versatile nature with the legends like MGR, SHIVAJI etc I will agree with you definitly.

But with KH, The question is out of the blue. Suddenly an atmosphere was created here to RIDICULE IR'S WORKS WITH KH with the works of MSV. As per the thread title, IR - KH IS THE BEST.

Any neutral observer will agree with it. I am batting for IR - KH and not MSV VS IR.

Reg your comments on the form of Sachin, Can you name anyone in the INDIAN team who is performaing consistently nowadays?

Can anyone surpass the RECORD of the GOD OF CRICKET?

Just like that, be it ARR OR anyone.. no one CAN BREAK THAT RECORD..

Even if KH wants to go with the same for any new MD, Do u think he can break the ACHIVEMENTS OF THIS COMBO?

YOu are pulling me towards IR VS MSV.. (I was just replying to a post which was made with this intention and which was ridiculing IR to the core. It is my reply)

I am not here for MSV vs IR. bUt for IR - KH.. Hope you got it !

Dear Selva
I replied you because you mentioned current generation not listening his music and he is within his circle. I just wants to clarify that his creations are evergreen. You can notice that I have only written that people are not listening old movies of kamal. That's it. I never compared MSV with any one. You only started.

coming back to tendular issue you forgot Rahu dravid, he is more consisten than Tendulkar often played crucial innings. He dont have flamboyant style that tendulkar has.

ramesh
From: selvakumar on Thu May 25 3:27:15 2006.

Ramesh,
Yes.. I agree that all the works of MSV are evergreen.

But the topic is not releated to that. The topic is on which combo is the BEST !

Is it ?
1. IR - KH
2. MSV - KH
etc

Just because of the fact that we are supporting the IR - KH combo, that doesn't mean that we have not heard the songs of MSV (atleast for KH)

It is so weird to see people commenting on AGE factor to appreciate the works of an MD.

Anyone can comment on the goodness or .. associated with the works of an MD.

Quote:

I replied you because you mentioned current generation not listening his music and he is within his circle. I just wants to clarify that his creations are evergreen

You got the point. Just like how ARR took the leaf away from IR.. Just like that IR took the leaf away from MSV.. Just like IR, MSV too couldn't live upto it.

But if we consider the COMBO FACTOR ALONE, I WOULD DEFINITLY SAY THAT IR - KH IS THE BEST AND WILL REMAIN AS THE BEST

Quote:

I never compared MSV with any one. You only started.

Please read the previous pages.. esp comments of Nakeeran.. I didn't start MSV - IR.. Mine was a mere reply. But got a reply for that from you
Again, I stress... I DIDN'T START THAT IN THIS THREAD. I JUST FOLLOWED IT

Reg Dravid issue, SACHIN CAN MAKE A COMEBACK AT ANYTIME.. UNLIKE GAVASKAR who is RETIRED
From: umaramesh on Thu May 25 3:55:35 2006.

Selva

Gavaskar retired gracefuly after winning the BENSON&HEDGES and clearly due to his captaincy and planning. When he retired people asked why he is retiring? But PAVAM tendulkar everybody says(even ex cricketer and fan of sachin) he cannot get back his old rhythem and can survive.

ramesh

From: villan007 on Thu May 25 4:04:02 2006.

umaramesh wrote:

Gavaskar retired gracefuly after winning the BENSON&HEDGES and clearly due to his captaincy and planning. When he retired people asked why he is retiring? But PAVAM tendulkar everybody says(even ex cricketer and fan of sachin) he cannot get back his old rhythem and can survive. Laughing

only u say this dude

From: villan007 on Thu May 25 4:07:09 2006.

umaramesh wrote:

Gavaskar retired gracefuly

news to me

my grandpa used to say he was literlaly kicked out of the team
From: Nakeeran on Thu May 25 4:12:33 2006.

selvakumar wrote:

I don't have anyone as my favorite MD. I enjoy all type of songs. I can comment on the greatness associated with this combo.

[quote selvakumar]But unfortunately SACHIN REMAINS AS THE "GOD OF CRICKET"

whereas GAVASKAR is still prefers to PLAY A VERY LONNNNNNNG INNINGS rather than what is much needed as per the dynamic MUSIC WORLD.

MSV gave those music in his period. He never came out of it.

Whereas, IR still rules .. be it 80's or 90's or THE NEW MILLENIUM..

Be it HEYRAAM or SINGAARAVELAN or ABOORVA SAGODARARGAL

IR gave music that will suit different set of audience (beyond generation gap)

whereas MSV operated within his own circle. and he never came out of it.

Ask any young boy BOYS generation.. Definitly he will enjoy ARR style of songs.. But at the same he would love to hear IR evergreen melodies.
It still rules beyond generations.whereas in the case of MSV [/quote]

Selva Anne,

Pathingala unga rendu comments in just 2 days !

On top you have mentioned that YOU DONT HAVE ANY FAVOURITE MD.
but look at the way you have WORSHIPPED IR and DEGRADED MSV .
In a way, enakku ungal karuthukalai parthal sirippu varugiradhu adhey samayam MIGAVUM VARUTHAMGA IRUKIRADHU.

JUST GO THROUGH WHAT YOU HAVE UTTERED YESTERDAY ABOUT MSV.

You have mentioned that MSV operated within his circle and never came out of it
Have you ever heard songs like :

1.Ulagamengum oray mozhi ( I have to mention the movie name for you to get enlightened - NADODEE )
2. Malar edhu un kangal than endru solvenade ( For your information Isainyani Ilayaraji and GKV were part of this elite composition and the movie was Avalukendru oru manam )
3. Engeyum eppodhum sangeetham ( gave a new dimension to Kamal's youth )
4. The entire movie Vennira aadai ( extensive usage of western instruments )
5. Pudhiya paravai - ENGAY NIMMADHI itself will speak volumes of his BGM
6. ULAGAM SUTRUM VALIBAN - Pls see this movie. I CANT ANYTHING BEYOND THIS. YOU CAN LEARN A LOT ABOUT MSV
7. Karnan - Classical usage of hindustani instruments ( pls parunga , unmai vilangum ungallukku )
8. Avargal - Junior Junior Junior . Kamal is still being remembered by oldies for this song
9. Kadavul amaithu vaitha medai - Have you seen / heard this song ?
10. Aayarathil oruvan - Paarthathuda anne ?
11. Yaar andha nilavu - THIS IS FROM SHANTI . THIS IS A CLASSIC EXAMPLE OF WHAT WESTERN MUSIC IS ALL ABOUT
12. FINALLY, NINAITHALAY INIKKUM

Indha ulagamay MSV isayai patri ariyum .

ACCORDING TO YOU, MSV NEVER CAME OUT OF HIS WORLD !

Ungallukku ivvalavu periya post thevai . En endraal ungallukku pavam MSV patri evvalavu theriyum endru naan ippodhu purindhu konden

On the other hand, YOU ARE A HARD CORE IR FAN BUT YOU WILL SHOW AS IF NOBODY IS YOUR FAVOURITE MD.
IF NO ONE IS YOUR FAVOURITE MD, WHY THERE IS A DISCONNECT IN YOUR OWN POSTINGS ?

From now, I will have to watch all your posts and then respond as I find so many fascinating facts like MSV NEVER CAME OUT OF HIS WORLD etc
From: Hulkster on Thu May 25 4:13:53 2006.

Ellarum cool down pennunga..the discussion is going off target....Let us settle that IR was best for kamal...and end it here...if not this will just get into a worthless argument with fingers pointing at each other...cool down people..
From: Nakeeran on Thu May 25 4:16:12 2006.

villan007 wrote:

umaramesh wrote:

Gavaskar retired gracefuly

news to me

my grandpa used to say he was literlaly kicked out of the team

Villain007 ,

Digression :

Gavaskar's final inning was at Bangalore in which he scored 96runs. He WAS THE ONLY GUY PROBABLY TILL DATE TO RETIRE GRACEFULLY.
Go through the old records before commenting pls

From: Nakeeran on Thu May 25 4:21:21 2006.

Hulkster wrote:

Ellarum cool down pennunga..the discussion is going off target....Let us settle that IR was best for kamal...and end it here...if not this will just get into a worthless argument with fingers pointing at each other...cool down people.. Not Worthy

Hulk anne, naan ungalai pondra oruvan dhaan. anaal ingu silar ariyamal oru manadhaga prarthikirargal about IR . Look, I am also a IR fan but WE SHOULD LEARN TO APPRECIATE THE WORKS OF OTHERS .
Look what kind of comments are coming . Horrible

From: umaramesh on Thu May 25 4:22:12 2006.

Dear Nakkeran

Thanks. I missed YAAR ANTHA NILAVU&MALAR ETHU KANGAL THAN ENDRU .what a composistion. I saw MSV singing with harmonium and explained how he did the composistion. Sounds of violin/guitar still fresh even after all these years.

ramesh
From: Hulkster on Thu May 25 4:24:43 2006.

Certainly MSV is himself a maestro of melodies..i believe he created a niche for himself of composing melodies different from the usual olden tamil film era usually mixing it with westernised orchestration. In fact he together with ramamoorthy introduced westernised orchestration to songs. To tell you the truth both IR and MSV do not have alot of difference..which is why i said IR is a more advanced version of MSV...anyone here is a fan of KV Mahadevan?..
From: umaramesh on Thu May 25 4:27:15 2006.

villan007 wrote:
umaramesh wrote:

Gavaskar retired gracefuly

news to me

my grandpa used to say he was literlaly kicked out of the team

He retired from the captaincy immaediately after BENSON &HEDGES and announced it in Aus itself. He broke the Bradman record after scoring 121 in new delhi and again scored 232 in mds and again 92 in Allahadbad that too against marshall/holding trio.

He scored 96 in mds against pakistan and again 96 in blore test and given out(edge from thigh pad I think).Hope this is enough

OONGA GRANDPA VISWANATH FAN ENRU NINAIKERAN.
From: Hulkster on Thu May 25 4:29:37 2006.

Guys please let off the cricket debate....we are going into a whole different topic...thanks..

From: Nakeeran on Thu May 25 4:30:15 2006.

umaramesh wrote:

Dear Nakkeran

Thanks. I missed YAAR ANTHA NILAVU&MALAR ETHU KANGAL THAN ENDRU .what a composistion. I saw MSV singing with harmonium and explained how he did the composistion. Sounds of violin/guitar still fresh even after all these years. Thumbs Up!

ramesh

Ramesh, believe me , on going through the posts of Selva Anne, I was very upset yesterday night .
ITS REALLY SAD SAD THAT THERE ARE GUYS WHO HAVE LITTLE IDEA ABOUT MSV
I AM A HARDCORE IR FAN AND I CAN IDENTIFY HIS SONG THROUGH PRELUDES . AT THE SAME TIME, I ADMIRE MSV FOR HIS SPLENDID CONTRIBUTION TO TFM.

Why, even IR himself apparently had told once that INDRAIKU NAANGAL AMAIKUM ISAI ELLAM NEENGAL VAZIKATIYA ORU MELLISAI PADHAYAI THAN .

endu migavum thanadakathodu sonaar.

I started this thread to have opinion from all corners , whether they are MSV fans or IR fans or ARR fans .
but I what I realise here is that there are guys WHO ARE NOT WILLING TO EVEN THINK ABOUT MDs OF YESTERYEARS.

Just look at what Selva anne said yesterday - MSV NEVER CAME OUT OF HIS CIRCLE

I fail to understand what he means by that ?

From: selvakumar on Thu May 25 4:33:23 2006.

NakeeRan THAATHA,

It is only you who are laughing at my comments. But UNGA POST ELLAM PAARTHU OORAE SIRICHATHAE .. MARANTHUTEENGALA THAATHA !

Unfortunately I didn't bash anyone without a reason like you.

THAATHA,
NeeNga thaaNa Nadigar thilagam over act panna mattum thaan theriyumnu sonnathu.

Neenga itha sollurathukku munndai atha eLLam konjam rewind pannunaa nalla irukkum

THAATHA,
MSV pathi NAAN sonnathu eNNoda opinion.. AThukkaaga naan IR ennoda favorite aayidumaa.. NeeNga koodathaan shivaji ya kanna pinnaannu kindal adichinga.... ATHUKKU PER THAAN FAVORITISM

Kamal, IR pathi VAAI KILIYA KAATTU KATTHU KAATHREENGALA THAATHA,

UNMAIYAANA SILA THAATHAAKKAL FIELD ULA Innum imsai pannuraangagalae

ATHA PATHI VAAI, KANNU, KAADU....ELLAATHATHUM MOODITTU IRUKEENGALAE.. ithukku PEYAR THAAN NADIKKURATHU.

THAATHA,
GAVASKAR pathi ENGALUKKU THERIYAATHU.. ENAA ENGALUKU UNGALAI MAARI ARIVUM, VAYASUM ILLAI

But IR - KH combo pathi soLLa ithueLLam romba avaisyam. ippo mattum atha kalatti vachureenga.

THAATHA,

NAAN IR - AH WORKSHIP PANNURENNA..

Naan eNNa uNgaLai maari MSV jaaLra nnu nenachuteeNgala.

Why should I workship a human? NEENGA THAAN WORKSHIP PANNUREENGA.

GAVASKAR ai... KAPIL DEV KOODA SIDE AAGINAAR.

aanaaa.. SACHIN ODA PUGAL ENNAIKKUM IRUKKUM CRICKET "GOD OF CRICKET" apadinugura TAG LINE Ods.

GAVASKAR - ai - TEAM AH VITTU VIRATTUNAANGA.. SUMMA JOLLYKKU AVARUKKU ORU MATCH KUDUTHU RETIRE AAGUNAANGA..

PAAVAM SRIKANTH KITTA KOODA SIDE VAANGINAAR.

ippadikku,
UNGAL ANBU PERAN

selva

THAATHA =--- I LOVE YOU THAATHAA / PAATI
From: Sanjeevi on Thu May 25 4:38:16 2006.

Why mod deleted my thread titled "Best MD for Shivaji"??????

If he is neutral please ban this thread too
From: selvakumar on Thu May 25 4:39:14 2006.

NAKEERAN THAATHA,

NeeNga kudutha LIST - LA ethaNai KAMAL - MSV song irukkunnu paarunga.

AIYO.. UNGA ARIYAAMAIYAI ENNANNU SOLLURATHU.

IR - KH songs list pannavae mudiyaathu.. avvalavu iruku.

ITHU EPPO Ungalukku puriyumoe THAATHA

UNGA ADUTHA THREAD PER SOLLATTUMA:

WHICH MD GAVE BEST INTRO FOR RAJINI -- DEVA OR IR? Apuram IR ah anda threadla KAATU thanamaa thaakuveenga.

eNakku... eVAN MUSIC POTTA ENNA.. athu kizhadaa irundaalum, kumarana irundaalum FACT THAAN MUKKIYAM

eVanaiyum(music director evanaiyum) NAAN KUMBUDA VENDIYA AVASIYAM ILLAI

IPPADIKKU,

UNGAL ANBU PERAN,

SELVA
From: selvakumar on Thu May 25 4:41:20 2006.

Sanjeevi,

First of all, THIS THREAD SHOULD BE UNDER "CURRENT TOPICS"

Athuvae iNga TF section la irukku

ithuLa thread ai delete pannitaangannu sollureenga

From: Sanjeevi on Thu May 25 4:42:30 2006.

NOV wrote:

Hulkster wrote:

a 19 year old boy commenting on the genius of MSV. Banging Head

this is probably what someone meant by youngsters not knowing MSV Rolling Eyes

True MSV fans, nay music fans, MUST stay away from this silly argument. Mad

Who is true MSV fans??

Nakeeran?

If you think about him as a true MSV fan, i can only pity.

May be he is a true IR hater

From: Nakeeran on Thu May 25 4:42:47 2006.

selvakumar wrote:

NakeeRan THAATHA,

It is only you who are laughing at my comments. But UNGA POST ELLAM PAARTHU OORAE SIRICHATHAE .. MARANTHUTEENGALA THAATHA ! LOL

Unfortunately I didn't bash anyone without a reason like you.

THAATHA,
NeeNga thaaNa Nadigar thilagam over act panna mattum thaan theriyumnu sonnathu.

Neenga itha sollurathukku munndai atha eLLam konjam rewind pannunaa nalla irukkum

THAATHA,
MSV pathi NAAN sonnathu eNNoda opinion.. AThukkaaga naan IR ennoda favorite aayidumaa.. NeeNga koodathaan shivaji ya kanna pinnaannu kindal adichinga.... ATHUKKU PER THAAN FAVORITISM

Kamal, IR pathi VAAI KILIYA KAATTU KATTHU KAATHREENGALA THAATHA,

UNMAIYAANA SILA THAATHAAKKAL FIELD ULA Innum imsai pannuraangagalae

ATHA PATHI VAAI, KANNU, KAADU....ELLAATHATHUM MOODITTU IRUKEENGALAE.. ithukku PEYAR THAAN NADIKKURATHU.

THAATHA,
GAVASKAR pathi ENGALUKKU THERIYAATHU.. ENAA ENGALUKU UNGALAI MAARI ARIVUM, VAYASUM ILLAI

But IR - KH combo pathi soLLa ithueLLam romba avaisyam. ippo mattum atha kalatti vachureenga.

THAATHA,

NAAN IR - AH WORKSHIP PANNURENNA..

Naan eNNa uNgaLai maari MSV jaaLra nnu nenachuteeNgala.

Why should I workship a human? Huh?!

NEENGA THAAN WORKSHIP PANNUREENGA.

GAVASKAR ai... KAPIL DEV KOODA SIDE AAGINAAR.

aanaaa.. SACHIN ODA PUGAL ENNAIKKUM IRUKKUM CRICKET "GOD OF CRICKET" apadinugura TAG LINE Ods.

GAVASKAR - ai - TEAM AH VITTU VIRATTUNAANGA.. SUMMA JOLLYKKU AVARUKKU ORU MATCH KUDUTHU RETIRE AAGUNAANGA..

Crying or Very sad

PAAVAM SRIKANTH KITTA KOODA SIDE VAANGINAAR. Crying or Very sad

ippadikku,
UNGAL ANBU PERAN

selva

THAATHA =--- I LOVE YOU THAATHAA / PAATI Rolling Eyes

Selva Anne,

vanakkam. Still you have not replied on any single point which I have posted earlier today

ana neenga periya aal anne.
Sambandham sambandham illama indha threadku vandhuteenga.
Unga ego ungalai vittu pola pavam.
Naan THATHAnu solreenga

Romba unarchi vasapattu en anne indha threadai spoil panreenga.
En mookula adipaticho

En anne, naan keta kelvigalukku badhil sollungalen

NOW I TELL YOU WHAT WILL HAPPEN. Your set of followers with groups will send a threatening pm to me and send some nasty words through posts

En anne, ungalluku MSV alladhu KVM alladhu matra MDs patri theriyadhu endral vitrungalen

En anne thappu thappa post panreenga

PLS EXPLAIN NOW, HOW DID YOU SAY THAT

MSV NEVER CAME OUT OF HIS WORLD

Ungalala mudiyadhu. enna edho thonichu. post panteenga anne.

From: selvakumar on Thu May 25 4:43:42 2006.

umaramesh wrote:

Selva

Gavaskar retired gracefuly after winning the BENSON&HEDGES and clearly due to his captaincy and planning. When he retired people asked why he is retiring? But PAVAM tendulkar everybody says(even ex cricketer and fan of sachin) he cannot get back his old rhythem and can survive. Laughing

ramesh

ithae MAAARI thaan WORLD CUP muNNadi DANDANAKKA KAAMICHEENGA.

But eNNa AACHU...

NONDI MAARI VILAYAADAAMA.. summa SOORAAVALI MAARI AADI,

eLLaR meLayum KARI ALLI POOSINAARAE..

maranthuteeNgala..

Inda world cup paarunga... PHOENIX WILL RISE AGAIN.. unlike someone who was kicked out of the team

From: Sanjeevi on Thu May 25 4:44:44 2006.

selvakumar wrote:

Sanjeevi,

First of all, THIS THREAD SHOULD BE UNDER "CURRENT TOPICS"

Athuvae iNga TF section la irukku

ithuLa thread ai delete pannitaangannu sollureenga

hi selva, you did not understand.

I have created one hour back a new thread for "Best MD for Shivaji" including a poll with options IR, MSV, Deva, KVM, etc.

Where is the thread now? I couldn't find.
From: umaramesh on Thu May 25 4:46:19 2006.

Selva

Nakkeran just listed out films and songs against your comment MSV WITHIN HIS CIRCLE.
whether worshipping MSV or IR that is irrelvant but do not post anything against particular MD without know his creativiity or his achivement. No one will accept the above comment.

ramesh

From: Nakeeran on Thu May 25 4:49:11 2006.

selvakumar wrote:

NAKEERAN THAATHA,

NeeNga kudutha LIST - LA ethaNai KAMAL - MSV song irukkunnu paarunga.

AIYO.. UNGA ARIYAAMAIYAI ENNANNU SOLLURATHU.

IR - KH songs list pannavae mudiyaathu.. avvalavu iruku. Crying or Very sad

ITHU EPPO Ungalukku puriyumoe THAATHA Embarassed

UNGA ADUTHA THREAD PER SOLLATTUMA:

WHICH MD GAVE BEST INTRO FOR RAJINI -- DEVA OR IR? Apuram IR ah anda threadla KAATU thanamaa thaakuveenga.

eNakku... eVAN MUSIC POTTA ENNA.. athu kizhadaa irundaalum, kumarana irundaalum FACT THAAN MUKKIYAM

eVanaiyum(music director evanaiyum) NAAN KUMBUDA VENDIYA AVASIYAM ILLAI

IPPADIKKU,

UNGAL ANBU PERAN,

SELVA

Selva anne,

Naan kodutha villakam ungalukku migavum thevai pattadhu en endral ungallukku andha padalgal ellam theriyaadhu endru ninaikiren. Otherwise you would not have said MSV LIVED NEVER CAME OUT OF HIS WORLD

Patheengala naan sonna padalgalai. THEY WERE ALL COMPOSED LONG BACK WHEN THE TFM MUSIC WAS NOT IN THE ADVANCED STAGES.

Ayyo ayyo, if you listen to MALAR EDHU UN KANGAL & ULAGAMENGUM ORAY MOZHI you will realise the truth

Ippa kooda onnum time agala. Pls hear those songs and then comment about MSV.

I WISH YOU TAKE BACK YOUR WORDS ABOUT MSV

From: selvakumar on Thu May 25 4:50:20 2006.

Quote:

MSV NEVER CAME OUT OF HIS WORLD

NakeeRAn THAATHA,

eNakku mookula adipadala.. UNGALUKKU MOONJULA KARIALLI POOSITAANGA eLLarum

Had MSV been so POWERFUL and had the MAGIC AND STEAM he had,

HE SHOULD HAVE COMPOSED MORE MUSIC FOR KAMAL ERA ALSO.

Just look at IR,

He is coping up with younger generation of directors like Bala with SETHU, PITHAAMAGAN etc.

aaNa MSV... MOTHALLA,, MSV - KH COMBO number of films ayum, IR - KH combo voda list ayum PAARUNGA.

UNGA ARIVA NENACHA ENAKKUM thaan panna thonuthu.

Naan topic maari discuss pannureenga.

itha sollaatheenga velila.. appuram NAKEERARAE THIRUMBA VANTHU UNGALA SUTTERIKKA PORAARU

Neenga mattum enna ANNANNU KOOPIDALAM...

Naan UNGALA THAATHANNU KOOPIDAKKOODAATHU

THAATHAA...

inda question nukku answer pannu thaatha,

MSV - KH COMBO ETHANA PADAM SILVER JUBILEE,

WORLD POPULAR (NAYANGAN)

summa JAPANIL KALYANAARAM EQUAL AAH irukiran MAANGA PADAPPERA ELLAM SOLLA KOODATHU.

MSV never came out of the world. I repeat !

Idukku motha reply pannunga THAATHA,

ippadikku,

UNGAL PERAN,

SELVA

I love you THAATHA
From: selvakumar on Thu May 25 4:53:55 2006.

Sanjeevi,
I indirectly referred to MODS deleting that thread and keeping this one alive.

Don't worry.. This thread will be buried soon.. else recreate that thread.

RAMESH,
I don't want to insult MSV.. AThukkaaga,,.. IR ennamoe enakku kula saami maariyum

NAAN MSV PAATTA KEKAATHA MAARIYUM PESURAARU Nakeeraru.

avara nirutha sollunga.. appuram paarkalam.

NAKEERAN,

I REPEAT... MSV NEVER CAME OUT OF HIS WORLD...
From: Hulkster on Thu May 25 4:54:50 2006.

Seri seri...this is getting out of hand...Selva sir..MSV might not have done alot of movies for Kamal and may have been overwhelmed by IR but that does not understate his talent...he was one of the pioneers of westernised tamil songs in cinema and his evergreen melodies can still be enjoyed by youths...IR has proven himself and is not just a mere tamil film composer...he is someone of the world class standard....alright please end this argument here...it will only turn into a fight thread....

From: Nakeeran on Thu May 25 4:55:21 2006.

umaramesh wrote:

Selva

Nakkeran just listed out films and songs against your comment MSV WITHIN HIS CIRCLE.
whether worshipping MSV or IR that is irrelvant but do not post anything against particular MD without know his creativiity or his achivement. No one will accept the above comment.

ramesh

Mr. Ramesh,

Vitrunga avarai. If he is really aware of MSV , he wouldnt have UTTERED LIKE THAT :

MSV WITHIN HIS CIRCLE

See, the songs and movies which I listed today were ALL OUT OF THE WORLD COMPOSITIONS FROM THE LEGEND MSV.

Selva anne has no direct answers for them becas he has not heard those

but his only strength is to call me as THATHA

earlier he called me as MAMA

cant you realise his limitations as music lover.

From: umaramesh on Thu May 25 4:55:40 2006.

Nakkeran
Leave it. He is not replying our question. MANNICHUTANGA.

ramesh

From: alwarpet_andavan on Thu May 25 4:55:43 2006.

selvakumar wrote:

umaramesh wrote:

ramesh

NETHI ADI SELVA!!!!

indha adi podhuma innum konjam venuma.

BTW, Sachine nenachaalum oru full [ODI] innings la 36 not out ellaam mudiyadhu

From: selvakumar on Thu May 25 4:56:22 2006.

Nakeeran THAATHA,

The list of songs that you gave proves that MSV never came out of his world.

whereas IR. ruled it with his own variations as per two generations.. until ARR took that towards TEENAGE ..

YOU BETTER LISTEN TO ALL SONGS OF IR- KH COMBO.. Before commenting on IR..

ippadikku,

UNGAL PERAN,

SELVA

From: Nakeeran on Thu May 25 5:00:33 2006.

selvakumar wrote:

Quote:

MSV NEVER CAME OUT OF HIS WORLD

NakeeRAn THAATHA,

ROTFL

eNakku mookula adipadala.. UNGALUKKU MOONJULA KARIALLI POOSITAANGA eLLarum

Had MSV been so POWERFUL and had the MAGIC AND STEAM he had,

HE SHOULD HAVE COMPOSED MORE MUSIC FOR KAMAL ERA ALSO.

Just look at IR,

He is coping up with younger generation of directors like Bala with SETHU, PITHAAMAGAN etc.

aaNa MSV... MOTHALLA,, MSV - KH COMBO number of films ayum, IR - KH combo voda list ayum PAARUNGA.
ROTFL

UNGA ARIVA NENACHA ENAKKUM ROTFL

thaan panna thonuthu.

Naan topic maari discuss pannureenga.

ROTFL

itha sollaatheenga velila.. appuram NAKEERARAE THIRUMBA VANTHU UNGALA SUTTERIKKA PORAARU ROTFL

Neenga mattum enna ANNANNU KOOPIDALAM... ROTFL

Naan UNGALA THAATHANNU KOOPIDAKKOODAATHU

THAATHAA... ROTFL

inda question nukku answer pannu thaatha,

MSV - KH COMBO ETHANA PADAM SILVER JUBILEE,

WORLD POPULAR (NAYANGAN)

summa JAPANIL KALYANAARAM EQUAL AAH irukiran MAANGA PADAPPERA ELLAM SOLLA KOODATHU.

MSV never came out of the world. I repeat !

Idukku motha reply pannunga THAATHA,

ippadikku,

UNGAL PERAN,

SELVA

I love you THAATHA

Selva Anne,

Indha post onne podhu anne. Ungaludaya isai rasanai and idea about MSV music . Naan save panni vachiruken for future reference

From now I will desist as you are BASHING TOO MUCH ABOUT MSV .

Thanks a lot for your valuable comments anne

From: umaramesh on Thu May 25 5:01:56 2006.

selva
The list of songs that you gave proves that MSV never came out of his world.

what happened to you? All these composistion happend 35 years back i.e way ahead . Ridiculous.

ramesh

From: Nakeeran on Thu May 25 5:07:49 2006.

umaramesh wrote:

selva
The list of songs that you gave proves that MSV never came out of his world.

what happened to you? All these composistion happend 35 years back i.e way ahead . Ridiculous.

ramesh

Mr. Ramesh,

IGNORANCE IS BLISS. vitrunga avarai.
Selva anne has taken a position to throw abuse on MSV music . Now he has moved to the next pedestal. Next you will see a post from him that MSV WORKED AS AN ASSITANT TO IR

AND MSV LEARNT FROM IR

Do you realise now ? Selva anne started by saying that he has NO FAVOURITE MD BUT NOW HE IS COMING OUT WITH TRUTH. A BIASED IR FOLLOWER.

A true music fan should be able to appreciate music from any MD which I found lacking today.

Avar enna pannuvaru pavam . Avarukku naan kurippitta padalgal edhuvum theriyadhu.

chumma beating around the bush

Apparently, he has already told moderators to lock this thread which he himself admits.

Looks like he has a good clout

From: Nakeeran on Thu May 25 5:14:56 2006.

selvakumar wrote:

Nakeeran THAATHA,

The list of songs that you gave proves that MSV never came out of his world.

whereas IR. ruled it with his own variations as per two generations.. until ARR took that towards TEENAGE ..

YOU BETTER LISTEN TO ALL SONGS OF IR- KH COMBO.. Before commenting on IR.. Very Happy

ippadikku,

UNGAL PERAN,

SELVA

Ayyo ayyo kadavulay

Selva anne, I am giving you another chance to hear all the songs listed by me today. IDHUKU MELA UNGALAI PATRI ONNUM SOLLA ENAKKU THONA VILLAI.
The list of songs are OUT OF THE WORLD COMPOSITIONS AND WERE WAY AHEAD OF TIMES DURING THOSE YEARS.
Fortunately, I could hear by listening to my elder brothers and uncles who are fond of music .
I AM CHALLENGING YOU NOW. CAN YOU PROVE BY HEARING THOSE SONGS ??

Pls do not vent your frustration further on MSV songs . You are only exposing yourself

From: alwarpet_andavan on Thu May 25 5:16:01 2006.

Nakkeeran,
Can you read?? Selva has clearly posted about ARR not only here but in many other threads. He has said IR is his fav WITH AANDAVAR. He has given HIS REASONS. Is that a complex mathematical equation to comprehend? You and umaramesh say MSV is the best, we prefer IR. I repeat PREFER. You cant force anyone to sing the praises of MSV just because you want to.
First you ask for "justification" and when people start giving one, you label them as IR fanatics who don't say a single word of praise about MSV.

Neenga enna George Bush lineage-a? "You are with us or against us"???
What's your problem in life man???

PLEASE DONT LIST SONGS OF MSV-KH AGAIN. Of course he's a great composer who has done great songs for Aandavar. Who denied that he has done good songs for Aandavar?????
From: umaramesh on Thu May 25 5:22:00 2006.

Dear Nakkeran
I am die hard fan of MSV(till today) but I got stunned when I heard
URAVANEUM PUDIYA VANNIL/MADAI THIRANTHU/MANDRAM VANTHA
like this so many songs. That is IR style. ARR wont be what he is now if he copied IR. IR will become so serious and UNARCHIVASA PADUVAR whenever he talk about MSV. Even in MSV book he explained how he got attracted to his music and the feelings are from his heart.

SAmeway MSV use to say MEETUKU PAATA /PATTUKU METTA NU KANDU PIDIATHU KAZTAM while talking about VAALAOOSAI KALA KALA SONG(kamal movie). MSV said this press interview.

We should admire good music and should not criticise just like that without knowing the truth.

ramesh

From: Nakeeran on Thu May 25 5:22:58 2006.

alwarpet_andavan wrote:

Nakkeeran,
Can you read?? Selva has clearly posted about ARR not only here but in many other threads. He has said IR is his fav WITH AANDAVAR. He has given HIS REASONS. Is that a complex mathematical equation to comprehend? You and umaramesh say MSV is the best, we prefer IR. I repeat PREFER. You cant force anyone to sing the praises of MSV just because you want to.
First you ask for "justification" and when people start giving one, you label them as IR fanatics who don't say a single word of praise about MSV.

Neenga enna George Bush lineage-a? "You are with us or against us"???
What's your problem in life man???

PLEASE DONT LIST SONGS OF MSV-KH AGAIN. Of course he's a great composer who has done great songs for Aandavar. Who denied that he has done good songs for Aandavar?????

Banging Head

Good that you have brought some sanity to the proceedings.

Look, I havent bashed IR or any MD . YOU CAN GO THROUGH THE ENTIRE THREAD ONCE AGAIN.
I have listed the movies of both IR and MSV.

WHAT I EXPECTED WAS A CIVILIZED ANALYSIS OF OTHER MDs as well. I took MSV as my choice AS HE WAS A GENUINE COMPOSER WHO HAD GIVEN SOME OUTSTANDING MUSIC FOR KAMAL DURING HIS FORMATIVE YEARS.

But if I highlight this, I become an IR basher, I am a MSV worshipper , I am a Thatha , Mama etc etc and all praises are being heaped on me

Read my post again, I have never said that MSV music is the best but I wanted all to have a look at MSV songs for Kamal also before concluding .

By the way, any comments about Selva anne mentioning that MSV NEVER CAME OUT OF HIS WORLD

Have you heard the songs which I had listed today of MSV which were composed some 30-40 years back when the music level of TFM didnt reach that growth ?

wish to know from you

From: Nakeeran on Thu May 25 5:25:59 2006.

umaramesh wrote:

Dear Nakkeran
I am die hard fan of MSV(till today) but I got stunned when I heard
URAVANEUM PUDIYA VANNIL/MADAI THIRANTHU/MANDRAM VANTHA
like this so many songs. That is IR style. ARR wont be what he is now if he copied IR. IR will become so serious and UNARCHIVASA PADUVAR whenever he talk about MSV. Even in MSV book he explained how he got attracted to his music and the feelings are from his heart.

SAmeway MSV use to say MEETUKU PAATA /PATTUKU METTA NU KANDU PIDIATHU KAZTAM while talking about VAALAOOSAI KALA KALA SONG(kamal movie). MSV said this press interview.

We should admire good music and should not criticise just like that without knowing the truth.

ramesh

precisely Mr. Ramesh.

When IR himself admires the music of MSV , I wonder why not we !

By the way, how come the topic got digressed to Sachin vs Gavaskar ! Could be the Selva anne effect becas he mentioned it somewhere .

From: umaramesh on Thu May 25 5:28:51 2006.

AIYYO KADAVULAE Who said MSV IS BEST? we only saying hear those songs then comment. His composistion are way ahead of time . Thos who know little bit about music will accept this. HE ONLY SAID MSV IS IN CIRCLE.
just like that support PANNATHENGA.

ramesh
From: alwarpet_andavan on Thu May 25 5:31:00 2006.

Nakkeeran,I've listened to those songs. Also, Unakkenna Mele nindrai, Engeyum Eppodhum [brilliant marriage of western almost-rockish guitaring with the snake tune] are like anthems for me. Of course IR considers MSV as his guru.

That said, indha madhiri IR-Aandavar godown-la pala madangu irukku and that has been our point all along. Had you merely disagreed and "free-a vittufied", pechu ivalo dhooram vandhirukkaadhu.... adha vittuttu you complained that we have ignored the works of MSV and we are blind fanatics of IR etc....

Anyway, i dont see this moving anywhere and rest my case. So there....
From: great on Thu May 25 5:33:19 2006.

/@Neenga enna George Bush lineage-a? "You are with us or against us"???
What's your problem in life man??? @/

Even i am trying to figure out from the time he has opened this thread

From: Nakeeran on Thu May 25 5:37:21 2006.

alwarpet_andavan wrote:

Nakkeeran,I've listened to those songs. Also, Unakkenna Mele nindrai, Engeyum Eppodhum [brilliant marriage of western almost-rockish guitaring with the snake tune] are like anthems for me. Of course IR considers MSV as his guru.

That said, indha madhiri IR-Aandavar godown-la pala madangu irukku and that has been our point all along. Had you merely disagreed and "free-a vittufied", pechu ivalo dhooram vandhirukkaadhu.... adha vittuttu you complained that we have ignored the works of MSV and we are blind fanatics of IR etc....

Anyway, i dont see this moving anywhere and rest my case. So there....

Nice to hear this from you. thanks

Indha threadla Selva anne endru oruvar ullar. Avar seidha comments about MSV :

MSV NEVER CAME OUT HIS WORLD .

Idharku than naan vilakkam ketkiren becas you came to his rescue.
His case is not mere disagreement but throwing some unethical comments about MSV music which I want him to get enlightened

And look at the spontaneous reaction. Someone had already opened a thread for Shivaji's best MD!

Nice to hear that you like Unakenna melay nindrai !

From: Nakeeran on Thu May 25 5:39:10 2006.

great wrote:

/@Neenga enna George Bush lineage-a? "You are with us or against us"???
What's your problem in life man??? @/

Even i am trying to figure out from the time he has opened this thread Laughing

vanakamna Great anne

Enge kanumenu ninaichen. Stock marketla poondhu vilayadurengala

Vaazga valamudan

From: selvakumar on Thu May 25 5:43:35 2006.

------------------------
A_A,

uNga Level perusu.. neeNga Nakeeran levelukku iraNgai vara veNaam..
I can do it.. coz yOU know the reason..
Don't try to explain him again. We might get AMAZON dreams all the time if we do that.

and
We might be tempted to ridicule everyone.
------------------------

NakeeRan THAATHA,

Neenga Mattum eNNa annannu koopidalaam... (without my permission)..

Idukku oru kelvi.. PACHAYA KEKALAAM.. NEE NAAN yaarukku ..........etc apadinnu kekalaaam.

"First try to clean the dust on ur side. Then you can advice others"

NO more MSV bashing

MSV IS A SUPERMAN

MSV is the WORLD'S GREATEST MUSICIAN (Am I getting )

MSV is the BEST OF ALL..

MSV is the BEST OF YOUNGER GENERATION.

HIs youthful music still lifts us. ! like riding the bicyle on a hilly area.

AVAR ULAGA ISAI METHAI.

THAMBI MSV VAAZGHA !
From: great on Thu May 25 5:48:02 2006.

Nakeeran wrote:

vanakamna Great anne

Enge kanumenu ninaichen. Stock marketla poondhu vilayadurengala

Vaazga valamudan

Vanakkam Anne

who started it first.

you were trying to enforce your view on others.when others said IR why want to bring MSV into the picture .

You were repeatedly mentioning MSV songs are as follows blah blah

we are not denying MSV has given some beautiful tracks to KH.

you have no right to impose ur views on others

Itha porulalar postLa irrukara neenga seiyveengannu naan expect pannala

Nakeerar anne vaazgha

avar pugal ongunga
From: umaramesh on Thu May 25 5:58:37 2006.

THAMBI MSV VAAZGHA
From: selvakumar on Thu May 25 6:00:11 2006.

NakeeRan,

My comments came after your ridiculing and personal attacks on those who supported IR

Neenga eNNa EINSTEIN ah ?

Everyone has their right to say their opinion.

Atha nakkal pannunaa.. naanga MSV ya pathi thaan fact ah sonnoem.

I never handled MSV like how you HANDLED IR, KAMAL, NADIGAR THILAGAM etc

MSV oNNum eNakku kadan vaangittu thiruppithaaraama pogala.. so, why should I bash him?

Nee senja niyaayam... naan sonna groupism..

nalla logic pa !

From: Nakeeran on Thu May 25 6:00:34 2006.

great wrote:

Nakeeran wrote:

vanakamna Great anne

Enge kanumenu ninaichen. Stock marketla poondhu vilayadurengala Very Happy

Vaazga valamudan Very Happy

Vanakkam Anne LOL

who started it first.

you were trying to enforce your view on others.when others said IR why want to bring MSV into the picture .

You were repeatedly mentioning MSV songs are as follows blah blah

we are not denying MSV has given some beautiful tracks to KH.

you have no right to impose ur views on others

Itha porulalar postLa irrukara Embarassed

neenga seiyveengannu naan expect pannala Mad

Nakeerar anne vaazgha Embarassed

avar pugal ongunga Mad

Great anne,

neenga mudhalil vaazga . Appa than naan vaaza mudiyum

Naan solvadhelaam ondru ondru ondru - matravargar isayim naam kuripittu pinbu theerpu solla vendum. Idhu enadhu thazmayana karuthu. Do you have any second opinion on this ?

Second, Selva anne MSV patri migavum kuzapamana oru vilakkam koduthar MSV NEVER CAME OUT OF HIS CIRCLE etc etc

Adharku naan konjam vilakkam keten . AVAR ESCAPU

Anne, indha thread earlier pages poneengana ungalukku puriuyum. I have listed many songs and movies of IR and then moved to MSV for other MDs section as IMO, MSV comes immediately for analysis.

Anbudan porulalar

From: villan007 on Thu May 25 6:02:22 2006.

umaramesh wrote:

THAMBI MSV VAAZGHA
From: selvakumar on Thu May 25 6:03:52 2006.

Nakeeran ,

Naan onnu unnaa maari illa kannu.

I repeat... MSV didn't came out of his world. He didn't cope up with the expectations of the upcoming directors. But IR is still ruling with works like sethu, pithamagan etc

Just answer my question. Don't run away
From: selvakumar on Thu May 25 6:05:42 2006.

Great,

I am starting NAKEERAN THAATHA PERAVAI.

Would you like to join us?

We don't have any posts as of now.

Let's rejoice our THAATHA's fame .

From: Nakeeran on Thu May 25 6:08:31 2006.

selvakumar wrote:

------------------------
A_A,

uNga Level perusu.. Very Happy

neeNga Nakeeran levelukku iraNgai vara veNaam..
I can do it.. coz Huh?!

yOU know the reason.. Wink

Don't try to explain him again. ROTFL

We might get AMAZON dreams all the time if we do that.

and
We might be tempted to ridicule everyone. Smile

------------------------

NakeeRan THAATHA,

Neenga Mattum eNNa annannu koopidalaam... (without my permission)..

Idukku oru kelvi.. PACHAYA KEKALAAM.. NEE NAAN yaarukku ..........etc apadinnu kekalaaam.

"First try to clean the dust on ur side. Then you can advice others"

NO more MSV bashing

MSV IS A SUPERMAN

MSV is the WORLD'S GREATEST MUSICIAN (Am I getting Embarassed

)

MSV is the BEST OF ALL..

MSV is the BEST OF YOUNGER GENERATION.

HIs youthful music still lifts us. ! like riding the bicyle on a hilly area.

AVAR ULAGA ISAI METHAI.

THAMBI MSV VAAZGHA ! Clap

Selva anne, enna ippadi solteenga

Naan endraikkumay ungal anbu thambi dhan. Endha alavukku isayai patri theriyum endru parthen.
Romba thanks anne

Anaa neenga kuripitta andha comment edho avasarathula poteengala anne ? MSV NEVER CAME OUT OF HIS CIRCLE.

Venumna adhai edit pannidunga pls.

From: villan007 on Thu May 25 6:09:29 2006.
From: selvakumar on Thu May 25 6:11:57 2006.

Nakeeera,

Answer my question. PRove how MSV lived upto the expectations of the next generation? Why didn't he achieve with the likes of Sethu, pithamagan etc.

He did a movie with IR recently.. But aaLa athukapuram kaanoem

I must escalate the issue to the MODS if you again call me as ANNA..

I don't want to have a THAMBI like you who is that much old
From: Nakeeran on Thu May 25 6:12:28 2006.

selvakumar wrote:

Great,

I am starting NAKEERAN THAATHA PERAVAI.

Would you like to join us?

We don't have any posts as of now.

Let's rejoice our THAATHA's fame .

Anne. pavam neenga. enna kobathin uchathukku poiteenga pola.

Ippa kooda onnum kettu pola anne. Unga egovai vittu vittu manam thirandhu oppukollungal about other MDs and then conclude about IR .

Vaazga neengal engirundhalum

From: great on Thu May 25 6:13:02 2006.

Nakeeran wrote:

Great anne,

Naan solvadhelaam ondru ondru ondru - matravargar isayim naam kuripittu pinbu theerpu solla vendum. Idhu enadhu thazmayana karuthu. Do you have any second opinion on this ?

Anne the topic is who is Best MD for KH !!! I hope i got the topic correct if not please correct it nakeerar anne

If some "x" gives their opinion stating IR is the best why you want to give suggestion like MSV,ARR, S.A.Rajkumar even they would have listned to most of the popular songs.

Porularar vaazgha

Nakeeran wrote:

Second, Selva anne MSV patri migavum kuzapamana oru vilakkam koduthar MSV NEVER CAME OUT OF HIS CIRCLE etc etc

Adharku naan konjam vilakkam keten . AVAR ESCAPU Laughing

But who started MSV talk over here

Nakeeran wrote:

Anne, if you want i can go trace back who started it first. I dont want to do that , if you feel so i can do that also.

Porularar NakeeRar vazgha vazhgha

From: great on Thu May 25 6:14:54 2006.

selvakumar wrote:

Great,
I am starting NAKEERAN THAATHA PERAVAI.
Would you like to join us?
We don't have any posts as of now.
Let's rejoice our THAATHA's fame .

Are we supposed to start from Thaatha vadai sutta kathai
From: umaramesh on Thu May 25 6:16:10 2006.

OK. Appa enn manirathnam/BR/shankar ellam ARR kitta ponnanga?
I think last year SUPER HIT album GAJINI. ENTHA ULLAGATHIL IRUKEENGA

From: Nakeeran on Thu May 25 6:16:40 2006.

selvakumar wrote:

Nakeeera,

Answer my question. PRove how MSV lived upto the expectations of the next generation? Huh?!

Why didn't he achieve with the likes of Sethu, pithamagan etc.

He did a movie with IR recently.. Crying or Very sad

But aaLa athukapuram kaanoem Crying or Very sad

I must escalate the issue to the MODS if you again call me as ANNA..
ROTFL

I don't want to have a THAMBI like you who is that much old Crying or Very sad

Ayyo ayyo anne

Ulaga nayagan Kamal himself belonged to the next generation when MSV composed music for him & he gave outstanding songs for him.
Do you really expect an aged legend like MSV at this stage of his life to repeat his old magic. Anne , ippo naan ungalai patri romba seriousa think pannanum anne.
Neenga engeyo poi kondu irukeenga.
Do you know the age of MSV now

& you are posing a question like this ?
Marubadiyum unga limitations dont expose pls anne.

From: great on Thu May 25 6:21:16 2006.

umaramesh wrote:

OK. Appa enn manirathnam/BR/shankar ellam ARR kitta ponnanga?
I think last year SUPER HIT album GAJINI. ENTHA ULLAGATHIL IRUKEENGA

you know the answer but still you expect reply

MR went to ARR not bcoz IR does not have the required stuff they got seperated due to ego clash.

Shankar never been to IR .Its not a written rule that all the directors should go to IR .

Regd BR same as MR
From: villan007 on Thu May 25 6:22:16 2006.

MSV vs IR than ithu varaikum illa... ippo adhum vandhachu
From: selvakumar on Thu May 25 6:23:43 2006.

Appa BALA aen MSV kitta pogaama IR kitta poraaru

enda uLagathiLa irukeenga pa.. !

nakeera,

YOu have insulted MSV by telling that KH belonged to next generation.
Then why did MANY DURING THOSE TIMES PREFER IR?

MSV innum koncham kilichurukalaamal.. Why did he retire ?

No one was waiting in the queue for him. EVeryone preferred IR.

EVen at this generation, MANY people like BALA and others prefer IR :

MSV

BTW,
I know the age of MSV.. 16 vayasu thaan.. Thambi MSV vaazhga !

From: selvakumar on Thu May 25 6:25:26 2006.

great wrote:

umaramesh wrote:

OK. Appa enn manirathnam/BR/shankar ellam ARR kitta ponnanga?
I think last year SUPER HIT album GAJINI. ENTHA ULLAGATHIL IRUKEENGA

you know the answer but still you expect reply Laughing

MR went to ARR not bcoz IR does not have the required stuff they got seperated due to ego clash.

Shankar never been to IR .Its not a written rule that all the directors should go to IR .
Regd BR same as MR

But everyone prefer MSV now.. Don't u know the fact

MSV is a young boy who can still give stunning music..

Shankar is too old for MSV to suit his taste

From: great on Thu May 25 6:28:26 2006.

vaaliba vayasu
From: villan007 on Thu May 25 6:28:57 2006.

nakeeran ,

Poonai kannai moodichina ulagam irundu ponathunu ninaikumam

antha maari iruku..neenga argue panrathu.....
From: umaramesh on Thu May 25 6:29:03 2006.

Its not a written rule that all the directors should go to IR .

SAMEWAY it is not written rule that every gneration should go to MSV.

Selva

must escalate the issue to the MODS if you again call me as ANNA..

avoid putting MSV AS THAMBI. You dont have basic ......

From: Nakeeran on Thu May 25 6:29:35 2006.

selvakumar wrote:

Appa BALA aen MSV kitta pogaama IR kitta poraaru Question

enda uLagathiLa irukeenga pa.. !

nakeera,

ROTFL

YOu have insulted MSV by telling that KH belonged to next generation.
Then why did MANY DURING THOSE TIMES PREFER IR? Crying or Very sad

MSV innum koncham kilichurukalaamal.. Why did he retire ? Crying or Very sad

No one was waiting in the queue for him. EVeryone preferred IR. Crying or Very sad

EVen at this generation, MANY people like BALA and others prefer IR :

MSV Crying or Very sad

BTW,
I know the age of MSV.. 16 vayasu thaan.. Thambi MSV vaazhga ! Not Worthy

Selva anne, arent you aware of the vicious life circle

What you mentioned that everyone preferred IR !
BY THE TIME IR ARRIVED IN 76, MSV HAD ALREADY ACHIEVED EVERYTHING IN LIFE AND HAD REACHED HIS PEAK.

The same IR impact on MSV happened to IR also in 93-94 after the arrival of ARR with his new brand of music ( and IMHO, thats the best of IR when he reached his peak levels )

Anne romba deepa pona neenga sikkalla matikkuvinga anne. Vitrunga

From: selvakumar on Thu May 25 6:31:45 2006.

Ramesh :rotfl

First ask Nakeeran to stop kidding Nadigar ThiLagam, IR, KH etc
Apuram vandu UNga niyaayatha sollunga.

NaaN eppavaum porumayaa irukka maattaen

Ask him to stop calling me as ANNNNNEEE.. so that I can stop THAATHA , THAMBI etc

"ooRukku thaan upathesam.. ungalukku illa
From: great on Thu May 25 6:32:18 2006.

umaramesh wrote:

Its not a written rule that all the directors should go to IR .

SAMEWAY it is not written rule that every gneration should go to MSV.

Ramesh , point is simple both IR and MSV belongs to different genres we are not here to discuss on the quality of work done.

Here we are discussing to the topic !!!

If i say IR why you guyz want to teach me about MSV.
From: selvakumar on Thu May 25 6:33:52 2006.

Nakkeran,

I am not like MSV to be in a vicious circle
Just prove me:

Why MSV was unable to make inroads into IR's era even though IR was able to do the same even at ARR -etc period.

Retirement vaaNgaLa IR... but MSV... VRS vaangittaaru
From: villan007 on Thu May 25 6:35:25 2006.

yaaruba antha oru vote pottathu MSV ku.... ramesh or nakeeran ?
From: umaramesh on Thu May 25 6:36:45 2006.

PAVAM IR. EVVALVU KAZTA PATTLUM ORU HIT KODUKKA MUDIYALLA.

ENNA PANRATHU VAYASU AADICHU. RETIRE AAGHA MANASU VARALA.
MEDAI EAARAE NAAN INNUM IRUKKEN ENDRU KAANBIKIRAR.
VAAZHA IR THATHA.

CHANCE KADACHA THIRUVASAGAM NU PER POTTU CINEMA PAATAI MATTRI BUSINESS PAANALLAM. YAARAIAVATHU EAAMATTRALAM

RAMESH
From: selvakumar on Thu May 25 6:37:49 2006.

great wrote:

If i say IR why you guyz want to teach me about MSV.

Great,
If they had thought about this, then they wouldn't have dragged this issue. They were not able to speak with statistics apart from a few good songs of MSV.

But if someone like RAMI comeup with HEYRAM etc, they will jump on those poor people.

NaaMa ATHA REPEAT PANNUNAA.. naanma pollaathavanga .. This Nakeeran's logic ..

From: Nakeeran on Thu May 25 6:38:32 2006.

selvakumar wrote:

great wrote:

umaramesh wrote:

OK. Appa enn manirathnam/BR/shankar ellam ARR kitta ponnanga?
I think last year SUPER HIT album GAJINI. ENTHA ULLAGATHIL IRUKEENGA

you know the answer but still you expect reply Laughing

But everyone prefer MSV now.. Don't u know the fact Twisted Evil

MSV is a young boy who can still give stunning music..

Shankar is too old for MSV to suit his taste Twisted Evil

Selva Anne,

kadaisiyaaga naan oru murai ungalukku kuripida virumbugiren

Ippodhu MSV sirukku enna vayaso, andha vayasukku naam ellorum oru naal varathan pogirom , including IR and ARR and other MDs.
During that phase , some other guy will pose a question to you like this.

If you realise the truth , you will never abuse MSV like this.

BYE FOR NOW ANNE .

From: villan007 on Thu May 25 6:38:45 2006.

umaramesh wrote:

PAVAM IR. EVVALVU KAZTA PATTLUM ORU HIT KODUKKA MUDIYALLA.

ENNA PANRATHU VAYASU AADICHU. RETIRE AAGHA MANASU VARALA.
MEDAI EAARAE NAAN INNUM IRUKKEN ENDRU KAANBIKIRAR.
VAAZHA IR THATHA.

CHANCE KADACHA THIRUVASAGAM NU PER POTTU CINEMA PAATAI MATTRI BUSINESS PAANALLAM. YAARAIAVATHU EAAMATTRALAM

RAMESH

ok ok..don shout.....

( hope u know the meaning of posting in caps

)

From: umaramesh on Thu May 25 6:39:42 2006.

You guys only saying IR ruling
people use to hear HJ/Yuvan/VS etc .
IR still composing with them but better to retire then KUMBALA GOVINDA

ramesh

From: great on Thu May 25 6:39:53 2006.

umaramesh wrote:

Vaazgha-La G missing Ramesh.

Unga rendu peraiyum nenachu sirripu thaan varuthu

Full-a solli mudichurunga at a strectch i will read those comedies and laugh

From: selvakumar on Thu May 25 6:41:34 2006.

umaramesh wrote:

yes.. WE ARE ALSO TELLING THE SAME.

IR can never match the YOUTH OF MSV.. Still MSV is a YOUTH.

MSV is a sweet 16 boy.

MSV is a YOUNG GIRLS' HEARTHROB.

MSV is the world's best MD

From: Sanjeevi on Thu May 25 6:46:24 2006.

selvakumar wrote:

Nakeeran ,

Naan onnu unnaa maari illa kannu.

I repeat... MSV didn't came out of his world. He didn't cope up with the expectations of the upcoming directors. But IR is still ruling with works like sethu, pithamagan etc

Just answer my question. Don't run away ROTFL

Super Selva, He can't answer for this.

Not only MSV didn't came out of his world. His fans also

From: great on Thu May 25 6:47:41 2006.

Sanjeevi wrote:

Super Selva, He can't answer for this.

Sanjeevi, He will never answer any questions
From: villan007 on Thu May 25 6:48:57 2006.

great wrote:

Sanjeevi wrote:

Super Selva, He can't answer for this.

Sanjeevi, He will never answer any questions

Nakeeraruku kutram kandupidakathan therium..
From: great on Thu May 25 6:51:25 2006.

Nakeeran wrote:

BYE FOR NOW ANNE .

Anne

Engala thaniya vittu pogathinga engalukku timepass aganum
From: umaramesh on Thu May 25 6:53:56 2006.

Not only MSV didn't came out of his world. His fans also

You guys are telling this. just come out of IR world.

ramesh
From: great on Thu May 25 6:55:04 2006.

umaramesh wrote:

Not only MSV didn't came out of his world. His fans also

You guys are telling this. just come out of IR world.

ramesh

Yup musical world
From: umaramesh on Thu May 25 7:02:04 2006.

Yup musical world

World means co existence .

ramesh
From: great on Thu May 25 7:06:45 2006.

Nakeera pls change the thread title to IR V/S MSV.

I would come out with more details then
From: selvakumar on Thu May 25 7:29:21 2006.

umaramesh wrote:

Not only MSV didn't came out of his world. His fans also

You guys are telling this. just come out of IR world.

ramesh

Sorry.. A small correction.

We are young.. We are in MSV WORLD. MSV rocks our world with his YOUTH !
From: Sanjeevi on Thu May 25 8:02:35 2006.

great wrote:

Nakeera pls change the thread title to IR V/S MSV.

I would come out with more details then

Nethi adi great .

Nakeeranare thairiyam irunthal ippadi thalaippai mathunga, appuram parkalam.
From: selvakumar on Thu May 25 8:34:33 2006.

http://geethamsangeetham.blogspot.com/2006/05/blog-post_22.html

நம்ம ப்ளாக் நண்பர் சாணக்கியன் (சாய்) கமல் பாடிய பாடல்கள் வச்சி ஒரு பதிவு போடுங்கன்னு கேட்டுக்கிட்டார். நேயர் விருப்பமா பாடல் போட்டு, இப்போ பதிவு போட ஆரம்பிச்சாச்சு.

கமலை பற்றி நம்ம எஸ்.பி.பி சுந்தர் அடிக்கடி அழகா, சில சமயம் கோவமா அவர் பதிவில் சொல்லிக்கிட்டே இருப்பார். இரண்டு படம் ஓடியதும் ஏதோ தமிழகமே தன் பின்னால் இருப்பது போல கேமராவை பார்த்து பேசிக்கொண்டு, துதி பாடல் வைத்துக்கொண்டு நாற்காலி கனவு கண்டு கொண்டிருக்கும் பல நடிகர்களுக்கு மத்தியில், ஒரு நடிகனாக நடிப்பில் ஏதாவது வித்தியாசமா செய்யணும் என்று துடிப்போடு இருக்கும் மிக சில நடிகர்களில் கமலுக்கு எப்பவுமே முதலிடம் உண்டு. நானும் ஒரு கமல் ரசிகன் தான்.

ஹேராம் பாடல் ஒலிப்பதிவை படம் வெளியாகும் போது அடிக்கடி காட்டுவார்கள். 'ரெண்டு குத்து பாட்டு, ஒரு துதி பாட்டு, ரெண்டு டூயட்' என்று மெனு கார்டை இசை அமைப்பாளர்களிடம் கொடுத்து விட்டு, ஹிட் ஆனா போதும் என்னும் இன்றைய நிலையில், இசையில் கூட கமல் ராஜாவிடம் உட்கார்ந்து கேட்டு ரசித்து பாடல் வாங்குவது போல சில க்ளிப் (ஹேராம்) பார்க்கும் போது இசையில் கமலின் ஈடுபாடு தெரியும். எங்கே வித்தியாசமான முயற்சிகள் இருக்கிறதோ, அங்கே சில தோல்விகளும் சகஜம் தான். கமல் 'மும்பை எக்ஸ்பிரஸ்' படத்திற்கும் பாடலுக்கும் கொடுத்த பில்ட்-அப் அப்படி தான் ஆனது. 'மும்பை எக்ஸ்பிரஸ்' பாடல்களை முதலில் கேட்கும் போது, இசை ஓட்டம் பிடி படாமல் ('ஏலே நீ எட்டிப்போ') எனக்கு தலைசுற்றியது உண்மை தான். JAZZ இசையாம், அது இப்படி தான் ஒரு கட்டமைப்பு இல்லாமல் ஓடுமாம். பொதுஜனத்திற்கு எந்த பாடலையும் கேட்டவுடன் ஒரு அழகான ஓட்டத்துடன் இருந்தால் தான் மனதில் ஒட்டும். அந்த வகையில் 'மும்பை எக்ஸ்பிரஸ்' பாடல்களும் சரி, படமும் சரி பத்தோடு ஒன்றாக போய்விட்டது. அதிலும் டக்கென்று பிடிக்கும் 'பூ பூத்தது' பாடலை படத்தில் கொத்து பரோட்டாவில் மாட்டின முட்டை மாதிரி கொத்தி இருப்பார் கமல். கொடுமையடா சாமி! உண்மையில் 'மும்பை எக்ஸ்பிரஸ்' இசையில் ராஜா இசையில் இன்னொரு சிகரம் தொட்டிருப்பார். அதற்கு கமலும் ஒரு காரணம். ஆனால் எல்லாம் வேஸ்டா போச்சு. இப்படி கமலின் முயற்சிகளை 100 பதிவு போட்டு எழுதிகிட்டே இருக்கலாம்.

இப்போதைய நடிகர்களில் நன்றாக பாடக்கூடிய ஒரே நடிகரும் கமல் தான் ( விஜயும் ஓ.கே. அதுக்காக 'இந்த பாடலை பாடியவர் உங்கள் விஜய்' என்று எல்லா எஸ்.ஏ.சி படத்தில் எல்லாம் டைட்டில் போடுவது கொஞ்சம் ஓவர் ). பார்த்தா, பாடாத நடிகர்களே இருக்க மாட்டார்கள். எல்லோருக்கும் கேசட்டில் பாடகர் பட்டியலில் தன் பெயரை பார்க்க ஆசை தான். பாடுவார்களா, படிப்பார்களா என்பது கேட்பவருக்கே வெளிச்சம். ஆனால் கமலை எடுத்துக் கொண்டால் வெறுமனே எளிதான பாடல்களாக பாடாமல், கிட்டத்தட்ட ஒரு professional பாடகர் அளவுக்கு நிறைய பண்ணியிருப்பார். டூயட் (நினைவோ ஒரு பறவை), தனி பாடல் (பொன் மானை தேடுதே), சோகம் (தென்பாண்டி சீமையிலெ, மாடவிளக்கே), ஹை பிட்ச் (விக்ரம், போட்டு வைத்த காதல் திட்டம்) என்று நிறைய வித்தியாசமான பாடல்களை முயற்சி செய்திருப்பார். அவற்றில் சில இந்த பதிவில் பார்க்கலாம்.

கமல் பாடல் என்றவுடன் எனக்கு நினைவுக்கு வருவது 'சிகப்பு ரோஜாக்கள்' படத்தில் இருந்து 'நினைவோ ஒரு பறவை'. அருமையான ஒரு டூயட் பாடல். இன்னொரு பாடலும் உடனே நினைவுக்கு வருகிறது. 'ஞாயிறு ஒளி மழையில் திங்கள் குளிக்க வந்தால்'. இது கமல் தானே? தெரிந்தவர்கள் சொல்லுங்கள். மெல்லிசை மன்னர் இசையா? என்ன படம்?

அடுத்து, 'அவள் அப்படித்தான்' படத்தில் இருந்து 'பன்னீர் புஷ்பங்களே'. இளம் கமலின் குரல். இந்த பாடலை கேட்கும் போது கமலை பேசாமல் நடிகர் பட்டியலில் இருந்து பாடகர் பட்டியலில் சேர்த்து விடலாம் என்று தோன்றும். ஏனோ இந்த பாடலில் எனக்கு கமலின் குரல் ரொம்ப பிடிக்கும்.

'ஓ! மானே மானே' மோகன்-ஊர்வசி நடித்த படம் ( டி.வியில் அடிக்கடி 'ரோஜா ஒன்று உள்ளங்கையில் பூத்தது' பாடல் பார்க்கலாம்). ஆனால் அதில் கமல் பாடிய பாடல் ஒன்று இருக்கிறது. இது கமல் மோகனுக்கு பாடியதா? இல்லை கமலும் அந்த படத்தில் நடித்திருக்கிறாரா? தெரிந்தவர்கள் கூறுங்கள். ராஜாவின் இசையில் 'ஓ! மானே மானே' படத்தில் இருந்து 'பொன் மானை தேடுதே'.

சத்யா படத்தில் இருந்து ஒரு வித்தியாசமான பாடல். 'போட்டா படியுது படியுது'. எல்லா பாடகர்களாலும் இந்த பாடலை பாடமுடியாது. கமலின் குரல் இயற்கையாகவே இந்த மாதிரி பாடல்களுக்கு பொருந்தி வரும். ( சமீபத்தில் யுவன் சங்கர் ராஜா இசையில் 'புதுப்பேட்டை'ல இந்த மாதிரி ஒரு பாடல் கமல் பாடி இருக்கிறார்). ராஜாவின் கலக்கல் இசைக்காகவும் கமலின் குரலுக்காகவும் இந்த பாடல் எனக்கு புடிக்கும். உங்களுக்கு?

2000-க்கு அப்புறம் ராஜா இசையில் நான் ரசித்து வந்த சில விசயங்கள் குறைந்து போனது போல எனக்கு தோன்றும். எல்லாம் பீட்டும், கணிணி இசையுமா போனதின் தாக்கம் ராஜாவின் இசையிலும் கொஞ்சம் வர ஆரம்பித்தது. அழகாக ஒரு குரூப் வயலின் வந்து, அப்படியே ஒரு கோரஸ் சேர்த்து, Manual ட்ரம்ஸ் 'தும் தும்' என்று ஒரு உற்சாம் கொடுத்து..இப்படி அவரது ஒவ்வொரு பாடலிலும் ரசிக்க 1000 விசயங்கள் இருக்கும். அது 2000 க்கு அப்புறம் கொஞ்சம் மிஸ்ஸிங்.ம்ம்ம்ம்..நமக்கு வயசாகி போச்சு. இளவட்டங்கள் எப்படி விருப்புதோ அப்படி தானே (Current Trend) கொடுக்கமுடியும். தபேலா இசையை கேட்டாலே பத்திரிகைகளில் '80ஸ் மாதிரி இருக்கு. பழைய பாட்டு மாதிரி இருக்கு' என்று முத்திரை குத்தப் பட்ட ராஜாவின் இசை ஏராளம். இசை கருவிகளுக்கும் காலகட்டம் கொடுத்த நம்ம அறிவாளிங்கள என்ன சொல்ல. அப்போது தான் 'விருமாண்டி' வந்தது. அந்த படத்தில் ராஜா எவ்வளவு fresh-a வந்தார். அடடா! கமலுக்கு தான் அதில் பாதி பெருமை சேர வேண்டும். எல்லா பாடல்களையும் கமல் பாடினாலும், கேட்க ரொம்பவே நன்றாக இருந்தது. அதில் 'ஒன்ன விட இந்த ஒலகத்தில் ஒசந்தது' பாடலை படத்தில் பார்க்கும் போது, அந்த இருட்டும், நிலா வெளிச்சமும் அதை இசையில் ராஜா கொண்டு வரும் போது நாமே ஏதோ நிலவொளியில் இருப்பது போல தோன்றும். ஸ்ரேயா கோஷல் தன்னுடைய Limited உச்சரிப்பில் அழகாவே பாடி இருப்பார்.

கடைசியா, வித்யாசாகர் இசையில் 'அன்பே சிவம்' பாடல். தலைப்பு பாடல். 'அன்பே சிவம்' படத்தை பற்றி நம்ம தமிழ்மணத்தில் ஒரு 50 பதிவு வந்திருக்கும். வித்யாசாகர், அர்ஜுன் படங்களுக்கு ஆஸ்தான இசையமைப்பாளராக இருக்கும் போதில் இருந்தே எனக்கு பிடிக்கும். இந்த பாடலை கேட்ட சாணக்கியனிடமே பின்னூட்டத்தில் ஏதாவது சொல்வார் என்று விட்டுவிட்டு பாடலை போடுகிறேன்.
From: swathy on Fri May 26 4:41:01 2006.

Thanks selva
From: selvakumar on Fri May 26 5:02:33 2006.

swathy wrote:

Thanks selva

Welcome
From: Nakeeran on Fri May 26 9:01:09 2006.

For those MSV baitors, go through the write up by Mr. Saravanan SO THAT YOU ALL GET ENLIGHTENED.

I HAVE TO PUT THIS FOR THOSE TINY TOTS WHO KNOW LITTLE ABOUT MSV AND HIS MUSIC

This was the phase wherein TFM was undergoing a musical change in line with western music , the entry of ABBA & BoneyM

2006 marks 27 years of Premalaya�s ninaithaalE inikkum (released on 14th April 1979). The Telugu version Andhamaina Anubhavam was released on 19th April 1979. And the Hindi version Pyaara Tarana made its appearance belatedly in 1982 hoping to cash in on the popularity that Jayapradha and Kamal were enjoying in Hindi just then.

The astute KB thought it opportune to harness the cult following that Abba and Boney M enjoyed among the youth of the late 70s, and calculated that if he were to also throw in the exotic Singapore locales for good measure, the film ought to set the cash counters jingling. So he set about summoning writer Sujatha to put together a story of youthful romance, and sat with Kannadasan, (& Kannmani Subbu) and MSV to ensure that they came up with an immortal album.

Apart from the main actors, there were many miniscule, yet arresting characterizations: Geetha in the role of the receptionist hailing from Karaikkudi; Poornam Viswanathan the bet-loving father of Jayapradha (remember Toyota car versus sundu viral?); Jayasudha in the role of the elusive �anbarE� tape sundari, Saratbabu as one among her many victims; SV Shekhar as the man who helps unscrambling the enigmatic message in the cassette--all unforgettable cameos. Mention must be made of Saritha too for her invisible presence throughout the film as Sona�s expressive voice.

Interesting characterizations, slick screenplay interspersed with moments of hilarity, the magnificence of Singapore, KB�s stylish narration aimed at the youth (�iLaingnargaLukku samarppaNam� the closing credits proclaimed), the winning combination of Kamal and Rajini, the breathtakingly beautiful Jayapradha, an awesome musical score�with all these spectacular ingredients, KB�s calculations went awry, for the story itself, the mainstay of all KB creations, was a major letdown. In a reminiscent vein years later, Sujatha would philosophize: �Ninaithale Inikkum' for Balachandar was the first script I wrote for a film. Before that, my stories had been filmed, but I had not played any role in writing the screenplay or dialogue. For 'Ninaithale Inikkum,' I had written a totally different kind of screenplay. Unfortunately, owing to constraints like star dates, Balachandar did not follow my script exactly. He made several changes and looked at the film as an opera on the lines of Abba. My original script was lively and if it had been faithfully followed, it would have been a model screenplay. Anyway, no regrets and I enjoyed working with Balachandar, his assistant Ananthu, Kamal and Rajni.�

Yet we recall this film today, and with gratitude, for the wonderful songs that MSV filled its frames with. The late 70s on the whole, were not very happy years for MSV and his glorious era seemed to be nearing its end, but with ninathaalE inikkum, he seemed to have reinvented himself, and silenced his detractors with a fabulous album comprising 14 songs in all, each one chiseled lovingly to absolute perfection. While he retained SPB as the only male voice (apart from singing a song of boisterous revelry himself), he used the 4 celebrated divas of tfm to sing for Sona. �idhu oru thEnisai mazhai� screamed the hoardings, and a stupendous shower of magical music it sure was! Of course, there were occasional flashes of brilliance in his subsequent endeavors in the 80s, but ninaithaalE inikkum will forever be enshrined in the annals of tfm as the last tour de force album of the great Mellisai Mannar.

---------**-------------------------------------------------------------------**-----------

As Chandru is doodling (bright red lips, as usual, the insignia of his music group �Yours� Lovingly�) listlessly on a piece of paper, his mother comes with a determined air and raises the topic that she�s raised in vain so many times before- Chandru�s marriage. Chandru, exasperated at her undaunted perseverance, reminds her that he�s not a bachelor, but a widower, and storms out.

We then see him driving along Cathedral Road and his glance falls on the Music Academy---his thoughts fly back to the day when their group staged a show in its hallowed precincts, for it all began on that momentous day--

* * * * *

Chandru appears on the stage, and introduces the rest of his troupe- Deepak, the guitarist whose twin obsessions are singing in MSV�s voice and small-time kleptomania; Visu, whose two fixations are �drums and dames�; and Kamalakar Rao alias Mama.

A pretty girl finds her way down the aisle and seats herself. But why does she have a furtive look? We are soon to find out. Meanwhile, the audience, who are all frenzied fans of �Yours Lovingly� applaud and scream deliriously, and the magic begins--

1. engEyum eppOdhum sangeetham sandhOsham:

http://www.tfmpage.com/cgi-bin/stream.pl?url=http://www.dhool.com/sotd/enge.rm

Dodging his crazed fans adroitly, Chandru is seen entering his room in Hotel Chola, in preparation for their next show there. But he is surprised to see an unknown beautiful girl in his room (she is known to us, though- the same �furtive� female!). He assumes she�s another wild fan, and she plays along, going so far as to express her longing to become a guitar in his hands--a panicky Chandru rushes out seeking his friends. But when he returns with them, she�s not there. And there�s a legend emblazoned on the cupboard door- �I Love You� (with an �ea� inside the O).

The troupe is leaving to Singapore on their first tour abroad. Chandru is stunned to see his fleeting nocturnal visitor seated in the lounge of the airport, also waiting for the same flight. But when he accosts her, she coolly rebuffs them. He is not to be put off, and with the help of the ever-resourceful Deepak, manages to get a seat next to her in the flight. She pretends not to know him and seems immersed in her book (Heinrich Boll, no less!) But his persistence pays off, and as his clumsy attempts at palmistry amuse her, she finally bursts into peals of laughter and exclaims �I like you�. He is quick to respond with �I love you!�--Romance is in the air--literally!

2. vaanilE mEdai:

http://www.tfmpage.com/cgi-bin/stream.pl?url=http://www.dhool.com/sotd/vaanilemedai.rm

As the flight lands, Sona (for that is her name), disappears into the crowd, but not after Chandru manages to elicit her address. Chandru & friends look at the sights of Singapore with wonder, as they are taken to the Cockpit Hotel. Later Chandru and Deepak find that the address that Sona had given him belongs to a shop dealing in Chinese antiques! Chandru is dejected, and his frustration mounts as they happen to catch glimpses of Sona in a cable car, and later in a mall. He manages to talk to her in the mall, but she says she�s not Sona and rushes out.

The National Theater is packed to capacity, and their show is about to commence, when Chandru spies Sona, along with another man, seated amidst the audience. He sends a note to her asking her to come out, and goes to meet her. He remonstrates with her to give him her true address, but she seems reluctant--

Inside, the crowd gets restive. And Deepak, summoned to do some fire fighting, ignites the hall with an impromptu zestful performance, wherein he espouses his hedonistic philosophies in a delightfully irreverent song:

3. Sambo siva sambo:

http://www.tfmpage.com/cgi-bin/stream.pl?url=http://www.dhool.com/sotd/sambo.rm

Chandru manages to wrest out a promise from Sona to meet him the next day in Jurong Park. He sits expectantly on a picturesque bridge, and wonders if Sona would turn up for the rendezvous. The hours pass and presently--

4. What a waiting:

http://www.tfmpage.com/cgi-bin/stream.pl?url=http://www.dhool.com/sotd/whataw.rm

A fat man walking up the bridge shakes Chandru out of his reverie, and he realizes with disappointment that it was all a dream, and Sona had taken him for a ride again!

But when he returns to his hotel room, he finds Sona there! Tired of her antics, he speaks harshly to her, and tells her not to meet him again. Sona weeps, and pleads with him to give her some more time, and assures him that everything would fall in place soon. He believes her, and they snatch some idyllic hours together--we see them having fun in the skating rink, going up in the cable car, boating, praying devoutly in the Mariamman temple for this happiness to last---

5. Nizhal kandavan:

http://www.tfmpage.com/cgi-bin/stream.pl?url=http://www.dhool.com/sotd/nizhalkan.rm

Meanwhile, Deepak too is beset with frustrations�a female fan sends him a tape in which she expresses her love for him, and challenges him to find her address. He goes crazy trying to get the address, for that part of the message seems to be scrambled. He guesses that the pretty receptionist in the hotel may be this �tape sundari� and in the pretext of returning her chain which he had purloined earlier, he approaches her�she simpers and accepts that she was the elusive �tape sundari��Deepak�s joy knows no bounds--

6. Namma ooru singari:

http://www.tfmpage.com/cgi-bin/stream.pl?url=http://www.dhool.com/sotd/nammaooru.rm

As the joyous song ends, she pushes him from the roof, and Deepak wakes up with a startled scream�cha, it was all a dream; the real �tape sundari� is still elusive!

The four friends visit a nightclub, and are outraged to find Sona among the dancers. Chandru, in particular, is broken hearted at this unexpected turn of events.

Meanwhile, we get an insight into the aura of enigma surrounding Sona. We find Nicky (a guy who has been ominously shadowing Sona and Chandru everywhere) asking Sona for some �packet�, and Sona explaining that Chandru hasn�t brought that guitar from Madras. Nicky doesn�t buy her story, and jabs her with a needle.

Next morning, Chandru is shocked to discover Sona huddled in a heap on the road, and drags her to a nearby park. She seems to be in a drunken stupor; Chandru is disgusted at her inebriated state and walks off in a huff. Sona lures him back with this song of debauched abandon�

7. Anandha thandavamo:

http://www.tfmpage.com/cgi-bin/stream.pl?url=http://www.dhool.com/sotd/anandhath.rm

The mystery deepens as Chandru is beaten up next. And at last a remorseful Sona reveals all- apparently she had lost all her money in Madras, and this Nicky had offered her return airfare if she would smuggle in a small packet inside Chandru�s guitar. And that was why she broke into his room in Chennai. To her dismay, Chandru didn�t bring that guitar to S�pore, and it was to repay Nicky�s money that she was dancing in the nightclub. All clouds of mistrust get cleared.

To matters perfect, Deepak catches Nicky trying to surreptitiously enter their hotel room, and after a preamble of elaborate Bruce-like movements, clobbers him in style--

8. Thatti kEtkka:

http://www.tfmpage.com/cgi-bin/stream.pl?url=http://www.dhool.com/sotd/thatti.rm

And unceremoniously hanging him upside down, Deepak sends for the police.

The four friends, along with a radiant Sona, are all set to enjoy the rest of their stay, and go about painting the town red. Sentosa Island welcomes the joyous revelers--

9. Yaadhum Oorey:

http://www.tfmpage.com/cgi-bin/stream.pl?url=http://www.dhool.com/sotd/yaadhum.rm

In an intimate moment in a cable car, Chandru proposes to Sona, but she demurs telling him not to build castles in the air. Later, Chandru brings up the topic again, but Sona cleverly puts him off by challenging him to lie still for 3 hrs, and making him lose the wager by suddenly declaring that she has consumed poison--naturally a shaken Chandru gets up, falling for her ruse. Yet he doesn�t lose hope, and their romance continues, as they sing this bewitching duet:

10. Bharathi Kannamma:

http://www.tfmpage.com/cgi-bin/stream.pl?url=http://www.dhool.com/sotd/bharathi.rm

But his bliss is soon shattered --Sona informs him that her days are numbered as she is suffering from leukemia. An incredulous Chandru takes this as the next among her numerous inventions, but Sona seems serious as she solemnly avers that it was indeed the truth. Chandru doesn�t know what to make of this latest cruel twist--

11. You�re like a fountain:

http://www.tfmpage.com/cgi-bin/stream.pl?url=http://www.dhool.com/sotd/fountain.rm

Chandru is now convinced that Sona is speaking the truth. He wants to take her to the best doctor in S�pore, but Sona refuses, telling him wryly that it was the best doctor who had given up on her. She is resigned to her impending end, and tells Chandru to go back to India, while she passes on to heaven. The two of them weep together, as they recall the wonderful 3 weeks they had spent with each other, what precious memories--ninaithaalE inikkum--

12. Ninaithaale Inikkum:

http://www.tfmpage.com/cgi-bin/stream.pl?url=http://www.dhool.com/sotd/ninai.rm

Chandru takes an impulsive decision to take back Sona with him and marry her. But when he asks her father for his permission, he realizes that Sona has been pulling his leg again, for her amused father informs him that there is nothing wrong with her health, further, she�s betrothed to her cousin Vinod! Chandru is thoroughly disillusioned, and soon afterwards, they all leave Singapore.

As the flight soars in the sky, Chandru is down in the dumps, for he has left his heart behind--

13. Sayonara:

http://www.tfmpage.com/cgi-bin/stream.pl?url=http://www.dhool.com/sotd/sayanora.rm

It is then that a sheepish Deepak hands over a letter to Chandru that Vinod had given to him. Deepak had forgotten all about it! Chandru reads the letter and is elated, for Vinod had written relinquishing his claim to Sona, and telling Chandru that Sona is really in love with him. Chandru is overjoyed.

And when he reaches home, his cup of bliss is full�the ever-unpredictable Sona is already there, having reached Madras by an earlier flight! She still maintains that she is sick, but expresses her wish to be part of the music band. And so the ensemble, with the new addition, travel from place to place, performing to packed halls--

14. Inimai niraindha ulagam:

http://www.tfmpage.com/cgi-bin/stream.pl?url=http://www.dhool.com/sotd/inimai.rm
But Sona�s time is running out, and the doctors at HM Hospital in Madras too shrug their shoulders and point upwards. But inexorable destiny knows no second thoughts, and Sona�s condition deteriorates. Despite the nearing end, Chandru goes ahead with his decision and weds Sona, watched by his tearful mother and friends. And so Sona passes away peacefully, her last days filled with love and bliss.

* * * *

Chandru�s flashback comes to an end--Sona lives on in their memories, as they continue to make wonderful music--for the show must go on--

-----------**--------------------------------------------------------------------**------------

25 years have gone by, yet fond memories of ninathaalE inikkum endure�I was part of a big group of cousins who were enjoying the annual vacation in my aunt�s house in Pollachi. I was going to 4th std, and though among the youngest in the gang, I was already an avid tfm fan. I can still recall the high expectations amidst which ninaithaalE inikkum was released on Tamil New Year�s day, all of us going traveling to nearby Coimbatore to see it, and being dazed by the hypnotic spell of the songs. The film left a lasting impact on our impressionable minds, and the rest of the holidays passed in animated discussions regarding all aspects of the film, the stunning vistas of Singapore, and of course the songs--

For starters, we eschewed the �da� suffix and latched onto �la� as a more avant-garde suffix of address--- then we drove the elders to helpless rage by answering any uncomfortable query with a take-off on Sona�s enigmatic two-way nod--- and also adopted a casual shrug of the shoulders accompanied by a stylish �siva sambO� to any accusation of misdemeanor--- Of course, we had to repeatedly enact poor Rao�s �kudichittu pesaREnnu ninaikkadha--excuse me� dialogue, always followed by that hiccup--- Our female cousins poured scorn on Jayapradha�s short hair style (pure envy, we declared, as we looked with distaste at their well oiled and primly ribboned long braids)--- Heated exchanges that were sparked off by one cousin hinting that �sayanora� was inspired by �mamamia�, and another drawing similarities with �mil gaya hum ko saathi�--- I also remember petulantly wondering why I didn�t have a trendy name like Chandru or Deepak--- and sulking at the imponderable ways of the elders, when instead of praising me for an brilliant rendition (accompanied by strumming of an imaginary guitar) of �sambO sivasambO�, I was sternly rebuked for daring to sing impudent lines like �appavum thaathavum vandhaargaL pOnaargaL!�

Soon afterwards I had to part with my cousins as we went abroad, but I clutched tightly onto the precious memories of the summer of �79---

ninaithaalE inikkum!

ADHU !
From: Nakeeran on Fri May 26 9:08:00 2006.

If those 16 year old school going kids still doubt MSV, then May God Bless You !
From: selvakumar on Fri May 26 9:37:15 2006.

Quote:

If those 16 year old school going kids still doubt MSV, then May God Bless You

wow.. Seems some 2 year old school kid who called me "anneeeee" is coming up with this

NakeeRan,

1. Why only a single album to give as an example? Why not even a single album from IR era?
2. Why MSV was not able to make inroads into IR era. ?
3. Seems MSV has tried his level best to give the last one fine innings befor retiring.

But to pity your ignorance,
what I meant by the next generation is:

* The one which saw movies of MOHAN running purely for IR music without any mass element associated with it

* The one which created Tsunamis in the TFM with IR remaining the king in all the movies.

* The one in which KAMAL did some classic love cum action movies and not the TEENAGE dudes who can go crazy with the music

Like the one which remained in the hearts of many TEENAGE BOYS AND GIRLS during that period through MIKE MOHAN

* It was those days in which MSV was pretty happy with his retirement and restricted himself to his mystery circle

---------

But if you have a look at IR,

He still impresses the taste of the present generation with fine songs like:

* MaaLayiL vethaNai koottuthadi
kaathal than velaiyai kaattuthadi (Wonderful melody that makes everyone feel and explains the pain of love)

* chikaatha chittonnu chikkikitta (racy , youthful song)

* kaaNa karungauilae, kacherikku variya (perfect kuthu)
* iLaNgaathu veesuthey..

* Kombulla poovasuthuiii (A song with lots of kidding and mass elements and wonderful BGM)

* uNNai vida ... inda uLgathiL usanthathu yaarum illa (AGain.. wonderful melody)

NOW THE ULTIMATE FOR THE KH INTRO

VIRU...............VIRU.....MAANDI.. VIRUMAANDI
VIRU...............VIRU.....MAANDI.. VIRUMAANDI
VIRU...............VIRU.....MAANDI.. VIRUMAANDI

KiRagam vittu saami veliyaaerthu..
Saamy........

and the ones like

"சாந்து பொட்டு... அட சந்தன் பொட்டு.. எடுத்து.. வச்சுக்க
வச்சுக்கலாம"

* who will forget the unforgettable INGI IDUPPAAZHAGA

"இஞ்சி இடுப்பழ்கா.. மஞ்ச சிவப்பழகா.. மறக்க மனம்.. ..."

&

* Nee PaaRtha ... from CLASSIC HEYRAM

This is what we mean by SUITING THE TASTE OF YOUNGER GENERATIONS

You are talking about RAVICHANDRAN, JEYASHANKAR Younger generation songs .. dude..

P.S: BTW, It is not unfair to be a child if you have some brain.. unless age alone doesn't your capability..

Is it o.k TINY TOT... !
From: Nakeeran on Fri May 26 10:06:59 2006.

Selva Anne,

Neenga ippadi en avasarappatu oru ......... pola kudhicikondu vareenga
Edho ungalai thaan 16 year old kidsnu kuripiita madhiri
Ayyo ayyo ayyo .
Indha threadla pala per MSV patri onnum theriyamal post panni kondu irundhanga.

Naan kodutha post ellarukkum .

Ada pavamay.

Neenga dhaanu ninaichiteengala inga udanay vandhu Color Colora post panteenga

Naan ungalukku edhuvum solla mudiyadhu anne.
En endral Neengal enakku ANNE adhanal dhaan anne

Pogattum inniiku yaarkellam naatamai senjeenga . adha sollunga. udanay avanga ungalluku pinay vandhu thanks thanks endru solvangalay . Onnum kanomay anne
From: great on Fri May 26 10:13:18 2006.

Nakeeran wrote:

Ayyo ayyo ayyo .
Indha threadla pala per MSV patri onnum theriyamal post panni kondu irundhanga.

Muthalil Porulalar , Nuttu Aamai , Nakeerar vazgha

Anne yaarukku MSV pathi theriyama illa

Nee start panna title ungalukku maranthuruchu pola

ungalukku short term memory loss unda anne If so please take treatment immediatly.

Ungala mathiri isai Jeevikku entha problem varakudathu endru ellam valla Iraivanai prathikirean

Nakeerar vazgha
From: selvakumar on Fri May 26 10:15:26 2006.

Quote:

Naan kodutha post ellarukkum .

Nakeeran,

What an oxymoron from you?

If that post is meant for all (I repeat all who were on IR side) then

It must be selva first.

Why are you acting smart again?

From: Nakeeran on Fri May 26 10:16:45 2006.

great wrote:

Nakeeran wrote:

Ayyo ayyo ayyo .
Indha threadla pala per MSV patri onnum theriyamal post panni kondu irundhanga.

Muthalil Porulalar , Nuttu Aamai , Nakeerar vazgha Very Happy

Anne yaarukku MSV pathi theriyama illa

Nee start panna title ungalukku maranthuruchu pola Sad

ungalukku short term memory loss unda anne Confused

If so please take treatment immediatly.

Ungala mathiri isai Jeevikku entha problem varakudathu endru ellam valla Iraivanai prathikirean Surprised

Nakeerar vazgha Not Worthy

Engal thanai thalaivar Great Annan pugaz onguga

Vatradha jeeva nadhiyay varuga

Stock market wizarday varuga varuga

Ungal Vaigai valavan

From: Nakeeran on Fri May 26 10:21:56 2006.

selvakumar wrote:

Quote:

Naan kodutha post ellarukkum .

Nakeeran,

What an oxymoron from you? ROTFL

If that post is meant for all (I repeat all who were on IR side) then

It must be selva first.

Why are you acting smart again? ROTFL

Selva Anne,

Eppodhum naan dhan ellarayum sirikka vaipen anaal indraikku

Anne oru sandhegam, 5 natkal munbu nam common nanbar Nilavupriyar ennai Mohanlal threadukku azaithar . Sila questions ketar. Adharku nan badhil sonna pinbu AVAR ESCAPU
Engay anne avar ? Vlasam vlasam iruka anne

Pona varam avar pavam. Ippodhu yaar yaaro .

Idhu manidhar unarndhu kolla idhu manidha Nakeeran alla. Adhaiyum thaandi Punidhamanavan

Indraiku vera joke vendam anne. Vitrunga.

From: selvakumar on Fri May 26 10:27:18 2006.

Nakeeran THAATHA,

ASIN PAATI aduchutaaNgaLa ! uNga COMEDYKKY alavae illa.

THAATHA,

UNgala pparthu unga comedykku OORAE sirichathae..

maranthuteengala.

NILAVU won't come to the hub often. adukkaaga avan illaatha neram paarthu nakkala.. VEKKAMAA ILLA THAATHA.

uNga COMEDY INDA THREAD LA THODARATTUM.

Asin PAATI EPADI IRUKKA

From: Nakeeran on Fri May 26 10:28:23 2006.

great wrote:

Nakeeran wrote:

Ayyo ayyo ayyo .
Indha threadla pala per MSV patri onnum theriyamal post panni kondu irundhanga.

Muthalil Porulalar , Nuttu Aamai , Nakeerar vazgha Very Happy

Anne yaarukku MSV pathi theriyama illa

Nee start panna title ungalukku maranthuruchu pola Sad

ungalukku short term memory loss unda anne Confused

If so please take treatment immediatly.

Ungala mathiri isai Jeevikku entha problem varakudathu endru ellam valla Iraivanai prathikirean Surprised

Nakeerar vazgha Not Worthy

Great Anne,

Oru siru thirutham.

SELECTIVE AMNESIA

From: selvakumar on Fri May 26 10:33:18 2006.

THAATHA,

YOu suffer from FULL TIME MEMORY LOSS.. not AMNESIA

Ida vache ASIN ah correct panniteeNga pola irukku
From: great on Fri May 26 10:49:33 2006.

Nakeerar Anne

athu enna asin matter

ELOVE
From: Nakeeran on Fri May 26 10:53:44 2006.

great wrote:

Nakeerar Anne

athu enna asin matter

ELOVE

Great Anne,

Ennaku migavum pididhavanga rendu per :

1. Superstarini 9dara
2. Sadha

Kannil noorazagu kayil noolazagu unaal boomi azagay !
From: Thirumaran on Fri May 26 11:23:52 2006.

Innum intha topic discussions mudiyalayaa
From: Alien on Fri May 26 13:44:04 2006.

Nakeeran Anna !! (Maddy anne )
I was thinking how r u gonna support IR over ARR or anyone !! U urself have made urself well known to others !!

This topic is quite ridiculous !!
V all agree on MSV's greatness !! But then to call there was a combo better than IR - KAMAL in tamil film history !! isn't that blasphemy !! ??

Mayb MSV had been more consistent with Kamal than IR ! (Thatz bcos IR had composed to a lot of masala junk movies of Kamal in 80s ) ! But IR- Kamal combo had scored 1000/100 on more than many occasions , for ex:- like Guna, Mahanadhi, Sippikkul muthu, Salangai Oli, Hey raam, Punnagai Mannan, Sigappu rojaakkal , Sakala kala vallavan, Aboorva sagodharargal, Virumaandi, Thevar magan, Naayagan, Moonraam pirai, 16 vayathinilE, etc, etc .....

For me Kamal - IR combo is the best thing I have come across in tamil films !! and the best films r Guna, Sippikkul muthu, Thevar magan, Mahanadhi, raja paarvai etc ......

I have never listened to nor will I ever listen to albums like Guna , Mahanathi, Naayagan , Sippikkul Muthu .......
Kamal - IR is UNDOUBTEDLY the best !!!!!!!
From: Sinthiya on Fri May 26 23:53:36 2006.

only IR....
From: Sinthiya on Fri May 26 23:55:40 2006.

-delete-
From: Sinthiya on Fri May 26 23:56:10 2006.

-edited- ....not my fault....
From: Justice on Fri May 26 23:57:47 2006.

are you excited?
From: Sinthiya on Sat May 27 0:03:04 2006.

no, Justice......

i don't know why......
From: Surya on Sat May 27 18:03:33 2006.

Ilayaraja all the way.

ARR - Indian...it was alright.

Baradhwaj - Vasool Raja. Very Average.

Harris Jeyaraj - VV. Pretty Cool

But no one matches with Raja who created masterpieces for Kamala Haasan.
From: Renault on Sat May 27 23:50:21 2006.

ARR has only tenali and indian to back his credentials. It is Raja all the way, undoubtably. This thread mught close soon as the obvious verdict is out.
From: Villan on Sun May 28 7:14:40 2006.

Renault wrote:

ARR has only tenali and indian to back his credentials. It is Raja all the way, undoubtably. This thread mught close soon as the obvious verdict is out.

eventhough he had 2 chance he proved his talent...

so my vote is to ARR
From: shalitha on Sun May 28 17:17:45 2006.

only Ilaya Raja,, kudigara parama kudigara...
From: best on Mon May 29 1:25:05 2006.

My first post :
Look at it this way...

If u talk about best of IR , it might feature Mohan before Kamal or Rajini
If u talk about best of MSV, it will mainly feature Sivaji, MGR.. Kamal or Rajini may not even get a place there..
But that cannot imply that Kamal and Rajini are not good actors...

Similiarly.. When u say best of Vijay.. Deva might get the first place.. Does that mean Deva is better than IR..

If u want to vote about bets singer for KAmal, it might end with SPB or KJ or Kamal himself..

PB Srinivas, Raja all might not be there.. Does that mean Srinivas and Raja have not contributed anything.. Its not that.,.

When we stick to the topic and see, the Kama-IR duo is the best..
I dont see any reason that such a choice wud degrade MSV.. IR will have no votes when u say Best MD for Sivaji or Best MD for MGR. MSV
will win there hands up...

So the comparison between IR and MSV is baseless as they are best in their own ways.. So please dont degrade any of them in ur worthless fight..
From: Scale on Mon May 29 3:36:43 2006.

indha kadhavayum CTla vulla innoru kadhavayum serthu adachi periya poota pottu, IR seal vaikkum padi MODai thaazhmayudan kettu kolgiren.

Actorukkagha adhigha padam music pottadhu MSV, IR mattum thaan. IR will easily win if taken for KH/RK as he has done the max movies and most of his memorable songs are at his/their peak time which really lifted them parallely.

From: Nakeeran on Mon May 29 8:25:39 2006.

Scale wrote:

indha kadhavayum CTla vulla innoru kadhavayum serthu adachi periya poota pottu, IR seal vaikkum padi MODai thaazhmayudan kettu kolgiren.

Actorukkagha adhigha padam music pottadhu MSV, IR mattum thaan. IR will easily win if taken for KH/RK as he has done the max movies and most of his memorable songs are at his/their peak time which really lifted them parallely.

Scale , the thread is not properly addressed by anyone IMHO.
Some guys around here are not even willing to think about other MDs and MSV in particular & thats why I feel there is total bias & prejudice towards IR.
this forced me to write more about MSV . Though IR is my idol, I admire MSV's classics & after all before IR, its was MSV who was ruling the TFM for long
It seems some friends around here have little knowledge about MSV and this made me to enlighten them
If you run through the posts of some of the guys DEGRADING MSV YOU WILL BE STUNNED

That shows the level of ignorance they have

From: great on Mon May 29 8:28:27 2006.

Vannakam`nna

check the topic before posting something

Just like that you cant say others are not aware off MSV maybe you can be musical genius but others also will be having ideas of music directors

vazgha porulalar

From: Nakeeran on Mon May 29 8:34:54 2006.

great wrote:

Vannakam`nna Tongue Out

check the topic before posting something Evil or Very Mad

Just like that you cant say others are not aware off MSV maybe you can be musical genius Razz

but others also will be having ideas of music directors

vazgha porulalar Very Happy

Vanakamna. Anaa neenga mattum ille, pala posts vandhirukku . Silar dhan matra MDs patri kuripitaanga. Silar MSV patri tharam thaanzdhu vimarsanam seidhaanga. MSV patri onnum theriyama avar patri tharakuraiva vimarsanam seivadhu thappungna

Alladhu isai patriyay edhuvum theriyadhona

Edhukuna sanda namakulla. Neenga ennduya nanbarna

Unga madhipla MSV epperpattavarna . Sollungna

From: selvakumar on Mon May 29 9:00:57 2006.

Quote:

Though IR is my idol

Comedy of the year !
From: Nakeeran on Mon May 29 9:31:07 2006.

selvakumar wrote:

Quote:

Though IR is my idol

Comedy of the year !

Selva Anne,

vanakamne, adhu ennamo theriyala enna mayamo puriyala. neenga vandha than threade kalakala irukku anne appadi enna jadhu poteenga anne
Anne, oru vinnappam. Neenga MSV patri soona karuthukala pala varundangal kazithu unga pera pullainga padichittu ungalai paarthu KATI KOTTI SIRIKKA PORANGA ANNE
Ippo kooda onnum kettu poidala anne. Edit pandunga pls.

Anne, oru vinnappam anne. Isayai patri theriyadhenral vittu vidungal. adharkaga MSV pondra oru medhayai tharam kuraithu madhipittu ungalai patri pirar ariya vazi seyadheergal.

Ungalukku endru oru group undu. avanga varutha paduvanga anne indha madhiri post seidhal

Anne IR patri enakku pidikkum enbathal naan matravargalai patri kurai koora maateen because enakku oralavukku isai patri theriyum anne
adhilum MSV , ARR pondravargal potrathakavargal.

Neengal solvadhal avargalin tharam kuraindhu vidaathu. Pugaz perugum anne
From: selvakumar on Mon May 29 9:40:16 2006.

Nakeeran THAATHA,
It was not me who ridiculed legends like Shivaji, KH, IR etc .
It was you who ridiculed them.

It is funny to see you asking me to edit my posts. I am not a coward to edit my posts and disappear in the middle. I stick to my point. YOu have not yet answered my question. That is the deal here>

Answer it first ! IT was your unnecessary provocation that went ahead in this thread.

Just point out any single negative comment about ARR from me (in this thread). If that is the case, then ARR fans might have jumped here this time.

They know very well that I dont have any favorite MDs. I enjoy all type of songs. eNakku ENDA PARADESI MUSIC POTTALUM, paatu naLLa iruKKuthaaNNu kirathu thaan mukkiyam

But for this topic, We don't require special knowledge. IT is crystal clear. When it comes to KH, it is IR WHO IS THE MAN. That doesn't mean that MSV is not good. But if you take MGR, SHIVAJI era, MSV IS THE MAN

I will accept that if you start a thread for that. But don't expect me to accept your view with a force. I will never ever do it

Apart from us, most of the people will convey the samething. It is funny to see you starting threads with the intention of ridiculing legends like

* IR
* KH
* NT
etc

Considering that, I won't edit my posts. I stick to my point. regarding MSV and IR in this thread.

P.S: I don't require a GROUP to post my views. Even I can manage people like u single handedly and ofcourse without putting a mask like an IR FAN (like u)
From: Nakeeran on Mon May 29 10:08:32 2006.

Thanks anne. Normalla color poduveenga. Innaiku theerndhu poidicha anne.
vidunga adhai.

Neenga MSV patri adicha comment podhuvana comment anne .

avarudaya ulagatha vittu veliyay varalanu soneengale adha marandhuteengala anne !

En anne, konjam sollunga. Endha threadla naan IR patri mosama pesinen ?

En anne, Rajinikku ARR 3 padangal dhan kodugthanga. Avarukku niraya padangal illadhu podhu eppadi anne avarai kuraithu madhipida mudiyum anne.
I was stressing this point in Rajini's MD thread anne. Ippo cleara anne ( marubadiyum cleara padinga anne andha threadai )
adhu mattum illa, andha threadla pala nalla IR padalgal list panirken anne. Parunga. Ungalukku theriyadho ennamo andha padalgal .adhanal than vambukku vareenga.

Indha threadukku varuvom anne ippo :
Naan solluvadhellam ondru anne. IR mattum dhan ungal kannuku therikiradha anne. En neenga matra MDs , in particular MSV patri konjam kooda sollamal oruthalai patchamaga decision koduthuteenga anne .
adhu thappu anne.
Anne neenga enakku annanaga irundhalum neenga thappa onnu sonna naan correct pannuven anne.

Nandrianne
From: Nakeeran on Mon May 29 10:12:54 2006.

[quote="selvakumar"]Just point out any single negative comment about ARR from me (in this thread). If that is the case, then ARR fans might have jumped here this time.

They know very well that I dont have any favorite MDs. I enjoy all type of songs. eNakku ENDA PARADESI MUSIC POTTALUM, paatu naLLa iruKKuthaaNNu kirathu thaan mukkiyam

Anne, not only in this thread, everywhere its apparent that you are a hardcore IR fan . adhan thulli kudhicikondu vareenga. Neenga oru neutral fan illa anne. Appadi ilaata oru MVS paatavadhu kuripiteengala inga ? ellaye anne.

Neenga thapi thavari ARR patri onnum solladheenga anne. avaru pudhuyugam padaicha oru king anne
From: selvakumar on Mon May 29 10:21:41 2006.

Nakeeran THAATHA,
1) I do accept that the works of a COMBO should not be rated based on the number of films. But the number of quality albums that they have given should be taken. That is why IR - KH combo has an edge over IR - MSV combo.

2)I think you are suffering from SHORT TERM MEMORY LOSS. Visit the same RK's MDs thread. You have referred IR as a big headed person etc. esp in subjects related to his works with MR. IT was you who ridiculed IR. Just refer your comments in that thread.

3) Just coz that ARR had done 3 movies, should we have to take it for making him the BEST MD for RK. (forgetting the number of movies that IR had done with IR - which remain in the HALL OF FAME)

4) I asked you a question regarding MSV not coming out of his world. I still stick to my point. But you have never given the answer yet. But without answering our questions, you have the habit of
* Ridiculing others' opinion
* JUmping to a different point when people are putting their points on the table
* Using DUMB Jargons like Anne, sirippu varuthu etc
Just answer my question related to MSV rather than blabbering

5) All the hubbers here are mentioning one point.. This topic calls for who is the best MD for KH. IF that has to be considered, that has to be IR. If u think that it is MSV, suppy the proof and rate these two MDs as per their ALBUMS. I bet you cannot do that.. coz IR will win hands down ! I am asking the same question posted by GREAT.

Why on earth you should ridicule the comments of RAMI, SWATHY, A_A etc when they say that IR is the best.. (their opinion) and want to force ur opinion on others.

P.S: THAATHA, NeeNga ETHANAI THADAVAI THAPPU SENJAALUM, UNGALA PORUMAIYAAI THIRUTHUVAAAN

UNGAL ANBU PERAN,

Selva
From: selvakumar on Mon May 29 10:25:57 2006.

Nakeeran THAATHA,

NeeNga mattum MSV pathi soLLaLaam.. NaaN ARR pathi soLLa koodaatha.

I never ever respect any MD and praise their albums without salt.
I appreciate the good works of all MDs..
Generally I stay away from criticising the not so good works of MDs.

IF ARR IS A PUDHUYUGAM PADAITHA KING, THEN IR --- IS ALSO THE SAME WHEN IT COMES TO ERA AFTER MSV..

But IR still proves his touch beyond generation. He competes with young people..

Even now, He gives KUTHU, MELODY ETC songs that can suit the taste of the Young people.
This is my point.. Not necessary that others like u should accept it
From: selvakumar on Mon May 29 10:28:03 2006.

NakeeRan THAATHA,

If I am an IR fan, then FIRST OF ALL I MUST HAVE STOPPED REPLYING TO UR BLABBER ... rather than replying to you.

IR, ARR, YOUTH MSV.. yaara iRunda eNakeNNapppaaaaa!!!!

Naan eNNa ivaNgalukku KADAN VAANGITTU THIRUPPI THARALAYA

Why should I care / respect them anyway ?

From: Nakeeran on Mon May 29 10:41:37 2006.

selvakumar wrote:

Nakeeran THAATHA,
1) I do accept that the works of a COMBO should not be rated based on the number of films. But the number of quality albums that they have given should be taken. That is why IR - KH combo has an edge over IR - MSV combo.

QUALITY ALBUMS :

Good point anne

1. Apoorva ragangal
2. Avargal
3. Moondru mudichu
4. Nizal nijamagiradhu
5. Varumayin niram sigappu
6. Ninaithalay inikkum
7. Manmadha leelai
8. Uyarndhavargal
9. Savaal

Anne, indha padangal ellam ungaludaya QUALITY listla varadha anne

Anne, naan kuripitta ovvoru padangalum KAMAL 80 VAYASANALUM PESAPADUM PADANGAL ANNE . andha padalgal NIRANDHARAMANAVAI

Anne, neenga cricket rasigar pola. Ok. Endha vilayataga irundhalum, oru alavukku than anne irukka mudiyum. Vayadhu, anuvabavam, uzaippu, ellam kanakkil kollunga anne.
MSV pavam migavum vayadhavanavar. Avaridam neenga enna thaan edhipakuringa anne idhaivida.
Ungalukku theriyumo theriyadho, Kamal even during mid 70s ( his formative years ) was already a NEXT GENERATION FOR MSV because MSV generation was NT & MGR anne.
Anna, MSV tired agala anne. Salaikama thaan naan kurippata andh above list vandhadhu.

Anne, MSV oru medhai anne.

Thayavu seidhu valaratrin pakkangalai purati parthu vittu inga vanga anne.

Konjam time eduthukunga

Bye anne

From: selvakumar on Mon May 29 11:04:23 2006.

Nakeeran THAATHA,

Just like how others put, If we have to list the NUMBER OF QUALITY albums, then IR will win hands down (with KH ofcourse)

with great trouble, You have listed a few good albums of MSV.
Just like that, We can list many GOOD ALBUMS OF IR - KH COMBO.

This combo lived even after the change that took place in the taste of the audience for music.

Be it VIRUMAANDI, HEY RAM etc IR still rules when it comes to KH and others.
That means... He continues to play some of the BEST STROKES IN THE RECORDs and thereby providing a competition to others and ofcourse with his MAESTRO TOUCH.

Whereas MSV just survived for sometime towards the end of MGR era and the beginning of KH era (at that time, he was not that much popular like how he was after that)

During those periods, IR not only RULED TFM but also cope up with the expectations that people had on him.

so, WHEN IT COMES TO QUALITY + QUANTITY > IR wins hands down

But the point here is : YOu are dealing with PRO - KH generation which had the taste of Sivakumar, Jeyashankar touch. Not the usual KH - RK touch.

IR made inroads into the MSV area at this time with spectacular albums and MSV couldn't resist his penetration.

But IR,, even though ARR and other MDs made inroads into his place, HE STILL RETAINS HIS TOUCH AND CATERS TO THE EXPECTATIONS whenever he joins with KH.. and ofcourse with people like BALA etc.

MSV lacked this important thing. IT is pretty easy to say that A PLAYER PLAYED WELL ON THAT PERIOD. BUT AFTER THAT

Remember u criticised, IR fans in some thread for not accepting works of ARR.
Nee ippo Inga ENNA PANNURA... OORUKKUTHAAN UPADESAMA.. uNakku iLLaya..

BTW, We never said that MSV was not a genius. But he lost his touch when IR made inroads into his career and he failed to bounce back during that period (due to the skills displayed by IR on that time)

THAATHA, To tell the truth, We won't require much time.. If I had lie like you, then I HAD TO WAIT LIKE U

Answer my QUESTION related to MSV - world and his failure to achieve like IR over generations.

Don't divert again

Ippadikku,
UNGAL ANBU PERAN,
Selva
From: selvakumar on Mon May 29 11:06:23 2006.

Nakeeran THAATHA,

I am sticking to the topic .. and post comments as per KH - IR combo.

Don't divert this again as IR VS MSV just like how you have been doing till now.
From: Nakeeran on Mon May 29 11:34:32 2006.

Anne, nandri anne.

Ellavatrirkum vayadhu endra oru kanakku irukiradhu anne. Neengalum naanum siru vayadhu ippodhu. namaal edhayum seyya mudiyum.
anaal, namakku oru 50 alladhu 55 vayadhu vandhavudan thanagavay udalum ullamum thalarndhu vidum anne.
Idharku peyar DEPRECIATION / DEPLETION

Namma udal oru machine dhan anne.

Kamal munnukuvarum kala katathilay ( 70s ) already for MSVikku avar next generation anne. Idhai naan soonaa insult seireenga ! idhu nalla joke anne ! anaa vilakkam innum varala idharku
Ungallukku theriyadha, MSV age group enna, Kamal age group enna vendru !

Pala murai ungallukku puriyumbadiyaga migavum thelivaga nan idhai eduthu sonnen anne. Anaa neenga ????

Onnu oppukolgiren anne manam thirandhu.

neenga mudhalil pota posts compare seidhal ippodhu konjam yosithu post seivadhu pola therigiradhu anne. Vaazthukkal anne !

Neenga Virumandi isaya paratureenga . IRukendru oru scale irukiradhu anne. Avar seidha sadhanai scale during 80s . Andha padalgalukku opitaal, Virumandi ambel anne.
Indha unmai avarukkey theriyum.
Adharkaga avarai kurai solla mudiyadhu . en endral during 80s avarudaya ilamai kalam.
Ippodhu 63 + anne avar.

Naan great troubeloda podala anne.

Ulagamay ariyum MSV padalgal endha alavukku Kamalukku lift koduthirukiradhenru.

especially :

Irumanam konda thirumana vaazvil
Kadavul amaithu vaitha medai
Vasantha kala nadhigalilay
Engeyum eppodhum
Kamban emandhan

indha list romba perisu anne. Indha padalgal innum pesa paduginrana anne.

Moderator NOV oru arumayana post seidhar !
Unmayana MSV fans should stop from posting endru.
Ayirathil oru vaarthai anne !

Avar solvadhu mutrilum unmai anne.

Vishayam puriyadhavanga kitte enna sonaalum seya mudiyadhanne !

Neenga sadharanamana aal ille anne.
Mathavanga MSV patri kuripittu , IR best endru sonnargal.
anaa neenga Muyalukku 3 kaalnu innum irukeenga.

Bye bye anne.

romba nandrianne for today's thamash
From: great on Mon May 29 11:41:03 2006.

anne ......... okka nimisham

Onga Depreciation part varaikkum padichean

Ennoda sitrazhavukku puriyala if you dont mind could you echplain pleach
From: selvakumar on Mon May 29 11:41:51 2006.

Nakeeran THAATHA,
Again you are running and ofcourse with your regular diversion. When people here commented on IR - KH combo's greatness, u ridiculed / laughed at them

But when we did the same "NAANGA ARGUE PANNALA AND U ARE QUOTING NOV'S SIGNATURE"

The samething "RAJASARNAM" mentioned in RK thread too.. IR fans walkout. Till now , We are the people who are discussing it.

IT was only you who is telling that IR lost his touch that he had in 80's.. ANY HARDCORE OF IR WILL NEVER COMMENT LIKE THIS.. ONLY A FAN OF OTHERS (ARR, MSV, ETC) will come up with this kind of comment.

According to you, MSV satisfied pre - kh generation.. but IR didn't do that for this generation.

eNNa logic pa idu? This itself is enough to prove how BIASED YOU ARE TOWARDS OTHERS AND NOT WITH IR.

It is Straight !
IF what we have done is DEPLETION / DEPRECIATION, then what can we term the one that you have done for IR here? IT is 100 times more than what we have done for MSV

Thanks for YOUR EVERGREEN cOMEDIES !

IPPADIKKU,
UNgal anbu peran,
Selva
From: Sinthiya on Mon May 29 11:51:18 2006.

....wow....good job Nakeeran and Selva...you guys can write so much (very passionate about this topic)...impressive...

From: Nakeeran on Mon May 29 12:01:43 2006.

selvakumar wrote:

IT was only you who is telling that IR lost his touch that he had in 80's.. ANY HARDCORE OF IR WILL NEVER COMMENT LIKE THIS.. ONLY A FAN OF OTHERS (ARR, MSV, ETC) will come up with this kind of comment.

According to you, MSV satisfied pre - kh generation.. but IR didn't do that for this generation.

ROTFL

eNNa logic pa idu? This itself is enough to prove how BIASED YOU ARE TOWARDS OTHERS AND NOT WITH IR. Laughing

It is Straight !
IF what we have done is DEPLETION / DEPRECIATION, then what can we term the one that you have done for IR here? Laughing

IT is 100 times more than what we have done for MSV

Thanks for YOUR EVERGREEN cOMEDIES !

IPPADIKKU,
UNgal anbu peran,
Selva

Selva Anne,

So as per your definition of a hardcore fan, HE SHOULD HAVE BLIND FOLLOWING.

nalla theory anne !
Onnu gavanicheengala neenga ? I have never blasted IR anne . ayyo ayyo. Ennudaya IR class vera , neenga pakura IR class vera anne. adharkaga naan IR patri kuraithu madhipida maten anne.

Meendum oru murai ella threadukkum padithu vittu vanga anne. You will learn more about IR music from my posts

IR class of 80s theriyuma anne ungalluku ? ketrukeengala andha padalgalai anne

Ketirundha neenga nichayam ippo varum padalagalai thothiram panna mateenga anne.
70s and 80s IR isai venuma anne ungalukku .

Nenjathai killadhey parunga, Johnny parunga anne
Aradhanainu oru padam vandhadhu theriyuma anne. Adhula oru paatu iruku theriyuma anne. Ilam pani thulir ? Kellunga anne. Isai patri konjam kathupeenga . Appodhu puriyum , ennudaya IR yaar endru

From: rajasaranam on Mon May 29 12:21:28 2006.

nakeeran,

What is your agenda over here though it seems you want to find out the best ever MD for KH movies your malicious intent of demeaning IR is very much evident from the summation of your posts.
why do you want to discuss on a thing for which you have already formulated a opinion- that 'MSV is the Best ever MD for KH movies'. Keep that opinion of yours within yourself or change the topic discussion to 'MSV is the Best Ever MD for KH movies' and call all MSV fans to discuss upon it. then we shall refrain from entering this topic

If you really want to find out the real best MD... well whats there to find out or discuss the Truth lies before your eyes err...ears

MSV 2% [ 1 ]
IR 75% [ 30 ]
ARR 22% [ 9 ]

And whose vote was cast for MSV here? is it yours or umaramesh's
From: Justice on Mon May 29 12:31:16 2006.

rajasaranam wrote:

MSV 2% [ 1 ]
IR 75% [ 30 ]
ARR 22% [ 9 ]

And whose vote was cast for MSV here? is it yours or umaramesh's

he sounded like a MSV fan but voted for ARR
From: great on Mon May 29 12:31:58 2006.

avar vottu sella ottu

From: Nakeeran on Mon May 29 12:50:13 2006.

rajasaranam wrote:

nakeeran,

What is your agenda over here Rolling Eyes

though it seems you want to find out the best ever MD for KH movies your malicious intent of demeaning IR is very much evident from the summation of your posts.
why do you want to discuss on a thing for which you have already formulated a opinion- that 'MSV is the Best ever MD for KH movies'. Keep that opinion of yours within yourself or change the topic discussion to 'MSV is the Best Ever MD for KH movies' and call all MSV fans to discuss upon it. then we shall refrain from entering this topic
Huh?!

If you really want to find out the real best MD... well whats there to find out or discuss Confused

the Truth lies before your eyes err...ears

MSV 2% [ 1 ]
IR 75% [ 30 ]
ARR 22% [ 9 ]

And whose vote was cast for MSV here? is it yours or umaramesh's Razz

rasasaranamna,
Vanakamna,

When a topic like this is given, one should analyze the MDs who were instrumental in giving best numbers for Kamal & then conclude. THMHO. Ok ?
Though I started the topic, I took up MSV as a case study for analysis ( doesnt mean that IR is not worthy ) because after IR, MSV gave maximum numbers to Kamal.

SOME ARE UNILATERAL IN HEAPING PRAISES ON IR
SOME ARE KEEN TO DEGRADE MSV & his classics
SOME WHO HAVE NO IDEA ON MSV BLAST HIM

I realised that its MOST IMPORTANT TO HIGHLIGHT TO NOVICES , ABOUT MSV AND HIS MUSIC AND HIS MUSICAL ACHIEVEMENTS ,SOME TIME IMMEMORIAL COMPOSITIONS WHICH WERE WAY AHEAD OF TIME !

In the process, I have been stamped as MSV FAN !

Arent you appreciating MSV music ?

Dont you realise that the list given by me are GEMS of MSV

Not even a single post of mine degrades / downgrades IR & his music AS I CAN EMPHATICALLY SAY THAT I KNOW IR BETTER THAN THE GUYS AROUND HERE

I pity the height of ignorance about MSV

About what I know about IR, I gave a glimpse of his gems and after that some guys are ESCAPU

From: Scale on Tue May 30 0:49:58 2006.

Dign\

FH is conducting an interview with Singer Naresh Iyer. Link is in CT's.
http://forumhub.mayyam.com/hub/viewtopic.php?t=7058

Without being ******, atleast for the sake of FH's effort please post your Q's & make it a grand success..

Thanks.

End Dign.
From: selvakumar on Tue May 30 1:08:15 2006.

Nakeeran THAATHA,

Please answer our question.. It is you who is escaping again and again.... Not us.. and you are cleverly digressing into a different corner.

None of us initially said that MSV's albums are not worth of salt. It was you who ridiculed them to the core with the intent of achieving some crap advantage

Till now, No one degraded (apart from me and a few others). They just said their opinion.

uNakku aen valikkuthu.. eLLarum IR ah pathi ezhuthuna.. neeNga periya paruppu maari mathavanukku onnu theriyaathunnu neeyae karpanai pannura

Just answer our previous questions:
----------------------------------

Don't escape again and again. YOu are CORE IR - HATER who has come up under IR fan umbrella to gain cheap advantage.

Don't think that people are not knowing about your intentions. They are aware of the proceddings.

Again I repeat)
----------------
1)Why MSV failed to retain the KINGDOM beyond generations and handed it over to IR ?

2)Why he was not able to penetrate into IR era just like how IR is doing with classics like HEYRAM, Virumaandi etc

Just answer these questions

Don't RUN AWAY AND DIVERT THE DISCUSSIONS
From: selvakumar on Tue May 30 1:12:51 2006.

Nakeeran THAATHA,

Answer this:

RAMI was explaining about Heyram and virumaandi. What was your reply to her>

Check this out :

http://forumhub.mayyam.com/hub/viewtopic.php?t=7044&postdays=0&postorder=asc&start=30

This shows your intentions clearly It was you who brought this one.

With the intent of ridiculing IR..

Vekkamaa iLLa uNakku..

ippadikku,
ungal ANBU PERAN,

Selva

From: rajasaranam on Tue May 30 1:18:57 2006.

Justice wrote:

rajasaranam wrote:

MSV 2% [ 1 ]
IR 75% [ 30 ]
ARR 22% [ 9 ]

And whose vote was cast for MSV here? is it yours or umaramesh's Razz

he sounded like a MSV fan but voted for ARR ROTFL

great wrote:

avar vottu sella ottu

From: selvakumar on Tue May 30 1:24:06 2006.

ONE MORE IMPORTANT POINT

Till now, SOMEONE HAS CASTED A SINGLE VOTE FOR MSV;

If it is umaramesh,
It is clear that Nakeeran has voted for IR / ARR.. If It is for IR.. then he has accepted the fact now.. If it is for ARR, he is acting smart

IF it is for MSV, then he doesn't know how to appreciate the great works of others
From: rajasaranam on Tue May 30 1:53:01 2006.

nakeeran thambi Vonakkom,

Inge yaarum MSV sappainnu sollala. Semma paatellam keethupa avar pottathu kamalthaasan padthukku. Aana inge kovisteen innanna, yaaru besta potukeerango...Kaeviya eyupinathu neethan. Badhilum neeyae solra maeri irntha innathukku inga venthu veena prachnai panninnu keera...enganna theniya poi sovurenda ninnukeenu solla vendiyathu thaenae.

nayiru oyi mayayil, kamben yemaanthaan, sooniaar sooniar, athisiya raagom... pattellam naanga kettukeerom athellam superthaanu othukirom...aana meedum meendum vaa, pattu kannam, vaaniley thaenila, enge en thevathai, naanaga naanillai, vanithamani, germaniyin...maeri paatellam pottu engala gusipadthuna thalai Raasaiyyavukkuthaan athikapetcha vote kedikkum. itha pirinjikaama 20 pakkam itanthutiyae engala paesi paesi...innatha solrathu . aapeesla velai illeena ithu maeri thaan ethunna panninnu irpiyaa

NOM summa sokku maeri padi ithaa
From: selvakumar on Tue May 30 2:08:14 2006.

I love "GERMANIYIN SENTHENMALARAE" very much.
A soft song which gives you the feel of romantic melody the moment it starts !

I mean.. IF we consider all these MDs, it is IR who varied himselfas per the generation change.
He composed tunes for KH when he was young.
He is composing tunes for him till now.

Even then he comes up with classic beats that can mesmerise everyone.
The HEYRAM melody itself is a soung example.
I mean "NEE PAARTHA"

Also,
I think IR is more versatile when it comes to KH songs. He gives him folk songs, melodies, etc and ofcourse serves it in his own style with a modern touch.
From: terminator on Tue May 30 3:03:32 2006.

innum intha thread uyiroda irukka.....

From: Nakeeran on Tue May 30 8:22:22 2006.

rajasaranam wrote:

nakeeran thambi Vonakkom,

Inge yaarum MSV sappainnu sollala. Semma paatellam keethupa avar pottathu kamalthaasan padthukku. Aana inge kovisteen innanna, yaaru besta potukeerango...Kaeviya eyupinathu neethan. Badhilum neeyae solra maeri irntha innathukku inga venthu veena prachnai panninnu keera...enganna theniya poi sovurenda ninnukeenu solla vendiyathu thaenae.

nayiru oyi mayayil, kamben yemaanthaan, sooniaar sooniar, athisiya raagom... pattellam naanga kettukeerom athellam superthaanu othukirom...aana meedum meendum vaa, pattu kannam, vaaniley thaenila, enge en thevathai, naanaga naanillai, vanithamani, germaniyin...maeri paatellam pottu engala gusipadthuna thalai Raasaiyyavukkuthaan athikapetcha vote kedikkum. itha pirinjikaama 20 pakkam itanthutiyae engala paesi paesi...innatha solrathu Banging Head

. aapeesla velai illeena ithu maeri thaan ethunna panninnu irpiyaa Razz

NOM summa sokku maeri padi ithaa Smile

Tanksna . Neenga konjam visayam therinja aalnu ninaikirenna. Adhanal than konjam MSV patri solreenga. Anaa inga silar pavamna . avangalukku theriyadhuna. Neenga fulla padichuparungna. Appa puryumna. Oray tamas dhana . Avangalukku onnu poriyaleengna. Avangaloda perapulainga 30 varsam kayichi MSV paatai kepangna appo avanga adicha thamash patri kai kotti siripangna. Adha than naan sollavandhengna .
Oruthar ravusu udrarna inga. Msvkku oru circle vuttu varlengrarna.
Avarudaya circle rumba perisunu solungna .
Enakku IR kadavulungna , adhukaga mathavanga patai naan rasikakodadhangna ! enna nyayamna idhu.
Rajini threadla kooda na ARRukku chance rumba kodukama avar isayai pathi eppadingna comment seya mudiyumna ? idhai naan sonna , naan oru IR baiter ? ARR fans in disguise ?
Sirippu dhaan varudhungna.

Anna, atleast neenga oru IR pattavadhu list paneengna. koodave gunsa MSV patayum solreengna. neenga oru nadunilayana alungna. anaa mathavangna

enku ippa enna sandhegamna , silarukku Ir patri kooda romba suluva theriyumanga ? doubtakeedhungna

Naan oru Ir list koduthengna netru. Adhuku onnum badhil kanumna. AVUNGA ESCAPU ngna

From: Nakeeran on Tue May 30 8:27:44 2006.

selvakumar wrote:

ONE MORE IMPORTANT POINT

Till now, SOMEONE HAS CASTED A SINGLE VOTE FOR MSV;

If it is umaramesh,
It is clear that Nakeeran has voted for IR / ARR.. ROTFL

If It is for IR.. then he has accepted the fact now.. If it is for ARR, he is acting smart ROTFL

IF it is for MSV, then he doesn't know how to appreciate the great works of others ROTFL

Selva Anne,

Naan innum ottu poda villai anne . Enna anne ippadi solluputeega

Naan uruvakiya threadukku, naane eppadi anne vote poda mudiyum

manasatchinu onnu irukuanne

pogatumne. Indraya joke edhavadhu sollunga anne ! na romba late arrival today anne

From: selvakumar on Tue May 30 8:31:35 2006.

Quote:

Naan oru Ir list koduthengna netru. Adhuku onnum badhil kanumna. AVUNGA ESCAPU ngna

Nakeeran THAATHA,

This is today's comedy from you.. Yesterday you listed MSV songs.. Not IR

Seems you are not aware of what you are posting

Tell us : WHO IS POSTING IN YOUR ID?

Nee VeNa vetti yaa irukaLaam.. naan iLLa ! from this crap thread you had created

THAMBI MSV VAAZHGA !
AVARODA ANNA NAKEERAN THAATHA VAAZHGA !

ippadikku,
avarin anbu peran
Selva

From: Nakeeran on Tue May 30 8:47:45 2006.

selvakumar wrote:

Quote:

Naan oru Ir list koduthengna netru. Adhuku onnum badhil kanumna. AVUNGA ESCAPU ngna

Nakeeran THAATHA,

This is today's comedy from you.. ROTFL

Yesterday you listed MSV songs.. Not IR ROTFL

Seems you are not aware of what you are posting

Tell us : WHO IS POSTING IN YOUR ID? ROTFL

Nee VeNa vetti yaa irukaLaam.. naan iLLa ! Wave

from this crap thread you had created

THAMBI MSV VAAZHGA !
AVARODA ANNA NAKEERAN THAATHA VAAZHGA !

ippadikku,
avarin anbu peran
Selva

Wave

Quote:

Nenjathai killadhey parunga, Johnny parunga anne
Aradhanainu oru padam vandhadhu theriyuma anne. Adhula oru paatu iruku theriyuma anne. Ilam pani thulir ? Kellunga anne. Isai patri konjam kathupeenga . Appodhu puriyum , ennudaya IR yaar endru

_________________

Selva anne,

unga prachnaye idhu dhaan anne

nethu dhaan anne naan indha patellam kuripiten anne

Adha pakalaya anne.
Dhayavu seidhu previous page parunga anne

anne, ippo marubadiyum enakku Moderator Nov sonna unmai vilangudhu

en anne, oruvelai, naan kuripitta padalgal ungalukku theriyadha anne ? I mean those Ir songs !

Anne, aradhanai paatu onne podhum anne. IR PUGAZ PATRI PESA . Adhu vandha varudam ungallukku theriyuma anne

pala varundangal munbe avar sarithiram padaithavar anne ennudaya IR

Naan marubadiyum onnu solren anne.

Enkitte modha varum munbu, nanraaga ella experts check pannunga

piragu neen mudhalil enna soneenga endru padithu parunga

piragu , unga aniyinarukku PM podunga

Groupa vanga anne.

Ayyo ayyo. ennavendru solvadhamma.

From: selvakumar on Tue May 30 9:08:05 2006.

Nakkeran THAATHA,

NaLLa samalippu

I meant your IR songs that were meant for KH .. you didn't understand that dude..

You WILL NEVER EVER ANSWER MY QUESTIONS (POSTED EARLIER HERE)

Now, YOU CONSIDERED NOV'S MESSAGE IN THIS THREAD.. BUT NOW I REMEMBER NOV'S SIGNATURE

YOu will proclaim this as if I ran away from the argument

BUT THE TRUTH IS > YOU NEVER ANSWERED MY QUESTIONS ON MSV

IGNORANCE IS BLISS. That suits you well.

Periya paruppunna THAATHA ADA ANSWER PANNU.

Selva

BYE DA THAATHA
From: great on Tue May 30 9:22:16 2006.

Nakeeran wrote:

Enkitte modha varum munbu, nanraaga ella experts check pannunga

who are those experts

By anychance you meant urself to be expert

From: Nakeeran on Tue May 30 9:22:22 2006.

selvakumar wrote:

Nakkeran THAATHA,

NaLLa samalippu ROTFL

I meant your IR songs that were meant for KH .. Laughing

you didn't understand that dude..

You WILL NEVER EVER ANSWER MY QUESTIONS (POSTED EARLIER HERE)

Now, YOU CONSIDERED NOV'S MESSAGE IN THIS THREAD.. BUT NOW I REMEMBER NOV'S SIGNATURE
ROTFL

YOu will proclaim this as if I ran away from the argument ROTFL

BUT THE TRUTH IS > YOU NEVER ANSWERED MY QUESTIONS ON MSV ROTFL

IGNORANCE IS BLISS. Laughing

That suits you well.

Periya paruppunna THAATHA ADA ANSWER PANNU.

Selva

BYE DA THAATHA Wave

Ayyo ayyo anne

Kamal - IR list pathi naan dhan anne first 2 pages parunga !
ungalukku theriyadha pala padalgal angum irukku. list paniiruken anne.
Unga prachnaye idhan anne. Seriya padika mateenga . anaa kudhicikondu avasaramaga varuveenga. pavamne neenga.

naan than sonene anne. Medhuva padichitu vanga anne

Anne, enakku ippo oru sandhegam. Yaarukku selective memory anne

From: Nakeeran on Tue May 30 9:24:53 2006.

Nakeeran wrote:

Moonram pirai is another classic from IR

Enakkul oruvan is another

Ofcourse sakalakala vallavan was a commercial movie but IR was there as well

Kaaki sattai was one more

MSV :

Avargal

Manmadha leelai

APOORVA RAGANGAL !

Selva anne,

marubadiyum padinga anne. Ir list irukudhu anne

From: Nakeeran on Tue May 30 9:26:55 2006.

Nakeeran wrote:

Rajaparvai
Guna
Apoorva sagotharargal

3 OUTSTANDING MOVIES OF IR !

Selva anne,

marubadiyum padinga idha anne

ADHU
From: Nakeeran on Tue May 30 9:29:07 2006.

great wrote:

Nakeeran wrote:

Enkitte modha varum munbu, nanraaga ella experts check pannunga

who are those experts

By anychance you meant urself to be expert

Greatna,

vanakamna.

Unga kaladila kidakira oru kevalamana oru jandhu anne naan.

Unga level varuma.

naan Expertnu kuripitadhu ungalathan anne

ungaludaya siruthondanna
From: Shakthiprabha. on Thu Jun 1 4:46:15 2006.

IR
From: great on Sun Jun 11 5:46:41 2006.

IR is the best

Aboorva sagotharargal TITLE music by IR

http://www.coolgoose.com/music/song.php?id=95070

still more to come

| RSS Feed | Email me when a reply is posted

Want to post a response?

(Hello Guest, you need to Login to post a response. Are you a New User? Register first.)

Back to Tamil Films Archived forum