Mumbai express.......... WHY DID IT FAIL?

Topic started by Shakthiprabha. on Sun Apr 9 12:34:07 2006.

| RSS Feed | Email me when a reply is posted

Responses:

• From: Kadavul on Sun Apr 9 12:36:42 2006.

  Kamal can beat anyone The simple reason was that people are appealed to fantasy than quality
  
  

• From: terminator on Sun Apr 9 12:38:04 2006.

  The timing comedies were not understood by the B&C center audiences..
  
  I think it is the major reason..
  
  

• From: Shakthiprabha. on Sun Apr 9 12:41:08 2006.

  comeon guys.............
  
  i am a fan of both
  
  i know kamal gives quality
  i like quality than entertainment too.
  
  kamal's other pics with qual.ity has faired well.
  
  this was sheerly or mostly because WHEN IT COMES TO BOX OFFICE RAJNI RULEZ..........
  
  kamal cant over take rajni in BO. its the fact.
  
  

• From: Kadavul on Sun Apr 9 12:46:48 2006.

  It cannot be termed as one of Kamal's best movie. Kamal rulez in everything, I like Rajini too . Because Rajini releases his movies after everything three year, lots of efforts will be put into it. The expectation will be high.
  
  If Kamal release his movies like Nayakan or Indian after every three years, they'd pummel anyone.
  
  

• From: great on Sun Apr 9 12:46:58 2006.

  Shakthiprabha wrote:

  so............. why? it could not compete rajni's 'Chandramukhi'

  
  
  enna kodumai ithu SP
  
  

• From: Nerd on Sun Apr 9 12:47:19 2006.

  This thread will be locked in <12 hours, I bet my shirt
  
  The reason for MX failure: The movie was mediocre CM is not a great movie but atleast it was better than MX in quality as well
  
  

• From: great on Sun Apr 9 12:48:43 2006.

  CM quality movie compared to MX
  
  

• From: Nerd on Sun Apr 9 12:49:18 2006.

  yeh yeh keep rolling.. The truth is already out
  
  

• From: ajithfederer on Sun Apr 9 12:49:41 2006.

  mx is a better attempt in comedy than cm which was a remake
  
  

• From: kb on Sun Apr 9 12:50:16 2006.

  CRazy mohan didnt write dialogue for MX...
  
  if he had..... then the result would be different
  
  

• From: Ghlli on Sun Apr 9 12:50:27 2006.

  I still havnt watched MX and i will not watch it unless i'm dead bored.
  
  well i dont think anyone could win against rajinis films cos he's known as the king of BO and super star, but doesn't mean they are the best and quality films but his films just run for more
  
  

• From: Nerd on Sun Apr 9 12:50:50 2006.

  Yes thats a remake, agreed. Remember the original script won a national award. P.Vasu had massacred it, but anyways the original story and the screenplay were damn good so that even after a massacre the movie came out good!
  
  

• From: kb on Sun Apr 9 12:52:13 2006.

  ajithfederer wrote:

  mx is a better attempt in comedy than cm which was a remake

  
  
  
  kashtam
  
  

• From: terminator on Sun Apr 9 12:53:25 2006.

  Digital filming attempt worked in only QUBE Cinemas installed theatres and in ordinary theatres the picture was very dull..
  
  

• From: Kadavul on Sun Apr 9 12:54:08 2006.

  hail jothika for her performance in CM
  
  

• From: ajithfederer on Sun Apr 9 12:55:56 2006.

  ashtam naa go and see a doctor.......
  

  kb wrote:

  ajithfederer wrote: mx is a better attempt in comedy than cm which was a remake kashtam

  
  

• From: ajithfederer on Sun Apr 9 12:56:49 2006.

  
  

  Kadavul wrote:

  hail jothika for her performance in CM

  
  

• From: kb on Sun Apr 9 12:57:21 2006.

  Kadavul wrote:

  hail jothika for her performance in CM

  
  
  
  
  http://www.behindwoods.com/tamil-movie-news/apr-06-01/09-04-06-rajini-fans.html
  
  

• From: great on Sun Apr 9 12:59:14 2006.

  Movie which are hit cannot be termed as Quality movie
  Movie which is flop need not be Bad movie
  
  Mx falls under the later category...... i dont need to explain on the other movie
  
  

• From: Kadavul on Sun Apr 9 12:59:32 2006.

  kb wrote:

  Kadavul wrote: hail jothika for her performance in CM http://www.behindwoods.com/tamil-movie-news/apr-06-01/09-04-06-rajini-fans.html

  
  
  what a joke
  
  

• From: Nerd on Sun Apr 9 12:59:37 2006.

  kb wrote:

  Kadavul wrote: hail jothika for her performance in CM http://www.behindwoods.com/tamil-movie-news/apr-06-01/09-04-06-rajini-fans.html

  
  
  
  
  Hey find the news of MX 365th day..
  
  

• From: nilavupriyan on Sun Apr 9 13:01:31 2006.

  Nerd wrote:

  This thread will be locked in <12 hours, I bet my shirt The reason for MX failure: The movie was mediocre CM is not a great movie but atleast it was better than MX in quality as well

  
  
  QUALITY...?...SEMA POWERMA?...SEMA MATTERMA... IDHAN QUALITYYA KASI?
  
  

• From: Nerd on Sun Apr 9 13:02:29 2006.

  Hey I was talking about the story and screenplay!
  
  btw, u promised something.. am still waiting
  
  

• From: Shakthiprabha. on Sun Apr 9 13:25:31 2006.

  I agree with kasi, when he says CM had good story and screenplay THAN mx (though CM was an inspired movie )
  
  CM ws diff
  MX ws repetition
  
  

• From: nilavupriyan on Sun Apr 9 13:26:31 2006.

  Shakthiprabha wrote:

  I agree with kasi, when he says CM had good story and screenplay THAN mx (though CM was an inspired movie ) CM ws diff MX ws repetition

  
  
  repition?..repition of what?
  
  it had out and out different comedy!
  
  

• From: villan007 on Sun Apr 9 13:27:37 2006.

  sp akka ,
  
  ippo intha thread ethuku open paneenga ....
  
  

• From: great on Sun Apr 9 13:27:51 2006.

  nilavupriyan wrote:

  Shakthiprabha wrote: I agree with kasi, when he says CM had good story and screenplay THAN mx (though CM was an inspired movie ) CM ws diff MX ws repetition repition?..repition of what? it had out and out different comedy!

  
  
  The movie is about comedy of error, new of it kind in tamil cinema.
  
  

• From: Shakthiprabha. on Sun Apr 9 13:28:08 2006.

  comeon.............
  
  same olddddddddddd stereo type comedy dialogues by CRAZY MOHAN............
  
  it had story....... but v.v.v. poor climax. kinda incomplete.
  
  

• From: great on Sun Apr 9 13:29:14 2006.

  Shakthiprabha wrote:

  comeon............. same olddddddddddd stereo type comedy dialogues by CRAZY MOHAN............ it had story....... but v.v.v. poor climax. kinda incomplete.

  
  
  You mean to say CM had good screenplay dir cant take credit of the story though
  
  

• From: Shakthiprabha. on Sun Apr 9 13:31:41 2006.

  great, I dont deny, its a diff type of story which he wanted to present............
  
  somewhere.........................someway..... he missed
  
  I am still contemplating what......... I am clueless at times......
  
  so i blame it all on BO KING rajni
  
  I WOULD SAY CM WAS REALLY GOOD
  
  jyo swept the show
  rajni was presentable
  story was good
  direction was yucky
  
  but over all nice x(
  
  

• From: Ghlli on Sun Apr 9 13:32:14 2006.

  ok well every knows CM is just 100 times better than MX.
  
  

• From: nilavupriyan on Sun Apr 9 13:33:24 2006.

  Shakthiprabha wrote:

  comeon............. same olddddddddddd stereo type comedy dialogues by CRAZY MOHAN............ it had story....... but v.v.v. poor climax. kinda incomplete.

  
  
  sp...did u see mx first..it doesnt have crazy mohan type dialogues
  
  dialogues by kamal!..and they were diff
  
  

• From: Kadavul on Sun Apr 9 13:33:37 2006.

  Ghlli wrote:

  ok well every knows CM is just 100 times better than MX.

  
  
  you said you didn't watch MX, right?
  
  

• From: villan007 on Sun Apr 9 13:34:45 2006.

  enaku left-hand driving varathu.......
  
  

• From: Shakthiprabha. on Sun Apr 9 13:36:05 2006.

  nilavu,
  
  I watched both in THEATRE.
  
  So..........i know it
  
  the dissapointment I had with MX...... WITH KAMAL
  
  
  esp after watching CM......... AND SUCH IMPACT IT CREATED
  
  cute-gaayu
  
  

• From: villan007 on Sun Apr 9 13:37:07 2006.

  Shakthiprabha wrote:

  esp after watching CM......... AND SUCH IMPACT IT CREATED

  
  
  horror stories create much impact than comedy movies..
  
  

• From: nilavupriyan on Sun Apr 9 13:37:16 2006.

  so u r creating a thread now!
  
  whats the significance of creating it now?
  
  

• From: Shakthiprabha. on Sun Apr 9 13:38:32 2006.

  why should I answer, WHY I CREATED A THREAD NOW??????????
  
  I JUST WANTED TO.
  
  SO I DID
  
  any probs?
  
  villain........
  
  hmmmmm.......... u have a point. That is why i said, ITS CM which swept MX of its due credit may be
  
  

• From: Ghlli on Sun Apr 9 13:38:41 2006.

  ya i havnt watched
  
  but CM has done nearly a whole year now while MX just losttttt
  and comedy vs action....
  
  action wins
  and i'v seen 3 or 4 scenes on sun tv... utter crap...
  

  Kadavul wrote:

  Ghlli wrote: ok well every knows CM is just 100 times better than MX. you said you didn't watch MX, right?

  
  

• From: Shakthiprabha. on Sun Apr 9 13:40:17 2006.

  gaayu,
  
  MX is not crap
  
  believe me...... its riots of laughter first half.
  
  second half ...... is............. kinda not bad...... hmmmmm... okei......... tolerable......... good (for kamal's sake)
  
  climax very bad
  
  

• From: nilavupriyan on Sun Apr 9 13:41:16 2006.

  Ghlli wrote:

  ya i havnt watched but CM has done nearly a whole year now while MX just losttttt and comedy vs action.... action wins and i'v seen 3 or 4 scenes on sun tv... utter crap... Kadavul wrote: Ghlli wrote: ok well every knows CM is just 100 times better than MX. you said you didn't watch MX, right?

  
  
  yeah kids like cartoon movies...the flying of rajni would have attracted u
  
  

• From: Kadavul on Sun Apr 9 13:41:50 2006.

  It takes a billgate to enjoy MX.
  
  So no problems
  
  

• From: villan007 on Sun Apr 9 13:42:35 2006.

  Kadavul wrote:

  It takes a billgate to enjoy MX. So no problems

  
  
  
  
  

• From: Djpak on Sun Apr 9 13:48:04 2006.

  YEA, this is the truth songs bad of the year, cause of Illayaraja and then flopped the movie!
  
  

• From: Kadavul on Sun Apr 9 13:49:32 2006.

  Djpak wrote:

  YEA, this is the truth songs bad of the year, cause of Illayaraja and then flopped the movie!

  
  
  Ah aah flopped because of AR Rahman
  
  

• From: villan007 on Sun Apr 9 13:49:56 2006.

  Djpak wrote:

  YEA, this is the truth songs bad of the year, cause of Illayaraja and then flopped the movie!

  
  
  Dont bring in your IR vs ARR fite here..
  
  

• From: kb on Sun Apr 9 13:50:50 2006.

  Djpak wrote:

  YEA, this is the truth songs bad of the year, cause of Illayaraja and then flopped the movie!

  
  
  Dj.. u r starting a new battle man. i dont know where this is goin to end..
  
  ur signature tell all abt u.. watch out for replies
  
  

• From: great on Sun Apr 9 13:51:47 2006.

  Djpak wrote:

  YEA, this is the truth songs bad of the year, cause of Illayaraja and then flopped the movie!

  
  
  if you cant appreciate good music dont blabber.
  
  

• From: kb on Sun Apr 9 13:52:31 2006.

  Kadavul wrote:

  Djpak wrote: YEA, this is the truth songs bad of the year, cause of Illayaraja and then flopped the movie! Ah aah flopped because of AR Rahman

  
  
  worst arguement of the year...
  
  i dont want to start an digr..
  
  

• From: Kadavul on Sun Apr 9 13:54:31 2006.

  kb wrote:

  Kadavul wrote: Djpak wrote: YEA, this is the truth songs bad of the year, cause of Illayaraja and then flopped the movie! Ah aah flopped because of AR Rahman worst arguement of the year... i dont want to start an digr..

  
  
  worst argument CM ran for rajini
  
  

• From: Ghlli on Sun Apr 9 13:55:13 2006.

  well the scenes i watched were just like
  

  Shakthiprabha wrote:

  gaayu, MX is not crap believe me...... its riots of laughter first half. second half ...... is............. kinda not bad...... hmmmmm... okei......... tolerable......... good (for kamal's sake) climax very bad

  
  

• From: Ghlli on Sun Apr 9 13:55:58 2006.

  no his style, action, story etc. flying rajini was just like WTF?!
  

  nilavupriyan wrote:

  Ghlli wrote: ya i havnt watched but CM has done nearly a whole year now while MX just losttttt and comedy vs action.... action wins and i'v seen 3 or 4 scenes on sun tv... utter crap... Kadavul wrote: Ghlli wrote: ok well every knows CM is just 100 times better than MX. you said you didn't watch MX, right? yeah kids like cartoon movies...the flying of rajni would have attracted u

  
  

• From: Kadavul on Sun Apr 9 13:56:37 2006.

  Ghlli wrote:

  well the scenes i watched were just like

  
  
  my little cousin watche few scenes from CM in the thirai vimarsanam. the scenes that were shown are double meaning ones and few.......
  
  she didn't watch CM till now
  
  

• From: Ghlli on Sun Apr 9 13:56:49 2006.

  ok fine just dream that u r bill gates
  
  

  Kadavul wrote:

  It takes a billgate to enjoy MX. So no problems

  
  

• From: Kadavul on Sun Apr 9 13:57:12 2006.

  Ghlli wrote:

  no his style, action, story etc. flying rajini was just like WTF?!

  
  
  Rajini fan vazhga
  
  

• From: Ghlli on Sun Apr 9 13:58:19 2006.

  hmmmmmm CM went on thirai vimasaram?????????????????????
  
  ya MX went on thirai vimasaram the week is released thts where i saw the scenes, so ur cousin decides to watch funnny cartoons rather than gd chandramukhi...or maybe she's scared...
  

  Kadavul wrote:

  Ghlli wrote: well the scenes i watched were just like my little cousin watche few scenes from CM in the thirai vimarsanam. the scenes that were shown are double meaning ones and few....... she didn't watch CM till now

  
  

• From: Ghlli on Sun Apr 9 13:58:47 2006.

  
  

  Kadavul wrote:

  Ghlli wrote: no his style, action, story etc. flying rajini was just like WTF?! Rajini fan vazhga

  
  

• From: Kadavul on Sun Apr 9 13:59:44 2006.

  Ghlli wrote:

  hmmmmmm CM went on thirai vimasaram????????????????????? ya MX went on thirai vimasaram the week is released thts where i saw the scenes, so ur cousin decides to watch funnny cartoons rather than gd chandramukhi...or maybe she's scared...

  
  
  I convinced my other cousin that CM is also a cartoon movie with many graphics. She watched it but after watching King Kong, she says King Kong is betta
  
  

• From: Ghlli on Sun Apr 9 14:03:31 2006.

  IN ur earlier post the last line says
  
  she didnt watch CM till now
  
  then u say u convinced her too and she says king kong is better
  
  
  
  ok so CM is better than MX and king kong is better than CM.
  
  king kong is far more better than MX in that case.
  

  Kadavul wrote:

  Ghlli wrote: hmmmmmm CM went on thirai vimasaram????????????????????? ya MX went on thirai vimasaram the week is released thts where i saw the scenes, so ur cousin decides to watch funnny cartoons rather than gd chandramukhi...or maybe she's scared... I convinced my other cousin that CM is also a cartoon movie with many graphics. She watched it but after watching King Kong, she says King Kong is betta

  
  

• From: nilavupriyan on Sun Apr 9 14:06:25 2006.

  Djpak wrote:

  YEA, this is the truth songs bad of the year, cause of Illayaraja and then flopped the movie!

  
  
  poo poothadhu is one of the best!
  
  

• From: Kadavul on Sun Apr 9 14:07:10 2006.

  I think you didn't now read it carefully. I said my OTHER COUSIN. That kid has better tast than ..............
  
  

• From: terminator on Sun Apr 9 14:09:29 2006.

  nilavupriyan wrote:

  Djpak wrote: YEA, this is the truth songs bad of the year, cause of Illayaraja and then flopped the movie! poo poothadhu is one of the best!

  
  
  Songs are great..
  
  There is no doubt in it.
  
  

• From: Raikkonen on Sun Apr 9 21:41:26 2006.

  Padam vanthu 1 varusham agapogutu..
  Apdiyenna aaraichi...
  
  

• From: m_23_bayarea on Sun Apr 9 21:46:46 2006.

  Raikkonen wrote:

  Padam vanthu 1 varusham agapogutu.. Apdiyenna aaraichi...

  
  
  Aaah !! Ithu oru nalla kelvi ... SP Akka paatuku oru thread-a open pannitaanga .... Odanae namma Nilavu thambi anga oru thread open pannitaaru !!!
  
  

• From: Raikkonen on Sun Apr 9 21:47:19 2006.

  Sabaaash..
  Sariyaana Potti
  
  

• From: Raikkonen on Sun Apr 9 21:57:19 2006.

  Naanum oru thread open panna poren..
  
  SImha Narasimha,.....
  
  Why it wasnt selected for OScarnu....
  
  

• From: joe on Sun Apr 9 23:14:52 2006.

  I think enough discussed on this matter.