Concept Ondru, Iruveru padangal (Robin Hood Vs Ramana)

The Hub : Tamil Films Archived

Hello Guest, Login to post.

Topic started by bingleguy on Tue Apr 11 6:35:14 2006.

Hi all

I happ to the film Naan Sigappu Manidhan yest ! i wish to relate that with a similar concept film Ramana !

I see a lot of similarities n ofcourse the way things were handled in the story ! I would like to share some of the similarities with all

Simi
===

1. Both films have heroes who live 2 LIVES , one as a Teacher and the other as a man-hunter

2. Rajini n VJ kanth, both acts as a Professsor in a college !

3. In both the movies, there is a THIRD brain which finds the culprit(so called good ppl) in the film. NSM has Bhagiyaraj n Ramana has Yuhi sethu, both from Police dept

4. Both of them Surrender and are put under trial, and argument goes on as their acts are against only brutal ppl n not good ones !

Here are few points which i could co-relate with both the movies ... there might be many .... so i request ppl to contribute with more points !

Poll
Does similar concept in two movies affect its performance in the BOX office !
Yes [ 2 ]
No [ 7 ]

| RSS Feed | Email me when a reply is posted

Responses:

From: sgokulprathap on Tue Apr 11 6:38:57 2006.

BG, ur poll question is meaningless.
Both movies did well @ box-office.
From: bingleguy on Tue Apr 11 6:44:26 2006.

Oh well ... i guess u didnt get it ... that quest was a general one ... relatively think about all the movies in such a cadre ...

we can also discuss other same concept movies !
From: selvakumar on Tue Apr 11 6:45:52 2006.

BG / Vasanth,

It depends on lot of factors.

Though in both the movies, the concept was a bit similar, the SUCCESS OF THE FILM RELIES HEAVILY ON HOW BEST THE DIRECTOR CAN DIFFERNTIATE THE TWO.

BUT I think RAMANA WAS MORE LIKE INDIAN + NSM.

So, the SUCCESS DEPENDS ON THE SCREENPLAY (DIRECTOR)

for E.g,

Many movies copied OKKADU.. ghilli was a superhit.. bUt aayudam and saravana flopped.
From: bingleguy on Tue Apr 11 6:48:34 2006.

Well said Selva !

Success definitely depends on SCREENPLAY !

Ghilli was a HIT ... ys .... yup Aayudam did not do well !

Does Nayagan have any clone ?
From: sgokulprathap on Tue Apr 11 6:51:07 2006.

Absolutely Selva
From: selvakumar on Tue Apr 11 6:55:10 2006.

bg & GOKUL - Thanks

Vasanth,

Nayangan didn't have a clone. But Many people like chinni jeyanth did that VELU NAYAKKAR GETUP for comedy
From: sgokulprathap on Tue Apr 11 6:55:40 2006.

bingleguy wrote:

Well said Selva !

Success definitely depends on SCREENPLAY !

Ghilli was a HIT ... ys .... yup Aayudam did not do well !

Does Nayagan have any clone ?

No.
Nayagan was completely on a different track.
From: bingleguy on Tue Apr 11 6:57:18 2006.

nayagan hasnt inspired any other films ????

or how many films do we have with similar concepts !
From: sgokulprathap on Tue Apr 11 7:00:28 2006.

Not many films tried the storyline of nayagan,
bcoz everyone know it cant b better than nayagan.
From: bingleguy on Tue Apr 11 7:02:04 2006.

i guess Indian Vs Ramana Vs NSM can form a TRIO or even a TRIANGLE ! wat say ?
From: sgokulprathap on Tue Apr 11 7:02:08 2006.

There r certain stories which only certain heroes can do.
Nayagan is one such story. No one else except Kamal can do such movies.
From: bingleguy on Tue Apr 11 7:02:43 2006.

hahahah very true gokul !

how about Vikram in Indian ????
From: bingleguy on Tue Apr 11 7:03:19 2006.

Does Citizen and one more Vikram's movie have similar line stories ????
From: sgokulprathap on Tue Apr 11 7:03:40 2006.

bingleguy wrote:

i guess Indian Vs Ramana Vs NSM can form a TRIO or even a TRIANGLE ! wat say ?

i don think so.
From: terminator on Tue Apr 11 7:03:52 2006.

A comparison of Pithamagan and Pattiyal..

Both are double hero subjects.

In both movies one of the hero was handicapped.

Rendu padathulaiyum oru hero jollyana aalu..

Climax Jollyana herova villan konnuduvaangaa..

Innoruthar antha villana pazhi vaanguvaar...

Both the movies were hit.. The screenplay were different..
From: terminator on Tue Apr 11 7:06:04 2006.

bingleguy wrote:

Does Citizen and one more Vikram's movie have similar line stories ????

mm ya..

Also Vaanathai Pola and Anandham had smilar story lines..
From: sgokulprathap on Tue Apr 11 7:07:05 2006.

terminator wrote:

In both movies one of the hero was handicapped.

R u sure
From: terminator on Tue Apr 11 7:10:17 2006.

sgokulprathap wrote:

terminator wrote:

In both movies one of the hero was handicapped.

R u sure

In Pithamagan, Sithan dont have the knowledge of the world and emotions of the peoples (mentally he is handicapped)

In Pattiyal.. Bharath was deaf and dumb..

Both of them cant speak..
From: sgokulprathap on Tue Apr 11 7:13:00 2006.

But mental disability is different from physical one.
From: terminator on Tue Apr 11 7:14:51 2006.

Then take that point as this

Both the heros cant speak..
From: Ghlli on Tue Apr 11 7:26:55 2006.

....i dont think so....
From: Raikkonen on Tue Apr 11 11:02:53 2006.

Ghiilli and Sandakozhi
From: terminator on Tue Apr 11 11:22:37 2006.

Jeyam - Ghilli - Mazhai - Saravana

The above movies have almost same plot..

They all remade from Telugu...

In telugu all these movies were HIT.
From: Raikkonen on Tue Apr 11 11:26:18 2006.

Jayam - Telugu - SUPERHIT (Nitin, Sadaf)
Jayam - Tamil - HIT (Ravi, Sadaf)

Okkadu - Telugu - Blockbuster (Mahesh Babu, Bhumika)
Ghilli - Tamil - Blockbuster (Vijay, Trisha)

Varsham - Telugu - Blockbuster (Prabhas, Trisha)
Mazhai - Tamil - Average (Ravi, Shriya)

Bhadra - Telugu - Super Hit (Raviteja, Meera JAsmine)
Saravana - Tamil - Average (Simbhu, Jothika)

Varsham, Okkadu, Bhadra all had similar story...
From: sgokulprathap on Wed Apr 12 1:22:23 2006.

terminator wrote:

Then take that point as this

Both the heros cant speak..

Sithar paattellam paaduvaru.

| RSS Feed | Email me when a reply is posted

Want to post a response?

(Hello Guest, you need to Login to post a response. Are you a New User? Register first.)

Back to Tamil Films Archived forum