|
| The Hub : Tamil Films Archived | Hello Guest, Login to post. |
Rajni's bollywood's copies
| Topic started by nilavupriyan on Tue Mar 14 9:43:37 2006. |
| RSS Feed
| Email me when a reply is posted
| From: Justice on Tue Mar 14 9:45:44 2006. |
| From: Alien on Tue Mar 14 9:47:23 2006. |
....Nilavu 
...... U rock !! ....
.... Was it NTR ? who posted it ... 
| From: Kamalan on Tue Mar 14 9:51:17 2006. |
| From: nilavupriyan on Tue Mar 14 9:52:58 2006. |
| From: sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar on Tue Mar 14 9:55:11 2006. |
| From: sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar on Tue Mar 14 9:55:38 2006. |
| From: joe on Tue Mar 14 9:55:40 2006. |
| Kamalan wrote: |
| when kamalhassan has hollywood copy thread, the mods cant close this one......... |
| From: ajithfederer on Tue Mar 14 9:57:32 2006. |
| From: sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar on Tue Mar 14 9:57:58 2006. |
| From: bingleguy on Tue Mar 14 9:59:22 2006. |
| From: Kamalan on Tue Mar 14 9:59:39 2006. |
| joe wrote: | ||
Ofcourse,as long as the dicussion is on the topic without any fight and bashing |
| From: sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar on Tue Mar 14 9:59:48 2006. |
| From: Alien on Tue Mar 14 10:01:10 2006. |
| From: bingleguy on Tue Mar 14 10:01:36 2006. |
| sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar wrote: |
| muthu - thenmaavin kombaththu or sambaththu
padayappa - a slight copy from devar magan, esp 1st half baba - a 2nd make of rajni's some telugu movie with his friend mohanbabu as lead annamalai??? |
| From: ajithfederer on Tue Mar 14 10:01:43 2006. |
| Kamalan wrote: | ||||
|
| From: ajithfederer on Tue Mar 14 10:02:50 2006. |
| From: bingleguy on Tue Mar 14 10:04:01 2006. |
| From: joe on Tue Mar 14 10:04:06 2006. |
| Kamalan wrote: | ||||
|
| From: sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar on Tue Mar 14 10:06:54 2006. |
| Alien wrote: |
| Padayappa was a copy of Annamalai |
| From: sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar on Tue Mar 14 10:08:06 2006. |
| sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar wrote: |
| can anyone tell me the original from where rajni lifted "Veettukku oru Nallavan" and "Naattukku oru Nallavan"
|
| From: Alien on Tue Mar 14 10:08:10 2006. |
... Kamal's Hollywood copies thread is going to complete one year without much trouble 
......| From: Alien on Tue Mar 14 10:10:26 2006. |
| sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar wrote: | ||
Nammavar avataarla irunthuttu athenna Aliennnu per..onnu avatar maathunga illai unga perayee maaththunnga |
... Aliens kooda Nammavar-a rasikkinum enru solla vaaren .....
| From: r_o_j_a on Tue Mar 14 10:12:21 2006. |
| From: NOV on Tue Mar 14 10:18:02 2006. |
| From: sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar on Tue Mar 14 10:18:15 2006. |
| Alien wrote: |
|
BTW I'm vasanth_luv , incase u couldn't sense .... |
| From: nilavupriyan on Tue Mar 14 10:29:02 2006. |
| NOV wrote: |
| SIGHHHHHH
It is very clear that this thread was started on spite and not for real discussions. FACT is almost all movies of Kamal of last many years have been inspired. This is a common perception held by most people. FACT is also many Tamil movies are inspired from elsewhere and Rajini's movies are no exception. While he is "popular" for many reasons, copying is not known to be his speciality. Therefore tit-for-tat does not serve any purpose. I hope distractors will not let emotion cloud ther judgement, as I am a great fan of Kamal's acting too - and I have not missed seeing every single of his movie in the cinema since Aboorva Sagothargal days.
For further understanding of my position, the last Rajini movie I saw in cinema was Dhalapathy. All I have said above are as a Tamil cinema fan and not as a moderator. Have fun guys.... |
| From: Alien on Tue Mar 14 10:31:38 2006. |
....
.... just like what is supposed to take place in "Kamal's hollywood copies" thread ....
just got my handle changed by our mod tks to him ...| From: bingleguy on Tue Mar 14 10:35:22 2006. |
| Quote: |
|
kamal's films are inspired yeah!...but many of the rajni's movies are copied!....total script! kamal is also popular for many reasons!copying is not known to be his speciality!
tit for tat!..yeah..tit for tat!...but also to make people know the real facts! once when i saw an amitabh movie..i thought amitabh copied it from "velaikaran"..later came to know that rajni copied |
[/quote]| From: sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar on Tue Mar 14 10:37:55 2006. |
| From: Thirumaran on Tue Mar 14 10:39:20 2006. |
| From: nilavupriyan on Tue Mar 14 10:41:29 2006. |
| From: joe on Tue Mar 14 10:44:08 2006. |
| nilavupriyan wrote: |
| bingleguy,
because sholay was an indian hit...many people in tamilnadu have seen the film! just like marocharithra not made in tamil eventhough kamal is a superstar here!....because "ek tuje keliye" is seen by many people in tamil nadu(but could have dubbed)! |
| From: Alien on Tue Mar 14 10:48:11 2006. |
..... Thats what Nilavu is trying to say , I think .... | From: nilavupriyan on Tue Mar 14 10:53:29 2006. |
| From: joe on Tue Mar 14 11:00:25 2006. |
| nilavupriyan wrote: |
| joe...what abt kamal acting as a tamilian who loves a hindi girl in tamilnadu!
is it a great deal to change the storyline?...even roja is made in hindi! |
| From: nilavupriyan on Tue Mar 14 11:01:26 2006. |
| From: Thirumaran on Tue Mar 14 11:01:57 2006. |
| nilavupriyan wrote: |
| joe...what abt kamal acting as a tamilian who loves a hindi girl in tamilnadu!
is it a great deal to change the storyline?...even roja is made in hindi! |
| From: Thirumaran on Tue Mar 14 11:04:00 2006. |
| Alien wrote: |
| U r rite Joe, those movies can't be dubbed bcos they had cross-over love , which makes it impossible to dub .....
Though, the movie could have been REMADE in tamil (probably having Kamal as a telugu guy or asking some other telugu hero to perform that role) , but it wasn't remade bcos the movie was a renown hit !! ..... Thats what Nilavu is trying to say , I think .... |
| From: nilavupriyan on Tue Mar 14 11:04:14 2006. |
| joe wrote: | ||
change story line? hope we are talking about dubing,not remake. |
| From: nilavupriyan on Tue Mar 14 11:10:31 2006. |
| From: Thirumaran on Tue Mar 14 11:13:43 2006. |
| nilavupriyan wrote: |
| did thee made an impact of deewar?
heard that deewar is a great hit in hindi! |
| From: ssanjinika on Tue Mar 14 11:14:38 2006. |
| From: Thirumaran on Tue Mar 14 11:16:15 2006. |
| ssanjinika wrote: |
| was thee a hit?Dont think TN fans accepted Rajini dying.It was a good movie though... |
| From: Thirumaran on Tue Mar 14 11:17:53 2006. |
| From: nilavupriyan on Tue Mar 14 11:22:12 2006. |
| From: Thirumaran on Tue Mar 14 11:25:44 2006. |
| nilavupriyan wrote: |
| what abt "thai veedu" and "Mr.Barath"....they are also having hindi touch..isnt it? |
| From: Raikkonen on Tue Mar 14 11:26:02 2006. |
| From: ajithfederer on Tue Mar 14 11:40:46 2006. |
| joe wrote: | ||
I think the reason why both movies not dubbed in tamil is ,the hero is a tamilian who speaks tamil to some extend even in original movie..so the story is not apt to dub in tamil. |
| From: Raikkonen on Tue Mar 14 11:43:05 2006. |
| From: Kamalan on Tue Mar 14 11:47:12 2006. |
| Raikkonen wrote: |
| Adutta thread enna?
Vijay's tollywood copies-ah? |
| From: Raghu on Tue Mar 14 11:55:57 2006. |
| From: nilavupriyan on Tue Mar 14 12:03:46 2006. |
| Raghu wrote: |
| Aaha, unge ellarukum super knowledge pa, when it comes to cinema :shock :
Any ways, some one opened some silly thread about 'Kamal's hollywood....', so to retaliate, this thread has been started. Is that so Nilavu? Or is this a GENUINE thread?, I am NOT trying to be rude here Nilavu, but if ur intentions were for retaliation, then it is o CHILDISH!, just my opinion, but I don’t think this thread will have as many posting or will last as long as Kamal's Hollywood thread! |
| From: nilavupriyan on Tue Mar 14 12:05:51 2006. |
| From: sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar on Tue Mar 14 12:13:15 2006. |
| Raghu wrote: |
| or will last as long as Kamal's Hollywood thread!
|
| From: joe on Tue Mar 14 12:14:35 2006. |
| sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar wrote: | ||
i too think this thread wont have too many postings, afterall there is not many complexity and intellectualness & smartness in the rajni's imports, as u see in kamals his[rajni's] originals too are "araichcha maavuu" |
| From: Kollywoodfan on Tue Mar 14 12:16:26 2006. |
| Raikkonen wrote: |
| Adutta thread enna?
Vijay's tollywood copies-ah? |
Oh well, no wonder they both are considered Superstar and Prince respectively...| From: Lambretta on Tue Mar 14 12:19:15 2006. |
| Raikkonen wrote: |
| Badshah is Hum |
| From: nilavupriyan on Tue Mar 14 12:25:30 2006. |
| From: m_23_bayarea on Tue Mar 14 12:36:07 2006. |
| From: Shakthiprabha. on Tue Mar 14 12:36:59 2006. |
| From: ssanjinika on Tue Mar 14 12:37:41 2006. |
| From: nilavupriyan on Tue Mar 14 12:44:10 2006. |
| m_23_bayarea wrote: |
| This is just RIDICULOUS ..... Just cos somebody created Kamal's HollyWood Copies, you've created this thread Nilavu .... Whatever your motive is for this thread, this thread just wont provide scope for a healthy discussion for all .... |
| From: m_23_bayarea on Tue Mar 14 12:47:43 2006. |
| nilavupriyan wrote: | ||
its just a thread for telling that tamil superstar bought something from hindi superstar! if somebody can mention inspired movies as copy.......why cant we discuss abt complete copy! |
| From: joe on Tue Mar 14 12:52:29 2006. |
| From: ssanjinika on Tue Mar 14 12:53:31 2006. |
| From: ssanjinika on Tue Mar 14 12:53:31 2006. |
| From: nilavupriyan on Tue Mar 14 12:54:18 2006. |
| From: m_23_bayarea on Tue Mar 14 12:56:30 2006. |
| NOV wrote: |
| SIGHHHHHH
It is very clear that this thread was started on spite and not for real discussions. Therefore tit-for-tat does not serve any purpose. |
| From: m_23_bayarea on Tue Mar 14 12:58:06 2006. |
| ssanjinika wrote: |
| But then bay why have a seperate Kamals Hollywood copies thread?
If we cant have that thread why cant we have this thread ? Its afterall not like just because they copy other language films it diminishes their star value in any way rite.Infact some of these movies ran only because of the superstar's star value. |
| From: ssanjinika on Tue Mar 14 12:58:31 2006. |
:sorry:
)| From: m_23_bayarea on Tue Mar 14 12:59:51 2006. |
| nilavupriyan wrote: |
| i will be happy if the hollywood inspirations of kamal is discussed in kalaignani kamal thread!
|
| From: ssanjinika on Tue Mar 14 13:00:03 2006. |
| From: ssanjinika on Tue Mar 14 13:00:23 2006. |
| From: nilavupriyan on Tue Mar 14 13:13:37 2006. |
| From: Nerd on Tue Mar 14 13:21:14 2006. |
| joe wrote: | ||||
I agree with you! |
| NOV wrote: |
| Therefore tit-for-tat does not serve any purpose. |
| From: Shakthiprabha. on Tue Mar 14 13:24:26 2006. |
| From: m_23_bayarea on Tue Mar 14 13:25:30 2006. |
| Nerd wrote: |
|
Well why do u want to bring KH here?? Discuss about RK and not KH's(?) intellectualness as u claim
|
| From: ssanjinika on Tue Mar 14 13:26:29 2006. |
| From: Shakthiprabha. on Tue Mar 14 13:28:26 2006. |
| From: nilavupriyan on Tue Mar 14 13:28:36 2006. |
| From: ssanjinika on Tue Mar 14 13:30:26 2006. |
| From: ssanjinika on Tue Mar 14 13:31:22 2006. |
| From: joe on Tue Mar 14 13:32:02 2006. |
| Nerd wrote: | ||||||
Well why do u want to bring KH here?? Discuss about RK and not KH's(?) intellectualness as u claim
|
| From: nilavupriyan on Tue Mar 14 13:38:31 2006. |
| From: Lambretta on Tue Mar 14 13:39:27 2006. |
| Shakthiprabha wrote: |
| lol k
yeah thillu mullu again rajni was better than amol |
| From: nilavupriyan on Tue Mar 14 13:43:03 2006. |
| From: joe on Tue Mar 14 13:44:55 2006. |
| From: ssanjinika on Tue Mar 14 13:45:28 2006. |
| From: ssanjinika on Tue Mar 14 13:46:40 2006. |
| From: Shakthiprabha. on Tue Mar 14 13:48:09 2006. |
| From: nilavupriyan on Tue Mar 14 13:49:00 2006. |
| From: r_o_j_a on Tue Mar 14 13:50:38 2006. |
| From: joe on Tue Mar 14 13:50:53 2006. |
| Shakthiprabha wrote: |
| sir lambretta,
THILLU MULLU WAS ORIGINAL. i think GOLMAAL WAS REMAKE |
| From: Shakthiprabha. on Tue Mar 14 13:50:59 2006. |
| From: Lambretta on Tue Mar 14 13:51:51 2006. |
| nilavupriyan wrote: |
| lambretta...i thought balachander had a great sense of humour while watching thillu mullu!
its a remake |
| Quote: |
| the dialogues are by visu...how abt rajni's acting and body language..had any similarity with amol?
i asked u abt deewar and thee |
).....except I rem. catching jus one scene in this movie on TV once..wher Rajni appears for the job interview.....he seemed to make a more melodramatic effect than Amol does in Golmaal.
| From: ssanjinika on Tue Mar 14 13:52:29 2006. |
| From: nilavupriyan on Tue Mar 14 13:54:54 2006. |
| From: Lambretta on Tue Mar 14 13:55:17 2006. |
| Shakthiprabha wrote: |
| sir lambretta,
THILLU MULLU WAS ORIGINAL. i think GOLMAAL WAS REMAKE |
I was told by our mod. Thiru tat TM was remake of Golmaal.....so I donno if he was right/wrong! Spare ME plse.! :folding hands:
), so how cud it be b4 Golmaal (wich was released in 1979/80).....? | From: Shakthiprabha. on Tue Mar 14 13:55:29 2006. |
| From: Lambretta on Tue Mar 14 13:57:16 2006. |
| ssanjinika wrote: |
| Yes ..hes a good actor.SP,is he the one who acts as Mamaji in Gudiya? thats the Jaya Badhuri's first movie. |
)| From: Shakthiprabha. on Tue Mar 14 13:58:07 2006. |
| From: Lambretta on Tue Mar 14 13:59:46 2006. |
| From: ssanjinika on Tue Mar 14 14:00:19 2006. |
.| From: Shakthiprabha. on Tue Mar 14 14:00:50 2006. |
| From: Shakthiprabha. on Tue Mar 14 14:01:34 2006. |
| From: ssanjinika on Tue Mar 14 14:01:35 2006. |
| RSS Feed
| Email me when a reply is posted