Thread started by NOV on 3rd May 2007 08:54 AM
http://www.nst.com.my/Current_News/NST/Thursday/Features/20070502154524/Article/pppull_index_html

Originally Posted by
NST
CINEMA: Jeevan’s no Gemini Ganesan
By K.N. Vijiyan
03 May, 2007
AAN AVANILLAI (Tamil) Directed by Jeeva Starring Jeevan, Sneha, Namitha, Malavika, Jyorthirmayi, Keerthi Chawla, Tejashree, Letchumy, Raj Kapoor, Livingstone, Mayilsamy IN 1974, noted director K. Balachander came out with Naan Avanillai, with Gemini Ganesan in the lead.
Gemini, who had produced the black-and-white movie himself, did not get back his investment. All he got was critical appreciation for his superb acting, playing seven different characters in the film.
I remember how impressed I was with the story in which Gemini was accused of marrying more than five women, abandoning each one after robbing them blind.
It was then that I began to appreciate director Balachander even more.
Now Tamil movie producers have caught the fever sweeping Bollywood — remaking old movies. After Naan Avanillai, Rajnikanth’s Billa is also being remade.
I would rather prefer producers continue to remake movies from other Indian languages like they have been doing for so long.
Naan Avanillai 2007 has more “sex”, with the producers splurging on making the song sequences more interesting and outstanding. Hero Jeevan danced with all five heroines.
The songs, by Vijay Anthony, who found fame through his Dailamoh song from the movie Dishum, are very hummable and enjoyable.
Maybe I am biased, but Jeevan’s acting never comes up to Gemini’s level in the original movie. This was a golden opportunity for him to show his histrionics but Jeevan displayed so few emotions. The only time he seems to show great enthusiasm is when frolicking with the maidens, especially the Malayalee lass.
This is a bit surprising as Jeevan was so effective in the role of a criminal in the 2003 film Kaakha Kaakha.
The movie has a different ending from the original. In the original, you begin to doubt that one man could be married to so many women. When you see all those flashbacks in court, you have to keep guessing whether all the allegations against the hero are true. It is only in the last scene that he is exposed for what he is and was.
But in the new movie, director Selva assumes that the audience know that the hero is guilty from the start.
Having seen the original somewhat reduced the pleasure I would have got from watching this movie. Otherwise, one will enjoy this movie, basically because the story is so different from what we have been getting lately in Tamil movies.
-
From: joe
on 3rd May 2007 08:56 AM
[Full View]
Nov,
Neenga avan illiya?
-
From: joe
on 3rd May 2007 09:00 AM
[Full View]
Heard this movie is a hit.
-
From: P_R
on 3rd May 2007 09:06 AM
[Full View]
Was the original a hit ? I vaguely remember that it was produced byb Gemini himself and didn't do that well. Senior hands may confirm.
-
From: joe
on 3rd May 2007 09:17 AM
[Full View]

Originally Posted by
Prabhu Ram
Was the original a hit ? I vaguely remember that it was produced byb Gemini himself and didn't do that well. Senior hands may confirm.
I beleive it was just a moderate hit ,since the concept is bit advance then ..Selva is Balachandar's assist,I think ..So he chooses this movie since it is KB's movie and fit for this modern time.
-
From: NOV
on 3rd May 2007 09:20 AM
[Full View]

Originally Posted by
Prabhu Ram
Was the original a hit ? I vaguely remember that it was produced byb Gemini himself and didn't do that well. Senior hands may confirm.
naa senior illa, irundhaalum confirm pannurEn.
i have yet to watch the old movie, but have listened to the story umpteen times, courtesy of LP's then.
memorable song: raadha kaadhal varaadhaa...
-
From: P_R
on 3rd May 2007 09:24 AM
[Full View]

Originally Posted by
NOV
naa senior illa, irundhaalum confirm pannurEn. Exactly
idhukku pEr dhAn 'engappan kudhirukkuLLe illai'
-
From: joe
on 3rd May 2007 09:25 AM
[Full View]

Originally Posted by
Prabhu Ram

Originally Posted by
NOV
naa senior illa, irundhaalum confirm pannurEn. Exactly
idhukku pEr dhAn 'engappan kudhirukkuLLe illai'

-
From: rockydeva
on 3rd May 2007 09:30 AM
[Full View]

Originally Posted by
Prabhu Ram

Originally Posted by
NOV
naa senior illa, irundhaalum confirm pannurEn. Exactly
idhukku pEr dhAn 'engappan kudhirukkuLLe illai'

joe,"Nan avan illai" is very average film . but its a HIT here...
karumathukkunu padam yedukirAnunga....
ithE KAMAL vizhundhu,vizhundhu nadicahlum... , sila nalla padatha namma alUnga Flop akurAnunga.....
TN yengE pothu..
-
From: groucho070
on 3rd May 2007 09:31 AM
[Full View]
I think it's unfair comparing Jeeva to Gemini. It's like comparing Rajini in Thalabathi to NT in Karnan.
I have not seen it, but I shall catch it on TV. I heard it was a flop.
Oh, the original has an interesting segment in Kerala. It featured the then child star in an adult role. What was his name? Some Haasan.
-
From: P_R
on 3rd May 2007 09:36 AM
[Full View]

Originally Posted by
groucho070
Oh, the original has an interesting segment in Kerala. It featured the then child star in an adult role. What was his name? Some Haasan.
-
From: NOV
on 3rd May 2007 09:39 AM
[Full View]
PR, :P
enakku andha angigaaram vEndaamnu thaan sonnEn. too much of respectability. :P

Originally Posted by
groucho070
I have not seen it, but I shall catch it on TV.
velli thirai?

there is an incredible amt of movies playing now. NAI, PEAS, AT, UU, MK, MV and of course Spiderman3.

hope to catch some this wknd.
-
From: Querida
on 3rd May 2007 09:03 PM
[Full View]
hmmm i doubt people are going to watch this film in anticipation of comparing it to the original

it will be for the songs, Sneha, the glamour, i was going to say the slight suspense...but if he's guilty from the beginning...(

)Sneha better have a pretty good reason for falling for such a cad!
-
From: P_R
on 3rd May 2007 10:00 PM
[Full View]

Originally Posted by
Querida
hmmm i doubt people are going to watch this film in anticipation of comparing it to the original

it will be for the songs, Sneha, the glamour, i was going to say the slight suspense...but if he's guilty from the beginning...(

)Sneha better have a pretty good reason for falling for such a cad!

Here is a
fun review from a blogger.
Note to Joe: neenga maatum dhAn blog review pOduveengaLA, naangaLum pOduvOm
-
From: Roshan
on 3rd May 2007 10:36 PM
[Full View]

Originally Posted by
Prabhu Ram

Originally Posted by
Querida
hmmm i doubt people are going to watch this film in anticipation of comparing it to the original

it will be for the songs, Sneha, the glamour, i was going to say the slight suspense...but if he's guilty from the beginning...(

)Sneha better have a pretty good reason for falling for such a cad!

Here is a
fun review from a blogger.
Note to Joe: neenga maatum dhAn blog review pOduveengaLA, naangaLum pOduvOm

Thanks PR for quoting that blog here. Athula NAI-ai vida oru interesting-aana thagaval irunthuchu (killing of TN fishermen). Hope I can get more information on that. Comments post paNNi paakanum. Thanks once again
-
From: P_R
on 3rd May 2007 11:22 PM
[Full View]

Originally Posted by
Roshan
Athula NAI-ai vida oru interesting-aana thagaval irunthuchu (killing of TN fishermen). Hope I can get more information on that. Comments post paNNi paakanum. Thanks once again

It is
being discussed in the Hub too, rather lazily and a tad too cautiously .
-
From: Roshan
on 3rd May 2007 11:28 PM
[Full View]

Originally Posted by
Prabhu Ram

Originally Posted by
Roshan
Athula NAI-ai vida oru interesting-aana thagaval irunthuchu (killing of TN fishermen). Hope I can get more information on that. Comments post paNNi paakanum. Thanks once again

It is
being discussed in the Hub too, rather lazily and a tad too cautiously .
PR, I am a silent reader of that thread. anga discuss paNNuRathu vElaikku Avaathunnu enakku theriyum

Besides, muzhusa vishayam therinju pEsuravanga antha thread-la kammi - ellaam emotional outbursts.
-
From: mareen
on 5th May 2007 03:52 PM
[Full View]
naan avan illai a good movie but many feel that Jeevan's charcter of Playboy should've been given to arya...
but the ending is crap... the movie has a good suspense and the reason it makes ppl think tht he is guilty, coz he is running away from the police from the 1st scene itself, he'd rather got caught and act normally and wouldve've been different !!
-
From: Wibha
on 5th May 2007 11:55 PM
[Full View]
the movie is kinda boring...sneha has no proper role.but the way he proves himself to b someone else is good............
-
From: thamiz
on 6th May 2007 01:52 AM
[Full View]
This is the remake of which thamizh film
Who *-ed in that movie
-
From: mareen
on 6th May 2007 02:47 AM
[Full View]

Originally Posted by
thamiz
This is the remake of which thamizh film
Who *-ed in that movie

Gemini ganesan
-
From: NOV
on 6th May 2007 07:34 AM
[Full View]
thamiz, Naan Avan Illai is the original title of the 1974 movie starring Gemini Ganesan, Jayanthi, Kutty Padmini etc.
I watched NAI last night. Good attempt at remaking and was quite entertaining, as long as you dont take things too seriously.
Jeevan was miscast. He just cant emote properly and went about the entire movie with similar style.

Srikanth would have been apt for the role. Or even prithviraj of Mozhi.
None of the gals impress very much except for darling soniechoa.

Namita is fat as ever and looks like huge beside the white gals in the desert scene.

uke:
Songs have been rehashed. My personal favourite
raadhaa kaadhal varadhaa originally sung by SP Bala has been royally mutiliated by Vijay Anthony. And to drive the nail to the coffin, dancemaster dances to in in saffron robes with disco steps.
the original
mandhaara malarE mandhaara malarE is also not spared and appears in the tail end of the kerala scene, which is also preceded by
kadallinakkara pOnOrE. god! isnt any thing sacred.
talking of sacred, even
Kandha Sashti is not spared... and also
pazham neeyappa!
Overall the movie is fun and definitely a respite from the norm called films these days.
Of course I had to ruin the instant by watching PEAs next, but that is another story.
-
From: Roshan
on 6th May 2007 12:58 PM
[Full View]

Originally Posted by
thamiz
This is the remake of which thamizh film
Who *-ed in that movie

Hi Thamiz - how have you been?
Surprising that you are unaware of the old flick "naan avanillai" - *-ed Gemini Ganeshan. I have not seen the old one so cannot make a comparison. I saw 'thirai vimarsanam' on SUN TV of the latest NAI. Some scenes were quite funny - specially Jeven's Saamiyaar role.
-
From: Villan
on 6th May 2007 06:02 PM
[Full View]
I have watched the movie...personally i feel that the movie good...but sneha dont have a proper role in this film...
-
From: raaja_rasigan
on 6th May 2007 06:46 PM
[Full View]

Originally Posted by
NOV
talking of sacred, even
Kandha Sashti is not spared... and also
pazham neeyappa!

Music by Vijay ANTONY
-
From: interz
on 7th May 2007 02:54 PM
[Full View]
Its a good time pass movie. It made me courious about how the original Naan Avan Illai movie was.
pros:
+ Jeevan, he might not be leading actor in kollywood, but he shows the way by choosing different characters than mass heroes nowadays
+ Sneha, jyothirmayi
+ Two songs (nee kavithai, ean enakku)
cons:
- Lot of Glamour exposing.
- The first song was unnecessary.
- The stupid ending
-
From: thamiz
on 7th May 2007 10:30 PM
[Full View]
Thanks, NOV and Roshan!
I should have read the first post of this thread!
Have not seen both. I will watch the remake and get back with few comments!
R: I am doing good but busy!
-
From: Nerd
on 8th May 2007 07:52 PM
[Full View]
Its the #1 in sun tv's top 10. Anything special in this movie? I have not seen the original..
-
From: selvakumar
on 9th May 2007 08:29 AM
[Full View]

Originally Posted by
Nerd
Its the #1 in sun tv's top 10. Anything special in this movie? I have not seen the original..
Speciality :
Kalaanidhi Maaran is the financier of this movie
-
From: Nerd
on 9th May 2007 08:30 AM
[Full View]
Thanks selva. Now this explains everything
Is this at least worth a download ??
-
From: selvakumar
on 9th May 2007 08:34 AM
[Full View]

Originally Posted by
Nerd
Thanks selva. Now this explains everything
Is this at least worth a download ??

I heard mixed reviews on this movie. Many say that it is a piece of CRAP and MANY OF THE
GUYS feel that it is
WATCHABLE
You decide.
It would be better if u go for chennai - 28. I got very good reviews for this movie from my friends
-
From: Sanguine Sridhar
on 9th May 2007 08:35 AM
[Full View]
Maams chumma download panni paarunga! Sneha, Namitha, Jodhirmayi, Keerthi Chawala, Malavika ellarayum ottukka paatha maadhri irrukumla!
Ellaarum Jeevan-a paathu mayanguraangalaama....
-
From: Nerd
on 9th May 2007 08:38 AM
[Full View]

Originally Posted by
Sanguine Sridhar
Maams chumma download panni paarunga! Sneha, Namitha, Jodhirmayi, Keerthi Chawala, Malavika ellarayum ottukka paatha maadhri irrukumla!
Will defly do that. ippOllAm padam pAkka kUda time kedaikka mAttenguthu.
Chennai 28 enga ooru theatres pakkam varala.. varAdhunnu nenaikkiREn.. adhuvum d/l dhAn
-
From: hi
on 9th May 2007 08:39 AM
[Full View]

Originally Posted by
Sanguine Sridhar
Maams chumma download panni paarunga! Sneha, Namitha, Jodhirmayi, Keerthi Chawala, Malavika ellarayum ottukka paatha maadhri irrukumla!

-
From: mareen
on 10th May 2007 10:42 PM
[Full View]

Originally Posted by
Nerd
Thanks selva. Now this explains everything
Is this at least worth a download ??

yes
-
From: RC
on 10th May 2007 11:16 PM
[Full View]

Originally Posted by
Sanguine Sridhar
Maams chumma download panni paarunga! Sneha, Namitha, Jodhirmayi, Keerthi Chawala, Malavika ellarayum ottukka paatha maadhri irrukumla!
Ellaarum Jeevan-a paathu mayanguraangalaama....

Swathy indha thread pakkkam varaama paathukkonga... vandha ungaLukku uNdu
Comparing GG & Jeevan is not fair!
The suspense element seems to be missing because most of them knew about the old version. Selva could have changed the climax. The very last scene in the movie "Sila varudangaLukku pin..." did not make any sense at all.
Like Becks said, if not for anything else... this movie is worth a watch for the ladies in the cast
-
From: mareen
on 11th May 2007 01:48 AM
[Full View]

Originally Posted by
RC

Originally Posted by
Sanguine Sridhar
Maams chumma download panni paarunga! Sneha, Namitha, Jodhirmayi, Keerthi Chawala, Malavika ellarayum ottukka paatha maadhri irrukumla!
Ellaarum Jeevan-a paathu mayanguraangalaama....

Swathy indha thread pakkkam varaama paathukkonga... vandha ungaLukku uNdu
Comparing GG & Jeevan is not fair!
The suspense element seems to be missing because most of them knew about the old version. Selva could have changed the climax. The very last scene in the movie "Sila varudangaLukku pin..." did not make any sense at all.
Like Becks said, if not for anything else... this movie is worth a watch for the ladies in the cast

its wasnt sila varundangalukku pin, atleast that is chewable, but what they actually said was " On one fine day "
-
From: RC
on 11th May 2007 01:52 AM
[Full View]
Thanks for correcting, mareen!