|
| The Hub : Tamil Films Archived | Hello Guest, Login to post. |
Best Shankar Movie (Rate It)
| Topic started by kamalsurya on Wed Feb 15 1:28:36 2006. |
| Poll |
| RSS Feed
| Email me when a reply is posted
| From: terminator on Wed Feb 15 1:50:53 2006. |
| From: kamalsurya on Wed Feb 15 1:57:34 2006. |
| terminator wrote: |
| Kurudhipunal was directed by P C Sriram |
| From: joe on Wed Feb 15 2:03:21 2006. |
| kamalsurya wrote: | ||
|
| From: ajithfederer on Wed Feb 15 2:24:47 2006. |
| From: Macho Man on Wed Feb 15 3:08:19 2006. |
| From: joe on Wed Feb 15 3:18:12 2006. |
| Macho Man wrote: |
| Anniyan
Indian Mudhalvan |
| From: lancelot on Wed Feb 15 3:31:05 2006. |
| From: joe on Wed Feb 15 3:34:42 2006. |
| lancelot wrote: |
| 1) indian
2) Mudalvan 3) Kathalan 4) Anniyan 5) Gentelmen 6) Boys and Jeans...... even boys and jeans i rate as 2 of the best tamil films hehe |
| From: lancelot on Wed Feb 15 4:03:10 2006. |
| From: joe on Wed Feb 15 4:06:13 2006. |
| From: lancelot on Wed Feb 15 4:11:00 2006. |
| From: joe on Wed Feb 15 4:14:48 2006. |
| lancelot wrote: |
| tastes differs..... i loved the 2 movies...story was nothing much... but the technology used was amazing.....
and the music..... hehe |
| From: kamalsurya on Wed Feb 15 4:24:39 2006. |
| From: nilavupriyan on Wed Feb 15 4:24:47 2006. |
| From: Fire on Wed Feb 15 4:35:46 2006. |
| nilavupriyan wrote: |
| indian
gentleman(though not so realistic...the issue dealt in the film is said effectively) mudhalvan boys(nice movie in deed...) kadhalan anniyan jeans! |
| From: NOV on Wed Feb 15 4:41:46 2006. |
| From: trisha_krish on Wed Feb 15 4:44:26 2006. |
| NOV wrote: |
| Director Shankar's filmography
Kairaasikkaran (1984) Gentleman (1993) Kadhalan (1994) Indian (1996) Jeans (1998) Mudhalvan (1999) Nayak: The Real Hero (2001) Boys (2003) Anniyan (2005) Shivaji: The Boss (2006) |
| From: NOV on Wed Feb 15 4:44:28 2006. |
| From: lancelot on Wed Feb 15 4:44:52 2006. |
| joe wrote: | ||
Ok .Ok..Jeans and Boys are all time best tamil movies ..Thampi poranthathu 1990-laya? |
| From: NOV on Wed Feb 15 4:47:56 2006. |
| trisha_krish wrote: |
| who were the cast in Kairaasikaran? i hav never heard abt ths movie |
| From: joe on Wed Feb 15 4:48:56 2006. |
| From: NOV on Wed Feb 15 4:51:51 2006. |
| From: lancelot on Wed Feb 15 4:53:39 2006. |
| From: NOV on Wed Feb 15 4:54:36 2006. |
| NOV wrote: |
| Prabhu |
| From: joe on Wed Feb 15 4:54:58 2006. |
| NOV wrote: |
| aamaam Joe.
a little known fact! |
| From: joe on Wed Feb 15 4:55:58 2006. |
| NOV wrote: | ||
Music vEru yaaru, namma IR thaan. |
| From: joe on Wed Feb 15 4:57:33 2006. |
| From: NOV on Wed Feb 15 4:59:35 2006. |
| From: trisha_krish on Wed Feb 15 5:04:31 2006. |
| From: joe on Wed Feb 15 5:07:37 2006. |
| NOV wrote: |
| ok Joe, I may be wrong.
isnt it the story of the rendu pondaattikkaaran?
Good question. If he can use the very untalented Prashanth, why not Vijay?
Tho I hope he will use Surya for his next movie. |
| From: kamalsurya on Wed Feb 15 5:15:14 2006. |
| From: NOV on Wed Feb 15 5:21:44 2006. |
| joe wrote: |
| You are right in 'Untalented Prashant' .Basically I don't hate any actor except Prashant,sometimes I don't know why I hate this guy these much .
I think ,he is the only reason for I didn't like the movie Jeans |
| From: NOV on Wed Feb 15 5:23:25 2006. |
| kamalsurya wrote: |
| Hello guys i am new to the forum and just wanted to ask ur opinion on which u think is the best movie that shankar has made thus far.... |
| From: kamalsurya on Wed Feb 15 5:44:26 2006. |
| NOV wrote: | ||
p/s: what was your previous avathar? |
| From: nilavupriyan on Wed Feb 15 6:29:57 2006. |
| From: Aryaz on Wed Feb 15 6:53:07 2006. |
| From: RajaRam on Wed Feb 15 7:37:22 2006. |
| From: Shakthiprabha. on Wed Feb 15 7:40:11 2006. |
| From: Shakthiprabha. on Wed Feb 15 7:40:52 2006. |
| From: Thirumaran on Wed Feb 15 10:08:05 2006. |
| From: ssanjinika on Wed Feb 15 10:45:10 2006. |
)| From: Thirumaran on Wed Feb 15 10:50:24 2006. |
| ssanjinika wrote: |
| Indian-(didnt like Old Kamal's makeup and hated the scenes with Urmila and Manisha)
|
| From: ssanjinika on Wed Feb 15 11:13:36 2006. |
| From: Thirumaran on Wed Feb 15 11:16:05 2006. |
| ssanjinika wrote: |
| True..and Im sure he enjoyed them too
On a serious note though..we have to commend the star for his superb potrayal as the Indian thatha(barring makeup) and also the wasteral son. |
| From: NTR on Wed Feb 15 11:16:52 2006. |
| From: Kollywoodfan on Wed Feb 15 16:37:30 2006. |
| kamalsurya wrote: |
| Jeans was a tremendous movie IMO. The airport scence where aish wants to tell her love to prasanth was just outstanding and touching |
...Mudhalvan was a great film, with entertainment and substance all interwoven and great performances!! | From: m_23_bayarea on Wed Feb 15 16:39:55 2006. |
| From: Kollywoodfan on Wed Feb 15 16:42:27 2006. |
| m_23_bayarea wrote: |
| My ratings ..
Anniyan (new concept called MPD ... well if only CM hadn't released before this movie, it would have been a totally innovative concept ... tough luck) Mudhalvan (The one day CM concept .. and the racy screenplay in the first half ... Had everybody at the edge of their seats) Indian Gentleman Jeans But above all, my Shankar's fav is soon gonna be SHIVAJI - The Boss ... Rajini haters, pls don't pounce on me or start teasing Rajini for this ... I beg your pardon ... Rajiniya pathi ezhuthanum apdinu nenachaale bayamaa irukku ... |
| From: Thirumaran on Wed Feb 15 16:42:57 2006. |
| m_23_bayarea wrote: |
|
But above all, my Shankar's fav is soon gonna be SHIVAJI - The Boss ... Rajini haters, pls don't pounce on me or start teasing Rajini for this ... I beg your pardon ... Rajiniya pathi ezhuthanum apdinu nenachaale bayamaa irukku ... |
| From: Ramakrishna on Wed Feb 15 16:44:34 2006. |
| m_23_bayarea wrote: |
| My ratings ..
Anniyan (new concept called MPD ... well if only CM hadn't released before this movie, it would have been a totally innovative concept ... tough luck) Mudhalvan (The one day CM concept .. and the racy screenplay in the first half ... Had everybody at the edge of their seats) Indian Gentleman Jeans But above all, my Shankar's fav is soon gonna be SHIVAJI - The Boss ... Rajini haters, pls don't pounce on me or start teasing Rajini for this ... I beg your pardon ... Rajiniya pathi ezhuthanum apdinu nenachaale bayamaa irukku ... |
| From: m_23_bayarea on Wed Feb 15 17:07:43 2006. |
| Thirumaran wrote: |
| Bayapadaatheenga.
Nowadays Rajini fans itself started making fun of Rajini. |
| From: Thirumaran on Wed Feb 15 17:16:23 2006. |
| m_23_bayarea wrote: | ||
That's just impossible !!! |
| From: villan007 on Wed Feb 15 17:18:55 2006. |
| From: Ghlli on Wed Feb 15 17:19:22 2006. |
| From: Sanjeevi on Wed Feb 15 17:21:06 2006. |
| From: villan007 on Wed Feb 15 17:21:09 2006. |
| Ghlli wrote: |
| i'm nt sure i only remember watchign jeans, mudhalvan, boys, anniyan, i dnt remember the others bt for me its anniyan. |
| From: Ghlli on Wed Feb 15 17:35:08 2006. |
| villan007 wrote: | ||
gaayu . Indian padam paakaliya ? |
| From: Thiru on Wed Feb 15 17:46:27 2006. |
| From: captain on Wed Feb 15 17:48:06 2006. |
| Thiru wrote: |
| Indian
Gentleman Mudhalvan These were the only movies worth talking about.. Even Mudhalvan has lots of commercial elements that make it boring.. After that pick your poison.. you can put these 4 movies in any order and its equally bad... I dont know why Shankar is being hyped so much after just 2 (may be 3 quality movies).. Anniyan Kaadhalan Boyz Jeans |
my point| From: Ghlli on Wed Feb 15 18:58:58 2006. |
| From: Alien on Wed Feb 15 21:48:08 2006. |
| Thiru wrote: |
| Indian
Gentleman Mudhalvan These were the only movies worth talking about.. Even Mudhalvan has lots of commercial elements that make it boring.. After that pick your poison.. you can put these 4 movies in any order and its equally bad... I dont know why Shankar is being hyped so much after just 2 (may be 3 quality movies).. Anniyan Kaadhalan Boyz Jeans |
| From: joe on Wed Feb 15 22:15:00 2006. |
| RajaRam wrote: |
| IMO,
Till now He doesn't give any good or excellent movies like sindhu pairavi for KB, 16 vayadhinile for Bharathiraja, Moondran pirai for Balu, Nayagan for Mani Heyram for Kamal. He has given just fantasy movies. My rank is Indian,Mudhalvan is ok. Gentleman and Kadhalan above average. Anniyan below average. Jeans,boys-poor. |
| From: Nerd on Wed Feb 15 22:20:46 2006. |
| From: kidils on Wed Feb 15 22:58:16 2006. |
| From: kamalsurya on Thu Feb 16 1:44:29 2006. |
| From: RajaRam on Thu Feb 16 7:18:58 2006. |
| Quote: |
|
Rajaram, I am almost in the same with your ratings ,except I put Kadhalan also below average |
| From: dinesh2002 on Wed Mar 1 2:03:36 2006. |
| trisha_krish wrote: | ||
who were the cast in Kairaasikaran? i hav never heard abt ths movie |
| From: dinesh2002 on Wed Mar 1 2:18:23 2006. |
..see the movie is a copy & paste from all his previous movie...songs no need to say... ...
...| From: dinesh2002 on Wed Mar 1 2:23:20 2006. |
....its not in the list but the picturisation for Saiyaan & Tu Accha Lagtha Hai was more grand....u should watch Tu Accha Lagtha Hai,good 1!!| From: Navin on Wed Mar 1 6:56:00 2006. |
| From: r_o_j_a on Wed Mar 1 9:51:55 2006. |
| From: m_23_bayarea on Wed Mar 1 9:55:57 2006. |
| dinesh2002 wrote: |
|
Anniyan goes last becoz it was more like a movie Shankar did just to get his name cleaned coz of boys ..see the movie is a copy & paste from all his previous movie...songs no need to say... ...
|
| From: great on Wed Mar 1 9:56:10 2006. |
| r_o_j_a wrote: |
| 1) gentlemen
2) indian 3) jeans 4)mudhalvan |
| From: r_o_j_a on Wed Mar 1 10:00:37 2006. |
| great wrote: | ||
Jeans |
| From: r_o_j_a on Wed Mar 1 10:02:42 2006. |
| From: r_o_j_a on Wed Mar 1 10:02:42 2006. |
| From: selvakumar on Wed Mar 1 10:07:07 2006. |
| m_23_bayarea wrote: | ||
I agree ANNIYAN had pretty much the same theme as Shankar's previous movies .... But isnt the MPD concept new to Tamil cinema ... Just imagine, if only CM wasnt released two months in advance, and if ppl hadnt known SPLIT PERSONALITY, Anniyan would have just been top-notch innovative ... In fact, didnt ANNIYAN even start rolling before CM ? Very unfortunate for Shankar I think ... |
Nalla aasai thaan.. If ANNIYAN released before CM, people might not have had an idea on what is MPD and all.. coz CM explained it in simple style which helped shankar in making his movie an average in tamil nadu.. that s the truth..
| From: m_23_bayarea on Wed Mar 1 12:28:50 2006. |
| selvakumar wrote: |
| bay Nalla aasai thaan.. If ANNIYAN released before CM, people might not have had an idea on what is MPD and all.. coz CM explained it in simple style which helped shankar in making his movie an average in tamil nadu.. that s the truth..
Shankar - fantasy masala mannan who doesnot has the potential of a good director. |
| From: icemansiva on Wed Mar 1 12:39:57 2006. |
| r_o_j_a wrote: |
| sorry posted twice |
| From: selvakumar on Thu Mar 2 3:01:24 2006. |
| m_23_bayarea wrote: | ||
Machi, So you think Shankar dint explain the MPD concept well in the movie ?? |
| From: kidils on Thu Mar 2 20:28:02 2006. |
| From: m_23_bayarea on Thu Mar 2 20:57:58 2006. |
| selvakumar wrote: |
|
Exactly.. From a layman perspective, Shankar sucks big time in explaining the concept. For an average person, IT WILL BE LIKE A MAGIC In MPD, Getups, dress etc won't change. ONly the behaviour will change In CM, Jyo's role was perfect in explaining that.. A layman will understand it.. But the same person will consider ANNIYAN as "KAATHULA POO" |
| From: kidils on Thu Mar 2 21:12:02 2006. |
| Quote: |
| Kidils, Acc to me, MR is the best Director in Tamil ... And Shankar is next .. I know many wont agree with me on this .. But just my opinion ! |
| From: m_23_bayarea on Thu Mar 2 21:19:06 2006. |
| kidils wrote: |
| ur very right. MR is a different league altogether. you cannot compare his movies to anyone in tamil or even India.
But after him Shankar is the most daring, different and entertaining director in tamil cinema. |
| From: selvakumar on Fri Mar 3 1:05:31 2006. |
| m_23_bayarea wrote: |
|
Sorry to differ from you ... But I thought Shankar was really UNFORTUNATE to have had CM before Anniyan ...
Cos I remember watching Anniyan in the theatre ... The scene before Intermission where Vikram gets beaten up by the bad guys, he looses his conscience, and wakes up saying "DEI B____DU, KA____TI" ... And then he stands up ... Almost everybody in the theatre was like "Oh Split Personality pa ithu" ... in a very layman's accent ....
|
| From: kidils on Fri Mar 3 13:31:05 2006. |
| selvakumar wrote: | ||
mm.. But I heard from many people..(who watched the movie).. They were confusing it with CM role. They were not able to accept the on-the-fly transformation of vikram considering the role of Jyo in CM. Also many people could not understand the concept at all. CM explained it well. But Anniyan failed miserably in this case which lead to its average business in TN. |
| From: Ramakrishna on Fri Mar 3 13:50:26 2006. |
| From: kidils on Fri Mar 3 15:24:31 2006. |
| From: Ramakrishna on Fri Mar 3 15:32:27 2006. |
| kidils wrote: |
| who actually says it did only average business? Maybe in comparison to CM. |
| From: kidils on Fri Mar 3 16:49:08 2006. |
| Ramakrishna wrote: | ||
And also due to its mega-budget. |
| From: Ramakrishna on Sat Mar 4 6:03:29 2006. |
| kidils wrote: | ||||
True... 26 crores... can any other Tamil director even dream of that much... |
| From: m_23_bayarea on Wed Mar 29 12:43:18 2006. |
| From: r_o_j_a on Wed Mar 29 15:10:41 2006. |
| m_23_bayarea wrote: |
| Shankar’s dream-project of distinct!!
. The master’s dream project is to make a movie on AIDS awareness and rout the evil out. |
| Quote: |
| robots |
| From: Raikkonen on Wed Mar 29 23:30:35 2006. |
| From: rami on Thu Mar 30 3:10:38 2006. |
| From: Raikkonen on Thu Mar 30 10:39:39 2006. |
| From: manmadan on Fri Mar 31 14:37:19 2006. |
| From: kamalsurya on Fri Mar 31 15:13:02 2006. |
| From: manmadan on Fri Mar 31 18:10:45 2006. |
| kamalsurya wrote: |
| Hey did u notice guys most of shankar movies end with an 'N' |
| From: Ghlli on Fri Mar 31 18:13:44 2006. |
| From: manmadan on Fri Mar 31 18:21:24 2006. |
| Ghlli wrote: |
| I heard after sivaji shanker might do a film with vijay called ''WORLD" |
would be great but where did u hear this from?| From: Ghlli on Fri Mar 31 18:23:02 2006. |
| From: Kollywoodfan on Fri Mar 31 18:25:56 2006. |
| Ghlli wrote: |
| I heard after sivaji shanker might do a film with vijay called ''WORLD" |
| From: Ghlli on Fri Mar 31 18:31:02 2006. |
| From: captain on Fri Mar 31 18:34:59 2006. |
| From: Thirumaran on Fri Mar 31 18:41:05 2006. |
| captain wrote: |
| Surya in Shankar’s next flick? March 27, 2006
Would you believe that Shankar saw the Surya starrer Gajini only recently? Yes, and he was all praises for Surya’s performance. The moment finished watching the flick, he rang up the hero and heaped his praises on him. Surya was pleased and expressed that he would love to work in one of Shankar’s projects. Shankar has promised that he would keep it in his mind and that it would not take long. Shankar’s Sivaji is expected to release this Deepavali. He has also promised to make a film for Venkatesh, the Telugu hero who has turned a producer now. As Surya has a good fan base both in Andhra and Tamil Nadu, maybe Shankar thinks it wise to rope this guy in for his next Telugu flick which will also be dubbed in Tamil simultaneously. Surya then has enough time to complete his Jillennu Oru Kaadhal and the much delayed Chennaiyil Oru Mazhai Kaalam. |
| From: captain on Fri Mar 31 18:44:36 2006. |
| Thirumaran wrote: |
| Shankar is brilliant. He knows who will be good for his movie |
| From: kb on Fri Mar 31 19:14:19 2006. |
| From: captain on Fri Mar 31 19:15:33 2006. |
| From: Ghlli on Fri Mar 31 19:16:10 2006. |
| From: kb on Fri Mar 31 19:16:35 2006. |
| captain wrote: |
| but Kamal is the perfect choice |
| From: kidils on Fri Mar 31 20:10:15 2006. |
| kb wrote: |
| Muthalvan was tailor made for rajini..
a fate of a state would have changed by now.. if it had happened.. |
| From: kb on Fri Mar 31 20:14:10 2006. |
| kidils wrote: | ||
that wud've ran for more than 1000 days if it was Rajni... |
| From: Alien on Fri Mar 31 20:31:13 2006. |
| captain wrote: |
| but Kamal is the perfect choice |
| From: Thirumaran on Fri Mar 31 21:16:58 2006. |
| From: Alien on Fri Mar 31 21:27:43 2006. |
| Thirumaran wrote: |
|
And shankar is waiting for the call sheets of Kamal for his dream project "Robo". He had been visiting Kamal's office before the announcement of Vettaiyadu Vilayadu. Kamal could not give the bulk dates for that movie. Hence it could not take over still. |
| From: Thirumaran on Fri Mar 31 21:33:27 2006. |
| From: villan007 on Sat Apr 1 1:17:54 2006. |
| Ghlli wrote: |
| Yep and thirupachi was meant to be for rajini but he didnt accept. |
| From: Ghlli on Sat Apr 1 8:10:04 2006. |
| kidils wrote: | ||
that wud've ran for more than 1000 days if it was Rajni... |
| From: Raikkonen on Sun Apr 2 13:00:09 2006. |
| From: Ghlli on Sun Apr 2 18:40:18 2006. |
| From: Raikkonen on Sun Apr 2 21:58:30 2006. |
| From: Ramakrishna on Mon Apr 3 10:49:39 2006. |
| Raikkonen wrote: |
| Vijay was approcahed too |
| From: Raikkonen on Mon Apr 3 10:50:39 2006. |
| From: Ramakrishna on Mon Apr 3 10:52:58 2006. |
| Raikkonen wrote: |
| Shanker wanted bulk of dates, hence Vijay would have missed on Thullata Manamum Thullum... |
| From: Raikkonen on Mon Apr 3 10:57:30 2006. |
| From: kidils on Mon Apr 3 10:58:38 2006. |
| Raikkonen wrote: |
| TMT is a classic, where is Arjun now?
I still feel Arjun did faboulous job in Mudhalvan, for Vijay its a massive role.. |
| From: Thirumaran on Mon Apr 3 11:00:59 2006. |
| Raikkonen wrote: |
| TMT is a classic, where is Arjun now?
I still feel Arjun did faboulous job in Mudhalvan, for Vijay its a massive role.. |
| From: Ghlli on Mon Apr 3 11:57:13 2006. |
| Raikkonen wrote: |
| Vijay was approcahed too |
| From: Ghlli on Mon Apr 3 11:58:41 2006. |
| Raikkonen wrote: |
| Shanker wanted bulk of dates, hence Vijay would have missed on Thullata Manamum Thullum... |
| From: Raikkonen on Mon Apr 3 12:03:56 2006. |
| From: Ghlli on Mon Apr 3 12:24:00 2006. |
| From: m_23_bayarea on Wed Apr 12 11:05:21 2006. |
| RSS Feed
| Email me when a reply is posted