best music director
Responses:
-
From: thimuru on 20th April 2007 03:14 PM [Full View]
maddy...quality in terms of what...what do u mean as quality?
-
From: Shakthiprabha. on 20th April 2007 03:15 PM [Full View]
-
From: leosimha on 20th April 2007 03:17 PM [Full View]
where are the polls? Lets start a new poll.
-
From: leosimha on 20th April 2007 03:18 PM [Full View]
quality of music can be defined as the tunes which are liked by all. the tunes should be rich. Am I right? Are you satisfied with answer?
Originally Posted by thimuru
-
From: MADDY on 20th April 2007 03:20 PM [Full View]
romba sirikadheenga.......i have an answer Originally Posted by Shakthiprabha
yes thimuru, sorry i cant teach music to you here
but yes quality in simple terms , the difference betn a oorvasi and gopala gopala is not huge whereas a difference betn a nee paartha paarvai and raaman aanalum akbar aanalum (sorry, i'm bad with IR's songs lyrics).......IR has been consistently maintaining such a gap in his albums whereas ARR has consistently maintaing the standards throughout the albums....
and can u pls answer whether brahms or IR is greater wrt time taken for composing
-
From: selvakumar on 20th April 2007 03:22 PM [Full View]
Can someone couple of more options like "Both" / "None"
-
From: thimuru on 20th April 2007 03:22 PM [Full View]
I have heard many elder people saying "aahhh...kadhu valikudhu" for arr song! Originally Posted by leosimha
quality of music can be defined as the tunes which are liked by all. the tunes should be rich. Am I right? Are you satisfied with answer? Originally Posted by thimuru
noone complains ir from 16 to 60....so thats quality?
-
From: thimuru on 20th April 2007 03:23 PM [Full View]
selva..cant edit
-
From: Flavia on 20th April 2007 03:24 PM [Full View]
Ask them consult a good ENT doctor. Originally Posted by thimuru
I have heard many elder people saying "aahhh...kadhu valikudhu" for arr song! Originally Posted by leosimha
quality of music can be defined as the tunes which are liked by all. the tunes should be rich. Am I right? Are you satisfied with answer? Originally Posted by thimuru
noone complains ir from 16 to 60....so thats quality?
-
From: thimuru on 20th April 2007 03:24 PM [Full View]
already sanjeevi has given u the list of crap albums by arr just now.. Originally Posted by MADDY
romba sirikadheenga.......i have an answer Originally Posted by Shakthiprabha
yes thimuru, sorry i cant teach music to you here
but yes quality in simple terms , the difference betn a oorvasi and gopala gopala is not huge whereas a difference betn a nee paartha paarvai and raaman aanalum akbar aanalum (sorry, i'm bad with IR's songs lyrics).......IR has been consistently maintaining such a gap in his albums whereas ARR has consistently maintaing the standards throughout the albums....
and can u pls answer whether brahms or IR is greater wrt time taken for composing
-
From: MADDY on 20th April 2007 03:24 PM [Full View]
r u talking abt quality or bearability here???? Originally Posted by thimuru
I have heard many elder people saying "aahhh...kadhu valikudhu" for arr song! Originally Posted by leosimha
quality of music can be defined as the tunes which are liked by all. the tunes should be rich. Am I right? Are you satisfied with answer? Originally Posted by thimuru
noone complains ir from 16 to 60....so thats quality? ..........
-
From: leosimha on 20th April 2007 03:24 PM [Full View]
yes...true...exactly...this is the same from my side...lots of people don't like the western beats of ARR but IR has come out with superb music which are melodious hits and liked by all. Can you remember of Illaiyaraaja performing with Western beats? Please put it here. Originally Posted by thimuru
I have heard many elder people saying "aahhh...kadhu valikudhu" for arr song! Originally Posted by leosimha
quality of music can be defined as the tunes which are liked by all. the tunes should be rich. Am I right? Are you satisfied with answer? Originally Posted by thimuru
noone complains ir from 16 to 60....so thats quality?
-
From: thimuru on 20th April 2007 03:25 PM [Full View]
cha cha .arr music andha alavukku sathama illa Originally Posted by Flavia
Ask them consult a good ENT doctor. Originally Posted by thimuru
I have heard many elder people saying "aahhh...kadhu valikudhu" for arr song! Originally Posted by leosimha
quality of music can be defined as the tunes which are liked by all. the tunes should be rich. Am I right? Are you satisfied with answer? Originally Posted by thimuru
noone complains ir from 16 to 60....so thats quality?
-
From: MADDY on 20th April 2007 03:25 PM [Full View]
which is very less when u consider the amount of time ARR has been in the industry..... Originally Posted by thimuru
already sanjeevi has given u the list of crap albums by arr just now.. Originally Posted by MADDY
romba sirikadheenga.......i have an answer Originally Posted by Shakthiprabha
yes thimuru, sorry i cant teach music to you here
but yes quality in simple terms , the difference betn a oorvasi and gopala gopala is not huge whereas a difference betn a nee paartha paarvai and raaman aanalum akbar aanalum (sorry, i'm bad with IR's songs lyrics).......IR has been consistently maintaining such a gap in his albums whereas ARR has consistently maintaing the standards throughout the albums....
and can u pls answer whether brahms or IR is greater wrt time taken for composing
-
From: leosimha on 20th April 2007 03:25 PM [Full View]
send a pm to our tigers. they will edit it by adding those options. Originally Posted by thimuru
selva..cant edit
-
From: selvakumar on 20th April 2007 03:26 PM [Full View]
Vikki,
I don't think the time taken for composing the songs can be taken as a criteria for judging the MDs? It varies from person to person.
Einstein wasn't as good as Newton while verifying the theories. He used to think a lot and revise his own set of conclusions time and again before presenting them / using them for further research.
I read somewhere that "Describing Music is like Describing Sex. Would you be able to describe it?"
If we see with that line, One who takes more time is better.
-
From: thamizhvaanan on 20th April 2007 03:26 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by thimiru
there are several street performs who make music on the fly... seems like our man will throw any pinkfloyd album in gutter and listen to them 
finally it boils down to gud or bad songs buddy
-
From: thamizhvaanan on 20th April 2007 03:27 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by selvakumar
Vikki,
I don't think the time taken for composing the songs can be taken as a criteria for judging the MDs? It varies from person to person.
Einstein wasn't as good as Newton while verifying the theories. He used to think a lot and revise his own set of conclusions time and again before presenting them / using them for further research.
I read somewhere that "Describing Music is like Describing Sex. Would you be able to describe it?"
If we see with that line, One who takes more time is better.
-
From: thimuru on 20th April 2007 03:29 PM [Full View]
there are lots in post 80 period..his works with maniratnam,pratap pothan...! Originally Posted by leosimha
yes...true...exactly...this is the same from my side...lots of people don't like the western beats of ARR but IR has come out with superb music which are melodious hits and liked by all. Can you remember of Illaiyaraaja performing with Western beats? Please put it here. Originally Posted by thimuru
I have heard many elder people saying "aahhh...kadhu valikudhu" for arr song! Originally Posted by leosimha
quality of music can be defined as the tunes which are liked by all. the tunes should be rich. Am I right? Are you satisfied with answer? Originally Posted by thimuru
noone complains ir from 16 to 60....so thats quality?
then adhenna..western beats avlo mukkiyama
-
From: thimuru on 20th April 2007 03:31 PM [Full View]
ir is not a street performer and his work is not amatuer...to provide such a quality in few days needs talent Originally Posted by thamizhvaanan
Originally Posted by thimiru
there are several street performs who make music on the fly... seems like our man will throw any pinkfloyd album in gutter and listen to them
finally it boils down to gud or bad songs buddy
-
From: thimuru on 20th April 2007 03:33 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by selvakumar
Vikki,
I don't think the time taken for composing the songs can be taken as a criteria for judging the MDs? It varies from person to person.
Einstein wasn't as good as Newton while verifying the theories. He used to think a lot and revise his own set of conclusions time and again before presenting them / using them for further research.
I read somewhere that "Describing Music is like Describing Sex. Would you be able to describe it?"
If we see with that line, One who takes more time is better.
then one film wonders can be awarded as best mds...as quantity doesnt matter
-
From: selvakumar on 20th April 2007 03:34 PM [Full View]
I agree on this Originally Posted by thimuru
His talent is something many will admire irrespective of their taste.
"Sangeetha Megam" is one of the best examples of IR magic ! One of the songs that lights up my day all the time
-
From: selvakumar on 20th April 2007 03:35 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by thimuru
then one film wonders can be awarded as best mds...as quantity doesnt matter 
One good example would be Josuah Sridhar !
-
From: thamizhvaanan on 20th April 2007 03:35 PM [Full View]
You miss my point Originally Posted by thimuru
-
From: thimuru on 20th April 2007 03:36 PM [Full View]
thats what i say! Originally Posted by selvakumar
Originally Posted by thimuru
then one film wonders can be awarded as best mds...as quantity doesnt matter
One good example would be Josuah Sridhar !
quantity also matters!
even after these many years...there are unheard gems of ir...thats his greatness
-
From: ThalaNass on 20th April 2007 03:37 PM [Full View]
IR's 80's songs just too good.. but now..?? uhum.. none of his song was good lately.. Mayakannadi, etc
so, since 1992, the man who consistently giving rocking song none other than Isai Puyal.. a humble man indeed..
-
From: MADDY on 20th April 2007 03:38 PM [Full View]
thimuru can u also remove - Isaipuyal and keep it simply ARRahman??
-
From: thamizhvaanan on 20th April 2007 03:38 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by selvakumar
"Sangeetha Megam" is one of the best examples of IR magic ! One of the songs that lights up my day all the time If anyone needs a sample for IR's orchestration skills, they should listen to the prelude of this song. A very short sex
-
From: thimuru on 20th April 2007 03:38 PM [Full View]
why? Originally Posted by MADDY
thimuru can u also remove - Isaipuyal and keep it simply ARRahman??
-
From: thamizhvaanan on 20th April 2007 03:39 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by MADDY
thimuru can u also remove - Isaipuyal and keep it simply ARRahman??
-
From: selvakumar on 20th April 2007 03:40 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by thamizhvaanan
Originally Posted by selvakumar
"Sangeetha Megam" is one of the best examples of IR magic ! One of the songs that lights up my day all the time If anyone needs a sample for IR's orchestration skills, they should listen to the prelude of this song. A very short sex Exactly ! and the violin bit ! :P
-
From: MADDY on 20th April 2007 03:42 PM [Full View]
cos, i always think, that was a mischievous title given for ARR Originally Posted by thimuru
why? Originally Posted by MADDY
thimuru can u also remove - Isaipuyal and keep it simply ARRahman??
.....puyal is incosistent, which is a very wrong adjective for the great man
-
From: thimuru on 20th April 2007 03:52 PM [Full View]
ilayaraja created new raaga!
*He created the Raaga "Panchamukhi" explaining the five facets of music that included the colorful aspect of film music.
*Ilayaraja spontaneously writing the notes for a re-recording at Prasad Studio while the musicians copy their part to be played.Without playing the part first, he just composes the notes.Amazing isn't it???
*he is also the first Indian who has written a western classical symphony. Composing a symphony is the ultimate in composing music in the western classical tradition. That is on the lines of such great composers like Bach, Mozart, Beethoven, Brahms, et.al. who had given us so much of great music. The time taken to complete a symphony to be played by a full scale symphony orchestra varies from composer to composer; depending upon his mood, the complexity of music, etc. If Mozart took a few days to complete a symphony, Brahms took fourteen years to complete one of his symphonies. And Ilaiyaraaja well known for his speed of composing completed this symphony in just one month's time.
* "His music will be heard through the twenty-first century" predicted Mr. Joseph Eager, Conductor, World Symphony Orchestra, at a function to release the CD of his new album Nothing But Wind in New York in 1988.
* "Your ears will hear music like they never heard before" commented Mr. Victor Rangel Ribeiro, a well-known musicologist and author of Baroque Music-A Practical Guide to Performers.
-
From: thilak4life on 20th April 2007 03:55 PM [Full View]
New topic and let's start a meaningful conversation..
Anyway..here is the post that I replied to Lavanya longtime back..she conveniently overlooked it and funny enough that, she was no where to be seen for a while. No wonder about her ignorance. But she still seem to flaunt with her arrogance..Here it goes..
I never said, ARR is trash. I never do that. I never choke down my values through people's throat.
First of all, opinions itself differs among people. Why is that? Is it because of different 'self'.
there is nothing called 'self', we all wear that facade for others, this 'self' is shaped by cultural, racial, economical, lingual (in turn, Semantical), regional(environmental), etc, almost everything external to you (right from your birth as you grow up).
Our genes just determine our physical attributes and it contains few other traits. Your tolerance level to different things, might be decided by these genes but it’s the other social factors that ultimately decides, both decreasing and overpowering the tolerance level and in turn, the reactions to different things. Again that depends on how you are exposed to these factors through people you meet (from parents, friends to strangers) throughout your lifetime.
This 'self', is a social construct ascribed to fit the margins better (even this margin and the ‘attuned’ comfort zone, is based on the above-said influences).
Sometimes, we live denial to like certain things. For example, I might find ‘Fountainhead’, boring, uninteresting, and pretentious piece-of-**** but it is valued to be the best-written work. Consequently, I immediately jump into the bandwagon of double standards and call it great!
Same way, I feel each person’s favorite music, books, movies, dress (style, color and make), even friends (And enemies), life-partner, are determined by ‘external factors’!
So In your case (or very other case), liking something 'more' is something thats not because of 'your' judgment alone. Because there is no 'you'.
Now you guys can decipher what I said. I have nothing against ARR. But the way, this external factors has programmed 'me', I measure 'greatness' from the way the products (music, movies and books) 'affects' , 'amazes' or 'bewilders' me. I don't think ARR has done that as often as I would like to. He is in my secondary list except for very few tracks. Like I love the trance in Yakkai thiri. I also like Bombay's bgm, Vande Mataram,etc. But somehow he doesn't achieve Maestro's sense of nostalgia. It's a sensation which transcends understanding. I don't know "How to name it?" I wish you could also experience that wonderful violin symphony and let the waves vibrate the mind. Of all the themes I've been through, Punnagai mannan's stands out. It conveys the feeling. With or without the video. The overture and the follow-through is beyond human expression. The music is eternal. ARR's is more modernist than a classical or a retro kind(which I rate higher). Having listened to almost all his tracks, he improvised the 'composition' focusing more on instrumental and Acoustical engineering. When to use what..how to compile the prelude, interlude and postlude to lure the audience into it and the way the juxtaposition of different sounds should work and sound to different people.
I wouldn't blame you, if you rate ARR high. But please, Think again before you pass some inane judgement over IR's music!
I would like to say this for the final time..our tastes are built on exposure. Lack of it can bring in blind prejudiced views against the rival of our favorite. Thats why ARR fans ridicule IR and IR fans reciprocate. This blindfolds us from making a neutral comparison. I will reiterate again, Opinions/tastes like 'ARR is the best' or 'IR is the best' are constructed by the external factors more than 'you' per se. It's not something you choose. It's something that just happened. Greatness is a highly subjective term with an individualist notion to it. Some people bring in this 'popularity' rant out of no where. That doesn't in anyway should affect your evaluation of greatness. Beverages like Coke or Pepsi can be sold in different places..their sales records shouldn't affect your taste or evaluation of the drink.. As simple as that..
Don't bring the popularity contest hereafter.. It is not a yardstick to measure greatness..
When you can say something based on their 'name' being known in different parts of the country, that is entirely different or flawed. Eminem is known all around the world, 2pac was known only in USA. Does that make 2pac lesser than Eminem? Or no one knows Ennio morricone but people know James horner..does that make James horner great? Or, Horner's music is popular amongst people and reached different people..Does that make him 'BETTER'? How many of them getting ARR's albums know about Bach here? Have they listened to IR's albums? Do they understand how IR revolutionized WCM?
I am not as bad as these kids to ridicule about ARR lowly to prove a point. Like 'pray for me brother' is ridiculous and out of life. It was pretentious..The video was even more presumptuous and didn't invoke the feeling. One gets the feeling that he made the video for his own good rather than a honest song for 'poverty alleviation' . Blaze's rap was overdone in that respect. I am yet to see a song where Rahman composes a tune with little less mixing and focusing a lot more on the continuity of that tune to make the sounds acoustically more pleasant, blended, smoothened and striking a chord in the process. That way it affects the listener's senses unlike the general junky 'WOW' effect..
P.S: Whatever I wrote may not be applicable to others. But I would like to make my stance clear..And in the process of it, could have shown my bias towards IR.
PPS: Don't take some selected chunks of this and leave out the rest as it would only make it contextually flawed. Thank you.
-
From: Sanguine Sridhar on 20th April 2007 04:00 PM [Full View]
I am fan of IR's <90, few >90 songs and music, but personaly I dont like him.
I am always a fan of ARR and his songs,music , personaly I like him a lot.
Nilai uyarum podhu panivu kondal ulagam unnidam mayangum
-
From: nemesis786 on 20th April 2007 04:02 PM [Full View]
neenga arasiyal vaadhiya Originally Posted by Sanguine Sridhar
-
From: thamizhvaanan on 20th April 2007 04:06 PM [Full View]
Greatness is a highly subjective term with an individualist notion to it. Some people bring in this 'popularity' rant out of no where. That doesn't in anyway should affect your evaluation of greatness.
All his melodies are like thatam yet to see a song where Rahman composes a tune with little less mixing and focusing a lot more on the continuity of that tune to make the sounds acoustically more pleasant, blended, smoothened and striking a chord in the process.
. May be thats again an individual's notion. But I do recommend u to listen to "piya ho" from Water. You wont repeat that statement again
-
From: Thirumaran on 20th April 2007 04:09 PM [Full View]
We need to consider the number of albums he had given so far Originally Posted by MADDY
The list takes only the song part. If we take re-recording many more movies will go in that list
-
From: nemesis786 on 20th April 2007 04:11 PM [Full View]
What kind of partial poll is this no harris or yuvan or vidyasagar or deva in the list
-
From: Thirumaran on 20th April 2007 04:13 PM [Full View]
Thimiru,
Shall i add more polling options like MSV, Harris, YSR, Vidyasagar, none with ur permission
-
From: thimuru on 20th April 2007 04:16 PM [Full View]
I TRIED TO ADD...BUT CANT EDIT POLL!
THATS WHY!
THIRUMARAN...U ADD OR TELL ME HOW TO ADD
-
From: selvakumar on 20th April 2007 04:16 PM [Full View]
I feel the topic has been fine tuned now. We can discuss on these two people by correlating others like YSR and HJ
-
From: Sanguine Sridhar on 20th April 2007 04:17 PM [Full View]
Thirumaran,
Why you want add MSV to this? What is the point in comparing generations?
-
From: Thirumaran on 20th April 2007 04:23 PM [Full View]
I had already mentioned in my long post few hours back Originally Posted by Sanguine Sridhar
Then in a way IR and ARR too from different generations though IR still making impressions to this Generation like Vaali even at this age holds something for us
Here the thing what i consider is All time Best
Any how people people Thimuru can give me list of options to be added
-
From: Sanguine Sridhar on 20th April 2007 04:27 PM [Full View]
Sorry Thirumaran I didn see
a retired person like MSV needs to be in the list?
Anyways its Nilavu's choice!
-
From: selvakumar on 20th April 2007 04:29 PM [Full View]
I would strongly recommend removal of the polls. They don't reflect anything. Both IR and ARR were voted so that it will remain = allt he time !
Let us avoid the polls and discuss the various aspects of these MDs. (All the TFM MDs)
-
From: Sanguine Sridhar on 20th April 2007 04:31 PM [Full View]
Yes I agree!! Originally Posted by selvakumar
I would strongly recommend removal of the polls. They don't reflect anything. Both IR and ARR were voted so that it will remain = allt he time !
Let us avoid the polls and discuss the various aspects of these MDs. (All the TFM MDs)
-
From: nemesis786 on 20th April 2007 04:33 PM [Full View]
MSV IR a compare pana koodadhuna IR n ARRa comparey pana koodadhu! This is what i said in the other locked thread IR vs ARR is like Sivaji vs kamal or Gavaskar vs Sachin!
-
From: thimuru on 20th April 2007 04:33 PM [Full View]
"ILAYA" RAJA YUVAN SHANKAR RAJA
HARRIS JEYARAJ
VIDHYASAGAR
MSV(IF U WISH)
NONE
-
From: MADDY on 20th April 2007 04:44 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by thilak4life
u r right when u say, greatness and tastes are subjective.........so, for u "how to name it" is a unassailable piece whereas for me, Vande mataram or a pray for me brother is........i think u shuld also agree to ARR's fans tastes and leave it at that, instead just saying ARR didnt achieve this,that which IR could...... Originally Posted by thilak4life
for me, ARR took the sound revolution to a new heights.........if u look at the base of music - its nuthing but sound........so, he stuck right at the base........for a musical layman like me, its always the sounds which attract, where ARR inovated aplenty............but yes, musical grammar is also important, where IR was the master.........
if ARR pursued the IR';s way of music and tried to master WCM and other genres, he wud have failed badly cos IR had already achieved so much in it.......so, ARR expanded the horizon and started sound imporvement, where IR wasnt that interested in.........infact, this sound recogntion of a human mind is global which perfectly explains y people across the globe like ARR's music......
-
From: Thirumaran on 20th April 2007 04:50 PM [Full View]
Once again we take care of only numbers. I dont see it as a point on who wins in the poll. I would like to see different views. There may be some who would feel MSV is all time best and they may have valid points to support. In the last polling option that option itself was not given. Let us see is there any one who vote for him Originally Posted by selvakumar
I would strongly recommend removal of the polls. They don't reflect anything. Both IR and ARR were voted so that it will remain = allt he time !
Let us avoid the polls and discuss the various aspects of these MDs. (All the TFM MDs)
Of Course there are lots of people's name to be included which is not supported in the poll. So hence the notable ones. Some people who feels others like TR can be best, they can post their views and poll for others.
Also Since MADDY felt Isaipuyal is not an apt title for ARR i had taken that as he is one of the hardcore ARR fans. In order to maintain neutrality i had not mentioned anything for other MD's too.
-
From: thilak4life on 20th April 2007 04:53 PM [Full View]
Yeah, that was little harsh Originally Posted by thamizhvaanan
All his melodies are like thatam yet to see a song where Rahman composes a tune with little less mixing and focusing a lot more on the continuity of that tune to make the sounds acoustically more pleasant, blended, smoothened and striking a chord in the process. . May be thats again an individual's notion. But I do recommend u to listen to "piya ho" from Water. You wont repeat that statement again 
I watched Water recently. "Piya ho" was pretty good, although it didn't strike a chord. But my complaints over water was, it could have easily gone without the songs..Not much of an effect..Or else, should have remembered it.. But I believe my individualistic notion sometimes (not always) has that bias. The bias* that IR's melodies has built over the years and in turn, prone to be harsh over others. But talking about melodies, there are quite a few and even the recent 'Sahana' isn't that bad either. Rahman melodies has some effect too..Maybe IR's kind is a far-shot..I think.
*I would reveal my 'bias' rather than being a hypocrite. So you can trust my word Although, I could easily defend my point. Let me break the shield and be more straight-across. It's as bad as saying ARR is bad. ARR is good in his own way. Maybe overrated in my opinion..But that shouldn't matter to others, I guess...
Originally Posted by MADDY
u r right when u say, greatness and tastes are subjective.........so, for u "how to name it" is a unassailable piece whereas for me, Vande mataram or a pray for me brother is........i think u shuld also agree to ARR's fans tastes and leave it at that, instead just saying ARR didnt achieve this,that which IR could......
for me, ARR took the sound revolution to a new heights.........if u look at the base of music - its nuthing but sound........so, he stuck right at the base........for a musical layman like me, its always the sounds which attract, where ARR inovated aplenty............but yes, musical grammar is also important, where IR was the master.........
if ARR pursued the IR';s way of music and tried to master WCM and other genres, he wud have failed badly cos IR had already achieved so much in it.......so, ARR expanded the horizon and started sound imporvement, where IR wasnt that interested in.........infact, this sound recogntion of a human mind is global which perfectly explains y people across the globe like ARR's music...... I would agree there. Lets leave it like that.
-
From: Thirumaran on 20th April 2007 05:04 PM [Full View]
Thilak and MADDY,
Valid points over there in both your posts :P 
-
From: Sanjeevi on 20th April 2007 05:12 PM [Full View]
remove the poll
-
From: MADDY on 20th April 2007 05:20 PM [Full View]
thanks TM and thilak....
i think its pretty normal for fans of one MD to expect the successor to emulate them.......like IR fans want ARR to be more precise on music-grammar and melodies, and we ARR fans are so strict on HJ/YSR for their lack of sound innovation and invention of new sound ........so this is something which cant be prevented
but i have a very serious concern here, how many of u believe in "musical exhaustion" or "genre exhaustion"??? ......u get to hear such terms when people say "all genres are exhausted, all raagas are exhausted" ??? has it really happened??? does it mean nuthing new will arise now??? 
-
From: Pras on 20th April 2007 05:20 PM [Full View]
which is very high when u consider the amount of albums composed by ARR ... Originally Posted by MADDY
which is very less when u consider the amount of time ARR has been in the industry..... Originally Posted by thimuru
already sanjeevi has given u the list of crap albums by arr just now.. Originally Posted by MADDY
romba sirikadheenga.......i have an answer Originally Posted by Shakthiprabha
yes thimuru, sorry i cant teach music to you here
but yes quality in simple terms , the difference betn a oorvasi and gopala gopala is not huge whereas a difference betn a nee paartha paarvai and raaman aanalum akbar aanalum (sorry, i'm bad with IR's songs lyrics).......IR has been consistently maintaining such a gap in his albums whereas ARR has consistently maintaing the standards throughout the albums....
and can u pls answer whether brahms or IR is greater wrt time taken for composing
-
From: nemesis786 on 20th April 2007 05:22 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by MADDY
thanks TM and thilak....
i think its pretty normal for fans of one MD to expect the successor to emulate them.......like IR fans want ARR to be more precise on music-grammar and melodies, and we ARR fans are so strict on HJ/YSR for their lack of sound innovation and invention of new sound ........so this is something which cant be prevented
but i have a very serious concern here, how many of u believe in "musical exhaustion" or "genre exhaustion"??? ......u get to hear such terms when people say "all genres are exhausted, all raagas are exhausted" ??? has it really happened??? does it mean nuthing new will arise now???
u just want to bully harris n yuvan while they give more hits in kollywood than ARR
-
From: Sanjeevi on 20th April 2007 05:23 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by Pras
which is very high when u consider the amount of albums composed by ARR ... Originally Posted by MADDY
which is very less when u consider the amount of time ARR has been in the industry..... Originally Posted by thimuru
already sanjeevi has given u the list of crap albums by arr just now.. Originally Posted by MADDY
romba sirikadheenga.......i have an answer Originally Posted by Shakthiprabha
yes thimuru, sorry i cant teach music to you here
but yes quality in simple terms , the difference betn a oorvasi and gopala gopala is not huge whereas a difference betn a nee paartha paarvai and raaman aanalum akbar aanalum (sorry, i'm bad with IR's songs lyrics).......IR has been consistently maintaining such a gap in his albums whereas ARR has consistently maintaing the standards throughout the albums....
and can u pls answer whether brahms or IR is greater wrt time taken for composing ofcourse maddy, it was not full list
marupadiyum sandai aarambikutha
-
From: kamalsurya on 20th April 2007 05:26 PM [Full View]
I think ARR got a better success rate then this tow guys...Cause whatever movies ARR does it creates a kind of expectation Originally Posted by nemesis786
Originally Posted by MADDY
thanks TM and thilak....
i think its pretty normal for fans of one MD to expect the successor to emulate them.......like IR fans want ARR to be more precise on music-grammar and melodies, and we ARR fans are so strict on HJ/YSR for their lack of sound innovation and invention of new sound ........so this is something which cant be prevented
but i have a very serious concern here, how many of u believe in "musical exhaustion" or "genre exhaustion"??? ......u get to hear such terms when people say "all genres are exhausted, all raagas are exhausted" ??? has it really happened??? does it mean nuthing new will arise now???
u just want to bully harris n yuvan while they give more hits in kollywood than ARR
-
From: MADDY on 20th April 2007 05:28 PM [Full View]
if u think thats wat my/other ARR fans' intentions are, then i'm not changing it Originally Posted by nemesis786
u just want to bully harris n yuvan while they give more hits in kollywood than ARR
IMO, (dunno abt other ARR fans and IR fans) My biggest complaint on YSR and HJ has been :
why havent they been able to bring a new sound or completely replace ARR trend??? sample this:
1976 - difference in MSV and IR's styles
1992 - difference in IR and ARR's tyles
2000 - wats the difference in ARR and HJ - tell me frankly???
-
From: Sanjeevi on 20th April 2007 05:33 PM [Full View]
yes i agree not much difference, but it does not make sense that ARR still rules
-
From: Flavia on 20th April 2007 05:38 PM [Full View]
Then who according to you is still ruling? IR, is it? Originally Posted by Sanjeevi
@ Maddy's and Thilak's posts
-
From: thimuru on 20th April 2007 05:39 PM [Full View]
ysr and harris! Originally Posted by Flavia
Then who according to you is still ruling? IR, is it? Originally Posted by Sanjeevi
:claps: @ Maddy's and Thilak's posts
check out the number of hit albums in near past
-
From: thimuru on 20th April 2007 05:41 PM [Full View]
first of all...thats not arr style...thats western! Originally Posted by MADDY
if u think thats wat my/other ARR fans' intentions are, then i'm not changing it Originally Posted by nemesis786
u just want to bully harris n yuvan while they give more hits in kollywood than ARR
IMO, (dunno abt other ARR fans and IR fans) My biggest complaint on YSR and HJ has been :
why havent they been able to bring a new sound or completely replace ARR trend??? sample this:
1976 - difference in MSV and IR's styles
1992 - difference in IR and ARR's tyles
2000 - wats the difference in ARR and HJ - tell me frankly???
as the global music has entered every home via channels...u cant expect a new trend evolving
-
From: Flavia on 20th April 2007 05:41 PM [Full View]
'Rehash' King and 'Remix' king ruling Originally Posted by thimuru
ysr and harris! Originally Posted by Flavia
Then who according to you is still ruling? IR, is it? Originally Posted by Sanjeevi
:claps: @ Maddy's and Thilak's posts
check out the number of hit albums in near past
-
From: thimuru on 20th April 2007 05:41 PM [Full View]
enna siripu?... Originally Posted by Flavia
Originally Posted by thimuru
ysr and harris! Originally Posted by Flavia
Then who according to you is still ruling? IR, is it? Originally Posted by Sanjeevi
:claps: @ Maddy's and Thilak's posts
check out the number of hit albums in near past
cant reply?
-
From: nemesis786 on 20th April 2007 05:43 PM [Full View]
Well said thimuru Originally Posted by thimuru
-
From: MADDY on 20th April 2007 05:44 PM [Full View]
who is no.1 MD in TFM now?? Originally Posted by Sanjeevi
(purely commercial)
criteria:
1.Highest paid MD (success pays - no producer will pay highest amount to one guy if he can get better success with lesser money.......makes sense??)
2. Sales records whoever sells the most is considered the no.1.........if there is a one on one, then whoever sells more than the other.......
3. whom do the people really listen to discussion forums and fans' opinions are not valid "public opinions"..........whom do people listen to a lot?? do they know who the MD is for their fav song??
statistics relating to the above 3 factors over 5 years should give us current no.1
-
From: thimuru on 20th April 2007 05:46 PM [Full View]
these happen once in a while... Originally Posted by MADDY
who is no.1 MD in TFM now?? Originally Posted by Sanjeevi
(purely commercial)
criteria:
1.Highest paid MD (success pays - no producer will pay highest amount to one guy if he can get better success with lesser money.......makes sense??)
2. Sales records whoever sells the most is considered the no.1.........if there is a one on one, then whoever sells more than the other.......
3. whom do the people really listen to discussion forums and fans' opinions are not valid "public opinions"..........whom do people listen to a lot?? do they know who the MD is for their fav song??
statistics relating to the above 3 factors should give us current no.1
-
From: Thirumaran on 20th April 2007 05:48 PM [Full View]
I would like to add more points and reply to few others's post. Due to time concern i could not do. Let me see if that is possible in the coming week. But not with a lengthy post like before
See you guys later. bye. Have a nice week end
-
From: coucou on 20th April 2007 05:50 PM [Full View]
i have a some feeling tha after comparison between IR-ARR, comparison ARR-HJ-YSR will start!!!
-
From: nemesis786 on 20th April 2007 05:50 PM [Full View]
"MADDY" your 2nd n 3rd point defeat ARR's cause to harris!!
When more people listen to your songs more sales happens right? Atleast downloads
In that case Initial Sales of Boys was very good but gradually it was KAAKA KAAKA's music that overtook Boys in REACH which is your 3rd point!
You can talk of awards , well harris got FILMFARE award beating BOYS and KADHAL KONDEN
-
From: Sanjeevi on 20th April 2007 05:51 PM [Full View]
Yes, the so-called remix king has won best musician award in Cyprus international film festival 2006. And unfortunately his 7GRC has lost to Vidyasagar's Swarabisekam to get National Award for Best MD Originally Posted by Flavia
'Rehash' King and 'Remix' king ruling
-
From: Flavia on 20th April 2007 05:51 PM [Full View]
Your post is not replyworthy! Originally Posted by thimuru
enna siripu?... Originally Posted by Flavia
Originally Posted by thimuru
cant reply?
-
From: MADDY on 20th April 2007 05:53 PM [Full View]
thimuru, once in a while??? i didnt get u
also, abt ARR trend - its not just western.......ARR's trend has many implications:
1. Digitalisation of Indian music(recording style)
2. Fusion of various global/national genres/sounds
3. making western instruments sound Indian
if u want i have some points abt changes that IR brought in too..... .....
-
From: Sanjeevi on 20th April 2007 05:54 PM [Full View]
When considering today Originally Posted by MADDY
who is no.1 MD in TFM now?? Originally Posted by Sanjeevi
(purely commercial)
criteria:
1.Highest paid MD (success pays - no producer will pay highest amount to one guy if he can get better success with lesser money.......makes sense??)
2. Sales records whoever sells the most is considered the no.1.........if there is a one on one, then whoever sells more than the other.......
3. whom do the people really listen to discussion forums and fans' opinions are not valid "public opinions"..........whom do people listen to a lot?? do they know who the MD is for their fav song??
statistics relating to the above 3 factors over 5 years should give us current no.1
Are you ready to give half credit to Rajni and his fans?
-
From: Flavia on 20th April 2007 05:55 PM [Full View]
I can list umpteen awards won by ARR like this. :P Originally Posted by Sanjeevi
Yes, the so-called remix king has won best musician award in Cyprus international film festival 2006. And unfortunately his 7GRC has lost to Vidyasagar's Swarabisekam to get National Award for Best MD Originally Posted by Flavia
'Rehash' King and 'Remix' king ruling
-
From: nemesis786 on 20th April 2007 05:55 PM [Full View]
MADDY fusion i agree but bringing in technology , which precisely thimuru termed as WESTERNISATION , does not support your cause that ARR is a superior musician!
It is like saying Rajinikanth is the best actor because he was the first guy to bring in hair streaks to tamil cinema
-
From: Flavia on 20th April 2007 06:00 PM [Full View]
You've got to be joking! Originally Posted by thimuru
these happen once in a while...
ARR is the only MD who renders hits consistently.
-
From: thimuru on 20th April 2007 06:00 PM [Full View]
maddy,
ruling is different from getting higher salary!
do u think rajni rules now among heroes..NO!
because he gives movies once in a while...his presence is not known!
but younger generation actors rules the field..hope u understand
-
From: Tamilan on 20th April 2007 06:03 PM [Full View]
yes, all came from india and indians Originally Posted by Flavia
I can list umpteen awards won by ARR like this. :P Originally Posted by Sanjeevi
Yes, the so-called remix king has won best musician award in Cyprus international film festival 2006. And unfortunately his 7GRC has lost to Vidyasagar's Swarabisekam to get National Award for Best MD Originally Posted by Flavia
'Rehash' King and 'Remix' king ruling
-
From: MADDY on 20th April 2007 06:03 PM [Full View]
do u have any link to suppot that KK is the highest sold album ever in 2000??? cos there are links to suggest BOYS is the highest sold album since 2000 in TFM Originally Posted by nemesis786
ok, i'm not saying ARR is a superior musician just bcos he bought in new tehcnology, but yes, he atleast had the tenacity and thought process to bring in a new style thru technology instead of just using the templates and styles left by his predecessor....
-
From: Flavia on 20th April 2007 06:06 PM [Full View]
Oh. Now I understand. Originally Posted by thimuru
The problem lies in the yardstick that you use to judge.
-
From: nemesis786 on 20th April 2007 06:08 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by MADDY
do u have any link to suppot that KK is the highest sold album ever in 2000??? cos there are links to suggest BOYS is the highest sold album since 2000 in TFM Originally Posted by nemesis786
ok, i'm not saying ARR is a superior musician just bcos he bought in new tehcnology, but yes, he atleast had the tenacity and thought process to bring in a new style thru technology instead of just using the templates and styles left by his predecessor....
No links r needed to show that! Boys had lesser reach than KK its a matter of observation not media reports?!? Kaaka Kaaka overtook BOYS in all aspects except for the INITIAL SALES which you are talking about
-
From: thimuru on 20th April 2007 06:10 PM [Full View]
kadhal kondein also had a great reach during that period
-
From: MADDY on 20th April 2007 06:11 PM [Full View]
no thimuru, i dont want to put ARR and IR in this cat fight with the "kids".........my question is simple: Originally Posted by thimuru
who is the no.1 now??? can someone provide the statistics for 5 years of those 3 points????
i'm not saying ARR is ruling, i dont want ARR to be in TFM, leave alone ruling it
-
From: nemesis786 on 20th April 2007 06:14 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by thimuru
-
From: nemesis786 on 20th April 2007 06:19 PM [Full View]
Your useless bylly at Harris n Yuvan as Kids is by no way gonna make ARR more successful Originally Posted by MADDY
no thimuru, i dont want to put ARR and IR in this cat fight with the "kids".........my question is simple:
who is the no.1 now??? can someone provide the statistics for 5 years of those 3 points????
i'm not saying ARR is ruling, i dont want ARR to be in TFM, leave alone ruling it
You guys can say ARR dethroned IR with ROJA ; but do you also know harris dethroned ARR with MINNALE?
After Kaaka Kaaka There is no looking back
Also included in the list is YSR especially after DHEENA
-
From: MADDY on 20th April 2007 06:21 PM [Full View]
so who is no.1 - YSR or HJ??? dont tell both - name one person and justify it Originally Posted by nemesis786
Your useless bylly at Harris n Yuvan as Kids is by no way gonna make ARR more successful Originally Posted by MADDY
no thimuru, i dont want to put ARR and IR in this cat fight with the "kids".........my question is simple:
who is the no.1 now??? can someone provide the statistics for 5 years of those 3 points????
i'm not saying ARR is ruling, i dont want ARR to be in TFM, leave alone ruling it
You guys can say ARR dethroned IR with ROJA ; but do you also know harris dethroned ARR with MINNALE?
After Kaaka Kaaka There is no looking back
Also included in the list is YSR especially after DHEENA
FYI, ARR was a kid when he came in 1992 and was till he attained a position......so there no wrong in calling HJ and YSR - kids
-
From: nemesis786 on 20th April 2007 06:24 PM [Full View]
The fight for #1 spot has become a race between Harris n YSR! There is no need to mention only one or both i would not even say neither! They are vying for the same spot but ARR is out of the scheme of things
HArris at times is #1 while yuvan is #1 in the next season so the permanent #1 will be decided in due course but not for sure ARR!
-
From: Sanguine Sridhar on 20th April 2007 06:26 PM [Full View]
Why IR or any other musician other than ARR couldn music direct any hindi movies?! Can anybody help me here?
-
From: MADDY on 20th April 2007 06:28 PM [Full View]
when i ask abt YSR and HJ , u keep on mentioning ARR, which itself is a testimony to ARR's power in TN.....i dunt think i need to add more....... Originally Posted by nemesis786
The fight for #1 spot has become a race between Harris n YSR! There is no need to mention only one or both i would not even say neither! They are vying for the same spot but ARR is out of the scheme of things
HArris at times is #1 while yuvan is #1 in the next season so the permanent #1 will be decided in due course but not for sure ARR!
-
From: selvakumar on 20th April 2007 06:30 PM [Full View]
did IR compose for Hindi movies like ARR ? I think the no. of movies that he had done there is very less. Originally Posted by Sanguine Sridhar
-
From: nemesis786 on 20th April 2007 06:30 PM [Full View]
Then when someone questions you about power of ARR currently you call harris n yuvgan as kids? Shows you are insecure about them and fail to agree the truth they r ruling! Originally Posted by MADDY
when i ask abt YSR and HJ , u keep on mentioning ARR, which itself is a testimony to ARR's power in TN.....i dunt think i need to add more....... Originally Posted by nemesis786
The fight for #1 spot has become a race between Harris n YSR! There is no need to mention only one or both i would not even say neither! They are vying for the same spot but ARR is out of the scheme of things
HArris at times is #1 while yuvan is #1 in the next season so the permanent #1 will be decided in due course but not for sure ARR!
Useless to argue with people who play hide n seek like you
NOTE : Enavo IR fans kalachingale Ramarajan Satyarajnu... then what was ARR doing with VANDISOLAI CHINNARAASU , PARASURAM?
-
From: selvakumar on 20th April 2007 06:32 PM [Full View]
Maddy,
We agree the popularity, hype that surroounds arr albums in tamil. We acknowledge his success.
But bitter truth is HJ and YSR are more popular nowadays with the kind of albums that they are giving ! Right
-
From: MADDY on 20th April 2007 06:33 PM [Full View]
hmmm.......hard to tell........IR - they couldnt relate themselves with IR's music... Originally Posted by Sanguine Sridhar
HJ's RHTDM was a huge hit in Mumbai with the songs staying for 26-28 weeks in top10 .....but dunno, y he never came back........
with YSR and HJ, i think its preference not to work in Hindi movies but even if they come, how successfull will they be - not sure
-
From: Sanguine Sridhar on 20th April 2007 06:34 PM [Full View]
Right, I asked the reason for that Originally Posted by selvakumar
did IR compose for Hindi movies like ARR ? I think the no. of movies that he had done there is very less. Originally Posted by Sanguine Sridhar
-
From: ajaybaskar on 20th April 2007 06:38 PM [Full View]
ARR is a genius when it comes to western and Hindustani. NI ppl love these two stuff. So no wonder Rahman has become a hit in north. Originally Posted by Sanguine Sridhar
-
From: nemesis786 on 20th April 2007 06:42 PM [Full View]
Veena IRa Ramarajan movies satyaraj moviesnu olari kalaicha sila ARR fansuku :
list of ARR's mokkais / flops :
Ashokan (1993)
Uzhavan
Vandicholai Chinnaraasu
Super Police
Pudhiya Mannargal
Manitha Manitha
Love Birds
Mr Romeo
Anthimantharai
Sangamam
Taj Mahal
Star
Alli Arjuna
Parthale Paravasam
Udhaya
Parasuram
Kangalal Kaithu Sei
Anbe Aaruyire
Apuram edhuku IRa kalaikureenga? Apo trend was village based movies so he did it? Didnt he give an urban feel to mOUNDA RAAGAM or NAYAGAN? Didnt he give a haunting feel for THALAPATHY?
Apuram ena veen mockery?
ARR is famous in northna udane ARR is national icona?
IR was ruling entire south india
-
From: MADDY on 20th April 2007 06:43 PM [Full View]
selva, u know my views rite?? Originally Posted by selvakumar
Maddy,
We agree the popularity, hype that surroounds arr albums in tamil. We acknowledge his success.
But bitter truth is HJ and YSR are more popular nowadays with the kind of albums that they are giving ! Right ......i dont want ARR to be in tamil at all......not even in bollywood to a extent...... .......he shuld shift base to somewhere outside India and work on Hollywood projects, private albums with other artistes and aim for a grammy/oscar (sorry if this sounds ridiculous/funny.....its just my opinion)
i look at ARR for innovation and some difference in tamil....thats it.......avaru album ellam success aaganamnnu kooda illa....... .....same goes for IR - i still think he'll surprise us with a truly different album one day.... .......
i defnitely think its HJ or YSR......but who in that??? both are giving flops left and right....tuf to choose one....
-
From: nemesis786 on 20th April 2007 06:47 PM [Full View]
Another baseless claim! HJ's VV n UNALE UNALE r huge hits! Unale Unale doesnt have boastable star cast! Even the article which you guys provided to show sales of sivaji audio says its "BRAND RAJINI" ! YSR's PATTIYAL last year, PUDUPETTAI and the recent chennai 28 r huge hits as well! Originally Posted by MADDY
i defnitely think its HJ or YSR......but who in that??? both are giving flops left and right....tuf to choose one....
it is ARR is who gave left nright useless albums to lose to "KIDS" as you termed like AA..AAAAHhh... ooo..ohhhh
-
From: ajaybaskar on 20th April 2007 06:48 PM [Full View]
Haunting feel for thalapathya? Adhu enna pei padama?
-
From: thimuru on 20th April 2007 06:50 PM [Full View]
chinna thayaval song Originally Posted by ajaybaskar
-
From: nemesis786 on 20th April 2007 06:50 PM [Full View]
hauntingna unforgettable! Not cheerful but gels well with the mood of the film which by itself is serious Originally Posted by ajaybaskar
-
From: dinesh2002 on 20th April 2007 06:51 PM [Full View]
ive come across many people saying " EW " and "hahaha...he should retire" Originally Posted by thimuru
I have heard many elder people saying "aahhh...kadhu valikudhu" for arr song! Originally Posted by leosimha
quality of music can be defined as the tunes which are liked by all. the tunes should be rich. Am I right? Are you satisfied with answer? Originally Posted by thimuru
noone complains ir from 16 to 60....so thats quality? ... yes...that EW was from few 20s and that " he should retire" from a 50 y/o man after listenin to Kastooriman song....
-
From: ajaybaskar on 20th April 2007 06:51 PM [Full View]
Adhu sogamathaane irukkum..Enna haunting?
-
From: MADDY on 20th April 2007 06:51 PM [Full View]
ajay - good one....leave it...... Originally Posted by ajaybaskar
unnale unnale is a bigger hit or ch-28 is a bigger hit??? selva and other neutral guys???
-
From: thimuru on 20th April 2007 06:52 PM [Full View]
so funny :yawn: Originally Posted by dinesh2002
ive come across many people saying " EW " and "hahaha...he should retire" Originally Posted by thimuru
I have heard many elder people saying "aahhh...kadhu valikudhu" for arr song! Originally Posted by leosimha
quality of music can be defined as the tunes which are liked by all. the tunes should be rich. Am I right? Are you satisfied with answer? Originally Posted by thimuru
noone complains ir from 16 to 60....so thats quality? ... yes...that EW was from few 20s and that " he should retire" from a 50 y/o man after listenin to Kastooriman song....
-
From: thimuru on 20th April 2007 06:52 PM [Full View]
haunting-ku neraya meaning rkku! Originally Posted by ajaybaskar
-
From: nemesis786 on 20th April 2007 06:53 PM [Full View]
hauntingna everlasting in your ears .. thoonguravana elupalam nadikuravana mudiyadhu! Originally Posted by ajaybaskar
-
From: nemesis786 on 20th April 2007 06:54 PM [Full View]
Mokkai started Originally Posted by MADDY
ajay - good one....leave it...... Originally Posted by ajaybaskar
unnale unnale is a bigger hit or ch-28 is a bigger hit??? selva and other neutral guys??? 
-
From: ajaybaskar on 20th April 2007 06:55 PM [Full View]
Behindwoods songs top ten
1. Sivaji
2.Unnalae unnalae
3.Mozhi
4.PKMC
5.Chennai 28
6.Paruthi Veeran
7.Maayakannadi
8.Pokkiri
9.Deepavali
10.Oram Po
-
From: thimuru on 20th April 2007 06:56 PM [Full View]
behindwoods Originally Posted by ajaybaskar
look.....rajni herova irukanalathan this album is pasied...its not a great album for arr standards for sure!
-
From: dinesh2002 on 20th April 2007 06:56 PM [Full View]
normal la... innum kevalama comments innum iruntheche...didint wanna mention it & hurt u guys feelings Originally Posted by thimuru
so funny :yawn: Originally Posted by dinesh2002
ive come across many people saying " EW " and "hahaha...he should retire" Originally Posted by thimuru
I have heard many elder people saying "aahhh...kadhu valikudhu" for arr song! Originally Posted by leosimha
quality of music can be defined as the tunes which are liked by all. the tunes should be rich. Am I right? Are you satisfied with answer? Originally Posted by thimuru
noone complains ir from 16 to 60....so thats quality? ... yes...that EW was from few 20s and that " he should retire" from a 50 y/o man after listenin to Kastooriman song....
-
From: thimuru on 20th April 2007 06:57 PM [Full View]
haha...u hurting us hehe!
-
From: ajaybaskar on 20th April 2007 06:57 PM [Full View]
Oh..Apdikka varreengala...Englishla naanga weakkungo... Originally Posted by nemesis786
hauntingna everlasting in your ears .. thoonguravana elupalam nadikuravana mudiyadhu! Originally Posted by ajaybaskar
-
From: nemesis786 on 20th April 2007 06:57 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by thimuru
behindwoods Originally Posted by ajaybaskar
look.....rajni herova irukanalathan this album is pasied...its not a great album for arr standards for sure!
Same behindwoods wrote one audio report which said its BRAND RAJINI for all the success
-
From: dinesh2002 on 20th April 2007 06:59 PM [Full View]
we all know how u IR-family-devotees reacts when some1 say something bout IR ... Originally Posted by thimuru
haha...u hurting us hehe!
-
From: ajaybaskar on 20th April 2007 07:00 PM [Full View]
Same Behinwoods had placed Munbae vaa song for record 18 weeks in the top position. Adhu enna brand suryava?
-
From: thimuru on 20th April 2007 07:00 PM [Full View]
how do we react?..come on... Originally Posted by dinesh2002
we all know how u IR-family-devotees reacts when some1 say something bout IR ... Originally Posted by thimuru
haha...u hurting us hehe!
-
From: nemesis786 on 20th April 2007 07:04 PM [Full View]
Adha BRAN RAJINInu potadhum , munbe vaa songa 18 weeks pota BEHINDWOODSa kekanum enai ilai Originally Posted by ajaybaskar
-
From: ajaybaskar on 20th April 2007 07:08 PM [Full View]
Sonnaalum sollaatiyum SOK was the album of 2006.
-
From: thimuru on 20th April 2007 07:09 PM [Full View]
ajay...munbe va is a great song...so it remained at top!
but shivaji album sells due to rajni
-
From: ajaybaskar on 20th April 2007 07:10 PM [Full View]
If Sivaji is selling for Rajini, then Chandramukhi audio wud've been the album of 2005.
-
From: nemesis786 on 20th April 2007 07:11 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by thimuru
-
From: thimuru on 20th April 2007 07:13 PM [Full View]
purinjututhan pesureengala... Originally Posted by ajaybaskar
cmkum shivajikum diff iruku!...the expectations are sky high!shankar-rajni combo!
next...lets really see how the album has been sold by final reports
-
From: nemesis786 on 20th April 2007 07:14 PM [Full View]
Combination n hype! CM was just ordinary with less hype initially! Originally Posted by ajaybaskar
But Shankar-Rajini which was the most expected combo for a long time from mudalvan SIVAJI audio has sold!
Harris jayaraja irundha kooda adhedhaan airikkum
-
From: ajaybaskar on 20th April 2007 07:16 PM [Full View]
Once the film gets released, the audio sales is going to go on an all time high...
Do u honestly think that ppl wud've anticipated for Sivaji audio in the same way if composed by some other MD?
-
From: thimuru on 20th April 2007 07:18 PM [Full View]
anticipation would be there...for any top md! Originally Posted by ajaybaskar
yuvan/harris also would have created hype...but lesser than arr!
arr dint deliver greatly...!
-
From: ajaybaskar on 20th April 2007 07:19 PM [Full View]
Dont ever argue for the sake of arguing,nemesis..
-
From: ajaybaskar on 20th April 2007 07:20 PM [Full View]
That may be your opinion. But rest of the ppl in TN think otherwise. Originally Posted by thimuru
anticipation would be there...for any top md! Originally Posted by ajaybaskar
yuvan/harris also would have created hype...but lesser than arr!
arr dint deliver greatly...!
-
From: thimuru on 20th April 2007 07:29 PM [Full View]
u asked all? Originally Posted by ajaybaskar
That may be your opinion. But rest of the ppl in TN think otherwise. Originally Posted by thimuru
anticipation would be there...for any top md! Originally Posted by ajaybaskar
yuvan/harris also would have created hype...but lesser than arr!
arr dint deliver greatly...!
-
From: nemesis786 on 20th April 2007 07:32 PM [Full View]
thhonguramadiri nadikaravangala elupa mudiyadhu! Originally Posted by ajaybaskar
-
From: ajaybaskar on 20th April 2007 07:32 PM [Full View]
Wat if i did?
-
From: ajaybaskar on 20th April 2007 07:34 PM [Full View]
Mulichukkittae thoonguravangala eluppalam. Elumbu,nemesis.. Originally Posted by nemesis786
thhonguramadiri nadikaravangala elupa mudiyadhu! Originally Posted by ajaybaskar
-
From: nemesis786 on 20th April 2007 07:49 PM [Full View]
Ilamai Ullasam -- Unale Unale HARRIS IS BEST IN URBAN MUSIC
-
From: thimuru on 20th April 2007 07:50 PM [Full View]
harris songs brings a jolly mood easily!
unnale unnale song rocks!
-
From: ajaybaskar on 20th April 2007 07:55 PM [Full View]
Kaanal neer rocks. The best urban music of this year. So does Veerasami...
-
From: nemesis786 on 20th April 2007 07:55 PM [Full View]
Yes thats what y i like him Originally Posted by thimuru
12B , Minnale, Ullam Ketkume, Unale Unale, Majnu are all very pleasant albums ive ever heard
-
From: nemesis786 on 20th April 2007 07:56 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by ajaybaskar
-
From: Nerd on 20th April 2007 07:58 PM [Full View]
orE naaLLa 30 page-A ???????
-
From: selvakumar on 20th April 2007 08:07 PM [Full View]
Harris
For a change, let me express my opinion on these two MDs. First of all, I would love to highlight the fact that I don't have any grudge on U1 or HJ !
HJ
> This guy simply amazes me with the kind of presentation that he instills in every one of his albums. Right from Minnale, this guy is consistent and follows his own way.
His primary skills include
- Packaging of songs (He carefully presents them so that an ordinary guy won't run away if he starts hearing the songs)
- Selection of singers (One of the important skills of HJ. He is very careful with his singers. He knows exactly who should sing a particular song. But not sure why he uses BJ often. )
- Lyrics - He gives enough care to the lyrics. Hardly you will feel like missing a line in his song. His style is simple. Give 50% chance for the poet and ride your music and fill the necessary 50% so that you will have a song in your hand0
- The pan urban feel is something noteworthy. He is very clear on what he is doing. He doesn't like giving albums which will be drastically diff to his audience. Be it Minnlae, Lesa Lesa, UU, Gajini etc ! He knows clearly what he should do !
- He has abundant fans among the college students. His female fan base is high comparitively
Negatives
- All the points that I have listed above work as negatives for him sometimes. He uses same singers often which reduces the feel making them sound similar. The DEJAVU FEEL is more in his albums.
- BGM > This is one area in which he has to concentrate heavily. His works of late were pathetic.
- He is too good in using soft instruments. so, BGM for a movie like minnale, LL, UU etc will fit perfectly. But for other movies, it will look like a TOMATO SAUCE poured on a SAMBAAR RICE !
If HJ concentrates a bit and experiments a little bit, he would have been more successful.
Tail piece : I loved "JUne ponaal" and I rate this better than the original
-
From: selvakumar on 20th April 2007 08:08 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by Nerd
orE naaLLa 30 page-A ??????? Porumaiyaa Read pannunga
-
From: selvakumar on 20th April 2007 08:12 PM [Full View]
and I will write more on U1 as well. My favorite MD in the recent times.
-
From: sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar on 20th April 2007 08:18 PM [Full View]
selva,
superb points
i saw VV recently on dvd, in my laptp, weared big headphones.....there is lot of good BGM in this movie. all good music in one movie! i know other movies BGM sucks....
-
From: nemesis786 on 20th April 2007 08:23 PM [Full View]
BGM of Kaaka Kaaka,Samurai, Ghajini, Anniyan, Minnale , 12B, Ullam Ketkume , Thotti jaya sucked? I thought they were smash hits Originally Posted by sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar
selva,
superb points
i saw VV recently on dvd, in my laptp, weared big headphones.....there is lot of good BGM in this movie. all good music in one movie! i know other movies BGM sucks....
-
From: Sanguine Sridhar on 20th April 2007 08:29 PM [Full View]
Excellent analysis Selva! but do you think HJ is responsible for the lyrics? I dont think so!
All Gautham + HJ songs are lyrics based hits because of Thamarai, so it reached all young ladies.But we have to accept that some of his songs are like Christian Choire songs... (Paartha Mudhal Naale,Oru Maalai Ilaveyil). But Hj songs reach all type of mass, thats his greates strength!
-
From: nemesis786 on 20th April 2007 08:31 PM [Full View]
Hits due to thamarai? Can you elaborate on this?
-
From: Sanguine Sridhar on 20th April 2007 08:33 PM [Full View]
Talking about Thotti Jeya...
Uyire En Uyire\Yaaridamum thondravillai... are the two greatest melodies
In Anniyan Iyengaru veetu azhage - excellent carnatic song...
Hmmmm am I becoming a HJ fan ?
-
From: Sanguine Sridhar on 20th April 2007 08:36 PM [Full View]
I said Lyrics based hits ... ! but music is an added advantage to those songs. Originally Posted by nemesis786
-
From: Nerd on 20th April 2007 08:44 PM [Full View]
Give it a break guys. nEthu nadanthathayE naan innum padichu mudikkala. But some of the posts are plain hilarious
IR the BEST
-
From: thimuru on 20th April 2007 08:45 PM [Full View]
HE DOESNT CHOP LYRICS LIKE OTHER MDS... Originally Posted by Sanguine Sridhar
Excellent analysis Selva! but do you think HJ is responsible for the lyrics? I dont think so!
All Gautham + HJ songs are lyrics based hits because of Thamarai, so it reached all young ladies.But we have to accept that some of his songs are like Christian Choire songs... (Paartha Mudhal Naale,Oru Maalai Ilaveyil). But Hj songs reach all type of mass, thats his greates strength!
-
From: great on 20th April 2007 08:57 PM [Full View]
25 pages-a
East or west , IR is the Best
-
From: Nerd on 20th April 2007 10:03 PM [Full View]
My 2 cents
Pras said HJ is better than ARR and I guess he meant it as a JOKE.
Sanjeevi said pavithra songs are duds. Please listen to uyirum neeyE from pavithrA. That song IMO will feature in ARR's top 10 best songs. These are the kind of songs an MD would wish to have in his resume
If it is OK to assume that either ajith or vijay is the no. 1 hero in TF industry then its OK to assume that either HJ or YSR is the #1 in tfm right now. Rajini gives a movie once in two years but in the last 12 years or so he has hardly fail and me, along with a whole bunch of people/media are still hailing him as the #1 star in tamil nadu. Similary eventhough ARR is not giving a lot of albums, he is still at the #1 position. I mean the hype it generates for his albums is monstrous.
Also I think its safe to assume that YSR has surpassed even ARR in terms of BGM. HJ is a JOKE when it comes to BGM
phew.....
-
From: villan007 on 20th April 2007 10:18 PM [Full View]
Nerd
-
From: kb on 20th April 2007 10:34 PM [Full View]
karthik raja does the BGM for YSR in some cases..
and sabesh murali does for some ARR movies..
check out for shivaji BGM which is done by ARR
-
From: Jabroni on 20th April 2007 10:44 PM [Full View]
Chandramuhi was the biggest of 2006 in sales wise so that is the album of the year Originally Posted by ajaybaskar
-
From: Jabroni on 20th April 2007 11:02 PM [Full View]
All the blabbel here can you tell me whether a normal cine goer from a village will get satisfaction from ARR songs?
Directors like Goutham are westernizing tamil cinema and tamil culture will dissapear should it continue.
ARR with his westernizing ruins tamil cinema. Would an average person be able to listen boys, new, aah aah, or for that matter HJ's music?
osaama neeyanu paadina kizhavi paralogam pOguthu. Can people of different age enjoy ARR and HJ songs?
I'm not in denial of ARR's good albums but now his albums are targetted at youth.
-
From: Villan on 20th April 2007 11:03 PM [Full View]
Exactly Originally Posted by Nerd
My 2 cents
Pras said HJ is better than ARR and I guess he meant it as a JOKE.
Sanjeevi said pavithra songs are duds. Please listen to uyirum neeyE from pavithrA. That song IMO will feature in ARR's top 10 best songs. These are the kind of songs an MD would wish to have in his resume
If it is OK to assume that either ajith or vijay is the no. 1 hero in TF industry then its OK to assume that either HJ or YSR is the #1 in tfm right now. Rajini gives a movie once in two years but in the last 12 years or so he has hardly fail and me, along with a whole bunch of people/media are still hailing him as the #1 star in tamil nadu. Similary eventhough ARR is not giving a lot of albums, he is still at the #1 position. I mean the hype it generates for his albums is monstrous.
Also I think its safe to assume that YSR has surpassed even ARR in terms of BGM. HJ is a JOKE when it comes to BGM
phew.....
-
From: Sanjeevi on 21st April 2007 12:09 AM [Full View]
Originally Posted by Nerd
please read the sentence in brackets (except two songs) Originally Posted by Nerd
Sanjeevi said pavithra songs are duds. Please listen to uyirum neeyE from pavithrA. That song IMO will feature in ARR's top 10 best songs. These are the kind of songs an MD would wish to have in his resume
Thus, i liked not only Uryirum song, Sevvanam song too
Originally Posted by Nerd
terrific comparision betw current MDs with Current Heros
According to me, the No. 1 MD in TFM should go to three persons ARR, YSR, HJ.
When 7G, Manmadhan - YSR leads
When Gajini, VV - HJ leads
now it is time to ARR - thanks to Sivaji
However, Vidayasagar did a fabulous album, Mozhi and it is rocking TN.
-
From: Sanjeevi on 21st April 2007 12:13 AM [Full View]
intha 11 pakkangalum serthal Originally Posted by great
25 pages-a
East or west , IR is the Best
40 pages in a single day
-
From: Flavia on 21st April 2007 07:23 AM [Full View]
Macroni's posts, right? Originally Posted by Nerd
Give it a break guys. nEthu nadanthathayE naan innum padichu mudikkala. But some of the posts are plain hilarious
IR the BEST
-
From: ajaybaskar on 21st April 2007 11:10 AM [Full View]
U stole my words,Nerd except the last line. Originally Posted by Nerd
My 2 cents
Pras said HJ is better than ARR and I guess he meant it as a JOKE.
Sanjeevi said pavithra songs are duds. Please listen to uyirum neeyE from pavithrA. That song IMO will feature in ARR's top 10 best songs. These are the kind of songs an MD would wish to have in his resume
If it is OK to assume that either ajith or vijay is the no. 1 hero in TF industry then its OK to assume that either HJ or YSR is the #1 in tfm right now. Rajini gives a movie once in two years but in the last 12 years or so he has hardly fail and me, along with a whole bunch of people/media are still hailing him as the #1 star in tamil nadu. Similary eventhough ARR is not giving a lot of albums, he is still at the #1 position. I mean the hype it generates for his albums is monstrous.
Also I think its safe to assume that YSR has surpassed even ARR in terms of BGM. HJ is a JOKE when it comes to BGM
phew.....
YSR's BGMs resemble his father's works. But wat ARR composes is fresh and is a not-heard-before kinda stuff.
-
From: dinesh2002 on 21st April 2007 01:01 PM [Full View]
this is just some reasons for u guys to grab the credit from ARR .... Originally Posted by nemesis786
Combination n hype! CM was just ordinary with less hype initially! Originally Posted by ajaybaskar
But Shankar-Rajini which was the most expected combo for a long time from mudalvan SIVAJI audio has sold!
Harris jayaraja irundha kooda adhedhaan airikkum
yo buddies....typical logic la machi.... the hype which was created,must usually comes down after 3 -4 days.... so during those time,if the audio sales r high,it goes to the hype of the combo & rajine...after that,wat is gonna rock is SOLELY the audio's power.... ohh come on... b4 for CM when it got released, the songs wasnt popular... after the movie was doing a great job....then the audio picked up...esp Devuda & Raa Raa .... did u see anyone going crazy for Raa Raa b4 the movie was released???
now....is Sivaji audio rocking ???!!! YES!!! and a big thanks to ARR..... and ofcource that ARR-Shankar combo...... other than Bailellaka, no 1 would guess it was songs of a Rajini starrer film....
-
From: nemesis786 on 21st April 2007 01:49 PM [Full View]
Adhu 2006 ilai 2005 Originally Posted by Jabroni
Chandramuhi was the biggest of 2006 in sales wise so that is the album of the year Originally Posted by ajaybaskar
But in 2005 reach-wise ghajini n anniyan songs were
-
From: nerdy on 22nd April 2007 04:50 PM [Full View]
Ilaiyaraja is our Isai Raja
Has ARR given any ever green albums like IR's Nenjathai Killadhey, Ninaivellam Nithay and a lot or done recording like Hey Ram.?
Honestly speaking Most of ARR albums fade away and forgotten after few months of its release.But this is the not the same case for IR.
IR is as good as KVM in Carnatic
IR is as good as MSV in Melodies
He is very good in western.
IR - the music emperor of our Country.
-
From: nemesis786 on 22nd April 2007 05:32 PM [Full View]
-
From: Flavia on 22nd April 2007 06:11 PM [Full View]
That may be the case for IR fans like you. But we ARR fans do savour every bit of each song right from Roja to Sivaji. We never feel blase about even a single song. Hear songs from Roja(chinna chinna aasai, kadhal rojave) , Rangeela (Hey raama, kya kareka) , Kadhalan(Kadhalikum pennin, Ennavale) ...i can go on listing like this. They still sound as fresh as morning dew. Originally Posted by nerdy
:P
-
From: villan007 on 22nd April 2007 07:41 PM [Full View]
innum sandai mudialia ?
-
From: NOV on 22nd April 2007 07:56 PM [Full View]
WARNING: Do not go overboard with your criticisms. Asking people who do not agree with your opinion to go back to school and retorting by calling names, will not only not help in your argument, but could also result in moderator intervention.
-
From: RPB on 22nd April 2007 07:57 PM [Full View]
VISWANATH AND ILLAYARAGA ARE LEGENDS.
ILLAYARAJA IS INSPIRATION OF ALL YOUNG MUSIC DIRECTORS.
AFTER ILLYARAJA AND MSV.YSR AND HARRISH JAYARAJ IS BEST.
-
From: ajaybaskar on 22nd April 2007 09:41 PM [Full View]
Naanum appadithaan. Daily ARR paattu kettuttuthaan mulikkiradhe!!! Adhu oru suganubavam... Originally Posted by Flavia
That may be the case for IR fans like you. But we ARR fans do savour every bit of each song right from Roja to Sivaji. We never feel blase about even a single song. Hear songs from Roja(chinna chinna aasai, kadhal rojave) , Rangeela (Hey raama, kya kareka) , Kadhalan(Kadhalikum pennin, Ennavale) ...i can go on listing like this. They still sound as fresh as morning dew. Originally Posted by nerdy
:P
-
From: Pras on 23rd April 2007 12:01 PM [Full View]
ya, naanum appadithaan, ARR pattu kettu thaan mulikurathe, DAMAAL DUMIL-nu background-la satham ketta, nalla mulikalaam Originally Posted by ajaybaskar
Naanum appadithaan. Daily ARR paattu kettuttuthaan mulikkiradhe!!! Adhu oru suganubavam... Originally Posted by Flavia
That may be the case for IR fans like you. But we ARR fans do savour every bit of each song right from Roja to Sivaji. We never feel blase about even a single song. Hear songs from Roja(chinna chinna aasai, kadhal rojave) , Rangeela (Hey raama, kya kareka) , Kadhalan(Kadhalikum pennin, Ennavale) ...i can go on listing like this. They still sound as fresh as morning dew. Originally Posted by nerdy
:P
-
From: ajaybaskar on 23rd April 2007 12:05 PM [Full View]
Comedyamaam....
-
From: MADDY on 23rd April 2007 12:28 PM [Full View]
reminds me of my nephew's story.........he was born on the day Boys audio released ........when they came to india, i used to play "girlfriend" song non-stop in my house.......my nephew got used to it so much, we had to play that song whenever he had to eat.......
for those "dammal-dummil" critics of ARR - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T4oK6A2JOTc
-
From: thilak4life on 23rd April 2007 12:30 PM [Full View]
Arambichitaanga da..
-
From: ajaybaskar on 23rd April 2007 12:37 PM [Full View]
The same applies to my sister too. She was jus 15 months old then and she will start shakin her tiny legs whenever her father plays Musthafa song.. Thats ARR... Originally Posted by MADDY
reminds me of my nephew's story.........he was born on the day Boys audio released ........when they came to india, i used to play "girlfriend" song non-stop in my house.......my nephew got used to it so much, we had to play that song whenever he had to eat.......
for those "dammal-dummil" critics of ARR - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T4oK6A2JOTc
-
From: joe on 23rd April 2007 12:49 PM [Full View]
Ada pongappa ! 16 months old en payyan kooda TV-la entha serial title song vanthaalum super-a dance aaduran..is it power of all TV serial music directors? Originally Posted by ajaybaskar
-
From: thilak4life on 23rd April 2007 12:55 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by joe
Ada pongappa ! 16 months old en payyan kooda TV-la entha serial title song vanthaalum super-a dance aaduran..is it power of all TV serial music directors? Originally Posted by ajaybaskar
-
From: ajaybaskar on 23rd April 2007 12:56 PM [Full View]
Endha serial title song vandhalum kaala aatturadhu vera..Orey paattukku mattum cameo panradhu vera,Joe..
-
From: MADDY on 23rd April 2007 01:03 PM [Full View]
ada vidu ajay, my father used to say that i used to shake my leg for "ponmeni" (moonraam pirai) song when i was a 10 month old...............adhukaaga adhu IR music power-nnu solla mudiyuma???
MODS, can we pls rename the thread to "criticisms on ARR and rebuttals from his fans" ???
-
From: ajaybaskar on 23rd April 2007 01:07 PM [Full View]
Ungalukku "Ponmeni" songna enakku "Vaigaikkarai kaatrae nillu, Vanjithanai paarthaal sollu". I was a TR Fan at the age of 2... Originally Posted by MADDY
ada vidu ajay, my father used to say that i used to shake my leg for "ponmeni" (moonraam pirai) song when i was a 10 month old...............adhukaaga adhu IR music power-nnu solla mudiyuma???
MODS, can we pls rename the thread to "criticisms on ARR and rebuttals from his fans" ???
-
From: joe on 23rd April 2007 01:07 PM [Full View]
Ajay, Originally Posted by ajaybaskar
As Maddy said (Though he is ARR fan) there is no logic in your claim -nnu solla vanthen.
My son now dances for all beats ..OK ..But when he was 8 months old ,when the music comes 'SUN TV-n Thamizh Maalai' athukku mattum thaan vacha kannu vaangama parppaan ,not even for Mustafa ..Does it mean ,all time powerful music is Sun TV music ?
-
From: ajaybaskar on 23rd April 2007 01:16 PM [Full View]
Sariyaana SUNTV kuzhandaiya iruppaan polirukkae... Originally Posted by joe
Ajay, Originally Posted by ajaybaskar
As Maddy said (Though he is ARR fan) there is no logic in your claim -nnu solla vanthen.
My son now dances for all beats ..OK ..But when he was 8 months old ,when the music comes 'SUN TV-n Thamizh Maalai' athukku mattum thaan vacha kannu vaangama parppaan ,not even for Mustafa ..Does it mean ,all time powerful music is Sun TV music ?
Anyways wat i intended to say was She was only dancing for Musthafa and she is 10+ yrs old now and still the song is her all time fav.
-
From: thilak4life on 23rd April 2007 04:45 PM [Full View]
vidu pa..Ariyada vayasulla naan kooda ARR fan..ippo karuthu therinju....nariya paattu keta udanne marittaen..It takes time..thats okay..Exposure is the main issue:
-
From: selvakumar on 23rd April 2007 04:51 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by thilak4life
vidu pa..Ariyada vayasulla naan kooda ARR fan..ippo karuthu therinju....nariya paattu keta udanne marittaen..It takes time..thats okay..Exposure is the main issue: That is why I never refuse to listen to the works of Baratwaj, Deva, Dhina, etc
-
From: Sanjeevi on 23rd April 2007 05:10 PM [Full View]
adada what a memory power ungalukku ellam Originally Posted by ajaybaskar
Ungalukku "Ponmeni" songna enakku "Vaigaikkarai kaatrae nillu, Vanjithanai paarthaal sollu". I was a TR Fan at the age of 2... Originally Posted by MADDY
ada vidu ajay, my father used to say that i used to shake my leg for "ponmeni" (moonraam pirai) song when i was a 10 month old...............adhukaaga adhu IR music power-nnu solla mudiyuma???
MODS, can we pls rename the thread to "criticisms on ARR and rebuttals from his fans" ???
why you missed, when you are in mother's stomach
-
From: thilak4life on 23rd April 2007 05:16 PM [Full View]
Nalla joke sir..You're smart..but unfortunately they are not near IR or ARR's class..So don't bother about them.. I have listened to their stuff and it's not near the above two composers.. Originally Posted by selvakumar
Originally Posted by thilak4life
vidu pa..Ariyada vayasulla naan kooda ARR fan..ippo karuthu therinju....nariya paattu keta udanne marittaen..It takes time..thats okay..Exposure is the main issue: That is why I never refuse to listen to the works of Baratwaj, Deva, Dhina, etc
-
From: MADDY on 23rd April 2007 05:17 PM [Full View]
in a urgency to snub, i think people are missing words here...... Originally Posted by Sanjeevi
adada what a memory power ungalukku ellam Originally Posted by ajaybaskar
Ungalukku "Ponmeni" songna enakku "Vaigaikkarai kaatrae nillu, Vanjithanai paarthaal sollu". I was a TR Fan at the age of 2... Originally Posted by MADDY
ada vidu ajay, my father used to say that i used to shake my leg for "ponmeni" (moonraam pirai) song when i was a 10 month old...............adhukaaga adhu IR music power-nnu solla mudiyuma???
MODS, can we pls rename the thread to "criticisms on ARR and rebuttals from his fans" ???
why you missed, when you are in mother's stomach and not me remembering it......... Originally Posted by Maddy
yes thilak, exposure is the key here............even i was listening to IR's works till ARR came........since 1992, its just one-way traffic.........only ARR no IR........
-
From: thilak4life on 23rd April 2007 05:23 PM [Full View]
Maddy,
we both seem to be quite the opposite
-
From: MADDY on 23rd April 2007 06:06 PM [Full View]
yeah...... Originally Posted by thilak4life
Maddy,
we both seem to be quite the opposite .......bala kitta kelunga avarum idha thaan solluvaaru enna pathhi....
yes, ppl. who were neutral b4 1992, and then bcame ARR fans always remain ARR fans.........ppl. who were IR fans and then bcome ARR fan in 1992, tend to gradually move out of ARR and get back to IR..........so this "impression" of ARR having lost ground is very false IMO ........
-
From: thimuru on 23rd April 2007 06:21 PM [Full View]
naanum chinna vayasula rajni fan..eppo paathalum rajni rajninu thirivanam....veetla sonnanga.. Originally Posted by thilak4life
vidu pa..Ariyada vayasulla naan kooda ARR fan..ippo karuthu therinju....nariya paattu keta udanne marittaen..It takes time..thats okay..Exposure is the main issue:
appurama buthi thelinjapuram kamal fan..idhellam ariyadha vayasu puriyadha manasu thelinja sariyayidum
-
From: Rajkumar_mj on 23rd April 2007 06:40 PM [Full View]
Nilavu Originally Posted by thimuru
naanum chinna vayasula rajni fan..eppo paathalum rajni rajninu thirivanam....veetla sonnanga..appurama buthi thelinjapuram kamal fan..idhellam ariyadha vayasu puriyadha manasu Originally Posted by thilak4life
vidu pa..Ariyada vayasulla naan kooda ARR fan..ippo karuthu therinju....nariya paattu keta udanne marittaen..It takes time..thats okay..Exposure is the main issue: thelinja sariyayidum
Indha Example Ippa thevaiya.?
-
From: thimuru on 23rd April 2007 06:42 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by Rajkumar_mj
Nilavu Originally Posted by thimuru
naanum chinna vayasula rajni fan..eppo paathalum rajni rajninu thirivanam....veetla sonnanga..appurama buthi thelinjapuram kamal fan..idhellam ariyadha vayasu puriyadha manasu Originally Posted by thilak4life
vidu pa..Ariyada vayasulla naan kooda ARR fan..ippo karuthu therinju....nariya paattu keta udanne marittaen..It takes time..thats okay..Exposure is the main issue: thelinja sariyayidum
Indha Example Ippa thevaiya.?
-
From: MADDY on 23rd April 2007 06:45 PM [Full View]
romba thevai Originally Posted by Rajkumar_mj
Nilavu Originally Posted by thimuru
naanum chinna vayasula rajni fan..eppo paathalum rajni rajninu thirivanam....veetla sonnanga..appurama buthi thelinjapuram kamal fan..idhellam ariyadha vayasu puriyadha manasu Originally Posted by thilak4life
vidu pa..Ariyada vayasulla naan kooda ARR fan..ippo karuthu therinju....nariya paattu keta udanne marittaen..It takes time..thats okay..Exposure is the main issue: thelinja sariyayidum
Indha Example Ippa thevaiya.? .....cos i'm again a opposite here.......i was a HC kamal fan in my childhood days..........now, i'm a rajini fan ........
but, now waiting for 10A to make the switch again .....but will always stay a rajini-admirer
-
From: thimuru on 23rd April 2007 06:47 PM [Full View]
MADDY...ungalaoda parinama valarchiye thalageela irukke Originally Posted by MADDY
romba thevai Originally Posted by Rajkumar_mj
Nilavu Originally Posted by thimuru
naanum chinna vayasula rajni fan..eppo paathalum rajni rajninu thirivanam....veetla sonnanga..appurama buthi thelinjapuram kamal fan..idhellam ariyadha vayasu puriyadha manasu Originally Posted by thilak4life
vidu pa..Ariyada vayasulla naan kooda ARR fan..ippo karuthu therinju....nariya paattu keta udanne marittaen..It takes time..thats okay..Exposure is the main issue: thelinja sariyayidum
Indha Example Ippa thevaiya.? .....cos i'm again a opposite here.......i was a HC kamal fan in my childhood days..........now, i'm a rajini fan ........
but, now waiting for 10A to make the switch again .....but will always stay a rajini-admirer
-
From: thilak4life on 23rd April 2007 06:50 PM [Full View]
yenamo ponga Maddy...romba kollapama irukku.. Ippidi kooda irukka moodiyuma!!!! Originally Posted by MADDY
romba thevai Originally Posted by Rajkumar_mj
Nilavu Originally Posted by thimuru
naanum chinna vayasula rajni fan..eppo paathalum rajni rajninu thirivanam....veetla sonnanga..appurama buthi thelinjapuram kamal fan..idhellam ariyadha vayasu puriyadha manasu Originally Posted by thilak4life
vidu pa..Ariyada vayasulla naan kooda ARR fan..ippo karuthu therinju....nariya paattu keta udanne marittaen..It takes time..thats okay..Exposure is the main issue: thelinja sariyayidum
Indha Example Ippa thevaiya.? .....cos i'm again a opposite here.......i was a HC kamal fan in my childhood days..........now, i'm a rajini fan ........
but, now waiting for 10A to make the switch again .....but will always stay a rajini-admirer
-
From: selvakumar on 23rd April 2007 07:00 PM [Full View]
Thilak,
Athu Joke illa.. Unmai thaan I listen to works from all the MDs without rejecting anything.
-
From: MADDY on 23rd April 2007 07:06 PM [Full View]
yes selva seems to have a criticism for everyone, from IR to ARR to YSR and HJ.......so he is really neutral Originally Posted by selvakumar
Thilak,
Athu Joke illa.. Unmai thaan I listen to works from all the MDs without rejecting anything. ...... 
-
From: nemesis786 on 23rd April 2007 07:13 PM [Full View]
Harris rocks next is yuvan
-
From: nemesis786 on 23rd April 2007 08:08 PM [Full View]
Poove Vai Pesumbodhu ALL TIME BEST CLASSIC from HARRIS for 12B
-
From: Villan on 23rd April 2007 09:43 PM [Full View]
All time fav is ARR....he rocks
-
From: Flavia on 24th April 2007 01:20 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by Villan
All time fav is ARR....he rocks
-
From: Flavia on 24th April 2007 01:24 PM [Full View]
mooooooodiyave mooooooooooodiyadu Originally Posted by thilak4life
j/k
-
From: zz on 24th April 2007 02:08 PM [Full View]
Poove vaipesum boshu..crdit goes to ARR
This song is another example of the sneak copy that HJ employs and is a master with.
The original is a sankarabaranam number from ARR "Thoda thoda marndha dhenna"
I could have absolved HJ from using this raaga, anubody could use it, but the way he employs other instruments and flow, clearly suggests that it is not a e-adichchan copy but e-dikkadha effective copy.
-
From: Flavia on 24th April 2007 02:14 PM [Full View]
Re: Poove vaipesum boshu..crdit goes to ARR
Originally Posted by zz
What are you trying to say?
-
From: thamizhvaanan on 24th April 2007 02:22 PM [Full View]
Flavia .. look at the subject of his post..
"Poove vaipesum boshu..crdit goes to ARR"
he is talking abt that song
-
From: Flavia on 24th April 2007 02:25 PM [Full View]
Thanks for enlightening. Now I understand. Originally Posted by thamizhvaanan
-
From: nemesis786 on 24th April 2007 02:36 PM [Full View]
Re: Poove vaipesum boshu..crdit goes to ARR
I dont see any similarity between them HARRIS' 12B music was a big hit Originally Posted by zz
-
From: thamizhvaanan on 24th April 2007 02:37 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by Flavia
Thanks for enlightening. Now I understand. I too wondered.. thats why I noticed :P
-
From: dinesh2002 on 24th April 2007 04:34 PM [Full View]
Re: Poove vaipesum boshu..crdit goes to ARR
he has many songs which he actually keeps an ARR number as his reference... thats y it becomes a big hit... thanks to that previous ARR number that was registered in people's mind & heart... when they listen to another version of this, it strikes !! they get hooked to it... a very good example is Originally Posted by nemesis786
I dont see any similarity between them HARRIS' 12B music was a big hit Originally Posted by zz
Venmathiye - Minnale = Evano Oruvan - Alaipayuthey
Kadhal Konjam - PKMC = New York - SOK
Vaigasi Nilave - UU = Mayilirage - Ah Aah
what is a super hit...doesnt means its super in quality wise....and vice versa.... there r many songs of HJ which was good that went unnoticed aswell....
-
From: nemesis786 on 24th April 2007 04:43 PM [Full View]
Re: Poove vaipesum boshu..crdit goes to ARR
Originally Posted by dinesh2002
a very good example is
Venmathiye - Minnale = Evano Oruvan - Alaipayuthey
Kadhal Konjam - PKMC = New York - SOK
Vaigasi Nilave - UU = Mayilirage - Ah Aah
what is a super hit...doesnt means its super in quality wise....and vice versa.... there r many songs of HJ which was good that went unnoticed aswell....
man i am not deaf ! they dont have any similarity
There is similarity between Suttum Vizhi Sudare and Paartha Mudhal naale , but not for sure the 3 songs u mentioned
-
From: selvakumar on 24th April 2007 05:04 PM [Full View]
Dinesh,
You could have mentioned few songs of HJ which will be more similar to ARR songs. I have diff of opinion on your list.
Songs in Ullam ketkumae were much similar to some of ARR songs and not to forget the latest one in Sainikudu !
-
From: dinesh2002 on 24th April 2007 05:16 PM [Full View]
Re: Poove vaipesum boshu..crdit goes to ARR
simularity between thier own song is not a big thing... ARR has many in that case infact.... Originally Posted by nemesis786
Originally Posted by dinesh2002
a very good example is
Venmathiye - Minnale = Evano Oruvan - Alaipayuthey
Kadhal Konjam - PKMC = New York - SOK
Vaigasi Nilave - UU = Mayilirage - Ah Aah
what is a super hit...doesnt means its super in quality wise....and vice versa.... there r many songs of HJ which was good that went unnoticed aswell....
man i am not deaf ! they dont have any similarity
There is similarity between Suttum Vizhi Sudare and Paartha Mudhal naale , but not for sure the 3 songs u mentioned
bro... thats the speciality in HJ... he copies/follows the songs of ARR alwiz.... but sometimes he does it in a very slick way that not many could recognize it on the spot... actually MANY doesnt know... but some people could notice it very fast....
Venmathi & Evano Oruvan - Instruments/arrangments r same
Kadhal konjum & New york - listen to Kadhal Konjam from 2:23 up to the song when it ends... and listen to New York from 3:24 up to the end... that FEEL/arrangments and usage of female chorus that pops in & out of both the song is quite obvious...
and as for Vaigasi NIlave .... dude...just sing " Vaigasi Nilave...Vaigasi Nilave.... Mai Poosi vethirukum Kannil..." and " Mayilirage...Mayilirage.... Varudugirai Mella" and ofcource...the stanza " Itho....Ennakage Virindhe Ithar...edakavathene..." & " Paal...Vilakangal...Nee Koore....Oor...Urangakthum...Uraipen...Keelu" was a total give away....
but nevertheless...they were good songs from HJ...
still cant notice??? then i have no comments....
-
From: dinesh2002 on 24th April 2007 05:19 PM [Full View]
no selva... i wanna point out the songs that was copied which is very profesionally covered by HJ.... the obvious once r just too obvious... no need to mention it... def the HJ fans will realize it... Originally Posted by selvakumar
Dinesh,
You could have mentioned few songs of HJ which will be more similar to ARR songs. I have diff of opinion on your list.
Songs in Ullam ketkumae were much similar to some of ARR songs and not to forget the latest one in Sainikudu !
-
From: zz on 24th April 2007 06:28 PM [Full View]
Some one said about 12B.
Come on I pointed out the unobvious "Poove vai pesum bodhu"
have you all forgotten the almost e-dichchan copy of song "oru punnagai poove". Man it is a near perfect rendition of "kickku erudhe" in HJ style.
HJ wantedly let the e fly so that he does not adichchify the e mistakenly and make it a perfect e-adichchan.
Honestly speaking I admire HJ for how he works on ARR numbers and come up with some pleasing numbers. In my young age I too imagine how else I could have compsed this song from where ARR has left. Who knows HJ might be a huge fan of ARR like me
-
From: selvakumar on 24th April 2007 06:30 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by zz
-
From: MADDY on 24th April 2007 08:46 PM [Full View]
http://www.musicindiaonline.com/musi...vie_name.4493/ - Kannai Katti (1997) Originally Posted by selvakumar
Originally Posted by zz
http://www.musicindiaonline.com/musi...vie_name.4138/ - love pannu (2001)
dont look for 100% lift, obviously, there will be some changes by HJ, but the beats,general feel and the arrangements - its inspired........defntly..........also, please notice the trumpet pieces in both the songs.....its so embarrasingly similar....
-
From: nemesis786 on 24th April 2007 08:49 PM [Full View]
s there is similarity
-
From: Yathu on 24th April 2007 09:29 PM [Full View]
I personally am very happy that ARR has influenced other peoples music. It only increases the amount of good music coming out of India, which is a GOOD thing!
ARR has shown others how to make GOOD music.
-
From: thimuru on 24th April 2007 09:39 PM [Full View]
so...what is bad music according to u? Originally Posted by Yathu
I personally am very happy that ARR has influenced other peoples music. It only increases the amount of good music coming out of India, which is a GOOD thing!
ARR has shown others how to make GOOD music. [/b]
-
From: nemesis786 on 24th April 2007 09:41 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by thimuru
so...what is bad music according to u? Originally Posted by Yathu
I personally am very happy that ARR has influenced other peoples music. It only increases the amount of good music coming out of India, which is a GOOD thing!
ARR has shown others how to make GOOD music. [/b]
The ones that MDs like BHARANI , VIJAY ANTONY give
-
From: Flavia on 24th April 2007 09:42 PM [Full View]
Thimiru won't get sleep without triggering atleast one fight a day in hub.
-
From: Yathu on 24th April 2007 09:49 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by nemesis786
Originally Posted by thimuru
so...what is bad music according to u? Originally Posted by Yathu
I personally am very happy that ARR has influenced other peoples music. It only increases the amount of good music coming out of India, which is a GOOD thing!
ARR has shown others how to make GOOD music. [/b]
The ones that MDs like BHARANI , VIJAY ANTONY give
I could add a few more to that list
, but RELAX thimuru I wont! 
-
From: thimuru on 24th April 2007 09:54 PM [Full View]
enna pathi ipdi nenachuteengale Originally Posted by Flavia
Thimiru won't get sleep without triggering atleast one fight a day in hub.
-
From: ajithfederer on 24th April 2007 09:57 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by thimuru
enna pathi ipdi nenachuteengale Originally Posted by Flavia
Thimiru won't get sleep without triggering atleast one fight a day in hub.
-
From: Flavia on 24th April 2007 10:04 PM [Full View]
pinna epdi ninaikardhu? Originally Posted by thimuru
enna pathi ipdi nenachuteengale Originally Posted by Flavia
Thimiru won't get sleep without triggering atleast one fight a day in hub.
-
From: thimuru on 24th April 2007 10:05 PM [Full View]
neenga m/f? Originally Posted by Flavia
pinna epdi ninaikardhu? Originally Posted by thimuru
enna pathi ipdi nenachuteengale Originally Posted by Flavia
Thimiru won't get sleep without triggering atleast one fight a day in hub.
-
From: thimuru on 24th April 2007 10:09 PM [Full View]
enna badhilaye kanom
-
From: Flavia on 24th April 2007 10:10 PM [Full View]
F thAn. Originally Posted by thimuru
neenga m/f? Originally Posted by Flavia
pinna epdi ninaikardhu? Originally Posted by thimuru
enna pathi ipdi nenachuteengale Originally Posted by Flavia
Thimiru won't get sleep without triggering atleast one fight a day in hub.
-
From: Flavia on 24th April 2007 10:12 PM [Full View]
Net connection slow Originally Posted by thimuru
enna badhilaye kanom
-
From: thimuru on 24th April 2007 10:12 PM [Full View]
mmm...appo enna vena nenainga...aanaa nenacha podhum
-
From: nemesis786 on 24th April 2007 10:15 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by thimuru
mmm...appo enna vena nenainga...aanaa nenacha podhum
-
From: thimuru on 24th April 2007 10:16 PM [Full View]
harris jeyaraj is giving a jazz feel in all his songs!...is it?
or enakuthan apdithonudha
-
From: Flavia on 24th April 2007 10:16 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by thimuru
mmm...appo enna vena nenainga...aanaa nenacha podhum
-
From: villan007 on 24th April 2007 10:18 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by thimuru
mmm...appo enna vena nenainga...aanaa nenacha podhum
-
From: nemesis786 on 24th April 2007 10:18 PM [Full View]
Yes he gives an urban feel but not sure if its jazz Originally Posted by thimuru
-
From: thimuru on 24th April 2007 10:20 PM [Full View]
how abt harris composing for village subject?
-
From: villan007 on 24th April 2007 10:21 PM [Full View]
kovanathuku zip vecha maari irukum Originally Posted by thimuru
kovil was a village subject aana songs modern-a irunthichi
-
From: thimuru on 24th April 2007 10:22 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by villan007
kovanathuku zip vecha maari irukum Originally Posted by thimuru
kovil was a village subject aana songs modern-a irunthichi apdiye elastikum vechuta sowriyama pochu.
-
From: selvakumar on 24th April 2007 10:22 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by thimuru
mmm...appo enna vena nenainga...aanaa nenacha podhum
-
From: Flavia on 24th April 2007 10:22 PM [Full View]
Kizhakku chEmaiyilE, KaruthammA and Tajmahal are there for him na, he can definitely score Originally Posted by thimuru
-
From: thimuru on 24th April 2007 10:23 PM [Full View]
do u think they are exactly folk songs...hehe Originally Posted by Flavia
Kizhakku chEmaiyilE, KaruthammA and Tajmahal are there for him na, he can definitely score Originally Posted by thimuru
-
From: Sanjeevi on 24th April 2007 10:27 PM [Full View]
hilarious villan Originally Posted by villan007
kovanathuku zip vecha maari irukum Originally Posted by thimuru
-
From: villan007 on 24th April 2007 10:27 PM [Full View]
illEndriya Originally Posted by thimuru
do u think they are exactly folk songs...hehe
-
From: thimuru on 24th April 2007 10:29 PM [Full View]
pinna aamandriya Originally Posted by villan007
illEndriya Originally Posted by thimuru
do u think they are exactly folk songs...hehe
-
From: nemesis786 on 24th April 2007 10:31 PM [Full View]
Folk songna YUVAN THAAAN BEST
-
From: Flavia on 24th April 2007 10:31 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by thimuru
do u think they are exactly folk songs...hehe Originally Posted by Flavia
Kizhakku chEmaiyilE, KaruthammA and Tajmahal are there for him na, he can definitely score Originally Posted by thimuru
What i meant was HJ would lift tunes from these movies if he were to score for a village-based subject.
BTW, what genre do u think the songs 'adi manja kilange', 'variyadi vAriyadi', 'maanoothu manthaiyile', 'KathAzhang kaatu vali' are?
-
From: villan007 on 24th April 2007 10:33 PM [Full View]
Vidyasagar Originally Posted by nemesis786
Folk songna YUVAN THAAAN BEST
-
From: thimuru on 24th April 2007 10:33 PM [Full View]
folkthan...inimel sanda poda vendam :P Originally Posted by Flavia
village subjects should have only folk songs is it? Originally Posted by thimuru
do u think they are exactly folk songs...hehe Originally Posted by Flavia
Kizhakku chEmaiyilE, KaruthammA and Tajmahal are there for him na, he can definitely score Originally Posted by thimuru
What i meant was HJ would lift tunes from these movies if he were to score for a village-based subject.
BTW, what genre do u think the songs 'adi manja kilange', 'variyadi vAriyadi', 'maanoothu manthaiyile', 'KathAzhang kaatu vali' are?
ARR vazhga
-
From: thimuru on 24th April 2007 10:33 PM [Full View]
i guess only thamirabarani was done by him in folk Originally Posted by villan007
Vidyasagar Originally Posted by nemesis786
Folk songna YUVAN THAAAN BEST
-
From: selvakumar on 24th April 2007 10:35 PM [Full View]
Apadi podu ! Originally Posted by thimuru
:ching Chaaa: :ching Chaa:
-
From: villan007 on 24th April 2007 10:35 PM [Full View]
paruthiveeran...
-
From: thamizhvaanan on 24th April 2007 10:35 PM [Full View]
Cmon.. avar thaan joke panraar'na avarukku neeyum eedu koduthu pesuriye Originally Posted by villan007
Vidyasagar Originally Posted by nemesis786
Folk songna YUVAN THAAAN BEST
-
From: thimuru on 24th April 2007 10:36 PM [Full View]
oiii...paruthiveeran by yuvan Originally Posted by villan007
paruthiveeran...
-
From: Flavia on 24th April 2007 10:36 PM [Full View]
Moreover who cares whether a song is exactly folk or approximately folk song is good to hear or not only matters
-
From: villan007 on 24th April 2007 10:36 PM [Full View]
enna machi , posukunu madangitta Originally Posted by thimuru
-
From: nemesis786 on 24th April 2007 10:36 PM [Full View]
Urban music na HARRIS
Urban, Folk, Remix, Masala all rounder YUVAN
-
From: villan007 on 24th April 2007 10:37 PM [Full View]
thamirabharani kooda than Originally Posted by thimuru
oiii...paruthiveeran by yuvan Originally Posted by villan007
paruthiveeran...
sivapathikaratha solla vandhEnu ninaikren
-
From: thimuru on 24th April 2007 10:37 PM [Full View]
eiii...arr ku enna korachal!u bloody idiot Originally Posted by villan007
enna machi , posukunu madangitta Originally Posted by thimuru
-
From: thimuru on 24th April 2007 10:38 PM [Full View]
aamaa...aamaa...small confusion Originally Posted by villan007
thamirabharani kooda than Originally Posted by thimuru
oiii...paruthiveeran by yuvan Originally Posted by villan007
paruthiveeran...
sivapathikaratha solla vandhEnu ninaikren
-
From: thimuru on 24th April 2007 10:38 PM [Full View]
point Originally Posted by Flavia
Moreover who cares whether a song is exactly folk or approximately folk song is good to hear or not only matters
-
From: Flavia on 24th April 2007 10:38 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by thimuru
-
From: villan007 on 24th April 2007 10:39 PM [Full View]
ada paavi.... pona vaaranthandaa ellaruma ARR-a koodi kummi adicheenga inga Originally Posted by thimuru
-
From: thimuru on 24th April 2007 10:39 PM [Full View]
appa yaru yenaanu vishayam theriyadhu!i mean arr yaaru yennanu therila Originally Posted by villan007
ada paavi.... pona vaaranthandaa ellaruma ARR-a koodi kummi adicheenga inga Originally Posted by thimuru
-
From: nemesis786 on 24th April 2007 10:40 PM [Full View]
ATHIRADEE song from SIVAJI seems to be inspired from NERUPE SIKI MUKI NERUPE from VV by HARRIS
harrisa matum thitureenga idhellam keka mateengala
-
From: villan007 on 24th April 2007 10:40 PM [Full View]
1 vaarathula epdi gnanodhayam vandhichu
ennamo po... nalla iruntha seri
-
From: thimuru on 24th April 2007 10:41 PM [Full View]
yaru arr-a? Originally Posted by villan007
1 vaarathula epdi gnanodhayam vandhichu
ennamo po... nalla iruntha seri
-
From: villan007 on 24th April 2007 10:42 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by nemesis786
ATHIRADEE song from SIVAJI seems to be inspired from NERUPE SIKI MUKI NERUPE from VV by HARRIS .... enna inspiration irundhichi ?
tune ? beats ? arrangements ? renudme complete-a vera maari iruke :P
-
From: Flavia on 24th April 2007 10:43 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by thimuru
eiii...arr ku enna korachal!u bloody idiot Originally Posted by villan007
enna machi , posukunu madangitta Originally Posted by thimuru
at times you too post something sensible
-
From: thimuru on 24th April 2007 10:43 PM [Full View]
similarity irundhucho illiyo....sikki mukki nalla irundhuchu... Originally Posted by villan007
Originally Posted by nemesis786
ATHIRADEE song from SIVAJI seems to be inspired from NERUPE SIKI MUKI NERUPE from VV by HARRIS .... enna inspiration irundhichi ?
tune ? beats ? arrangements ? renudme complete-a vera maari iruke :P
adhiradi...........hehe...romba nalla irundhuchu
-
From: nemesis786 on 24th April 2007 10:44 PM [Full View]
Beats and tune were similar
-
From: villan007 on 24th April 2007 10:45 PM [Full View]
-
From: nemesis786 on 24th April 2007 10:45 PM [Full View]
thimuru appreciating ARR
Puli padhunguradhu paayuradhuko
-
From: Flavia on 24th April 2007 10:45 PM [Full View]
For me, it seems something is terribly wrong with your hearing capability Originally Posted by nemesis786
ATHIRADEE song from SIVAJI seems to be inspired from NERUPE SIKI MUKI NERUPE from VV by HARRIS
-
From: nemesis786 on 24th April 2007 10:47 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by Flavia
For me, it seems something is terribly wrong with your hearing capability Originally Posted by nemesis786
ATHIRADEE song from SIVAJI seems to be inspired from NERUPE SIKI MUKI NERUPE from VV by HARRIS
I know ARR fans wont accept it but listen to the songs fully you will know beats n tunes were similar
-
From: Flavia on 24th April 2007 10:49 PM [Full View]
You being sarcastic? Originally Posted by thimuru
-
From: Nerd on 24th April 2007 10:49 PM [Full View]
I am not an ARR fan and I dont see the similarity. First you were claiming that its a straight lift from some vijay song Originally Posted by nemesis786
[
I know ARR fans wont accept it but listen to the songs fully you will know beats n tunes were similar
-
From: nemesis786 on 24th April 2007 10:51 PM [Full View]
Listen to CHELLA PERU APPLE from POKIRI, NERUPE FROM VV, ATHIRADEE FROM SIVAJI okva? Originally Posted by Nerd
I am not an ARR fan and I dont see the similarity. First you were claiming that its a straight lift from some vijay song Originally Posted by nemesis786
[
I know ARR fans wont accept it but listen to the songs fully you will know beats n tunes were similar
I found similarity in beats and tunes also only between VV and SIVAJI Nerupe & Athiradee
-
From: nemesis786 on 24th April 2007 10:53 PM [Full View]
Ok inga mass ila so i am
-
From: villan007 on 24th April 2007 10:53 PM [Full View]
chella peru apple , nerupe has nothing to do with athiradee.. be it tune , beats , arrangements...
of course athiradee is superior in all aspects :P
-
From: villan007 on 24th April 2007 10:53 PM [Full View]
neela saayam veluthu pOchu Originally Posted by Flavia
You being sarcastic? Originally Posted by thimuru
-
From: Flavia on 24th April 2007 11:03 PM [Full View]
Thimuru and all
-
From: Yathu on 25th April 2007 01:06 AM [Full View]
Next he will be saying that Athiradee sounds like some old Ilayaraja song! Originally Posted by nemesis786
Listen to CHELLA PERU APPLE from POKIRI, NERUPE FROM VV, ATHIRADEE FROM SIVAJI okva? Originally Posted by Nerd
I am not an ARR fan and I dont see the similarity. First you were claiming that its a straight lift from some vijay song Originally Posted by nemesis786
[
I know ARR fans wont accept it but listen to the songs fully you will know beats n tunes were similar
I found similarity in beats and tunes also only between VV and SIVAJI Nerupe & Athiradee
-
From: ajaybaskar on 25th April 2007 12:13 PM [Full View]
Athiradee being compared with Sikki mukki and chella paeru apple !!!. Disgusting with these non ARR fans. Edhavadhu vaaikku vandhapadi pesuradhu. Konjam vitta Sahara paattu manmadharasa tunela irukkumbaanga..
-
From: selvakumar on 25th April 2007 12:21 PM [Full View]
Athiradee - a bit was indeed stolen from Dangerous !
Ballelakka - The background bit is 100% same as that of the one in "Rathiri nerathu poongyil" song in Oomai vizhingal
-
From: Flavia on 25th April 2007 12:30 PM [Full View]
Yeah. They are just cussed Originally Posted by ajaybaskar
Each time coming with some funny accusations. I wonder why not they spend time listening to their fav MD's music rather than doing research on ARR's music.
-
From: selvakumar on 25th April 2007 12:31 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by Flavia
Yeah. They are just cussed Each time coming with some funny accusations. I wonder why not they spend time listening to their fav MD's music rather than doing research on ARR's music. IF someone does research on ur favorite MD's work, that shows how much popular & successful he is !
-
From: Flavia on 25th April 2007 12:42 PM [Full View]
Agreed. Originally Posted by selvakumar
Originally Posted by Flavia
Yeah. They are just cussed Each time coming with some funny accusations. I wonder why not they spend time listening to their fav MD's music rather than doing research on ARR's music. IF someone does research on ur favorite MD's work, that shows how much popular & successful he is !
But always coming up with delusive accuasation is simply maddening
-
From: Flavia on 26th April 2007 05:37 PM [Full View]
http://youtube.com/watch?v=U3IruH_FmjQ
An exemplar of ARR's magical+sensual+powerful+deep+striking+tuneful+viv id music
-
From: nemesis786 on 26th April 2007 06:18 PM [Full View]
Then why dont u people listenm to ARR albums instead of cursing HARRIS or YUVAN Originally Posted by Flavia
Yeah. They are just cussed Originally Posted by ajaybaskar
Each time coming with some funny accusations. I wonder why not they spend time listening to their fav MD's music rather than doing research on ARR's music.
You people dont right? No one can bcoz when they listen to a particular song n if the tune or beat sounds very similar they do express what they feel
-
From: Flavia on 26th April 2007 06:41 PM [Full View]
When did we curse? Originally Posted by nemesis786
Then why dont u people listenm to ARR albums instead of cursing HARRIS or YUVAN nAnga appAvi
Ok. You feel that there are similarities between Mayya Mayya and Manmadarasa right? C'mon, express it. We won't ask you anything. Originally Posted by nemesis786
You people dont right? No one can bcoz when they listen to a particular song n if the tune or beat sounds very similar they do express what they feel
-
From: thineshan54321 on 27th April 2007 01:52 AM [Full View]
HAHA what a joke!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Athiradee and Nerupae? LMFAO, thats joke of the decade. Damn u should write joke books, instead of wasting ur time here. I wanna suggest a name for ur joke book: "Enakku Kathu Kaekathu!"
-
From: nickraman on 27th April 2007 06:07 AM [Full View]
Maestro Raaja > ARR (current)
-
From: nickraman on 27th April 2007 06:08 AM [Full View]
Ballelakka was stolen from CM's Devuda. Just add in female vocals and done. Originally Posted by selvakumar
Athiradee - a bit was indeed stolen from Dangerous !
Ballelakka - The background bit is 100% same as that of the one in "Rathiri nerathu poongyil" song in Oomai vizhingal
-
From: thineshan54321 on 27th April 2007 06:15 AM [Full View]
Yes I agree. AR Rahman did steal! Not CM's Devuda or w/e the crap u guys are talking about, but many hearts -- hearts that know how to appreciate good things!
-
From: Sanjeevi on 27th April 2007 10:36 AM [Full View]
Copy cat HJ's guru was ARR where he took lesson that how to remix/rearrange an english album or even how to reformat an famous song without irritating listeners mind. Originally Posted by nickraman
Ballelakka was stolen from CM's Devuda. Just add in female vocals and done. Originally Posted by selvakumar
Athiradee - a bit was indeed stolen from Dangerous !
Ballelakka - The background bit is 100% same as that of the one in "Rathiri nerathu poongyil" song in Oomai vizhingal
-
From: MADDY on 27th April 2007 11:14 AM [Full View]
then where did YSR took training from Originally Posted by Sanjeevi
Copy cat HJ's guru was ARR where he took lesson that how to remix/rearrange an english album or even how to reformat an famous song without irritating listeners mind. Originally Posted by nickraman
Ballelakka was stolen from CM's Devuda. Just add in female vocals and done. Originally Posted by selvakumar
Athiradee - a bit was indeed stolen from Dangerous !
Ballelakka - The background bit is 100% same as that of the one in "Rathiri nerathu poongyil" song in Oomai vizhingal ......
-
From: lavanya22rit on 27th April 2007 11:17 AM [Full View]
YSR and IR were trained in the same XEROX shop Originally Posted by MADDY
then where did YSR took training from Originally Posted by Sanjeevi
Copy cat HJ's guru was ARR where he took lesson that how to remix/rearrange an english album or even how to reformat an famous song without irritating listeners mind. Originally Posted by nickraman
Ballelakka was stolen from CM's Devuda. Just add in female vocals and done. Originally Posted by selvakumar
Athiradee - a bit was indeed stolen from Dangerous !
Ballelakka - The background bit is 100% same as that of the one in "Rathiri nerathu poongyil" song in Oomai vizhingal ......
-
From: Sanjeevi on 27th April 2007 11:31 AM [Full View]
hahahahaha Originally Posted by lavanya22rit
YSR and IR were trained in the same XEROX shop Originally Posted by MADDY
then where did YSR took training from Originally Posted by Sanjeevi
Copy cat HJ's guru was ARR where he took lesson that how to remix/rearrange an english album or even how to reformat an famous song without irritating listeners mind. Originally Posted by nickraman
Ballelakka was stolen from CM's Devuda. Just add in female vocals and done. Originally Posted by selvakumar
Athiradee - a bit was indeed stolen from Dangerous !
Ballelakka - The background bit is 100% same as that of the one in "Rathiri nerathu poongyil" song in Oomai vizhingal ......
source iruntha thana Xerox, copy ellam
They are sources
-
From: MADDY on 27th April 2007 11:43 AM [Full View]
frankly speaking, i dont see any need for ppl. like IR and ARR to copy from anyone ..........
ppl. do accuse ARR of copying or rearranging western songs bcos they are unaware of ARR's composing style and for them , western beats irundhaale, adhu copy......so cant help it .....listen to it and move on
-
From: thamizhvaanan on 27th April 2007 12:00 PM [Full View]
wow MAddy Originally Posted by MADDY
frankly speaking, i dont see any need for ppl. like IR and ARR to copy from anyone ..........
ppl. do accuse ARR of copying or rearranging western songs bcos they are unaware of ARR's composing style and for them , western beats irundhaale, adhu copy......so cant help it .....listen to it and move on
enna ippadi thideer matram right from ur avatar
-
From: dinesh2002 on 27th April 2007 02:58 PM [Full View]
and some 'maestro' is still composing songs when no 1 cares whether if he still composes or not... Originally Posted by Sanjeevi
Copy cat HJ's guru was ARR where he took lesson that how to remix/rearrange an english album or even how to reformat an famous song without irritating listeners mind. Originally Posted by nickraman
Ballelakka was stolen from CM's Devuda. Just add in female vocals and done. Originally Posted by selvakumar
Athiradee - a bit was indeed stolen from Dangerous !
Ballelakka - The background bit is 100% same as that of the one in "Rathiri nerathu poongyil" song in Oomai vizhingal the songs goes down the drain everytime it releases.... tsk tsk tsk.... what was even his last album ?!? guess he aint there to entertain u guys thats y ur here condemning other mds huh... mind very disturbed?? releasing ur tense on other mds?
-
From: villan007 on 27th April 2007 03:05 PM [Full View]
apdina Originally Posted by dinesh2002
-
From: Sanjeevi on 27th April 2007 03:08 PM [Full View]
avaru backuroundu mugic kodukuraaru Originally Posted by villan007
apdina Originally Posted by dinesh2002
-
From: thimuru on 27th April 2007 03:10 PM [Full View]
he has already given large collection...adha kettale podhum Originally Posted by dinesh2002
and some 'maestro' is still composing songs when no 1 cares whether if he still composes or not... Originally Posted by Sanjeevi
Copy cat HJ's guru was ARR where he took lesson that how to remix/rearrange an english album or even how to reformat an famous song without irritating listeners mind. Originally Posted by nickraman
Ballelakka was stolen from CM's Devuda. Just add in female vocals and done. Originally Posted by selvakumar
Athiradee - a bit was indeed stolen from Dangerous !
Ballelakka - The background bit is 100% same as that of the one in "Rathiri nerathu poongyil" song in Oomai vizhingal the songs goes down the drain everytime it releases.... tsk tsk tsk.... what was even his last album ?!? guess he aint there to entertain u guys thats y ur here condemning other mds huh... mind very disturbed?? releasing ur tense on other mds?
ungaluthan aadikorudhadava amaavasaiku oruthadava album vitaaru even at his peak time
-
From: Flavia on 27th April 2007 03:11 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by dinesh2002
and some 'maestro' is still composing songs when no 1 cares whether if he still composes or not... the songs goes down the drain everytime it releases.... tsk tsk tsk.... what was even his last album ?!? guess he aint there to entertain u guys thats y ur here condemning other mds huh... mind very disturbed?? releasing ur tense on other mds?
J/K
-
From: Sanjeevi on 27th April 2007 03:16 PM [Full View]
kodumai kodumai-nu kovilukku (IR songs) pona ang rendu pootham (other md songs) vanthu jingu jingu nu aducham Originally Posted by Flavia
Originally Posted by dinesh2002
and some 'maestro' is still composing songs when no 1 cares whether if he still composes or not... the songs goes down the drain everytime it releases.... tsk tsk tsk.... what was even his last album ?!? guess he aint there to entertain u guys thats y ur here condemning other mds huh... mind very disturbed?? releasing ur tense on other mds?
J/K
-
From: Flavia on 27th April 2007 03:17 PM [Full View]
Though engaAlu comes Adukoruthadavai and AmavAsaiku oru thadavai, everytime he gives 1000 wala saravedi Originally Posted by thimuru
he has already given large collection...adha kettale podhum
ungaluthan aadikorudhadava amaavasaiku oruthadava album vitaaru even at his peak time ,
UngAlu gives only namuthu ponA oOsi vedi
-
From: thimuru on 27th April 2007 03:22 PM [Full View]
music saravediyave irukka koodadhu...kaadhu ennathukagum! Originally Posted by Flavia
Though engaAlu comes Adukoruthadavai and AmavAsaiku oru thadavai, everytime he gives 1000 wala saravedi Originally Posted by thimuru
he has already given large collection...adha kettale podhum
ungaluthan aadikorudhadava amaavasaiku oruthadava album vitaaru even at his peak time ,
UngAlu gives only namuthu ponA oOsi vedi
engalu appappa konjam idhamana oosi vediya varuvaru..adhellam ungalukku puriyadhu
-
From: Flavia on 27th April 2007 03:29 PM [Full View]
This is why I advise people not to listen *Young King* songs. See You have started babbling. pretty soon Originally Posted by Sanjeevi
-
From: Flavia on 27th April 2007 03:32 PM [Full View]
Either it be saravedi or oosi vedi, if it is a dud You can only dump it. Originally Posted by thimuru
music saravediyave irukka koodadhu...kaadhu ennathukagum!
engalu appappa konjam idhamana oosi vediya varuvaru..adhellam ungalukku puriyadhu
-
From: thimuru on 27th April 2007 04:08 PM [Full View]
apdiyaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa Originally Posted by Flavia
Either it be saravedi or oosi vedi, if it is a dud You can only dump it. Originally Posted by thimuru
music saravediyave irukka koodadhu...kaadhu ennathukagum!
engalu appappa konjam idhamana oosi vediya varuvaru..adhellam ungalukku puriyadhu
-
From: villan007 on 27th April 2007 07:14 PM [Full View]
-
From: m_23_bayarea on 28th April 2007 12:14 AM [Full View]
The Legend MSV has not even a single vote! Even the leading contenders IR and ARR wont agree to this... Classic example of how false these polls in our HUB could be!
-
From: thineshan54321 on 28th April 2007 12:52 AM [Full View]
well bay, its just people's opinion for who the best is according to them. Clearly, there is no MSV fans out here. Which is not surprising because I dont expect my grandfather to be hubbing.
-
From: nemesis786 on 28th April 2007 01:11 AM [Full View]
Originally Posted by thineshan54321
-
From: thineshan54321 on 28th April 2007 01:32 AM [Full View]
no no it wasnt an insult or anything, just truth.
-
From: m_23_bayarea on 28th April 2007 11:58 PM [Full View]
Very funny!
-
From: thineshan54321 on 29th April 2007 06:40 AM [Full View]
sry bay, i just wrote something that came to my head at the moment. i wasnt trying to insult. Really sorry
-
From: NOV on 29th April 2007 07:59 PM [Full View]
actually there are many, but we already know that MSV is the best of the best and all the rest are just shadows of him, and we just watch these shows from the sidelines. we don't need acceptence from IR and ARR's fans when even thier idols will agree to this assessment. Originally Posted by thineshan54321
-
From: joe on 29th April 2007 08:38 PM [Full View]
I think the option MSV is just added ..I am sure MSV was not there when I voted ,otherwise I would have voted for MSV ,who cares if you call me Thatha
-
From: villan007 on 29th April 2007 08:42 PM [Full View]
yes.. ARR and IR oru paaratu vizhavula sonnaingale.. MSV ku inai yaarume illainu ... entha function nu maranthu pochu
-
From: nemesis786 on 29th April 2007 08:49 PM [Full View]
Sachin kooda soluvar gavaskaruku paratu vizha nadathina "sunil gavaskaruku nigar yaarume ilai" nu adhellam oru mariyadhai thaan Originally Posted by villan007
yes.. ARR and IR oru paaratu vizhavula sonnaingale.. MSV ku inai yaarume illainu ... entha function nu maranthu pochu
Adhukaaga mathavanga ellam wastea? Dont mistake me! Dont take things of formality to be facts , and please stop comparing musicians of different generations! There r lots of differences
-
From: A.ANAND on 30th April 2007 06:09 AM [Full View]
superb Originally Posted by nemesis786
Sachin kooda soluvar gavaskaruku paratu vizha nadathina "sunil gavaskaruku nigar yaarume ilai" nu adhellam oru mariyadhai thaan Originally Posted by villan007
yes.. ARR and IR oru paaratu vizhavula sonnaingale.. MSV ku inai yaarume illainu ... entha function nu maranthu pochu
Adhukaaga mathavanga ellam wastea? Dont mistake me! Dont take things of formality to be facts , and please stop comparing musicians of different generations! There r lots of differences
-
From: thineshan54321 on 30th April 2007 07:44 AM [Full View]
good post nemesis.
-
From: joe on 30th April 2007 08:17 AM [Full View]
After 10 years some other player will say "sachinukku nigar yaarume illai " ,then will you say it is just for formaility? Originally Posted by nemesis786
Sachin kooda soluvar gavaskaruku paratu vizha nadathina "sunil gavaskaruku nigar yaarume ilai" nu adhellam oru mariyadhai thaan Originally Posted by villan007
yes.. ARR and IR oru paaratu vizhavula sonnaingale.. MSV ku inai yaarume illainu ... entha function nu maranthu pochu
-
From: Flavia on 30th April 2007 08:48 AM [Full View]
Ofcourse! Lets say, after 10 years, we have someone with stronger record than Sachin and people/other players still says 'No one can match Sachin' then it's absolutely for formality's sake only. Originally Posted by joe
After 10 years some other player will say "sachinukku nigar yaarume illai " ,then will you say it is just for formaility? Originally Posted by nemesis786
Sachin kooda soluvar gavaskaruku paratu vizha nadathina "sunil gavaskaruku nigar yaarume ilai" nu adhellam oru mariyadhai thaan Originally Posted by villan007
yes.. ARR and IR oru paaratu vizhavula sonnaingale.. MSV ku inai yaarume illainu ... entha function nu maranthu pochu
If someone's place in history is earlier than others doesn't necessarily make them better.
What i feel is we shouldn't be comparing across generations considering the inequality of the technical advancements accessible to the generations.
Hope I make some sense.
-
From: joe on 30th April 2007 10:44 AM [Full View]
Reverse also possible. Originally Posted by Flavia
If someone's place in history is earlier than others doesn't necessarily make them better.
-
From: nemesis786 on 30th April 2007 03:16 PM [Full View]
Neenga ellarum ipo irukura musiciansla who is best for scoring songs n BGM for various categories of movies nu ninaikureenga? I guess this would be an interesting discussion, eg:
Thrillers
Masala
Class Action
Romance
-
From: Villan on 30th April 2007 03:17 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by joe
Reverse also possible. Originally Posted by Flavia
If someone's place in history is earlier than others doesn't necessarily make them better.
-
From: crajkumar_be on 30th April 2007 04:27 PM [Full View]
Background music current generation Yuvan is the best
-
From: Villan on 30th April 2007 05:44 PM [Full View]
Illayaraja always score good in background music..... Originally Posted by crajkumar_be
-
From: crajkumar_be on 30th April 2007 06:05 PM [Full View]
Villan,
I meant in the current generation:
When it comes to all time BEST...
there is no doubt...
Its a photo-finish between Vikraman "Choir Service" S.A Rasukumar
and "Arabia Tune Surutti" Sirpi.
I am a deaf-hard fan of these two and i have zero tolerance for any critics, so please be warned.
M.S.V, Ilayaraja and A.R Rahman can share the next prize.
-
From: MADDY on 30th April 2007 07:07 PM [Full View]
i was in chennai over the weekend and i met up with guys from venkateshwara college........they were around 10 and my cousin's frnds.........i asked them who is the best MD in tamil now? they were like HJ, and a couple of them - YSR.....i asked them "whose album u expect the most" and they were unanimously - "ARRahman"
HJ seems to be the heart-throb now.......but ARR is in their all time list ........YSR has lost a lot of ground......needs to work out some big hits soon........
-
From: MrJudge on 30th April 2007 09:21 PM [Full View]
enna oru Poll! enna oru revelation!! appadiye konjam producers-aiyum meet panni poll eduththa nalla irukkum, hehehe Originally Posted by MADDY
i was in chennai over the weekend and i met up with guys from venkateshwara college........they were around 10 and my cousin's frnds.........i asked them who is the best MD in tamil now? they were like HJ, and a couple of them - YSR.....i asked them "whose album u expect the most" and they were unanimously - "ARRahman"
HJ seems to be the heart-throb now.......but ARR is in their all time list ........YSR has lost a lot of ground......needs to work out some big hits soon........
-
From: thimuru on 30th April 2007 10:44 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by MADDY
i was in chennai over the weekend and i met up with guys from venkateshwara college........they were around 10 and my cousin's frnds.........i asked them who is the best MD in tamil now? they were like HJ, and a couple of them - YSR.....i asked them "whose album u expect the most" and they were unanimously - "ARRahman"
HJ seems to be the heart-throb now.......but ARR is in their all time list ........YSR has lost a lot of ground......needs to work out some big hits soon........
ac nielson poll-a vida better...hmmm...best
-
From: Shakthiprabha. on 30th April 2007 10:50 PM [Full View]
-
From: Sanjeevi on 30th April 2007 11:09 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by MADDY
i was in chennai over the weekend and i met up with guys from venkateshwara college........they were around 10 and my cousin's frnds.........i asked them who is the best MD in tamil now? they were like HJ, and a couple of them - YSR.....i asked them "whose album u expect the most" and they were unanimously - "ARRahman" . Appuram i asked them, "Who is best MD", they replied "Ilaiyaraja"
HJ seems to be the heart-throb now.......but ARR is in their all time list ........YSR has lost a lot of ground......needs to work out some big hits soon........
Muzhu poosanikkaya sothula marakka kudathu :P
-
From: m_23_bayarea on 30th April 2007 11:31 PM [Full View]
YES! And let's also take MSV's name off this poll, so that his legacy is saved! Originally Posted by nemesis786
Dont take things of formality to be facts , and please stop comparing musicians of different generations! There r lots of differences
-
From: Shakthiprabha. on 30th April 2007 11:52 PM [Full View]
Its very sad to see such a GREAT music d irector, wtih nil votes.
I second bayarea, in requesting to REMOVE msv from polls.
thanks
-
From: Sanguine Sridhar on 1st May 2007 12:03 AM [Full View]
idha thaan munnaidye sonnen... Originally Posted by Shakthiprabha
but yaarum kekkala, why there is no Thyagaraja Bagavadhar in the poll? Innaikum "Manmadha Leelaiyay vendraar" song-a adichukka vera paatila....
-
From: MADDY on 1st May 2007 09:08 AM [Full View]
in regards to my post abt my cousin and his frnds' opinions:
1. i dint draw any general conclusion or opinions from my observation
2. i dint insert a "u-must-believe" tag in my post
3. i dint even put anything hurting abt any MD here
then, y were there 4 posts mocking at me??? personal issues with me???? ........if so PM me - SP,Timuru,Sanjeevi,Judge.........
-
From: MrJudge on 1st May 2007 11:36 AM [Full View]
If you have opinions and don't want others to say anything about them, please keep them in your heart. This is a public forum afterall, you need to understand if you spill your beans, it will be counted Originally Posted by MADDY
in regards to my post abt my cousin and his frnds' opinions:
1. i dint draw any general conclusion or opinions from my observation
2. i dint insert a "u-must-believe" tag in my post
3. i dint even put anything hurting abt any MD here
then, y were there 4 posts mocking at me??? personal issues with me???? ........if so PM me - SP,Timuru,Sanjeevi,Judge.........
-
From: thimuru on 1st May 2007 03:58 PM [Full View]
read the bolded ones Originally Posted by MADDY
i was in chennai over the weekend and i met up with guys from venkateshwara college........they were around 10 and my cousin's frnds.........i asked them who is the best MD in tamil now? they were like HJ, and a couple of them - YSR.....i asked them "whose album u expect the most" and they were unanimously - "ARRahman"
HJ seems to be the heart-throb now.......but ARR is in their all time list ........YSR has lost a lot of ground......needs to work out some big hits soon........
-
From: MADDY on 1st May 2007 05:55 PM [Full View]
that was my opinion on those 3......i dint say it was the general view of public Originally Posted by thimuru
read the bolded ones Originally Posted by MADDY
i was in chennai over the weekend and i met up with guys from venkateshwara college........they were around 10 and my cousin's frnds.........i asked them who is the best MD in tamil now? they were like HJ, and a couple of them - YSR.....i asked them "whose album u expect the most" and they were unanimously - "ARRahman"
HJ seems to be the heart-throb now.......but ARR is in their all time list ........YSR has lost a lot of ground......needs to work out some big hits soon........ ........r u guys so impatient to snub me?? ......and that too ganging up to snub me ........
judge, i posted that as a piece of info and nuthing else...........u wanna take it, take it, if u wanna leave it, leave it......analyse MDs and not my posts
-
From: Shakthiprabha. on 1st May 2007 07:26 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by MADDY
in regards to my post abt my cousin and his frnds' opinions:
1. i dint draw any general conclusion or opinions from my observation
2. i dint insert a "u-must-believe" tag in my post
3. i dint even put anything hurting abt any MD here
then, y were there 4 posts mocking at me??? personal issues with me???? ........if so PM me - SP,Timuru,Sanjeevi,Judge.........
enakku enna personal issues. I dont even know u much
I was only JOKING maddy plz relax
As much as I like IR, I do believe ppl have different preference :P.
PLEASE i just have FAVOURITES, never FANATIC of ANYBODY !
phew , sirichathukku ivLo explanation kudukka vendirukku
-
From: thimuru on 1st May 2007 07:53 PM [Full View]
maddy,
less tension more work
more tension less work
no tension
-
From: selvakumar on 9th May 2007 09:03 AM [Full View]
One of the best posts on comparison b/w MDs I have ever read. Exactly my opinion except his comments on YSR !
Thanks vnkatkumar who posted it HERE
Originally Posted by vnkatkumar
-
From: MADDY on 9th May 2007 09:45 AM [Full View]
thanks vnkatkumar and selva for reiterating my points on YSR Originally Posted by selvakumar
-
From: selvakumar on 9th May 2007 10:43 AM [Full View]
Originally Posted by MADDY
thanks vnkatkumar and selva for reiterating my points on YSR Originally Posted by selvakumar
-
From: selvakumar on 9th May 2007 04:51 PM [Full View]
I am not sure about his other interviews. But that one was indeed confusing a bit and proved the way he was trying to eliminate the cloud that was surrounding him. Originally Posted by Roshan
here is that interview
http://img136.imagevenue.com/img.php..._122_504lo.jpg
http://img156.imagevenue.com/img.php..._122_568lo.jpg
http://img21.imagevenue.com/view.php..._122_389lo.jpg
http://img11.imagevenue.com/img.php?..._122_359lo.jpg
http://img125.imagevenue.com/img.php..._122_366lo.jpg
-
From: nemesis786 on 9th May 2007 05:05 PM [Full View]
Who is Vm?
-
From: dinesh2002 on 9th May 2007 05:07 PM [Full View]
i believe its VairaMuthu.... Originally Posted by nemesis786
Who is Vm?
-
From: Sanjeevi on 9th May 2007 05:13 PM [Full View]
athanga eppavumae 2 times pesuvarae vayiramuthu Originally Posted by nemesis786
Who is Vm?
-
From: Roshan on 9th May 2007 05:17 PM [Full View]
Thanks Selva for the links. Padichuttu vanthu solREn
-
From: nemesis786 on 9th May 2007 05:41 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by Sanjeevi
athanga eppavumae 2 times pesuvarae vayiramuthu Originally Posted by nemesis786
Who is Vm?
-
From: selvakumar on 9th May 2007 06:36 PM [Full View]
Listened to CHEENIKUM. Songs are awesome and are pleasing to the ears. Though they are reharshed tunes, they still look fresh with new additions / changes etc 
Worth a listen. IR eliminates the effect he created with Maayakannadi
Will post more on this later
-
From: Roshan on 9th May 2007 07:40 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by selvakumar
-
From: MADDY on 9th May 2007 07:44 PM [Full View]
CHEENI KUM - Amitabh starrer with Raaja music Originally Posted by Roshan
Originally Posted by selvakumar
CHEENI KUM means - sugar less in hindi
-
From: dinesh2002 on 9th May 2007 07:48 PM [Full View]
could u gimme a link to listen to the songs?? many of my frens too had a word of praise for the album... Originally Posted by selvakumar
Listened to CHEENIKUM. Songs are awesome and are pleasing to the ears. Though they are reharshed tunes, they still look fresh with new additions / changes etc
Worth a listen. IR eliminates the effect he created with Maayakannadi
Will post more on this later
-
From: Roshan on 9th May 2007 08:00 PM [Full View]
Thanks Maddy for the info Originally Posted by MADDY
CHEENI KUM - Amitabh starrer with Raaja music Originally Posted by Roshan
Originally Posted by selvakumar
CHEENI KUM means - sugar less in hindi but nejemAvE athuthaan meaning-A?
-
From: Roshan on 9th May 2007 08:17 PM [Full View]
Went through it. Lots of confusions and controdictions. GR's response to IR sounds straight and strong. Anyway, lets leave as it is and move on to next. Originally Posted by selvakumar
I am not sure about his other interviews. But that one was indeed confusing a bit and proved the way he was trying to eliminate the cloud that was surrounding him. Originally Posted by Roshan
here is that interview
http://img136.imagevenue.com/img.php..._122_504lo.jpg
http://img156.imagevenue.com/img.php..._122_568lo.jpg
http://img21.imagevenue.com/view.php..._122_389lo.jpg
http://img11.imagevenue.com/img.php?..._122_359lo.jpg
http://img125.imagevenue.com/img.php..._122_366lo.jpg
Thanks again Selva for the links
-
From: crajkumar_be on 9th May 2007 08:56 PM [Full View]
Ilaiyaraaja's Cheeni Kum:
On first hearing:
- Percussion disappoints BIG TIME (as has been the case of late). What a welcome change MX was! Where's that percussion Raaja?
- Synth sound-a vida maattengararu Raaja Rears its ugly head often in the album.
On repeated hearings:
Baatein Hawa and Jane Do Naa are knockout
Baatein Hawa - What an enchanting reworking of the original. The greatness is in the way Raaja has used the same tune to a different situation.
Jane Do Naa - What a tune! Shreya Ghoshal
Cheeni Kum - Shreya and the interludes save the song from the dreadful 'beats'. This is more pronounced in the sad version 'Sooni Sooni' - thagara dabba la thatra madhiri oru sound. Reminiscent of the beats in "Ennai thaalaatta varuvaalo". How i missed the acoustic drums of the original "Mandram Vandha"!!
Infact, pudhu music system vaangina first test panna ideal song-a irundhudhu adhu.
Theme Music - Beautiful and uplifting. Wow Superb transitions
Melody Sax - Experimental Raaja is back with all that jazz. Thou art the master
The album does get better on a few more listenings
Cheeni Kum - Mandram Vandha (Mouna Ragam)
Jaane Do Naa - Vizhiyile (Nooraavadhu Naal)
Baatein Hawa - Kuzhaloodhum Kannanukku ( Slowly Opened The Door)
-
From: Madavan on 10th May 2007 09:59 AM [Full View]
What he says is Deva's Vyabari is noway inferior to ARR's Sivaji? Originally Posted by selvakumar
One of the best posts on comparison b/w MDs I have ever read. Exactly my opinion except his comments on YSR !
Thanks vnkatkumar who posted it HERE
Originally Posted by vnkatkumar
-
From: crajkumar_be on 10th May 2007 10:14 AM [Full View]
What he says is Deva's Vyabari is noway inferior to ARR's Sivaji.[/quote] Originally Posted by Madavan
Originally Posted by vnkatkumar
Note the glaring contradiction and hypocrisy in vnkatkumar's statements.
Compare panna koodadhaam, aana "no IR/ARR fan would listen to YSR" aam.. ivaru enna karuthu kanippu eduthaara? enna logic idhu?
Selva,
You agree to all his points *except* the one about YSR - adhu dhaane point-e
He himself doesn't practise what he preaches
-
From: selvakumar on 10th May 2007 10:46 AM [Full View]
Read this page for few links. I have re-posted the links which were posted by Rajasaranam in that thread Originally Posted by dinesh2002
http://forumhub.mayyam.com/hub/viewt...asc&start=1215
http://forumhub.mayyam.com/hub/viewt...015497#1015497
IR section neenga porathae kedaiyaathaa Avalo kaduppaah
-
From: selvakumar on 10th May 2007 10:59 AM [Full View]
Originally Posted by crajkumar_be
Selva,
You agree to all his points *except* the one about YSR - adhu dhaane point-e
He himself doesn't practise what he preaches I agree with that. I just highlighted what I wanted to convey on the comparison b/w MDs and the appreciation. I don't agree with that entire post. Few of the things of a MD should be appreciated. This is the point what I referred to.
P.S: I agree that I should have clarified it a bit more
-
From: crajkumar_be on 10th May 2007 11:04 AM [Full View]
Fair enough Originally Posted by selvakumar
I agree with that. I just highlighted what I wanted to convey on the comparison b/w MDs and the appreciation. I don't agree with that entire post. Few of the things of a MD should be appreciated. This is the point what I referred to.
P.S: I agree that I should have clarified it a bit more
-
From: selvakumar on 11th May 2007 04:11 PM [Full View]
After listening to Blue - All Rise and "June Pona" I feel that JUne POna is better than the original. Ofcourse, for be both look similar. But I feel that it is an ot an EXACT COPY !
People with musical knowledge can confirm the same
Listen to BLUE - ALL RISE here
http://share.up1file.com/files/fJI3MIWtGV
& post ur opinion
-
From: Sanjeevi on 11th May 2007 04:16 PM [Full View]
Ithu kuda oru MD pannalaina eppadi Originally Posted by selvakumar
After listening to Blue - All Rise and "June Pona" I feel that JUne POna is better than the original. Ofcourse, for be both look similar. But I feel that it is an ot an EXACT COPY !
People with musical knowledge can confirm the same
Listen to BLUE - ALL RISE here
http://share.up1file.com/files/fJI3MIWtGV
& post ur opinion avaru enna xerox machinea?
HJ has knowledge how to extend an existing song
-
From: selvakumar on 11th May 2007 04:18 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by Sanjeevi
Ithu kuda oru MD pannalaina eppadi avaru enna xerox machinea?
HJ has knowledge how to extend an existing song That is what I am referring to. ON what grounds, shallwe judge it ? or how can we define COPY & INSPIRATION ?
But the starting of the original is awesome compared to June pona ! IMO
-
From: nemesis786 on 11th May 2007 04:26 PM [Full View]
HARRIS IS THE BEST MUSICIAN IN KOLLYWOOD RIGHT NOW
-
From: selvakumar on 11th May 2007 04:28 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by nemesis786
It must be U1
-
From: nemesis786 on 11th May 2007 04:33 PM [Full View]
Yuvan is equally good Originally Posted by selvakumar
Originally Posted by nemesis786
It must be U1
-
From: MADDY on 11th May 2007 04:42 PM [Full View]
how do u judge whether its a copy or inspiration -> good question........but y is this question raised on one person always cutting across ARR/IR fans is not a good thing - u agree?? Originally Posted by selvakumar
Originally Posted by Sanjeevi
Ithu kuda oru MD pannalaina eppadi avaru enna xerox machinea?
HJ has knowledge how to extend an existing song That is what I am referring to. ON what grounds, shallwe judge it ? or how can we define COPY & INSPIRATION ?
But the starting of the original is awesome compared to June pona ! IMO
well this song resembles the original ->
a) starting music - the same notes but different tempo. thats it.....
b) the way the beats start - its xeroxed.....
c) starting tune (pallavi) - 100% xeroxed.......
anyways, i answered this cos, there have been far too many "loose" accusations on the legends which will be smashed by the musical pundits......
(i already see some display messages changing)
-
From: Sanjeevi on 11th May 2007 04:45 PM [Full View]
adichanya oru paldi Originally Posted by nemesis786
Yuvan is equally good Originally Posted by selvakumar
Originally Posted by nemesis786
It must be U1
-
From: selvakumar on 11th May 2007 05:01 PM [Full View]
CheeniKum
IF I have to use the write word to term the songs of Cheenikum, I will go with vigneshram's line "Cheeni Jaasthi". All the songs are sweet, romantic, sizzling and they flow like a gentle breeze.
Initially, I was a bit hesitating to download the songs (Thanks to Maayakannadi). Then went ahead with downloading. The result is
1) CheeniKum - Though it cannot match Mandram Vantha since the original was sung my SPB, this song is unique in its own way. Somehow, I feel that it is a bit diff compared to the original esp the way Shreys sings this one. It is a bit fast but well controlled. Even the music that comes in between is good. Something that comes when you didn't expect it. The way she raises her voice and ends with "Kyon hi kyun" is superb :P well.. not the best if u compare the other songs in this one
2) Baatein Hawa - 1
Again, though it is a much popular song in tamil, it looks different and teh feel is also slightly diff. Naduvula varrah AB voice distrupts the flow. Not sure how it is going to be picturised The ELECTRIC GUITAR piece that comes in the middle One of the best songs in the album.
Baatein Hawa - 2
The second one of Baatein Hawa ! The best thing is, in both the versions of BH are diff situations and couple of listens is enough to enjoy this one continously ! what a song ! (Better read the lyrics of the song atleast once though it is not required since shreya is amazing with her voice)
3) Jaane do
when I listened first, I didn't like Jaane do since we got carried away by the much popular versions Cheenikum and Baatein Hawa (coz of the impact of the original songs Mandram vantha and Kuzhaloothum kannanukku) ! But few more listens and easily the BEST SONG !
But I was disappointed when my colleagues (kannadigas) told me that it is a V.V.Very popular Kannda song and they had their own opinion that this song had killed the original I got the kannada version as well. It is also good.. But I blamed myself since I had the tamil version too.(vizhiyilae). I was shocked when I heard that there is a Malayaalam version as well
O.K enough said. But THIS SONG IS CERTAINLY THE BEST OUT OF ALL including the Kannada version IMO !
BTW I watched a small video on the picturisation AB looks & the otherthings. not sure at what time this song comes in the movie. Let us wait and see
4) Sooni Sooni
When I listened to it, I thought that HariHaran is singing this song. But who is this vijay prakash guys Is this an effect of "voice rendering" or vijay's own attempts to resemple HariHaran. The way he rises his voice and his pronunciations are It is a song which u can skip and try to hear the other songs since there is already one CHEENIKUM !
The effect was something |||ar to hearing male version of "Ninaithu Ninaithu" (7g) after the superb female version
5) Theme Melody
Good one The keyboard piece But this looks like an old IR song or a mixture of songs. 1:20 to 1:37 and then again slow music ! I am not sure abt how it is going
6) Saxophone Melody
Starting nalla thaan irukku But to me after a period of time, it looks like "EN INIYA PON NILAVAE" SONG in Moodu pani ! esp 0:10 to 0.45 ! OK one ! IMHO !!
Overall, WORTH A BUY !!
I have been listening to this one for the past two days. Not even a single time, I got frustrated with this one !
After CK, IR had indeed eliminated the impression I had on the music he is giving oflate. (Madhu,Maayakannadi etc)
Plus - IF someone uses the same singer in a single film music, you will get a PULICHU PONA effect & irritation. That is not here. SHREYA GOSHAL (Am I becoming a SG fan ? )
IF you are a person who had followed many music download site, you will find one or two links to download the albums of IR. But if it U1,HJ, ARR etc, you will get more than 6 links. I used to wonder how I can download them since even those 2 sites will be blocked As I expected I didn't find the links in the regular d/l sites
-
From: selvakumar on 11th May 2007 05:08 PM [Full View]
btw,
Will our dear HINDI speaking friends appreciate this album forgetting the kind of music that they have been enjoying oflate ? (Thanks to Himesh Reshmaiyya)
-
From: MADDY on 11th May 2007 05:10 PM [Full View]
make them listen to these songs and test urself..... Originally Posted by selvakumar
btw,
Will our dear HINDI speaking friends appreciate this album forgetting the kind of music that they have been enjoying oflate ? (Thanks to Himesh Reshmaiyya) ......naanga sonna dhaan othhukkamaatteengale
-
From: selvakumar on 11th May 2007 05:13 PM [Full View]
http://www.jaman.com/a/group/0G2KS8e.../0cV_Gddta6uU/ Originally Posted by MADDY
make them listen to these songs and test urself..... ......naanga sonna dhaan othhukkamaatteengale
http://www.lyricsmasti.com/2344/Song...heeni-Kum.html
http://forumhub.mayyam.com/hub/viewt...017454#1017454 ( A small comparison)
http://passionforcinema.com/music-ro...in-cheeni-kum/
(Courtesy : IR Albums )
-
From: Sanjeevi on 11th May 2007 05:14 PM [Full View]
nice review selva.
When i saw suddently your post naan payanthu poitten because so main
Welcome Originally Posted by selvakumar
by already become SG fans club
Originally Posted by selvakumar
bold decision. Do you enjoy the "Konjum" voice of SG when he sing the starting lines :so_sweet:
I think, you are falling in love with SG's voice Originally Posted by selvakumar
. But this song was built up for sad mood like original song and unlike the other song "Cheeni-kum"
-
From: selvakumar on 11th May 2007 05:15 PM [Full View]
and IR fans - Better buy this one to beat the kind of statistics being thrown for succesful albums nowadays !
Anyway,
I might buy this one this weekend
-
From: Sanjeevi on 11th May 2007 05:17 PM [Full View]
Don't worry this time, IR will taste fruit. Originally Posted by selvakumar
btw,
Will our dear HINDI speaking friends appreciate this album forgetting the kind of music that they have been enjoying oflate ? (Thanks to Himesh Reshmaiyya)
Vaanilai Arikkai appadithan sonnanga
-
From: selvakumar on 11th May 2007 05:23 PM [Full View]
Sanjeevi
Yes.. I think I am becoming SG fan (Thanks to CK & IR )
Sema voice ! :thumbsp:
Reg success in NI,
I am still unclear since we can judge it only when the movie hits the theatres. and as you said, I also have HOPES that it can be a HIT
btw, WHO IS THIS GUY BALKI? Has he directed anyother movies in HIndi ?
-
From: MADDY on 11th May 2007 05:30 PM [Full View]
y r u giving me: Originally Posted by selvakumar
http://www.jaman.com/a/group/0G2KS8e.../0cV_Gddta6uU/ Originally Posted by MADDY
make them listen to these songs and test urself..... ......naanga sonna dhaan othhukkamaatteengale
http://www.lyricsmasti.com/2344/Song...heeni-Kum.html
http://forumhub.mayyam.com/hub/viewt...017454#1017454 ( A small comparison)
http://passionforcinema.com/music-ro...in-cheeni-kum/
(Courtesy : IR Albums )
1. lyrics?
2. reviews?
3. IR fans reaction?
when i ask u abt the northies' reaction???
anyways, enakku yenna vela inga....got to listen to SHivaji songs.......
-
From: seran on 11th May 2007 05:35 PM [Full View]
selva,
for the review
-
From: selvakumar on 11th May 2007 05:37 PM [Full View]
Maddy
Sorry - I willlet you know a NORTHIE's comment after listening to it
btw, ONe of the links that I provided contains a NIndian's review ! (I believe he is NI guy)
http://passionforcinema.com/music-ro...in-cheeni-kum/
-
From: selvakumar on 11th May 2007 05:42 PM [Full View]
Thanks seran
----------
btw, Here is a an article on SG in Hindu Metro Plus DELHI ! She looks :P and that says at that time she was 18+ (2003)
so, now it should be 22+ :P
naLLa figure thaan
http://www.hinduonnet.com/thehindu/m...3000630200.htm
-
From: Sanjeevi on 11th May 2007 05:45 PM [Full View]
Balki aka R. Balakrishnan is a Tamilian and HC IR fan (I guess). He is one of very famous advertisement makers in India. Namma inetk Karthik knows him well Originally Posted by selvakumar
Check here Balki's name and the IR connection http://www.itwofs.com/advt.html
-
From: selvakumar on 11th May 2007 05:49 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by Sanjeevi
He had used IR songs in his ADs. It says (One of the self-confessed IR fan ) 
the self confessed 'one of Ilayaraja's biggest fans', Balki uses a snapshot from one of Ilayaraja's most loved tracks, 'Idhu oru pon maalai pozhudhu', from the 1980 movie, 'Nizhalgal'. What next Balki?
-
From: Sanjeevi on 11th May 2007 05:53 PM [Full View]
yes, many advetisements has IR's tune/music (mainly by Balki but not only Balki). I think the list by itwofs.com is not a complete list. Remember "Ilamai Itho" song with Maddy in pepsi ad. Saravana Store ad continuously has IR songs/music. Now they are using "Naane Naana Yaaro Thana Mella Mella" song their jewellary advt.
-
From: selvakumar on 11th May 2007 05:57 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by Sanjeevi
Is there anything like "MDs can sue them for this" ?
-
From: thilak4life on 11th May 2007 06:31 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by crajkumar_be
Ilaiyaraaja's Cheeni Kum:
On first hearing:
- Percussion disappoints BIG TIME (as has been the case of late). What a welcome change MX was! Where's that percussion Raaja?
- Synth sound-a vida maattengararu Raaja Rears its ugly head often in the album.
On repeated hearings:
Baatein Hawa and Jane Do Naa are knockout
Baatein Hawa - What an enchanting reworking of the original. The greatness is in the way Raaja has used the same tune to a different situation.
Jane Do Naa - What a tune! Shreya Ghoshal
Cheeni Kum - Shreya and the interludes save the song from the dreadful 'beats'. This is more pronounced in the sad version 'Sooni Sooni' - thagara dabba la thatra madhiri oru sound. Reminiscent of the beats in "Ennai thaalaatta varuvaalo". How i missed the acoustic drums of the original "Mandram Vandha"!!
Infact, pudhu music system vaangina first test panna ideal song-a irundhudhu adhu.
Theme Music - Beautiful and uplifting. Wow Superb transitions
Melody Sax - Experimental Raaja is back with all that jazz. Thou art the master
The album does get better on a few more listenings
Cheeni Kum - Mandram Vandha (Mouna Ragam)
Jaane Do Naa - Vizhiyile (Nooraavadhu Naal)
Baatein Hawa - Kuzhaloodhum Kannanukku ( Slowly Opened The Door)Onnum illa..Thought about reviewing..But two of 'em have already gave their expert opinions.. Now that I listened to it, if I had to dissect the album, it would be merely the replication/duplication of their points/observations. Originally Posted by selvakumar
CheeniKum
IF I have to use the write word to term the songs of Cheenikum, I will go with vigneshram's line "Cheeni Jaasthi". All the songs are sweet, romantic, sizzling and they flow like a gentle breeze.
Initially, I was a bit hesitating to download the songs (Thanks to Maayakannadi). Then went ahead with downloading. The result is
1) CheeniKum - Though it cannot match Mandram Vantha since the original was sung my SPB, this song is unique in its own way. Somehow, I feel that it is a bit diff compared to the original esp the way Shreys sings this one. It is a bit fast but well controlled. Even the music that comes in between is good. Something that comes when you didn't expect it. The way she raises her voice and ends with "Kyon hi kyun" is superb :P well.. not the best if u compare the other songs in this one
2) Baatein Hawa - 1
Again, though it is a much popular song in tamil, it looks different and teh feel is also slightly diff. Naduvula varrah AB voice distrupts the flow. Not sure how it is going to be picturised The ELECTRIC GUITAR piece that comes in the middle One of the best songs in the album.
Baatein Hawa - 2
The second one of Baatein Hawa ! The best thing is, in both the versions of BH are diff situations and couple of listens is enough to enjoy this one continously ! what a song ! (Better read the lyrics of the song atleast once though it is not required since shreya is amazing with her voice)
3) Jaane do
when I listened first, I didn't like Jaane do since we got carried away by the much popular versions Cheenikum and Baatein Hawa (coz of the impact of the original songs Mandram vantha and Kuzhaloothum kannanukku) ! But few more listens and easily the BEST SONG !
But I was disappointed when my colleagues (kannadigas) told me that it is a V.V.Very popular Kannda song and they had their own opinion that this song had killed the original I got the kannada version as well. It is also good.. But I blamed myself since I had the tamil version too.(vizhiyilae). I was shocked when I heard that there is a Malayaalam version as well
O.K enough said. But THIS SONG IS CERTAINLY THE BEST OUT OF ALL including the Kannada version IMO !
BTW I watched a small video on the picturisation AB looks & the otherthings. not sure at what time this song comes in the movie. Let us wait and see
4) Sooni Sooni
When I listened to it, I thought that HariHaran is singing this song. But who is this vijay prakash guys Is this an effect of "voice rendering" or vijay's own attempts to resemple HariHaran. The way he rises his voice and his pronunciations are It is a song which u can skip and try to hear the other songs since there is already one CHEENIKUM !
The effect was something |||ar to hearing male version of "Ninaithu Ninaithu" (7g) after the superb female version
5) Theme Melody
Good one The keyboard piece But this looks like an old IR song or a mixture of songs. 1:20 to 1:37 and then again slow music ! I am not sure abt how it is going
6) Saxophone Melody
Starting nalla thaan irukku But to me after a period of time, it looks like "EN INIYA PON NILAVAE" SONG in Moodu pani ! esp 0:10 to 0.45 ! OK one ! IMHO !!
Overall, WORTH A BUY !!
I have been listening to this one for the past two days. Not even a single time, I got frustrated with this one !
After CK, IR had indeed eliminated the impression I had on the music he is giving oflate. (Madhu,Maayakannadi etc)
Plus - IF someone uses the same singer in a single film music, you will get a PULICHU PONA effect & irritation. That is not here. SHREYA GOSHAL (Am I becoming a SG fan ? )
IF you are a person who had followed many music download site, you will find one or two links to download the albums of IR. But if it U1,HJ, ARR etc, you will get more than 6 links. I used to wonder how I can download them since even those 2 sites will be blocked As I expected I didn't find the links in the regular d/l sites
Overall, "Percussion disappoints" - thats the only complaint really but it's pretty good considering the movie is an out and out romantic comedy.
Maestro
Shreya Goshal
-
From: Sanjeevi on 12th May 2007 10:44 PM [Full View]
Saw VIJYA TV's Kofee with Anu
Wov what a wonderful show, they will continue on next saturday too (first time in KWA's history).
Full of fun made by SPB, Gangai Amaran and their sons SPB Charan, Venkat Prabhu and sweet memories with Ilaiayaraja's younger days.
Many informations were new to me.
Before IR introduction as MD in TFM 8 persons including IR, SPB, GA met with an accident while they were driving a Car. Car did some dives and fell in a stream. Luckily they did not meet with heavy injuries. IR said "naam varunkaalathula etho sathikamnu irukuda athanalathan pizhaichurukkom". As IR said, all the 8 persons, achieved a lot in their departments
GA composed for 165 films (poll-a Gangai Amaran name add pannungappa)
-
From: Nerd on 14th May 2007 05:13 AM [Full View]
Here is the clincher, if something else has not already done that
http://video.google.com/videoplay?do...uration%3Along
Listened to it after almost a year, the effect is still the same
-
From: ajaybaskar on 14th May 2007 10:55 AM [Full View]
[tscii]Tryst with a music monarch
MALATHI RANGARAJAN
Always ahead of his times, M.S.Viswanathan inspires and influences composers big and small.
Creating magic: M. S.Viswanathan.
The music that wafts through the spacious third floor apartment at Valmiki Nagar, Chennai, indicates it’s composing time at the household. Even as your hands hesitatingly reach for the bell, the door opens and you are welcomed into a melodious milieu.
M.S.Viswanathan — the name that casts a spell on millions of music buffs worldwide, is back in action. “What do you mean? I’ve always been in action. If you are making a movie let me know, I’ll work for you,” he guffaws. The septuagenarian is now the composer of a film titled, ‘Vaaliban Sutrum Ulagam.’ (‘Ulagam Sutrum Vaaliban’ was one of MGR’s mega hits). Smiles MSV: “The hero looks a lot like MGR. Vaali is the lyricist.”
Not hi-tech
Music gizmos are not for him. Even today it’s a live orchestra he’s comfortable with. “But handling hi-tech stuff also needs skill. Only that I believe in full-fledged rehearsals. Why, I can’t even operate that radish in your hand,” he cheekily points out to your mobile.
Infirmity can’t keep the veteran away from the magic of music — magic he has created over the years and which still breathes fresh. He refutes the argument about changing tastes of youngsters. “Recently there was this teenager at one of our shows at Puducherry. He sent up a note requesting us to sing ‘Ninaippadhellam …’ a song we composed 38 years ago for ‘Nenjil Or Alayam,’” he says.
Teaming up with T.K. Ramamurthy in the first few decades of his career, MSV continued to create mesmerising pieces after the two parted ways. He has tried innovations rarely attempted by film composers of his era. The strikingly different beats for the ‘Vellikinnam Dhaan’ song, use of traditional percussion for an item number, trying out the raga with just four notes (Mahati — the song, ‘Adhisaya Raagam …’), eloquently adopting merely five instruments for a song and a 100 for another — the feats have been incredible! “I like to experiment,” he smiles simply.
Every song in Sivaji Ganesan’s ‘Karnan’ is a scintillating exercise and stirs you to this day. “Producer-director Panthulu sent Kannadasan and me to Bangalore for composing. They were ready in just three days! Those were the times when we never went out of the recording studio to work. ‘If you have it in you, you can even compose on the beach. Only that people could drop a few coins if you had your towel lying there,’ Kannadasan would quip,” recalls MSV. The lyricist-composer duo has given many riveting songs to Tamil cinema. “Matter, meter, melody are all I know,” he says softly.
These days we have singers mushrooming with every film. But MSV didn’t use many fresh talents, though a few such as Yesudas made it. “It wasn’t in my hands. Producers have the last word and when they wanted established singers I had no choice. See Ananthu here. He’s a great talent and he’s been with me for a decade now, and I’m still trying to get him a break. Each one’s time has to come,” is his philosophical response.
Besides solos and humming in his own films Viswanathan has sung for many other composers too. The Rahman composition he sang was a major hit. “One morning Rahman called me up and requested I sing for ‘Sangamam.’ I was hesitant and thought I’d go in person and tell him so. But there was a festive air at his place and I got to know it was his birthday. I didn’t have the heart to say ‘no’ then. So I went ahead. Only my voice was recorded. And when I heard it with the BGM and Hariharan’s voice joining mine, I was floored.” MSV is always lavish in his praise when he notices his potential.
Into acting
For a few years now he has been into acting too. “It happened by chance. Director Saran and actor Vivek were after me to do a role in ‘Kaadhal Mannan.’ The next thing I knew Kamal Haasan insisted I do a role.”
MSV recalls an incident when he met Sivaji Ganesan at a wedding. “ He looked at me seriously and said, ‘Viswanathan, I’m planning to make music for films. I saw your performance.’ I jokingly retorted, “It’s your fate that you had to see me act. And if you compose it will be my fate to have to listen to it.” He recalls the exchange with laughter.
There’s yet another facet of MSV — that of producer. “That was a blunder. AVM Chettiar used to tell me, ‘Goddess Saraswati has blessed you amply. Don’t try anything else…’” For a moment he is pensive.
No conversation with MSV is complete without his reference to Hindi film composer Naushad. “He’s like God to me. Imagine my joy when he came to my concert in Mumbai, sat through the entire show, and even sent a note asking for the song, ‘Odam Nadhiyinilae …’ [A memorable strain by Sirkazhi Govindarajan],” he says.
M.S.Viswanathan’s achievements are awesome (check out msvtimes.com), and his simplicity, stunning!
http://www.hindu.com/fr/2007/05/11/s...1150860100.htm
-
From: MuratuKaalai on 19th May 2007 09:03 PM [Full View]
Isaignai Ilayaraja vin isai kaadhuku inimai kulumai
Matravargalin Isai Ellam Miga periya Kodumai
-
From: dinesh2002 on 19th May 2007 09:08 PM [Full View]
Ithu Vere Onnum Illai...PORAMAI!!! Originally Posted by MuratuKaalai
-
From: shobana_in on 19th May 2007 09:29 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by MuratuKaalai
-
From: MADDY on 19th May 2007 11:06 PM [Full View]
superappu.... Originally Posted by dinesh2002
Ithu Vere Onnum Illai...PORAMAI!!! Originally Posted by MuratuKaalai
........yaen indha "ariyamai" HUB-la abt ARR music??
-
From: Wibha on 19th May 2007 11:10 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by dinesh2002
Ithu Vere Onnum Illai...PORAMAI!!! Originally Posted by MuratuKaalai
ungalukku IR music pidikum-na avara appreciate pannunga...adhukkaga mathavala mattama solladhinga
-
From: crajkumar_be on 19th May 2007 11:51 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by MuratuKaalai
matravarin isai pala nerangalil kodumai. sila nerangalil arumai thaan. :P
-
From: nickraman on 20th May 2007 06:49 AM [Full View]
Raja is the best hands down.
Rahman once had the glory, but he's made his money down south. Lately, he's been getting hits in North rather than South.
-
From: littlemaster1982 on 20th May 2007 09:13 AM [Full View]
Nickraman,
Rahman might have been giving hits in North than South is acceptable. But why you have to rant about the money he made in south. Does it matter anyway
-
From: MADDY on 20th May 2007 09:15 AM [Full View]
leave it, LM........ARR-a criticise pannuradhu "style" indha hub-la...... Originally Posted by littlemaster1982
Nickraman,
Rahman might have been giving hits in North than South is acceptable. But why you have to rant about the money he made in south. Does it matter anyway .....ARR-a pidichalum, thittara madhiri kaattikaradhu dhaan fashion....
-
From: Wibha on 20th May 2007 09:18 AM [Full View]
y don't ppl just leave him alone..........it's not like he's ignoring south industry...........it's his profession to compose music and he's doing it well....y do ppl get possessive about dat? Originally Posted by nickraman
-
From: Pras on 22nd May 2007 05:06 PM [Full View]
Music is beyond barriers of region and language. Isaignani Ilaiyaraja has proved this point once again by bringing out a melody album for a to-be-released-soon Bollywood movie. The movie is none other than the Amitabh Bachchan-starrer Cheeni Kum that is all set to hit the screens on 25 th of May.
The album has been highly appreciated for its high melodious tunes and surprising levels of sound. It stands out in the age of techno sounds and beats. Shreya Ghosal is at her best in this album rendering two melodies with élan. The solo saxophone too is also worth mentioning. Half of this album is a lift from his yesteryear Tamil classics. The title song Cheeni Kum is a rip off from Maniratnam's Mauna Raagam hit song 'Mandram vandha thendralukku', another song Batein hawa also rendered by Shreya Ghosal is from Mella Thirandhadhu Kadhavu movie's hit song 'Kuzhaludhum kannanukku'. Both these songs have been lapped up by the Bollywood industry.
It's a surprise that the songs which were termed classics some 15 years ago in Kollywood are appreciated by Bollywood now. It's not without reason that Ilaiyaraja is called the Isaignani. This is a fine example of how he as well as his music is evergreen. We at Behindwoods.com salute the king of melodies.
-
From: dinesh2002 on 22nd May 2007 05:55 PM [Full View]
yea...a good example Sivaji audio was apriciated by Amir Khan allot and see some clowns down south here...saying its not in ARR's caliber etc etc.....
-
From: shobana_in on 22nd May 2007 05:59 PM [Full View]
ameer periya vennaya...avunukku pidicha ellarukum pidikanuma Originally Posted by dinesh2002
-
From: c4ramesh on 22nd May 2007 06:02 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by shobana_in
ameer periya vennaya...avunukku pidicha ellarukum pidikanuma Originally Posted by dinesh2002
-
From: dinesh2002 on 22nd May 2007 06:38 PM [Full View]
there u go... the answer.... Originally Posted by shobana_in
ameer periya vennaya...avunukku pidicha ellarukum pidikanuma Originally Posted by dinesh2002
-
From: Pras on 22nd May 2007 08:05 PM [Full View]
Ilayaraaja-vidam ullathu thiramai Originally Posted by dinesh2002
Ithu Vere Onnum Illai...PORAMAI!!! Originally Posted by MuratuKaalai
Matravar-kalin isai-yai ketka enakku illai porumai
<dig>
periya TR thambi, maman, machan-nu ninappu, niruthungaya :P
</dig>
-
From: Roshan on 22nd May 2007 10:09 PM [Full View]
Listened to the album finally
My humble opinion is - songs like 'ManRam vantha thenRalukku' are master pieces.. atha rehash/retune paNNuRathu ellaam original-a kEvalapaduthuRa maathiri. Originally Posted by selvakumar
CheeniKum
1) CheeniKum - Though it cannot match Mandram Vantha since the original was sung my SPB, this song is unique in its own way. Somehow, I feel that it is a bit diff compared to the original esp the way Shreys sings this one. It is a bit fast but well controlled. Even the music that comes in between is good. Something that comes when you didn't expect it. The way she raises her voice and ends with "Kyon hi kyun" is superb :P well.. not the best if u compare the other songs in this one Even if IR, SPB and the same orchestra were brought back together - the magic the original created can never ever be beaten. SG is a good singer ( my favourite out of the new comers) but SPB-Oda master peice munnAdi jujubi. And Selva, in the last line of the pallavi and charanam, unlike you say she doesnt finishes it properly (thirumbavum compared to the original).
Only one thing I can say about this song - the orchestra, interlude, AB's kara kara voice inbetween and the way SG sings - gives a typical re-mix feeling.2) Baatein Hawa - 1
Again, though it is a much popular song in tamil, it looks different and teh feel is also slightly diff. Naduvula varrah AB voice distrupts the flow. Not sure how it is going to be picturised The ELECTRIC GUITAR piece that comes in the middle One of the best songs in the album.
I dont understand Hindi - so I get the same feeling as said in 2 above - except that you dont hear AB's voice inbetween.
Baatein Hawa - 2
The second one of Baatein Hawa ! The best thing is, in both the versions of BH are diff situations and couple of listens is enough to enjoy this one continously ! what a song ! (Better read the lyrics of the song atleast once though it is not required since shreya is amazing with her voice)
SG is simply lovely in this but as your Kannada friends said original-oda compare paNNAma irunthA you would definitely love it. VizhiyilE maNi vizhilyil mouna mozhi - SPB and SJ niRaiya versatility-Oda paaduna pAttu. But towards the end of pallavi and charanam - it deviates quite a bit compared to the original - but I feel that the change had been made intentionally by IR.3) Jaane do
when I listened first, I didn't like Jaane do since we got carried away by the much popular versions Cheenikum and Baatein Hawa (coz of the impact of the original songs Mandram vantha and Kuzhaloothum kannanukku) ! But few more listens and easily the BEST SONG !
But I was disappointed when my colleagues (kannadigas) told me that it is a V.V.Very popular Kannda song and they had their own opinion that this song had killed the original I got the kannada version as well. It is also good.. But I blamed myself since I had the tamil version too.(vizhiyilae). I was shocked when I heard that there is a Malayaalam version as well
Is it including the Thamiz version?But THIS SONG IS CERTAINLY THE BEST OUT OF ALL including the Kannada version IMO ! I have serious doubts
SPB-Oda original-a asingapaduthuvathaRkaaga edukkappatta oru muyArchi
4) Sooni Sooni
When I listened to it, I thought that HariHaran is singing this song. But who is this vijay prakash guys Is this an effect of "voice rendering" or vijay's own attempts to resemple HariHaran. The way he rises his voice and his pronunciations are It is a song which u can skip and try to hear the other songs since there is already one CHEENIKUM !
Exactly !5) Theme Melody
Good one The keyboard piece But this looks like an old IR song or a mixture of songs. 1:20 to 1:37 and then again slow music ! I am not sure abt how it is going
Yes again. At the beginning it has the mixture of 'en iniya pon nilaavE' and in the middle - it reminds the charanam of 'thatthOm thalaangu thatthOm' .6) Saxophone Melody
Starting nalla thaan irukku But to me after a period of time, it looks like "EN INIYA PON NILAVAE" SONG in Moodu pani ! esp 0:10 to 0.45 ! OK one ! IMHO !!
Overall, I am sure it's going to be something new to Hindhi and will be received well. IR has made changes to the interludes to go with the taste of the Northies But for people who had lived with the originals .... 'original originalthaampA - asechukka mudiyAthu'
-
From: crajkumar_be on 22nd May 2007 10:56 PM [Full View]
Roshan,
Oru humble vendugol
Please don't use the word remix and Raaja in the same sentence! It's blasphemy.
Remix = using the same tune, changing the tempo/beats and butcher the interludes and BGM as much as possible Adhavadhu, primarily, they just 'change the beats' and strip off the orchestration.
Raja NEVER does that.
Even if the tune is the same, the BGM (rhythm, instruments, bass), interludes (totally different) and the application to a different situation are totally different. The result is it is NOT a remix!
Rehash/Retune, fine but please don't call it a *remix*.
e.g
Cheeni Kum - Ruins the rhythm/percussion alright but look at the interludes, the subtle change in the way Shreya ends the charanam. Nowhere near the original, i agree
Baatein Hawa - Wow! Same tune. See how well it matches the 'playful' situation. Rhythm, BGM, interludes are totally different. The interludes take this song to a different level.
Jane Do Na - The prelude and the first interlude. Enough said One of Raaja's best interludes in recent times.
The theme and the sax melody are as original and 'Raaja' as one can get - though the former contains bits from Cheeni Kum (Mandram Vandha) and that's why its the theme music- and the latter is the "Ilaiya" Raaja who thrilled us
in Mumbai Express. Its not the same tune as "En Iniya Pon Nilave".
-
From: Roshan on 22nd May 2007 11:05 PM [Full View]
Sorry I used the wrong word thereRoshan,
Oru humble vendugol
Please don't use the word remix and Raaja in the same sentence! It's blasphemy.
Remix = using the same tune, changing the tempo/beats and butcher the interludes and BGM as much as possible
Raja NEVER does that.
Even if the tune is the same, the BGM (rhythm, instruments, bass), interludes (totally different) and the application to a different situation are totally different. The result is it is NOT a remix!
Rehash/Retune, fine but please don't call it a *remix*. MannichukOnga. Will change it right now. But I agree with you on the interludes. Atha pathi naan konjam detail-a solli irukkanum. Sorry I missed it But again kuzhaloothum rehash gives a remix feeling to me
Irukkalaam CR but it at once gave me the feel of 'en iniya pon nilaavE' - naan thirumba thirumba 3 thadava kEttEn. thatthOm thalaangu thatthOm -oda charanam feelum irukku.
The theme and the sax melody are as original and 'Raaja' as one can get - though the former contains bits from Cheeni Kum (Mandram Vandha) and that's why its the theme music- and the latter is the "Ilaiya" Raaja who thrilled us
in Mumbai Express. Its not the same tune as "En Iniya Pon Nilave".
-
From: crajkumar_be on 22nd May 2007 11:12 PM [Full View]
http://desipundit.com/baradwajrangan...ew-cheeni-kum/
Easily the best review I've read on this album
The comments are very interesting too...
-
From: crajkumar_be on 22nd May 2007 11:14 PM [Full View]
En Iniya Pon Nilave maaaadhiri phrase irukku but i think not quite it Originally Posted by Roshan
Ah, now you have made me want to listen to thathOm thLAngu thathOm
-
From: Roshan on 22nd May 2007 11:18 PM [Full View]
CR one more thing I need to say. When it comes to songs I mainly pay attention to the way of singing - clarity, sangathis , versatility etc. - romba unnippA gavanippEn. Next -thaan interlude and I think it differs person to person.
-
From: Roshan on 22nd May 2007 11:20 PM [Full View]
I am also going to listen Originally Posted by crajkumar_be
En Iniya Pon Nilave maaaadhiri phrase irukku but i think not quite it Originally Posted by Roshan
Ah, now you have made me want to listen to thathOm thLAngu thathOm ethukkum oruthadava kEttu paakalaamnu thOnuthu :P
-
From: crajkumar_be on 22nd May 2007 11:22 PM [Full View]
Yes, i look for the *music* first, followed by tune, lyrics etc... Originally Posted by Roshan
And on its own, without the baggage of the originals in our minds, the album still scores
This is the album in which Ilaiyaan has 'surprised' me after MX!
-
From: Roshan on 22nd May 2007 11:30 PM [Full View]
Agree ! But as I said earlier I am a person who had lived with those originals - enna panna mudiyum sollunga. vizhiyilE paattula.. Originally Posted by crajkumar_be
And on its own, without the baggage of the originals in our minds, the album still scores
vizhiyilE mani viziyil mouna mozi pEsum annam
ivaL viral thodum idangaLil ponnum minnum - enRu SPB paadumpOthu SJ mmhm mmhm-nu lEsa oru humming koduppaanga paarunga - athu onnu pOthum..
-
From: Roshan on 22nd May 2007 11:35 PM [Full View]
Che.. intha musicindiaonline-la thathOm thalaangu is missing
Raaga - download aagurthathukkuLLa vidinjudum
Any other sites ?? I usually use only these two.
-
From: Sanjeevi on 23rd May 2007 12:00 AM [Full View]
Roshan,
Cheeni kum is fun/happy song whereas Manram vantha is sad song.
how can you compare these two songs? yes it is mainly happened due to "we don't know the meaning of lyrics"
-
From: Roshan on 23rd May 2007 12:06 AM [Full View]
Thats a different story and it is even more bad I would say. My opinion is all time GREATS like 'manRam vantha' CANNOT be matched in quality even if the same team is brought back together no matter it is sad, happy or peppy. Originally Posted by Sanjeevi
-
From: thilak4life on 23rd May 2007 12:06 AM [Full View]
Baddy namba aalu, ALWAYS!! Originally Posted by crajkumar_be
http://desipundit.com/baradwajrangan...ew-cheeni-kum/
Easily the best review I've read on this album
The comments are very interesting too...
-
From: Sanjeevi on 23rd May 2007 12:15 AM [Full View]
Yes we can't accept, these songs are better than originals becase we addicted by tamil originals. Originally Posted by Roshan
Thats a different story and it is even more bad I would say. My opinion is all time GREATS like 'manRam vantha' CANNOT be matched in quality even if the same team is brought back together no matter it is sad, happy or peppy. Originally Posted by Sanjeevi
Anyway, Cheeni kum album is a hit in bollywood (First hit album of Ilaiyaraja in Hindi)
-
From: Roshan on 23rd May 2007 12:16 AM [Full View]
Hard luck. Couldn't listen to 'thathOm thalaangu' . Will try tomorrow. Leaving now
Hi Thilak
-
From: selvakumar on 23rd May 2007 05:23 PM [Full View]
Roshan,
Good review indeed. (konjam enna maari aalunga ezhthura review ellam serious ah eduthukaatheenga coz I donno what is pallavai, sangavi etc Just kidding On a serious note, I just express what I FEEL about the songs rather than going into the details something which I do only for songs )
Reg the first one "Cheeni kum", as I said it won't match the original. But SG had ensured that the original wont be spoiled drastically. I loved the different way she ends the songs. SPB held the tempo and speed very well. Obviously, we won't find the female version that much attractive since he makes it flow in a entirely diff direction
Reg Baatein Hawa, I loved the version which lacks AB's voice. But I loved the songs. I don't want to reject INITIAL REMIX FEEL that one will get if they listened to it off the block. But IR had done a good job here so that it wont affect the original much. SG too had a great role. I don't have any probs with this song.
Jaane Do - I love thsi version out of all the version INCLUDING THE TAMIL VERSION Good song.
I hate sooni sooni vijay prakash's voice
Rest all - I agree with you. I also felt that SAX melody looks close to "en iniya pon nilavae". But neenga "thathom thathaango thathom" song oda vera connect panneeteenga I will listen to that again and confirm it.
btw,
Can someone explain me the terms interlude, prelude, orchestration, percussion etc I often get confused b/w these terms
-
From: Thirumaran on 23rd May 2007 05:31 PM [Full View]
Same here Originally Posted by selvakumar
btw,
Can someone explain me the terms interlude, prelude, orchestration, percussion etc I often get confused b/w these terms
-
From: Nakeeran on 23rd May 2007 05:35 PM [Full View]
Interlude - The instrumental part between Pallavi and Charanam
Prelude - The instrumental before Pallavi
Orchestration - The instrumental / vocal arrangement throughout a song
Percussion - Ex : tabla, mridangam etc.
There is also another word : Postlude
this is the instrumental part after the song gets over ( mean, the final charanam gets over )
-
From: Roshan on 23rd May 2007 05:44 PM [Full View]
Correct Originally Posted by Nakeeran
Percussion is a related term of rythm . Tabla, mridangam maathiri items are used for that.
-
From: Thirumaran on 23rd May 2007 05:51 PM [Full View]
Thanks. Originally Posted by Nakeeran
Here after i can use these terms while talking about songs
-
From: Roshan on 23rd May 2007 06:02 PM [Full View]
Enna ippadi solliteenga - your review was good, seriously Originally Posted by selvakumar
Roshan,
Good review indeed. (konjam enna maari aalunga ezhthura review ellam serious ah eduthukaatheenga coz I donno what is pallavai, sangavi etc Just kidding On a serious note, I just express what I FEEL about the songs rather than going into the details something which I do only for songs ) and you have a different way and taste of seeing things in a song (konjam athigamA SG -ku jolluvittaalum :P - JK).
I agreeReg the first one "Cheeni kum", as I said it won't match the original. But SG had ensured that the original wont be spoiled drastically.
Reg Baatein Hawa, I loved the version which lacks AB's voice. But I loved the songs. I don't want to reject INITIAL REMIX FEEL that one will get if they listened to it off the block. But IR had done a good job here so that it wont affect the original much. SG too had a great role. I don't have any probs with this song.
Definitely the best numbe of the album and as I said SG is lovely there. IR had made few changes to the melody - still it's nice.Jaane Do - I love thsi version out of all the version INCLUDING THE TAMIL VERSION Good song.
Athu periya kodumaiI hate sooni sooni vijay prakash's voice
EnnavO theriyala enakku antha feel varuthu - even today i listened to it a couple of times. But still couldnt listen to 'thathOm thalAngu' - checked a couple of sites but couldnt get it. But overall kEkkuRathukku romba inimaiyA irukkuRest all - I agree with you. I also felt that SAX melody looks close to "en iniya pon nilavae". But neenga "thathom thathaango thathom" song oda vera connect panneeteenga I will listen to that again and confirm it.
-
From: selvakumar on 23rd May 2007 06:13 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by Roshan
Enna ippadi solliteenga - your review was good, seriously and you have a different way and taste of seeing things in a song (konjam athigamA SG -ku jolluvittaalum :P - JK).
Definitely the best numbe of the album and as I said SG is lovely there. IR had made few changes to the melody - still it's nice.
EnnavO theriyala enakku antha feel varuthu - even today i listened to it a couple of times. But still couldnt listen to 'thathOm thalAngu' - checked a couple of sites but couldnt get it. But overall kEkkuRathukku romba inimaiyA irukku Cheeni kum ketta ellarum kitta thatta oru sila % SG kku jollu vitrupaanga !
and Reg Sax melody, I think we can have a small R & D on that since there are lot of mixed opinion on what could be the original
-
From: MADDY on 24th May 2007 01:24 AM [Full View]
selva, check SG's pic here -
http://www.mayyam.com/hub/viewtopic....r=asc&start=15
also this-->
http://www.hamaraphotos.com/shreya_ghoshal_423.html
romba kaduppaana vishayam enna-nna , i have walked past her house(b4 she was famous), almost daily, for nearly a year but never seen her 
-
From: m_23_bayarea on 6th June 2007 09:39 AM [Full View]
Watching Ilayaraja's concert from Jaya TV on Youtube!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QiQlr...elated&search=
Just one word... AMAZING!
Makes me sooooo nostalgic as well!
-
From: Nerd on 6th June 2007 09:42 AM [Full View]
Yeh bay. Thats one hell of a program.
Shreya's thUduthE, IR imitating yuvan, IR singing about KH etc..,
-
From: m_23_bayarea on 6th June 2007 09:44 AM [Full View]
Kamal became very nostalgic and emotional too! It's obvious huh... :P Originally Posted by Nerd
-
From: ajithfederer on 6th June 2007 09:48 AM [Full View]
-
From: selvakumar on 13th June 2007 12:37 PM [Full View]
Hindi Music Director (MD of 10A)
Thiru. HImesh Reshmaiyya has acted in a movie as one of the HEROES !
The movie titled "AApkaa surroor" is about to be released on June 29 !
:P
Has any other MD acted as a HERO in any film ?
-
From: palanikumaran on 13th June 2007 12:42 PM [Full View]
ILAYARAJA HAS ACTED AS HERO OF MANY MOVIES... Originally Posted by selvakumar
Hindi Music Director (MD of 10A)
Thiru. HImesh Reshmaiyya has acted in a movie as one of the HEROES !
The movie titled "AApkaa surroor" is about to be released on June 29 !
:P
Has any other MD acted as a HERO in any film ?
-
From: raaja_rasigan on 13th June 2007 12:48 PM [Full View]
T Rajendhar - Music & Hero many movies Originally Posted by selvakumar
Hindi Music Director (MD of 10A)
Thiru. HImesh Reshmaiyya has acted in a movie as one of the HEROES !
The movie titled "AApkaa surroor" is about to be released on June 29 !
:P
Has any other MD acted as a HERO in any film ?
k Bhagyaraj - Music & Hero - idhu namma aalu
R Pandiyaraajan - Music & Hero - Nethi Adi
-
From: prasana84 on 30th June 2007 07:57 PM [Full View]
Somewhere in this thread i read rahman deosnt hav his own style take whether roja or may madham or indira or kadhalan or the legend of bhagat sigh or the latest guru i hav never heard this style of music ealier. the films listed above are jus samples. ilayaraja is great ofcourse i agree but rahman is also a genius.
-
From: prasana84 on 1st July 2007 03:38 PM [Full View]
whats this msv a legend got only 3 votes.
-
From: dinesh2002 on 1st July 2007 03:41 PM [Full View]
MSV's generation is not facing the PC and browsing tru webs ...thats the problem.... ....
-
From: prasana84 on 1st July 2007 04:00 PM [Full View]
ya thats true...
-
From: ajaybaskar on 2nd July 2007 04:18 PM [Full View]
Quality>Quantity
FILMOGRAPHY
TAMIL
01 Roja
02 Ashokan
03 Gentleman
04 Pudhiya Mugham
05 Thiruda Thiruda
06 Uzhavan
07 Kizhakku Cheemayile
08 Duet
09 Kaadhalan
10 Karuthamma
11 May Madham
12 Pavithra
13 Puthiya Mannargal
14 Super Police
15 Vandicholai Chinrasu
16 Bombay
17 Indhra
18 Manitha Manitha
19 Muthu
20 Anthi Manthaarai
21 Indian
22 Kaadhal Desam
23 Love Birds
24 Mr.Romeo
25 Rangeela
26 Iruvar
27 Minsara Kanavu
28 Monalisa
29 Ratchagan
30 Jeans
31 Uyire
32 En Swasa Kaatre
33 Jodi
34 Kaadhalar Dhinam
35 Muthalvan
36 Padaiyappa
37 Sangamam
38 Tajmahal
39 Thaalam
40 Alai Payuthey
41 Kandukondain Kandukondain
42 Rhythm
43 Thenali
44 Alli Arjuna
45 Paarthale Paravasam
46 Star
47 Baba
48 Kaadhal Virus
49 Kannathil Muthamittal
50 Boys
51 Enakku 20 Unakku 18
52 Kangalaal Kaidhi Sei
53 Parasuram
54 Udhaya
55 Aayitha Ezhuthu / Yuva
56 New
57 Desam / Swades
58 Ah..Aah / Anbe Aaruyire / B.F.
59 Godfather
60 Sillunu Oru Kaadhal
61 Guru
62 Sivaji
HINDI
01 Roja
02 Dharam Yoddha
03 Mawaali Raj
04 Bombay
05 Humse Hai Muqabla
06 Priyanka
07 Tu Hi Mera Dil
08 Chor Chor
09 Duniya Diwalon Ki
10 Hindustani
11 Khel Khiladi Ka
12 Love Birds
13 Rangeela
14 Daud - Fun on the Run
15 Kabhi Na Kabhi
16 Mr.Romeo
17 Sapnay
18 Vishwa Vidhaata
19 1947-Earth
20 Dil Se
21 Doli Saja Ke Rakhna
22 Jeans
23 Dil Hi Dil Mein
24 Pukar
25 Taal
26 Thakshak
27 Fiza
28 Zubeidaa
29 Lagaan
30 Love You Hamesha
31 Muthu Maharaja
32 Nayak
33 One 2 Ka 4
34 Saathiya
35 The Legend of Bhagat Singh
36 Tehzeeb
37 Fire
38 Meenaxi - Tale of 3 Cities
39 Lakeer - Forbidden lines
40 Yuva
41 Dil Ne Jise Apna Kaha
42 Kisna
43 Swades
44 Mangal Pandey - The Rising
45 Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose - The Forgotten Hero
46 Rang De Basanti
47 Guru
48 Water
International
1 Bombay Dreams
2 Warriors of Heaven and Earth
3 Lord of the Rings
AWARDS
A.R. Rahman has won the following awards:
Civilian Awards
Padmashree (Jan 2000) title awarded by Indian
Government
Awadh Sammaan (May 2001) awarded by Uttar Pradesh
government (Lucknow)
Al-Ameen Education Society Community Award (2001)
National Awards
Roja (1993)
Minsara Kanavu (1998)
Lagaan (2001)
Kannathil Muthamittal (2003)
Tamil Nadu State Award
Roja (1993)
Gentleman (1994)
Kadhalan (1995)
Bombay (1996)
Minsara Kanavu (1998)
Sangamam (2000)
International Indian Film Awards (IIFA)
Taal (2000) London
Lagaan (2002) Malaysia
Saathiya (2003) - Best Background Score
Saathiya (2003) - Best Composer
Best Background Score, Rang De Basanti
Best Song Recording, Rang De Basanti
Filmfare Awards
Roja (1993)
Gentleman (1994)
R D Burman Award for Best new musical talent (for
Roja, Hindi; 1995)
Kadhalan (1995)
Rangeela (Hindi; 1996)
Bombay (1996)
Kadhal Desam (1997)
Minsara Kanavu (1998)
Dil Se.. (Hindi; 1999)
Jeans (1999)
Taal (Hindi; 2000)
Mudhalvan (2000)
Alai Payuthey (2001)
Lagaan (Hindi; 2002)
Best Background Score for The Legend of Bhagat Singh
(Hindi 2003)
Saathiya (Hindi 2003)
Best Background Score for Swades (Hindi 2004)
Rang De Basanti (2006)
MTV Awards
MTV-VMA Award for Dil Se Re song from Dil Se.. 1999
MTV Asia Awards 2003 for Favourite Artist India
MTV IMMIES 2003 - Best Music Composer - 'Saathiya' -
Saathiya ( Hindi )
Screen-Videocon Awards
Kadhal Desam (South - Tamil; 1997)
Minsara Kanavu (South - Tamil; 1998)
Vande Mataram (Non-film; 1998)
Taal (Hindi; 2000)
Dinakaran Cine Awards
Minsara Kanavu (1998)
Jeans (1999)
Mudalvan, Kadhalar Dhinam (2000)
Cinema Express Award
Roja (1993)
Gentleman (1994)
Kadhalan (1995)
Kadhal Desam (1997)
Jeans (1999)
Kalasaagar Award
Roja (1993)
Gentleman (1994)
Kadhalan (1995)
Bombay (1996)
FilmFans' Award
Roja (1993)
Gentleman (1994)
Kadhalan (1995)
Bombay (1996)
CineGoers' Award
Roja (1993)
Gentleman (1994)
Kadhalan (1995)
Bombay (1996)
Zee Awards
Zee Sangeet Awards (1999) Dil Se..
Zee Cine Awards (2000) Taal
Zee Gold Bollywood International Awards (2000) Taal
Zee Fairglow Awards (2002) Lagaan
Zee Cine Awards (2003) Best Music Direction: Saathiya
Zee Cine Awards (2003) Best Background Score: The
Legend Of Bhagat Singh
Zee Cine Awards (2003) Best Music : Rang De Basanti
Other Awards
was nominated for Laurence Olivier Theatre Award
(2003) (The Hilton Award) for "Best New Musical of
2002" - Bombay Dreams Musical
Sangeet Awards 2005
Best Music Director (Film music - Swades)
The Mahavir-Mahatma Award (Instituted by the Oneness
Forum)
National Lata Mangeshkar awards for 2004-05
( The awards instituted by Madhya Pradesh government )
Sangeet Awards 2004
Best Music Director (Film music - Yuva)
Best music arranger (Critics award) for 'Yeh Rishta' -
Meenakshi
2004 American India Awards
R D Burman Award at the SuMu Music Awards (1993)
Madras Telugu Academy Puraskar (1992 to 1994)
Bommai Nagi Reddy Award (1995/96)
Lux-Kumudam Award for Kadhalan (1995)
Mauritius National Award (1995; for contribution to
music)
Malaysian Award (1996; for contribution to music)
Sanskriti Award from Delhi based Sanskriti foundation
(1994)
Kalaimamani Award from Tamil Nadu Government (1995)
Thangapillai Award
Rajiv Gandhi Award
3rd Channel [V] Awards - Coca Cola Viewer's Choice
Award 1998
The Channel [V]-IMI Award for Best Producer for
Vandemataram 1998
Fanta Award in 1999
Stardust Cine Honours Taal (2000)
Filmgoers's Award Taal (2000)
First Bollywood Music Awards (Best Music Director and
Best Song) Taal (2000)
V Shantaram Award: Taal (2001)
Bollywood US Awards (2003) Best Music Director :
Saathiya
8th Annual Planet-Bollywood Awards (People's Choice
Awards! - Best of 2002) Best Music Direction :
Saathiya, The Legend of Bhagat Singh
Star Screen Award - Best Background Score - Rang De
Basanti
GIFA Award - Best Music and Background music - Rang De
Basanti
-
From: lavanya22rit on 2nd July 2007 04:23 PM [Full View]
Ajay
-
From: ajaybaskar on 2nd July 2007 04:28 PM [Full View]
'ALL PERFECT PRAISES BELONGS TO GOD ALONE' Originally Posted by lavanya22rit
Ajay
-
From: Devar Magan on 2nd July 2007 05:46 PM [Full View]
Quality >>>> Quantity.
thats why Illayaraaja is unbeatable.. he is the god of music...
-
From: prasana84 on 2nd July 2007 08:02 PM [Full View]
yeppa en evloo tension ilayaraja pathii yaracham yethavathu sonnangala a.r.rahman pathi pesuna ennamoo unga parama yethiri pathi pesuna mathiri emotion aguringa. nenga sonnalum sollavitalum a.r.r is great evlo styles tamil, hindi eppo world level vitudunga namma nattukuthan perumai ungalukku pidikalana a.r.rahman waste aga mattaru. world maket irukku avarukku. sooo dont worry no one can stop a.r.rahman taste differs man. Originally Posted by Devar Magan
-
From: prasana84 on 2nd July 2007 09:08 PM [Full View]
Unmaiyana isai rasikan ella vetha isaiyaiyum rasippam if u would hav said like raja is a great music director nan ungala appreciate panneruppain bt god of music overa therila. mozart, beethovennalam enna solvinga avaru godna evanga enna angel la. enna venunalum sollalamnu sollathinga. ungalukku pidithathuthan best ella same 4 us a.r.r fans so yosichu pesunga. rahman entha vithathulayum rajavuku koranchavaru illa both r genius ethuthan unmai
-
From: thineshan54321 on 2nd July 2007 09:11 PM [Full View]
I agree that IR is great but I wont agree with quality >>>> quantity. ARR beats IR in this ratio. In most of IR's albums there is only one or two songs that are evergreen, absolutely amazing songs, others r just fillers. But in ARR 4/6 songs are amazing, evergreen, especially in the 90s. Originally Posted by Devar Magan
-
From: thineshan54321 on 2nd July 2007 09:15 PM [Full View]
well put prasana. but truly, IR's indian classical knowledge can be compared to Beetoven's or Mozart's western classical knowledge. ARR's knowledge is spread between classical, hindustani, and technical brilliance. In my opinion, there are only three tamil MD's that can be compared to Beetoven or Mozart: IR, ARR, and MSV. Originally Posted by prasana84
Unmaiyana isai rasikan ella vetha isaiyaiyum rasippam if u would hav said like raja is a great music director nan ungala appreciate panneruppain bt god of music overa therila. mozart, beethovennalam enna solvinga avaru godna evanga enna angel la. enna venunalum sollalamnu sollathinga. ungalukku pidithathuthan best ella same 4 us a.r.r fans so yosichu pesunga. rahman entha vithathulayum rajavuku koranchavaru illa both r genius ethuthan unmai
-
From: sakthivel_cool on 2nd July 2007 09:17 PM [Full View]
I.R >>>>>>>>>>>MSV>>>>>>>>>> A.R.R
IR is just the rite combination nd da first 2 bring diff. styles f music and just take da whole world by storm..
-
From: raaja_rasigan on 2nd July 2007 09:54 PM [Full View]
meendum oru murai padalgalai ketkavum Originally Posted by thineshan54321
I agree that IR is great but I wont agree with quality >>>> quantity. ARR beats IR in this ratio. In most of IR's albums there is only one or two songs that are evergreen, absolutely amazing songs, others r just fillers. But in ARR 4/6 songs are amazing, evergreen, especially in the 90s. Originally Posted by Devar Magan
nandraga vaai vittu azhagu thamizhil ucharithu paadavum
manadhukku pidithirundhal rasikkavum
-
From: sakthivel_cool on 2nd July 2007 09:55 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by raaja_rasigan
meendum oru murai padalgalai ketkavum Originally Posted by thineshan54321
I agree that IR is great but I wont agree with quality >>>> quantity. ARR beats IR in this ratio. In most of IR's albums there is only one or two songs that are evergreen, absolutely amazing songs, others r just fillers. But in ARR 4/6 songs are amazing, evergreen, especially in the 90s. Originally Posted by Devar Magan
nandraga vaai vittu azhagu thamizhil ucharithu paadavum
manadhukku pidithirundhal rasikkavum
-
From: prasana84 on 2nd July 2007 10:55 PM [Full View]
each one hav their individuality bt in raja as thenishan said 2/6 songs will be nice others wont be nice thats quality
yaru 10 pothakatha orey naalula padikarangarathu mukkiyam illa orey puthakatha olunga padichaley pothum athuthan mukkiyam
-
From: prasana84 on 2nd July 2007 11:05 PM [Full View]
annae nenga enna solringa Originally Posted by sakthivel_cool
I.R >>>>>>>>>>>MSV>>>>>>>>>> A.R.R
IR is just the rite combination nd da first 2 bring diff. styles f music and just take da whole world by storm..
a.r.rahman pathi solrain kelungaa
classical+western=fusion(indira,may madam,roja,kadhalan,duet etccc)
hindutani+western=fusion(guru,legend of bagat sigh,zubeidaa,meenakshi)
arabic+western=fusion(rangela,doub)
ennum neraiya variety irukku kannaa
pudhu pudhu sa neraiya senchurukkaru. whereas raja hav his own style bt the same style frm the beg 2 now with konjam changes.
bt
with raja bass guitarla avaru panra variationsa ethuvaraikum yarum pannathillai.
rehman chordsa classical musickoda veluthu vangirukaru a.r.r isaiya ketta sella nerangalin manam pari poividum.
thats y we lov a.r.r
-
From: prasana84 on 2nd July 2007 11:05 PM [Full View]
meedum padalai kettain nanragathan irukirathu anal kadavuluku ennai yarum illai. 100% thiramaiyalar yarum illai athu a.r.r or ilayaraja. pala raja padalkal ennai kathai poothavum seithullathu pala padalkal birammikavum seithullathu. atharkaga Originally Posted by raaja_rasigan
meendum oru murai padalgalai ketkavum Originally Posted by thineshan54321
I agree that IR is great but I wont agree with quality >>>> quantity. ARR beats IR in this ratio. In most of IR's albums there is only one or two songs that are evergreen, absolutely amazing songs, others r just fillers. But in ARR 4/6 songs are amazing, evergreen, especially in the 90s. Originally Posted by Devar Magan
nandraga vaai vittu azhagu thamizhil ucharithu paadavum
manadhukku pidithirundhal rasikkavum
ilayaraja than siranthavar illai. ulagathaiyae tamil isai pakkam therupinavar than a.r.r hindi matrum tamil no.1 ulaga alavil irukum isai amaipalar. tamiluku perumai serthavar.
-
From: NOV on 3rd July 2007 06:09 AM [Full View]
MSV is always number 1 and even both IR and ARR will agree to that.
Even in terms of hits vs output, MSV will still lead. IR will be at a disadvantage here solely becos of his huge number of output. In that sense, ARR is wise to limit his output.
-
From: Music4Ever on 3rd July 2007 09:03 AM [Full View]
Since I am unable to vote, here is my take.
Sixties ---> MSV
Seventies ---> Shared by MSV and Ilayaraja
Eighties ---> Ilayaraja
Nineties ---> Rahman
The current decade ---> Rahman, Vidya Sagar, followed by Yuvan and Harris
-
From: raaja_rasigan on 3rd July 2007 12:20 PM [Full View]
u have given as a.r.r.... Originally Posted by prasana84
I'll replace it as Ilayaraaja....
some one change it as M S V.....
taste differs.....
i dont have the musical or instrumental knowledge to argue or don't have links to point it
-
From: raaja_rasigan on 3rd July 2007 12:29 PM [Full View]
At present it is Yuvan & Harris Jeyaraj who are associated with hit films regularly. Originally Posted by Music4Ever
Rahman - I think sivaji is a hit bcoz of Rajinikanth.... adhukku
S A Rajkumar music pottalum odi irukkum..... then Azhagiya thamizh Magan.... in this vijay alone has a market to sell his films
Vidya sagar - Except Mozhi..... is there any recent hits for him?
Plz include vijay Antony.... he is on the rise
-
From: NOV on 3rd July 2007 12:34 PM [Full View]
kannai katti kollaadhE
kandadhai ellaam nambaathE
thOzhaa
-
From: kb on 3rd July 2007 12:38 PM [Full View]
sillunu oru kadhal maathiri nalla paatu pota padam flop-nu solreenga..
padam hit aana.. rajinikanth is only reason solreenga..
-
From: raaja_rasigan on 3rd July 2007 12:43 PM [Full View]
bossu.... AVM 60 kodiya mudhaleedu pannunadhu Rajinikkudhan..... Originally Posted by kb
sillunu oru kadhal maathiri nalla paatu pota padam flop-nu solreenga..
padam hit aana.. rajinikanth is only reason solreenga..
1 1/2 varusam sankar javvu iluppi izhuthaalum AVM poruthadhu Rajinikkudhan.....
Unga nenja thottu sollunga...... sivaji's biggest opening yaarukkaga?
unga kootru padi parthaal udhaya'va hit panni irukkalame.... suvade theriyama azhinjuruche
-
From: NOV on 3rd July 2007 12:47 PM [Full View]
Whether anyone chooses to admit or not, ARR is the current hot MD and no other MD - talented or otherwise - have even come close to him.
Who next after ARR, still remains to be seen.
-
From: ajaybaskar on 3rd July 2007 12:50 PM [Full View]
Anne, andha 60 kodi padathukku neenga sonna HJ, YSR, Vijay Antonya meesik panna kooppitturukkalamae.. Yaen sir koopidala? Originally Posted by raaja_rasigan
bossu.... AVM 60 kodiya mudhaleedu pannunadhu Rajinikkudhan..... Originally Posted by kb
sillunu oru kadhal maathiri nalla paatu pota padam flop-nu solreenga..
padam hit aana.. rajinikanth is only reason solreenga..
1 1/2 varusam sankar javvu iluppi izhuthaalum AVM poruthadhu Rajinikkudhan.....
Unga nenja thottu sollunga...... sivaji's biggest opening yaarukkaga?
unga kootru padi parthaal udhaya'va hit panni irukkalame.... suvade theriyama azhinjuruche
-
From: ajaybaskar on 3rd July 2007 12:53 PM [Full View]
ARR was a rage bcoz he adapted a completely different style from that of IR. But now YSR, HJ uses the same style of ARR. When a guy comes out with some completely different sounds and style, ur query may get an answer... Originally Posted by NOV
-
From: kb on 3rd July 2007 12:56 PM [Full View]
ARR pota first padam roja..
yuvan potathu enna (google search pannaama sollanum)
-
From: Devar Magan on 3rd July 2007 12:58 PM [Full View]
MSV is awesome.. no doubts.. i think IR came up with very different and refreshing songs.. may be MSV was limited by the state of tamil cinema and technology in his times.. Originally Posted by NOV
MSV is always number 1 and even both IR and ARR will agree to that.
Even in terms of hits vs output, MSV will still lead. IR will be at a disadvantage here solely becos of his huge number of output. In that sense, ARR is wise to limit his output.
-
From: NOV on 3rd July 2007 12:59 PM [Full View]
poovellaam kEttupaar? Originally Posted by kb
yuvan potathu enna (google search pannaama sollanum)
-
From: Devar Magan on 3rd July 2007 12:59 PM [Full View]
aravindan Originally Posted by kb
ARR pota first padam roja..
yuvan potathu enna (google search pannaama sollanum)
-
From: Thirumaran on 3rd July 2007 01:00 PM [Full View]
Aravindan. Originally Posted by kb
ARR pota first padam roja..
yuvan potathu enna (google search pannaama sollanum)
-
From: NOV on 3rd July 2007 01:01 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by Devar Magan
i think IR came up with very different and refreshing songs..
may be MSV was limited by the state of tamil cinema and technology in his times..
his songs live even to this day. fact is songs deteriorated after that era.
there is nothing to beat the Kannadhasan-MSV-TMS combo.
-
From: kb on 3rd July 2007 01:02 PM [Full View]
aravindhan.. thanks.. i didnt know
-
From: ajaybaskar on 3rd July 2007 01:03 PM [Full View]
Second film?
-
From: NOV on 3rd July 2007 01:04 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by Devar Magan
poovellaam kEttuppaar had fantastic songs! good variety.
-
From: Devar Magan on 3rd July 2007 01:05 PM [Full View]
i didnt say his songs faded.. Originally Posted by NOV
may be MSV was limited by the state of tamil cinema and technology in his times..
his songs live even to this day. fact is songs deteriorated after that era.
there is nothing to beat the Kannadhasan-MSV-TMS combo.
particularly his MGR songs are out of this world.. even after 100 years, it will rock..
-
From: Thirumaran on 3rd July 2007 01:06 PM [Full View]
Appuram third movie fourth movie nnu kaetutae poaveengalo Originally Posted by ajaybaskar
-
From: ajaybaskar on 3rd July 2007 01:08 PM [Full View]
Illa thalaiva. idha mattum sollunga Originally Posted by Thirumaran
Appuram third movie fourth movie nnu kaetutae poaveengalo Originally Posted by ajaybaskar
-
From: NOV on 3rd July 2007 01:09 PM [Full View]
before he asks, IR's 1st movie was annakkili.
2nd movie la konjam kuzhappam and the jury is still out there..
-
From: Thirumaran on 3rd July 2007 01:13 PM [Full View]
I think the movie is Velai which starred Nasser and some least known artists like vignesh ( Originally Posted by ajaybaskar
Illa thalaiva. idha mattum sollunga Originally Posted by Thirumaran
Appuram third movie fourth movie nnu kaetutae poaveengalo Originally Posted by ajaybaskar
).
One song i like during that movie release. But dont remember any of the songs now
-
From: Thirumaran on 3rd July 2007 01:16 PM [Full View]
second movie. no idea Originally Posted by NOV
before he asks, IR's 1st movie was annakkili.
2nd movie la konjam kuzhappam and the jury is still out there..
BTW in Thinathanthi everyday IR's Vaazhkai Varalaaru comes for the past 2 months. It seems it explains in details from his beginning days.
I could happen to see few times. Those who read that regularly would definetly know.
The few issues i read was quite interesting i would say.
-
From: NOV on 3rd July 2007 01:18 PM [Full View]
2007 - Satham Podathey
2007 - Aadavari Matalaku Ardhalu Verule (Telugu)
2007 - Raju Bhai (Telugu)
2007 - Chennai 600028
2007 - Agaram
2007 - Paruthi Veeran
2007 - Deepavali
2007 - Thamiraparani
2006 - Vallavan
2006 - Kedi
2006 - Thimiru
2006 - Pudhupettai
2006 - Azhagai Irukkirai Bayamai Irukkirathu
2006 - [Madana] (Kannada)
2006 - Pattiyal
2006 - Kalvanin Kadhali
2006 - Raam (Telugu)
2006 - Happy (Telugu)
2005 - Arinthum Ariyamalum
2005 - Daas
2005 - Kanda Naal Mudhal
2005 - Oru Kalluriyin Kathai
2005 - Raam(Tamil)
2005 - Sandakozhi
2004 - 7G Rainbow Colony
2004 - Aethiree
2004 - Bose
2004 - Manmadhan
2004 - Perazhagan
2003 - Kadhal Kondein
2003 - Pop Carn
2003 - Pudhukottayilirundhu Saravanan
2003 - Punnagai Poove
2003 - Pudhiya Geethai
2003 - Thennavan
2003 - Winner
2003 - Bala
2002 - April Madhathil
2002 - Mounam Pesiyadhe
2001 - Dheena
2001 - Manadhai Thirudivittai
2001 - Nandha
2001 - Thulluvatho Illamai
2000 - Rishi
1999 - Poovellam Kettuppar
1999 - Unakkaga Ellam Unakkaga
1999 - Kalyana Kalatta
1998 - Velai
1997 - Aravinthan
-
From: thilak4life on 3rd July 2007 01:21 PM [Full View]
Based on my preference: Ilayaraja - orchestration guru.(wow..Nostalgia)
Rahman - acoustical vibrance.
MSV - Lyrical content with good rhythm.
Why don't we stop this 'chinna pulla thanam' by comparing them?
I'm sure, IR fans and ARR fans wouldn't accept the other being the 'best'. And moreover, 'Best' is a subjective term! So there.. The futility of this discussion is evident, by now
-
From: Sanguine Sridhar on 3rd July 2007 01:26 PM [Full View]
comparison pathi naan indha thread aarambichone sonnen...what is the point in comparing generations?
-
From: Roshan on 3rd July 2007 01:36 PM [Full View]
Well said Thilak Originally Posted by thilak4life
Based on my preference: Ilayaraja - orchestration guru.(wow..Nostalgia)
Rahman - acoustical vibrance.
MSV - Lyrical content with good rhythm.
Why don't we stop this 'chinna pulla thanam' by comparing them?
I'm sure, IR fans and ARR fans wouldn't accept the other being the 'best'. And moreover, 'Best' is a subjective term! So there.. The futility of this discussion is evident, by now
-
From: selvakumar on 3rd July 2007 01:41 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by Devar Magan
particularly his MGR songs are out of this world.. even after 100 years, it will rock..
-
From: raaja_rasigan on 3rd July 2007 02:30 PM [Full View]
enna panradhunga...... M S Guhan sankarukku asai pattaru, Originally Posted by ajaybaskar
sanagaru .... ARR ku asai pattaru..... thats all....
Adutha padam P Vasu panna.... cheap & best'a vidyasagar'a pidipparu..... ellam director's choice
Deva pottu pattu hit agalaiya... vidyasagar pottu pattu hit agalaiya.. yaaru potta enna makkalukku thevai Rajini
-
From: sriranga on 3rd July 2007 02:30 PM [Full View]
one of the gems from MGR - vettaikaran
excellent lyrics, music by kv mahadevan
unnai arindhal nee unnai arindhal ulagathil poradalam
uyarnthalum thazhnthalum thalia vanangamal nee vazhalam
maaberum sabaiyinil nee nadandhaal - unakku maalaigal vizhavaendum - oru maasu kuraiyaadha mannavan ivanenru poatripugazha vaendum
boomiyil naeraaga vaazhum manidhargal saamikku nigar illaiyaa thannaith thaanum arindhukondu oorukku solbavargal thalaivargaL aavathillaiyaa
-
From: ajaybaskar on 3rd July 2007 02:39 PM [Full View]
Shankar ARRku yaen aasaipattarungradhuthan anne idhula matter. his previous film was with HJ. He cud've very well continued with the same. Yaen pannala? Originally Posted by raaja_rasigan
enna panradhunga...... M S Guhan sankarukku asai pattaru, Originally Posted by ajaybaskar
sanagaru .... ARR ku asai pattaru..... thats all....
Adutha padam P Vasu panna.... cheap & best'a vidyasagar'a pidipparu..... ellam director's choice
Deva pottu pattu hit agalaiya... vidyasagar pottu pattu hit agalaiya.. yaaru potta enna makkalukku thevai Rajini
Deva pottu paattu hit achu. VS pottum paattu hit achu. But best opening song enga thalaivarthaana koduthar. In fact, Baasha's MD was ARR first. But due to prior commitments, it went to Deva.
-
From: thilak4life on 3rd July 2007 02:45 PM [Full View]
Yeah, Let's not discredit ARR Shankar would be grateful to ARR, not the other way around. The man who works with Deepa mehta, Ashutosh Gowarikar, Mani rathnam and the likes, don't necessarily have to do a 'mass film'. Come on
-
From: raaja_rasigan on 3rd July 2007 03:02 PM [Full View]
ARR'ku oru aasai irukkadha super star koda innoru padam pannalamnu (or) ippo ARR call sheet kedachurukkalam.... where as it's not the case for Anniyan, so sankar used ARR's phototcopy (xerox)... as sankar is used to ARR type music Originally Posted by ajaybaskar
u mean Ballelakka Originally Posted by ajaybaskar
appo...
murattukalai - podhuvaga en manasu thangam
rajathi raja - enkitta modhadhe (though it is not an opening song... it has that rajini flavour)
padikkathavan - rajavukku raja nan da ( " )
idhayellam ennanu solveenga...... rajini rasigara irundhu mattum yosichu parunga...
ippo for eg: rajini arasiyalukka vandha ... Thamizh natuladhanu vara poraru..... appo nan sonna patellam speakerla pottu vote keppingala....... illai adhiradikkaran (sivaji) pottu indha first night enna waste'a nu kekka poreengala....
sandi raniye enakku kappam kattu di (mannan) - indha patta use panna vendi vandhalum varalaam
It's IR first.... even for Annamalai & Basha too...... due to his differences with its producers it went to new & upcoming MD's of that time Originally Posted by ajaybaskar
-
From: ajaybaskar on 3rd July 2007 03:06 PM [Full View]
Anne, Balleilakkava naan sollavae illa. I meant Oruvan oruvan. As a Rajni fan too, this one is my favourite. Originally Posted by raaja_rasigan
ARR'ku oru aasai irukkadha super star koda innoru padam pannalamnu (or) ippo ARR call sheet kedachurukkalam.... where as it's not the case for Anniyan, so sankar used ARR's phototcopy (xerox)... as sankar is used to ARR type music Originally Posted by ajaybaskar
u mean Ballelakka Originally Posted by ajaybaskar
appo...
murattukalai - podhuvaga en manasu thangam
rajathi raja - enkitta modhadhe (though it is not an opening song... it has that rajini flavour)
padikkathavan - rajavukku raja nan da ( " )
idhayellam ennanu solveenga...... rajini rasigara irundhu mattum yosichu parunga...
ippo for eg: rajini arasiyalukka vandha ... Thamizh natuladhanu vara poraru..... appo nan sonna patellam speakerla pottu vote keppingala....... illai adhiradikkaran (sivaji) pottu indha first night enna waste'a nu kekka poreengala....
sandi raniye enakku kappam kattu di (mannan) - indha patta use panna vendi vandhalum varalaam
It's IR first.... even for Annamalai & Basha too...... due to his differences with its producers it went to new & upcoming MD's of that time Originally Posted by ajaybaskar
It was not IR, brother. For Baasha, the film was planned with ARR and RK Selvamani first, which RKS revealed in an interview a couple of yrs back. No idea on Annamalai though. I dont think ARR was in the field at that time..
-
From: thilak4life on 3rd July 2007 03:10 PM [Full View]
Raaja_rasigaR,
I think, he was referring to Muthu. That's my favorite anyway. Just for the prelude and how it sets up the song with SPB's voice eventually (and his diction rocks).
-
From: raaja_rasigan on 3rd July 2007 05:02 PM [Full View]
sabaa.... ippovavadhu sivaji'la atleast oru pattavadhu rajini'in standardukku illainu othukitteengale..... Originally Posted by ajaybaskar
mathapadi onnum solradhukku illai
Best Rajini songnu oru thread open panniralaama...... 1/2 an hourla lock panniruvaanga
Best duet edhunga..... sahana sarala (or) baba kichu kichu moottava (or) kuluvalile va (or) thillana thillana va (or) suthi suthi vandheengala ......
appuram Rajini rasigara neenga Rajini+IR padalgalai ketkave matteengala...... for eg: vellai pura onru, kadhalin deepam onru,
sundari kannal oru sedhi, sandhana katre ponra kadhal padalgal + kuzhandaigaludan padum... vaa vaa vasandhame, adi adu poongodiye, muthu mani sudare... innum niraya irukkiradhu....
ennanga idhu... enbadhugalin (80's) rajakkalukku (rajini + kamal) parabatcham parkama sirandha padalgalai koduthavar indha Ilayaraaja. Ivarudaya pangalippu onrume illadhdhu pola solreenga.
i read about this in junior vikatan IR interview about periyar music (from link given by some fellow hubber)..... though i am also not sure about this.... yeanna appo naan chinna payyan Originally Posted by ajaybaskar
-
From: dinesh2002 on 3rd July 2007 06:05 PM [Full View]
Sivaji album was in & out a Shankar-ARR album.... .....
-
From: Pras on 3rd July 2007 06:29 PM [Full View]
raaja_rasigaa,appuram Rajini rasigara neenga Rajini+IR padalgalai ketkave matteengala...... for eg: vellai pura onru, kadhalin deepam onru,
sundari kannal oru sedhi, sandhana katre ponra kadhal padalgal + kuzhandaigaludan padum... vaa vaa vasandhame, adi adu poongodiye, muthu mani sudare... innum niraya irukkiradhu....
ithu enna ithu ? chinna pulla thanamaa-la irukku !! 8 songs only ... I think you can easily add 100 more songs in the list ... come on, let's play the game - 10 by 10
I start : (love songs)
Kanmaniyae Kadhal - 6 to 60
Vaadi Vethalai, Malai Kovil Vaasalil, Maadethile Kanni, Konji Konji - veera (4 in a row :P )
Ramanin Mohanam - Netrikan
Oru Naalum, Aalapol Velapol - Ejaman
Oru Kola Kili - Uzhapaali
Sodi Kili Engae - Padikathavan
your turn :P
-
From: raaja_rasigan on 3rd July 2007 06:42 PM [Full View]
venaanga vidunga..... yarukku enna pidikkudho adha kekkattum.... kaasa panama Originally Posted by Pras
raaja_rasigaa,appuram Rajini rasigara neenga Rajini+IR padalgalai ketkave matteengala...... for eg: vellai pura onru, kadhalin deepam onru,
sundari kannal oru sedhi, sandhana katre ponra kadhal padalgal + kuzhandaigaludan padum... vaa vaa vasandhame, adi adu poongodiye, muthu mani sudare... innum niraya irukkiradhu....
ithu enna ithu ? chinna pulla thanamaa-la irukku !! 8 songs only ... I think you can easily add 100 more songs in the list ... come on, let's play the game - 10 by 10
I start : (love songs)
Kanmaniyae Kadhal - 6 to 60
Vaadi Vethalai, Malai Kovil Vaasalil, Maadethile Kanni, Konji Konji - veera (4 in a row :P )
Ramanin Mohanam - Netrikan
Oru Naalum, Aalapol Velapol - Ejaman
Oru Kola Kili - Uzhapaali
Sodi Kili Engae - Padikathavan
your turn :P
en sidela irundhu neengalae micha 90 ayum potrunga
eppadiyum muthu, baba, padayappa, sivaji dhaan best nu solvaanga... illaina edhavadhu deva, sankar-ganesh, chandrabose, hamsalekha pattu eduthu adhu idha vida nalla / best'a irukkunnu solvaanga....
-
From: NOV on 3rd July 2007 06:47 PM [Full View]
my name is billaa paattu enna kasakkudhaa?
-
From: Nerd on 3rd July 2007 06:54 PM [Full View]
adhaanE. illa raagangaL 16 uruvaana varalaaRu kasakkuthA Originally Posted by NOV
my name is billaa paattu enna kasakkudhaa?
-
From: Roshan on 3rd July 2007 06:56 PM [Full View]
Rajini-IR combo has given 100s of lovely songs and almost all Albums have been super hits. Athai othukAthavanga or othukka mudiyAthunnu pidivAtham pidikkiravanga nalla/theevira Rajini rasigargaLaaga irukka mudiyAthu.
-
From: sriranga on 3rd July 2007 06:59 PM [Full View]
IMO, JOHNY is the best album in IR+rajni combo.
-
From: Sanguine Sridhar on 3rd July 2007 07:00 PM [Full View]
'Nilave Mugam Kaatu' is an excellent melody...! manasa ennamo pannum....so as Chittuku Chella Chittuku from NN
perai sollava (Thangamagan ), Kanmaniye, Kaadhalin deepam ondru, Rathriyil poothirukum..wow!
-
From: Nerd on 3rd July 2007 07:00 PM [Full View]
IR is the best for Rajini/Kamal/Karthik/VJkanth/Prabu/Ramarajan etc..,
I have 100s of Rajini+IR songs in my playlist :P
Also we should not take anything away from ARR. He had to score music for a *superstar* if you know what I mean. He has not failed so far, IMO
Even deva dint fail. B and C people would still rate BatshA/ANNAmalai over any other movie in terms of music!
-
From: sriranga on 3rd July 2007 07:03 PM [Full View]
perai sollava athu nyayam aguma Originally Posted by Sanguine Sridhar
'Nilave Mugam Kaatu' is an excellent melody...! manasa ennamo pannum....so as Chittuku Chella Chittuku from NN
perai sollava (Thangamagan ), Kanmaniye, Kaadhalin deepam ondru, Rathriyil poothirukum..wow!
ithu kamal padampa(guru?).
-
From: NOV on 3rd July 2007 07:05 PM [Full View]
vasantha kaala nadhigalilE vairamani neer alaigal...
when MSV sings for Rajini at the tail end, the menace of the villain is brought out excellently.
-
From: Sanguine Sridhar on 3rd July 2007 07:06 PM [Full View]
i think i was trying to say "Pesa Koodathu" sorry!
-
From: Nakeeran on 3rd July 2007 07:07 PM [Full View]
Sanguine S
Perai sollavaa >>> is for Kamal in Guru
IR has given many wonderful albums for SS like >>. Johnny, Dharmyudham, Priya , Murattu kalai etc.
But ARR also has proved his class including Sivaji ! I would say its honours even
-
From: Roshan on 3rd July 2007 07:08 PM [Full View]
pErai chollavA - is Kamal's from Guru Originally Posted by Sanguine Sridhar
'Nilave Mugam Kaatu' is an excellent melody...! manasa ennamo pannum....so as Chittuku Chella Chittuku from NN
perai sollava (Thangamagan ), Kanmaniye, Kaadhalin deepam ondru, Rathriyil poothirukum..wow!
Kannil enna kArkAlam - from Un Kannil Neer VazhinthAl
pon mAnE sangeetham pAdivA - Naan Sigappu Manithan
Kaadhalin Deepam Onru - one of the top 10 love songs till date from Thambikku entha Ooru
There many such lovely melodies. List paNNittE pOgalAm
-
From: NOV on 3rd July 2007 07:09 PM [Full View]
just as MSV is best for MGR/Sivaji/Gemini/Muthuraman/Jaishankar etc... Originally Posted by Nerd
-
From: sriranga on 3rd July 2007 07:09 PM [Full View]
its from adutha varisu Originally Posted by Sanguine Sridhar
i think i was trying to say "Pesa Koodathu" sorry!
another song from the same movie, kaviriye kavikuyile - my favourite in the movie.
-
From: Pras on 3rd July 2007 07:10 PM [Full View]
add mohan, sathiyaraj in your list and not to forget : Originally Posted by Nerd
vijay : his first () super hit movie Kaadalukku mariyaathai, and a great entertainer "friends"
vikram : same thing here with sethu (and all of his performance oriented roles : kaasi, pithamagan)
-
From: Nakeeran on 3rd July 2007 07:12 PM [Full View]
Pls remove MSV from the list.
It will be a great insult to add his name here.
He is the definition of TREND SETTER & even IR and ARR acknowledged openly .
One should not even think of such a genius to compare with the likes of Harris or any current crop of composers including IR or ARR.
-
From: Roshan on 3rd July 2007 07:12 PM [Full View]
Adutha Vaarisu has another Super Hit Rajini song - Aasai Nooru Vagai... superb beat
-
From: Nerd on 3rd July 2007 07:14 PM [Full View]
aasai nooRu vagai maRakka mudiyumA. Its been played in a pub here (Desi, of course) Originally Posted by sriranga
its from adutha varisu Originally Posted by Sanguine Sridhar
i think i was trying to say "Pesa Koodathu" sorry!
another song from the same movie, kaviriye kavikuyile - my favourite in the movie.
And MSV, IR and ARR are the best in their generation. My preference would be IR, ARR, MSV simply because i have not listened to a LOT of MSV songs!
-
From: Thirumaran on 3rd July 2007 07:28 PM [Full View]
Just 4 movie done by ARR for Rajini brings equal to the numerous movie IR made for Rajini Originally Posted by Nakeeran
How many songs of ARR for Rajini stands even after times like the ones from IR There are many from IR+Rajini which stays with even after years.
The same is applicable for Kamal too
-
From: Pras on 3rd July 2007 07:35 PM [Full View]
thiru mama, Originally Posted by Thirumaran
Just 4 movie done by ARR for Rajini brings equal to the numerous movie IR made for Rajini Originally Posted by Nakeeran
How many songs of ARR for Rajini stands even after times like the ones from IR There are many from IR+Rajini which stays with even after years.
The same is applicable for Kamal too
aana neenga ippadi ellam pesa koodathu, ARR fans kovichukka poranga
-
From: Nakeeran on 3rd July 2007 07:35 PM [Full View]
Thirumaran
ARR was in school / college when Rajini-IR combo peaked. If ARR had been the contemprory , then he also could have got equal chance .
Now, given 4 or 5 chances, he had given 100% success rate. Hence the opinion
Now, pl dont call for Deva. Most of his songs are copies & even the ludes he copies though he might have given highly successful hits for Rajini.
-
From: Nakeeran on 3rd July 2007 07:35 PM [Full View]
Thirumaran
ARR was in school / college when Rajini-IR combo peaked. If ARR had been the contemprory , then he also could have got equal chance .
Now, given 4 or 5 chances, he had given 100% success rate. Hence the opinion
Now, pl dont call for Deva. Most of his songs are copies & even the ludes he copies though he might have given highly successful hits for Rajini.
-
From: Nakeeran on 3rd July 2007 07:35 PM [Full View]
Thirumaran
ARR was in school / college when Rajini-IR combo peaked. If ARR had been the contemprory , then he also could have got equal chance .
Now, given 4 or 5 chances, he had given 100% success rate. Hence the opinion
Now, pl dont call for Deva. Most of his songs are copies & even the ludes he copies though he might have given highly successful hits for Rajini.
-
From: Pras on 3rd July 2007 07:38 PM [Full View]
nakeera, netri kannai thiranthaalum kutram kutrame ... 2 posts-a delete pannuga
-
From: Thirumaran on 3rd July 2007 07:44 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by Pras
thiru mama,
-
From: thilak4life on 3rd July 2007 08:24 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by Nerd
aasai nooRu vagai maRakka mudiyumA. Its been played in a pub here (Desi, of course) Originally Posted by sriranga
its from adutha varisu Originally Posted by Sanguine Sridhar
i think i was trying to say "Pesa Koodathu" sorry!
another song from the same movie, kaviriye kavikuyile - my favourite in the movie.
And MSV, IR and ARR are the best in their generation. My preference would be IR, ARR, MSV simply because i have not listened to a LOT of MSV songs!
-
From: Thirumaran on 3rd July 2007 08:38 PM [Full View]
This If statement if we keep on using according to our convenience then there is no point in any argument. Originally Posted by Nakeeran
IMHO except Shivaji I dont think any other ARR+Rajini Combo had ARR Trademark. Those will never come in ARR Top 10 itself.
Those albums could have been a hit. For that Maximum credit goes to Rajini, then only There are people who buy Rajini albums just because for a Rajini movie. The hit term u say was period. It ends with the movie hype and release. Many of those songs were not for repetitive listening over time.
The same cannot be said for IR+Rajini. Those period people were
not buying/Listening the songs only for Rajini. Those songs were hit just because of the Quality of the Product, nothing else. They are hits even now. And there is a big list of songs to say.
When it comes Rajini/Kamal IR name comes with their rise.
-
From: Thirumaran on 3rd July 2007 08:43 PM [Full View]
My first preference is IR and then with equal preference to MSV and ARR. ARR in day time and IR in night Originally Posted by thilak4life
Originally Posted by Nerd
-
From: Music4Ever on 3rd July 2007 09:23 PM [Full View]
One dimension which may go in ARR's favor is that his Rajni songs would appeal to even non-tamil folks. For example, vAzhkaiyil aayiram thadai-kallappa. What a lovely number. When I heard it on Headline News, I was like, WOW. IR is great, no doubt, in fact, arguably, the greatest in TFM, but his hit music, apart from tamil speakers, would not appeal beyond the Vindhyas in most cases. Imagine a hindi fellow listening to podhuvaga en manasu thangam. He would consider a second listen beneath him, IMO.
As for Rajni-MSV combo, don't forget Namma ooru singari, Sambo Siva Sambo, Vidiya vidiya solli tharuvEn, Adho vArAndi vArandi villendhi oruththan, Veththalaiya pOttEndi, My name is Billa, among several others. These came when MSV was declining, BTW.
Ilayaraja is all-time best for Rajni because, like NOV hinted, both were in their prime then. Indeed, for Kamal and Rajni films, when you look at overall quality, quantity, and mass appeal it has to be IR.
-
From: joe on 3rd July 2007 09:51 PM [Full View]
shivaji-music -honour
Still I don't understand what is great about this shivaji songs ..After many hearings too ,I still feel it is just OK ,that if it is not a Rajini movie ...I don't want to say
Comparing with Jonny ,Thalapathi...compare pannurathe paavam
-
From: thilak4life on 3rd July 2007 09:55 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by joe
shivaji-music -honour
Still I don't understand what is great about this shivaji songs ..After many hearings too ,I still feel it is just OK ,that if it is not a Rajini movie ...I don't want to say
Comparing with Jonny ,Thalapathi...compare pannurathe paavam
But still, ARR has also given some 'different kind of songs. Why don't we acknowledge that too? IR alavuku illatayum parava ille. At least, it's different from likes of Vidyasagar, etc AND it sounds good (Definitely not 'bad')..
-
From: Nerd on 3rd July 2007 09:57 PM [Full View]
Well. How on earth could you compare apples and oranges?? Johnny was by mahendran, an off-beat film. ThaLapathi was commercial, alright but it was by mani ratnam. Sivaji is an out and out masala film and IMHO, thats ARR's best with Rajini till date Originally Posted by joe
shivaji-music -honour
Still I don't understand what is great about this shivaji songs ..After many hearings too ,I still feel it is just OK ,that if it is not a Rajini movie ...I don't want to say
Comparing with Jonny ,Thalapathi...compare pannurathe paavam
-
From: joe on 3rd July 2007 10:02 PM [Full View]
Nerd,
Inge compare pannurathala solluren.
Sivaji album is a honour level-kku pesurangappa
5 padam ithu varaikkum ,100 % success-am ..IR ethanai padam pottirukkar ...oru padam poda 6 maasam illai gentlemen ...Guna and Thalapathi released in same day ,both by IR ..Nobody can say which one win other...
Give credits ..But oru aLavu irukku.
-
From: Sanguine Sridhar on 3rd July 2007 10:04 PM [Full View]
enna ippadi solli puteenga? ARR-Shankar songs are always a treat to watch..paathuttu adutha vela paaka poidanum aaraya koodathu...! Originally Posted by joe
shivaji-music -honour
Still I don't understand what is great about this shivaji songs ..After many hearings too ,I still feel it is just OK ,that if it is not a Rajini movie ...I don't want to say
Comparing with Jonny ,Thalapathi...compare pannurathe paavam j/k
but honestly it is a different approach.Rajini rock song paaduradhu namakellam pudhusu thaane...!
-
From: thilak4life on 3rd July 2007 10:05 PM [Full View]
This ain't apples or oranges. Because, we clearly know which is 'better'! "Masala" films are generally low in quality and invariably bound to be 'worse', at least the 'songs'. So, this 'line of thought' is justified, I feel
And I agree with Joe that no one can give two successful AND 'high quality' songs like IR did, for Guna and thalapathy
-
From: joe on 3rd July 2007 10:11 PM [Full View]
Thilak, Originally Posted by thilak4life
Aren't Vetrivizha,Vikram,Raajathi Raaja ,Velai Kaaran masala movies ?what about the songs?
-
From: prasana84 on 3rd July 2007 10:12 PM [Full View]
ethu best music director threada illa rajini-ir combo or rajini-a.r.r combo threada?
rahman rajini kuda pannina padam motham 4
kamal kuda pannina padam 2 whereas ir has done a lot b'coz they were ir generation heros.
eppa nan kekura kelviku pathil sollunga aravindaswamy nadicha padathula yaru nalla music patturukangal? no sense in this.
music pathi therinja yarum a.r.rahman vida ir than supernu solla mattangal. comedya irukku.
ir avaru stylela hits koduthurukaru a.r.r avaru stylela hits koduthurukaru.
ungalaukku ir style pudicha avaruthan bestu illa
ungalluku pudichathuthan ulagathulayae bestta?
ir fans taniya utkarunthu think pannunga? a.r.r fanslam madayanga illa. ungalluku ir means 4 us its a.r.r
-
From: prasana84 on 3rd July 2007 10:14 PM [Full View]
ungalluku thalapathy guna engallukku thiruda thiruda, roja, may madham etcccc. Originally Posted by thilak4life
This ain't apples or oranges. Because, we clearly know which is 'better'! "Masala" films are generally low in quality and invariably bound to be 'worse', at least the 'songs'. So, this 'line of thought' is justified, I feel
And I agree with Joe that no one can give two successful AND 'high quality' songs like IR did, for Guna and thalapathy
-
From: prasana84 on 3rd July 2007 10:17 PM [Full View]
understand 1 fact taste differs ir is nt the best or a.r.r is nt the best logicca pesunga nenga pesurathula oru arthamey illa again im sayin taste differs Originally Posted by joe
Thilak, Originally Posted by thilak4life
Aren't Vetrivizha,Vikram,Raajathi Raaja ,Velai Kaaran masala movies ?what about the songs?
-
From: joe on 3rd July 2007 10:17 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by prasana84
Enakku music theriyathu ..But invariably ,All music-known people I know personally says "Raja is THE king ,No comparision"
-
From: thilak4life on 3rd July 2007 10:20 PM [Full View]
-deleted-
with warning
-
From: prasana84 on 3rd July 2007 10:20 PM [Full View]
appa raja en hindila hit agala? a.r.rahman is the top in hindi too world level marketta patha a.r.r has a lot more than wat ilaya has. ethukku enna pathil sollringa. ella audiencesaiyum rasika vaaikala unga raja ana namma aallu ponna edathulla ellam kalakoo kallakunu kalakitaru. Originally Posted by joe
Originally Posted by prasana84
Enakku music theriyathu ..But invariably ,All music-known people I know personally says "Raja is THE king ,No comparision"
-
From: thilak4life on 3rd July 2007 10:20 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by joe
Thilak, Originally Posted by thilak4life
Aren't Vetrivizha,Vikram,Raajathi Raaja ,Velai Kaaran masala movies ?what about the songs?
But, mostly, the songs are limited to appeal to the masses. I agree that, there are 'exceptions'.
Can we safely say, songs in "Masala movies" don't necessarily have to be bad.
Anyway, I don't agree with the demarcation of masala movies and non-mainstream movies, at least for songs.
One(Johnny) is clearly better than the other(chandramukhi). Right or wrong?
-
From: prasana84 on 3rd July 2007 10:22 PM [Full View]
ir mainly concentrated in tamil whereas a.r.r splited his mind over world music ethuthan rendu perukkum irukum diff
-
From: joe on 3rd July 2007 10:26 PM [Full View]
Sivaji Ganesan is not hit in North India ..But Hirthik Roshan is hit in whole india ..So Sivaji ganesan is nothing infront of Hirthik Roshan ,even Govinda.. Originally Posted by prasana84
Ayya..aaLa viduppa
-
From: prasana84 on 3rd July 2007 10:28 PM [Full View]
ennaku therinju music therinjavangalam a.r.r is the besttunu solranga Originally Posted by joe
Originally Posted by prasana84
Enakku music theriyathu ..But invariably ,All music-known people I know personally says "Raja is THE king ,No comparision"
my bro worked with harris jeyaraj(before cumin into film music) harris a.r.rahmanoda hardcore fan bt eeppa filmku vanthu avaru athellam kamika matturaru my bro worked as asst sound engineer in trinity wave studio(harris studio) appa harrisku music theriyatha
-
From: thilak4life on 3rd July 2007 10:29 PM [Full View]
My friend knows Rahman personally. Rahman is a hardcore Ilaiyaraja fan. And Rahman has worked under him too. So, Rahman-ku music theriyadha??? Originally Posted by prasana84
ennaku therinju music therinjavangalam a.r.r is the besttunu solranga Originally Posted by joe
Originally Posted by prasana84
Enakku music theriyathu ..But invariably ,All music-known people I know personally says "Raja is THE king ,No comparision"
my bro worked with harris jeyaraj(before cumin into film music) harris a.r.rahmanoda hardcore fan bt eeppa filmku vanthu avaru athellam kamika matturaru my bro worked as asst sound engineer in trinity wave studio(harris studio) appa harrisku music theriyatha
-
From: prasana84 on 3rd July 2007 10:29 PM [Full View]
govinda or hrithik r nt from tamil nadu thats their native bt a.r.r ku madras native like shivaji or ilayaraja Originally Posted by joe
Sivaji Ganesan is not hit in North India ..But Hirthik Roshan is hit in whole india ..So Sivaji ganesan is nothing infront of Hirthik Roshan ,even Govinda.. Originally Posted by prasana84
Ayya..aaLa viduppa
-
From: prasana84 on 3rd July 2007 10:32 PM [Full View]
nan comedy pannala its true bt ppl wont blive rehman was a great fan of r.d.burman nt raja bt i guess he 2 like some songs of raja ennna avarukku s.a.rajkumar padalkuda keeparu oru vella athanala kuda pidichurukkalam Originally Posted by thilak4life
My friend knows Rahman personally. Rahman is a hardcore Ilaiyaraja fan. And Rahman has worked under him too. So, Rahman-ku music theriyadha??? Originally Posted by prasana84
ennaku therinju music therinjavangalam a.r.r is the besttunu solranga Originally Posted by joe
Originally Posted by prasana84
Enakku music theriyathu ..But invariably ,All music-known people I know personally says "Raja is THE king ,No comparision"
my bro worked with harris jeyaraj(before cumin into film music) harris a.r.rahmanoda hardcore fan bt eeppa filmku vanthu avaru athellam kamika matturaru my bro worked as asst sound engineer in trinity wave studio(harris studio) appa harrisku music theriyatha
-
From: prasana84 on 3rd July 2007 10:34 PM [Full View]
rehman worked as keyboardist in raja's troup durin punnagai mannan it was jus 4 money oruthar kella work panna athukku fanna i like ur sense of humour
-
From: m_23_bayarea on 3rd July 2007 10:34 PM [Full View]
* MSV
* IR
* ARR
* Harris
etc etc...
Everybody is good in their on ways, and have succeeded like anything! Instead of being happy and proud for all of them to be a part of Tamil cinema, we're comparing and bringing them down, just to elevate the other! The pitfall of Comparisons....
Joe, please lock this thread, or change the title to "The Greatest MDs that Tamil Nadu has produced" or something like that.... And we'll have a chance to see the greatness of ppl rather than their minuses!
-
From: Roshan on 3rd July 2007 10:37 PM [Full View]
avar IR fan illa-nu ethe vechu sollureenga ? We too like your sense of humour Originally Posted by prasana84
-
From: thilak4life on 3rd July 2007 10:39 PM [Full View]
yean pa! bharathi kooda Thamizh-la (and Thamizh natla) MATTUM thaan famous or accepted! Is that a disadvantage?
-
From: joe on 3rd July 2007 10:41 PM [Full View]
Bharathi yaaru ? Santhana Bharathi-yannu keLvi varrathukku munnaadi oodi poyirunga Originally Posted by thilak4life
yean pa! bharathi kooda Thamizh-la (and Thamizh natla) MATTUM thaan famous or accepted! Is that a disadvantage?
-
From: thilak4life on 3rd July 2007 10:42 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by joe
Bharathi yaaru ? Santhana Bharathi-yannu keLvi varrathukku munnaadi oodi poyirunga Originally Posted by thilak4life
yean pa! bharathi kooda Thamizh-la (and Thamizh natla) MATTUM thaan famous or accepted! Is that a disadvantage?
-
From: Roshan on 3rd July 2007 10:42 PM [Full View]
IR and ARR both are great but when it comes to Rajini - IR leads and ARR is no where comparatively.
Sivaji songs are good - but the album is definitely not in the top 3 of Shankar or even top 20 of ARR. For that matter none of the other RK movies scored by ARR can hit the top 20 list.
-
From: joe on 3rd July 2007 10:44 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by Roshan
-
From: Shakthiprabha. on 3rd July 2007 10:44 PM [Full View]
This poll, acc to me SHOULD NOT CARRY MSV name.
Most MSV fans wont be in internet to vote for him.
He is like THE ODD MAN out
-
From: Roshan on 3rd July 2007 10:45 PM [Full View]
Aama - IllEnnA sila samayam K T Kunjumon-nu kooda sollalAm Originally Posted by joe
Bharathi yaaru ? Santhana Bharathi-yannu keLvi varrathukku munnaadi oodi poyirunga Originally Posted by thilak4life
yean pa! bharathi kooda Thamizh-la (and Thamizh natla) MATTUM thaan famous or accepted! Is that a disadvantage?
-
From: thilak4life on 3rd July 2007 10:46 PM [Full View]
Adha IR fans othukuvom. Aana ARR fans adam pidichu avar thaan gethu..mathavaen yellam vethu-nu solvangO! Originally Posted by Shakthiprabha
This poll, acc to me SHOULD NOT CARRY MSV name.
Most MSV fans wont be in internet to vote for him.
He is like THE ODD MAN out
-
From: Roshan on 3rd July 2007 10:47 PM [Full View]
Aha! pinnureenga Thilak Originally Posted by thilak4life
Adha IR fans othukuvom. Aana ARR fans adam pidichu avar thaan gethu..mathavaen yellam vethu-nu solvangO! Originally Posted by Shakthiprabha
This poll, acc to me SHOULD NOT CARRY MSV name.
Most MSV fans wont be in internet to vote for him.
He is like THE ODD MAN out
-
From: prasana84 on 3rd July 2007 10:49 PM [Full View]
nan roja padathula irunthu a.r.rahman pathi newsam thevirumapadikurain raja fan rehman sonnathu illayae. Originally Posted by Roshan
avar IR fan illa-nu ethe vechu sollureenga ? We too like your sense of humour Originally Posted by prasana84
-
From: prasana84 on 3rd July 2007 10:51 PM [Full View]
rajiniku rehman pannina padam 4 Originally Posted by Roshan
kamalku 2 ethellam oru mattera. raja generation herooos ma avanga
muthu vaa enna solrathu awesome songs tat 2 intro song ammadi pattaiya kelappunmae
-
From: prasana84 on 3rd July 2007 10:52 PM [Full View]
adengappa appadi yellam solla mattom msv is genius Originally Posted by thilak4life
Adha IR fans othukuvom. Aana ARR fans adam pidichu avar thaan gethu..mathavaen yellam vethu-nu solvangO! Originally Posted by Shakthiprabha
This poll, acc to me SHOULD NOT CARRY MSV name.
Most MSV fans wont be in internet to vote for him.
He is like THE ODD MAN out
-
From: Shakthiprabha. on 3rd July 2007 10:55 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by thilak4life
Adha IR fans othukuvom. Aana ARR fans adam pidichu avar thaan gethu..mathavaen yellam vethu-nu solvangO! Originally Posted by Shakthiprabha
This poll, acc to me SHOULD NOT CARRY MSV name.
Most MSV fans wont be in internet to vote for him.
He is like THE ODD MAN out
-
From: prasana84 on 3rd July 2007 10:56 PM [Full View]
msv,ir,rahman meenu perum genius bt entha threadla oru sila peru ir is god rahman is nothinlam sonnanga athunalathan konjam rahman pathi yeduthu sonnain meenu geniusum orey munnula poranthangal. barathi is a tamil peot avaru eppadi hindila periya aal aga mudiyum music has no language. anyway ethuthan unmai
-
From: m_23_bayarea on 3rd July 2007 10:57 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by prasana84
Wish we had a seperate forum for MSV! This poll should not have his name anymore.... It's insulting to see him getting 3 votes amidst other MDs!
-
From: joe on 3rd July 2007 11:03 PM [Full View]
That is the best proof for "Popularity can't decide level of genius" Originally Posted by m_23_bayarea
It's insulting to see him getting 3 votes amidst other MDs!
-
From: prasana84 on 3rd July 2007 11:04 PM [Full View]
ssssss sry verra yethoo amukka poi msg delete ayiduchu anyway msv is great
-
From: m_23_bayarea on 3rd July 2007 11:04 PM [Full View]
It's also proof that not many senior ppl use the Internet, or come to this HUB! :P Originally Posted by joe
That is the best proof for "Popularity can't decide level of genius" Originally Posted by m_23_bayarea
It's insulting to see him getting 3 votes amidst other MDs!
-
From: thilak4life on 3rd July 2007 11:23 PM [Full View]
Or the hindsight, we can safely assume only kids are omnipresent in cyberworld! Originally Posted by m_23_bayarea
It's also proof that not many senior ppl use the Internet, or come to thi HUB! :P Originally Posted by joe
That is the best proof for "Popularity can't decide level of genius" Originally Posted by m_23_bayarea
It's insulting to see him getting 3 votes amidst other MDs!
Prasana,
I agree with you on ARR being a desi favorite. But, desis aren't the yardstick to measure 'greatness', are they? IR oda music pidicha yenna? pidikati yenna? Ennai porutha varai, he is on par with greats like Ennio morricone, Bernard herrman, Thoman newman and others.
I agree that ARR is a genius, MSV is a legend. IR is a genius, legend, and above all, my favorite - as he has given me much more than others. Neenga yaen ARR thaan best'-nu solringa? because some north indians liked it or what? It's only because of the interludes, rhythm and composition. So, avoid 'popularism' being a yardstick (even if it is, then IR is still a contender).
Moreover, I agree that MSV should be removed from this poll. Mukavasi paer, ignorant about his best works!
-
From: prasana84 on 3rd July 2007 11:28 PM [Full View]
anyway each music director hav thier own style. in thier respective styles they r the king tats all avara vida evaru besttu eppadi ellam venam ungalluku pidicha rasinga atha vituttu entha mathiri commentsam venam ungalukku pidichathu than best illa a.r.rahman hav fans all over the world avanga ellam muttal kidaiyathu Originally Posted by Shakthiprabha
Originally Posted by thilak4life
Adha IR fans othukuvom. Aana ARR fans adam pidichu avar thaan gethu..mathavaen yellam vethu-nu solvangO! Originally Posted by Shakthiprabha
This poll, acc to me SHOULD NOT CARRY MSV name.
Most MSV fans wont be in internet to vote for him.
He is like THE ODD MAN out
-
From: m_23_bayarea on 3rd July 2007 11:29 PM [Full View]
Originally Posted by thilak4life
Or the hindsight, we can safely assume only kids are omnipresent in cyberworld! Originally Posted by m_23_bayarea
It's also proof that not many senior ppl use the Internet, or come to thi HUB! :P Originally Posted by joe
That is the best proof for "Popularity can't decide level of genius" Originally Posted by m_23_bayarea
It's insulting to see him getting 3 votes amidst other MDs!
Moreover, I agree that MSV should be removed from this poll. Mukavasi paer, ignorant about his best works!
-
From: prasana84 on 3rd July 2007 11:31 PM [Full View]
no buddy in my posts i hav said 3 r genius i 2 like raja, im a great fan of msv too i hav never said rahman the best appdi yethuvathu solliyiruntha mannichukonkal bt ennaku therinja vari appadi sollala Originally Posted by thilak4life
Or the hindsight, we can safely assume only kids are omnipresent in cyberworld! Originally Posted by m_23_bayarea
It's also proof that not many senior ppl use the Internet, or come to thi HUB! :P Originally Posted by joe
That is the best proof for "Popularity can't decide level of genius" Originally Posted by m_23_bayarea
It's insulting to see him getting 3 votes amidst other MDs!
Prasana,
I agree with you on ARR being a desi favorite. But, desis aren't the yardstick to measure 'greatness', are they? IR oda music pidicha yenna? pidikati yenna? Ennai porutha varai, he is on par with greats like Ennio morricone, Bernard herrman, Thoman newman and others.
I agree that ARR is a genius, MSV is a legend. IR is a genius, legend, and above all, my favorite - as he has given me much more than others. Neenga yaen ARR thaan best'-nu solringa? because some north indians liked it or what? It's only because of the interludes, rhythm and composition. So, avoid 'popularism' being a yardstick (even if it is, then IR is still a contender).
Moreover, I agree that MSV should be removed from this poll. Mukavasi paer, ignorant about his best works!
-
From: thilak4life on 3rd July 2007 11:40 PM [Full View]
Hey Prasana,
I like ARR. I just feel sometimes that both set of fans are unfair. Yes, both IR fans and ARR fans. NanE romba kevalama pesuvaen ARR-a pathi. Although, thats just signs of immaturity. Anyway, I do agree that all three legends, MSV, IR and ARR, are unique and great in their own way.
-
From: prasana84 on 3rd July 2007 11:47 PM [Full View]
this is wat maturity is Originally Posted by thilak4life
Hey Prasana,
I like ARR. I just feel sometimes that both set of fans are unfair. Yes, both IR fans and ARR fans. NanE romba kevalama pesuvaen ARR-a pathi. Although, thats just signs of immaturity. Anyway, I do agree that all three legends, MSV, IR and ARR, are unique and great in their own way. raja pathi perumaiya pesinathoda rahmanna matta paduthunanga tats nt the truth athan entha threadku vanthain anyway hope enimal varra postslam maturedda varanumnu. yes the legends are
msv
ilayaraja
a.r.rahman
-
From: Music4Ever on 4th July 2007 12:00 AM [Full View]
"Adha IR fans othukuvom. Aana ARR fans adam pidichu avar thaan gethu..mathavaen yellam vethu-nu solvangO! "
thilak4life, what you say above is certainly not true. I have been a music listener since the mid seventies. During those days the music fans were split into MSV and IR supporters, and IR fans never agreed that MSV was superior. Even now some of the hard core IR fans just allow it to pass simply because IR himself has acknowledged it, but secretly they would still strongly believe IR is superior. I know many many many such music lovers. Not that they are wrong, if IR's phenomenal (and mostly superior, at that) output is any indication. Just wanted to disagree with your statement, that's all. BTW, I want to vote for MSV.
-
From: thilak4life on 4th July 2007 12:04 AM [Full View]
Okay Originally Posted by Music4Ever
But, One can see fans 'supporting' their favorites alone! I've never seen people voting against their favorites :P so, my statement would fit MSV, IR and ARR fans. Because none of us, would ever vote for the other!
-
From: NOV on 4th July 2007 06:00 AM [Full View]
Ok, since everyone has come to an agreement that MSV, IR and ARR are the best MDs of their respective periods and with both IR and ARR receiving equal number of votes, the time to lock this thread has arrived.