Topic started by selvakumar on Tue Jan 30 9:59:18 2007.

[Full View]

Friends,
Sometimes, I feel like discussing some movies with all our hubbers. But finding it very difficult to use the existing threads since they are all dedicated to stars, directors, actresses etc !

I am sure MANY OF US may feel discussing on the scenes of a movie, the greatness etc. One benefit is: We can gain lot of INFO on the movie from the veteran hubbers. IF we discuss the same in existing threads, everyone won't be interested to join and share their thoughts since all the threads are unique in their own way.

So, I thought of creating something in which many can share their thoughts on a movie.

Ofcourse, having considered the HUB HISTORY, We are not going to touch the movies that are releasing nowadays. It may bring something unwanted. so, We can discuss on Yesteryear classics.

One movie per week.

I expect we can have fruitful discussion by remembering the past parallely !
I wanted to start this one with a movie in mind. will post the title now !

Expecting that hubbers will be happy to share their thoughs. Ofcourse, this thread is an inspiration from similar threads !

---

| RSS Feed | Email me when a reply is posted

Responses:

• From: ajithfederer on Tue Jan 30 10:12:24 2007.

  [Full View]

  good idea
  
  

• From: thinkfloyd on Tue Jan 30 10:23:03 2007.

  [Full View]

  Ippadi aalalukku pesama irundha eppadi?? Ungalukku theriyadhadhilla. Yaaravadhu aarambinga
  (Panchayat dialogue)
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Tue Jan 30 10:26:36 2007.

  [Full View]

  I think we can start with one of the movies which we like a lot ! This is one movie which I loved a lot !
  I thought of starting with one movies which I loved a lot. But changed my mind in the middle since it won't be a perfect "warm up" and should come in the middle.
  
  well, Shall we start with "AGNI NATCHATHIRAM" ?
  
  Hubbers can also suggest a few titles after this which will be included in the upcoming weeks.
  
  Thanks for the support friends ... esp AF machi and bala
  
  

• From: Saamy on Tue Jan 30 10:28:20 2007.

  [Full View]

  entha padatha pathi discuss panurathunu sandai venaam .. please
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Tue Jan 30 10:30:05 2007.

  [Full View]

  Kaarthi - POint taken ! I will be updating the title every week.
  Mostly it will be a different movie than the one we have been discussing all the time.
  I am thinking of choosing *different* movies everytime. Anyway, IF hubbers are interested to discuss on a movie, I will include the same here
  
  

• From: Thirumaran on Tue Jan 30 10:30:37 2007.

  [Full View]

  The first thing which comes to my mind while thinking about Agni nakshathiram is..
  
  "En Pondaati Nigamaavae Oorukku Poitaa"
  
  
  
  

• From: NOV on Tue Jan 30 10:31:51 2007.

  [Full View]

  
  
  

• From: kb on Tue Jan 30 10:32:33 2007.

  [Full View]

  i liked the BGM whenever karthik and prabhu meet.. sema hype ...
  
  raja rajaathi rajan intha raja
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Tue Jan 30 10:37:06 2007.

  [Full View]

  I think "AN" is one movie in which we can see EQUAL AMOUNT of SHARE for two popular Heroes. I loved this movie and the narration.
  Not to forget the songs from IR ! and the BGM whenever both the guys clash !
  
  I loved the scene in which Prabhu rescues his sister ! There are many GETHU scenes as well for both the stars. Kaarthik had some scenes with Nirosha which were extension of his "Mouna Raagam" character. The scenes b/w Nirosha - Kaarthik were
  
  One person whom we can never forget is CUTE Amala Her expressions and romance with Prabhu and Prabu's strict responses for the same
  
  One more scene is: The way prabu replies to his superior
  "Sir - Inimel unga Trainingu en kudumbatha use pannaatheenga" (not sure about the line though)
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Tue Jan 30 10:37:50 2007.

  [Full View]

  NOV
  Thanks a lot for the correct updation !
  
  

• From: kb on Tue Jan 30 10:38:42 2007.

  [Full View]

  man this thread is forcing me to see the movie again. gonna search for it..
  
  

• From: Amarshiva on Tue Jan 30 10:39:05 2007.

  [Full View]

  Agni Natchiram: Good supporting cast from both karthik and prabhu.. they were the so called youth at that time. ofourse amala and nirosha.
  
  Perfect comedy from Janakaraj and VKR.
  
  Songs: Still rocks...
  
  Good direction: Manirathinam Music: IR
  
  It had almost the good combo for a blockbuster..
  
  my favourite scene: The train scene, where prabhu will save her chitti's daughter..
  
  

• From: Saamy on Tue Jan 30 10:42:18 2007.

  [Full View]

  Thirumaran wrote:

  The first thing which comes to my mind while thinking about Agni nakshathiram is.. "En Pondaati Nigamaavae Oorukku Poitaa"

  neenga en eppovum ippidiye reply pannureenga
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Tue Jan 30 10:42:22 2007.

  [Full View]

  what is the name of the "Villan" friends ? He is simple but yet rocks in the small share provided
  
  "eNNa thambi, thangachi kitta sollaliya.. .."
  "namma maLLika paapaavukku oru nalla varan vanthuchi athaan"
  etc
  
  

• From: Thirumaran on Tue Jan 30 10:44:37 2007.

  [Full View]

  Amarshiva wrote:

  Perfect comedy from Janakaraj and VKR.

  
  
  Though the comedy was enjoyable, it was not at all needed for the movie. It is sad Mani also had to depend on separate comedy track in his earlier days
  
  One of my favourite scene in the movie was when prabhu arrests karthik by pulling his family as he dont have any other case against him
  
  

• From: Thirumaran on Tue Jan 30 10:45:53 2007.

  [Full View]

  Saamy wrote:

  Thirumaran wrote: The first thing which comes to my mind while thinking about Agni nakshathiram is.. "En Pondaati Nigamaavae Oorukku Poitaa" neenga en eppovum ippidiye reply pannureenga

  
  
  U will understand that after your marriage
  
  

• From: joe on Tue Jan 30 10:46:32 2007.

  [Full View]

  Highlight of Agni Natchathiram ...
  
  Raja!
  Ilaya Raja!
  
  Prabhu & Karthick did extremely well .
  
  Prabhu was mejastic when saying "Arrest him Now"
  
  

• From: Saamy on Tue Jan 30 10:47:22 2007.

  [Full View]

  the music is chanceless. raaja rocks. what great songs. all were superb and they are still superb..
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Tue Jan 30 10:48:47 2007.

  [Full View]

  Thirumaran wrote:

  U will understand that after your marriage

  
  
  
  
  

• From: joe on Tue Jan 30 10:50:21 2007.

  [Full View]

  selvakumar wrote:

  what is the name of the "Villan" friends ?=

  
  
  Is't he Anand theatre owner G.Umapathi?
  
  

• From: Thirumaran on Tue Jan 30 10:51:58 2007.

  [Full View]

  Joe and Saamy,
  
  There are several movies, without IR could have been incomplete. AN is one among them
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Tue Jan 30 11:00:25 2007.

  [Full View]

  joe wrote:

  selvakumar wrote: what is the name of the "Villan" friends ?= Is't he Anand theatre owner G.Umapathi?

  
  
  He looks so natural in the movie.
  
  

• From: joe on Tue Jan 30 11:07:16 2007.

  [Full View]

  selvakumar wrote:

  joe wrote: selvakumar wrote: what is the name of the "Villan" friends ?= Is't he Anand theatre owner G.Umapathi? He looks so natural in the movie.

  
  
  Yeah .He produced some movies too .He died few years back
  
  

• From: joe on Tue Jan 30 11:08:20 2007.

  [Full View]

  Thirumaran wrote:

  There are several movies, without IR could have been incomplete. AN is one among them

  
  
  Exactly!
  
  

• From: thinkfloyd on Tue Jan 30 11:25:23 2007.

  [Full View]

  God-level music by Raaja. The tabla was not used even in one song
  
  It had some great moments. The way Karthik says "Assshhhok Visssshhwanath" is funny
  
  Both Karthik and Prabhu were very convincing.
  
  It had a brand of cinematography (which was to follow in more movies) was irritating IMO.
  
  Above all, it had AMALA in it
  
  

• From: m_23_bayarea on Tue Jan 30 11:33:15 2007.

  [Full View]

  AWESOME thread Selva! And nice pic for the week too ... AGNI NATCHATHIRAM is a class movie from a Classy Director!
  
  
  

• From: kb on Tue Jan 30 11:39:01 2007.

  [Full View]

  just noticed.. karthik veedu kaamikum bothu.. dull lighting and whenever prabhu veedu will be always bright..
  
  

• From: ajithfederer on Tue Jan 30 11:44:15 2007.

  [Full View]

  Prabu : Arrest Him.....
  
  Karthik : Warrant Irukka.....Poi kondu vaanga ........Naanga inga than iruppom......
  
  Prabu : I said arrest him.......
  
  Karthik : Hello ...edhukagha arrest.......enna charge.......Warrant illama yaarayum arrest panna koodathu therium illai.......Poi anga sollungaa........
  
  Prabu gets down from the Police Jeep (IR BGM ROCKS HERE ....... )
  
  Prabu : Un per enna........
  
  Karthik : Has a lousy grin on his face.......
  
  Prabu : Ketta kelvikku bathil sollu.......Un peru enna........
  
  Karthik : Ashok........
  
  Prabu : Muzhu peru.......
  
  Karthik : Ashok Viswanath.....
  
  Prabu : Viswanath ngarathu.........?
  
  Karthik : Enga appa.......
  
  Prabu : AVar than unga appa nnu correctaa theriumaa
  
  Karthik : tries to hit him with his hand......prabu grabs him........
  
  Prabu : Arrestkku nee ketta karanam......duty la iruntha police officeraa adika paatathu...Arres him now....(IR BGM here again )
  
  Prabu : Yaravathu Jamin la ketta vidatheenga........en perae sollungaa
  
  Ngo****la Gethu scene.......
  

  Thirumaran wrote:

  One of my favourite scene in the movie was when prabhu arrests karthik by pulling his family as he dont have any other case against him

  
  

• From: Nerd on Tue Jan 30 11:50:49 2007.

  [Full View]

  kb wrote:

  man this thread is forcing me to see the movie again. gonna search for it..

  
  
  google videos la irukku kb
  
  The first few scenes are my favorite. Mani just needed 2 or 3 scenes to show how much hatred karthick had developed towards his father. The interview scene with VKR ( ) and the following scenes at his house where vk will be drinking were really good. Then when VK gets drunk, karthick would drop him home. These 3 scenes were so powerful that it makes you sit up and watch
  
  IR's music -- God level indeed
  
  PC -- Amazing. Except the climax which was pure irritation
  
  In fact, AN was a blockbuster for maNi
  
  

• From: kb on Tue Jan 30 11:56:16 2007.

  [Full View]

  karthik bail vida bothu..
  
  rendu peru sign pannuvaaanga..
  
  prabhus mother will sign fast in english.. she will write vishwanath completly
  karthik mother sill sign slowly in tamil.. she will write only V..
  
  
  
  

• From: Scale on Wed Jan 31 9:09:29 2007.

  [Full View]

  Anyone sold out for a frame to frame delightment during childhood? That is MR's -Agninatchathiram for me Iluthu pudichi Camerakullerndhu paakka vaipparu, kaadhula earphones maatina maadhiri aarvama ketka vaippaaru
  
  An example, look: "The tabla was not used even in one song "
  
  Really? Have you checked BGM's as well? Can it be an Obligation? An exclusive cadence score by the Maestro! No take back......
  
  
  

• From: thinkfloyd on Wed Jan 31 11:24:07 2007.

  [Full View]

  Scale wrote:

  Have you checked BGM's as well? Can it be an Obligation? An exclusive cadence score by the Maestro! No take back...... [/tscii]

  
  Nalla kelvi but i'm not sure about the BGM. Recent- a paathavanga sollalaam
  
  

• From: mrsrajan on Thu Feb 1 9:11:44 2007.

  [Full View]

  Tabla is used in BGMs in hospital scenes
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Thu Feb 1 9:47:40 2007.

  [Full View]

  I loved the songs. The starting of "Thoongaatha VizhigaL" rendu songs was amazing. Was that "Guitar" + "Violin"
  
  

• From: MADDY on Thu Feb 1 10:02:42 2007.

  [Full View]

  selvakumar wrote:

  I loved the songs. The starting of "Thoongaatha VizhigaL" rendu songs was amazing. Was that "Guitar" + "Violin"

  
  
  reg that instrument - it was Keyboard + violin......keyboard- must be Rahman's.....
  
  (its still widely speculated that ARR was the addnl programmer for raja's smash hits like Punnagai Mannan,Agni Natchitram,Anjali etc etc.....but cannot call it ARR's work, its 100% IR's......)
  
  

• From: Nakeeran on Thu Feb 1 10:06:13 2007.

  [Full View]

  Ninnukori varnam picturisation was spoilt in toto by Mani R. I think he had no clue on how to go about it.
  Absolutely messed up.
  Never expected this from Mani.
  
  

• From: Nakeeran on Thu Feb 1 10:07:29 2007.

  [Full View]

  Ninnukori varnam picturisation was spoilt in toto by Mani R. I think he had no clue on how to go about it.
  Absolutely messed up.
  Never expected this from Mani.
  
  

• From: Wibha on Sun Feb 4 0:57:16 2007.

  [Full View]

  AGNI NATCHATRAM what a movie................
  
  kaarthik
  
  evergreen songs raja raaja di rajan
  
  amala anjali cute
  
  tara and nirosha r cool
  
  

• From: buddysathi on Sun Feb 4 1:03:46 2007.

  [Full View]

  There was a joke goin around when agni natchatram was running in theatres,, jus bcos of very different lightings and camerawork ( PC Sriram rt?)
  
  X: Ennangae kaila torch light-oda engae kelambiteenga?
  Y: Agni natchatram paaka thaan!
  
  

• From: kb on Sun Feb 4 1:45:19 2007.

  [Full View]

  mani vittu vaikalaiya
  
  

• From: Raghu on Tue Feb 6 6:12:49 2007.

  [Full View]

  selvakumar wrote:

  Thirumaran wrote: U will understand that after your marriage

  
  
  That's the wish of every man(Husband), Janakaraj was Hilarious at that scene
  
  Excellent Film, Greats stuff From Karthick, Prabhu , Dr.IR and Mani Ratnam
  
  

• From: Thirumaran on Tue Feb 6 6:22:57 2007.

  [Full View]

  Is the week not completed
  
  So what is the next movie of the week..
  
  

• From: Ramakrishna on Tue Feb 6 6:27:10 2007.

  [Full View]

  Sivakaasi
  
  

• From: Thirumaran on Tue Feb 6 6:29:18 2007.

  [Full View]

  Ramakrishna wrote:

  Sivakaasi

  
  
  For complete comedies we have different threads.
  
  
  By the way some old classics will be better option.
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Tue Feb 6 6:40:11 2007.

  [Full View]

  Next Movie has been selected already. I will be posting the same shortly !
  
  

• From: MADDY on Tue Feb 6 6:41:33 2007.

  [Full View]

  Thirumaran wrote:

  Ramakrishna wrote: Sivakaasi For complete comedies we have different threads. By the way some old classics will be better option.

  
  
  how abt 1000-athhil oruvan?? /.......MGR is one of the few things that we can agree upon, i guess....
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Tue Feb 6 6:50:56 2007.

  [Full View]

  Maddy,
  Point taken. But at the sametime, we will be concentrating on rare classics and different movies that got released in the past ! For sometime, let us keep aside popular stars We will be updating this thread shortly with them.
  
  

• From: Thirumaran on Tue Feb 6 6:52:49 2007.

  [Full View]

  MADDY wrote:

  how abt 1000-athhil oruvan?? /.......MGR is one of the few things that we can agree upon, i guess....

  
  
  But we can discuss on movies other than MGR, Shivaji, Rajini and Kamal. As these stars have common thread and lots had been already discussed some other stars movies would do better in my opinion
  
  

• From: MADDY on Tue Feb 6 7:01:01 2007.

  [Full View]

  selvakumar wrote:

  Maddy, Point taken. But at the sametime, we will be concentrating on rare classics and different movies that got released in the past ! For sometime, let us keep aside popular stars We will be updating this thread shortly with them.

  
  
  yes sir...
  
  (enna avtar change?? )
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Tue Feb 6 7:04:26 2007.

  [Full View]

  Thanks for sharing your comments on "Agni Natchathiram" friends.
  -------------------------------------------------------------------
  
  Here is the movie of this week.
  
  "Thooral Ninnu Pochu"
  
  Cast:
  K.BagyaRaj
  M N NambiyaaR
  SenthaaMarai
  Sulokshana
  and others
  
  This movie is from KB Factory - I mean K.BagyaRaj Factory
  
  K.BagyaRaj - One of the famous and talented directors in tamil cinema is known for his clever screenplay and direction. He must be one of the directors who is still respected for his brilliance in writing sheer screenplay. None of the characters in his movies go unnoticed. Apart from this, he is a good actor.
  
  The movie had "NambiyaaR" in a different character role. The "KUshti VaathiyaaR" role he played in the movie is one of the funny yet powerful characters in the movie.
  
  Suloksha and SEnthaamaRai too had good roles.
  
  This movie had great numbers from IR. Not to forget his BGM too. songs like "Aeri Karai PoongaatraE" and others are quite popular.
  
  Let us discuss on this different yet good love story !
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Tue Feb 6 7:05:30 2007.

  [Full View]

  MADDY wrote:

  (enna avtar change?? )

  
  
  Summaa thaaN.. I love Attagaasam Getup more than other getups of thala
  
  

• From: Nakeeran on Tue Feb 6 9:00:07 2007.

  [Full View]

  TNP , semey comedy padam !
  Super pick.
  
  I love the pen parkum scene when someone will comment about Bagyaraj's education .
  
  Maapla niraya padichirukaaaru
  PUC 4 varusam padichirukaru !!
  
  Nambiar made a handsome come back ( retired man requested to come again )
  
  

• From: Nakeeran on Tue Feb 6 9:03:11 2007.

  [Full View]

  Though all songs are super, I love Boopaalam isaikkum poomagal oorvalam.
  
  When Jesudas touches Irumanam ( bass guitar will be terrific ) . Uma Ramanan also sang well.
  
  2 more songs , Thanga changili minnum paingili and Yeri kara poongatre
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Tue Feb 6 9:05:54 2007.

  [Full View]

  Indeed Nakeeran. That "PeN PaaRkura" scene is a hilarious one.
  
  "Aemba ThoNa maappiLLai kootikittu Varathu oRu Latchanamaana paiyaNa kooti kittu vara koodaaathu"
  
  Bagyaraj oru muzhi muzhippaaru !
  
  

• From: Nerd on Tue Feb 6 12:29:14 2007.

  [Full View]

  The scenes after the peN parkkum padalam would be very entertaining as well. Bhagyaraj beating up nambiyar's men, sulokshana's friends teasing her are nice scenes indeed. But the movie gets a bit senti towards the end when bhagyaraj moves into nambiyar's house and when nambiyar dies etcc., The second half is actually not that good when compared to the first.
  
  Songs - Top class. My favorite is thangachangili minnum paingiLi
  
  

• From: vasanthgt on Fri Feb 9 2:23:24 2007.

  [Full View]

  In that film, Bhagyaraj will take his relative along with him to meet Sulochana.
  On seeing his relative combing his hair, Bhagyaraj will ask him to apply cycle oil in his face and then will take along wiht him
  Senthaamarai's old mother has done comedy sort of role in that film and this may be Manirathanm's inspiration of naughty grandma's in his film
  
  

• From: Amarshiva on Fri Feb 9 11:00:15 2007.

  [Full View]

  vasanthgt wrote:

  In that film, Bhagyaraj will take his relative along with him to meet Sulochana. On seeing his relative combing his hair, Bhagyaraj will ask him to apply cycle oil in his face and then will take along wiht him Senthaamarai's old mother has done comedy sort of role in that film and this may be Manirathanm's inspiration of naughty grandma's in his film

  
  
  Yes- that is for the second time i guess. First time both will sit in the chair and she will all praise the other actor and illtreat bagyaraj, who s the actually mapillay. You must see the reaction..good one though.. offcourse nambilar played a very vital role..songs.and senthamarai best supporting appa actor those days..(like vijayakumar these days.)..
  
  

• From: ssanjinika on Fri Feb 9 23:14:11 2007.

  [Full View]

  This is one cool movie. Very funny. One of Bagyaraj's better movies. Loved the ponnu paakara scene where he describes how the girl should be dressed. Very funny
  
  

• From: Scale on Mon Feb 12 4:21:30 2007.

  [Full View]

  seekirama adutha padatha podunga :handcuffed: by nambiar
  
  

• From: saradhaa_sn on Mon Feb 12 7:07:31 2007.

  [Full View]

  A nice movie to watch...
  
  Songs were good
  
  'thangachangili minnum paingiLi'
  'poobALam isaikkum poomagaL oorvalam'
  'thAlAtta nAn poRandhEn thAlE...thAlElO'
  'yErikkarai pUngAtrE'
  'En sOga kadhaiyai kELu thAi kulamE'
  
  Bagyaraj honoured Nambiyar's seniority by putting Nambiyar's name in the first and his name in the second, in the title. (This is the only movie I saw Nambiyar's name in the first of all).
  
  But we should accept, second half was little boring, comparing to first half.
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Tue Feb 13 9:19:37 2007.

  [Full View]

  ORU THALAI RAAGAM
  
  Yes. This is one movie which explained the one sided love affair beautifully. This one is from our TR ! Not to forget the songs from this movie and the excellant packaging. The portrayal of human emotions in this movie was sound and crisp !
  
  I don't have much to update on this movie since I watched this long time back. Let us hope our veterans fill more info on this one. Thanks to everyone who shared their comments on Thooral Ninnu pochu
  
  
  [quote'"behindwoods"]
  Timeless is the best word to describe the effectiveness of the title. The movie which dealt with love that goes unreciprocated is still considered the best citable example of ‘one side’ love; all thanks to the title. Even today when one comes across anyone whose love is not being returned, ‘Oru Thalai Raagam’ comes to mind.[/quote]
  
  

• From: Nakeeran on Tue Feb 13 9:36:34 2007.

  [Full View]

  Selva Sirrrrrrrrrrrr
  
  Enna ellam oldiesaa pidikireenga !
  
  I have heard the songs & all are superb
  
  I was told that this movie was a craze for college goers then
  
  My favourite is Koodayila karuvadu
  
  

• From: MADDY on Tue Feb 13 9:45:16 2007.

  [Full View]

  TR's music was outstanding in this movie..... .....this struck perfect chord with the youth of 80's............this was the first movie which talked abt towns/villages' college youth.........till then tamil films portrayed as if ,only chennai had college youth......
  
  TR's 1981 classic was a trend setter of its own kind.......with so many tragic love stories flooding the tamil hearts.......this movie had its unique breed of characters.....the drunkard chandrashekhar, the bell bottom "ching cha's".........it identifies the period.......wonder why we dont get such movies nowadays..... ....
  
  but one things for sure, if i wud directed this movie now, i would have ended the movie with hero giving a "middle finger" salute to the heroine......seriously, i feel so happy that guys are much more sensible,career-oriented,parents-obeying than those 80's punnakku raajas......that was surely a dark phase for boys with so many ppl. losing their lives in the name of love....
  
  but its a movie which will remain etched in ur memory for years to come....
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Tue Feb 13 9:51:12 2007.

  [Full View]

  Nakeeran wrote:

  Selva Sirrrrrrrrrrrr Enna ellam oldiesaa pidikireenga !

  
  
  Ofcourse Nakeeran sir. That is the purpose of this thread. We may get some information from other veterans on the movies. (some tidbits, extra news, etc )
  
  Even hubbers can also suggest some movies which can be discussed later on
  
  

• From: joe on Tue Feb 13 10:16:13 2007.

  [Full View]

  I hope many of the hubbers know that the director of the movie is not TR ,but Ibrahim (If my memory is right).
  
  There was no takers among the distributers for 'Oru Thalai Raagam' ,so TR released the movie in few towns like nagercoil .After few days word of mouth made this movie huge hit and later it released in other towns and cities.
  
  

• From: Hulkster on Tue Feb 13 10:18:36 2007.

  [Full View]

  Ibrahim Rowther who acted as villain in chinna gounder?
  
  

• From: joe on Tue Feb 13 10:31:20 2007.

  [Full View]

  Hulkster wrote:

  Ibrahim Rowther who acted as villain in chinna gounder?

  
  
  I didn't know Producer Ibrahim Rowther (Ex -Vijaya kanth friend) acted as villian in Chinna Gownder ..But He is not the Ibrahim ,director of Oru thalai ragam
  
  

• From: MADDY on Tue Feb 13 10:32:17 2007.

  [Full View]

  http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0334065/
  
  yes joe u r right.....it was some E.M.Ibrahim......i dunno y ppl call it a TR movie then???
  
  

• From: joe on Tue Feb 13 10:36:44 2007.

  [Full View]

  MADDY wrote:

  http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0334065/ yes joe u r right.....it was some E.M.Ibrahim......i dunno y ppl call it a TR movie then???

  
  
  It is first movie of TR as a MD and Lyricst ..and songs are the main reason for the success of the movie.
  
  Another small note .TR's wife Usha acted in this movie in a small role as heroins friend
  
  

• From: Nerd on Tue Feb 13 11:32:38 2007.

  [Full View]

  Superb choice selva
  
  One of the best titled movies ever. The movie has a gripping, very entertaining screenplay. The biggest plus of the movie is the songs. ALL the songs are fantastic even now. My favorites are:
  
  kadavuL vaazhum kOvililE
  vaasamillA malaridhu
  Ithu Kuzhanthai paadum thAlAttu (superb lyrics)
  
  Even the manmadhan ratchikkanum song is very good and I guess its the first of its kind Dialogs (by TR, I assume) were sharp and not very long, thankfully Chandrasekar was awesome, especially his talk in their farewell day (forgot the dialogs, but something with a rOjA). But the other actors were pathetic Cant blame them, their first movie
  
  And Joe I dont remember usha acting in it but TR has also acted in the movie. In the first scene itself - the college culturals. He will try to compere but the students will boo him out
  
  

• From: joe on Tue Feb 13 11:46:03 2007.

  [Full View]

  Nerd,
  I may be wrong in saying Usha acted in a role ,But I am sure Usha appeared one or two scenes atleast.
  
  Yes ,Golden lyrics from TR ..Still most of the lines are in my memory
  
  

• From: joe on Tue Feb 13 11:49:38 2007.

  [Full View]

  இது குழந்தை பாடும் தாலாட்டு
  இது இரவு நேர பூபாளம்
  இது மேற்கில் தோன்றும் உதயம்
  இது நதியில்லாத ஓடம்
  
  
  
  

• From: Nakeeran on Tue Feb 13 12:14:59 2007.

  [Full View]

  One more info.
  
  The MD title shows AA RAJ - RAJENDAR
  
  What happened to AA Raj ?? Did he compose any other movie ?
  
  

• From: thamiz on Tue Feb 13 14:55:00 2007.

  [Full View]

  nerd: usha rajender is the only friend of Subathra (rupa) 's in oru thalai raagm.
  
  She will propose to Raja-the hero- but he will turn her down as e fell in love with rupa who is usha's best friend!
  
  

• From: Nerd on Tue Feb 13 15:45:34 2007.

  [Full View]

  I never know that was usha.. she looked very different off-screen
  
  

• From: Kollywoodfan on Tue Feb 13 16:07:11 2007.

  [Full View]

  My dad always says that this was the only worth-while film of TR's and the music is also nice
  
  

• From: thamiz on Tue Feb 13 16:50:09 2007.

  [Full View]

  Nerd wrote:

  I never know that was usha.. she looked very different off-screen

  
  
  nerd: I have a dvd of oru thalai raagam. Trust me it is usha who is the friend of rupa.
  
  You are right, rajendran was the first one who sings Hindi song in the stage. When people make fun of him, he will say "hindi theriyumaa unakku?"
  
  kolly: oru thalai raagam and rayil payaNangkaLil are good movies of TR! Of course your dad is right, kolly!
  
  

• From: joe on Tue Feb 13 21:27:33 2007.

  [Full View]

  Thamizh,
  I wonder whether TR was just MD and Lyricst for 'Rayil Payanaggalil'..Is he the director of RP?
  
  

• From: joe on Tue Feb 13 21:30:17 2007.

  [Full View]

  TR used TMS for two songs in Oru thalai Raagam
  
  1.Naan oru Rasiyilla Raaja
  2.En kathai Mudiyum Neramithu
  
  

• From: NOV on Tue Feb 13 21:34:42 2007.

  [Full View]

  joe wrote:

  TR used TMS for two songs in Oru thalai Raagam 1.Naan oru Rasiyilla Raaja 2.En kathai Mudiyum Neramithu

  and till this day, TMS laments that these songs were the cause of his downfall...
  
  he blames TR totally for his downfall, and describes him in deragatory words!
  
  

• From: joe on Tue Feb 13 21:38:30 2007.

  [Full View]

  NOV wrote:

  joe wrote: TR used TMS for two songs in Oru thalai Raagam 1.Naan oru Rasiyilla Raaja 2.En kathai Mudiyum Neramithu and till this day, TMS laments that these songs were the cause of his downfall... he blames TR totally for his downfall, and describes him in deragatory words!

  
  
  Yeah! I heard TMS pulampifying that after 'Naanoru Raasiyilla Raaja' ,he lost the market ..But I wonder he sung "Amaithikku Peyar thaan santhi" in TR's next movie rayil Payanangalil
  
  

• From: NOV on Tue Feb 13 21:51:55 2007.

  [Full View]

  Yes Joe, but he didnt complain while he was singing for TR.
  It was only after....
  
  thatti paarththEn kottaankuchi was originally meant for TMS.
  
  

• From: joe on Tue Feb 13 22:01:29 2007.

  [Full View]

  Nov,
  TMS is a pulampal mannan . He must learn from Great MSV
  
  

• From: Sanguine Sridhar on Tue Feb 13 22:34:42 2007.

  [Full View]

  very good movie with some excellent songs! "Vaasam illa malaridhu vasandhathai thedudhu" , "Idhu kuzhandhai paadum thaalattu" are great songs!
  
  Ibrahim didn direct anyother movie other than this?
  
  

• From: Sinthiya on Wed Feb 14 0:13:12 2007.

  [Full View]

  I saw this movie on tv 3-4 months ago......
  ...it was good....nice songs....story is ok....
  
  

• From: MADDY on Wed Feb 14 0:47:46 2007.

  [Full View]

  Sinthiya wrote:

  I saw this movie on tv 3-4 months ago...... ...it was good....nice songs....story is ok....

  
  
  yes, you will feel its a bit unreal for today's circumstances.....come on, y shuld a guy kill/torture himself for not getting a girl?? ......for the guys of the 80's, it was a fashion to lose self respect for love........
  
  proposing to a girl and getting rejected is losing respect and is shameful....
  proposing to a girl who has already rejected and again getting rejected is losing self respect and is strictly punishable...
  
  this movie sometimes makes u feel very low on the level that this guy goes down to get his love.....
  
  

• From: Nerd on Wed Feb 14 11:28:46 2007.

  [Full View]

  But TR once said in an interview that he was bold enough to give such a song to TMS in his first escapade with him (naan oru raasiyillA rAjA)
  
  

• From: thamiz on Wed Feb 14 13:50:25 2007.

  [Full View]

  joe wrote:

  Thamizh, I wonder whether TR was just MD and Lyricst for 'Rayil Payanaggalil'..Is he the director of RP?

  
  joe; I have not seen rayil payaNangaLil recently. I thought it was TR's first official movie as a director. I could be wrong!
  
  If you have any doubts aobut oru thalai raagam credits, I can clarify now. I will try answer the questions regarding RP when I watch the dvd of that movie. I sure will remember your question and will get back to you!
  
  

• From: thamiz on Wed Feb 14 14:48:44 2007.

  [Full View]

  MADDY wrote:

  Sinthiya wrote: I saw this movie on tv 3-4 months ago...... ...it was good....nice songs....story is ok.... yes, you will feel its a bit unreal for today's circumstances.....come on, y shuld a guy kill/torture himself for not getting a girl?? .

  
  
  Not everybody understands everything, maddy!
  
  

• From: ssanjinika on Wed Feb 14 20:59:19 2007.

  [Full View]

  Hey,
  What is the story of Oru Thalai Raagam. Have not watched and going by the discussions it looks like it might be a good movie to watch.
  
  

• From: Surya on Wed Feb 14 21:25:41 2007.

  [Full View]

  College Boy Falls for College Girl. It doensn't work out, College boy decides to take the Highway to DEVDAS-ville.
  
  That's all i remember....
  
  Can someone elaborate pls...
  
  

• From: joe on Wed Feb 14 21:28:52 2007.

  [Full View]

  If I am not wrong, The hero and heroin never talk to each other in 'Oru thalai raagam' ..am I correct?
  
  

• From: Nerd on Wed Feb 14 22:36:04 2007.

  [Full View]

  i guess so too joe.. Its been atleast 4 years since I watched the movie.
  
  SS: Thats one heck of a movie. You may not like but definitely worth a watch. Superb songs/Bgm/lyrics and screenplay
  
  

• From: ssanjinika on Wed Feb 14 22:46:01 2007.

  [Full View]

  Nerd/Surya,
  I thought that was the story of Rail Payanangal. Isnt the song Santhi Santhi from that movie? In that also college boy and college girl love eachother but dont speak.College girl marries another guy and guy becomes devdas. ITs a pretty good movie too . Have I got the movie names mixed up?
  
  

• From: Nerd on Wed Feb 14 23:04:27 2007.

  [Full View]

  amaithikku peyar thAn santhi is from rayil payaNangaLil and i havent seen the movie i think. TR is pretty famous for his love failure movies and I guess he drew inspirations from oru thalai raagam. If you remember
  
  - lots of train scenes
  - chandrasekar who drinks everyda
  - a non-actor as a hero
  - a heroine who is very conservative with just one friend
  - climax in the train where the protoganist dies
  
  then you are talking about OTR
  
  

• From: joe on Wed Feb 14 23:07:23 2007.

  [Full View]

  Nerd,
  TR once said that most of the songs in Oru thalai Raagam were from his real life ,he used to sing these songs while train travelling.
  
  

• From: Nerd on Wed Feb 14 23:11:33 2007.

  [Full View]

  Thats news to me joe
  
  Actually TR has given 5-6 silver jubilees during the 80s. Thats no mean achievement
  
  Also during that period (IR's peak, actually) his music was very popular as well..
  
  Its indeed saddening to see people ridiculing him these days, without knowing his talents. Having said that, his inane movies off late is not doing any good
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Wed Feb 14 23:16:41 2007.

  [Full View]

  wowwww It is nice to see lot of information on this movie and TR !
  
  TR is not the director of this movie Thanks for the info Joe ! I didn't know this one before !
  
  Nerd - Thanks Seems you like TR's old movies a lot ! btw, I think his music was different and he had his own style then. That is why he was able to ride the wave which was dominated by IR and others during that period. I loved his "Monisha eN Monalisa". Athukkapuram
  
  

• From: Sanguine Sridhar on Wed Feb 14 23:17:07 2007.

  [Full View]

  Thats true Nerd, he studied at Annamalai University(Chidambaram).He used to travel from Chidambaram to Mayiladuthurai(his native) through train, while traveling he will sing it seems
  
  Btw..you know guys, he will be the host for 'Arattai Arangam' from this week!!
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Wed Feb 14 23:22:04 2007.

  [Full View]

  Sanguine Sridhar wrote:

  Btw..you know guys, he will be the host for 'Arattai Arangam' from this week!!

  
  
  Is it I think the show will become popular immediately ! KannungaLa idukaagavaavathu TAMIL CHANNELS ah marupadiyum telecast pannuga, Bangalore La !
  
  

• From: Nerd on Wed Feb 14 23:27:57 2007.

  [Full View]

  See becks thats what I was trying to imply. Most of you guys are hellbent on ridiculing him. I am a big big fan of his music + lyrics. Of course just 10 odd movies not more that. selva, i am a fan of his music and not his movies. Out of all TR associated movies, OTR is the best easily. In fact i have not seen many TR movies. But his music + lyrics is pretty impressive. Even in the movies in which he did just that, the songs are awesome - pookkaLai paRikkathIrgaL, kiLinjalgaL (another pretty good movie, a deserving candidate for movie of the week)
  
  Anyway end digressions
  
  

• From: Sanguine Sridhar on Wed Feb 14 23:33:39 2007.

  [Full View]

  maams! ippo yaaru TR songs\lyrics pidikaadhu-nu sonnadhu? Even I like his songs very few has his talents.But as far as "Aratai Arangam" he is not the perfect host! He wont allow others to talk.Lets see how it is.
  
  

• From: joe on Wed Feb 14 23:33:56 2007.

  [Full View]

  Nerd,
  Me too a fan of his lyrics..I mentioned this many times in TR thread.As you told ,once TR songs are very very popular .I don't know what happened to him after Mythili ennai kaathali.
  
  Few examples of his excellent Lyrics
  
  From Rayil payanangalil
  
  பூத்தால் மலரும் உதிரும்
  நெஞ்சில் பூத்தாள் உதிரவில்லை
  நிலவும் தேய்ந்து வளரும்
  அவள் நினைவோ தேய்வதில்லை.
  
  One from Maithili ennai kaathali
  
  தடாகத்தில் மீன் ரெண்டு
  காமத்தில் தடுமாறி
  தாமரைப் பூ மீது விழுந்தனவோ
  இதைக்கண்ட வேகத்தில்
  பிரம்மனும் மோகத்தில்
  படைத்திட்ட பாகம் தான் உன் கண்களோ
  
  

• From: Thirumaran on Wed Feb 14 23:36:59 2007.

  [Full View]

  joe wrote:

  Nerd, I may be wrong in saying Usha acted in a role ,But I am sure Usha appeared one or two scenes atleast. Yes ,Golden lyrics from TR ..Still most of the lines are in my memory

  
  
  Yes JOE. It was Usha who acted as heroine's friend in the movie. Needless to say Music and Lyrics were Top class
  
  

• From: Nerd on Wed Feb 14 23:37:52 2007.

  [Full View]

  Sanguine Sridhar wrote:

  maams! ippo yaaru TR songs\lyrics pidikaadhu-nu sonnadhu? Even I like his songs very few has his talents.But as far as "Aratai Arangam" he is not the perfect host! He wont allow others to talk.Lets see how it is.

  
  
  becks, i am blaming TR here.. His gimmicks these days are so bad that it has made people forget the good things that he has done in the 80s. Very sad indeed.
  
  These days i just see people ridiculing him everywhere in the internet, not even one guy to appreciate his talents. That guy is sure talented, but has wasted everything, unfortunately
  
  

• From: Sanguine Sridhar on Wed Feb 14 23:41:19 2007.

  [Full View]

  I think he is doing this purposefully for publicity! Forget TR..Simbhu belongs to this generation he can advice his dad to stop giving movie like 'veerasaamy' right?
  
  Anyways end dig!
  
  

• From: joe on Wed Feb 14 23:41:19 2007.

  [Full View]

  //Dig..
  
  Nerd,Neenga Vera ..NT -yave kindal pannuranga ippa ullavanga..TR emmaathiram.
  
  dig//
  
  

• From: Nerd on Wed Feb 14 23:45:08 2007.

  [Full View]

  joe: The problem is I have not seen even a SINGLE person appreciating TR's talents
  
  becks: kELvi kEttuttu end digression ah anyway simbu does not even have 10% talents as that of his dad, IMHO. His vallavan is as bad as his dad's monisha..
  
  selva: sorry mate, hopefully we will get back to OTR
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Wed Feb 14 23:47:15 2007.

  [Full View]

  Nerd,
  Rightly put ! I like TR for the movies that he gave in the past (his early days). I also like his lyrics and music IF not all his movies. Must say - He is too good in giving "love failure" movies. Most of the heroines in his movies will be ordinary and yet the guy will fall for her Except MaithiLi ennai kaathaLi (heroine was Amala), most of the heroines of his early movies were like "girl next door". Oflate, many ridicule him for "N" other reasons IF not his lyrics and music ! Even Veerasaamy music was not ridiculed that much I believe
  
  Did TR wrote lyrics for "Oru thalai raagam" or it was someone else?
  
  

• From: joe on Wed Feb 14 23:50:20 2007.

  [Full View]

  Back to OTR...
  
  Even though the movie is tragedy and serious love story ,two of the songs are different
  
  1.Koodayila karuvaadu -teasing song
  
  2.Manmathan radchikkanum intha mangaiyar kaalaigalae - another teasing song ,very very famous then.
  
  

• From: joe on Wed Feb 14 23:52:18 2007.

  [Full View]

  selvakumar wrote:

  Did TR wrote lyrics for "Oru thalai raagam" or it was someone else?

  
  
  Enna selva ippadi kettuteenga ..TR wrote all songs and did music and I am not sure about dialogues also.
  
  

• From: Nerd on Wed Feb 14 23:56:44 2007.

  [Full View]

  I guess thamiz can help us with this since thamiz owns the DVD. AFAIK, TR penned OTR's story, screenplay and dialogs along with songs
  
  

• From: joe on Thu Feb 15 0:00:23 2007.

  [Full View]

  Nerd,
  Is the heroin same who acted in 'Puthu Kavithai' with rajini?
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Thu Feb 15 0:03:01 2007.

  [Full View]

  Joe,
  Unless we have a DVD or VCD copy we can never confirm these things. First, I thought this movie was directed by TR himself Never knew about Ibrahim then !
  
  That is why I was a bit skeptical. This is what happened with Iruvar as well for me. I thought MR wrote the dialogues. But in the movie, the credit for the same goes to Suhaashini !
  
  

• From: Nerd on Thu Feb 15 0:04:32 2007.

  [Full View]

  I don't think so Joe. Puthukavithai's heroine was jyothi and I guess she has not acted in any movie other than PK. Also I guess OTR's heroine(sarithA) acted in rayil payaNangaLil/UyiruLLavarai ushA. I am not very sure
  
  

• From: joe on Thu Feb 15 0:05:41 2007.

  [Full View]

  selvakumar wrote:

  Joe, Unless we have a DVD or VCD copy we can never confirm these things. First, I thought this movie was directed by TR himself Never knew about Ibrahim then ! That is why I was a bit skeptical. This is what happened with Iruvar as well for me. I thought MR wrote the dialogues. But in the movie, the credit for the same goes to Suhaashini !

  
  
  I agree .It is just like How many people know MD of Vazhve Mayam is Gangai Amaran ,not IR.
  
  But here Oru thalai Raagam songs are known as TR songs .Most know this.
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Thu Feb 15 0:08:13 2007.

  [Full View]

  Thanks for the info Joe !
  
  

• From: ssanjinika on Thu Feb 15 0:30:42 2007.

  [Full View]

  selvakumar wrote:

  Nerd, Rightly put ! I like TR for the movies that he gave in the past (his early days). I also like his lyrics and music IF not all his movies. Must say - He is too good in giving "love failure" movies. Most of the heroines in his movies will be ordinary and yet the guy will fall for her Except MaithiLi ennai kaathaLi (heroine was Amala), most of the heroines of his early movies were like "girl next door". Oflate, many ridicule him for "N" other reasons IF not his lyrics and music ! Even Veerasaamy music was not ridiculed that much I believe Did TR wrote lyrics for "Oru thalai raagam" or it was someone else?

  
  
  <Cont dig>
  Mythili en Kaadhali-la though heroine was amala the hero(TR ie) will be in love with someone else who def didnt look like heroine mat to me .
  <end dig>
  
  

• From: NOV on Thu Feb 15 0:35:00 2007.

  [Full View]

  hmmmm... some serious misinformation....
  
  
  ibrahim was the producer not the director of OTR
  directors were Robert Rajasekhar
  
  the actress in OTR is Roopa who was paired opposite Shankar
  
  
  the peculiarity of the songs were that there were no duets - all male voices only:
  
  vaasamillaa malaridhu vasanthaththai thEdudhu - SP Bala
  idhu kuzhandhai paadum paattu - SP Bala
  kadavul vaazhum kOvililE - Jayachandran
  koodaiyila karuvaadu - Malaysia Vasudevan
  en kathai mudiyum nEram idhu - TMS
  naan oru raasi illa raaja - TMS
  manmadhan ratchikkanum- Jolly Abraham
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Thu Feb 15 0:44:07 2007.

  [Full View]

  NOV,
  Ibrahim um director kedaiyaatha Thanks for the update. Innum ethanai director peyar uLLa vara poguthoE
  
  Sandya, Yes !! YOu are right ! TR will be in love with another girl IF not Amala !
  
  

• From: joe on Thu Feb 15 1:30:34 2007.

  [Full View]

  NOV,
  I am sure Ebrahim was the director of OTR ,not Robert raja sekar
  
  See here
  http://www.explorefree.com/popup_image.php?pID=597
  
  No Rober _rajasekar name there.
  
  Rober_rajaSekar were directors of 'Paalaivana Cholai' ,which had the song "Pownami Neram paavaiyoruththi'
  
  

• From: NOV on Thu Feb 15 2:56:23 2007.

  [Full View]

  But actor Chandrasekar says otherwise.
  
  http://72.14.235.104/search?q=cache:jQ8C8znwqDQJ:www.hindu.com/2006/11/30/stories/2006113014390200.htm+oru+thalai+ragam&hl=en&ct=clnk&cd=13
  
  anyway Joe, the fact remains that OTR is largely a TR film.
  Didnt it run for a year?
  
  

• From: joe on Thu Feb 15 3:12:48 2007.

  [Full View]

  NOV wrote:

  But actor Chandrasekar says otherwise. http://72.14.235.104/search?q=cache:jQ8C8znwqDQJ:www.hindu.com/2006/11/30/stories/2006113014390200.htm+oru+thalai+ragam&hl=en&ct=clnk&cd=13 anyway Joe, the fact remains that OTR is largely a TR film. Didnt it run for a year?

  
  
  I hope that they wrote wrong 'Oru Thalai Raagam' instead of 'Paalaivana cholai'.
  
  Yes! OTR ran for 365 days.
  
  

• From: thamiz on Thu Feb 15 12:18:56 2007.

  [Full View]

  Nerd wrote:

  I don't think so Joe. Puthukavithai's heroine was jyothi and I guess she has not acted in any movie other than PK. Also I guess OTR's heroine(sarithA) acted in rayil payaNangaLil/UyiruLLavarai ushA. I am not very sure

  
  
  You are correct, nerd.
  
  Rupa -oru thalai raagam
  
  jOthi_ puthu kavithai (rayil payaNangkaLil heroine)
  
  

• From: Amarshiva on Thu Feb 15 16:07:14 2007.

  [Full View]

  Yes tamiz..you are right.. Oru thalai ragam.. mixed with bunch of good songs and college galata and good stuff..
  
  Very nice TR movie. Infact, it will apply to alltime college goers. Though not a TR fan, I really liked the movie. Especially the songs" Kaduval vazum "
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Tue Feb 20 7:42:47 2007.

  [Full View]

  Sorry for the delay friends.
  Here is the pick of this week. A really different movie.
  
  VEEDU
  
  Director: Balu Mahendra
  Music : ILaya Raja
  Cast: Banu Chandar, Archana, M.A.Chokkalinga Bhagavathar
  year: 1988
  
  

  Quote:

  One of the few films that Balu Mahendra can be proud of. Archana won a national award for best actress (deservedly so) for playing a middle-class working woman in this songless movie (BGM is Ilayaraja's How to Name It). Well-made and realistic, worth watching. Don't expect any song-and-dance routines.

  
  
  

  Quote:

  * Balu Mahendra's Veedu deals with Housing a major problem faced by urban middle-class Indian. This film is a striking departure from the earlier works of Balu Mahendra..Balu Mahendra as his own cinematographer has made the film very visual. * Sudha, a clerk in Chennai lives with her sister and her grandfather, a retired music teacher.Her friends advice her to build her own house.When she starts on this venture, she runs into numerous hurdles.Helped by her colleague and friend Gopi she goes from one office to another trying to get the project going.As the house is nearing completion , her grandfather dies and the Metropolitan Water Authority appropriates the house.The film ends with Sudha seeking justice in a Court of Law. * Archana acted in the role of Sudha, the harassed clerk.Her portrayal won her the National Award for the Best Actress.Another striking feature of the film was the portrayal of the grandfather by M.A.Chokkalinga Bhagavathar, a one-time drama artiste. * Another interesting feature of the film was that it did not have any songs. The background music was scored by Illayaraja.The background music blends well with the movie.The major part of the background music was extracted from Illayaraja's music album How to name it

  
  

• From: MADDY on Tue Feb 20 10:03:30 2007.

  [Full View]

  
  
  i have never seen a worser depressing movie than this in my life.........wat a slow,negative,depressing,false movie.....i call it false bcos, around the same time, my parents (then a lower middle class couple) built a house in chennai and trust me, they didnt face any such problems..........just to make it sad, u shuldnt manipulate truth and facts.........who told art movies should be sad only??
  
  anyways, i havent watched a balumahendra movie since this one........ofcourse sathileelavathi for kamal's antics........ ......
  
  sorry selva, u started off with positive movie and now scaling new depths of negative movies..... .......
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Tue Feb 20 10:22:27 2007.

  [Full View]

  Maddy,
  You need positive movies. Right ? Then you can recommend the same. I will include them in the upcoming weeks.
  
  The whole purpose of this thread is to "To enable users to come up with movies which they want to discuss with others. Unfortunately, it is only me who is posting the info on movies so that a movie can be discussed
  
  Next time : You can come up with some movies which u like !
  
  

• From: raaja_rasigan on Tue Feb 20 10:31:51 2007.

  [Full View]

  selvakumar wrote:

  Maddy, You need positive movies. Right ? Then you can recommend the same. I will include them in the upcoming weeks. The whole purpose of this thread is to "To enable users to come up with movies which they want to discuss with others. Unfortunately, it is only me who is posting the info on movies so that a movie can be discussed Next time : You can come up with some movies which u like !

  
  
  i recommend k.bagyaraj's "indru poi naalai vaa"
  
  comedy unlimited... only the 2nd half is a bit boring
  
  

• From: raaja_rasigan on Tue Feb 20 10:35:22 2007.

  [Full View]

  to be frank, yedhaartha vazhkayil ellorum jeippadhillai......
  
  not everyone becomes multimillionaire in a single song (like in rajini films)..
  
  thatz y some people tend to make films like veedu, nizhalgal etc. with -ve ending... (i dont remember veedu as it will be shown only in DD)
  
  

• From: MADDY on Tue Feb 20 10:35:30 2007.

  [Full View]

  selvakumar wrote:

  Maddy, You need positive movies. Right ? Then you can recommend the same. I will include them in the upcoming weeks.

  
  
  sure......next week - kadhalikka neramillai......my request.....
  
  

• From: kannannn on Tue Feb 20 11:05:28 2007.

  [Full View]

  Selva, great choice. Veedu is one of my favourite movies. It's been a long time since I watched it, but let me write what I think of it.
  

  MADDY wrote:

  i have never seen a worser depressing movie than this in my life.........wat a slow,negative,depressing,false movie.....i call it false bcos, around the same time, my parents (then a lower middle class couple) built a house in chennai and trust me, they didnt face any such problems..........just to make it sad, u shuldnt manipulate truth and facts.........

  
  Strongly disagree. Economic and social standings vary from family to family - even among middle classes. Suburbs like Thambaram, Velachery came up just so that middle class families can build a house. In late 80's and early 90's you could see half built houses standing there for years on end, while their owner's completed the work in stages, whenever they got the money.
  
  The protagonist in the movie had to struggle all alone in her quest to build a house. And the movie is not just a statement on the her efforts to get a house of her own and can be seen as a commentary on different aspects of today's life. It speaks about the importance of working women in today's society. It talks about the place society has accorded to the older generation and their anguishes (which Balu Mahendra later explored in 'Sandhya Raagam'). Beyond all, it hails today's woman as a strong and central figure in her family.
  
  As in any BM movie, it is the camera that catches our attention in this one too. But for a different reason. If I remember right, there are long shots (uncharacteristic of BM) abound in this movie, especially the ones showing the locality on which the house is built. Ofcourse, Illayaraja's BGM requires special mention. A particular scene has Chokalinga Bhagavadar stepping into the house (first he places his left foot, which he immediately retracts and then places his trembling right foot). As he enters the house Illayaraja's BGM takes over, merging the viewer into the scene, making us go through the same emotions as the old man.
  
  

• From: thinkfloyd on Tue Feb 20 15:20:49 2007.

  [Full View]

  Thanks Selva for mentioning a great movie from the great BM.
  
  Archana gave a top-class performance.
  
  Yes, Kannan, it was a superb commentary on the issues you have mentioned. By long shots do you mean long takes (time) or distance?
  
  

• From: Nerd on Tue Feb 20 15:42:13 2007.

  [Full View]

  Veedu has realism written all over it. Almost 80% of the middle/lower-middle class people would have faced such problems and thats BM's best movie, easily. Haven't seen veedu in years though
  
  His kathai nEram is the best TV series ever barring a few episodes. Again realistic to the core. Thats his strenght, realistic portrayal of simple real-life incidents.
  
  

• From: bingleguy on Tue Feb 20 15:56:58 2007.

  [Full View]

  VEedu ..... excellent portrayal of a middle-class problem .....
  
  the movie was a slow mover though .... having no songs did not feel up as with good bg by IR .....
  
  Many ppl referred this movie as a documentary ... which was the name given to slow movers with much of non-entertainment factors .... ! but this movie really did stand out in all those ..... and proved artistical value of an art movie ....
  
  Archana did a commending role in the movie.... and CB too CB later appeared in Gentleman, Sathi Leelavathi and more movies .... where his performance in Veedu and Sathi Leelavathi were leading ones ......
  
  Good Choice Selva
  
  

• From: Movie Cop on Tue Feb 20 16:00:48 2007.

  [Full View]

  thinkfloyd wrote:

  Thanks Selva for mentioning a great movie from the great BM. Archana gave a top-class performance.

  
  Veedu is one of my all time favourite movie! The movie was a very well made one. Archana apart, CB who acted as father of Archana also gave a spectacular performance!
  The scene where her father will catch a bus and visit his daughter's house(still under construction) is very touching!
  When he feelingly touches the bricks on the wall - listen to the background music from IR; it's sheer symphony! IR's background music infused lot of "life" into the scenes that did not have any dialogues! One of the finest movies ever made in Tamil cinema Glad to see folks are discussing about this classic from BM! Carry on guys!
  
  

• From: kb on Tue Feb 20 16:21:56 2007.

  [Full View]

  intha padam mattum marakave mudiyaathu.. naan serial ninachi paathukittu irrundhaen.. 1/2 hr mudiyum..1/2hr la mudiyum-nu
  
  oru thaatha nadaka aaramitchaaru.. vaadaga veetla irrundhu pudhu veetuku pora varaikum.. camera avaru pinnadiya eduthukittu ponaanga. paava avaruku vayasaaiyudchi.. methuva thaan ponaaru
  
  

• From: kannannn on Tue Feb 20 19:55:38 2007.

  [Full View]

  thinkfloyd wrote:

  By long shots do you mean long takes (time) or distance?

  
  I meant the distance. BM for some reason seems to be comfortable with medium shots and close ups. But from what I remember, Veedu had many long distance shots of the house with respect to where it is located (outskirts with some other houses coming up) - perhaps a concious attempt to show that the family is not alone in the dream of owning a house?
  
  Coming to think of it, the takes were long in the sense of time too. BM usually gets out of the scene quickly (without feeding the voyeur in the viewer). However, Veedu stands out in contrast. Long takes (in time) was very popular in the new wave that was embraced by Kannada and Malayalam cinema of the 70's. BM probably wanted to introduce that in Tamil too in Veedu.
  
  

• From: joe on Wed Feb 21 0:07:27 2007.

  [Full View]

  Nerd wrote:

  Veedu has realism written all over it. Almost 80% of the middle/lower-middle class people would have faced such problems and thats BM's best movie, easily. Haven't seen veedu in years though His kathai nEram is the best TV series ever barring a few episodes. Again realistic to the core. Thats his strenght, realistic portrayal of simple real-life incidents.

  
  
  Completely my views too
  
  

• From: NOV on Wed Feb 21 2:43:37 2007.

  [Full View]

  Movie Cop wrote:

  When he feelingly touches the bricks on the wall - listen to the background music from IR; it's sheer symphony! IR's background music infused lot of "life" into the scenes that did not have any dialogues!

  interestingly IR did not score any BGM for the movie.
  the BGM was entirely from IR's How to name it and Nothing but wind orchestral albums.
  
  

• From: great on Wed Feb 21 12:58:45 2007.

  [Full View]

  Next Pick kandippa Salangai Oli , ippaiyae thundu pottu vechutean
  
  

• From: vasanthgt on Thu Feb 22 4:00:13 2007.

  [Full View]

  Raja's BGM will be extra - ordinary
  
  

• From: Aandavan on Thu Feb 22 4:04:19 2007.

  [Full View]

  great wrote:

  Next Pick kandippa Salangai Oli , ippaiyae thundu pottu vechutean

  THe Best Performance BY Nammavar
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Mon Feb 26 3:00:55 2007.

  [Full View]

  Thanks a lot friends for sharing your views on "Veedu"
  Kannan - Your information on "Long shots" being used in the movie was very informative
  
  I request our dear friends to PM me the movie which they want to be discussed in this thread.
  
  Please note that the movies won't be listed in the order I receive the messages. I will be randomly picking them and will be listing them in this thread so that all the movies will be equally placed w.r.t each other.
  
  Seeking your support on the same. Thanks a lot once again friends !
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Tue Feb 27 1:48:58 2007.

  [Full View]

  Title : Kaathalika Neramillai (Eastman Colour)
  
  Pick from our hubber "MADDY"
  
  Highlights : This is a highly successful full length comedy. Ravichandran and Muthuraman plan to marry Baalaiya's daughters Kanchana and and Rajashree. Renowned for it's ground breaking songs and for making Viswanathan Vaelai Vendum song famous. Ravichandran's first movie. Entertaining comedy by Nagesh and Sachu, including a dance by this famous duo.
  
  Cast : Muthuraman, Ravichandran, Kaanchana, Rajashree, Balaiya, Nagesh, Sachu
  
  Story, Dialogue : Sri Thar, Gopu
  
  Director : Sri Thar
  
  Producer : Chithralaya
  
  Music : Viswanathan, Rama Moorthy
  
  Lyrics : Kavingar Kannathasan, assistance - Panchu Arunasalam
  
  Songs : P B Sreenivas, P Susila, Seer Kaazhi Govindarajan, L R Eswari, Jesudass, Rajee
  
  

• From: joe on Tue Feb 27 1:58:31 2007.

  [Full View]

  Kaathalikka Neramillai -One of All time best classic comedies.
  
  The one and only Nagesh and great actor Balaih rock
  
  Director of the most serious movie 'Nenjil oru Alayam' and and director of most hilarious movie 'Kathalikka Neramilai" is same ..It tells How a director could be versatile like Sreedar.
  
  

• From: Sanguine Sridhar on Tue Feb 27 2:14:30 2007.

  [Full View]

  Kaadhalikka Neramillai excellent classic!
  
  First of all, colour of the movie is so true!!
  
  I will add up my comments about this movie later.
  
  
  Sridhar - his hands and legs are paralyzed now
  
  What a great man, he is unable to speak,walk properly. They showed it in DD-Podhigai!
  
  He was trying to speak something,but it was not clear!
  
  Idhu thaan vaazhkayao?
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Tue Feb 27 2:23:53 2007.

  [Full View]

  One thing which I liked in this movie was :
  
  It was a complete package with brilliant comedy and good songs.
  IF you take away the songs, then the movie will look ordinarly. The same applies for the comedy sequences also. Everyone had equal share.
  
  Nagesh timing will be awesome so do Balaiya's body language and expressions.
  
  Sisters: OhhHoo Productions ahh ? ennada idhu peru
  Nagesh: Idhaa naaN ungaLUkkaaga VAikaLa, enakkaa vachathu.
  
  
  

• From: hi on Tue Feb 27 2:37:00 2007.

  [Full View]

  I hve this movie CD.. i wont feel bored if i watch it n..number of times..
  
  Songs are good too
  
  Esp the scene where Nagesh teach saachu( i guess it's correct )
  
  Nagesh - "idhu kaadhal parvaya.. ?thirutu parvai"
  saachu- "Sir ungae mooncha patha enaku indhaey parvai dhan varudhu
  
  

• From: kb on Tue Feb 27 3:32:09 2007.

  [Full View]

  super movie.. balayya body language TOP-pu..
  
  nagesh- story telling scene..
  
  and with sachchu.. yo padam edukara padam edukara sollikittu thaan iruka.. oru photo naachi eduthaiya ya
  
  

• From: MADDY on Tue Feb 27 3:49:08 2007.

  [Full View]

  kb wrote:

  super movie.. balayya body language TOP-pu.. nagesh- story telling scene.. and with sachchu.. yo padam edukara padam edukara sollikittu thaan iruka.. oru photo naachi eduthaiya ya

  
  
  thats my fav dialogue too
  
  one more -
  
  Balayya to muthuraman after knowing Ravichandran is a rich boy
  
  "andha asokar unga magar-ungala"??
  
  full length comedy from a intense director like Sridhar......and wow, what camera angles in some scenes....... ......this guy is a genius director.........ivar allavo "Iyakkunar sigaram"..... ...
  
  music - path breaking from MSV-TKR...... .....all in all a complete entertainer without any masala elements.....
  
  

• From: pavalamani pragasam on Tue Feb 27 5:45:38 2007.

  [Full View]

  The movie was the craze of college students when it was released; they didn't keep count of how many times they viewed the movie!( I have a classic example in our home!). Dialogues are highly realistic, the humour very natural. Very ingenious job from Sridhar & all the artistes, old & new. When we recently visited Aziyar dam where some of the scenes were shot my hubby went into raptures reciting word by word each dialogue & scene. BTW, he knows the whole script by heart! Such pure comedy has become a rarity now! ALL songs are superb! 'anupavam puthumai' was a hot favourite of the teens of those times- lyric & music make the song a feast UNLIKE the lewd LOVE songs that keep jarring my ears today! The naivety of the dialogue, expression & theme is simply marvellous. To sum up, the movie is a CLASSIC!
  
  

• From: joe on Tue Feb 27 5:56:49 2007.

  [Full View]

  I don't know why selva put "KaathaLikka NeraMiLLai" instead of "Kaathalikka Neramillai" .it is not காதளிக்க நேரமிள்ளை.
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Tue Feb 27 6:01:49 2007.

  [Full View]

  Joe, I hope you will be happy now
  
  

• From: pavalamani pragasam on Tue Feb 27 6:02:11 2007.

  [Full View]

  ¸¡¾Ä¢ì¸ §¿ÃÁ¢ø¨Ä- kaathalikka nEramillai.
  
  

• From: joe on Tue Feb 27 6:06:18 2007.

  [Full View]

  selvakumar wrote:

  Joe, I hope you will be happy now

  
  
  
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Tue Feb 27 6:08:33 2007.

  [Full View]

  pavalamani pragasam wrote:

  ¸¡¾Ä¢ì¸ §¿ÃÁ¢ø¨Ä- kaathalikka nEramillai.

  
  
  Aaahaaa !! Thanks PP Madam !
  
  

• From: pavalamani pragasam on Tue Feb 27 6:18:57 2007.

  [Full View]

  
  
  

• From: Nakeeran on Tue Feb 27 6:25:00 2007.

  [Full View]

  joe wrote:

  I don't know why selva put "KaathaLikka NeraMiLLai" instead of "Kaathalikka Neramillai" .it is not காதளிக்க நேரமிள்ளை.

  
  
  Ayya Tamil kudimagan Joe Avargale
  
  Evvalavu pizai irukiradho adharku thagundhapadi adjust seidhu kollungal
  
  KN is IMO, THE BEST EVER COMEDY MOVIE till date .
  May be MMKR will come closer to it .
  
  One scene I quickly recollect :
  
  Balaiya trying to meet Muthuraman in his guest house .
  While entering, he gets stopped by his own watchman
  
  Watchman : Ayya ulle pogandheenga
  Balaiya : Endaa pogakoodadhu
  Watchman : Ayya dhaan sonnaaru
  Balaiya : Dei. ovvoru maasamum naan dhaanda unakku sambalam tharravan ( with a pitiable look )
  
  Scene 2 :
  Rajashree screams to Balaiyaa and complains about Ravichandran .
  
  RS : Appa naan udane poi andha aalaa oru vazi pannanum. Avaru kitte poi sanda podanum
  Balaiyaa : Vendaaaammmmmmmaa... Nee ange ponaa KADHAYE VERA VIDHAMA MAARIDUM .
  
  Scene 3 :
  Balaiyaa : Dei Chelapaa. Unga pedhadhukku naan ennai serupaala adikanum. serupala adikanum
  Nagesh : Appo naan enna seiradhu
  B : naa adicha serupaalaa neeyuum adichikooooooooooo
  
  EACH AND EVERY DIALOGUE IN THIS MOVIE IS WITH COMEDY
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Tue Feb 27 6:29:44 2007.

  [Full View]

  PP Madam,
  That was an excellant compilation on the movie. It just make us feel as if we were there during that time
  
  

  pavalamani pragasam wrote:

  The movie was the craze of college students when it was released; they didn't keep count of how many times they viewed the movie!( I have a classic example in our home!).

  
  
  BTW, I heard that they advertised this movie with the slogan "Kathaiyai ethirpaarthu VaraatheergaL" (something similar to this) Is this true?
  
  

• From: pavalamani pragasam on Tue Feb 27 6:34:32 2007.

  [Full View]

  Can't remember!
  
  In those days radio was an important entertainment & KN's full sound track was a frequent repetition to our glee!
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Tue Feb 27 6:47:55 2007.

  [Full View]

  pavalamani pragasam wrote:

  Can't remember! In those days radio was an important entertainment & KN's full sound track was a frequent repetition to our glee!

  
  
  Ya.. Songs are a BIG PLUS in this movie. Whenever the comedy pours in continously, songs provided the needed difference.
  
  In the song "Kaathalikka Neramillai, Kaathalippaar Yaarumillai", I felt the male voice didn't suit "Muthu Raman".
  
  

• From: Nakeeran on Tue Feb 27 6:55:02 2007.

  [Full View]

  Selva Sir
  
  Title song was by Seergazi Govindarajan.
  
  I believe Sridhar gave 2 options to MSV .
  
  Either chose a comedy subject ( Sridhar was confident that the movie will be a super hit 0
  
  Another, experimental movie - kalaikovil which Sridhar felt may not be that successful
  
  MSV chose the latter and burnt his fingers.
  
  KN is one of the best albums of MSV-TKR and tamil cinema itself.
  
  Listen to ANUBAVAM PUDHUMAI song
  
  

• From: Designer on Tue Feb 27 6:57:10 2007.

  [Full View]

  My favorite scene is where Nagesh tells the story to Balayya - the expressions and body language of both was superb, such a hilarious scene with nice comedy timing
  
  btw, this film was remade in Hindi, with Kishore Kumar (I think) doing Nagesh's role, and Om Prakash for Balayya. But I didnt find it as enjoyable as 'KN'
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Tue Feb 27 6:59:25 2007.

  [Full View]

  Thanks for the information Nakeeran sir !
  I have a DVD copy of this movie I like the songs in this movie. Yes. "anupavam pudhumai" is a superb melody.
  
  

• From: Thirumaran on Tue Feb 27 7:04:31 2007.

  [Full View]

  MADDY wrote:

  full length comedy from a intense director like Sridhar......

  
  
  
  Cant say that. Even in his first movie Kalyana Parisu the comedy track was excellent.
  
  

• From: Nakeeran on Tue Feb 27 7:07:12 2007.

  [Full View]

  Digression :
  
  I have alse seen OOty varai uravu ( another 100 %comedy movie by Sridhar )
  
  But Nagesh's comedy was mediocre / average when compared to Kadhalikka N.
  But Balaiyaa was superb in both !
  
  

• From: kannannn on Tue Feb 27 8:04:25 2007.

  [Full View]

  Again, superb choice for the week . From one of my favourite directors. Though I don't agree with Nakeeran's ranking, it is true that KN is right up there with MMKR. Sridhar proved yet again why he was the best of the era. Everything about the movie is great. Songs, screenplay, direction and dialogues. My favourite is of course "Unga ponnana kaigal" (sexist, but still I love the tune). Balaiyya and Nagesh come out tops. However, Sachu's character is usually underrated. Her comic timing is excellent and matched Nagesh scene for scene. And, did I mention she was beautiful?! More later..
  
  

• From: ksen on Tue Feb 27 8:25:36 2007.

  [Full View]

  Designer wrote:

  My favorite scene is where Nagesh tells the story to Balayya - the expressions and body language of both was superb, such a hilarious scene with nice comedy timing

  
  
  Theatrela paakkum pOdhu indha scenela enna dialoguennE yaarukkum kEkkaadhu - avvalavu saththam TV / CDla paathappuramthaan fullaa purinjudhu
  
  I love Nagesh and Sachu dancing 'malar endra mugam ondru sirikkattum' - way beyond times Sachu is so cute in this movie! 'Outdoor ellaam enga Sir, Ootythaane - enga - Ooty - indha saakkula Ooty suthi paakkalaamnu nenaikkuriyaa, poora padathaiyum indha kaatiladhaan edukka pOren' Sachu's expression is superb
  
  The titles itself was great, - the way the cartoon changes into the real car - so advanced and delightful
  
  

• From: Shakthiprabha on Tue Feb 27 10:41:13 2007.

  [Full View]

  Nice thread
  
  Every scene is nice to watch in kathlikka neram illia.
  
  I love to watch EXPRESSIONS on balaiya's face almost in all scenes.
  
  * When he tries to impress fake lakshathipathi muthuraman
  
  * His casual approach towards ravichandran and changing his body language on knowing his wealth.
  
  * His submissiveness to his daughter's actions, reactions and opinions...yet helpless situations
  
  *his authority on nagesh.
  
  BALAIYA would rule the movie
  
  

• From: Designer on Tue Feb 27 13:46:44 2007.

  [Full View]

  hi wrote:

  I hve this movie CD.. i wont feel bored if i watch it n..number of times.. Songs are good too Esp the scene where Nagesh teach saachu( i guess it's correct ) Nagesh - "idhu kaadhal paarvaiya..? thiruttu paarvai" Saachu- "Sir unga moonja paatha enakku indha paarvai dhan varudhu

  
  
  similar dialogues between Nagesh & Sachchu when he teaches her how to emote the scenes
  
  

• From: ajithfederer on Tue Feb 27 14:28:52 2007.

  [Full View]

  we dont watch tamil movies......only english movies.....
  
  

• From: bingleguy on Tue Feb 27 14:36:58 2007.

  [Full View]

  WOW wonderful movie to watch .... excellent actors ...... every single person has some contribution to this movie ....
  
  Particularly the scenes of Nagesh and Balayya together .... they were Hilarious .... Masterpieces !
  
  The scene where Nagesh recites a story and the reaction of Balayya .... awesome ...
  One more scene where he recites a story during lunch
  
  oru naai avanukkaaga nunnu azhudhuttu pochu ..... pathu varushathukku munnadi biscuit pottirukkiraan ...... appadiye camera thooki mela kaatrom ... JO nnu mazhai ... ulagamae indha payalukkaaga azharamaadiri ....
  anna .... cha indha oru scene kkaaga un padam nooru naal oodum
  oodum oodum ...orey idathula nikkum
  
  

• From: rajeshkrv on Tue Feb 27 14:52:16 2007.

  [Full View]

  KAdhalikka neramillai ..
  
  Every department was superb in this
  
  right from the opening.. camera captures merina beach and film opens with a song..
  
  Enna paarvai undhan paarvai by KJY & PS
  
  lovely song
  
  After this story travels to the estate
  
  T.S.Baliah as Viswanathan my god he's another actor whose body language speaks volume about the character (As some one said he's very different in OVU)
  
  Nagesh as chellapa .. chellapa character was made for him and he only could do that..
  
  When he says ohho productions kelvipatirukkengala and sisters say ohho ..
  
  the scenes involving nagesh and chachu are ultimate
  
  that too when chachu says aamam sir chinna vayasula, shcoola raja rani nadaguthula . nagesh says rani vesham pottaya, chachu says rani vesham potta ponnukku samaram veesinen
  
  
  you should see nagesh's face expression here
  
  not to forget Muthuraman who was doing serious roles in Sridhar film did a full fledged comedy role in this and excelled in the old character where he acts as Ravichandran's father andha dhoranai, midukku adhikaram etc..
  
  RaviC and Rajashri as the young lovers were enjoyable too
  
  Chachu's father character is also worth mentioning .thambi car vangalama veedu vangalama
  nagesh aamayaa aprom enna engappa munnadi kal mela kal pottu ukkaralam
  he replies adhu mariyadhai illa adhu mariyadhai illa
  
  Funfilled movie with alll ingredients without obscenity, vulgar dialouges and unnecessary scenes.
  
  Each and Every Frame is adorable and that is the golden period of Tamil cinema where Sridhar, balachander and many others portrayed cinema with some meaning
  
  

• From: kannannn on Tue Feb 27 21:36:03 2007.

  [Full View]

  hi wrote:

  Esp the scene where Nagesh teach saachu( i guess it's correct ) Nagesh - "idhu kaadhal parvaya.. ?thirutu parvai" saachu- "Sir ungae mooncha patha enaku indhaey parvai dhan varudhu

  
  Continuing from there - Balaiya stops his car on seeing Nagesh and Sachu on the road side:
  Balaiya: Indha kanraviyellam indha kannala dhaan naan paarkanuma?
  Nagesh: Appa (jumping down from higher ground), idhellam indha kannala parkadhingappa, kalai kannala parunga..
  and later,
  Balaiya: innum ennada nadakkanum, nee indha ponna kootittu oor sutharannu paper-la varala, adhu onnu dhaan baaki..
  Nagesh: Varudhu, naan dhan news kuduthen, adutha vellikizhama annikku varudhu..
  
  KN is also strewn with dialogues that bring a silent chuckle. For example this one between Rajasri and Ravichandran:
  Rajasri: Ayyayyo..
  Ravichandran: Thannikulla ennanga pottinga..?
  Rajisri: Transistor
  Ravichandran: yaar sister?
  
  

• From: Shakthiprabha on Tue Feb 27 23:36:37 2007.

  [Full View]

  Nagesh: "oru ponnu... avalukku oru kannu"
  
  Balaiya: "aa... oru ponnulla kanna " (would twist words in sheer fear)
  
  N: "innum kekkareengala"
  
  Balaiya: "Venamppa manasu sariyilla"
  
  
  
  cuteeeeeeeeeeeeeeee to watch balaiya seriously
  
  

• From: ksen on Wed Feb 28 1:47:44 2007.

  [Full View]

  The way we remember each and every scene and dialogue speaks volumes about the film Indha padatha paathuttu, when we see Balaiya in serious roles, even as villain, in other movies, it just doesn't gel! Avvalo strong comedy image create aayiduchu
  
  When Muthuraman and Ravichandran push Nagesh and Sachu out of the guest house, the way Nagesh says 'ippadi sadaarnu veliya thalli padaarnu kadhava saatharaane, avanthaan periya manushan - it is their greatness '.
  
  Andha vintage car, and the sound it makes (where is Lamby ), adhula styleaa paduthutu Ravichandran 'onga ponnaana kaigal' paadaradhu, the way Nagesh's office room is decorated with old hollywood actors photos, English dialogue ellaam followed by Tamil translation (which is a comedy by itself), each and every aspect of the movie is enjoyable
  
  Ippo indha padatha theatrela release panninaakooda housefullaa Odum
  
  

• From: dsath on Wed Feb 28 6:12:50 2007.

  [Full View]

  ksen wrote:

  Ippo indha padatha theatrela release panninaakooda housefullaa Odum

  
  Absolutely true.
  
  

• From: Designer on Thu Mar 1 2:39:43 2007.

  [Full View]

  UngaL ponnaana manathu puNNaagalaama? uthavikku vanthuvittEn !
  
  'Kaadhalikka nEramillai' will be telecast on March 3rd 2007 (Sat) - Sun TV - 5pm IST
  
  

• From: ksen on Thu Mar 1 2:44:58 2007.

  [Full View]

  
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Thu Mar 1 2:50:49 2007.

  [Full View]

  Designer wrote:

  UngaL ponnaana manathu puNNaagalaama? uthavikku vanthuvittEn ! 'Kaadhalikka nEramillai' will be telecast on March 3rd 2007 (Sat) - Sun TV - 5pm IST

  
  
  They normally telecast new movies. Right ?
  Anyway, Good to hear that
  
  

• From: Nakeeran on Thu Mar 1 3:35:54 2007.

  [Full View]

  selvakumar wrote:

  Designer wrote: UngaL ponnaana manathu puNNaagalaama? uthavikku vanthuvittEn ! 'Kaadhalikka nEramillai' will be telecast on March 3rd 2007 (Sat) - Sun TV - 5pm IST They normally telecast new movies. Right ? Anyway, Good to hear that

  
  
  Selva Sir
  
  Past , present and future ellam therindha oru KADAVUL ...NAAN KADAVUL neenga sir Adhaan sariyaana padamaa parthu list panni irukeenga.
  
  So, whats next in line ?
  
  Put some Puratchi thalaivar movie pls
  
  

• From: ajithfederer on Thu Mar 1 3:35:57 2007.

  [Full View]

  I think its "Ungal ponnanaa kaigal punnagalama......udhavikku varalama.....sammatham varumaa.....santhegam thanaaa"
  

  Designer wrote:

  UngaL ponnaana manathu puNNaagalaama? uthavikku vanthuvittEn ! 'Kaadhalikka nEramillai' will be telecast on March 3rd 2007 (Sat) - Sun TV - 5pm IST

  
  

• From: Designer on Thu Mar 1 4:01:32 2007.

  [Full View]

  ajithfederer wrote:

  I think its "Ungal ponnanaa kaigal punnagalama......udhavikku varalama.....sammatham varumaa.....santhegam thanaaa" Designer wrote: UngaL ponnaana manathu puNNaagalaama? uthavikku vanthuvittEn ! 'Kaadhalikka nEramillai' will be telecast on March 3rd 2007 (Sat) - Sun TV - 5pm IST

  
  
  AF : ya I knew the lyrics; but modified it to suit my post
  
  

• From: ajithfederer on Thu Mar 1 4:17:32 2007.

  [Full View]

  
  //Dig
  is ur avatar from oorkavalan ?
  //
  

  Designer wrote:

  ajithfederer wrote: I think its "Ungal ponnanaa kaigal punnagalama......udhavikku varalama.....sammatham varumaa.....santhegam thanaaa" Designer wrote: UngaL ponnaana manathu puNNaagalaama? uthavikku vanthuvittEn ! 'Kaadhalikka nEramillai' will be telecast on March 3rd 2007 (Sat) - Sun TV - 5pm IST AF : ya I knew the lyrics; but modified it to suit my post

  
  

• From: selvakumar on Thu Mar 1 4:43:00 2007.

  [Full View]

  Nakeeran wrote:

  Selva Sir Past , present and future ellam therindha oru KADAVUL ...NAAN KADAVUL neenga sir Adhaan sariyaana padamaa parthu list panni irukeenga. So, whats next in line ? Put some Puratchi thalaivar movie pls

  
  
  Enna Thitturatha irundha Neradiyaavae thittidunga
  
  BTW, You can PM the movie to be discussed to me. It will be listed as your pick
  
  

• From: Designer on Thu Mar 1 5:11:36 2007.

  [Full View]

  its from 'Raja Chinna Roja'
  
  

  ajithfederer wrote:

  //Dig is ur avatar from oorkavalan ? // Designer wrote: ajithfederer wrote: I think its "Ungal ponnanaa kaigal punnagalama......udhavikku varalama.....sammatham varumaa.....santhegam thanaaa" Designer wrote: UngaL ponnaana manathu puNNaagalaama? uthavikku vanthuvittEn ! 'Kaadhalikka nEramillai' will be telecast on March 3rd 2007 (Sat) - Sun TV - 5pm IST AF : ya I knew the lyrics; but modified it to suit my post

  
  

• From: Designer on Thu Mar 1 7:31:03 2007.

  [Full View]

  Correction :
  
  'Kaadhalikka nEramillai' will be telecast on March 10th 2007 (Sat) - Sun TV - 5pm IST (and not 3rd March)
  
  

• From: umaramesh on Thu Mar 1 8:08:04 2007.

  [Full View]

  Everyone acted quite naturally.
  
  Dining hall
  
  Nagesh/Baliah having lunch. Broker enteres with horoscope
  
  Broker: PAIYANUKKU YEKAAR KANAKA NELAM IRUKKU
  
  You have to see the Nagesh casual reply without lifting his head while eating
  
  Nagesh: PAIYAn ENNA EAAYER UZHARANA(meaning doing agriculture)
  
  While meeting sachu father:
  
  Nagesh: UNGA PONNU NADIGAYA AAGAITA ENGA APPA MATHIRI CAR/BANGALOW ELLAM VAANGALAM
  
  SACHU FATHER: AAPADIGANGALA
  
  NAGESH: AYYAVLVU ENN AVAR MUNNADI KAL MELLA KAL POTTU UTTKARALAM
  
  SACHU FATHER: VENDAM ATHU AVVALLVU MARIYADHA ILLA
  
  regards
  ramesh
  
  

• From: kb on Thu Mar 1 21:16:20 2007.

  [Full View]

  those two ladies with ravichandran..
  
  l1:antha kaara ennadi panrathu
  l2:kuppaila podu
  l1:idicha ivara
  l2:avaraiyum kuppaila podu
  ravichandran:neenga corporationla vela panreengala
  
  

• From: kb on Thu Mar 1 21:18:15 2007.

  [Full View]

  http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lCYHAhbwvxU
  
  
  
  

• From: Thirumaran on Fri Mar 2 0:29:45 2007.

  [Full View]

  Designer wrote:

  Correction : 'Kaadhalikka nEramillai' will be telecast on March 10th 2007 (Sat) - Sun TV - 5pm IST (and not 3rd March)

  
  
  
  
  Those who had missed this movie before, dont miss it now
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Tue Mar 6 2:21:18 2007.

  [Full View]

  SINDHU BHAIRAVI
  
  Was Selected for discussion by "Movie Cop" for this week.
  
  Sindhu Bhairavi (1985) is a Tamil drama film directed by K. Balachander. It stars Suhasini, Sivakumar and Sulakshana. The film's score and soundtrack are composed by Ilaiyaraaja. The songs in the film were sung by Yesudas and K. S. Chithra.
  
  Cast
  * Suhasini
  * Sivakumar
  * Sulakshana
  * Delhi Ganesh
  * Janagaraj
  
  Awards
  
  The film has won the following awards since its release:
  
  1986 National Film Awards (India)
  
  * Won - Silver Lotus Award - Best Actress - Suhasini
  * Won - Silver Lotus Award - Best Music Direction - Ilayaraaja
  * Won - Silver Lotus Award - Best Female Playback Singer - K. S. Chithra
  
  Soundtrack
  
  The soundtrack features 7 songs composed by Ilayaraaja.
  
  * Kalai Vaaniyae - Yesudas
  * Mahaganapathim - Yesudas
  * Mari Mari - Yesudas
  * Mohum Ennum- Yesudas
  * Naan Oru Sindhu - K. S. Chithra
  * Paadariyen - K. S. Chithra
  * Thanni Thotti - Yesudas
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Tue Mar 6 2:25:11 2007.

  [Full View]

  Sorry for the delay friends
  Thanks for sharing your comments on "Kadhalikka Neramillai"
  
  

• From: swathy on Tue Mar 6 2:29:25 2007.

  [Full View]

  Top three in this movie
  
  1.Ilaiyaraja
  
  2.Location
  
  3.KJY + Chithra
  
  

• From: NOV on Tue Mar 6 2:32:51 2007.

  [Full View]

  
  
  top three would be KB, Sivakumar-Suhasini and then IR.
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Tue Mar 6 2:33:16 2007.

  [Full View]

  It has been quite a long time since I watched this movie. Unable to recollect anything except a few songs
  
  

• From: NOV on Tue Mar 6 2:36:15 2007.

  [Full View]

  selva, its like I have just watched the movie yesterday. cant count the number of times I've watched it. was also the last movie in cinemas before the complete takeover by VCRs.
  
  endha scene'um marakka mudiyaadhadhu!
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Tue Mar 6 2:37:11 2007.

  [Full View]

  NOV wrote:

  selva, its like I have just watched the movie yesterday. cant count the number of times I've watched it. was also the last movie in cinemas before the complete takeover by VCRs. endha scene'um marakka mudiyaadhadhu!

  
  
  oh !! Neenga KB A/C la !! Idha naan maranthuttaen
  
  

• From: Jabroni on Tue Mar 6 2:38:57 2007.

  [Full View]

  NOV wrote:

  top three would be KB, Sivakumar-Suhasini and then IR.

  
  
  
  
  SIVAKUMAR? why? he can't act.
  
  ONLY IR.
  
  then KB.
  
  

• From: Jabroni on Tue Mar 6 2:40:11 2007.

  [Full View]

  swathy wrote:

  Top three in this movie 1.Ilaiyaraja 2.Location 3.KJY + Chithra

  
  
  righta seppuneer swathy
  
  but it was an OVER-RATED film, agree or disagree?
  
  suhasini got a NA, what for?
  
  

• From: Sanguine Sridhar on Tue Mar 6 3:06:12 2007.

  [Full View]

  One of the irritating movie by Kb..I am out of the discussion!
  
  

• From: swathy on Tue Mar 6 3:16:27 2007.

  [Full View]

  Sanguine Sridhar wrote:

  One of the irritating movie by Kb..I am out of the discussion!

  
  
  correct . naanum poitu adutha vaaram varen
  
  

• From: kb on Tue Mar 6 3:20:15 2007.

  [Full View]

  ah thanni thotti thedi vantha kannu kutti naan ..
  sarayatha oothu an jannala thaan saathu..
  
  vera ethuvum enaku nyabagam illa.. an one more.. paadariya padipariya song.. gudnight. cya later
  
  

• From: thinkfloyd on Tue Mar 6 3:28:10 2007.

  [Full View]

  A movie i used to watch 'n' number of times back then
  Good choice
  
  IR deserved the National Award and more for this incomparable score.
  This is a very much watchable movie even now inspite of the irritating (to me) presence of Suhasini...
  Yet another 'typical' Delhi Ganesh performance
  
  

• From: Hulkster on Tue Mar 6 3:29:25 2007.

  [Full View]

  Well Sindhu Bhairavi for me was quite good...it had two themes...1 highlighted a man's desire for another woman after his wife is found to be infertile and the events that come as a result of them..in a way a social message. Secondly it highlights the arrogance of a classical musician shadowed and humbled by the more vibrant and fun-loving style of his fan. And the way both themes are mixed is Kb style....if it was another director the movie might have possible overfocussed on one and become reduced on the latter leading to total confusion. Nothing to say about IR...he made sure the movie lived with his music..amazing
  
  

• From: hi on Tue Mar 6 3:39:42 2007.

  [Full View]

  Hulkster wrote:

  Well Sindhu Bhairavi for me was quite good...it had two themes...1 highlighted a man's desire for another woman after his wife is found to be infertile

  
  
  I dont think that's the reason.. sivakumar will get attarcted to suhasini for her music talent which his wife lacks.. "gyana suniyam" appadinu sivakumar thituvaru
  
  

• From: NOV on Tue Mar 6 3:49:17 2007.

  [Full View]

  kilo enna vilai?
  
  

• From: pavalamani pragasam on Tue Mar 6 3:53:43 2007.

  [Full View]

  Sanguine Sridhar wrote:

  One of the irritating movie by Kb..I am out of the discussion!

  
  
  Sridhar! Ditto!
  
  

• From: NOV on Tue Mar 6 4:11:55 2007.

  [Full View]

  this thread is on celebrating selected movies. with due respect to thier views, why would ppl come and tell that they dont like this movie (or any other movie) in this thread?
  
  surely no movie can command 100% favour. there are likely to be large numbers of ppl who like and dislike a movie. pls dont be a wet blanket and spoil the enthusiasm of celebrants of a particular movie being discussed in this thread.
  
  

• From: pavalamani pragasam on Tue Mar 6 4:23:27 2007.

  [Full View]

  thadaa?!
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Tue Mar 6 4:46:19 2007.

  [Full View]

  NOV wrote:

  this thread is on celebrating selected movies. with due respect to thier views, why would ppl come and tell that they dont like this movie (or any other movie) in this thread? surely no movie can command 100% favour. there are likely to be large numbers of ppl who like and dislike a movie. pls dont be a wet blanket and spoil the enthusiasm of celebrants of a particular movie being discussed in this thread.

  
  
  I second this. Thanks NOV for stepping in at the right time
  Friends,
  Instead of bashing the movie or the creator, we can discuss about many things about the movie like music, acting etc !
  You can express what you feel. But please make sure it won't hurt others. After all, it is going to be someone who will be listing their favorite movies Who knows - We may also face this kind of situation one day !
  
  Sorry if this sounds a bit rude !
  
  Let us continue on "SB"
  
  

• From: NOV on Tue Mar 6 5:01:05 2007.

  [Full View]

  two points about the songs: mahaa ganapathy doesnt have any mirudangam accompaniments while kalaivaaniyE is unique. anyone knows why?
  
  

• From: thinkfloyd on Tue Mar 6 5:03:54 2007.

  [Full View]

  NOV wrote:

  two points about the songs: mahaa ganapathy doesnt have any mirudangam accompaniments while kalaivaaniyE is unique. anyone knows why?

  
  1) Mrudangist Delhi Ganesh is drunk
  (Violin Sarathy pinnittAru)
  2) Only ArOhaNam, no avarOhaNam
  
  

• From: NOV on Tue Mar 6 5:18:46 2007.

  [Full View]

  
  
  

• From: swathy on Tue Mar 6 5:20:27 2007.

  [Full View]

  thinkfloyd wrote:

  NOV wrote: two points about the songs: mahaa ganapathy doesnt have any mirudangam accompaniments while kalaivaaniyE is unique. anyone knows why? 1) Mrudangist Delhi Ganesh is drunk (Violin Sarathy pinnittAru) 2) Only ArOhaNam, no avarOhaNam

  
  
  
  
  

• From: Thirumaran on Tue Mar 6 6:22:47 2007.

  [Full View]

  thinkfloyd wrote:

  NOV wrote: two points about the songs: mahaa ganapathy doesnt have any mirudangam accompaniments while kalaivaaniyE is unique. anyone knows why? 1) Mrudangist Delhi Ganesh is drunk (Violin Sarathy pinnittAru) 2) Only ArOhaNam, no avarOhaNam

  
  
  
  
  
  This is what makes certain people genius. The near perfection they take. Some mediocre Direcor/ MD could have missed that one.
  
  Kudos to KB and IR
  
  

• From: kalnayak on Tue Mar 6 6:25:01 2007.

  [Full View]

  'Sindhu Bairavi (SB)' and 'Mudhal Mariyaadhai (MM)' released at the same time. It was expected that MM to get few national awards. Best Lyricist award went to Vairamuthu for MM. Radha lost Best actress award to Suhasini. Lot of criticism for this . IR got best music director award for SB. SB is one among many of KB's two wives story. Classical music and hence IR's music played very important role in this film.
  
  

• From: Aandavan on Tue Mar 6 6:26:53 2007.

  [Full View]

  the theme of this movie is like renting a woman for delivering a baby... suhasini's dialogues in the climax are irritating.. but its an interesting movie.. with godly music
  
  

• From: Ulaganayagan on Tue Mar 6 6:37:25 2007.

  [Full View]

  Aandavan wrote:

  the theme of this movie is like renting a woman for delivering a baby...

  
  The movie focuses on the extra marital love affair of a music artist.. Almost all love affairs result in a baby (unless the guy/girl are impotent) and some of them end in separation.. So saying the theme of the movie is renting a woman for delivering a baby is inappropriate IMO..
  
  

• From: Hulkster on Tue Mar 6 9:22:04 2007.

  [Full View]

  deleted
  
  

• From: Hulkster on Tue Mar 6 9:22:49 2007.

  [Full View]

  hi wrote:

  Hulkster wrote: Well Sindhu Bhairavi for me was quite good...it had two themes...1 highlighted a man's desire for another woman after his wife is found to be infertile I dont think that's the reason.. sivakumar will get attarcted to suhasini for her music talent which his wife lacks.. "gyana suniyam" appadinu sivakumar thituvaru

  
  
  but i have separated the themes into two....if you add the second theme to the first theme you got the movie's main theme, i separated it to show how KB could handle his plots into a movie and weave them despite them being similar to his old movies
  
  

• From: great on Tue Mar 6 11:29:42 2007.

  [Full View]

  damn good movie !!!!
  
  Nice pick
  
  Shivakumar at his best . Music was topnotch
  
  Thanni thotti thedi vantha kannuti Naan
  
  Padariyaen padippariyaen
  
  Mari Mari song
  
  Delhi Ganesh was too good in this movie
  
  
  Ethana murai paathalam intha movie bore adikathu . The scene where shivakumar attends the concert of lesser know artist after consuming liquor was simply superb Bilahari-ya ithu
  
  

• From: thinkfloyd on Tue Mar 6 11:51:40 2007.

  [Full View]

  great wrote:

  The scene where shivakumar attends the concert of lesser know artist after consuming liquor was simply superb Bilahari-ya ithu

  
  Are you talking about "Yochana Kamala Lochana"?
  It is darbAr rAgam...
  
  

• From: great on Tue Mar 6 12:23:41 2007.

  [Full View]

  thinkfloyd wrote:

  great wrote: The scene where shivakumar attends the concert of lesser know artist after consuming liquor was simply superb Bilahari-ya ithu Are you talking about "Yochana Kamala Lochana"? It is darbAr rAgam...

  
  
  yes Bilahari Unnal Mudiyum ThambiLa varum
  
  

• From: thinkfloyd on Tue Mar 6 12:26:21 2007.

  [Full View]

  great wrote:

  thinkfloyd wrote: great wrote: The scene where shivakumar attends the concert of lesser know artist after consuming liquor was simply superb Bilahari-ya ithu Are you talking about "Yochana Kamala Lochana"? It is darbAr rAgam... yes Bilahari Unnal Mudiyum ThambiLa varum

  
  eppadi pAthAlum namma Raaja dhAne!
  
  

• From: great on Tue Mar 6 12:29:08 2007.

  [Full View]

  Raja Raja thaan
  
  

• From: MADDY on Tue Mar 6 13:11:33 2007.

  [Full View]

  great wrote:

  Raja Raja thaan

  
  
  ooru, onnu koodittangaippa, onnu koodittangaippa
  
  Sindhu Bhairavi - genius of KB, National award winning score by Raaja, good performances from Sivakumar,Sulochana,Suahisini (i hate this female though i love her hubby )
  
  the things i liked in SB:
  
  1. the suhasini-mom plot - very bold for that period of time, i shuld say
  2. Sivakumar's action in initial scenes as a typical, egoistic carnatic genius
  3. Sulochana's innocent but irritating portrayal of a wife
  4. condemning the bias and prejudice that surrounds the concept of a concubine in Indian society
  5. Janakaraj and delhi ganesh comedy track
  6. IR's grand musical score
  
  

• From: Nakeeran on Tue Mar 6 13:48:59 2007.

  [Full View]

  thinkfloyd wrote:

  great wrote: thinkfloyd wrote: great wrote: The scene where shivakumar attends the concert of lesser know artist after consuming liquor was simply superb Bilahari-ya ithu Are you talking about "Yochana Kamala Lochana"? It is darbAr rAgam... yes Bilahari Unnal Mudiyum ThambiLa varum eppadi pAthAlum namma Raaja dhAne!

  
  
  ThinkF
  
  Guess which Raga is applied for Nan oru sindhu kavadi sindhu ?
  
  

• From: thinkfloyd on Tue Mar 6 14:37:51 2007.

  [Full View]

  Nakeeran wrote:

  ThinkF Guess which Raga is applied for Nan oru sindhu kavadi sindhu ?

  
  Sindhu Bhairavi (My favorite)
  
  

• From: Surya on Tue Mar 6 15:46:02 2007.

  [Full View]

  A Classic!!
  
  It's one of those movies that I could watch over and over again and still not get tired of it!
  
  Balachander -
  
  Music = Like someone said Earlier, Raja Raja Thaan!
  
  Sivakumar = Sollanuma?
  
  Suhasani - As Usual. Awesome.
  
  The woman who plays Sivakumar's Wife -
  
  Even Minor Charecters would've done an awesome job in the movie like Delhi Ganesh etc.
  
  An All Time Favorite.
  
  

• From: Movie Cop on Tue Mar 6 16:10:29 2007.

  [Full View]

  Sindhu Bhairavi is a 4* movie, IMO. It's been at least more than a decade or so since I last saw this all time classic. The movie is very down to earth, simple and made a very good way! The ending where Suhasini gives her baby to Sivakumar/Sulochana and walks away might be little "controversial" or cinematic depending on how you look at it. But that's the only way a writer could end the story, IMO. To me, watching Sindhu bhairavi is a like reading a novel
  
  The highlights of the movie are:
  
  1. KB's directorial touches - You could see all over the place in this movie! This is a complete "director's movie".
  2. IR's music - IR proves that he is a musical genius with his touch of class carnatic numbers! It's both sad & embarrassing that he was not given a national award for this movie!
  3. The performance of all the characters in this movie... starting from the lead characters Sivakumar, Suhasini and Sulochana to all the supporting cast like Delhi Ganesh, Janakaraj etc. everyone did their job to perfection.
  4. The screen play and characterization - it's nice, simple and realistic.
  
  Couple of glitches in the movie:
  1. The movie takes a little bit of detour when it touches on Suhasini's character. While the detour itself is necessary from the script point of view to give some "background" to Suhasini's character it could have been made a little more precise.
  2. The character of Prathap Pothan could have either been avoided.
  
  Besides these two the movie is "near perfect" in screenplay, direction, music, performance of all the lead & supporting characters!
  
  

• From: thinkfloyd on Tue Mar 6 16:12:59 2007.

  [Full View]

  Movie Cop,
  IR did win a National Award for this film...
  
  

• From: Movie Cop on Tue Mar 6 16:37:47 2007.

  [Full View]

  thinkfloyd wrote:

  Movie Cop, IR did win a National Award for this film...

  
  Oh is that right? I wrongly thought that IR has never won a National award! That's awesome! IR's music for Sindhu bhairavi was a gem and he thoroughly deserves a National Award. In fact there are lots of other Tamil movies where IR really deserved a National award but couldn't get one...
  
  

• From: Wibha on Tue Mar 6 22:06:44 2007.

  [Full View]

  a wonderful movie
  
  songs sollavea vendam
  
  i love it wen SK tells" sindhu illati bhairavi illa,sindhu bharavi illati paatu illa" da way he tells it is awesome............
  
  

• From: thinkfloyd on Tue Mar 6 22:46:43 2007.

  [Full View]

  Movie Cop wrote:

  thinkfloyd wrote: Movie Cop, IR did win a National Award for this film... Oh is that right? I wrongly thought that IR has never won a National award! That's awesome! IR's music for Sindhu bhairavi was a gem and he thoroughly deserves a National Award. In fact there are lots of other Tamil movies where IR really deserved a National award but couldn't get one...

  
  Infact, he has won 3 - Sagara Sangamam, Sindhu Bhairavi, Rudraveena...
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Tue Mar 13 10:16:10 2007.

  [Full View]

  SALANGAI OLI
  
  Movie selected by : Great
  
  Salangai Oli (1983) is a Tamil film directed by K. Vishwanath. It was based upon the Telugu film, Sagara Sangamam. The soundtrack and score were composed by Ilaiyaraaja.
  
  
  Cast
  KamalHassan, JeyaPrasha, Sarath Babu etc
  
  
  PLOT
  Balakrishna (Kamal Hassan) is an economically poor multi-talented dancer, adept at Bharata Natyam, Kathakali, Kuchipudi etc.. and his dream is to perform at an All-India level competition. Madhavi (Jayaprada), a rich girl notices his talent and helps in getting him an opportunity to perform in an all-India competition. As he is all set to relaise his dream, his ageing mother passes away which denies the fulfillment of his dream. Slowly, he gets closer to Madhavi and the day he wishes to propose to her, he realises that she is already married and her husband left her. Now the husband wants to re-unite with her which forces him to sacrifice his love. Years pass by and he turns into a drunkard. Meanwhile Madhavi loses her husband. She comes to know of Balakrishna who the doctors say is going to die soon. So she takes care of his medical needs and requests Balakrishna to teach dance to her daughter. The movie ends with Madhavi's daughter becoming a great dancer and the death of Balakrishna giving a message "There is no end to art
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Tue Mar 13 10:17:55 2007.

  [Full View]

  SALANGAI OLI - ****
  
  Cast: Kamalhassan, Jayaprada, S.P.Shailaja, Sarathbabu
  Music: Ilaiyaraja
  Direction: K.Vishwanath
  
  Kamalhassan's dance skills have always been well known but it is only in Salangai Oli that he gets the chance to exhibit them on the scale that he deserves. Dubbed from Saagara Sangamam, which was directed by K.Vishwanath(who was also responsible for arguably the most popular Telugu movie in Tamil, Sankarabharanam), the movie finds Kamalhassan in top form, whether dancing or emoting. As necessary for a musical with classical dance at its center, the movie features a great soundtrack from Ilaiyaraja with the songs being rendered superbly by S.P.Balasubramaniam. Unserstandably, the Telugu original won National awards for both of them.
  
  The story starts with Balu(Kamalhassan), an accomplished dancer in his younger days, writing a scathing review on the bharatanatyam performance of Shailaja(S.P.Shailaja). His past, where he was helped by Madhavi(Jayaprada), is shown in flashback, interspersed with his present. He had fallen in love with Madhavi and had even proposed to her, but circumstances prevented her from agreeing. Now his only thought is her well-being. Shailaja is none other than Madhavi's daughter and when Madhavi learns of Balu's whereabouts and condition, she arranges to have Shailaja learn dance under him. But she must take steps to prevent Balu from being aware the misfortune that has befallen her.
  
  The movie is a showcase for Kamalhassan's classical dance skills and he parades his wares gloriously. And the dancing is not limited to the song sequences. There are several shorter sequences which are designed for the same purpose. The scene where he points out the huge flaw in Shailaja's performance by repeating the step in difference dance forms is exhilarating. His making a non-Tamilian understand the reason for his visit through dance gestures is another such cute scene. Among the song sequences, the scene where he conducts an impromptu recital in the kitchen is very sweet.
  
  Ofcourse most of the song sequences are designed to bring out the best in him. Though Ilaiyaraja won a National award for the Telugu version, music if ofcourse universal and the lyrics blend in well enough to make us forget the songs' non-Tamil origins. Unlike Idhayathai Thirudaathey, where Mano took over for S.P.Balasubramaniam in Tamil, SPB renders the songs here too and gives us a hint of what won him the National award for the Telugu songs. Naadha Vinodhangal... is a nice mix of melody and Carnatic music. Mounamaana Neram... is slow and soothing while Thakita Thadhimi... is faster. Om Namachivaayaa... and Vedham Anuvilum... are perfectly suited for the dance performances. Vishwanath also makes a telling point about how a genuine artist is forced to sacrifice his talent at the altar of commercial cinema with the Vaan Pole Vannam... sequence
  
  There are nice laughs initially during Kamal's photo session with his young photographer and the resulting photos. Starting from this, the friendship between Kamal and Jayapradha is developed in a sweet but mature way. Her acts of kindness and Kamal's reactions to them are natural. His feelings for her are completely believable and the way he proposes to her is a nice touch. Another enviable relationship is the friendship between Kamal and Sarathbabu. Sarathbabu's role is designed to make everyone wish for a friend like him. He is always at hand, supporting him and never faulting him.
  
  Though the fact that a man could have only the well-being of a woman he once loved, in his heart(to the extent shown here) seems cinematic in theory, the way the character of Kamal is developed makes it utterly believable. Similarly, Jayapradha's act to hide her situation from him sounds a little corny but makes complete sense on screen. The climax is very strong and the way Shailaja breaks down on hearing Kamal talk about Jayapradha makes a very strong impact. The final scene is touching without being overly sentimental.
  
  Kamalhassan must have come perilously close to an acting award for his performance here. His enthusiasm for dancing as a youngster is as well brought out as his love for his mother. He melts our hearts as he tearfully clutches Jayapradha's hands and thanks her after seeing his photo in the dance program invitation. Jayapradha generates respect for her character while Sarathbabu effectively conveys his genuine affection for Kamal through his performance. Shailaja(SPB's sister) is believable as the arrogant dancer in her debut in front of the camera.
  
  Salangai Oli is music not just to our ears but to our hearts too.
  
  

• From: joe on Tue Mar 13 10:21:19 2007.

  [Full View]

  Hmm..My all time most favourite movie ..ennatha sollurathu ..One can easily understand from this movie ,why kamalhassan is special.
  
  Salangai Oli -The movie made me Kamal Fan
  
  

• From: kannannn on Tue Mar 13 10:26:32 2007.

  [Full View]

  Padathulerndhu onnume nyabagam illae . Waiting for interesting inputs from others..
  
  

• From: NOV on Tue Mar 13 10:45:35 2007.

  [Full View]

  selvakumar wrote:

  Salangai Oli (1983) is a Tamil film directed by K. Vishwanath. It was based upon the Telugu film, Sagara Sangamam. The soundtrack and score were composed by Ilaiyaraaja.

  no!
  
  It is a telugu movie which was dubbed into Tamil.
  
  

• From: Thirumaran on Tue Mar 13 10:59:20 2007.

  [Full View]

  NOV wrote:

  selvakumar wrote: Salangai Oli (1983) is a Tamil film directed by K. Vishwanath. It was based upon the Telugu film, Sagara Sangamam. The soundtrack and score were composed by Ilaiyaraaja. no! It is a telugu movie which was dubbed into Tamil.

  
  
  
  
  

• From: thinkfloyd on Tue Mar 13 11:05:27 2007.

  [Full View]

  Sagara Sangamam
  
  Ada munnAdiyE sollapdAdha?
  [sollirundha mattum enna pannappora?-nu kekka koodadhu!]
  
  

• From: Nakeeran on Tue Mar 13 11:11:48 2007.

  [Full View]

  A classic from Kamal .
  
  Infact, one of the very best of Indian cinema !
  
  K.Vishwanath fully utilized Kamal’s skills in the art of dancing . Also , the youthful years of Kamal. Will look absolutely handsome .
  
  SaratBabu plays able foil as a good friend and well wisher
  
  The beautiful Jayapradha is all grace and class
  
  Music by the Maestro scintillating songs & lovely BGM
  
  Many superb scenes but I wish to highlight some :
  
  1. Mother about to die . kamal performs a mini dance . A very emotional scene. He loses a life time opportunity becaz of the death .
  2. Jayapradha shows the photos of various participants for a major event . Kamal browses each one and finally sees his nryutya posture like Nataraja and becomes emotional. Beautiful scene !
  3. When Kamal takes to task S.P.Shailaja for not having performed to perfection. As he displays each art of dancing, one mudra makes the coffee tumbler jump . After that, he gives a slap to her boy friend.
  4. The final scene. As SPS performs her dance as a mark of respect to guru Kamal, kamal is being shown dead and slowly both Jayapradha and Saratbabu take him away.
  
  AN OUTSTANDING MOVIE. COMPLETE IN ALL ASPECTS.
  
  
  
  
  

• From: Nakeeran on Tue Mar 13 11:14:34 2007.

  [Full View]

  Maestro Isainyani has applied many ragas
  
  1. Bala kanaka maya - Ataana
  
  2. Nadha vinodhangal - vasantha
  
  3. Om Namashivaya - Hindolam
  
  

• From: Nakeeran on Tue Mar 13 11:19:57 2007.

  [Full View]

  And not to forget, SUPERB SINGING BY S.P.B.
  
  Top class album by SPB.
  
  Listen to Vaan pole vannam kondu . Konjum kural.
  
  he becomes classical for Nadha vinodhangal
  and Vedam anudhinam .
  
  Ultimate is Mounamana neram . Both SJ and SPB , all class.
  
  

• From: thinkfloyd on Tue Mar 13 11:24:02 2007.

  [Full View]

  Nakeeran wrote:

  Maestro Isainyani has applied many ragas 1. Bala kanaka maya - Ataana 2. Nadha vinodhangal - vasantha 3. Om Namashivaya - Hindolam

  
  vAn pOlE vaNNam - mOhanam
  "vEdham" - hamsAnandhi
  thakita thadhumi - shaNmugapriyA
  
  

• From: ajithfederer on Tue Mar 13 11:28:49 2007.

  [Full View]

  Some excellent scenes in the movie i like
  
  1) the scene where kamal dances to spb shailaja
  
  2) Beautiful chemistry between kamal and jayapradha....
  
  3) thakida thatumi song and the dance
  
  4) The photographical scenes between kamal and the small boy
  
  will add the rest later
  
  

• From: Nakeeran on Tue Mar 13 11:46:55 2007.

  [Full View]

  thinkfloyd wrote:

  Nakeeran wrote: Maestro Isainyani has applied many ragas 1. Bala kanaka maya - Ataana 2. Nadha vinodhangal - vasantha 3. Om Namashivaya - Hindolam vAn pOlE vaNNam - mOhanam "vEdham" - hamsAnandhi thakita thadhumi - shaNmugapriyA

  
  
  
  Adadadadaaa Marandhe pochu ThinkF
  
  Thanks . Indha padam oru musical / barathnatyam special no ! And one can see high level of etiquete and respect for each other ( kamal and JP ).
  
  

• From: Roshan on Tue Mar 13 12:12:51 2007.

  [Full View]

  Wow !! Salangai Oli
  
  All scenes that Nakkeeran has listed are my favourites too. Those scenes have made me cry
  
  Yes it is a COMPLETE movie !! Great songs and great dancing. It's worth mentioning about Shylaja's singing in vaan pOlE vaNNam koNdu and naatha vinOthangaL .
  
  

• From: sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar on Tue Mar 13 12:27:56 2007.

  [Full View]

  CAn anyone name any last recent movie which was in the lines of salangai oli?? i dont say there was one(infact, there cannot be one ), but any attempts?
  
  What is the uttermost important thing in this movie ehich makes it to live longer in the hearts of rasikas?
  
  1) The Hard-to-be seen Clasiical Dance and Classical Music
  2) Kamal & others' Performance
  3) Storyline
  4) All reasons above
  5) something apart from the above ??
  
  

• From: thimuru on Tue Mar 13 13:00:34 2007.

  [Full View]

  when Kamal sees Jayapradha ater thakita thadhumi ..........
  
  

• From: thamizhvaanan on Tue Mar 13 13:54:33 2007.

  [Full View]

  salangai oli ...
  
  just saw it recently in one of the channles .. dont remember which one , but I cudnt take my eyes off the screen. Another spellbinding performance from KH and this film just shows why he is peerless. IF anyone can truly replicate KH performance in this film, he wud be KH's true match.
  
  Another notable aspect of the film is camerawork .... It was particularly good especially in the dance scenes. The continuosly moving camera angles, does more than its best to supplement the dance movements. A good example is in the scene where KH points out mistakes in SP shailaja in the office, the way in which the space available in the office was utilised is applaudable. And the camera was never static throughout.
  
  Only when the film ended, my father told me that the director is infact a cameraman... no wonder
  
  

• From: Sinthiya on Tue Mar 13 16:56:52 2007.

  [Full View]

  thamizhvaanan wrote:

  A good example is in the scene where KH points out mistakes in SP shailaja in the office, the way in which the space available in the office was utilised is applaudable

  
  that scene was well done......
  Kamal's dance was ...too bad i never saw the ending ...but i know it now...
  
  

• From: Kollywoodfan on Tue Mar 13 17:55:46 2007.

  [Full View]

  Salangai Oli is a beautiful movie. Kamal was just brilliant and for the zillionth time I guess shows how versatile he is.
  
  My fav scene is definitely when he is insulted for his article and retorts by doing a step from each dance to show that he does know a thing or two about dance.
  
  We were looking for the movie all over the place because my mom said I had to see it since I'm a dancer myself. I'm so happy that we finally found the DVD at a local Indian fair.
  
  

• From: thamiz on Tue Mar 13 18:27:27 2007.

  [Full View]

  Quote:

  for the zillionth time I guess shows how versatile he is

  
  
  zillionth time?
  
  

• From: Kollywoodfan on Tue Mar 13 19:04:47 2007.

  [Full View]

  thamiz wrote:

  Quote: for the zillionth time I guess shows how versatile he is zillionth time?

  
  
  Yup, if we were to count each scene of every one of his movies that's he been in W/e...you get what I mean...
  
  I would not describe myself as an ardent Kamal fan, although I know he's amazing. But this was one of his films that completely blew me away!
  
  

• From: Wibha on Tue Mar 13 19:18:28 2007.

  [Full View]

  SALANGAI OLI.............. wowwwwwwww what a movie...........KAMAL is da best!!!!!!! wen i saw his dance what a movie......... :thumsup: a very cool movie
  
  

• From: Designer on Tue Mar 13 19:28:39 2007.

  [Full View]

  Such a memorable film So many fav scenes, especially the one where Kamal dances on the well in pouring rain, and Jayapradha comes to save him from falling - both literally and figuratively
  
  
  thakida thathimi thakida thathimi thamthAnA
  idhaya oliyin jathiyil enathu thillAnA
  irudhayam adikkadi thudikkuthu enbEnA
  en kathai ezhuthida maRukkuthu en pEnA
  
  
  

• From: Querida on Tue Mar 13 20:45:44 2007.

  [Full View]

  I love this movie and repeat the same sentiments of Designer above...the dance performances wonderful! I love the part in which he shows her properly how to dance and then the song "Vandhan Gopalanae" parody about film gratuituous picturisation. Kamal's voice throughout his attempt to hold together his emotions, the part in which they both want to tell each other their feelings but cannot all priceless!
  
  my favourite part of the above song:
  
  idhu oru ragasiya naadagamae....
  alaigalil kulungidum oadam naanae
  baavamundu paavamillai vaazhkkaiyoadu koabamillai
  kaadhal ennai kaadhalikka villai!
  
  

• From: swathy on Tue Mar 13 22:48:23 2007.

  [Full View]

  Good pick
  
  recently I watched the movie in Jaya TV
  
  Excellent subject.
  
  K.Vishwanathirkku kodanu kodi nandrigal.
  
  

• From: joe on Tue Mar 13 23:00:53 2007.

  [Full View]

  The best aspect of this movie - I don't feel like watching a dubbing movie.
  
  wonderful scenes ..
  
  * Kamal demonstrates various dances for Shilaja
  
  * kamal's reactions when he was included as a performer of dance festival
  
  * when kamal went to join a dance class ,he express his desire with abinayam to a girl.
  
  * All the dance sequences (especially nathavinothangal)
  
  * Thakida thathumi
  
  sollitee pohalam.
  
  Ilayarajaa .hmm ..Isai Gnani indeed.
  
  
  

• From: NOV on Tue Mar 13 23:42:04 2007.

  [Full View]

  joe wrote:

  The best aspect of this movie - I don't feel like watching a dubbing movie.

  
  but KV's next movie Sippikkul Muthu was the total opposite. Horrible dubbing. SP Bala for Kamal?
  
  one other movie where dubbing was excellent was Idhayathai Thirudathe.
  
  

• From: joe on Tue Mar 13 23:50:51 2007.

  [Full View]

  NOV wrote:

  but KV's next movie Sippikkul Muthu was the total opposite. Horrible dubbing. SP Bala for Kamal?

  
  
  Yeah .I heard kamal had some problem in dubbing for SM,so they used SPB .
  
  What I felt the difference is salangai oli songs ,when dubbed in Tamil ,if fits for the exact modulation and music .
  
  whenever I hear this line ,tears trying to roll.
  
  நடராஜர் பாதத்தில் தலை சாயுமா
  நாம் சிந்தும் கண்ணீரும் கரை மீறுமா
  கனவிலும்....
  நனவிலும்...
  கனவிலும் நனவிலும்
  அழகிய பரதங்கள் ஆட.
  
  

• From: Shakthiprabha on Wed Mar 14 0:53:37 2007.

  [Full View]

  Oh so this thread is where SINTHU BHAIRAVI , which was eating all our hubber's brains for past few days, cropped up eh
  
  I wont rate the movie as MY FAVOURITE
  
  Not one of KB's best, according to me.
  
  Though nothing much can be pointed wrong about the direction, story or screen play, or even ACTING by any of them... (I mean everythign was good)
  
  but...
  
  SIMPLY SOMETHING did not gel with my mindset.
  
  LOVED its MUSIC would be an understantement.
  
  IR crowned the movie
  
  

• From: joe on Wed Mar 14 1:03:35 2007.

  [Full View]

  SP,
  Hope your comments are for 'Sindu Bhairavi' ..Now we moved to next movie 'Salangai Oli' .Expecting your views on salangai Oli.
  
  

• From: Shakthiprabha on Wed Mar 14 1:06:41 2007.

  [Full View]

  Salangai oli
  
  
  
  WORDS FAIL ME.
  
  What a movie!
  
  What characters!
  
  KAMAL SWEEPS the show... (nothing new bout it)
  
  "pancha boothangaLum muga vadivaaga",
  
  kamal would try to gel with the character, whence his thoughts would be on NOTHING BUT DANCE...
  
  
  SONGS AND MUSIC JUST RULE!!!!!!!!!
  
  Movie makes me feel heavy at heart.
  
  

• From: Shakthiprabha on Wed Mar 14 1:10:41 2007.

  [Full View]

  Some fav scenes..
  
  * Wonderful and polished way of expressing love
  
  * Proving his dance abilities to shailaja quietly and wordlessly BY PERFORMING THE DANCE right before her.
  
  * Jayapradha's wordless everexisting love, shown in THE MOST RESPECTABLE way.
  
  * The scene where kamal performs for his MOM
  
  * his anger on film director for askin him to perform not so acceptable dance steps
  
  * his not practical way of thinking and living
  
  can go on and on... ALMOST EVERY SCENE in this movie
  
  

• From: thinkfloyd on Wed Mar 14 1:29:10 2007.

  [Full View]

  Aandavar won the Best Actor award in an Asian Film festival for this (and Swathi Muthyam.. for Virumaandi - Best Film)...
  
  

• From: joe on Wed Mar 14 1:31:47 2007.

  [Full View]

  thinkfloyd wrote:

  Aandavar won the Best Actor award in an Asian Film festival for this (and Swathi Muthyam.. for Virumaandi - Best Film)...

  
  
  More info pls..when,where ,film festival name etc.
  
  

• From: Jabroni on Wed Mar 14 1:32:22 2007.

  [Full View]

  I only watched it for one reason: isai thendral, isai mazhai, isai aruvi, isai vayal, isai malai, isai mozhi, isai kuudal, isai manai, isai gnani, isai'in kadaisi tharipidam, the maestro Ilayarajah, the undisputed KING of GODS of MUSIC of tamil cinema
  
  

• From: thinkfloyd on Wed Mar 14 1:54:19 2007.

  [Full View]

  joe wrote:

  thinkfloyd wrote: Aandavar won the Best Actor award in an Asian Film festival for this (and Swathi Muthyam.. for Virumaandi - Best Film)... More info pls..when,where ,film festival name etc.

  
  SS - 1983, SM - 1985 Asian Film Festival, don't now the venue
  Virumaandi - Puchon International Film Festival (S.Korea), 2004
  
  

• From: Alek Niranjan on Wed Mar 14 4:22:21 2007.

  [Full View]

  thinkfloyd wrote:

  joe wrote: thinkfloyd wrote: Aandavar won the Best Actor award in an Asian Film festival for this (and Swathi Muthyam.. for Virumaandi - Best Film)... More info pls..when,where ,film festival name etc. SS - 1983, SM - 1985 Asian Film Festival, don't now the venue Virumaandi - Puchon International Film Festival (S.Korea), 2004

  
  
  I think This is the first telugu movie which nominated for Oscar. Kamal,IR and K.Viswanath got many Andhra State awards for this moive.
  
  

• From: ab_123 on Wed Mar 14 19:25:21 2007.

  [Full View]

  Salangai oli!!!!
  
  One of my FAV movies...
  
  Loved KAMAL
  Loved the songs (IR and SPB rock!)
  Loved KAMAL
  Well directed movie
  Loved the dancing (esp by KAMAL)
  and did I mention..LOVED KAMAL!!!!!!!!
  
  
  
  

• From: sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar on Thu Mar 15 0:45:54 2007.

  [Full View]

  Saagara Sangamam - Salangai Oli
  Seems telugu nae has a different maaning - the meet of grand oceans ???
  Swaathi Muthyam - Sippikkul Muththu
  what soed the telugu name mean?
  
  

• From: Querida on Thu Mar 15 0:54:09 2007.

  [Full View]

  ab_123 wrote:

  Salangai oli!!!! One of my FAV movies... Loved KAMAL Loved the songs (IR and SPB rock!) Loved KAMAL Well directed movie Loved the dancing (esp by KAMAL) and did I mention..LOVED KAMAL!!!!!!!!

  
  
  awww that's cute ab_123
  
  

• From: bingleguy on Thu Mar 15 1:24:11 2007.

  [Full View]

  Yadho Raja Thadho Praja
  
  is this the say that Kamal says to SPShailaja after quoting her mistakes ..... ?
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Thu Mar 15 11:19:30 2007.

  [Full View]

  SALANGAI OLI
  
  The film is told in flashback about the life of Balu, an eccentric dancer turned critic. Balu had been an aspiring dancer with dreams of creating a unified classical dance form. He is forever in search of a guru to teach him the nuances of the art. His friend, Sarathbabu, stands like a pillar of support to him. A chance meeting with Archana, a rich and lonely girl, kindles friendship between the two. Archana is very caring towards Balu and makes quiet efforts to help his career. She even arranges for his performance at an all India dance festival.
  
  
  Through all these heady events, their friendship blossoms into love. Just when Balu proposes to Archana unaware of her sad past, it revisits her to prevent her from saying yes. Just before Balu leaves for the festival, his mother also dies. The twin tragedies wreck Balu and he is never in control of his life anymore. He hits the bottle and lives like a vagabond. Fate brings him close to Archana again. He writes a scathing review of Shailaja’s dance performance without knowing that she is none other than Archana’s daughter. This time Archana does not reveal her presence but tries to make Balu comfortable.
  
  
  The film showcased the excellent dancing abilities of Kamal Hassan. Although he is not a trained dancer, his performance had grace and majesty. The scene where he points out the mistakes in Shailaja’s dance is memorable. Jayapradha matched him step for step and their dance duet was simply superb. Jayapradha’s quiet portrayal of a tormented woman was such a relief from the weeping and wailing sentiment often seen in our movies. Sarathbabu’s role of a true friend was also etched well.
  
  The central theme of the film is that classical dance always remains pure and free from corrupting influences. A true artist pursues art for its own sake and never hankers for money. Balu took his artistic journey very seriously and that is why he could not make compromises. In the end, his true artistry remains unsung.
  
  K. Viswanath is a noted director and his excellent screenplay portrays subtle and underplayed emotions. Every aspect, whether romance, sentiment or comedy has a genteel quality. Even the portrayal of crass commercialism in film dance has a touch of humor. Ilayaraja’s music has some fantastic songs and his background score is matched with the different moods of the film.
  
  Salangai oli is a film which is to be seen when one wants to reconnect to the inward looking values of artistic pursuit.
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Thu Mar 15 11:44:53 2007.

  [Full View]

  Just a gentle reminder to our dear hubbers:
  
  Hubbers who want a particular movie to be listed for discussion can send a PM to me. It can be any movie which you people liked. Whenever you see a movie, you might have come across a few interesting things and you may be keen to share these things. This thread provides the same platform for you.
  
  The movies will be listed in a random manner.
  
  Veteran hubbers can also suggest a few movies of the late cine personalities which can throw more light on the personalities and their greatness. It can be something like remembering them. Someone who used to sit at the back and do their job. Someone who went unnoticed inspite of their brilliant work.
  
  Such movies will be listed as SPECIAL PICKS. For e.g., if we have a birth anniversary / dearth anniversary of PERSONALITY X, hubbers can recommend a movie of them which will be listed as a special pick.
  
  IF you have further comments on improving the process and the discussions relevant to this thread, feel free to post them here.
  
  Thanks for your cooperation !
  
  

• From: Nerd on Thu Mar 15 13:30:17 2007.

  [Full View]

  Salangai oli -- one of my favorite KH movies.
  
  My favorite scene is the one in which KH sees his name in that invitation alongside greats. Superb acting and excellent background score.
  
  I wish I could say more but have not seen the movie lately
  
  

• From: Erica on Thu Mar 15 14:13:38 2007.

  [Full View]

  EXCELLENT movie and Kamal's performance in every single frame was simply Outstanding
  
  One of my favourite scene
  http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SUAyqwT2E74
  
  The climax song(vedham) was so beautiful....where he teaches shylaja.
  
  OMG...what a perfectionist?
  
  

• From: ajithfederer on Thu Mar 15 14:18:31 2007.

  [Full View]

  erica may be u can offer the telugu interpretation of the words sagara sangamam and swathy muthyam
  

  Erica wrote:

  EXCELLENT movie and Kamal's performance in every single frame was simply Outstanding One of my favourite scene http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SUAyqwT2E74 The climax song(vedham) was so beautiful....where he teaches shylaja. OMG...what a perfectionist?

  
  

• From: Sanjeevi on Thu Mar 15 14:58:40 2007.

  [Full View]

  joe wrote:

  NOV wrote: but KV's next movie Sippikkul Muthu was the total opposite. Horrible dubbing. SP Bala for Kamal? Yeah .I heard kamal had some problem in dubbing for SM,so they used SPB .

  
  
  The same repeated in "Paasavalai" too
  
  
  
  

• From: Sanjeevi on Thu Mar 15 15:12:58 2007.

  [Full View]

  thinkfloyd wrote:

  Nakeeran wrote: Maestro Isainyani has applied many ragas 1. Bala kanaka maya - Ataana 2. Nadha vinodhangal - vasantha 3. Om Namashivaya - Hindolam vAn pOlE vaNNam - mOhanam "vEdham" - hamsAnandhi thakita thadhumi - shaNmugapriyA

  
  
  ennamo solreengannu mattum puriyuthu
  
  

• From: Surya on Thu Mar 15 19:14:05 2007.

  [Full View]

  ab_123 wrote:

  Kamal is one actor that when he does a crying scene, you really feel the pain...

  
  
  Aboorva Sagodharargal - When Sri Vidhya Accepts that her son has a Defect. WOW! I almost Cried in that Scene.
  
  Salangai Oli is also a good example. Every movie of his for that matter. Even in Vasool Raja, when he cries after Zakhir's Death. That was very well done.
  
  

• From: Alek Niranjan on Fri Mar 16 4:48:43 2007.

  [Full View]

  ajithfederer wrote:

  erica may be u can offer the telugu interpretation of the words sagara sangamam and swathy muthyam Erica wrote: EXCELLENT movie and Kamal's performance in every single frame was simply Outstanding One of my favourite scene http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SUAyqwT2E74 The climax song(vedham) was so beautiful....where he teaches shylaja. OMG...what a perfectionist?

  
  
  
  Federer
  
  Sagara Sangamam -> Kadalgalin Sangamamam
  
  Swathy Muthyam -> Pure Pearl
  
  

• From: Alek Niranjan on Fri Mar 16 6:16:43 2007.

  [Full View]

  The movie was very huge hit in Andhra. The success was mainly due to the support provided by the Family audience.
  
  And this movie also faired very well in TN,KN(I am not sure about Kerala).
  
  I watched this movie 4 times in Vijayawada during it release with my Grandparents.Vijayawada it ran 200 days there.
  
  
  Very good direction by Kala Thapsvi "K.Viswanth"
  
  Very good music by Mastero
  
  Great acting by Kamal
  
  
  My Favorite sceanes in this movie.
  
  1.The way he acted while critisizing the Sylaja's dance in the
  begininng. And he showed what the exact dance is and Said "Natya Mayoori". Excellant Expression
  
  2.After the song "Vaan Pole vannam kondu vandhai gopalane", he was very sad and explain how he wanted to dance for
  that song.
  
  3. The scene in which Kamal sees his name in the inviation
  with other great Dancers. Fantastic acting
  
  4. Mounamane Neram - Song - Nice song and romance between the lead pair expressed by very well.
  
  
  
  
  5.Cilmax Song and The scens where Kamal taught Shilaja
  
  This film made by a die hard Kamal fan.
  
  

• From: groucho070 on Fri Mar 16 6:26:09 2007.

  [Full View]

  An angry young man.
  
  An angrier old man.
  
  A dancer.
  
  You might think that these are three characters. Nope, it's one man, that was the man Kamal plays in Salangai Oli. What a ride the movie is! Emotional roller coaster that leave you thinking and brooding for weeks, months, etc.
  
  Kamal was what? 29 years old at that time? 8 Years since he started playing lead roles? And here he is immersed in the role like a veteran. Of course, the ...what do you call...National Award? They ignored him.
  
  

• From: sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar on Fri Mar 16 6:56:38 2007.

  [Full View]

  groucho, we expected more from you, about this movie, like what you do to other kamal posts
  
  

• From: groucho070 on Fri Mar 16 7:43:38 2007.

  [Full View]

  Well, it's nice to have your post appreciated. But I don't remember long posts in Kamal's thread. You usually find them in NT.
  
  Anyway, here's my take on Salangai Oli:
  
  This movie can only be done with Kamal alone. Put any other actors, and the film will fail. The charisma, the energy, the emotional output, the ability to grab audience by the collar and shake him or her and give them a roller coaster of a ride. That is required for the lead role in this movie, and Kamal does it...almost effortlessly.
  
  Which scene do you want me to talk about? The dance sequences? The scene when the mother dies? His various disappointments? The dance on the well? The outburst of an old journalist?
  
  Rarely has Tamil films explored a single charcter in such fashion that director Viswanath did in this film (and later in Sippikkul Muthu and Pasavalai).
  
  One of the most difficult task for a filmaker is to engage the audience. Many fail to achieve this; even if they continuously think so. Vishvanath did a brilliant job in tracking the life of a passionate but failed artist.
  
  If there is one single expression you can use for the main character in this movie, it will be disappointment. For Kamal's character, life is a series of disappointments; where else to turn to but the only source that gives you that temporary detachment from reality - bottle.
  
  From a handsome young dance to a bitter alcoholic old man. This is one journey that we will never want be in. This is a journey Kamal and Vishvanath undertook for us. It's painful to watch, but along the journey there were many pleasant incidents, beautiful music, brilliant dances (I was told tweaked for cinema audience) and most importantly heartbreaking performances.
  
  Speaking of heartbreak, Jaya Pradha, while being painfully beautiful, gives a wonderful performance - a crutch to kamal at first, and then the source of the crunch in his heart.
  
  Ilayaraja is Ilayaraja. My favourite song of this track is Veedham. Powerful song. Powerful music. I'm getting goosebump as I write this.
  
  Fuuny enough, much through the first half an hour or so, you actually forget that it is a movie dubbed from Telugu. That is the impact of the performances.
  
  I'd revisit this movie any time. It's worth it. It's a movie that one should never forget. Especially Kamal, if he were to look back and figure out how in hell he became one of the best actors around (I said 'one of the' not to invite debate)
  
  

• From: sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar on Fri Mar 16 10:22:44 2007.

  [Full View]

  nice of u groucho, now it looks good
  
  http://myspb.blogspot.com/2006/10/blog-post_19.html
  
  this link is alread y posted, good rev on Salangai Oli
  
  

• From: Erica on Sat Mar 17 12:38:51 2007.

  [Full View]

  Alek Niranjan wrote:

  ajithfederer wrote: erica may be u can offer the telugu interpretation of the words sagara sangamam and swathy muthyam Federer Sagara Sangamam -> Kadalgalin Sangamamam Swathy Muthyam -> Pure Pearl

  
  
  AF, Alex has given the exact meaning
  
  

• From: great on Sun Mar 18 2:17:27 2007.

  [Full View]

  PadamNa ithu padam oru chinna varutham ithu direct tamil movie illa .
  
  Kamal
  Illayaraja
  Vishwanath
  Jayapradha
  
  
  
  
  Its easily one of the best movie of KH .
  
  

• From: thimuru on Sun Mar 18 8:06:45 2007.

  [Full View]

  the rerecording piece when jayapadha starts thinking abt the past....
  
  

• From: MADDY on Mon Mar 19 22:25:08 2007.

  [Full View]

  as Selva is stuck with some important personal work, i'm pleased tp inform that movie of the week is -
  
  Enga Veettu Pillai
  
  avar aanai ittar, adhu nadandhadhu
  
  The man of millenium - MGR in the movie of the century - Enga veettu pillai
  
  (pls discuss, also someone give a intro....i have to sleep )
  
  

• From: NOV on Mon Mar 19 22:27:55 2007.

  [Full View]

  
  
  
  Movie Name: Enga Veettu Pillai
  Cast: MGR , Saroja Devi , Nambiar , Nagesh , Rangarao , Pandaribai , Thangavelu , Rathna
  Music: Viswanathan-Ramamurthy
  Direction: Chanakya
  Rating: 3.0 / 5.0
  Review By: Balaji B
  
  
  Movies where the hero has a dual role have dealt with a variety of themes.While the characters the actor portrays are typically brothers, we have hadmovies where one of them is good and the other is evil(Uthama Puthiran) and movies where both are similar and switch places. Enga Veettu Pillai, with MGR in a dual role,distinguishes between the characters by making one a coward and the other abrave man. It has fun by putting the brave man in the coward's place and making himteach a lesson to the people around him. It is an enjoyable entertainer and was oneof MGR's biggest hits.
  Ramu(MGR) is the cowardly one - the heir to all riches of Poonjolai jamin. He hasbeen raised that way by his uncle Narendran(Nambiar). Ramu shivers at the verymention of his uncle's name and a whiplash is Narendran's favorite form of punishment.Narendran wants to get Ramu married to Leela(Saroja Devi) but she is turned off byhis cowardice. Ilango(MGR) is a jobless young man, prone to pick a fight and for this reason, the cause of trouble for his mother. Circumstances lead to Ramu and Ilango taking each others' place. Ilango teaches a lesson to Narendran while Ramu learns the ways of the world.
  
  Nowadays, the theme of mixed identities invariably leads to comedies with the laughsbeing raised through the ways the look-alikes don't fit into their new environments. The'fish out of water' scenario is the one most often used. But here the two MGRs fitinto their new roles quite well. The fun is in the way the others around them reactto the changes in them. Ilango taking the place of Ramu is easily the hands-down winnerin this. The first instance where MGR slaps Nambiar is memorable and exhilaratingwith the reactions of Nambiar and Thangavelu perfectly conveying their surprise.Ofcourse the Naan Aanaiyittaal... song sequence is the pinnacle with MGR givingNambiar a taste of his own medicine.
  
  The position of Ramu(in Ilango's place) is only marginally interesting as the listless romance with Rathna is the only major thing happening. Thankfully, theactions of Ilango are concentrated upon as he is wooed by Saroja Devi and hatedby Nambiar and co. The revelation of the switch is handled neatly and the emotionsof the heroines are not carried on for too long. But the subsequent story thatdigs into the pasts of the two look-alikes is confusing and extends the movieunnecessarily.
  
  One interesting thing to see in older movies in how well they stand up when watchedtoday. Though Enga Veettu Pillai is undeniably entertaining even today, there do exist a few instances which stand out awkwardly. Special effects which make thedual roles possible don't compare favorably even to the effects in Uthama Puthiran. The subservient role of women is quiteobvious in the way Saroja Devi, who is introduced as a 'modern' woman, gleefullyaccepts the demand of a dowry. The lament of Pandaribai about wanting to die atNambiar's feet after he has slapped her and walked out is quite irritating. On theother hand, the fact that the entire meal that MGR has in the hotel costs only sixRupees is bound to make people who lived then sigh in nostalgia!
  
  Nagesh was a permanent feature in movies released during those times and is at handhere too. His mispronounciation of words is quite funny at several places and leadsto many quick laughs. But the extended sequences, like the one where Thangavelu discovers his romance with his daughter, are a lot less funnier.
  
  MGR distinguishes well between the two roles though it is quite obvious he is more atease as the brave Ilango. His strict adherence to his enduring 'good samaritan' imageis obvious in the way he apologises before uttering a single lie to his mother andspeaks out against dowry. Saroja Devi is more irritating than endearing with herattempts to be cute. Nambiar plays the role he has played to perfection in countlessother MGR movies. Needless to say, the movie has some great songs. Kumari PenninUllathile... and Maandhoppu Kaavalkaara... are the melodious duets. Naan Aanaiyittaal... has enough political overtones that show how effectivelyMGR used the medium of cinema.
  
  
  http://www.thenisai.com/tamil/movies/evpillai.htm
  
  

• From: ajithfederer on Mon Mar 19 22:35:24 2007.

  [Full View]

  
  

  Erica wrote:

  Alek Niranjan wrote: ajithfederer wrote: erica may be u can offer the telugu interpretation of the words sagara sangamam and swathy muthyam Federer Sagara Sangamam -> Kadalgalin Sangamamam Swathy Muthyam -> Pure Pearl AF, Alex has given the exact meaning

  
  

• From: Raikkonen on Mon Mar 19 22:41:09 2007.

  [Full View]

  EVP is an amazing movie, my fav MGR movie of all time..
  
  

• From: NOV on Mon Mar 19 22:52:01 2007.

  [Full View]

  SONGS are
  
  naan aanaiyitaal adhu nadandhu vittaal
  
  kumari pennin ullaththilE kudi irukka naan vara vEndum
  
  naan maanthOppil nindrirundhEn avan maampazham vEndum endraan
  
  malarukku thendral pagai aanaal
  
  pen pOnaal indha pen pOnaal
  
  kangalum kaavadi sindhaagattum
  
  

• From: joe on Tue Mar 20 1:26:00 2007.

  [Full View]

  I think ,Enga veetu Pillai will be telecasted this saturday.Last week it was Thillana moganambal.
  
  

• From: Thirumaran on Tue Mar 20 1:34:46 2007.

  [Full View]

  One of the Clean entertainer
  
  MGR was the best choice for the movie and he did with perfection as a coward and angry young man.
  
  The place where both the MGR's go and eat in the same hotel was
  
  Not to forget the Songs.
  
  That too, Naan Aanayittal, Antha Paataai ezhuthiyavar theerkatharisi
  
  who wrote that ? Kannadasan / Vaali
  
  
  
  

• From: Raikkonen on Tue Mar 20 1:43:51 2007.

  [Full View]

  Theres one very funny scene in the movie, Nambiar introduce his mom to Saro's Father..
  i dont remember exact line..
  
  Nambiar : Ivangathan engamma
  Father: Innuma savala?
  
  
  
  i loved the coward MGR, he was so cute...
  
  

• From: Thirumaran on Tue Mar 20 2:22:57 2007.

  [Full View]

  Raikkonen wrote:

  i loved the coward MGR, he was so cute...

  
  
  
  
  Saroja Devi's father was Rangarao
  
  

• From: NOV on Tue Mar 20 2:31:44 2007.

  [Full View]

  Thirumaran wrote:

  MGR was the best choice for the movie and he did with perfection as a coward and angry young man.

  I hope you are aware that Kamal's Thoongaathe Thambi Thoongathe was a remake of EVP.
  
  

• From: NOV on Tue Mar 20 2:34:07 2007.

  [Full View]

  Thirumaran wrote:

  That too, Naan Aanayittal, Antha Paataai ezhuthiyavar theerkatharisi

  vaaliba kavignar, mister vaali
  
  

• From: Thirumaran on Tue Mar 20 2:40:17 2007.

  [Full View]

  NOV wrote:

  Thirumaran wrote: MGR was the best choice for the movie and he did with perfection as a coward and angry young man. I hope you are aware that Kamal's Thoongaathe Thambi Thoongathe was a remake of EVP.

  
  
  MGR was not a drunkard in the movie
  
  

• From: Thirumaran on Tue Mar 20 2:41:07 2007.

  [Full View]

  NOV wrote:

  Thirumaran wrote: That too, Naan Aanayittal, Antha Paataai ezhuthiyavar theerkatharisi vaaliba kavignar, mister vaali

  
  
  I know But still had a doubt
  
  

• From: kb on Tue Mar 20 2:56:13 2007.

  [Full View]

  hotel idli saapadra scene is gud
  
  

• From: NOV on Tue Mar 20 3:34:25 2007.

  [Full View]

  Thirumaran wrote:

  MGR was not a drunkard in the movie

  and neither was Kamal. If I am not wrong, he was given drugs....
  
  anyway, MGR took care of his image and never appeared drunk in any movie. In the only drunk scene - Oli Vilakku - neeyum manidhanaa, he was forced to drink.
  
  

• From: Nerd on Tue Mar 20 10:54:50 2007.

  [Full View]

  kb wrote:

  hotel idli saapadra scene is gud

  
  
  Thats the ONLY scene I remember from the movie and of course the scenes before the naan aanayittAl. Don't remember the movie at all to post a comment or two
  
  

• From: Movie Cop on Tue Mar 20 13:38:00 2007.

  [Full View]

  One interesting tidbit about EVP:
  Vaali wrote the lyrics for "Naan Aanai eittal..." song (excuse me for my spelling ). He mentioned in one of his interviews that he originally starting writing the lyrics along the lines of "Naan Arasan Aanal..." keeping in mind MGR's "demi-god" status among the masses. After reviewing the lyrics, MGR suggested Vaali to remove the word "Arasan" from it as it would be politically inappropriate at that time!
  
  It's nearly more than 2 decades since I saw EVP hence couldn't recall much from the movie except the songs which were all "gems"
  
  Thirumaran - Nov is correct. KH's TTT certainly looks inspired from MGR's EVP if not a "soft remake" of MGR's EVP!
  
  

• From: Thirumaran on Wed Mar 21 0:25:32 2007.

  [Full View]

  Movie Cop wrote:

  Thirumaran - Nov is correct. KH's TTT certainly looks inspired from MGR's EVP if not a "soft remake" of MGR's EVP!

  
  
  I was aware if that
  
  
  

• From: rockydeva on Wed Mar 21 0:37:31 2007.

  [Full View]

  Evergreen movie,
  
  i like that Innocent MGR acting
  
  

• From: VENKIRAJA on Wed Mar 21 0:39:06 2007.

  [Full View]

  Movie Cop wrote:

  One interesting tidbit about EVP: Vaali wrote the lyrics for "Naan Aanai eittal..." song (excuse me for my spelling ). He mentioned in one of his interviews that he originally starting writing the lyrics along the lines of "Naan Arasan Aanal..." keeping in mind MGR's "demi-god" status among the masses. After reviewing the lyrics, MGR suggested Vaali to remove the word "Arasan" from it as it would be politically inappropriate at that time! It's nearly more than 2 decades since I saw EVP hence couldn't recall much from the movie except the songs which were all "gems" Thirumaran - Nov is correct. KH's TTT certainly looks inspired from MGR's EVP if not a "soft remake" of MGR's EVP!

  
  
  arent u aware of ramarajan movies?half of them are EVP remakes.several movies made use of EVP.remember manal kayiru?
  
  

• From: Thirumaran on Wed Mar 21 0:50:51 2007.

  [Full View]

  VENKIRAJA wrote:

  arent u aware of ramarajan movies?half of them are EVP remakes.several movies made use of EVP.remember manal kayiru?

  
  
  Is not Manal Kayiru Visu movie
  
  

• From: joe on Wed Mar 21 4:32:28 2007.

  [Full View]

  Thirumaran wrote:

  VENKIRAJA wrote: arent u aware of ramarajan movies?half of them are EVP remakes.several movies made use of EVP.remember manal kayiru? Is not Manal Kayiru Visu movie

  
  
  Yes,It is Visu movie..Btw,manal kayirukkum EVP -kku ennaiya sampantham
  
  

• From: NOV on Wed Mar 21 4:55:21 2007.

  [Full View]

  joe wrote:

  Btw,manal kayirukkum EVP -kku ennaiya sampantham

  oru vElai rendum color padam engira otrumaiyaa irukkumO...
  
  

• From: thimuru on Wed Mar 21 5:25:00 2007.

  [Full View]

  [quote="NOV"]

  joe wrote:

  Btw,manal kayirukkum EVP -kku ennaiya sampantham

  oru vElai rendum color padam engira otrumaiyaa irukkumO... [/quote
  
  
  
  
  
  

• From: thimuru on Wed Mar 21 5:27:34 2007.

  [Full View]

  Thirumaran wrote:

  VENKIRAJA wrote: arent u aware of ramarajan movies?half of them are EVP remakes.several movies made use of EVP.remember manal kayiru? Is not Manal Kayiru Visu movie

  
  
  rr mgr fan...so no surprise
  
  manal kayiru had different story line
  
  

• From: Nakeeran on Wed Mar 21 6:02:23 2007.

  [Full View]

  Hi Selva Sir
  
  Thanks a lot for picking my choice !
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Thu Mar 22 1:47:43 2007.

  [Full View]

  Nakeeran,
  You are welcome.
  
  Maddy - You forgot to include "Nakeeran"'s name in the intro post. Anyway, thanks !
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Thu Mar 22 1:50:37 2007.

  [Full View]

  NOV wrote:

  Thirumaran wrote: MGR was the best choice for the movie and he did with perfection as a coward and angry young man. I hope you are aware that Kamal's Thoongaathe Thambi Thoongathe was a remake of EVP.

  
  
  There are many more ! IF I could remember, there is a movie which is almost a 100% remake of EVP ! Even the Nambiyaar - MGR episode was an exact copy !
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Thu Mar 22 2:32:14 2007.

  [Full View]

  Seems EVP itself is a remake of NTR film RAMUDU BHEEMUDU (1964)
  
  

• From: joe on Thu Mar 22 2:35:00 2007.

  [Full View]

  selvakumar wrote:

  Seems EVP itself is a remake of NTR film RAMUDU BHEEMUDU (1964)

  
  
  Ofcourse ,both Produced by Ramanaidu.
  
  

• From: rockydeva on Thu Mar 22 2:44:03 2007.

  [Full View]

  Watch EVP in the below link
  
  http://mgrmovies.blogspot.com/2007/02/enga-veettu-pillai-1965.html
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Thu Mar 22 2:53:28 2007.

  [Full View]

  joe wrote:

  selvakumar wrote: Seems EVP itself is a remake of NTR film RAMUDU BHEEMUDU (1964) Ofcourse ,both Produced by Ramanaidu.

  
  
  This Ramanaidu runs E TV now ! Right
  
  

• From: joe on Thu Mar 22 2:58:21 2007.

  [Full View]

  selvakumar wrote:

  joe wrote: selvakumar wrote: Seems EVP itself is a remake of NTR film RAMUDU BHEEMUDU (1964) Ofcourse ,both Produced by Ramanaidu. This Ramanaidu runs E TV now ! Right

  
  
  Now I confused EVP produced by Vijaya combines (who produced UzhaipaaLi and Nammavar).Not sure Ramanaidu is the same.
  
  

• From: villan007 on Thu Mar 22 3:01:48 2007.

  [Full View]

  joe wrote:

  Now I confused EVP produced by Vijaya combines (who produced UzhaipaaLi and Nammavar).Not sure Ramanaidu is the same.

  
  
  thamirabharani producer thanE uzhaipaLi producer.. naagi reddi
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Thu Mar 22 3:03:35 2007.

  [Full View]

  joe wrote:

  Now I confused EVP produced by Vijaya combines (who produced UzhaipaaLi and Nammavar).Not sure Ramanaidu is the same.

  
  
  Vijaya combines belongs to NAAGI REDDY ! RamaNaidu is a different person I think
  
  

• From: rockydeva on Thu Mar 22 3:08:10 2007.

  [Full View]

  for futher details on the movie go to
  
  
  http://mgrmovies.blogspot.com/2007/02/enga-veettu-pillai-1965.html
  
  

• From: Shakthiprabha on Thu Mar 22 7:12:17 2007.

  [Full View]

  One Never gets tired of watching it, time and again.
  
  I am yet to conclude whether its
  
  the story (aaLmaraatta kathai always has a kick)
  
  or
  
  music
  
  or MGR acting (shall we safely call it PRESCENCE or STAR VALUE?)
  
  but yes, I love watcihng the movie.
  
  Its but natural for every normal person, to get a thrill, to watch dare devil personality take over the villains and flabberghast them with interchanged personalities!
  
  

• From: Shakthiprabha on Thu Mar 22 7:21:16 2007.

  [Full View]

  and yes, I am not doing jsutice if I dont talk about MUSIC.
  
  MGR movie's music album, steals the show as usual.
  
  __
  
  MEANINGFUL lyrics!
  
  Malarukku thendral pagai aanal athu malarnthida kathiravan thunai undu
  nilavukku vaanam pagai aanal athu
  nadanthida veru thunai Ethu...
  
  

• From: Nakeeran on Thu Mar 22 8:46:14 2007.

  [Full View]

  My take on EVP :
  
  ENGA VEETTU PILLAI :
  
  Playing 2 characters is always a big challenge to an artist. Not everyone succeeded in distinguishing the characters.
  
  While the characters the actor portrays are typically brothers, we have had movies where one of them is good and the other is evil (Uthama Puthiran) and movies where both are similar and switch places. Enga Veettu Pillai, with MGR in a dual role, distinguishes between the characters by making one a coward and the other a brave man. It has fun by putting the brave man in the coward's place and making him teach a lesson to the people around him. It is an enjoyable entertainer and was one of MGR's biggest hits.
  
  Ramu(MGR-1) is the cowardly one - the heir to all riches of Poonjolai jamin. He has been raised that way by his uncle Narendran(Nambiar). Ramu shivers at the very mention of his uncle's name and a whiplash is Narendran's favorite form of punishment. Narendran wants to get Ramu married to Leela(Saroja Devi) but she is turned off by his cowardice.
  
  Ilango(MGR-2) is a jobless young man, prone to pick a fight and for this reason, the cause of trouble for his mother. Circumstances lead to Ramu and Ilango taking each others' place. Ilango teaches a lesson to Narendran while Ramu learns the ways of the world.
  
  Nowadays, the theme of mixed identities invariably leads to comedies with the laughs being raised through the ways the look-alikes don't fit into their new environments. The 'fish out of water' scenario is the one most often used. But here the two MGRs fit into their new roles quite well. The fun is in the way the others around them react to the changes in them. Ilango taking the place of Ramu is easily the hands-down winner in this.
  
  The first instance where MGR slaps Nambiar is memorable and exhilarating with the reactions of Nambiar and Thangavelu perfectly conveying their surprise. Ofcourse the Naan Aanaiyittaal... song sequence is the pinnacle with MGR giving Nambiar a taste of his own medicine.
  
  Wonder what was running in his mind when MGR sang NAAN AANAYITAAL probably a premonition to what he intended to achieve later ?!
  
  The position of Ramu(in Ilango's place) is only marginally interesting as the listless romance with Rathna is the only major thing happening. Thankfully, the actions of Ilango are concentrated upon as he is wooed by Saroja Devi and hated by Nambiar and co. The revelation of the switch is handled neatly and the emotions of the heroines are not carried on for too long. But the subsequent story that digs into the pasts of the two look-alikes is confusing and extends the movie unnecessarily
  
  One interesting thing to see in older movies in how well they stand up when watched today. Though Enga Veettu Pillai is undeniably entertaining even today, there do exist a few instances which stand out awkwardly. Special effects which make the dual roles possible don't compare favorably even to the effects in Uthama Puthiran. The subservient role of women is quite obvious in the way Saroja Devi, who is introduced as a 'modern' woman, gleefully accepts the demand of a dowry. The lament of Pandaribai about wanting to die at Nambiar's feet after he has slapped her and walked out is quite irritating.
  
  Ilango character is full of blood & aggression. So aggressive even while eating ! One can see this guy eating quite frequently & very fond of good food also !
  
  The best scene probably is the super hit song NAAN AANAYITAAL ADHU NADANDHU VITAAL .
  
  MSV-TK Ramamurthy combination had composed some beautiful songs :
  
  1. Kangalum kaavadi chindadatum
  Its the song after the title which also introduces the timid MGR Ramu , who is fond of dance , music .
  I suspect a political agenda hidden deep into himself becaz there will be a close up shot on MGR when the words NADELLAM UNNAI KANDU PUGAZ PADATTUM
  
  2. Kumari pennin ullathile kudiyiruka naan varavendum
  Ilango and Saroja Devi sing . The song starts with a take actually being shot for a movie which is being watched by both ( the movie also shows Ilango being fond of acting & in pursuit of acting also )
  
  This song was written by Valee . There is a story behind this song . Valee actually wrote thinking about his lover who latter became his wife also !
  
  3. Naan maandhopill ninrirundhen
  For MGR 1 and Ratna , after the cross over & a mild change in the behaviour traits. MGR learns the basics through that lady.
  This song is a TMS special
  
  4. Pen ponaal
  Ilango and SD. Nothing great to write .. The song could have been avoided
  
  5. Malarukku thendral pagayanaal
  Beautiful song for SD and Ratna amidst the confusion / misunderstanding as both MGR characters get mixed up
  I would say that its one of the best of P.Susheela-LR Iswari combination.
  
  This Chanakya directed movie features : M.G.R. - 2 roles/Saroja Devi/Rathna/Nambiar/Nagesh/Thangavelu/ Ranga Rao / Pandari Bhai
  
  Cost of living then :
  It will be quite fascinating & shocking to note that that the entire meal that MGR takes in the hotel costs only six Rupees is bound to make people who lived then sigh in nostalgia!
  
  Nagesh was a permanent feature in movies released during those times and is at hand here too. His mispronounciation of words is quite funny at several places and leads to many quick laughs. But the extended sequences, like the one where Thangavelu discovers his romance with his daughter, are a lot less funnier.
  
  MGR distinguishes well between the two roles though it is quite obvious he is more at ease as the brave Ilango. His strict adherence to his enduring 'good samaritan' image is obvious in the way he apologises before uttering a single lie to his mother and speaks out against dowry.
  
  The great Nambiar plays his character as precise as ever .
  
  It was MGR who used the cinema medium to the best advantage
  
  A movie for the masses
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Thu Mar 22 9:10:09 2007.

  [Full View]

  EVP : Actor Nambiyar - Makkal Thilagam - and his fans
  
  
  An eminent actor Nambiyar who was always the villian in MGR films had a great encounter with MGR fans.
  
  
  In Enga Veetu Pillai, MGR donned two characters one character is coward who gets whipped by Nambiyar.
  
  After the release of the film, Nambiyar was driving through a village, he was stopped by some villagers. He came out of the car and the conversation goes like this;
  
  Villagers : You are the one who lashed MGR right?
  (Actually the conversation was like this >
  Villagers: Nee thaana enga annanah adichathu
  Nambiyaar: Yaaruppa unga annan? naan adikaliyae
  Villagers: enga annan ah unakku theriyaathu. Makkal thilagatha theiryaathu)
  Nambiyar: No I am his friend.
  Villagers : No we saw you lashing MGR in that film?
  Nambiyar : It is a film I am an actor.
  Villagers: Whatever it is you should not beat our Vathiyar (MGR) right if you do it again we will beat you.
  Nambiyar: OK I wont do that, but in that film MGR lashed me back don’t you see that.
  Villagers: Vathiyar will beat you, but you should not.
  
  After getting the assurance from Nambiyar that he wont harm MGR they gave way.
  
  He also mentions that his fans were so much involved with MGR that in a movie "Thirudathae" in climax scene, where Nambiyar is hiding below the staircase to kill MGR and MGR getting down, his fans mostly ladies were shouting "Vathiyaar" be careful Nambiyar in below the staircase. That was the love MGR got from his fans. Even now though 18 years after his death the same feeling is expressed by his Fans.
  Hats off to MGR Fans.
  
  

• From: NOV on Thu Mar 22 9:14:22 2007.

  [Full View]

  Nakeeran wrote:

  My take on EVP :

  
  
  
  http://www.thenisai.com/tamil/movies/evpillai.htm
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Thu Mar 22 9:17:41 2007.

  [Full View]

  NOV wrote:

  Nakeeran wrote: My take on EVP : http://www.thenisai.com/tamil/movies/evpillai.htm

  
  
  Nakeeran sir,
  Neenga thaan appoo BBTHOTS fame Balaji ah !???
  
  

• From: NOV on Thu Mar 22 9:23:28 2007.

  [Full View]

  selvakumar wrote:

  Neenga thaan appoo BBTHOTS fame Balaji ah !???

  you can see that altho the whole article is there, certain parts have been added towards the end.
  
  the irony is I gave this article in the intro post of EVP with a link!
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Thu Mar 22 9:37:55 2007.

  [Full View]

  NOV wrote:

  selvakumar wrote: Neenga thaan appoo BBTHOTS fame Balaji ah !??? you can see that altho the whole article is there, certain parts have been added towards the end. the irony is I gave this article in the intro post of EVP with a link!

  
  
  O.K. I see many of BALAJI's reviews getting replicated across sites like thenisai
  
  

• From: Nakeeran on Thu Mar 22 9:40:21 2007.

  [Full View]

  Selva Sir
  
  Ellam mixed stuff dhaan ! Ange inge konjam konjam kallakki kallaki presentation seidhullen.
  
  Actually, there is a hardcore MGR fan by name Roop who runs a beautiful site for MGR.
  
  Visit here :
  
  mgrroop.blogspot
  
  

• From: NOV on Thu Mar 22 9:43:29 2007.

  [Full View]

  Please ensure that you give the links if you have posted articles from elsewhere. We DO NOT support plagarism.
  
  And never ever offer someone else's views as yours!
  
  

• From: Designer on Thu Mar 22 9:46:15 2007.

  [Full View]

  One of my all time favorite song is this one from 'Enga Veettu Pillai' :
  
  naan aaNai ittAl adhu nadanthu vittAl
  intha EzhaigaL vEdhanai padamaattAr
  uyir uLLavarai siru thunbam illai
  ivar kaNNIr kadalilE vizhamaattAr
  ivar kaNNIr kadalilE vizhamaattAr
  
  oru thavaRu seythaal athai therinthu seythaal
  avan thEvan enRaalum vidamaattEn
  
  This song has impressed me since childhood, mainly bcos Makkal Thilagam MGR emotes the song with such style and panache.
  Lyrics and music is also good.
  
  Btw I had also seen the Bollywood version of this movie (*ing Sunil Dutt, father of Sanjay Dutt), but somehow didnt find it as impressive as 'Enga Veettu Pillai' - despite the fact that in those days I used to prefer watching Bollywood films to Tamil films.
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Thu Mar 22 9:51:57 2007.

  [Full View]

  NOV wrote:

  Please ensure that you give the links if you have posted articles from elsewhere. We DO NOT support plagarism. And never ever offer someone else's views as yours!

  
  
  Agree with you 100% NOV.
  
  One more purpose of this thread is to collect rare information like this on several movies. That is why I generally google a lot and post the relevant info here.
  
  Nakeeran sir - I know MGRROOP's blog. Infact, the Nambiar article I posted above is from his blog only though I remember the tamil version of the same !
  
  

• From: Thirumaran on Thu Mar 22 10:16:40 2007.

  [Full View]

  NOV wrote:

  Please ensure that you give the links if you have posted articles from elsewhere. We DO NOT support plagarism. And never ever offer someone else's views as yours!

  
  
  
  
  

• From: tacinema on Thu Mar 22 11:09:03 2007.

  [Full View]

  Good pick. The link provides nice synopsis of EVP. Some critic points:
  
  ** If everyone feels the movie is excellent, why is it getting only 3 out of 5 from the author? I agree mostly with the author Balaji. MGR as a brave personality was too good and close to excellent, but as an innocent personality, I dont think he convinced common public. In my view, MGR fails to bring out the innocent personality.
  ** I don't know how this movie became one of the biggest hits of MGR; the songs must have played a major role. On comparison, I would say MGR's Kudiyiruntha koil was better.
  ** Overall, a good entertainment movie.
  
  BTW, there is an NT movie that just mimics EVP. Incidentally, this movie was also made by the same producer who made EVP. Any guess?
  
  

• From: Nakeeran on Thu Mar 22 11:42:28 2007.

  [Full View]

  Tacinema
  
  Is it Vasantha maligai ?
  
  

• From: thamiz on Thu Mar 22 16:36:50 2007.

  [Full View]

  VsanthamaaLigai has nothing to do with EVP!
  
  

• From: thamiz on Thu Mar 22 16:38:22 2007.

  [Full View]

  tacinema:
  
  Let me make a wild guess!
  
  ennai pOl oruvan by any chance I have not seen EPO but I thought the name sounded sensible!
  
  

• From: thamiz on Thu Mar 22 16:42:00 2007.

  [Full View]

  Or, may be balE paaNdiyaa? Because paaNdiyan role is tough but other other shivaji role is sort of "funny"!
  
  

• From: tacinema on Thu Mar 22 22:22:54 2007.

  [Full View]

  It is Vani Rani. There is a major difference - MGR role was done by the heroine Vanishree. NT's role is almost like a guest appearance and the movie has got some fine songs.
  It is a fun-filled NT movie and Murali Srinivasan touched briefly about this movie in NT-part 1 thread.
  
  

• From: bingleguy on Thu Mar 22 22:29:57 2007.

  [Full View]

  Nice movie .... Enga veetu pillai ....
  Thuruthuru character - saadhuvaana character .... rendaiyum nalla blend panni nadichirukkaaru Makkal Thilagam !
  
  naan aanai ittal song .... ellorai polavum enakkum romba pidicha paatu ....
  
  

• From: thamiz on Fri Mar 23 10:30:50 2007.

  [Full View]

  tacinema wrote:

  It is Vani Rani. There is a major difference - MGR role was done by the heroine Vanishree. NT's role is almost like a guest appearance and the movie has got some fine songs. It is a fun-filled NT movie and Murali Srinivasan touched briefly about this movie in NT-part 1 thread.

  
  
  oh, that! It was coming to my mind but I just kept aside as I was concentrating on Shivaji!
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Mon Mar 26 0:04:23 2007.

  [Full View]

  Watched EVP once again ! ( Sun TV).
  Though there are many scenes which you will love to see, the scene where we eagerly wait for Makkal Thilagam to take a shot at Nambiyar is the highlight of this film. Not to forget the "Naan Aanaiyittal" song. Gethu song and superb lyrics !
  
  

• From: NOV on Mon Mar 26 4:22:19 2007.

  [Full View]

  tacinema wrote:

  It is Vani Rani. There is a major difference - MGR role was done by the heroine Vanishree. NT's role is almost like a guest appearance and the movie has got some fine songs. It is a fun-filled NT movie and Murali Srinivasan touched briefly about this movie in NT-part 1 thread.

  Vani Rani was a remake of Dharmendra Hema Malini starrer, Seetha Aur Geetha.
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Wed Mar 28 0:05:21 2007.

  [Full View]

  Vedam Puthithu
  
  Cast:
  
  Amala as Vaidehi
  Charu Haasan as Neelkanth Sastry (as Charuhasan)
  Janagaraj as Vaidehi's Suitor
  Nizhalgal Ravi as Widowed Forest Ranger
  Satyaraj as Balu Thevar
  
  - Timeless movie on casteism.. Satyaraj and Bharathiraja at their best.
  
  Friends,
  Thanks for sharing your comments on EVP. BTW, I didn't get much info online for Vedam Puthithu. please do provide the same on the movie.
  
  Music - IR thaane
  
  
  

• From: joe on Wed Mar 28 0:08:54 2007.

  [Full View]

  selvakumar wrote:

  Music - IR thaane

  
  
  Illa..But I couldn't recall his name now
  
  

• From: Hulkster on Wed Mar 28 0:08:55 2007.

  [Full View]

  selvakumar wrote:

  Music - IR thaane

  
  
  Devendran or is it hamsalekha?
  
  

• From: joe on Wed Mar 28 0:09:19 2007.

  [Full View]

  Yes,It is devendran KannukkuL NooRu nilavaa is excellent song.
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Wed Mar 28 0:10:22 2007.

  [Full View]

  I thought it was IR
  Confusing indeed !
  
  Tough to recall the songs even. Can someone provide the list of the songs in the movie?
  
  

• From: rocketboy on Wed Mar 28 0:11:49 2007.

  [Full View]

  Kai kuttai Kaathal Kaditham is one fantastic song. Even after many years it still strikes a chord Amala looked very beautiful in this movie. .
  
  Selva superb pick
  
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Wed Mar 28 0:20:47 2007.

  [Full View]

  rocketboy wrote:

  Kai kuttai Kaathal Kaditham is one fantastic song. Even after many years it still strikes a chord Amala looked very beautiful in this movie. . Selva superb pick

  
  
  Thanks Ya.. "Kai Kuttai Kaathal Kaditham" is an amazing song.
  
  Whenever I remember this movie, Satyaraj comes to my mind. I must say : it is one of his best.
  
  Not to forget BR too.
  
  

• From: NOV on Wed Mar 28 0:41:33 2007.

  [Full View]

  
  
  

• From: NOV on Wed Mar 28 0:43:51 2007.

  [Full View]

  songs are:
  
  puththam pudhu Olai varum
  
  mandhiram sonnEn vandhuvidu
  
  kannukkul nooru nilavaa
  
  I lost a bet with my sis when I insisted that mandhiram sonnEn was by SPB
  
  

• From: thinkfloyd on Wed Mar 28 0:50:04 2007.

  [Full View]

  arumayAna padam
  
  Though more verbose rather than visual, it was powerful indeed...
  Decent performance by Sathyaraj.. Janakaraj and Saritha were terrific...
  
  Of course, the 'slap' scene is immortal and my favorite too
  
  

• From: swathy on Wed Mar 28 1:03:34 2007.

  [Full View]

  Excellent movie
  
  

• From: joe on Wed Mar 28 1:16:31 2007.

  [Full View]

  The famous dialogues are
  
  "பாலுத்தேவர் பாலுத்தேவர் -ன்னு சொல்லுறீங்களே .பாலு உங்க பெயர் .தேவர்-ங்கரது நீங்க படிச்சு வாங்கின பட்டமா?'
  
  "நான் கரையேறிட்டேன் .நீங்க எப்போ கரையேறப் போறீங்க"
  
  
  
  

• From: unhappyboy on Wed Mar 28 1:21:26 2007.

  [Full View]

  joe wrote:

  The famous dialogues are "பாலுத்தேவர் பாலுத்தேவர் -ன்னு சொல்லுறீங்களே .பாலு உங்க பெயர் .தேவர்-ங்கரது நீங்க படிச்சு வாங்கின பட்டமா?' "நான் கரையேறிட்டேன் .நீங்க எப்போ கரையேறப் போறீங்க"

  
  
  Any movie that attacks a certain caste becomes extremely popular. I wonder why.
  
  

• From: smith on Wed Mar 28 1:25:01 2007.

  [Full View]

  One interesting sidelihght is that when the movie got released, there were protests that it showed a particular community in very bad light.
  
  

• From: joe on Wed Mar 28 1:26:39 2007.

  [Full View]

  I think this is the first movie BR did without IR.
  
  

• From: unhappyboy on Wed Mar 28 1:59:54 2007.

  [Full View]

  smith wrote:

  One interesting sidelihght is that when the movie got released, there were protests that it showed a particular community in very bad light.

  
  
  And which community is that? IS that why IR refused to compose music for this film?
  
  

• From: smith on Wed Mar 28 2:03:48 2007.

  [Full View]

  The community which is the favourite whipping boy of the medium, got it?
  
  No, this was not the reason for IR not doing the film. I guess, it was the IR-VM split, not sure.
  
  

• From: Roshan on Wed Mar 28 2:08:06 2007.

  [Full View]

  A lovely movie !!
  
  My all time favourite Sathyaraj movie. Great performances by Sathyaraj, Saritha, Amala, Charuhaasan, Nizhalgal Ravi and that littly boy.
  
  KannnukkuL nooru nilavaa and puthum puthu Olai are wonderful songs by Chitra.
  
  

• From: Nakeeran on Wed Mar 28 3:40:33 2007.

  [Full View]

  A top class movie.
  
  ONE OF THE VERY BEST OF TAMIL CINEMA .
  
  BR beautifully closes the movie with his customary style DAMN WITH CASTE . We are all human beings .
  
  And that boy finally calling Satyaraj as Appa is really touching & it says all.
  
  The best movie for Puratchi Thamizar Sathiiiiiiii
  
  Nice , lovely songs, challenging Isainyani. BR for a moment proved that he can survive even without IR's association !
  
  Kannukkul 100 nilava is real class song & as good as any IR compo !
  
  Beautiful camera work !
  
  The ever charming Amals , in traditional tamilian dressing ! Vow !
  
  The whole Sathiyaraj's family quickly giving up their practices for the sake of that boy are really wonderful scenes !
  
  Many touching dialogues . To name one :
  
  Rasa, endha kovillukku ponaalum ella saamiyum onnudhan !
  
  Sankaraaa Vaa rasaa .
  
  
  Another scene :
  
  Baluthevarnu solreengale, adhu neenga vangina pattamaa !!
  
  A memorable movie
  
  Great pick Selva Sirr
  
  

• From: MADDY on Wed Mar 28 3:42:18 2007.

  [Full View]

  there are set of ideas and thinking which you are born with.......
  there are incidents which make u think and try to change ur ideas and thinking......
  there are some events which break and shatter ur preset ideas,notions and conventions......
  
  in my case i was born with the thinking that Maniratnam is the best tamil director i'm going to see in my lifetime.....
  Vedam pudhidhu made me think and tried to change my initial thinking
  mudhal mariyadhai was one ripper of a movie which shattered my preconceived notion that no one can be better than Mani...
  
  (yes i saw many mani movies first and then vedam pudhidhu and then mudhal mariyadhai)
  
  a classic from BR..... .....with a very good message.........oru director-na society pathhi oru akkarai irukkanum.........suthhi nadakkara thappa than paarvaiyala solli makkalukku vellakannum.....avan dhaan oru nalla director.......
  
  the thing i liked abt this movie was he questioned many sections of the society and their thinking , not just a particular community......2 scenes to validate my points:
  
  1. the boy questioning the saamiar as to y he needs ppl. to carry him??
  2. asking sathyaraj y he always uses his caste name while spelling out his name
  
  sathyaraj was amazingly subtle and controlled the movie very well.....saritha was equally good with her performance as a village woman......songs were very good and yes they were not by Ilayaraja as popularly thought by my generation guys.... .....BR was desperate to find a alternate to raaja and tried many good guys like Hamsalekha,Devendran etc until he stuck gold in 1993.....
  
  Vedham pudhidhu - one of the important movies for me which changed my attitude on the great man Bharathiraja....
  
  

• From: joe on Wed Mar 28 3:46:07 2007.

  [Full View]

  Another movie People may assume IR did music ,but by Devendran was 'MannukkuL Vairam' (NT movie) with great song "Ithazhodu Ithazh serum neram"
  
  

• From: joe on Wed Mar 28 3:46:45 2007.

  [Full View]

  Maddy,
  Very good post
  
  

• From: groucho070 on Wed Mar 28 4:19:07 2007.

  [Full View]

  One of those movie that makes me proud to be a Sathyaraj fan. It could have easily been an actor proof role (meaning well written, three dimensional character) but as usual, Sathyaraj brings something extra to the table. He is a well-meaning man, but finds a tiny little hypochrite in him when the boy asks him about his "pattam".
  
  The subject is very touchy. But I think BR managed to balance it well. Each tiem I see this movie I'd think, "Whatever happened to the real Barathiraja."
  
  The background score is good, but we could see that Devendran was influenced by IR. He should, this kind of film needs the kind of treatment that IR can give.
  
  I don't have much to add...Maddy and other's have posted great stuff.
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Wed Mar 28 4:21:03 2007.

  [Full View]

  Maddy,
  So, the Music director of the movie is HAMSALEKHA ! Right
  
  

• From: joe on Wed Mar 28 4:23:15 2007.

  [Full View]

  selvakumar wrote:

  Maddy, So, the Music director of the movie is HAMSALEKHA ! Right

  
  
  Selva,
  Seems you havn't read other posts .It is not hamsalekah..It is Devendran. Hamsalekha is for Kodi Parakkuthu.
  
  

• From: NOV on Wed Mar 28 4:23:38 2007.

  [Full View]

  Devendaran!
  
  hamsalEka was for bharathirajavin kodi parakkudhu (remember sElai kattum pennukoru vaasam undu?)
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Wed Mar 28 4:37:13 2007.

  [Full View]

  From the posts, I thought HAMSALEKHA & DEVENDRAN are the two MDs who scored for VP !
  
  Anyway, Thanks for the clarification Joe and NOV
  
  

• From: Roshan on Wed Mar 28 5:09:33 2007.

  [Full View]

  Superb post by Maddy !!! intha maathiri uNamai pEsa thairiyam vENdum. Appreciate your open and straight forward attitude !!
  
  I remember in an internview Sathyaraj telling about his son Sibi complaining that Sathyaraj does not do strong roles like in Vedham Puthithu any more
  
  

• From: groucho070 on Wed Mar 28 5:28:09 2007.

  [Full View]

  Roshan wrote:

  I remember in an internview Sathyaraj telling about his son Sibi complaining that Sathyaraj does not do strong roles like in Vedham Puthithu any more

  
  
  I get this discontent very often. He can be a great character actor. Thank god he is doing Periyar now. Whether he is justifying it or not, at least he can do a decent job.
  
  But VP offered real character job. He is not the hero. The kid is. He provides the point of view from the other side and realises that he himself has weak points.
  
  Plus...the way he handles the lost of son. It's tough to get roles like this anymore.
  
  

• From: MADDY on Wed Mar 28 5:30:58 2007.

  [Full View]

  wow, thanks joe,roshan and groucho.....
  
  i really think there can be no one so artistically subtle and suggestive filmmaker than BR..... .....oh a preset notion again..... ......Ameer might break it one day
  
  yes forgot to add it was Sathyaraj's best performance as an actor.......
  
  sorry selva for giving u wrong info in the morning..... ........i got confused with Kodi parakkadhu and this movie.....
  
  but having doubts on its BO status - was it a average grosser atleast??
  
  

• From: joe on Wed Mar 28 5:34:49 2007.

  [Full View]

  MADDY wrote:

  was it a average grosser atleast??

  
  
  I think it was a hit ,but not super hit.
  
  

• From: smith on Wed Mar 28 5:45:30 2007.

  [Full View]

  The movie flopped at the B.O
  
  

• From: Roshan on Wed Mar 28 6:53:31 2007.

  [Full View]

  NO!!!!!!!!! The movie was a HIT !!
  
  Smith,
  
  Would you please stop pouring negative trash where ever you enter ?
  
  

• From: dsath on Wed Mar 28 11:36:13 2007.

  [Full View]

  In VP, BR has shown how an issue like casteism can be handled sensitively. Wonderful performances by all involved, the casting couldn’t have been any better. The music was not too overpowering and the conclusion was bold for its time. They don’t make movies like this now.
  
  
  

• From: great on Wed Mar 28 11:40:08 2007.

  [Full View]

  romba nalla movie aana yenakku thaan gyabagam illa except for few scenes.
  
  Naan kaRai eRittean neenga eppa kaRai eRa poreenga
  
  

• From: Nerd on Wed Mar 28 11:40:52 2007.

  [Full View]

  Superb movie Would easily feature in the Top 3 list of any BR lover. Powerful performances, excellent charecterization, strong script (Selvaraj again, I think), sharp dialogues, very good songs made this movie a classic. My only grouse was with the BG score, one area where IR was sorely missed
  
  

• From: thamiz on Wed Mar 28 12:00:38 2007.

  [Full View]

  Roshan wrote:

  NO!!!!!!!!! The movie was a HIT !! Smith, Would you please stop pouring negative trash where ever you enter ?

  
  
  Well said, R!
  
  He should take a break!
  
  

• From: ajithfederer on Wed Mar 28 12:04:13 2007.

  [Full View]

  one good movie....
  
  

• From: nemesis786 on Wed Mar 28 12:06:00 2007.

  [Full View]

  is it a controversial movie?
  
  

• From: villan007 on Wed Mar 28 12:06:30 2007.

  [Full View]

  satyaraj aRaivaangra scene mattum than paarthiruken
  
  

• From: VENKIRAJA on Wed Mar 28 12:11:26 2007.

  [Full View]

  i've saw the movie in bits n pieces.i jus remember the scene quoted by AF
  
  

• From: rocketboy on Thu Mar 29 11:48:53 2007.

  [Full View]

  I had written a big review for the movie ( Actually more about the river and the present Cauvery issue ) and when I pressed the submit button I was timed out .
  
  

• From: maithree on Thu Mar 29 11:56:28 2007.

  [Full View]

  nemesis786 wrote:

  is it a controversial movie?

  
  
  That's why it was such a GREAT movie! It was a very sensitive subject, but bharathiraja had taken it in such a way that no one found it offencive! That shows how good of a director he is!
  
  A couple scenes I loved!!
  
  *Sathyaraj the Periyar Follower has Thevar as his last name, and he says that he is agianst the Caste System etc etc, and the kid points that out, and Satyaraj feels like he just got slapped.
  
  *The religious Guru who is being carried by his followers realizes how he is not exactly doing what he preches. He realizes this because the boy points this out. And then he starts to walk.
  
  Those are just a couple scenes which always come to mind when I think abt the movie.
  
  

• From: maithree on Thu Mar 29 11:58:05 2007.

  [Full View]

  smith wrote:

  The movie flopped at the B.O

  
  
  Matter theriyalai na pesama irukanaum! It was a Solid Hit!
  
  

• From: Nakeeran on Thu Mar 29 12:04:19 2007.

  [Full View]

  maithree wrote:

  smith wrote: The movie flopped at the B.O Matter theriyalai na pesama irukanaum! It was a Solid Hit!

  
  
  Nahee Nahee . I doubt . I think it had a decent run & well appreciated by everyone but not a hit . It was not a commercial success.
  
  

• From: nemesis786 on Thu Mar 29 13:01:49 2007.

  [Full View]

  Nakeeran wrote:

  maithree wrote: smith wrote: The movie flopped at the B.O Matter theriyalai na pesama irukanaum! It was a Solid Hit! Nahee Nahee . I doubt . I think it had a decent run & well appreciated by everyone but not a hit . It was not a commercial success.

  
  
  apo anbe sivam madiriya
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Thu Mar 29 22:49:14 2007.

  [Full View]

  / dig
  Maithree = surya vaaa
  / dig
  
  

• From: ajithfederer on Thu Mar 29 23:19:18 2007.

  [Full View]

  athey doubt than raaj enakkum
  

  selvakumar wrote:

  / dig Maithree = surya vaaa / dig

  
  

• From: selvakumar on Thu Mar 29 23:24:46 2007.

  [Full View]

  rocketboy wrote:

  I had written a big review for the movie ( Actually more about the river and the present Cauvery issue ) and when I pressed the submit button I was timed out .

  
  
  It is better to save LENGTHY POSTS in a file before submitting them in the hub. Experience
  
  

• From: Jabroni on Thu Mar 29 23:30:29 2007.

  [Full View]

  rocketboy
  
  you can get back to it by clicking the 'go back'
  
  I have been successful
  
  

• From: nemesis786 on Fri Mar 30 2:29:34 2007.

  [Full View]

  one idea :
  
  write them in a wordpad file and copy paste it here
  
  

• From: dsath on Fri Mar 30 5:15:36 2007.

  [Full View]

  nemesis786 wrote:

  Nakeeran wrote: maithree wrote: smith wrote: The movie flopped at the B.O Matter theriyalai na pesama irukanaum! It was a Solid Hit! Nahee Nahee . I doubt . I think it had a decent run & well appreciated by everyone but not a hit . It was not a commercial success. apo anbe sivam madiriya

  
  I think the movie was a big hit.
  
  

• From: maithree on Fri Mar 30 16:37:55 2007.

  [Full View]

  ajithfederer wrote:

  athey doubt than raaj enakkum selvakumar wrote: / dig Maithree = surya vaaa / dig

  
  
  
  
  

• From: Kollywoodfan on Fri Mar 30 17:26:58 2007.

  [Full View]

  Nice movie, and splendid performance from Amala who also looks ravishing.
  
  Songs were beautiful and picturized simply yet elegantly.
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Mon Apr 9 8:54:28 2007.

  [Full View]

  AVAL ORU THODAR KATHAI
  
  Director : Balachandar K
  Produced by : Andal
  Original Novel : Perumal M.S
  
  Cast Member SUJATHA
  Cast Member RAMAKRISHNA
  Cast Member GANESH, Jai
  Cast Member GOKULNATH,
  Cast Member VIJAYAKUMAR
  
  

• From: NOV on Mon Apr 9 9:05:49 2007.

  [Full View]

  not another KN film!
  
  now all the anti-KB troupe will have a field day.
  
  

• From: NOV on Mon Apr 9 9:19:32 2007.

  [Full View]

  I dont know where you got your info Selva, but AOT introduced several new actors, among them...
  
  Sujatha - evergreen actress
  Sripriya - sexy then humpty dumpty now
  Vijayakumar - Hero turned character actor
  Jaiganesh - Villain turned character actor
  Fatafat Jayalakshmi - Suicide in movie, suicide in real life.
  
  A very young Kamalahasan played a small role in the film and even had one song for him - kadavul amaithu vaiththa mEdai. he loves sripriya but is afraid to tell and someone else comes and abEs her.
  
  story is about sujatha, a tough woman who sacrifices her life and love for her family.
  
  great songs: kadavul amaiththu vaiththa mEdai (kamal at sriprya's wedding)
  deivam thantha veedu (jaiganesh when asked to get out of the house)
  kannilE enna undu (story-in-song - typical KB fare)
  adi ennadi ulagam (fatafat and her take it easy life)
  
  teaser: who can remember jayakanthan's sila nErangalil sila manidhargal in this movie?
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Mon Apr 9 9:28:30 2007.

  [Full View]

  NOV,
  Let us hope that this won't get discussed aggressively in the MISC Section.
  
  NOV, I didn't find much info on the movie. I do remember a few things which u have already given in a single post !
  
  

• From: NOV on Mon Apr 9 9:38:58 2007.

  [Full View]

  the film can be examined from many angles. KB does not spell out many things and used imagery to convey messages. one was the SNSM reference.
  another was sripriya (young widow) who sings naa kOyi ... the kati patang song.
  
  something fabulous - the entire climax was just visuals and MSV's great score. nary a word in the last 10 mins!
  
  

• From: Roshan on Mon Apr 9 10:27:33 2007.

  [Full View]

  One of my favourite movies again
  
  Thanks Selva for some nice picks.
  
  I have only one thing to say about this movie. Comparing with the lead roles like Vijayakumar and Jeyganesh - I'm sure no body at that time would have ever imagined a lean, ordinary looking guy, who did an ordinary role as a mimic would reach several milestones , become an icon of Tamil/Indian cinema and remain on the top even at his 50s.
  
  

• From: Rajkumar_mj on Mon Apr 9 10:46:08 2007.

  [Full View]

  Roshan wrote:

  One of my favourite movies again Thanks Selva for some nice picks. I have only one thing to say about this movie. Comparing with the lead roles like Vijayakumar and Jeyganesh - I'm sure no body at that time would have ever imagined a lean, ordinary looking guy, who did an ordinary role as a mimic would reach several milestones , become an icon of Tamil/Indian cinema and remain on the top even at his 50s.

  
  
  Roshan
  
  Well said.
  
  

• From: rajeshkrv on Mon Apr 9 18:16:22 2007.

  [Full View]

  yet another master piece from KB
  
  thanks for the pick
  
  

• From: Querida on Tue Apr 10 0:28:55 2007.

  [Full View]

  What a heartrenching movie...and something that women even now can relate too...her fate she accepts so wholeheartedly in the ending....like she knew it was too good to be true... i watched this movie close to "Avargal" and "Manathil uruthi vendum" and "Sila Nerangalil Sila Manidhargal"...am a great fan of KB because of it and also my respect for tamil movies only grew after watching these masterpieces...I still haven't been able to watch many of his movies.
  
  The brother like the prodigal son finally...finally turns himself around...and ends up gone...the spurned lover who was never loved...the widowed sister who loves in shadows...
  
  

• From: swathy on Tue Apr 10 1:12:16 2007.

  [Full View]

  Roshan wrote:

  One of my favourite movies again Thanks Selva for some nice picks. I have only one thing to say about this movie. Comparing with the lead roles like Vijayakumar and Jeyganesh - I'm sure no body at that time would have ever imagined a lean, ordinary looking guy, who did an ordinary role as a mimic would reach several milestones , become an icon of Tamil/Indian cinema and remain on the top even at his 50s.

  
  
  
  
  

• From: MADDY on Tue Apr 10 2:35:37 2007.

  [Full View]

  Aval oru thodarkathai .......though i love KB's antics, this movie was way too intolerable..... ,......irritating to the core.....
  
  ayyo , yen avalavu sogathha puzhinjaarunnu innum enakku puriyala
  
  "deivam thantha veedu" and "kadavul amaithhu" songs are the only things i would like to see in this movie.....
  
  

• From: thimuru on Tue Apr 10 2:37:41 2007.

  [Full View]

  MADDY wrote:

  Aval oru thodarkathai .......though i love KB's antics, this movie was way too intolerable..... ,......irritating to the core..... ayyo , yen avalavu sogathha puzhinjaarunnu innum enakku puriyala "deivam thantha veedu" and "kadavul amaithhu" songs are the only things i would like to see in this movie.....

  
  
  lyrics
  
  

• From: Roshan on Tue Apr 10 3:21:13 2007.

  [Full View]

  thimuru wrote:

  MADDY wrote: Aval oru thodarkathai .......though i love KB's antics, this movie was way too intolerable..... ,......irritating to the core..... ayyo , yen avalavu sogathha puzhinjaarunnu innum enakku puriyala "deivam thantha veedu" and "kadavul amaithhu" songs are the only things i would like to see in this movie..... lyrics

  
  
  Yes lovely lyrics. Theyvam thantha veedu..
  
  

• From: Nakeeran on Tue Apr 10 4:42:51 2007.

  [Full View]

  Nice move but why KB always shows men in poor light ?
  
  Why this woman glorification always ?
  
  I think Kamal already played a good character in Aboorva ragangal before this movie ? Right ?
  Which came first ?
  
  And that mother ( of Fatafat ) character is really aweful . Indigestable characterisation .
  
  Sujatha is the main force . Why that JaiGanesh has to die. After all, he came good finally no ? Why not a positive end to that character ?
  
  MSV is the real king of melody. I love Kannile enna undu song . Beautiful tune .
  
  Selva Sir. Edhenna, KB vaaramaa ??
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Tue Apr 10 4:51:36 2007.

  [Full View]

  Nakeeran,
  KB vaaram endru ellaam illa. I rate this as one of the good movies of KB. Obviously there are many other KB gems as well. We are just making it a point that none of the good movies goes unnoticed.
  
  And - Life la +ve uhm irukku -ve uhm irukku. That is why we had legends like NT and MT portraying both the sides and how to carry ourself farward. The directors who came after that, fine tuned the same and gave us "Different" movie.
  
  
  

  Quote:

  Why not a positive end to that character ?

  
  
  That carries the whole message in the movie. I think the whole purpose of this movie is to portray how a responsible woman finds it difficult to fulfil her own desires / ambitions / wishes etc amidst all difficulties. I think it was O.K.
  
  Anyway, Let us agree to disagree and I respect ur opinion.
  /dig
  Just remind me a dialogue from "Ullam Ketkumae" now
  "Life la jeichukittae irundhaa, paithiyamae pudichutum. Life la chinna chinna tholvigal venum" !!
  / dig
  
  

• From: rami on Tue Apr 10 7:31:23 2007.

  [Full View]

  Aval oru Thodarkathai - Though a bit of exaggeration here and there was a good movie to sit and watch. A movie of different cadre among the movies which came out in that period.
  
  The way it starts and the way it ends is almost the same.
  
  The songs in the movie are lovely. Mainly the song "Kadavul amaithu vaitha medai.." the way it outlines the story ..
  
  But I never understood why Sripriya - widow sister of Sujatha, inspite of her attraction to Kamal - a vikatakavi , fells for Vijayakumar - her sisters lover and ends up in marrying him.
  
  

• From: smith on Tue Apr 10 8:05:15 2007.

  [Full View]

  also the climax..there was no need of sujatha getting her sister married to her suitor..since he was large herated, she could have married him & got her sister married off in a good way.
  
  seems they had already decided on the title & wanted to justify it
  
  

• From: Shakthiprabha on Tue Apr 17 0:53:48 2007.

  [Full View]

  hmm.. I agree with ramya, exaggeration to a large extent.
  
  Shripriya character was SIMPLY SELFISH AND PATHETIC.
  Worst ever!
  
  I agree iwth smith, sujatha's rich HER SUITOR could have supported them all, atleast temporarily.
  
  Anyway THATS NOT AN ENDING, probably one assumes she has another life, which she is yet to find.
  
  Frustration of a 30 year old, PORTRAYED very well.
  
  Songs are awesome, good script. Sujatha wins in her frist movie.
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Tue Apr 17 4:43:27 2007.

  [Full View]

  One more important thing is : KB never inserts characters as mere fillers. In this movie, even the bus conductor had a scene in which he can leave his mark
  
  Conductor : "Sorry maa unga kalyanathukku vara mudiyala. Kalyaanam ellam nalla padiya mudinjathungala
  
  Sujatha : Antha bus la porathukku enakku ticket kedaikaleenga
  
  Powerful dialogue !
  
  

• From: joe on Tue Apr 17 4:53:04 2007.

  [Full View]

  Selva,
  It is more than a week .where is announcement of next movie?
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Tue Apr 17 5:05:01 2007.

  [Full View]

  joe wrote:

  Selva, It is more than a week .where is announcement of next movie?

  
  
  Unmai thaan Joe. will post the movie of this week now !
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Tue Apr 17 5:18:56 2007.

  [Full View]

  Oomai Vizhigal
  
  Cast
  
  Ravi chandran
  Vijaykanth
  Saritha
  Arun Pandiyan
  Chandra Sekhar
  Karthik
  ?
  
  Music
  Shankar Ganesh
  
  Director:
  R. Aravindraj
  Writer:
  Aabavaanan (screenplay)
  Genre:
  Crime / Action
  
  

• From: swathy on Tue Apr 17 5:31:19 2007.

  [Full View]

  I don't remember the movie but can't forget the songs.
  
  Tholvi nilai ena ninaithal
  
  Mamarathu poo yeduthu
  
  Kanmani nillu kaaranam sollu
  
  Raathri nerathu poojaiyil
  
  
  selva: how u missed karthik?
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Tue Apr 17 5:34:41 2007.

  [Full View]

  MOW - Till Now
  
  (Thanks to RAMI for the wonderful suggestion)
  
  
  Agni Natchathiram
  
  "Thooral Ninnu Pochu"
  
  ORU THALAI RAAGAM
  
  VEEDU
  
  Kaathalika Neramillai
  
  SINDHU BHAIRAVI
  
  SALANGAI OLI
  
  Enga Veettu Pillai
  
  Vedam Puthithu
  
  AVAL ORU THODAR KATHAI
  
  

  Quote:

  Just a gentle reminder to our dear hubbers: Hubbers who want a particular movie to be listed for discussion can send a PM to me. It can be any movie which you people liked. Whenever you see a movie, you might have come across a few interesting things and you may be keen to share these things. This thread provides the same platform for you. The movies will be listed in a random manner. Veteran hubbers can also suggest a few movies of the late cine personalities which can throw more light on the personalities and their greatness. It can be something like remembering them. Someone who used to sit at the back and do their job. Someone who went unnoticed inspite of their brilliant work. Such movies will be listed as SPECIAL PICKS. For e.g., if we have a birth anniversary / dearth anniversary of PERSONALITY X, hubbers can recommend a movie of them which will be listed as a special pick. IF you have further comments on improving the process and the discussions relevant to this thread, feel free to post them here. Thanks for your cooperation !

  
  

• From: selvakumar on Tue Apr 17 5:36:58 2007.

  [Full View]

  swathy wrote:

  selva: how u missed karthik?

  
  
  Added
  
  

• From: thimuru on Tue Apr 17 5:41:11 2007.

  [Full View]

  sumaarana padam...donno how it is considered as one of the best thrillers!
  
  vijayakanth :Thumbsup:
  
  

• From: Thirumaran on Tue Apr 17 7:04:51 2007.

  [Full View]

  thimuru wrote:

  sumaarana padam...donno how it is considered as one of the best thrillers!

  
  
  
  
  Several scenes were artificial and except for VK and few songs nothing is worth mentioning
  
  This movie does not come under classic or great entertainer or did not had a great run either
  
  

• From: Sanjeevi on Tue Apr 17 7:09:52 2007.

  [Full View]

  Hi i guess,
  
  music by Manoj Kyan and Inai Isai : AapAvAnAn
  
  

• From: rami on Tue Apr 17 7:17:12 2007.

  [Full View]

  Its the music and the "eerie" feeling given by the movie ...
  
  It was new at that time in theatres .. If u watch the movie in TV now, it will be like another episode of "Kaathu Karuppu" ..
  
  

• From: rami on Tue Apr 17 7:21:07 2007.

  [Full View]

  The music in the movie is really good and of a different note ..
  
  You can try this link for the songs ..
  http://music.cooltoad.com/music/category.php?id=10302&page=66&order=title
  
  All the songs leave a haunting effect !
  
  The song "Nilai maarum ulagil " is an excellent "thathuva paadal"
  
  

• From: Roshan on Tue Apr 17 7:28:33 2007.

  [Full View]

  rami wrote:

  The music in the movie is really good and of a different note .. You can try this link for the songs .. http://music.cooltoad.com/music/category.php?id=10302&page=66&order=title All the songs leave a haunting effect ! The song "Nilai maarum ulagil " is an excellent "thathuva paadal"

  
  
  is it nilai maaRum ulagiL or thOlvi nilaiyana ninaithaal?
  
  I dont remember much about this movie. I think the plot was something like - kidnapping girls and removing their eyes and the code word used by the villain is black roses. I am not sure though
  
  

• From: Sanjeevi on Tue Apr 17 7:37:32 2007.

  [Full View]

  Roshan wrote:

  is it nilai maaRum ulagiL or thOlvi nilaiyana ninaithaal?

  
  
  two different songs
  
  thOlvi nilaiyana ninaithaal is my fav. along with mamarathu pooveduthu manjam onnu podava
  
  Omai Vizhigal was runaway hit and after this film, many gave respects to students of film institute.
  
  Aapaavaanan was one of film personalities who tried / achieved to give different
  
  

• From: rami on Tue Apr 17 8:22:52 2007.

  [Full View]

  Roshan wrote:

  rami wrote: The music in the movie is really good and of a different note .. You can try this link for the songs .. http://music.cooltoad.com/music/category.php?id=10302&page=66&order=title All the songs leave a haunting effect ! The song "Nilai maarum ulagil " is an excellent "thathuva paadal" is it nilai maaRum ulagiL or thOlvi nilaiyana ninaithaal? I dont remember much about this movie. I think the plot was something like - kidnapping girls and removing their eyes and the code word used by the villain is black roses. I am not sure though

  
  
  Both the songs are good !! and both songs are from the same movie only !!
  
  

• From: Nerd on Tue Apr 17 10:50:25 2007.

  [Full View]

  Thirumaran wrote:

  This movie does not come under classic or great entertainer or did not had a great run either

  
  
  
  
  The movie was a super hit, AFAIK. I have seen it long back on KTV and yes the movie was a total comedy Barring a few scenes it was a trash and the songs were terrific
  
  Talk about inspirational songs and you can't leave out this one:
  
  thOlvi nilaiyena ninaithAl manithan vaazhvai ninaikkalaamaa
  
  http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fdDCqPn8vfg
  
  Video is a bit funny though
  
  

• From: Sanjeevi on Tue Apr 17 10:57:55 2007.

  [Full View]

  Arunpandiyan's first movie?
  
  

• From: Roshan on Tue Apr 17 13:42:32 2007.

  [Full View]

  Thanks Sanjeevi and Rami for the clarification. As I said I dont remember exactly.
  
  

• From: Shakthiprabha on Tue Apr 17 13:56:05 2007.

  [Full View]

  Ah...
  
  Vedham pudhidu (I forgot to talk bout it when It was there)
  
  A MOVIE which created IMPACT in almost every person.
  
  "Naan karai ErittEn neenga?"
  
  "baalungarathu unga per, devar ngarathu neenga padichu vaangina pattama"
  
  etc were powerful dialogues
  
  CASTE diferentiation STOPS when humanity plays role. LOVELY movie. Great message. MOVIE DID CONVEY a good message. Had good Impact and thereby acheived its primary purpose.
  
  SONGs WERE AWESOME.
  
  

• From: Shakthiprabha on Tue Apr 17 13:58:54 2007.

  [Full View]

  OOmai vizhigaL
  
  I LOVE thrillers.....
  
  All I can say about this movie is
  
  "WOW"
  
  Songs, Cast, Screenplay, SIMPLY AWESOME.
  
  
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Tue Apr 24 2:51:10 2007.

  [Full View]

  I missed out listing a Vikram movie on his birthday in the previous week.
  Vikram fans or anyone can list a good movie of Vikram which can be discussed.
  
  

• From: sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar on Tue Apr 24 2:53:33 2007.

  [Full View]

  1. Kaasi
  2. Thil
  3. Majaa
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Tue Apr 24 2:57:06 2007.

  [Full View]

  Thanks Sakala ! I think it will be apt to discuss KAASI !
  
  Kasi
  
  
  Movie Name: Kasi
  Cast: Vikram , Kaveri , Kavya Madhavan , Rajeev , Aishwarya , Manivannan , Vinu Chakravarthy , Vadivukkarasi , Chandrasekhar , 'Thalaivaasal' Vijay
  Music: Ilaiyaraja
  Direction: Vinayan
  Rating: 3.5 / 5.0
  Review By: Balaji B
  
  Fun, youth and extravagance are undoubtedly the buzzwords in Tamil cinema today. Butdirector Vinayan moves away from all this in Kasi, a movie that revolvesaround a blind singer, and in the process, gives us one of the most affectingmovies in recent times. The movie was originally made in Malayalam as Vasanthiyum LakshmiyumPinne Nyaanum and brought its hero 'Kalabhavan' Mani very close toa National award(the award ultimately went to Mohanlal). Ironically, Vikram, who also lostthe award(for Sethu) the same year, now stars in thisTamil remake.
  
  Kasi(Vikram) has been blind from birth and makes his living singing by the roadside.His father(Vinu Chakravarthy), whose arms and legs are paralysed, his mother(Vadivukkarasi),an asthma patient, and his younger sister Lakshmi(Kavya Madhavan) are dependent uponhim. His elder brother Sevalai('Thalaivasal' Vijay) is a drunkard who snatches up the money Kasi earns while his elder sister's husband(Chandrasekhar) is threateningto send his wife home if he doesn't get the rest of his dowry. A dumb girlKaveri(Kaveri) is in love with Kasi. Kasi(and the rest of the village) thinks the worldof Raghupathy(Rajeev), an ex-MP, who makes annual trips to the village. This timehe has promised to pay for Kasi's eye operation and his sister's marriage. But hehas his own agenda and that brings Kasi's world crashing down.
  
  I am seldom a fan of movies where the director piles on the sadness in an obviouseffort to drive us to tears. And Kasi is definitely is a tearjerker in everysense. There are very few moments of mirth as Vikram, his lover and his sister areshamelessly manipulated and destroyed by Rajeev. But the surprising thing here isthe profound effect their experiences have on us. And the reason for this is the way things are handled by director Vinayan. While the happenings are definitely sad, the characters are realistic and their emotions are natural and underplayed. There areno loud cries or other sentimental outpourings and characters convey their emotionswith sad looks and sorrowful smiles. Our heart goes out to them and that is thedirector's triumph.
  
  Kasi announces its intention of being a tearjerker within a few minutes of starting. Vikram's troubles are introduced one after the other and almost everycharacter who is introduced seems to have a handicap of some kind. But whatdifferentiates the movie from countless other similar tearjerkers is the fact thatthe director doesn't continue to dwell on these sadnesses. Once the initial introductionsare done, he begins to focus on Vikram's naievity, goodheartedness and innocence(see his comment after Chandrasekhar blatantly uses his blindness to get his dowry) and this makes the sadness subtle but powerful. The fact that Vikram doesn't realise what is happening around him makes the film very effective.
  
  The movie is populated with characters that have a big effect, both positive and negative,on us. Kavya Madhavan and Kaveri easily earn our sympathy as Rajeev takes advantage of the love they hold for Vikram. Their predicament is tough and their silence is entirely believable. And as he reveals his gameplan, Rajeev turns into one of the most detestable bad guys in Tamil cinema in recent times. The depravity of his acts, the cheap motive behind them and his outwardly good guy image easily make us hate him. Supporting actors like Manivannan and Aishwarya too portray memorable characters that have their moments.
  
  As Kaveri and Kavya are pulled deeper and deeper into sorrow, the director very effectively contrasts this with Kasi's blissful ignorance of the situation ashe prepares for his sister's wedding(his meeting with the washerwoman is awonderful scene). The director keeps the story moving and successfully keeps us wondering about what will happen next. The climax, while not entirely unexpected, still manages to catch us by surprise with its timing and method of execution. It is powerful while the final ending itself is touching.
  
  Vikram once again proves himself to be an actor par excellence. With only the whitesof his eyes showing, he frequently manages to make us forget that he is justplaying a blind man. His gestures, hand movements and body language embellishhis performance and suggest that he must have spent some time observing blind people their behaviour. Kavya Madhavan, who played the same role in the Malayalam original,is brilliant as his sister. Her initial chirpiness gradually gives way to sadnessand she portrays this change wonderfully. Kaveri, who also reprises her role fromthe Malayalam original, is also good. There are no false notes from the rest of the cast either.
  
  

• From: Pras on Tue Apr 24 3:15:16 2007.

  [Full View]

  excellent choice selva, thanks
  
  i will post my view when i have time
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Tue Apr 24 3:16:38 2007.

  [Full View]

  Pras wrote:

  excellent choice selva, thanks i will post my view when i have time

  
  
  Thanks Pras At first, I thought of sending a PM to you for the pick. since you are busy these days, I posted that in this thread
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Tue Apr 24 3:18:38 2007.

  [Full View]

  Just a gentle reminder.
  
  I request veterans to recommend yesteryear classics that can be discussed here. I have little knowledge on the movies that released during 60's, 70's etc.
  
  what looks ordinary to me, might have been a great movie in the past. (Taste thaan mannichikonga ) and also people like me will change our opinion if we get diff perception on a old movie
  
  

• From: Raikkonen on Tue Apr 24 3:22:42 2007.

  [Full View]

  Songs were decent. Vikram was awesome as usual.. but the movie was soooo slow.. and last 15 minutes were almost like mega serial.. cry, ready for cry, cry, ready for cry, forgot to cry type..
  but Vikram's performance was a -class, thats something good in a lacklustre movie..
  
  

• From: joe on Tue Apr 24 3:24:43 2007.

  [Full View]

  I think Vikram's acting in Kaasi is much better than his national award winning performance in Pithamagan .But I heard ,Kalapavan Mani did equally good in original malayalam version.
  
  Mastero IR rocked in Kaasi
  
  Remarkable performance from Vikram
  
  

• From: sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar on Tue Apr 24 3:34:24 2007.

  [Full View]

  selvakumar wrote:

  I request veterans to recommend yesteryear classics that can be discussed here. I have little knowledge on the movies that released during 60's, 70's etc.

  
  
  old classics were discused in depth. i would ike to discus on films with broken part storylines like navarathri, dasaavatharam, thirumalai thenkumari ect....
  
  P.S.:
  i am not a veteran.
  i have seen only 20% of oldies...
  
  

• From: sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar on Tue Apr 24 3:36:40 2007.

  [Full View]

  kaasi, along with sethu and pithamagan spolied vikram's health\looks a bit.
  
  a digression - is it good for an artist to take up roles with slightly spoils his looks\health, on long term.....its bad rigth? and two fils had same director - Bala
  
  Joe ennai adikka varuvaaraa???
  
  

• From: sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar on Tue Apr 24 3:39:03 2007.

  [Full View]

  yes, this performance was not only good, but alsonatural, when compared with pithamagan
  
  

• From: joe on Tue Apr 24 3:48:28 2007.

  [Full View]

  sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar wrote:

  kaasi, along with sethu and pithamagan spolied vikram's health\looks a bit. a digression - is it good for an artist to take up roles with slightly spoils his looks\health, on long term.....its bad rigth? and two fils had same director - Bala Joe ennai adikka varuvaaraa???

  
  
  //Dig
  Actually you are forcing me to speak like bala fan by your underestimations on Bala ..never mind ..leave it
  //dig
  
  I don't get what made vikram's health spoiled ? Just after Kaasi only He did energetic movies like Thil and Thool.
  
  

• From: sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar on Tue Apr 24 3:56:40 2007.

  [Full View]

  vikram himself said those in an interview - he said his eyes lost the old beauty after kaasi, he was on a bad diet for sethu........for pithamahan too he did some thing similar.....his hair color to changed. he said it took long time to resume back.......
  
  i wonder, why can't those things could have been done with makeup\expressions\spl.effects...
  
  

• From: Flavia on Tue Apr 24 4:01:40 2007.

  [Full View]

  The strain Vikram took to emulate a blindman was mindblowing!
  
  Other than Vikram's performance, the movie has nothing special to talk about
  
  
  
  

• From: thimuru on Tue Apr 24 4:04:00 2007.

  [Full View]

  Flavia wrote:

  The strain Vikram took to emulate a blindman was mindblowing! Other than Vikram's performance, the movie has nothing special to talk about

  
  
  THIS IS CALLED "ENGA APPA KUDHURUKULLA ILLA" TYPE
  
  IR rocked!
  
  

• From: Flavia on Tue Apr 24 4:07:12 2007.

  [Full View]

  thimuru wrote:

  Flavia wrote: The strain Vikram took to emulate a blindman was mindblowing! Other than Vikram's performance, the movie has nothing special to talk about THIS IS CALLED "ENGA APPA KUDHURUKULLA ILLA" TYPE IR rocked!

  
  
  Kasi songs are definitely not in the same league of some IR's evergreen works. They are just average scores. Nothing to rave about.
  
  

• From: Sanjeevi on Tue Apr 24 4:27:49 2007.

  [Full View]

  Definitely kasi had very good run especially in B & C. One of bests from Vikram.
  
  

  Flavia wrote:

  Kasi songs are definitely not in the same league of some IR's evergreen works. They are just average scores. Nothing to rave about.

  
  
  Yes i agree 50%. Though it had dejavu feel, all the songs rocked TN (mainly B & C) especially En mana vaanil, athorathilae, punniyam thedi.
  
  Ithu onnum Best MD thread illaiyae
  
  

• From: Roshan on Tue Apr 24 5:17:08 2007.

  [Full View]

  Songs were good and IR showed a different dimension of Hariharan. Specially the song - aalamarathil ..
  
  Regarding the movie, apart from Vikram's performance the other outstanding one was - almost all characters were crying from the beginning to end.
  
  Selva,
  
  I shall pm you list of movies that you could consider
  
  

• From: ThalaNass on Tue Apr 24 5:24:11 2007.

  [Full View]

  Vikrams best perfomance..
  and one of the best of IR in last 6-7 years..
  
  

• From: MADDY on Tue Apr 24 5:35:51 2007.

  [Full View]

  Kaasi - wat overaction by vikram .......arghhh, this guy seems to be the king of overacting....... ......appadiye adhuvum original-a , adhuvum illa........inspired from pakkathhu state
  
  can anyone answer y a blind guy needs to have his "iris" and "pupil" stacked upwards???
  
  

• From: cancer on Tue Apr 24 5:48:35 2007.

  [Full View]

  Kaasi Below Average movie...
  
  Class MOvie um illai... commercial entertain um illai...
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Tue Apr 24 5:50:36 2007.

  [Full View]

  Roshan,
  Waiting for the same Take your own time and we will list them here.
  
  Reg Kaasi,
  I think this is one movie which must have won considerable amount of female fans for Vikram
  
  

• From: rockydeva on Tue Apr 24 5:51:34 2007.

  [Full View]

  cancer wrote:

  Kaasi Below Average movie... Class MOvie um illai... commercial entertain um illai...

  
  athunala than padam flop
  
  

• From: ThalaNass on Tue Apr 24 5:53:40 2007.

  [Full View]

  rockydeva wrote:

  cancer wrote: Kaasi Below Average movie... Class MOvie um illai... commercial entertain um illai... athunala than padam flop

  
  
  nijamaave padam flop'a..??
  
  

• From: nemesis786 on Tue Apr 24 5:53:46 2007.

  [Full View]

  rockydeva wrote:

  cancer wrote: Kaasi Below Average movie... Class MOvie um illai... commercial entertain um illai... athunala than padam flop

  
  
  
  Anbe Sivam kooda flop wasnt that entertaining?
  
  Kaasi movie wie it was bad but performance-wise
  
  
  
  

• From: cancer on Tue Apr 24 6:00:31 2007.

  [Full View]

  nemesis786 wrote:

  rockydeva wrote: cancer wrote: Kaasi Below Average movie... Class MOvie um illai... commercial entertain um illai... athunala than padam flop Anbe Sivam kooda flop wasnt that entertaining? Kaasi movie wie it was bad but performance-wise

  
  
  I m not disagree... Vikram's performance is good...
  
  Performance kkaka Thinikkpatta Scene kalaaka Thoniyathu enakku
  
  Anbesivam is much much better entertaining movie, U can watch it any no of times.. but not kaasi..
  
  

• From: rockydeva on Tue Apr 24 6:02:01 2007.

  [Full View]

  shiva
  
  

• From: nemesis786 on Tue Apr 24 6:07:38 2007.

  [Full View]

  cancer wrote:

  nemesis786 wrote: rockydeva wrote: cancer wrote: Kaasi Below Average movie... Class MOvie um illai... commercial entertain um illai... athunala than padam flop Anbe Sivam kooda flop wasnt that entertaining? Kaasi movie wie it was bad but performance-wise I m not disagree... Vikram's performance is good... Performance kkaka Thinikkpatta Scene kalaaka Thoniyathu enakku Anbesivam is much much better entertaining movie, U can watch it any no of times.. but not kaasi..

  
  
  Thats what i meant but credited the performance
  
  

• From: leosimha on Tue Apr 24 7:07:08 2007.

  [Full View]

  MADDY wrote:

  Kaasi - wat overaction by vikram .......arghhh, this guy seems to be the king of overacting....... ......appadiye adhuvum original-a , adhuvum illa........inspired from pakkathhu state can anyone answer y a blind guy needs to have his "iris" and "pupil" stacked upwards???

  
  
  after special recommendation by Joe, I watched Kaasi, but his acting is overacting and also copied...I can see a lot of Kamal-type style acting...hmm...this guy is totally inspired by Kamal's way of acting..agree he should take inspirations from a great actor like Kamal but he should not try to do a exact copy or overact...I will say that Vikram had a good outing in Sethu (even at the last part of climax...you can find him doing over a bit) but lets wait for his Bheema right for now....
  
  

• From: rockydeva on Tue Apr 24 7:08:19 2007.

  [Full View]

  LEO sOganthAn
  
  

• From: leosimha on Tue Apr 24 7:09:13 2007.

  [Full View]

  Is SELVA the moderator/owner of this thread....nice to see a neutral fellow being a moderator/owner of this thread....
  
  

• From: rockydeva on Tue Apr 24 7:12:13 2007.

  [Full View]

  Selva MOD.. yeppa irunthu..
  
  

• From: leosimha on Tue Apr 24 7:14:21 2007.

  [Full View]

  rockydeva wrote:

  Selva MOD.. yeppa irunthu..

  
  
  see some last few pages, where Selva is the decider of the "movie of the week" thread...
  
  

• From: leosimha on Tue Apr 24 7:14:54 2007.

  [Full View]

  rockydeva wrote:

  LEO sOganthAn

  
  
  
  
  

• From: nemesis786 on Tue Apr 24 7:21:25 2007.

  [Full View]

  Please put "KARAGAATAKARAN FOR NEXT WEEK "
  
  

• From: leosimha on Tue Apr 24 7:26:20 2007.

  [Full View]

  nemesis786 wrote:

  Please put "KARAGAATAKARAN FOR NEXT WEEK "

  
  
  We need to request our Moderator/Owner of this thread, Selva to change the topic of the thread.
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Tue Apr 24 7:31:36 2007.

  [Full View]

  leosimha wrote:

  Is SELVA the moderator/owner of this thread....nice to see a neutral fellow being a moderator/owner of this thread....

  
  
  Sathiyamaa kedaiyaathungo !
  
  
  Friends,
  Like how NOV said, this thread is for celebrating selected movie. Ofcourse, you can express your opinion on what you feel about the movie. At the same time, give space / room for others to do the same
  
  As I said, friends can PM me the movie to be listed for discussion
  
  

• From: nemesis786 on Tue Apr 24 7:32:46 2007.

  [Full View]

  selvakumar wrote:

  At the same time, give space / room for others to do the same As I said, friends can PM me the movie to be listed for discussion

  
  
  acre kanakula iruku eduthukonga
  
  

• From: Movie Cop on Wed Apr 25 18:39:06 2007.

  [Full View]

  joe wrote:

  I don't get what made vikram's health spoiled ? Just after Kaasi only He did energetic movies like Thil and Thool.

  
  Sorry Joe - You are wrong! Dhil was released before Kasi.
  
  Btw, talking about Kasi, Vikram's role was brilliant in that movie. It was definitely more challenging and more convincing than the National award winning PM.
  
  In terms of Vikram's acting performance - I would rate Sethu > Kasi > PM > Anniyan!
  
  As far as Kasi goes, I liked the way Vikram kills the villain (Rajeev?) in the end to take revenge for his sister! I thought that was positive end for a "tear jerker" movie like this. But what I didn’t like about the movie was (especially in the beginning) the way Vinoo Chakaravarhty bashes Kasi to get create sympathy for the blind character. To me that looked vewry artificial!
  
  
  

• From: Movie Cop on Wed Apr 25 18:47:07 2007.

  [Full View]

  MADDY wrote:

  Kaasi - wat overaction by vikram .......arghhh, this guy seems to be the king of overacting....... ......appadiye adhuvum original-a , adhuvum illa........inspired from pakkathhu state can anyone answer y a blind guy needs to have his "iris" and "pupil" stacked upwards???

  
  Maddy - I have seen and interacted with a blind person who used to live right next to my house who shows same kind of facial expressions when hearing or talking to others! Actually that person is the borther of our flat's watchman! That's why when I saw Kasi, I never felt anything unusual or artifical about Vikram's acting!
  
  

• From: MADDY on Tue May 1 1:54:40 2007.

  [Full View]

  Ok, MAY - 1st it is and the MOVIE FOR THIS WEEK is Mugavari
  
  on request from our Hubber "great"
  
  Cast : Ajith, Jyothika, Vivek, Raghuvaran, K.Vishwanath, Cochin Haneefa
  Director : Durai
  Cinematography : Ajayan Vincent
  Editing : B.Lenin
  Producer : SS Chakaravarthy
  Music : Deva
  
  review: http://www.tamilsweb.com/cgi-bin/etsearch/etsearch.cgi?ID=988422437
  
  MODS, please change the thread title to "MOVIE OF THE WEEK- Mugavari" .......thanks......
  
  

• From: Shakthiprabha on Tue May 1 9:58:17 2007.

  [Full View]

  As much as I wanna say about KAASI ,
  
  I CANT...
  
  becuase...
  
  Ive not seen the movie
  
  same holds for MUGAVARI too
  
  

• From: nemesis786 on Tue May 1 12:25:45 2007.

  [Full View]

  Make it to MUGAVARI please people who have not seen it may learn about the movie from this thread
  
  

• From: kalnayak on Wed May 2 5:58:27 2007.

  [Full View]

  Selva,
  
  Neenga Thala Rasigar. Athanaala Mugavari ya potuteenga, but I feel its not worth comparing with other films discussed so far in this thread. Ini ella Thala padathayum pottu discuss pannunga Thala Rasigargale.
  
  

• From: nemesis786 on Wed May 2 6:04:05 2007.

  [Full View]

  kalnayak wrote:

  Selva, Neenga Thala Rasigar. Athanaala Mugavari ya potuteenga, but I feel its not worth comparing with other films discussed so far in this thread. Ini ella Thala padathayum pottu discuss pannunga Thala Rasigargale.

  
  
  You want a film like pithamagan where a guy overacts like an animal to be called as great film n discussed?
  
  Whats ur problem u can always stay away if u dont consider a movie as good from ur viewpoint
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Wed May 2 6:05:41 2007.

  [Full View]

  kalnayak wrote:

  Selva, Neenga Thala Rasigar. Athanaala Mugavari ya potuteenga, but I feel its not worth comparing with other films discussed so far in this thread. Ini ella Thala padathayum pottu discuss pannunga Thala Rasigargale.

  
  
  I didn't list this movie just coz I am a THALA fan.
  As I said, we will give importance to yesteryear movies MOSTLY. At the sametime, we will list movie to celebrate the special events related to the celebrities.
  
  Be it MGR, SIVAJI, GEMINI, NADIGAVEL, SATYARAJ, IR, ARR, YSR, HJ etc. This is just one of the N ways to remember the events associated with the celebrities
  
  & Great nominated this movie long time back. I didn't want to list this at that time itself since I didn't want this to be in this thread at that time.
  
  Ungalukku pudicha nadigar oda special event irundha sollunga, avar movie ya kooda list pannalaam.
  
  Few more e.gs would be., Nagesh, chandrababu, yesteryear actresses, technicians, etc
  
  

• From: c4ramesh on Wed May 2 6:11:05 2007.

  [Full View]

  Mugavari is very realistic film.
  
  

• From: nemesis786 on Wed May 2 6:14:43 2007.

  [Full View]

  The direction , Music and Ajith's performance were the highlights!
  
  i think initially the climax was like ajith totally gives up his passion for music and goes for a job! But since the response was not good or objection was from fans the climax was changed a bit and film went on to become a hit
  
  
  My Favourite Songs and Scenes from the movie:
  
  * Ajith gaining confidence in life after seeing a small boy stretching n jumping to hit a bell after several failures
  
  * Climax scene between manivannan and Ajith
  
  * Keechu Kiliye song
  
  * Eh Nilave Song
  
  * The scene in recording theatre where Ajith becomes restless when he comes to know recording is canceled , acting was very natural and top notch
  
  

• From: c4ramesh on Wed May 2 6:26:42 2007.

  [Full View]

  The way Ajith will be insulted by some relatives of a producer. I felt like hitting them.
  
  

• From: lavanya22rit on Wed May 2 6:31:22 2007.

  [Full View]

  Only Kamal cud have portrayed Sridhar in a better way.
  Hats off to Ajith.
  
  

• From: Pras on Wed May 2 6:57:00 2007.

  [Full View]

  hi guys,
  I have to say that mugavari is not a movie i enjoyed ... like other ajith movies .. some scenes were good, music by Deva was good .. but
  
  just a view from a neutral fan
  
  

• From: Pras on Wed May 2 7:01:04 2007.

  [Full View]

  nemesis786 wrote:

  kalnayak wrote: Selva, Neenga Thala Rasigar. Athanaala Mugavari ya potuteenga, but I feel its not worth comparing with other films discussed so far in this thread. Ini ella Thala padathayum pottu discuss pannunga Thala Rasigargale. You want a film like pithamagan where a guy overacts like an animal to be called as great film n discussed? Whats ur problem u can always stay away if u dont consider a movie as good from ur viewpoint

  
  
  nemesis, why do you pull in pithamagan ? ... if you feel that vikram overacted in it, it is your point of view, i respect it ... but why speak about it here ?
  
  

• From: seran on Wed May 2 7:11:15 2007.

  [Full View]

  Pras wrote:

  hi guys, I have to say that mugavari is not a movie i enjoyed ... like other ajith movies .. some scenes were good, music by Deva was good .. but just a view from a neutral fan

  
  It depends on your taste whether you like a movie or not, you don't need to be a Ajith fan to like the film. I'm also a neutral fan
  
  Mugavari is a very good movie, which I loved, one of the realistic movies by Ajith. Ajith's performance is awesome as a struggling musician and Jo is cool as ever
  Though the songs in the movie are straight lift, they are good.
  
  

• From: VENKIRAJA on Wed May 2 7:14:55 2007.

  [Full View]

  Mugavari.
  
  Though ajith already proved that he could act with aplomb in vaali,mugavari earned him a feel-good atmosphere.Without any real change in his get-up,sridhar of mugavari made it big.Not just by the 200 day (real) run of the movie,the qualitativeness strikes.Ajith who is an aspiring MD makes his way into kollywood with patience.Raghuvaran incites a fable on this thought,which repeated by jyotikha reveals the mesage of the film.His family,especially his brother raghuvaran is by him.Ajith also wants to woo jothika whom he meets frequently and loves his music.But,his joblessness makes some sparks with his father.At the climax,ajith is portrayed in the most convincing way,which made this film a superhit,earned thala a great name among reviewers like madan and was appreciated by the magazines too.The songs of the movie were a major let-down.Deva,the king of "lavattifying" infact directly copied BSB hits which made the menace.However Keechu kiliye song which was original was the chartbuster,surprisingly.Overall,an appreciable movie.Definitely can be seen 5 or more times.
  
  

• From: VENKIRAJA on Wed May 2 7:16:05 2007.

  [Full View]

  hey all
  
  why do u guys pull down vikram?basically i dont understand u guys calling vikram an overactor.i feel ure wrong most of the time.
  
  pithamagan is definitely realistic,especially the climax.no wonder the national award was given o him.
  
  kasi,hmmmm maybe,but its not a crap.its definitely watchable.
  
  sethu excellent movie.however anniyan is 100% pure shankar-made garbage.
  
  dhool,saamy,etc. were ordinary.dhil was a decent effort.gemini doesn't deserve a mention.so do KS,samurai.
  
  i liked KING more than these movies,at par with sethu and pithamagan!very seasoned performance by both vikram and sneha.
  
  

• From: c4ramesh on Wed May 2 7:19:21 2007.

  [Full View]

  Venki unarchivasa pattu rendu thadava buttona alluthitngalo??
  
  

• From: nemesis786 on Wed May 2 7:20:00 2007.

  [Full View]

  VENKIRAJA wrote:

  Mugavari. Though ajith already proved that he could act with aplomb in vaali,mugavari earned him a feel-good atmosphere.Without any real change in his get-up,sridhar of mugavari made it big.Not just by the 200 day (real) run of the movie,the qualitativeness strikes.Ajith who is an aspiring MD makes his way into kollywood with patience.Raghuvaran incites a fable on this thought,which repeated by jyotikha reveals the mesage of the film.His family,especially his brother raghuvaran is by him.Ajith also wants to woo jothika whom he meets frequently and loves his music.But,his joblessness makes some sparks with his father.At the climax,ajith is portrayed in the most convincing way,which made this film a superhit,earned thala a great name among reviewers like madan and was appreciated by the magazines too.The songs of the movie were a major let-down.Deva,the king of "lavattifying" infact directly copied BSB hits which made the menace.However Keechu kiliye song which was original was the chartbuster,surprisingly.Overall,an appreciable movie.Definitely can be seen 5 or more times.

  
  
  
  
  
  

• From: nemesis786 on Wed May 2 7:22:50 2007.

  [Full View]

  Pras wrote:

  hi guys, I have to say that mugavari is not a movie i enjoyed ... like other ajith movies .. some scenes were good, music by Deva was good .. but just a view from a neutral fan

  
  
  
  I welcome your honest opinion!
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Wed May 2 7:23:13 2007.

  [Full View]

  Venki
  Good post on Vikram too
  
  

• From: VENKIRAJA on Wed May 2 7:26:55 2007.

  [Full View]

  favourite scenes:
  
  1.one of the best scenes in recent tamil movies:the scene where a boy tries to ring a bell and falls down,finally rings it.
  
  2.the scene where the names are written in cards and are shuffled,then ajith discovers his name written in all of em.raghuvaran and ajith look at each other:two greats looking at each other.
  
  3.the reaction of the ultimate star when he finds that his brother gets an attack.
  
  4.manivannan's speech to ajith;the gold treasure story.
  
  5.the scene where ajith sacrfices his self respect and fethes drinks for the director's relatives.
  
  

• From: c4ramesh on Wed May 2 7:27:47 2007.

  [Full View]

  VENKIRAJA wrote:

  dhool,saamy,etc. were ordinary.dhil was a decent effort.gemini doesn't deserve a mention.so do KS,samurai. i liked KING more than these movies,at par with sethu and pithamagan!very seasoned performance by both vikram and sneha.

  
  
  I liked Saami very much, one of Hari's best. He is back to form with Tamarabarani not as great as Saami, but surely a good movie!
  
  

• From: c4ramesh on Wed May 2 7:29:32 2007.

  [Full View]

  VENKIRAJA wrote:

  5.the scene where ajith sacrfices his self respect and fethes drinks for the director's relatives.

  
  
  I think producers relatives.
  
  I felt like hitting the idiots when I saw that scene.
  
  

• From: VENKIRAJA on Wed May 2 7:37:19 2007.

  [Full View]

  throughout the whole movie,ajith will hold a pathetic,helpless face which expresses his inability to leave music nor uplift the family.that feel was terrific!
  
  

• From: c4ramesh on Wed May 2 7:43:19 2007.

  [Full View]

  VENKIRAJA wrote:

  throughout the whole movie,ajith will hold a pathetic,helpless face which expresses his inability to leave music nor uplift the family.that feel was terrific!

  
  
  It was a sombre movie and sombre character played by Ajith, by all means.
  
  Whenever things turn out really gloomy around me, "Mugavari Shridar" comes to my mind. poor chap!
  
  

• From: rami on Thu May 3 6:55:13 2007.

  [Full View]

  Mugavari - A feel good movie. A youth with a high ambition gives up to have a practical approach in his life.. When I saw this movie, I was reminded of Varumayin niram sivappu in many places .. dunno why ..
  
  

• From: rami on Thu May 3 6:56:31 2007.

  [Full View]

  I think this was the last movie in which he looked really youthful and handsome.. After this his face started looking somewhat matured ..
  
  

• From: Nakeeran on Thu May 3 7:32:49 2007.

  [Full View]

  Definitely forms part of top 5 of next superstar Ajit . A realistic character ( more like in malayalam movies ) . that fight was unnecessary . It disturbs the movie.
  Jyothika, charming and nice .
  
  The scenes between Jyo-Raghuvaran-Ajit , are all simple but nice ones to watch.
  
  End. A pracitical solution.
  
  

• From: thimuru on Thu May 3 7:37:02 2007.

  [Full View]

  RAGHUVARAN-AJIT
  
  both are awesome
  
  

• From: mareen on Thu May 3 7:47:00 2007.

  [Full View]

  Mugavari a gr8 movie :claps:
  
  

• From: Prabhu Ram on Thu May 3 12:52:58 2007.

  [Full View]

  One of my favourite Ajith films. The support he gets from his family and Manivannan would be pretty moving. In the days were every hero prefers to pack a punch and play a tough guy all the time, it was refreshing to see Ajith playing a vulnerable man.
  

  Nakeeran wrote:

  End. A pracitical solution.

  
  The original ending just had Ajith walking into the sunset carrying his file. It is only later that they added the 'a few years later' appendix.
  
  One of my favourite scenes is when Rajeev comes home to give the invitation and mentions how the bridegroom is 'well' employed. When he hears Ajith say that he is still trying to become a music director he will react " innum adhE dhAnA !" then turning to K.Viswanath and Raghuvaran, he'll say "En pA neengellAm idhai oNNum sollavE maatteengaLA".
  
  Then he will assure Ajith that he will fins him a job (though no help was sought in the first place). And he will say " good job, good salary.... vEra enna vENum ?".
  
  That line would reflect his understanding. He is not being discouragin just to be hurtful. He is genuinely interested in Ajith's welfare and is only too practical to share his dreams.
  
  From the reaction of K.Vishwanath, you can sense that he would also prefer Ajith to get 'practical'. But, being an affectionate father he won't say it directly. Raghuvaran will defend Ajith's choice but at the same time be very polite to Rajeev.
  
  The movie had several nice parts like this. If I am right it didn't do too well which is why Ajith stuck to masAlA films. Well I may have to shoulder the blame in part, because I only saw it in 'Indhia tholaikkaatchigaLil...'
  
  

• From: nemesis786 on Thu May 3 12:55:38 2007.

  [Full View]

  PRabhuRam is right the lcimax was actually ajith walking away for a job in the sunset but it was changed
  
  

• From: Nakeeran on Thu May 3 13:10:06 2007.

  [Full View]

  PR
  
  Well narrated. Infact, I too love that scene with Rajeev !
  
  The respect Ajit gives to his brother Raghuvaran & the affection that he pours on his family, the combined resolve of the entire family to back Ajit for his musical aspiration, all very well emotionally portrayed.
  
  Raghuvaran character, excellent one !
  
  Ajit, always play a low profile before his dad, brother . Nice presentation !
  
  I think even that Jaiganesh -Jyots-Ajit scene also is another nice one to remember. Jaiganesh stating the practical things in life and trying to convince Ajit to reconcile so that his daughter's life is settled for good.
  
  Overall, a movie to cherish for Ajit .
  
  

• From: nemesis786 on Thu May 3 13:21:09 2007.

  [Full View]

  Really Ajit-Raguvaran combo rocked in this movie and amarkalam!
  
  But my favourite scene in the whole film is the beach scene where the short boy hits the bell with great effort -- symbolically showing never giveup policy
  
  
  Director VZ Durai [ who also directed thotti jaya and now doing nepali] did a good job
  
  

• From: thilak4life on Thu May 3 13:36:43 2007.

  [Full View]

  rami wrote:

  Mugavari - A feel good movie. A youth with a high ambition gives up to have a practical approach in his life.. When I saw this movie, I was reminded of Varumayin niram sivappu in many places .. dunno why ..

  
  
  Where exactly??? VNS is one of my all time favorites about unemployed youth. Pushpak was predominantly a 'comedy' until it ends just like it started. 'Nizhalgal' is another movie from 80s about Unemployed youth. But I haven't managed to watch the movie completely. Raj digital plus-la pOttAnga-nu nenaikuraen!! It was longtime ago. I didn't know it was BR's movie then.
  
  Now to Mugavari - decent film with one of the better efforts from Ajith. I liked him in that movie. He shouldn't have resorted to masala roles!
  
  

• From: Prabhu Ram on Thu May 3 13:38:55 2007.

  [Full View]

  Nakkeeran wrote:

  I think even that Jaiganesh -Jyots-Ajit scene also is another nice one to remember. Jaiganesh stating the practical things in life and trying to convince Ajit to reconcile so that his daughter's life is settled for good.

  Yeah. That was a good one too.
  dayavau sEidhu, naan solli kaatturadhA ninaikkak koodAthu. oru thagappanA neenga solradhai ennAle Ethukka mudiyalai...
  
  vEnumna ippidi seyvOm..naan konjam panam sEtthu vachirukkEn...adhai neenga udhavi, kadan, seeru eppidi vEnumna vachukkunga. oru business aarmabippOm, naanum kooda maada othAsaiyA irukkEn....
  
  The nice about the movie is, there is no-one who is actually bad and plotting the hero's ruin in the conventional Tamil Film sense. Everyone is veryu concerned about Ajith's welfare. But very few are able to travel the distance along with his ideals. Even Jo has to drop out and one can't even find fault with JaiganEsh's line of reasoning here.
  
  Very good film
  
  Indha padathai nambi, Durai-yOda adutha padmAna 'Kaadhal Sadugudu' padathukku nanbargaLai koottittu pOnEn. annaikku pala natpukaL murinjidhu
  
  

• From: Roshan on Thu May 3 13:39:08 2007.

  [Full View]

  Prabhu Ram wrote:

  One of my favourite scenes is when Rajeev comes home to give the invitation and mentions how the bridegroom is 'well' employed. When he hears Ajith say that he is still trying to become a music director he will react " innum adhE dhAnA !" then turning to K.Viswanath and Raghuvaran, he'll say "En pA neengellAm idhai oNNum sollavE maatteengaLA". Then he will assure Ajith that he will fins him a job (though no help was sought in the first place). And he will say " good job, good salary.... vEra enna vENum ?". That line would reflect his understanding. He is not being discouragin just to be hurtful. He is genuinely interested in Ajith's welfare and is only too practical to share his dreams. From the reaction of K.Vishwanath, you can sense that he would also prefer Ajith to get 'practical'. But, being an affectionate father he won't say it directly. Raghuvaran will defend Ajith's choice but at the same time be very polite to Rajeev.

  
  
  Nice scene that was !! Raghuvaran would politely say 'ovvorutharukku ovvoru ambition" .
  
  One of my most favourite Ajith movies. Dialogues were penned by Balakumaran and were very simple but sharp, like Raghuvaran saying to Jyothika - "hello ithu romba chinna ulagam. nallavangaLa nallavanga kaNdippA santhippAnga".
  
  Raghuvaran was excellent and Jyothika very sweet.
  
  My favourite scenens in the movie;
  
  * The one mentioned by PR.
  
  * Small boy hitting the bell in the beach
  
  * Ajith, Jyothika and Jaiganesh - where J'ganesh talks about his daughters marriage plans and Ajith talking about his ambition.
  
  * Raghuvaran relating the story of "gold at 10 feet" to Ajith in the mottai maadi.
  
  * Jyothika repeating the same story to Raghuvaran without knowing he is Ajith's brother
  
  * Ajith's encounter with V M Hanifa ( great performance in a very short scene) at the recording theatre - followed by the song "E-nilavE"
  
  

• From: Roshan on Thu May 3 13:45:37 2007.

  [Full View]

  Prabhu Ram wrote:

  Nakkeeran wrote: I think even that Jaiganesh -Jyots-Ajit scene also is another nice one to remember. Jaiganesh stating the practical things in life and trying to convince Ajit to reconcile so that his daughter's life is settled for good. Yeah. That was a good one too. dayavau sEidhu, naan solli kaatturadhA ninaikkak koodAthu. oru thagappanA neenga solradhai ennAle Ethukka mudiyalai... vEnumna ippidi seyvOm..naan konjam panam sEtthu vachirukkEn...adhai neenga udhavi, kadan, seeru eppidi vEnumna vachukkunga. oru business aarmabippOm, naanum kooda maada othAsaiyA irukkEn....

  
  
  PR thaan sari ippadi dialogue quote paNNuvathaRku Yes the way J'ganesh puts it across - body language, voice modulation, expressions of Jyothika and Ajith - very natural and realistic.
  
  

  Quote:

  The nice about the movie is, there is no-one who is actually bad and plotting the hero's ruin in the conventional Tamil Film sense. Everyone is veryu concerned about Ajith's welfare. But very few are able to travel the distance along with his ideals. Even Jo has to drop out and one can't even find fault with JaiganEsh's line of reasoning here.

  
  
  Credit should mainly go to Balakumaran
  
  
  

  Quote:

  Indha padathai nambi, Durai-yOda adutha padmAna 'Kaadhal Sadugudu' padathukku nanbargaLai koottittu pOnEn. annaikku pala natpukaL murinjidhu

  
  
  I am still laughing
  
  

• From: Freedom on Thu May 3 20:25:24 2007.

  [Full View]

  I think this is one of my favourite Ajit movies. Nice cinematography by PC Sriram.
  
  Edhaathamaana dialogues and well under played character for Ajith.
  
  The first time , I saw this movie I didn't like since Ajith looked too soft in the movie.....but subsequent views show how beautifully the film was made
  
  Every Dialogue was edhartham to core.
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Fri May 4 9:10:12 2007.

  [Full View]

  Good narration PR & Roshan.
  -------
  Apart from those scenes, I loved the scenes b/w Ajith & Jyo. esp the way he wishes her "Happy Birthday".
  
  

• From: ajaybaskar on Fri May 4 9:18:53 2007.

  [Full View]

  The movie released when i was doing my B.E in tiruchendur. 25 guys from our class bunked the class, hired a van and rushed to Tirunelveli Perinbavilas to see the film. We saw the FDSS. I liked the film. But most of my friends didnt like the climax. They didnt want to see Ajith walking dejected.
  
  

• From: mrsrajan on Fri May 4 9:19:17 2007.

  [Full View]

  Mugavari
  
  My Most Favorite Ajith's Movie and Very realistic Movie too.
  
  
  I expect Kireedom will bring back Mugavari's Ajith.
  
  

• From: littlemaster1982 on Fri May 4 9:26:04 2007.

  [Full View]

  The film owes big time to the dialogue writer Balakumaran. My fav. dialogue:- Ajith to Jaiganesh "yEn sir? sambathikkaRavan-than Ambalaiya? sAthikkaRavan-um Ambalaithan sir!"
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Fri May 4 9:27:49 2007.

  [Full View]

  ajaybaskar wrote:

  We saw the FDSS. I liked the film. But most of my friends didnt like the climax. They didnt want to see Ajith walking dejected.

  
  
  Many fans & friends didn't ilke the first climax That is why they added that extra scenes to satisfy them something which I feel they should not have done
  
  

• From: ajaybaskar on Fri May 4 9:33:25 2007.

  [Full View]

  I have not seen that extra footage till date. Is it available in the DVD version,Selva?
  
  

• From: joe on Fri May 4 9:35:28 2007.

  [Full View]

  selvakumar wrote:

  ajaybaskar wrote: We saw the FDSS. I liked the film. But most of my friends didnt like the climax. They didnt want to see Ajith walking dejected. Many fans & friends didn't ilke the first climax That is why they added that extra scenes to satisfy them something which I feel they should not have done

  
  
  oh! There is another version with extra scenes ?
  
  Luckily the VCD I got has only original climax version ,which I liked
  
  

• From: littlemaster1982 on Fri May 4 9:35:57 2007.

  [Full View]

  ajaybaskar wrote:

  I have not seen that extra footage till date. Is it available in the DVD version,Selva?

  
  
  It was not shot seperately. The extra footage is nothing but some earlier scenes rehashed.
  
  

• From: ajaybaskar on Fri May 4 9:38:58 2007.

  [Full View]

  I see. I missed watching the movie when it was telecast recently in K TV.
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Fri May 4 9:44:42 2007.

  [Full View]

  Joe and Ajay,
  The EXTRA SCENE that was added later was just a temporary piece only. It was added days after the movie release.
  
  The scene is like "Sila varudangal kazhithu > and it will show Ajith as a MD" That's all. I don't think we can find that in any VCDs / DVDs
  
  

• From: Roshan on Fri May 4 9:51:33 2007.

  [Full View]

  selvakumar wrote:

  Good narration PR & Roshan. ------- Apart from those scenes, I loved the scenes b/w Ajith & Jyo. esp the way he wishes her "Happy Birthday".

  
  
  Hey ! That's really a cute scene Jo would follow the same to express her love to Ajith - nice romance AppuRam - Jo's phone conversation with Ajith in her dreams.
  
  Jo : kEttuchaa (without talking anything)
  
  Ajith: aamA kEttuchu
  
  Jo :
  
  Lovely scene
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Fri May 4 9:58:39 2007.

  [Full View]

  Roshan,
  Thanks for reminding me that one. Infact, that phone conversation would have reminded the Vaali phone conversation to anyone watching the movie for the first time . But at the end they will feel the difference
  
  Cute one indeed. The way JYO pays it back to Ajith will also be good.
  
  btw, SONGS were also good. But sila idhu sema copy thaan.. But Anthe nera Mugavari songs sema HIT esp "Keechu Kiliyae" & "Ae nilavae"
  
  Lyrics were
  
  "Imai mooda maruthu vittal vizhigal thoongaathu
  Idi thaangaum idayam kooda mownam thaangaaathu"
  
  

• From: ajaybaskar on Fri May 4 10:00:38 2007.

  [Full View]

  I liked the first climax. The second climax seems to be cinematic, a typical vikraman kinda stuff.
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Fri May 4 10:02:02 2007.

  [Full View]

  ajaybaskar wrote:

  I liked the first climax. The second climax seems to be cinematic, a typical vikraman kinda stuff.

  
  
  & Thank God they didn't make it look like a OVER-NIGHT-STAR scene. But still many prefer the first climax. The second climax is almost forgotten by many
  
  

• From: kannannn on Fri May 4 10:05:32 2007.

  [Full View]

  Looks like I have got another movie to watch soon. Thedum padalam aarambam..
  
  

• From: ajaybaskar on Fri May 4 10:13:42 2007.

  [Full View]

  selvakumar wrote:

  ajaybaskar wrote: I liked the first climax. The second climax seems to be cinematic, a typical vikraman kinda stuff. & Thank God they didn't make it look like a OVER-NIGHT-STAR scene. But still many prefer the first climax. The second climax is almost forgotten by many

  
  
  The Ajith-Durai-Cochin Haneefa scene is one of my fav scenes in the movie..
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Fri May 4 10:13:50 2007.

  [Full View]

  kannannn wrote:

  Looks like I have got another movie to watch soon. Thedum padalam aarambam..

  
  
  http://techsatish-techsatish.blogspot.com/2006/12/mugavari-tamil-movie-download-links.html
  
  Not sure whether this will work or not. The link redirects to GOOGLE VIDEOS. Try panni paarunga.
  
  Thanks to Nakeeran who introduced this site.
  
  

• From: kannannn on Fri May 4 10:23:39 2007.

  [Full View]

  selvakumar wrote:

  http://techsatish-techsatish.blogspot.com/2006/12/mugavari-tamil-movie-download-links.html Not sure whether this will work or not. The link redirects to GOOGLE VIDEOS. Try panni paarunga. Thanks to Nakeeran who introduced this site.

  
  Aaha besha work panradhu. Thanks Selva (and Nakeeran) . Will watch it this weekend .
  
  

• From: nemesis786 on Fri May 4 10:35:08 2007.

  [Full View]

  littlemaster1982 wrote:

  The film owes big time to the dialogue writer Balakumaran. My fav. dialogue:- Ajith to Jaiganesh "yEn sir? sambathikkaRavan-than Ambalaiya? sAthikkaRavan-um Ambalaithan sir!"

  
  
  
  
  

• From: leosimha on Fri May 4 10:39:27 2007.

  [Full View]

  oh no...how come did I miss to see my favorite Thala movie Mugavari here in this hub....do I really need to comment on this movie...this movie is chanceless...wonderful movie....Ajith's strong emotions with good supporting moments by Raghuvaran and his family and nice performance by Jothika.
  
  But what pulled the movie to touch each and every person's heart was the portrayal of Ajith's strong EMOTIONS....wonderful...Ajith portrayed it very nicely. Durai, the new director is lucky to have been introduced by Thala. The dialogues in the climax were touching. The ones with Jaiganesh and then with Manivannan.
  
  The songs by Deva were good. Ye Nilave is my favorite. then Aande Nootrande.
  
  This is a class movie. Ajith is a class apart. Ajith proved his worth in an off-beat movie also. Thala Pola Varumaa...
  
  Well, Ajith we expect a class from Kireedom also.
  
  

• From: Roshan on Fri May 4 12:14:18 2007.

  [Full View]

  Though they were lifts - songs were nice and soothing to listen. All songs were good - "poo virinchaachu" - one of the best by Unni Krishnan - specially when he reaches the high notes at the the end of the pallavi - "neeyum naanum nadappOm nilavin mElE"
  
  

• From: Prabhu Ram on Fri May 4 12:43:45 2007.

  [Full View]

  There were one too many songs though.
  
  

• From: raaja_rasigan on Sat May 5 7:01:44 2007.

  [Full View]

  there is a song before or after when one of the boys (master mahendran) will jump high to ring a bell , in the beach, & is watched by jo & ajith....... this is an inspirational scene for ajith in the movie, but the song is a duet, thevai illadha idai sorugal.... editing mistake'o
  
  

• From: nemesis786 on Sat May 5 9:50:14 2007.

  [Full View]

  raaja_rasigan wrote:

  there is a song before or after when one of the boys (master mahendran) will jump high to ring a bell , in the beach, & is watched by jo & ajith....... this is an inspirational scene for ajith in the movie, but the song is a duet, thevai illadha idai sorugal.... editing mistake'o

  
  
  
  
  Director wanted to convey how JO encourages Ajith by showing the boy's example! I think that was an ameteurish attempt by director to have included a duet for that scene
  
  Good point Raaja Rasigan
  
  

• From: Roshan on Sat May 5 13:09:11 2007.

  [Full View]

  raaja_rasigan wrote:

  there is a song before or after when one of the boys (master mahendran) will jump high to ring a bell , in the beach, & is watched by jo & ajith....... this is an inspirational scene for ajith in the movie, but the song is a duet, thevai illadha idai sorugal.... editing mistake'o

  
  
  Yes that song was indeed unnecessary !!- Swarnalatha high pitch pOi sothappiya paadalgaLil ithuvum onRu .
  
  

• From: raaja_rasigan on Sun May 6 3:06:54 2007.

  [Full View]

  nemesis786 wrote:

  Good point Raaja Rasigan

  
  
  Nandri
  
  Mugavari is one of the very few ajith films which i (or neutrals) like
  
  Ajith has done his part very well
  
  His looks & voice modulation are perfect (as far as he is concerned)
  
  We are able to analyse about these things only bcoz the story is good & is presented well by the director.
  
  The other films with ajith in the same kind are
  
  vaali
  kadhal kottai
  asai (though dubbed by panneer pushpangal suresh, others are good)
  
  

• From: Roshan on Sun May 6 3:16:36 2007.

  [Full View]

  raaja_rasigan wrote:

  asai (though dubbed by panneer pushpangal suresh, others are good)

  
  
  Oh ! Suresh-A dub paNNathu . Thansk for the info raja_rasigan. I've heard that Vikram had also dubbed for Ajith. Any idea which movies it was for?
  
  

• From: raaja_rasigan on Sun May 6 3:38:09 2007.

  [Full View]

  Roshan wrote:

  raaja_rasigan wrote: asai (though dubbed by panneer pushpangal suresh, others are good) Oh ! Suresh-A dub paNNathu . Thansk for the info raja_rasigan. I've heard that Vikram had also dubbed for Ajith. Any idea which movies it was for?

  
  
  i hope it is Amaravathi.... but i am not sure
  
  

• From: VENKIRAJA on Sun May 6 3:41:39 2007.

  [Full View]

  raaja_rasigan wrote:

  nemesis786 wrote: Good point Raaja Rasigan Nandri Mugavari is one of the very few ajith films which i (or neutrals) like Ajith has done his part very well His looks & voice modulation are perfect (as far as he is concerned) We are able to analyse about these things only bcoz the story is good & is presented well by the director. The other films with ajith in the same kind are vaali kadhal kottai asai (though dubbed by panneer pushpangal suresh, others are good)

  
  
  enlist the others also please.
  
  

• From: raaja_rasigan on Sun May 6 4:12:32 2007.

  [Full View]

  VENKIRAJA wrote:

  Mugavari is one of the very few ajith films which i (or neutrals) like enlist the others also please.

  
  
  All the ajith's hit films
  
  Ungalukke theriyume edhellam hit'nu
  
  For me... i can add a couple here:
  
  vanmathi
  ullasam
  amarkalam
  varalaru (the credit goes to ajith's acting & screenplay of the movie)
  
  i even enjoyed the normal masala movie.....
  
  Minor mappillai
  
  

• From: thamizhvaanan on Sun May 6 4:24:30 2007.

  [Full View]

  raaja rasigan,
  
  pavithra? it is also one of the gud movies by ajith
  
  

• From: nemesis786 on Sun May 6 14:57:36 2007.

  [Full View]

  Who wrote the story for MUGAVARI was it director VZ DURAI himself or someone else?
  
  

• From: kannannn on Sun May 6 16:50:17 2007.

  [Full View]

  Nice movie. Easily Ajith's best performance (atleast among those I watched). The opening shot was about 5 minutes long without cut. Wonder how many takes it took !! The dialogues were good. One instant we root for the hero and the next instant we also see the logic in the arguments of those around him and wish he just lived a normal life. The movie wins on that count. Drawbacks - Deva in S A Rajkumar mode. Why couldn't they get a better MD? Some of the sundry characters could have done better too.
  
  My immediate reaction was, why did Ajith immediately decide that only mass movies work? IMO he should have tried more varied roles like the one in Mugavari.
  
  

• From: Wibha on Sun May 6 19:03:27 2007.

  [Full View]

  such a pessimistic movie
  
  

• From: keerthy on Sun May 6 19:38:26 2007.

  [Full View]

  Wibha wrote:

  such a pessimistic movie

  
  
  that is reality .....It is practically impossible for all human being to live their career dreams. Luck favors some and never even take a look at some people. Mughavari Sridhar's character was one such unlucky person's and it was one of the excellent movies of Ajith. Inspite of all his talent, hard work and family support, he fails in life.
  
  I actually liked the first climax where Sridhar just walks out saying that his family is more important than his music career ......I don't think it's a pessimistic ending b'cos, eventho' he fails in his career life he shines as a real hero for his family .....as an unselfish and a caring human being. That was so touching and practically acceptable climax. IMHO, the other so called optimistic climax was so artificial
  
  

• From: lavanya22rit on Mon May 7 3:55:22 2007.

  [Full View]

  raaja_rasigan wrote:

  VENKIRAJA wrote: Mugavari is one of the very few ajith films which i (or neutrals) like enlist the others also please. All the ajith's hit films Ungalukke theriyume edhellam hit'nu For me... i can add a couple here: vanmathi ullasam amarkalam varalaru (the credit goes to ajith's acting & screenplay of the movie) i even enjoyed the normal masala movie..... Minor mappillai

  
  
  
  AFAIK movies went well with neutral ppl are:
  
  Varalaru
  Ji
  Attagasam
  Villain
  Poovellam Un Vasam
  Citizen
  Dheena
  Kandukondain Kandukondain
  Mugavari
  Amarkalam
  Anandha Poongatre
  Vaali
  Kadhal Mannan
  Ullasam
  Kadhal Kottai
  Vaanmathi
  
  

• From: groucho070 on Mon May 7 4:13:25 2007.

  [Full View]

  keerthy wrote:

  Wibha wrote: such a pessimistic movie that is reality .....It is practically impossible for all human being to live their career dreams. Luck favors some and never even take a look at some people. Mughavari Sridhar's character was one such unlucky person's and it was one of the excellent movies of Ajith. Inspite of all his talent, hard work and family support, he fails in life. I actually liked the first climax where Sridhar just walks out saying that his family is more important than his music career ......I don't think it's a pessimistic ending b'cos, eventho' he fails in his career life he shines as a real hero for his family .....as an unselfish and a caring human being. That was so touching and practically acceptable climax. IMHO, the other so called optimistic climax was so artificial

  
  
  
  I refused to see this film. At that time, I was making a career transition. I was a bank clerk and I wanted to become a writer. My mom was against it and have constantly reminded me of this movie. Revealed the climax. So, hopping not to be discouraged, I did not watch it.
  
  And I am a writer now. I still don't want to watch the movie...because I have other higher dreams.
  
  But I am sure it's a good movie in terms of script and performance, as I have learned from others.
  
  

• From: Roshan on Mon May 7 4:58:14 2007.

  [Full View]

  Groucho,
  
  I dont think this movie will affect you anyway in terms of career transitions. The story is that - the hero has a chidlhood dream/ambition of becoming a music director and how it goes un fullfilled - due to circumstances beyond his control. So please change your mind and go ahead and watch it and I guarantee that you wouldn't regret.
  
  

• From: nemesis786 on Mon May 7 7:43:27 2007.

  [Full View]

  
  
  

• From: nemesis786 on Mon May 7 7:45:01 2007.

  [Full View]

  Mugavari's speciality are its dialogues, natural portrayal and story
  
  As for as performance is concerned i wouldnt rate it higher than vaali or varalaru!
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Mon May 7 7:47:41 2007.

  [Full View]

  MOVIE OF THIS WEEK - "RATHA KANNEER"
  
  Selected by : JOE
  
  Cast
  M R RADHA
  
  
  Directors
  
  R. Krishnan
  S. Panju
  
  Other Details:
  
  
  Courtest : IMDB
  
  P.S: I couldn't get further details on this CLASSIC. Veterans can update this thread with the necessary info
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Mon May 7 7:53:07 2007.

  [Full View]

  Nakeeran posted about this movie and few scenes in M.R.RADHA THREAD long time back. Please refer that as well
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Mon May 7 10:15:49 2007.

  [Full View]

  http://techsatish-techsatish.blogspot.com/2006/12/ratha-kaneer-tamil-movie-download-links.html
  
  I am not sure whether the links presented in the above link for Ratha Kanneer will work or not since I cannot verify them here
  
  People who would like to see the movie now can use the above link. Work aanaa update pannunga
  
  

• From: joe on Mon May 7 10:17:57 2007.

  [Full View]

  Raththa Kanneer
  
  The year was 1954. Independent India was only 7 years old. M. R. Radha had recently broken the very basic rule of theater acting: he showed his back to the audience when performing. But the audience could see him emoting by noticing the way his head and ears moved.
  
  Indian movies were busy showing us the finer points of love by showing two flowers caressing each other (The ’’Two birds pecking at each other’’ concept was not there yet.)
  
  It was at a time like this that Ratha Kanneer was released. Ratha Kanneer was the odd one out. The movie was about an evil person’s descent to his death.
  
  
  
  MAIN CHARACTERS
  
  Mohanasundaram:
  Also called Mohan. Westernized rich man who has just returned from abroad. Atheist. Arrogant. Proud. Sarcastic. Disrespectful to anything Indian and anyone below his social standards.
  
  Balu:
  Mohan’sfriend, who also studied abroad. Simple, down-to-earth, humble. A complete contrast to Mohan’s character. The milk of human kindness.
  
  Kantha:
  Danseuse. Temptress. Seductress. Parasite. The apple of Mohan’s eyes.
  
  Chandra:
  Mohan’s wife. Very traditional. Submissive.
  
  Mohan’s mom:
  
  Run-of-the-mill mom. Submissive to Mohan’s tantrums.
  
  
  ------------------------
  
  
  STORY
  
  Mohan comes to India. A group of laborers have arranged a ’’Welcome Ceremony’’ for him. When asked to speak, Mohan goes:
  
  --
  Mohan: Friends, when I was told that there would be a welcome ceremony for me, I thought I would be welcomed by people who have the social status to welcome me. I thought I would be welcomed by industrialists and rich men. I didn’t expect you laborers here. I hate seeing laborers like you... all you guys talk about is hunger, starvation, etc.(continues)
  --
  
  He meets Kantha. He falls in love with her. She loves his money. Once, when they are in a park, a very sick-looking leper comes to them and asks for alms.
  
  --
  Mohan (angry by the sight of the leper): A LEPER IN THE PARK!!! WHAT KIND OF A MUNICIPALITY IS THIS? THIS IS NONSENSE. WHY SHOULD LEPERS BE LET INSIDE THE CITY? SHOULDN’T THEY BE TAKEN AWAY AND SHOT??!!
  --
  
  Mohan is disrespectful even to his mom.
  
  --
  Mohan: Live in the outhouse!! I don’t want my friends to see you. I’d be embarrassed.
  --
  Mohan: Don’t you have manners? Whenever someone comes and asks for me, you tell them ’’Mohan is asleep. Mohan is not here.’’ What will my friends think of me? From now on, you will address me as ’’Mohan Sir’’.
  --
  
  His mom, worried by his playboy ways, convinces him to get married. He gets married to Chandra. Even during the wedding, Mohan is more with his foreigner friends than with his wife. When asked to pose with her for photos, he stands a little away from her, a clear indication that he really is not interested in her. Even on the night after his marriage, he leaves her and goes to Kantha.
  
  Even after marriage, Mohan spends most of his time with Kantha, coming home only once in 2-3 days. On one such day when he’s home, his mom asks him to mend his ways. He kicks a chair at her, hurting her in the process. He goes back to Kantha.
  
  His health has now deteriorated. He coughs all the time due to his chain-smoking. Balu once comes to Kantha’s house.
  
  --
  Balu: Mohan, I have to talk to you.
  Mohan: Don’t you have manners???!! You’re educated, aren’t you? Don’t you know that you should knock before you enter?
  Balu: Mom is seriously ill.
  Mohan: Then take her to a doctor. Why have you come here? Do I look like a doctor? I can’t come now. Can’t you see I’m busy??
  --
  
  He comes home when his mom is about to die. Even there, he is very rude to her. His mom dies.
  
  --
  Mohan: Balu, arrange to pack her off. Today is Kantha’s mom’s birthday. She’ll be very angry if I don’t go.
  --
  
  Balu arranges Mohan’s mom’s funeral and goes to Kantha’s house to call him to attend the funeral.
  
  --
  Balu: Mohan, I’ve made arrangements. Come to the funeral. We’ll have to walk to the crematorium.
  Mohan: How far is the crematorium?
  Balu: Two miles.
  Mohan: TWO MILES? I haven’t walked even two furlongs in my life. You guys start off. I’ll follow in my car.
  --
  
  He doesn’t attend the funeral.
  
  Chandra is very depressed. Earlier, her father walked off in a huff after Mohan insulted him a lot. Mohan’s mom is dead. Balu is the only person who sympathizes with her.
  
  Kantha convinces Mohan that Chandra and Balu are having an affair behind his back. He insults Balu, who vows not to talk to him and leaves the city.
  
  His health gets worse. A doctor diagnoses his condition as that of a very severe case of leprosy, which cannot be cured. Mohan is now kept in a separate room in Kantha’s house. His appearance is terrible. His money is now non-existent.
  
  In the meanwhile, Kantha gets friendly with a rotund movie producer from Bombay who promises to make her an actress. Mohan creates a scene when the producer comes to Kantha’s house, for which he is kicked out.
  
  It’s raining hard. Mohan seeks refuge under a tree. The tree is hit by lightning and Mohan loses his sight.
  
  Mohan now wanders the streets, blind and hungry. His sarcasm is still very much intact.
  
  --
  Man: I’ll give you some food. Sing me a song.
  Mohan (singing): The Lord will take care of all your problems...
  Man: If the Lord takes care of everyone’s problems, why did he not take care of your disease?
  Mohan (laughing): I sang this song only because you promised food. Why else would I sing it?
  --
  Man: God righteously punished you. You deserve this.
  Mohan: Don’t talk about God. You all are a bunch of hypocrites. You worship God, and kick him the very next second.
  Man: What do you mean?
  Mohan: Don’t you guys pray when you see the Flame of Thiruvannamalai???
  Man: But that’s Agni, the Fire God.
  Mohan: If that’s the case, why do you scream and curse if your house catches fire? Isn’t that Agni too? If you truly worship Agni, you should dance in glory.
  --
  
  The rest of the movie shows us Mohan’s degeneration till his death.
  
  http://www.mouthshut.com/review/Ratha_Kanneer-53027-1.html
  
  
  

• From: joe on Mon May 7 10:22:15 2007.

  [Full View]

  Selva,
  Thanks for choosing my pick.
  
  Raththa kanneer is one of my all time fav movie .It is the bench mark movie for Nakkal and social message .
  
  Nadiga VeL MR Radha at his best
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Mon May 7 10:25:13 2007.

  [Full View]

  joe wrote:

  Selva, Thanks for choosing my pick. Raththa kanneer is one of my all time fav movie .It is the bench mark movie for Nakkal and social message . Nadiga VeL MR Radha at his best

  
  
  Welcome I watched this film long time back. couldn't recall anything apart from the scene in which he attends a function.
  
  Watched some scenes of the Kannada remake Upendra was good. but couldn't digest since we are much familiar with the original
  
  

• From: thilak4life on Mon May 7 10:28:40 2007.

  [Full View]

  I first saw this when I was in high school. romba Aludhutaen.. But when I recently saw it, it wasn't as sad as it used to be. Excessively melodramatic and sentimental. MRR's acting had shades of his persona and in the second half, when he turns leper and suffers the twist of fate, we realize he can actually mold into that particular role. The sober effect affects you (atleast it did when I was young). In spite of its disadvantages, it's definitely worth a watch
  
  

• From: joe on Mon May 7 10:34:17 2007.

  [Full View]

  thilak4life wrote:

  I first saw this when I was in high school. romba Aludhutaen.. But when I recently saw it, it wasn't as sad as it used to be. Excessively melodramatic and sentimental. MRR's acting had shades of his persona and in the second half, when he turns leper and suffers the twist of fate, we realize he can actually mold into that particular role. The sober effect affects you (atleast it did when I was young). In spite of its disadvantages, it's definitely worth a watch

  
  
  Thilak4life,
  Apart from sentiements and tragedy at the end ,the movie is full of satire and sarcasm .Even when hero was at his last stage of death ,he was full of Nakkal.
  
  

• From: thilak4life on Mon May 7 10:41:48 2007.

  [Full View]

  joe wrote:

  thilak4life wrote: I first saw this when I was in high school. romba Aludhutaen.. But when I recently saw it, it wasn't as sad as it used to be. Excessively melodramatic and sentimental. MRR's acting had shades of his persona and in the second half, when he turns leper and suffers the twist of fate, we realize he can actually mold into that particular role. The sober effect affects you (atleast it did when I was young). In spite of its disadvantages, it's definitely worth a watch Tholak4life, Apart from sentiements and tragedy at the end ,the movie is full of satire and sarcasm .Even when hero was at his last stage of death ,he was full of Nakkal.

  
  
  Yes yes. I know. Should have mentioned few positives too. I am pretty short sighted at times. I either praise a movie or dismiss it. Should balance it more often. Anyway thanks Joe..
  
  Aana neenga yenoda paera ippidi misspell panitinga - Tholak
  
  

• From: kannannn on Mon May 7 10:45:53 2007.

  [Full View]

  M R Radha: Atleast oru gavunavudhu pottutu vandhu nillunna adhuvum ketka mattengira..
  His Mom: Yenda naana gown pottukkanum?
  M R Radha: Pinna naana?
  
  

• From: joe on Mon May 7 10:51:36 2007.

  [Full View]

  VeLi Naatukkaaran Neeraviya vachu rocket uduRaan .Nammorula Idly suduRaan
  
  

• From: thimuru on Mon May 7 10:56:08 2007.

  [Full View]

  can i download the movie from any website?
  
  

• From: c4ramesh on Mon May 7 10:57:07 2007.

  [Full View]

  thimuru wrote:

  can i download the movie from any website?

  
  
  http://techsatish-techsatish.blogspot.com/2006/12/ratha-kaneer-tamil-movie-download-links.html
  
  thanks to Selva.
  
  

• From: thimuru on Mon May 7 10:58:36 2007.

  [Full View]

  thans ramesh
  
  

• From: joe on Mon May 7 11:13:34 2007.

  [Full View]

  Radha's mom : Kaliyanathukku Purohithar nalla naaL paarthirukkar .anniku thaan sani varraR
  
  Radha : who is that sani ?Train-la ticket book pannitu Avanai vena early-a vara sollu .
  
  Radha's mom : Illapa .Sani-ngrathu graham
  
  Radha : You mean Planet?
  
  
  
  

• From: nemesis786 on Mon May 7 11:29:39 2007.

  [Full View]

  
  
  

• From: Sanguine Sridhar on Mon May 7 12:39:08 2007.

  [Full View]

  Joe! -->
  
  Superb movie! avarukku andha disease vandha peragum nakkal konjam kooda korayaadhu adhu thaan best part !!
  
  

• From: Shakthiprabha on Mon May 7 22:31:00 2007.

  [Full View]

  Ive not seen the movie.
  
  M.R. RADHA for his screaming shrieking voice is NOT MY TASTE
  
  
  
  

• From: ThalaNass on Mon May 7 22:32:53 2007.

  [Full View]

  its Ratha Kanneer or Ratta Kanneer??
  
  

• From: Shakthiprabha on Mon May 7 22:53:38 2007.

  [Full View]

  http://www.mouthshut.com/review/Ratha_Kanneer-53027-1.html
  
  Wont he ever get back to his wife?
  Wont he ever be loved by his wife or anybody GENUINELY before he dies?
  
  I feel sad.
  
  I WONT WATCH THE MOVIE, its too strong for me.
  
  

• From: swathy on Mon May 7 22:59:40 2007.

  [Full View]

  Andha kaalathilaye he'll ask his wife to marry again.
  
  M.R.Radha
  
  This movie was recently remade in kannada with ramya krishnan(kantha) and abhirami(wife character).
  
  Excellent pick
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Mon May 7 23:36:10 2007.

  [Full View]

  Shakthiprabha wrote:

  I WONT WATCH THE MOVIE, its too strong for me.

  
  
  SP, Ungalukku Indha maari padangal pidikaatha
  
  

• From: groucho070 on Tue May 8 0:18:06 2007.

  [Full View]

  Funny that this movie is selected...right around the time Periyar is released and debated about.
  
  MRR's Rathakaneer owes it to Periyar. This is a message riddled movie. So many of them, unfortunately from a guy who is labeled as bad from the beginning.
  
  MRR said many wonderful, useful line that make sense, but coming from him, who'd later become a leper...things fell on deaf ear.
  
  Of course, some lines should fall on deaf ear. Some really sensitive ones should be ignored.
  
  But those are political and religious stand.
  
  I personally loved this movie because it dared to make an anti-hero as the lead. It won't untill a bit later when NT does the same (Thirumbi Paar, Annaiyin Aanai and later Gouvaram).
  
  This character remains the prototype of many other wonderful MRR roles, especially the ones he did in the Pa varisai films.
  
  I haven't seen this movie for so long Too long. But I remember the impact it had on me when I saw it in my late teens. It made me think. A thinking teen...very rare indeed.
  
  I will be revisiting the movie soon. Definitely. Right after I watch Periyar.
  
  

• From: joe on Tue May 8 3:29:00 2007.

  [Full View]

  SP,
  Ratha Kaneer is not a off-beat movie as you may think .It is a great entertainer and ends with postive message.
  
  

• From: joe on Tue May 8 5:38:49 2007.

  [Full View]

  Watch raththa Kaneer online
  http://123indianonline.com/movies/rathak-kanneer-1954/
  
  

• From: Thirumaran on Tue May 8 8:02:01 2007.

  [Full View]

  It had been very long i saw this movie.
  
  Can someone tell a place in chennai where i can get the DVD/VCD for this movie
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Tue May 15 1:56:29 2007.

  [Full View]

  Mullum Malarum
  
  இளமையிலேயே தாய் - தந்தையரை இழந்த ரஜினி, கழைக் கூத்தாடியாக வாழ்க்கையைத் தொடங்கி, பின்னர் `டிராலி' டிரைவராக உயர்கிறார்.
  
  அவருடைய ஒரே தங்கை ஷோபா. தங்கை மீது உயிரையே வைத்திருக்கிறார், ரஜினி.
  
  அந்த ஊருக்கு புதிதாக வரும் என்ஜினீயர் (சரத்பாபு), கண்டிப்பானவர். அவர், ரஜினியை வேலையை விட்டு நீக்கி விடுகிறார். இதனால் ஆத்திரம் அடையும் ரஜினி, அளவுக்கு மீறி குடிக்கிறார். அதனால், விபத்தில் சிக்கி, ஒரு கையை இழக்கிறார்.
  
  ரஜினியிடம் அடைக்கலம் தேடி வரும் `படாபட்' ஜெயலட்சுமி, அவரை மணக்கிறார்.
  
  இதற்கிடையே சரத்பாபுவுக்கும், ஷோபாவுக்கும் காதல் ஏற்படுகிறது. சரத்பாபுவை தன் எதிரியாக நினைக்கும் ரஜினி, இந்தக் காதலை ஏற்கவில்லை. வேறு மாப்பிள்ளையை தேர்ந்தெடுக்கிறார்.
  
  திருப்பம்
  
  அண்ணன் மீது அளவற்ற பாசம் கொண்டிருந்தாலும், சரத்பாபுவை மணக்க தீர்மானிக்கிறார், ஷோபா.
  
  சரத்பாபுவுக்கும், ஷோபாவுக்கும் ஒரு கோவிலில் திருமணம் நடைபெற இருக்கிறது.
  
  கல்யாணத்துக்கு சில நிமிடங்களே இருக்கும்போது, ஷோபா மனம் மாறி ரஜினியிடம் ஓடி வருவார். "அண்ணா! நீதான் எனக்கு வேண்டுமë'' என்று கதறுவார்.
  
  தங்கை தன் மீது கொண்டிருக்கும் ஆழமான பாசத்தைக் கண்டு நெகிழ்ந்து போவார், ரஜினி.
  
  சரத்பாபுவுக்கும், ஷோபாவுக்கும் திருமணத்தை நடத்தி வைப்பார்.
  
  அற்புத நடிப்பு
  
  இந்தப்படத்தில் ரஜினியின் நடிப்பு அற்புதமாக அமைந்தது. "சூப்பர் ஸ்டார்'' பட்டத்துக்கு ஏற்ப, காளி என்ற கதாபாத்திரமாக வாழ்ந்து காட்டினார்.
  
  ஷோபாவின் நடிப்பும் மிகச்சிறப்பாக அமைந்தது.
  
  சரத்பாபு, `படாபட்' ஜெயலட்சுமி ஆகியோரும், பாத்திரத்தை உணர்ந்து நடித்தனர்.
  
  பாலசந்தர் பாராட்டு
  
  "முள்ளும் மலரும்'' படத்தில் ரஜினியின் நடிப்பைப் பார்த்த டைரக்டர் பாலசந்தர் பிரமித்துப்போனார்.
  
  உடனடியாக ரஜினிக்கு பாராட்டுக் கடிதம் எழுதினார். அக்கடிதத்தை ஒரு பொக்கிஷமாக இன்றும் பாதுகாத்து வருகிறார், ரஜினி.
  
  மகத்தான வெற்றி
  
  மகேந்திரன், ஏற்கனவே சிவாஜியின் "தங்கப்பதக்கம்'' படத்துக்கு வசனம் எழுதியிருந்தாலும், டைரக்ட் செய்த முதல் படம் "முள்ளும்
  
  மலரும்.''இந்தப்படம், தரத்தில் மிக உயர்ந்ததாக விளங்கியது. வெள்ளி விழாப் படமாகவும் அமைந்தது.
  
  இந்தப் படத்தின் ஒளிப்பதிவாளர் பாலுமகேந்திரா. படப்பிடிப்பு, மேல்நாட்டுப்படங்களுக்கு இணையாக விளங்கியது.
  
  இசை அமைத்தவர் இளையராஜா. கண்ணதாசன், பஞ்சு அருணாசலம், கங்கை அமரன் ஆகியோர் பாடல்களை எழுதியிருந்தனர்.
  
  "செந்தாழம் பூவில் வந்தாடும் தென்றல்'', "நித்தம் நித்தம் நெல்லுச்சோறு'', "ராமன் ஆண்டாலும் ராவணன் ஆண்டாலும்....'' உள்பட எல்லாப் பாடல்களும் இனிமையாக ஒலித்தன.
  
  "முள்ளும் மலரும்'', பல பரிசுகளை வென்றது. "காலத்தால் அழிக்க முடியாத காவியம்'' என்று ரசிகர்களாலும், விமர்சகர்களாலும் போற்றப்படும் படங்களில் ஒன்று "முள்ளும் மலரும்.''
  
  
  
  
  

• From: groucho070 on Tue May 15 2:27:23 2007.

  [Full View]

  Selva, wonderful movie. One in my top ten. Don't close this one yet. Wait for my review.
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Tue May 15 2:30:54 2007.

  [Full View]

  groucho070 wrote:

  Selva, wonderful movie. One in my top ten. Don't close this one yet. Wait for my review.

  
  
  Ungalukku innum 160+ hours irukku ! Yup !! Wonderful movie. It has been long time since I saw this one.
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Tue May 15 2:32:51 2007.

  [Full View]

  Rajini was awesome and his confrontations with Sarathbabu
  
  A typical worker and Rajini fitted that one perfectly. The picture here willprove that !
  http://www.rajinikanth.com/reviews/mullummalarum.htm
  
  

• From: Roshan on Tue May 15 2:33:17 2007.

  [Full View]

  Lovely movie One of my all time favorites of Rajini films.
  
  intha padam pathi niRaiya ezhuthalaam but sattunnu thOnuRa moonu vishayam;
  
  1. Rajini
  2. Superb screenplay
  3. and the lovely song - senthaazham poovil vanthaadum thenRal.
  
  
  I remember reading somewhere that Mahendran decided on the title 'mullum malarum' because it had two meanings - both being apt to the main story. The meaning that mostly comes to our mind is - Mul and Malar but it also means mullum (oru naaL) malarum.
  
  

• From: groucho070 on Tue May 15 2:36:08 2007.

  [Full View]

  Interesting Roshan. Never thought of the second meaning. My review...coming soon, Selva. Thanks for the 160 hours deadline. The clock is ticking....
  
  

• From: Sanjeevi on Tue May 15 2:41:39 2007.

  [Full View]

  Wov Superb film
  
  what an acting by Rajni, one of his best
  
  What a movie by Mahendran, one of the dirs who extracted very good effort from Rajni
  
  What a Music by IR, antha "la la la la la lo la la la lo lalilo lalilalo" chorus in Raman Aandalum song "clap:
  
  

• From: Sanjeevi on Tue May 15 2:44:14 2007.

  [Full View]

  Roshan wrote:

  I remember reading somewhere that Mahendran decided on the title 'mullum malarum' because it had two meanings - both being apt to the main story. The meaning that mostly comes to our mind is - Mul and Malar but it also means mullum (oru naaL) malarum.

  
  
  interesting.. never heard before
  
  

• From: NOV on Tue May 15 3:04:20 2007.

  [Full View]

  Sanjeevi wrote:

  interesting.. never heard before

  
  
  http://www.mayyam.com/hub/viewtopic.php?p=940003#940003
  
  

• From: groucho070 on Tue May 15 3:15:30 2007.

  [Full View]

  NOV wrote:

  Sanjeevi wrote: interesting.. never heard before http://www.mayyam.com/hub/viewtopic.php?p=940003#940003

  
  
  Oh, okay. Thanks Nov. Didn't see that one. Though the idea of thorn blossoming into flower is surreal. Somehow it reminds me of the surgical stuff they do in Thailand. Hmm....
  
  

• From: Roshan on Tue May 15 3:25:18 2007.

  [Full View]

  NOV wrote:

  Sanjeevi wrote: interesting.. never heard before http://www.mayyam.com/hub/viewtopic.php?p=940003#940003

  
  
  oh! i wasnt aware of this thread. I vaguely remember reading it one or two years back - probably in balaji's - dhool.com site. A detailed write up was given about the movie and the song senthaazham poovil. Let me try and get the link if possible.
  
  

• From: joe on Tue May 15 3:38:41 2007.

  [Full View]

  Interesting Info about this movie...
  
  Mahendran mentioned in his book.
  
  Venu Chettiyar is the Producer of this movie .Once the whole production except the 'Chenthazham poovil' song were completed ..Venu chettiyar seen the rush of the movie and got very angry with Mahendran ..He didn't like the movie at all and afraid all his money lost since he beleived no distributer will take the movie..Now mahendran told him ,one more song is pending and that song is very important ..venu chettiyar got more angry and told he won't spend even a paise anymore and he won't allow any more shooting.
  
  Mahendran was helpless and finally he went to kamal Hassan who is friend of Mahendran and Balu Mahendra (camera man of this movie) .Kamal went to Venu chettiyar and requested him the same ..He explained How talented Mahendran and Balumahendra are ,,but Venu chettiyar was admament ..Finally kamal asked him "OK..You no need to spend anything ..Just give permission to proceed the shooting ..I will take care of money .is it OK? " ..Venu chettiyar said " Ennavo panni tholainga " ..kamal spent his money ,bought fim role and all necessary ,then they shooted 'Chenthazham poovil'..Rest is history.
  
  Mahendran mentioned in this book that he will never forget Kamal Hassan ,who is a great supporter of good cinema.
  
  

• From: Roshan on Tue May 15 3:50:25 2007.

  [Full View]

  joe wrote:

  Interesting Info about this movie... Mahendran mentioned in his book. Venu Chettiyar is the Producer of this movie .Once the whole production except the 'Chenthazham poovil' song were completed ..Venu chettiyar seen the rush of the movie and got very angry with Mahendran ..He didn't like the movie at all and afraid all his money lost since he beleived no distributer will take the movie..Now mahendran told him ,one more song is pending and that song is very important ..venu chettiyar got more angry and told he won't spend even a paise anymore and he won't allow any more shooting. Mahendran was helpless and finally he went to kamal Hassan who is friend of Mahendran and Balu Mahendra (camera man of this movie) .Kamal went to Venu chettiyar and requested him the same ..He explained How talented Mahendran and Balumahendra are ,,but Venu chettiyar was admament ..Finally kamal asked him "OK..You no need to spend anything ..Just give permission to proceed the shooting ..I will take care of money .is it OK? " ..Venu chettiyar said " Ennavo panni tholainga " ..kamal spent his money ,bought fim role and all necessary ,then they shooted 'Chenthazham poovil'..Rest is history. Mahendran mentioned in this book that he will never forget Kamal Hassan ,who is a great supporter of good cinema.

  
  
  Kamal Kamal thaan !!!! - People should also note that it is a Rajini movie
  
  

• From: thilak4life on Tue May 15 3:56:33 2007.

  [Full View]

  joe wrote:

  Interesting Info about this movie... Mahendran mentioned in his book. Venu Chettiyar is the Producer of this movie .Once the whole production except the 'Chenthazham poovil' song were completed ..Venu chettiyar seen the rush of the movie and got very angry with Mahendran ..He didn't like the movie at all and afraid all his money lost since he beleived no distributer will take the movie..Now mahendran told him ,one more song is pending and that song is very important ..venu chettiyar got more angry and told he won't spend even a paise anymore and he won't allow any more shooting. Mahendran was helpless and finally he went to kamal Hassan who is friend of Mahendran and Balu Mahendra (camera man of this movie) .Kamal went to Venu chettiyar and requested him the same ..He explained How talented Mahendran and Balumahendra are ,,but Venu chettiyar was admament ..Finally kamal asked him "OK..You no need to spend anything ..Just give permission to proceed the shooting ..I will take care of money .is it OK? " ..Venu chettiyar said " Ennavo panni tholainga " ..kamal spent his money ,bought fim role and all necessary ,then they shooted 'Chenthazham poovil'..Rest is history. Mahendran mentioned in this book that he will never forget Kamal Hassan ,who is a great supporter of good cinema.

  
  
  Aandavaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
  
  

• From: crajkumar_be on Tue May 15 4:08:18 2007.

  [Full View]

  Just to add to Joe's post, i saw an interview with Mahendran in Podhigai channel 2 years back.
  Referring to the same incident, Mahendran also said: "Re-recording ku munnadi producer kitta kaatina padam vera, Ilaiyaraaja re-recording panna piragu vandha padame vera"
  
  

• From: thilak4life on Tue May 15 4:41:35 2007.

  [Full View]

  crajkumar_be wrote:

  Just to add to Joe's post, i saw an interview with Mahendran in Podhigai channel 2 years back. Referring to the same incident, Mahendran also said: "Re-recording ku munnadi producer kitta kaatina padam vera, Ilaiyaraaja re-recording panna piragu vandha padame vera"

  
  
  Maestro
  
  

• From: Nerd on Tue May 15 10:11:31 2007.

  [Full View]

  Thanks selva for the pick. This is my most favorite Rajini film till date. I will write more later
  
  

• From: raaja_rasigan on Tue May 15 10:13:25 2007.

  [Full View]

  crajkumar_be wrote:

  Just to add to Joe's post, i saw an interview with Mahendran in Podhigai channel 2 years back. Referring to the same incident, Mahendran also said: "Re-recording ku munnadi producer kitta kaatina padam vera, Ilaiyaraaja re-recording panna piragu vandha padame vera"

  
  
  i too had viewed it:
  
  actually b4 re-recording producer saw the film & told to mahendran,
  
  "ayyo en panamellam poachu, oomai padam maadhiri irukku"
  
  But Mahendran is confident that Ilaiyaraaja is yet to do the re-recording & his music will do the talkings.
  
  (producer is even more angry bcoz he is hesitant to make rajini as a hero, bcoz of mahendran he got convinced first)
  
  

• From: Nerd on Tue May 15 11:05:28 2007.

  [Full View]

  Scene#1:
  
  An old man abuses an innocent and meek coolie and refuses him the right amount of money for the work that he performed (petti thookkuthal enRu ninaikkiREn)
  
  Rajini will be silently watching all this. After the old man enters his house, Rajini will pick up a stone and will break one of the headlights and will walk away casually. No dialogs whatsoever till that point.
  
  Now we all know who kaaLi is!
  
  
  
  

• From: RC on Tue May 15 11:25:09 2007.

  [Full View]

  joe wrote:

  Interesting Info about this movie... Mahendran mentioned in his book. Venu Chettiyar is the Producer of this movie .Once the whole production except the 'Chenthazham poovil' song were completed ..Venu chettiyar seen the rush of the movie and got very angry with Mahendran ..He didn't like the movie at all and afraid all his money lost since he beleived no distributer will take the movie..Now mahendran told him ,one more song is pending and that song is very important ..venu chettiyar got more angry and told he won't spend even a paise anymore and he won't allow any more shooting. Mahendran was helpless and finally he went to kamal Hassan who is friend of Mahendran and Balu Mahendra (camera man of this movie) .Kamal went to Venu chettiyar and requested him the same ..He explained How talented Mahendran and Balumahendra are ,,but Venu chettiyar was admament ..Finally kamal asked him "OK..You no need to spend anything ..Just give permission to proceed the shooting ..I will take care of money .is it OK? " ..Venu chettiyar said " Ennavo panni tholainga " ..kamal spent his money ,bought fim role and all necessary ,then they shooted 'Chenthazham poovil'..Rest is history. Mahendran mentioned in this book that he will never forget Kamal Hassan ,who is a great supporter of good cinema.

  
  
  I have read this or (I'm not sure if I ) heard Mahendran talk about this. But always wondered why Mahendran did not work with Kamal. Or did he?
  
  

• From: Raghu on Tue May 15 11:26:28 2007.

  [Full View]

  SUPER* as an ANGRY and AGGRESSIVE youth was EXCELLENT, esp when all the confrontation with Sarathbabu were AWSOME, esp when he will get those guys to play the Melam and Nathasvaram and dance infront of sartha and humiliate him, excellent , excellent performance from an ACE actor
  
  

• From: Nerd on Tue May 15 11:52:52 2007.

  [Full View]

  Another scene:
  
  Rajini will be beating up a lot of thugs and after that incident, his friends will try to console him and Rajini will say,
  
  naanum en thangachiyum pichai edukka dhAn indha oorukku vanthOmAm. iva aathA kitteyA pOyi sORu kEttOm
  
  Rajini can emote very well, this scene is a classic example
  
  

• From: shobana_in on Tue May 15 12:30:01 2007.

  [Full View]

  using hands to act
  
  mahendran makes the heroes use the hands well...esp rajni had used his hands very well to emote...
  
  

• From: kannannn on Tue May 15 13:33:40 2007.

  [Full View]

  Easily my favourite Rajini movie. My favourite scene is the one where he meets Sarath Babu after the accident:
  "Rendu Kaiyum rendu kaalum ponaalum indha Kaalingravan pozhachikuvaan sir, Ketta paya sir avan." Amazing narrowing of the eyes to express his character..
  
  

• From: thilak4life on Tue May 15 15:22:40 2007.

  [Full View]

  Rajini would come back home after a little bit of dosage from Sarath babu. I think his sister and the other female would be little worried and he would first shout at them and almost to the juncture of bashing them all and would almost go to beat her, then he would say 'Moonja paaru' and I think "yaey yenna yenna" - finally they would all laugh their hearts out. Could Still remember the scene
  
  

• From: ajithfederer on Tue May 15 15:29:14 2007.

  [Full View]

  While rajini is shaving his beard, Sarathbabu's assistant would come and say "Ayya ungalai ippovae paakanumnu sonnar"
  
  rajini would reply " shave pannittu varein solraa poda"
  
  "ippovae paakanumnu sonnar"
  
  The next screenshot would be rajini standing in front of sarathbabu's house with shaving cream allover his face and would say"Ippovae paakanumnu sonnegalamae"
  
  
  
  

• From: m_23_bayarea on Tue May 15 16:14:46 2007.

  [Full View]

  The scene where Rajini will cry to Shobha explaining why he beat somebody on the road, when that guy said Rajini was ill-treating his sister's life or something like that! Rajini's voice will become so loud and he'll be crying alongside... Amazing scene!
  
  
  
  

• From: Nerd on Wed May 16 1:03:34 2007.

  [Full View]

  Another scene:
  
  Rajini's manager sarathbabu comes to his city for the first time and witnesses that Rajini is using the winch to help the poor carry their stuff to the city from the mountains. Sarathbabu is like,
  
  sarkkAr sotha ipdi ellAm payanpadutha kUdathu
  
  Rajini will gives a sarcastic look and says this to the *passengers*
  
  adhu dhAn ayya sollittArulla iRangungadA
  
  Sarath asks Rajini to start the winch so that he could go to his office/site. Rajini will oblige but when the winch is exactly halfway between the city and where it started, he will stop the winch and shout,
  
  sir veLa seyyala sir, nadanthE pOnga
  
  

• From: Raghu on Wed May 16 5:34:20 2007.

  [Full View]

  ajithfederer wrote:

  While rajini is shaving his beard, Sarathbabu's assistant would come and say "Ayya ungalai ippovae paakanumnu sonnar" rajini would reply " shave pannittu varein solraa poda" "ippovae paakanumnu sonnar" The next screenshot would be rajini standing in front of sarathbabu's house with shaving cream allover his face and would say"Ippovae paakanumnu sonnegalamae"

  
  
  super scene-pa athu, SUPERB* facial expression was AWSOME as usual.
  
  

• From: thilak4life on Wed May 16 5:48:14 2007.

  [Full View]

  kannannn wrote:

  Easily my favourite Rajini movie. My favourite scene is the one where he meets Sarath Babu after the accident: "Rendu Kaiyum rendu kaalum ponaalum indha Kaalingravan pozhachikuvaan sir, Ketta paya sir avan." Amazing narrowing of the eyes to express his character..

  
  
  
  Kannann,
  
  Before that "Paravalla sir..unga yedathula naan irundalum ippidi daan nadandhu-kuvaen..Kevalam namba yellam manushanga daane"...
  
  "Rendu Kaiyum rendu kaalum ponaalum indha Kaalingravan pozhachikuvaan sir.....Ketta Payyaaeeen Sir Avan"..then he would control himself from crying and finally "Sandosham sir...romba sandosham", I think he will salute and go..
  
  Easily the best scene of the movie
  
  

• From: Shakthiprabha on Fri May 18 8:28:19 2007.

  [Full View]

  oh wow.
  
  last scene.
  
  rajnikant's magnanimity...
  
  
  
  if someone can steal the show even BY JUST BEING QUIET... its RAJNIKANT.
  
  Why alone shobha (who won best actress award for her performance elsewhere) sarathbabu, phataphat jayalakshmi, u name them and they all queue up behind rajnikant.
  
  One name which stands significantly away from others in the impact it creats is RAJNIKANT.
  
  After watching muLLum malarum, hindi version and mithun's performance is NOTHING comparitivley.
  
  

• From: Shakthiprabha on Fri May 18 8:33:15 2007.

  [Full View]

  I dont know if I can propose the next movie...
  
  I dont know if I should pm selva or anyone else.
  
  I would like to have the foll mvoies as movie of the week sometimes.
  
  1. Johnny
  2. ThiruviLaiyadal
  3. micheal madhana kaama rajan
  4. unnal mudiyum thambi
  5. 6il irunthu 60 varai
  6. avaL appadiththaan
  7. athE kangaL
  8. puthu puthu arthangaL
  
  as of now...
  
  dunno if some movies were already discussed.
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Fri May 18 9:20:35 2007.

  [Full View]

  Shakthiprabha wrote:

  I dont know if I can propose the next movie... I dont know if I should pm selva or anyone else. I would like to have the foll mvoies as movie of the week sometimes.

  
  
  Idhukku thaan "Aadikku oruthada Amavaasaikku oruthadava TF section vara koodaathunnu sollurathu"
  
  Yes, YOu have to send me a PM. Ippadi mothamaa list pannunaa, vera yaaravathu oruthar idhu varaikkum vantha tamil padam ellaathayum post pannidu vaanga
  
  P.S: I humbly request you to nominate one movie at a time
  
  

• From: Shakthiprabha on Fri May 18 9:28:54 2007.

  [Full View]

  sari selva sorry
  
  I nominate
  
  JOHNNY (if its not already done)
  
  as my next immy choice.
  
  

• From: shobana_in on Fri May 18 9:30:18 2007.

  [Full View]

  Shakthiprabha wrote:

  sari selva sorry I nominate JOHNNY (if its not already done) as my next immy choice.

  
  
  
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Fri May 18 9:32:05 2007.

  [Full View]

  Fine SP !
  
  

• From: Nerd on Fri May 18 9:41:04 2007.

  [Full View]

  ANother scene:
  
  After Rajini loses his hand, his buddies will come to see him and console him. Eveyone will start crying and throwing words like naan pAthukkuREn kALi. Rajini,
  
  deii. ellArum enthiruchu pOngadA. kai pOna ennadA sethAdA pOyittEn? kAlampoorA ungaLA ukkAra vechu nAn sORu pOduvENdA
  
  Another one of Mahendran's famous close-up shots and Rajini would have shown terrific emotions
  
  Cross-posting. Actually intended to post here only
  
  

• From: Roshan on Sun May 20 13:12:49 2007.

  [Full View]

  Listening to 'senthaazam poovil ' now - thought of posting the lyrics here ..
  
  செந்தாழம் பூவில் வந்தாடும் தென்றல்
  என் மீது மோதுதம்மா
  பூ வாசம் மேடை போடுதம்மா
  பெண்போல ஜாடை பேசுதம்மா
  அம்மம்மா ஆனந்தம்
  
  வளைந்து வ்ளைந்து போகும்பாதை மங்கை மோக கூந்தலோ
  மயங்கி மயங்கி செல்லும் வெள்ளம் பருவ நாண ஊடலோ
  ஆலங்கொடி மேலே கிளி தேன் கனிகளை தேடுது
  ஆசை குயில் பாஷை இன்றி ராகம் என்ன பாடுது
  காடுகள் மலைகள் தேவன் கலைகள்
  
  --- செந்தாழ்ம்பூவில்----
  
  அழகு மிகுந்த ராஜகுமாரி மேகமாக போகிறாள்
  ஜரிகை நெளியும் சேலை கொண்டு மலையை மூட பார்க்கிறாள்
  பள்ளம் சில உள்ளம் என ஏன் படைத்தான் ஆண்டவன்
  பட்டம் தர தேடுகின்றேன் எங்கே அந்த நாயகன்
  மலையின் காட்சி இறைவன் ஆட்சி
  
  --- செந்தாழம்பூவில்---
  
  
  இளைய பருவம் மலையில் வந்தால் ஏகம் சொர்க்க சிந்தனை
  இதழில் வழியும் பனியின் காற்று கம்பன் செய்த வர்ணனை
  ஓடை தரும் வாடை காற்று வான் உலகை காட்டுது
  உள்ளெ வரும் வெள்ளம் ஒன்று எங்கோ என்னை கூட்டுது
  மறவேன் மறவேன் அற்புத காட்சி
  
  --- செந்தாழம்பூவில்----
  
  

• From: shobana_in on Sun May 20 13:26:58 2007.

  [Full View]

  Roshan wrote:

  Listening to 'senthaazam poovil ' now - thought of posting the lyrics here .. செந்தாழம் பூவில் வந்தாடும் தென்றல் என் மீது மோதுதம்மா பூ வாசம் மேடை போடுதம்மா பெண்போல ஜாடை பேசுதம்மா அம்மம்மா ஆனந்தம் வளைந்து வ்ளைந்து போகும்பாதை மங்கை மோக கூந்தலோ மயங்கி மயங்கி செல்லும் வெள்ளம் பருவ நாண ஊடலோ ஆலங்கொடி மேலே கிளி தேன் கனிகளை தேடுது ஆசை குயில் பாஷை இன்றி ராகம் என்ன பாடுது காடுகள் மலைகள் தேவன் கலைகள் --- செந்தாழ்ம்பூவில்---- அழகு மிகுந்த ராஜகுமாரி மேகமாக போகிறாள் ஜரிகை நெளியும் சேலை கொண்டு மலையை மூட பார்க்கிறாள் பள்ளம் சில உள்ளம் என ஏன் படைத்தான் ஆண்டவன் பட்டம் தர தேடுகின்றேன் எங்கே அந்த நாயகன் மலையின் காட்சி இறைவன் ஆட்சி --- செந்தாழம்பூவில்--- இளைய பருவம் மலையில் வந்தால் ஏகம் சொர்க்க சிந்தனை இதழில் வழியும் பனியின் காற்று கம்பன் செய்த வர்ணனை ஓடை தரும் வாடை காற்று வான் உலகை காட்டுது உள்ளெ வரும் வெள்ளம் ஒன்று எங்கோ என்னை கூட்டுது மறவேன் மறவேன் அற்புத காட்சி --- செந்தாழம்பூவில்----

  
  
  kannadasan
  
  

• From: Nerd on Sun May 20 14:48:47 2007.

  [Full View]

  The climax:
  
  vaLLidA en thangachi
  
  My most favorite scene in the movie
  
  

• From: rachel on Sun May 20 17:58:05 2007.

  [Full View]

  shobana_in wrote:

  Roshan wrote: Listening to 'senthaazam poovil ' now - thought of posting the lyrics here .. செந்தாழம் பூவில் வந்தாடும் தென்றல் என் மீது மோதுதம்மா பூ வாசம் மேடை போடுதம்மா பெண்போல ஜாடை பேசுதம்மா அம்மம்மா ஆனந்தம் --- செந்தாழம்பூவில்---- kannadasan

  
  
  is he writing about a woman?
  
  

• From: Thamizh-ahsan on Sun May 20 20:15:02 2007.

  [Full View]

  What does the title Mullum Malarum means?
  
  Is it Mull AND Malar or
  
  Mul Kooda Malarum endru arthama?
  
  

• From: rachel on Sun May 20 20:57:38 2007.

  [Full View]

  Thamizh-ahsan wrote:

  What does the title Mullum Malarum means? Is it Mull AND Malar or Mul Kooda Malarum endru arthama?

  
  
  mul + malar endru artham
  
  

• From: joe on Sun May 20 21:23:45 2007.

  [Full View]

  rachel wrote:

  Thamizh-ahsan wrote: What does the title Mullum Malarum means? Is it Mull AND Malar or Mul Kooda Malarum endru arthama? mul + malar endru artham

  
  
  No..It means MuLLum (oru naaL) Malarum.
  
  

• From: Shakthiprabha on Sun May 20 22:15:12 2007.

  [Full View]

  Nerd wrote:

  The climax: vaLLidA en thangachi My most favorite scene in the movie

  
  
  
  
  such pride!
  
  

• From: rachel on Mon May 21 0:21:11 2007.

  [Full View]

  joe wrote:

  rachel wrote: Thamizh-ahsan wrote: What does the title Mullum Malarum means? Is it Mull AND Malar or Mul Kooda Malarum endru arthama? mul + malar endru artham No..It means MuLLum (oru naaL) Malarum.

  
  
  
  i only heard about poo malarum. i never heard about mul malarum what the hell
  
  

• From: joe on Mon May 21 0:26:45 2007.

  [Full View]

  rachel wrote:

  joe wrote: rachel wrote: Thamizh-ahsan wrote: What does the title Mullum Malarum means? Is it Mull AND Malar or Mul Kooda Malarum endru arthama? mul + malar endru artham No..It means MuLLum (oru naaL) Malarum. i only heard about poo malarum. i never heard about mul malarum what the hell

  
  
  If Poo (Mottu) become malar ,it is nothing unusual and not a surprise ..But If a MuL become malar ,it is unusual and surprise
  
  "Poo Ontru Puyalanathu"..will it really hapen..Just take it in poetic way.
  
  

• From: rachel on Mon May 21 0:32:57 2007.

  [Full View]

  joe wrote:

  rachel wrote: joe wrote: rachel wrote: Thamizh-ahsan wrote: What does the title Mullum Malarum means? Is it Mull AND Malar or Mul Kooda Malarum endru arthama? mul + malar endru artham No..It means MuLLum (oru naaL) Malarum. i only heard about poo malarum. i never heard about mul malarum what the hell If Poo (Mottu) become malar ,it is nothing unusual and not a surprise ..But If a MuL become malar ,it is unusual and surprise "Poo Ontru Puyalanathu"..will it really hapen..Just take it in poetic way.

  
  
  oh.
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Mon May 21 10:31:36 2007.

  [Full View]

  
  
  Thiruvilayadal
  
  Thiruvilayadal (1965) is a Tamil feature film directed by A.P. Nagarajan. The cast includes Sivaji Ganesan, R. Muthuraman, Savithri, Nagesh, Manorama, and Balaiyah. It was one of the memorable films of Sivaji Ganesan and Nagesh.
  
  Plot
  
  The story comprises 4 episodes involving Lord Shiva and all 4 have different stories called as leelaigal. Each part teaches you something for life at the end. All stories have Lord Shiva as the main character and what he does to test the patience and devotions of His devotees. The sound track of this film is popular even today - after 40 years and is still played during temple festivals in Tamil Nadu.
  
  Trivia
  
  * The Dharumi scene played by Nagesh is memorable and the dialogues in that part of the movie are a feast.
  * Songs are excellent though classical.
  * The director A P Nagarajan himself did the role of Nakkeeran in the first episode.
  
  -----------------------------------------------------------------------
  So, Here we go with a Nadigar Thilagam film. Since many movies have been discussed in detail in NT thread, I have selected this movie (with suggestions from HUBBERS) since it has not been discussed that much in NT thread. (Thanks to NT fans for sparing this classic )
  
  P.S: thanks for sharing ur comments on the classic MM (Mullum oru naal Malarum)
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Mon May 21 10:34:47 2007.

  [Full View]

  http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0246986/
  

  Quote:

  If you are a fan of mythological movies this is a must watch. Sivaji Ganesan plays Lord Shiva and plays it in a manner that people will remember it for years to come. The story comprises of 4 parts and all 4 have different stories called as leelaigal. Each part teaches you something for life at the end. Songs are excellent though classical. Sivaji's acting in this movie is just too good. The dharmi scene played by Nagesh is memorable and the dialogues in that part of the movie are a feast. It is a nice Sunday afternoon movie.

  
  

• From: thilak4life on Mon May 21 10:38:40 2007.

  [Full View]

  Quote:

  The dharmi scene played by Nagesh is memorable and the dialogues in that part of the movie are a feast.

  
  
  Anyone who have a link to that particular scene. And if possible, pen that down here!
  
  I watched this movie when I was a kid, remember that scene 'the most'. Moreover, the scene was also played many times in television.
  
  NT
  Nagesh
  
  

• From: Nakeeran on Mon May 21 10:40:25 2007.

  [Full View]

  >>> real benchmark for a BAKTHI movie
  
  >>> The best part - Nagesh- NT Dharumi's question and NT's hands replying with grace !
  
  >>> Superb music . Hats off to Shri KVM
  
  >>> NT shows his versatility - As Lord Shiva - as a poet with ego - as a fisherman - as an uneducated but worldly knowledge possessed guy - rathful hubby of Dakshayini - FINALLY AS A FATHER
  
  A.P.Nagarajan - Great man
  
  

• From: Nakeeran on Mon May 21 10:44:53 2007.

  [Full View]

  Link for the movie :
  
  http://123indianonline.com/movies/thiruvilayadal-1965/
  
  

• From: joe on Mon May 21 10:49:10 2007.

  [Full View]

  "THIRUVILAYADAL" - BAKTHI MOVIE REVIEW BY "YOUR PRABHU"
  
  "NADIGAR THILAGAM" SHIVAJI GANESAN, "SUPER GIRL" SAVITHRI, MUTHU RAMAN, "MADURAI MODEL" DEVIKA, "KANAVU KANNI" K.P. SUNDARAMBAL, BALAIYA, NAGESH in a Super Duper Hit movie of last century "THIRUVILAYADAL" (EAST MAN COLOR) Music by K.V. MAHADEVAN. Enjoy my Review on LOLLU Classic collections "THIRUVILAYADAL".
  
  OVERVIEW:
  
  I still remember the days when i was in India there will be one Month in a Year Called "MARGAZHI". Its some thing like FALL Month or SPRING Month in US. If that MARGAZHI month comes that's it. No one in Madras can Study or Sleep or concentrate on any thing. There will be Speakers hanging in front of your house and those speakers will be in a Cone Shape normally painted in Blue or Violet Color and it will have a stamp called K.R Sound System or M.J Sound System and all that it does is Play "THIRUVILAYADAL" audio cassette Three Times a Day. No one can ask any question to the guy who is Playing that Audio. If you ask some thing the VOLUME will increase the next day. Why i am saying this story is "When i saw the movie yesterday all the dialogs are in My heart ". Its really nice to see such movie again and it gives you a sort of Pleasure and happiness!!!
  
  STORY:
  
  The story starts in a big way. A Man with a Goat Head and a Man with Elephant Head along with Six Ugly guys wearing a Red Lungi and who are dark in color and to make them more beautiful they have painted they body with COAL POWDER (Kari Powder) and who have two Horns in their head all of them beating some musical Instruments like TABLA, GANJIRA and creating music like BACK STREET BOYS and 20 JACKET LESS 30 Years old Auntie's Dancing for the music. The music went for 10 Minutes and i got a doubt that I got some OLD MUSIC CONCERT and its not THIRUVILAYADAL.
  
  At last SHIVAJI comes with a SNAKE in his Neck with a BLUE COLOR Powder in his body with THREE PATTAIS of Thiru Noor on his fore head and his hair folded into Three Layers and it looks exactly like a "WENDYS CHICKEN BURGER" with a TIGER SKIN LEATHER SHORTS without a Shirt along with SAVITHRI who was wearing a weird Saree which is a mixture of SAREE & CHUDI and some Rajastan Glass on the saree with a Skin Color Full hand Jacket with lots and lots of Gold Ornament etc etc. and both of them walking as if they are walking in a "FASHION PARADE" in MADISON SQUARE GARDEN. Then their Two sons (MURUGA & VINAYAGA) joins and they four gives a Family Pose in a place which looks like a Dance Floor in Kansas City with lots and lots of Steam and clouds around them.
  
  A Villan so called as "NARADHAR" who basically does the Job our "SUBRAMANIYA SWAMY" brings a Fruit which he bought in "AMINJIKARAI PLATFORM". I think its some Orange or Mango which you get for 50 Paise in India and says that its a Powerful fruit (GANA PAZAM). These two kids fight for that stupid fruit that NARADHAR gave and they will be shouting and crying and howling for that fruit. SAVITHRI who is a good Mom like DEMMI MOORE In STRIPTIES does' nt like her kids fighting for the FRUIT and asks them to eat half half. But SHIVAJI says that a FRUIT from AMINJIKARAI market must be eaten fully and you must not break into piece as FLYS and MOSQUITOES will come if you break the fruit into two.
  
  And there comes the competition. NARADAR keeps a running race. Its not the regular 100M or 400 M or 10 MILES like Marathon. For a simple 50 Paise ORANGE he asks the sad kids to make a round around the world. MURUGA who is a Poor Kid boards LUFTHANSA Airways From MADRAS and some how reaches LONDON and then makes a Connection in LONDON and reaches NEW YORK and then to NAGANO, JAPAN and Via SINGAPORE he reaches MADRAS again. Sad guy he has to wait for one Full day in JFK because of the FLIGHT DELAYS and Air Traffic in SINGAPORE. His brother VINAYAGA is a smart kid. He works out a formulae using TRAVELLING SALES MAN ROUTE and makes a round in seconds and gets the fruit.
  
  MURUGA who was tired after the Security check in Madras Airport some how manages to come out and asks the fruit. Where the hell he will the get the fruit its in VINAYAGAR Stomach. His Brother who has a Elephant head and a Tail and who looks like a Teddy bear. MURUGA gets irritated and gets out of his house and the real fun starts. An old lady (K.P SUNDARAMBAL) starts to sing. She will be wearing a MAJANTHA cotton saree and she will be having a walking stick and starts her famous song,
  
  Sing along with me .....
  
  PAZAM NE APPA GANA PAZAM NE APPA
  TAMIZ GANA PAZAM NE APPA (Repeat the two lines Three times in a DONKEY TONE)
  
  THIRU SABAYIL ORUVANA
  ARVULAGA KUMARA NEEEE......
  ARUVADU SINAM ORUVADU MAYIL
  ARIYADHA SIRUVANA NEEEEEEE........ (Change your voice to MONKEY TONE)
  
  PAZAM NE APPA GANA PAZAM NE APPA
  TAMIZ GANA PAZAM NE APPA (Repeat the two lines Three times in a DIANOSER TONE)
  
  No Song or advice can stop MURUGA's Anger. So her mom starts to tell stories about their family. What and all his father has done in past. Three to four flash back comes.
  
  First Flash back is MUTHURAMAN and DEVIKA. Muthuraman who is the king of Madurai and Devika who is the queen. Muthuraman who smells Devika's head and gets a BIG DOUBT. The doubt is "DOES FEMALS HEAD HAS A NATURAL FRAGRANCE OR NOT" ..... Aha what doubt. Just think how our KINGS who ruled India has wasted their time and brain and Money. He announces 1000 Gold Dollar who clears his doubt.
  
  Nagesh comes into picture who is a Poor poet and the way he has done that part was simply superb. SIVAJI who tries to help NAGAESH and Nagesh in turn asks who are you.
  
  Sivaji replies in his famous tone (Hope everyone knows what is SIVAJI's tone)
  
  18 IYUM, 21 IYUM SERTHU
  SUPER FIGURA PARTHU
  SUPARA JOLLU VIDUM JOLLU NAAN .....
  
  
  Then a Competition comes who is the big Jollu ....... Nagesh Asks few Questions to Sivaji Like
  
  " LKG" FIGARUKU "SBOA"
  " SCHOOL" FIGARUKU " SARADHA VIDYALAYA"
  " COLLEGE" FIGARUKU KANJIPURAM ARTS
  " JEANSUKU" ETHIRAJ
  " DAVANIKU" LADY WELINGTON
  " SAREE" FIGARUKU " UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN, DETROIT"
  " CHAPA" FIGARUKU ' UNIVERSITY OF TEXAS, EL PASO"
  " SUPER" FIGARUKU " BAIN SCHOOL"
  " AUNTIES" KU " ANNA NAGAR"
  " PATTIES" KU " PARANGI MALAI"
  " MID RANGE" FIGARUKU " SATHTABHAMA"
  " SUPER" FIGARUKU " SRM"
  " SONGI" FIGARUKU " CRECENT"
  " KATAIKU" STELLA MARIS
  " HALWAVUKU" VALIAMMAL
  " GILMAVUKU" VELAMMAL
  ..... The story ends as another fight goes between SIVAJI and NAKIRAN..... and all those comedy and Nagesh getting that 1000 Gold coins.
  
  There are another three flash backs in the story. All three are real Galij like Sivaji Fighting with a big Sea Whale, The whale is a real big one like the one in San Antonio Sea World. A song competition between Sivaji and Balayia and atlast the movie ends with MURUGAN understanding the fault and joins his family and the place from that day was called as "PALANI" where people goes to put their MOTTAI .....
  
  SIVAJI GANESHAN:
  
  A real super duper actor on Tamil Cinema. Each and every character he did in his Movie career are really amazing. You can list 100's of movies .. One can say that his body also acts! Each and every Vasanams he deliver with his facial expressions are really superb, I would say one must see his movies and get a feel what Acing is and how a actor must act. Not only in this movie his super hits like PASA MALAR, VIRA PANDIYA KATA BOMAN, KAPAL OTIYA THAMIZAN, MANOHARA till his MUDAL MARIYADAI ..... he is really a Super Actor and he deserves the Title "NADIGAR THILAGAM" Lollu Express wishes all the best to DR. SIVAJI GANESHAN
  
  SAVITHRI & DEVIKA:
  
  Of course DEVIKA is the Most beautiful female of 60's and 70's. My god in this movie she was toooo good. Her neat face with her flat Bottu really impressed me. I wonder why her daughter didnt get that good look. SAVITHRI is also a wonderful artist. But i still wonder how these females were able to manage their show being like a small Elephant. Almost all the artist were like that in 60's and 70's!! Savithri Gemini Ganesan "Koduthu Vaithavan"....
  
  LOLLU COMMENTS :
  
  An Excellent Comedy. It was really nice to see TIGER SKIN SHORTS and SNAKES hanging with DANCE FLOOR environment and our SIVAJI doing his CAT WALK with his TIGER SHORTS with a weird hair style. But thats how it works and thats how he made his fans to fall in his feet. If i want to say about SIVAJI i need to write another THREE pages. I will do it separately in my article section.
  
  Ever the artist who acted with Sivaji were excellent. Good Make up and ultimate songs by Sirgali Govindarajan, K.P Sundarmbal although it seems funny these days. Especially that
  
  "PATTUM NANNE PADALUM NANNE"
  PADUM UNNAI NAAN PADAL ARINDENE.....
  NAN ASIYNDAL ASYUM AGILAM ELLAME ....
  
  song .... by SIVAJI .... it takes you to another world... Good movie and a great change for anyone who are used to watching some masala movies I heartly grade this movie 90/100 for saying what?s happening in Heaven, What was the history of Lord Muruga, Lord Vinayaga, Lord Naradar ... and for the wonderful setup and for the make up.
  
  WITH LOVE,
  PRABHU,
  http://www.lolluexpress.com/thiruv.htm
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Mon May 21 10:49:59 2007.

  [Full View]

  "Naan asainthaal asaiyum agilam ellaamae"
  
  My favorite scene in the movie. That song was awesome.
  
  and who can forget the conversation b/w NT & Nagesh
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Mon May 21 10:51:16 2007.

  [Full View]

  Joe,
  
  
  

• From: Nakeeran on Mon May 21 10:53:07 2007.

  [Full View]

  Awesome display by NT for Pattum naane baavamum naane ! especially the final part when some 5-6 players ( all NT ) join together and create a real delight to the eyes ! Amazing sync. work by Nadigar thilagam sir !
  
  

• From: Nerd on Mon May 21 10:53:49 2007.

  [Full View]

  selvakumar wrote:

  Joe,

  
  
  
  
  But that review was damn hilarious
  
  Again its been long since I saw the movie so I dont have anything to say. And yeh naan asainthAl is one heck of a song
  
  

• From: joe on Mon May 21 10:54:24 2007.

  [Full View]

  Watch the evergreen NT-Nagesh session
  
  http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=paVn36tNRA4
  
  

• From: thilak4life on Mon May 21 10:56:06 2007.

  [Full View]

  Nakeeran,
  
  Thanks mate..
  
  

  joe wrote:

  Watch the evergreen NT-Nagesh session http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=paVn36tNRA4

  
  
  Thanks a lot!!!
  
  

• From: joe on Mon May 21 10:56:45 2007.

  [Full View]

  selvakumar wrote:

  Joe,

  
  
  Why shocked?
  The review is lollu ,I know ..but It shows even current generation like this movie.
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Mon May 21 10:57:57 2007.

  [Full View]

  joe wrote:

  Why shocked? The review is lollu ,I know ..but It shows even current generation like this movie.

  
  
  It looked a bit odd. That is why.
  
  

• From: crajkumar_be on Mon May 21 10:58:39 2007.

  [Full View]

  
  One of my favorite Sivaji movies.
  
  Infact, when i was a kid, i used to "recite" the whole movie from start to finish.. ippo mukkaal vaasi marandhu pochu
  
  The Dharumi Nakkeeran episode is one of my favorites scenes in cinema ever.
  
  Sivaji
  Nagesh What a monologue!
  Dialogues
  Music
  
  

• From: Nakeeran on Mon May 21 11:00:08 2007.

  [Full View]

  Any idea who penned the dialogue exchange for that Dharumi- NT scene . Amazing work .
  
  

• From: Nakeeran on Mon May 21 11:00:36 2007.

  [Full View]

  Any idea who penned the dialogue exchange for that Dharumi- NT scene . Amazing work .
  
  

• From: Madavan on Mon May 21 11:02:01 2007.

  [Full View]

  joe wrote:

  selvakumar wrote: Joe, Why shocked? The review is lollu ,I know ..but It shows even current generation like this movie.

  
  
  bagthi padam enraal vayasu ellai ellam illai.
  
  

• From: joe on Mon May 21 11:04:03 2007.

  [Full View]

  Madavan wrote:

  joe wrote: selvakumar wrote: Joe, Why shocked? The review is lollu ,I know ..but It shows even current generation like this movie. bagthi padam enraal vayasu ellai ellam illai.

  
  
  Appadi solli vida mudiyathu ..Paktha prakalatha,lavagusa even kanthan karunai etc are cannot be enjoyed by youngsters now ..but Thiruvilayadal stands out!
  
  

• From: joe on Mon May 21 11:06:04 2007.

  [Full View]

  Nakeeran wrote:

  Any idea who penned the dialogue exchange for that Dharumi- NT scene . Amazing work .

  
  
  I think it should be by A.P.nagarajan himself ..Infact the fun is not much in the dialogues and it was mostly serious ..Nagesh's tremendous individuality and NT's gambeeram made the difference.
  
  

• From: Thirumaran on Mon May 21 11:08:42 2007.

  [Full View]

  Probably the best Devotional movie
  
  
  During my young days any Temple functions people show this movie by default. Almost every time i saw the movie during those times.
  
  Shivaji and Nagesh
  
  Songs
  
  

• From: Madavan on Mon May 21 11:11:21 2007.

  [Full View]

  joe wrote:

  Madavan wrote: joe wrote: selvakumar wrote: Joe, Why shocked? The review is lollu ,I know ..but It shows even current generation like this movie. bagthi padam enraal vayasu ellai ellam illai. Appadi solli vida mudiyathu ..Paktha prakalatha,lavagusa even kanthan karunai etc are cannot be enjoyed by youngsters now ..but Thiruvilayadal stands out!

  
  
  true because thiruvilaiyaadal has a better story than kanthan karunai.
  
  

• From: joe on Mon May 21 11:11:29 2007.

  [Full View]

  Friends,
  Before production of the movie 'ThiruviLayadal' ,NT was told ,according to Purana ,Siva peruman kannai imaikka maattar ..and throughout the movie NT made sure he never close his eyes even for a fraction of second unless he sleeps ..if you guys watch this movie again ,you can notice this ..This speaks volume of NT's dedication and professionalism
  
  

• From: thilak4life on Mon May 21 11:15:37 2007.

  [Full View]

  joe wrote:

  Friends, Before production of the movie 'ThiruviLayadal' ,NT was told ,according to Purana ,Siva peruman kannai imaikka maattar ..and throughout the movie NT made sure he never close his eyes even for a fraction of second unless he sleeps ..if you guys watch this movie again ,you can notice this ..This speaks volume of NT's dedication and professionalism

  
  
  unga avatar-a patha..NT's shot to reprise Gene kelly's 'singin' in the rain' madhiri irukku!!!
  
  

• From: Nakeeran on Mon May 21 11:20:24 2007.

  [Full View]

  no no thats from Andha naal
  
  

• From: joe on Mon May 21 11:48:42 2007.

  [Full View]

  when all of us talk about NT and Nagesh in ThiruviLayadal ...we should not miss Nadigayar Thilagam Saavithiri who acted as Parvathi ..I can't even imagine any other actress in the place of savithiri to match with NT's majesty .
  
  The Sivan-Sakthi fight between NT and savithri was matchless ..Savithri's bold and accurate Tamil pronounciation and elegance really matches with NT's Garjanai.
  
  

• From: Raghu on Mon May 21 12:00:14 2007.

  [Full View]

  Nt ?? u mean Nadigar Thilagam
  
  Joe anNe, - yes u r right, i ONLY thought about the eye lid movement after you have told, excellent from the DON of ACTING,
  
  Shivaji sir RulZZZ all the way
  
  
  I thoroughly ENJOYED the NAGESH sir and NT sir scene in the temple, HILARIOUS, esp those bodily movements NAGESH sir would do, amazing and the SIMMA KURAL of the GREATEST actor that INDIA had EVER produced Dr.SHIVAJI GANESHAN.
  
  
  
  
  

• From: joe on Mon May 21 12:59:14 2007.

  [Full View]

  Highlights of the Movie 'ThiruviLayadal'
  ------------------------------------------------
  
  1.Dialogues -evergreen
  2.Music - KVM ...super duper songs for a purana movie
  3.NT,Savithri,Nagesh,Balaih Acting
  4.KB suntharambal's apperance as Avvai Paati
  5.High quality sets and effects.
  6.Outstanding screen play
  
  

• From: joe on Mon May 21 13:28:50 2007.

  [Full View]

  Enjoy ThiruviLayadal songs
  
  http://www.raaga.com/channels/tamil/movie/T0000528.html
  
  

• From: joe on Mon May 21 13:39:00 2007.

  [Full View]

  Google video link
  
  http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=8782970385163628171
  
  

• From: joe on Mon May 21 21:30:06 2007.

  [Full View]

  வாரியார் சுவாமிகள், ஒரு கோயிலில் திருவிளையாடல் புராணம் சொற்பொழிவு வழங்கிக் கொண்டு இருந்தார்.
  
  வாரியார் சுவாமியின் சொற்பொழிவு கேட்பவர்கள் மிகக் கவனமாக கேட்பார்கள். ஏனெனில், அரங்கத்தில் அமர்ந்திருப்பவர்களிடம் திடீரென்று கேள்விகள் கேட்பார். எனவே, முன்வரிசையில் அமர்பவர்கள் மிக்க கவனத்துடன் இருப்பார்கள்.
  
  சிவபெருமானின் பெருமைகளைச் சொன்னபடி இருந்த கிருபானந்தவாரியார் திடீரென்று ஒரு சிறுவனை எழுப்பி "தம்பி! தருமிக்கு பாட்டு எழுதிக் கொடுத்தது யாரு?" என்று கேட்டார்.
  
  அப்போது திருவிளையாடல் படம் வெளிவந்திருந்த சமயம்.
  
  அந்த பையன் சட்டென்று எழுந்து "சிவாஜி" என்றான்.
  
  அனைவரும் விழுந்து விழுந்து சிரித்தனர்.
  
  வாரியார் அனைவரையும் நோக்கி "ஏன் சிரிக்கிறீங்க? அந்தப் பையன் சரியாத்தான் சொல்லியிருக்கான்"
  
  "நீங்க நேருவை நேருஜி -ன்னு சொல்றீங்க, காந்தியை காந்திஜி -ன்னு சொல்றீங்க, அதைப் போல்தான் இந்தப் பையன் சிவாவை சிவாஜி-ன்னு சொன்னான், வடக்கே ஒருத்தரை உயர்வா மரியாதையாய் அழைக்க 'ஜி' சேர்ப்பது வழக்கம் , அந்த அர்த்தத்தில் 'சிவா' கூட 'ஜி' சேர்த்து சிவாஜின்னு சொல்லி இருக்கான் " என்றாரே பார்க்கலாம்.
  
  கூட்டம் வாரியாரின் நகைச்சுவைத் திறமை கண்டு வழக்கம் போல் அதிசயித்து நின்றது.
  
  

• From: kalnayak on Tue May 22 0:25:06 2007.

  [Full View]

  Selvakumar,
  
  Please change the title from Mullum Malarum to Thiruvilaiyaadal, so that many who have not commented Thiruvilaiyaadal will come.
  
  

• From: Sanguine Sridhar on Tue May 22 0:34:11 2007.

  [Full View]

  Thank you so much Selva
  
  What a pick..!
  
  Thiruvilayadal a true classic movie with some great acting by NT,Savithri...! Wonderful direction by A.P.Nagarajan
  
  I am waiting for experts like Joe, Groucho and other NT fans to speak abt this movie...
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Tue May 22 0:54:45 2007.

  [Full View]

  kalnayak wrote:

  Selvakumar, Please change the title from Mullum Malarum to Thiruvilaiyaadal, so that many who have not commented Thiruvilaiyaadal will come.

  
  
  Neenga yaarunga ? I changed The title yesterday itself
  
  

• From: umaramesh on Tue May 22 3:49:09 2007.

  [Full View]

  Guys
  
  One should not forget MAMA KVM . He gave excellent variety in this movie.
  
  people forgot to mention about ORU NAAL PODHUMA song .
  
  I cant imagine someone else other than TMS for PATTUM NAANAE. He gave life to NT acting in this sequence.
  
  KOTTUM ISAYUM KOTTIN MORAIYUM KATTUM ENNIDAM KATHAI SOLLA VANTHAYO . He sang effortlessly .
  
  regards
  ramesh
  
  

• From: leosimha on Tue May 22 3:58:46 2007.

  [Full View]

  joe wrote:

  Highlights of the Movie 'ThiruviLayadal' ------------------------------------------------ 1.Dialogues -evergreen 2.Music - KVM ...super duper songs for a purana movie 3.NT,Savithri,Nagesh,Balaih Acting 4.KB suntharambal's apperance as Avvai Paati 5.High quality sets and effects. 6.Outstanding screen play

  
  
  joe, this is one of my favorite movies...I would love to watch it again and again...umpteen number of times...not getting bored at all...an evergreen movie...
  
  a very good movie....
  
  but I would like to comment on one aspect about Sivaji's portrayal of Lord Shiva...
  
  Lord Shiva is actually "tamasic" in nature but Sivaji Ganesh portrayed Lord Shiva as "Rajasik" in nature in Tiruvilaiyaadal...
  
  

• From: kalnayak on Tue May 22 4:58:24 2007.

  [Full View]

  Quote:

  Selva Wrote: kalnayak wrote: Selvakumar, Please change the title from Mullum Malarum to Thiruvilaiyaadal, so that many who have not commented Thiruvilaiyaadal will come. Confused2 Neenga yaarunga ? Rolling Eyes I changed The title yesterday itself Rolling Eyes

  
  
  Selva,
  The Title of the forum appeared as 'MOVIE OF THE WEEK - "Mullum Malarum"', but discussion was going on "Thiruvilayaadal". Hence I asked you to change.
  
  Naan yaaru atha solrathukkunnu ketta enna solrathu - En systemla first time appadi appear agivittatho ennavo. Aandava!!!javascript:emoticon('')
  
  

• From: joe on Tue May 22 5:03:17 2007.

  [Full View]

  Kalnayak,
  The title changed from the begining ..May be something wrong with your browser ,you should have refresh the page.
  
  

• From: Thirumaran on Tue May 22 5:06:06 2007.

  [Full View]

  kalnayak wrote:

  Selva, The Title of the forum appeared as 'MOVIE OF THE WEEK - "Mullum Malarum"', but discussion was going on "Thiruvilayaadal". Hence I asked you to change. Naan yaaru atha solrathukkunnu ketta enna solrathu - En systemla first time appadi appear agivittatho ennavo. Aandava!!!javascript:emoticon('')

  
  
  He did not mean it in that way. It was just at a lighter sense.
  
  by the way, From the time the movie was decided as Thiruvilayaadal the title was changed. Issue could be with ur browser
  
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Tue May 22 5:11:59 2007.

  [Full View]

  kalnayak wrote:

  Naan yaaru atha solrathukkunnu ketta enna solrathu - En systemla first time appadi appear agivittatho ennavo. Aandava!!!javascript:emoticon('')

  
  
  I didn't mean that way. IF that sounded like that to you, my apologies.
  I just said that I changed the title of the thread from the beginning itself. Always I edit the title, right after my first post on the next movie in this thread.
  
  

• From: joe on Tue May 22 5:57:26 2007.

  [Full View]

  leosimha wrote:

  Lord Shiva is actually "tamasic" in nature but Sivaji Ganesh portrayed Lord Shiva as "Rajasik" in nature in Tiruvilaiyaadal...

  
  
  I am not sure what excatly you mean
  
  In my understanding ,Unlike Lord krishna (who is passive) ,LordSiva is known for energetic and agression. (Correct me if I am wrong)
  
  Moreover ,Lord siva comes as Viragu vetti and Meenavan .
  
  

• From: leosimha on Tue May 22 6:03:16 2007.

  [Full View]

  joe wrote:

  leosimha wrote: Lord Shiva is actually "tamasic" in nature but Sivaji Ganesh portrayed Lord Shiva as "Rajasik" in nature in Tiruvilaiyaadal... I am not sure what excatly you mean In my understanding ,Unlike Lord krishna (who is passive) ,LordSiva is known for energetic and agression. (Correct me if I am wrong) Moreover ,Lord siva comes as Viragu vetti and Meenavan .

  
  
  Lord Shiva or Rudra is TAMASIC.....but since he is the Destroyer of the WORLD, that is why you say he is known for energetic and aggression. Yes, indeed he came as Viragu Vetti and Meenavan and he portrayed it very well. Also he portrayed the other roles with ease and the aggresiveness of Lord Siva role was done superbly.
  
  

• From: groucho070 on Tue May 22 6:45:00 2007.

  [Full View]

  As per my PM to Joe, he has said all I wanted to say and more about this movie.
  
  But here is what I feel about this movie. This movie, while is about NT's performance, also shows NT's generosity in allowing other talents to flourish.
  
  Talk about Nagesh, two movies flash before us: One is Kathalikka Neeramillai and another is Thiruvilayadal.
  
  Dharumi's scene with NT, I mean, lord Siva is brilliant showcase of acting and reacting. They play off each other beautifully, and Nagesh really goes over-the-top, in a delightful way. Even NT, it seems, joked that he 'swalllowed' NT in that scene.
  
  Then, as Joe and other's put it, check out Savithiri's performance. Nobody is chalking out anybody, everyone gives their best - and the result is the classic.
  
  Also, can anyone forget Palliah. Just looking at the characters arrogance, you feel like wanting to go over and knock his head. Such conviction in his role.
  
  Let us also not forget the forgotten movie star T.R. Mahalinggam, who, while completely lost in these flood of majestic talents. just blew our minds away with his powerful Isai Tamizh Nee Seitha song.
  
  Kamal used to tease about the competition scene whereby Lord Siva, backed by TMS voice, defeats Pallaiyah, backed by Balamuralikrishna's voice. "Just because it's Sivaperuman, it doesn't mean that you can beat Balamuralikrishna's singing!," he'd mockingly argue.
  
  Such was the power of Oru Naal Pothuma song.
  
  You can sit all night long and talk about this movie. This gem of a classic that APN put together. He played Nakkeeran in this movie. and we all know his immortal line, "Nettrikann tirappinum kutram, kutramee".
  
  What a movie! These are the movies that make me proud to be one of the pazhaya kalattu manusan (title that even my mother referred to me).
  
  

• From: umaramesh on Tue May 22 7:36:03 2007.

  [Full View]

  Kamal used to tease about the competition scene whereby Lord Siva, backed by TMS voice, defeats Pallaiyah, backed by Balamuralikrishna's voice. "Just because it's Sivaperuman, it doesn't mean that you can beat Balamuralikrishna's singing!," he'd mockingly argue.
  
  Same Balamurali krishna sang for MGR(I think NAVARATHINAM).
  Theatre la yarrum illa
  
  He may be big shot in carnatic side but he cannot beat TMS as far as cine music is concerned.
  
  groucho070: Thanks for not mentioning KVM name in your article, otherwise very good one.
  
  regards
  ramesh
  
  

• From: joe on Tue May 22 9:10:40 2007.

  [Full View]

  சிவன்: இப்ப புலவன் கொண்டு வந்த பாட்டிற்கு இச்சபையில் குற்றம் கூறியவன் எவன்?
  
  மன்னன்: அவன் இவனென்ற ஏக வசனம் வேண்டாம். அவையடக்கத்துடன் கேட்டால் அதற்கு தக்க பதில் கூறுவார்கள்.
  
  சிவன்: அப்படியானால் மன்னரைவிட மற்றவருக்கு இங்கு அதிகாரமோ?
  
  மன்னன்: இது அரச சபை அன்று. தமிழ் திருச்சபை. இங்கே சகலருக்கும் சம உரிமை உண்டு.
  
  சிவன்: அதனால்தான் தருமி கொண்டு வந்த பாட்டில் தவறு கண்டீர்களோ?
  
  நக்கீரன்: ஆம். பழுதுள்ள பாட்டாய் இருந்ததால் பரிசுக்கு அருகதை இல்லையென்று தடுத்துக் கூறியவன் நான்தான்!
  
  சிவன்: யார் இந்தக் கிழவன்?
  
  செண்: முத்தமிழ்ச் சங்கத்தின் தலைமைப் புலவர் நக்கீரர்.
  
  சிவன்: ஆ கீரன்! தமிழ்ச் சங்கத்தின் தலைவன் என்ற ஆணவத்திலேதான் பாட்டிலே குறை கண்டீரோ? என்ன குற்றம் கண்டீர்?
  
  நக்கீரன்: முதற்கண் பாட்டை இயற்றியது யார்? அதற்கு பதில் தேவை.
  
  சிவன்: யாம்! யாம்! இயற்றினோம்!
  
  நக்கீரன்: எழுதிய நீர் வராமல் அதை இன்னொருவரிடம் கொடுத்து அனுப்பியதற்கு காரணம்?
  
  சிவன்: அது நடந்து முடிந்த கதை. தொடங்கிய பிரச்சினைக்கு வாரும்!
  
  நக்கீரன்: புலவருக்கு முதலில் பொய்யுரை தேவை இல்லை. அதைத்தாம் புரிந்து கொள்ள வேண்டும்.
  
  சிவன்: புரிந்தது, புரியாதது, தெரிந்தது, தெரியாதது, பிறந்தது, பிறவாதது அனைத்தும் அறிவோம். அதுபற்றி உமது அறிவுரை தேவை இல்லை. எல்லாம் எமக்கு தெரியும்.
  
  நக்கீரன்: எல்லாம் தெரிந்துவிட்டால் எழுதும் பாட்டிலே பிழை இருக்காதென்று அர்த்தமா? அது பற்றி யாம் குற்றம் கூறக் கூடாதா?
  
  சிவன்: கீரன்... என் பாட்டில் குற்றம் கூறுகிறாராம்! கூறும். கூறிப்பாரும்.
  
  மன்னன்: புலவர்களே! சாந்தமாக உரையாடுங்கள். புலமைக்கு சர்ச்சை தேவைதான். ஆனால் அது சண்டையாக மாறிவிடக் கூடாது.
  
  சிவன்: சண்டையும், சச்சரவும் புலவர்களின் பரம்பரைச் சொத்து. அதை மாற்ற யாராலும் இயலாது. சற்று பொறுத்திருந்து பாரும்! நக்கீரரே எமது பாட்டில் எங்கு குற்றம் கண்டீர்? சொற்சுவையிலா? அல்லது பொருட்சுவையிலா?
  
  நக்கீரன்: சொல்லில் குற்றமில்லை. இருந்தாலும் அது மன்னிக்கப்படலாம். பொருளில்தான் குற்றமிருக்கிறது.
  
  
  
  

• From: Raghu on Tue May 22 9:53:28 2007.

  [Full View]

  umaramesh wrote:

  Kamal used to tease about the competition scene whereby Lord Siva, backed by TMS voice, defeats Pallaiyah, backed by Balamuralikrishna's voice. "Just because it's Sivaperuman, it doesn't mean that you can beat Balamuralikrishna's singing!," he'd mockingly argue. Same Balamurali krishna sang for MGR(I think NAVARATHINAM). Theatre la yarrum illa He may be big shot in carnatic side but he cannot beat TMS as far as cine music is concerned. groucho070: Thanks for not mentioning KVM name in your article, otherwise very good one. regards ramesh

  
  
  
  There is No need to degrade DR.BMK,he had aBETTER voice than TMS, who sings through his nose rather than throat,
  
  DR.SPB can beat TMS any day in versatility and voice, no doubt!, besides TMS's head is the HEAVIEST amongst singers for NO REASON!
  
  

• From: Nakeeran on Tue May 22 10:27:56 2007.

  [Full View]

  Raghu sir
  
  Is it wrong if someone sings through throat !?
  
  I presume you are a musical expert . Thats why U are coming up with such an expert comment . Pl enlighten us with technical explanation on this.
  
  And U have rating Dr. BMK better . can you list some 20 songs of BMK in cinema . Not carnatic songs.
  
  Besides, how do you rate Dr. SPB better than TMS ? What yardstick you are applying for this ? ( I am not supporting both but curious to know from you )
  
  

• From: ajithfederer on Tue May 22 10:40:52 2007.

  [Full View]

  Great work joe
  Please finish the entire dialogue
  

  joe wrote:

  சிவன்: இப்ப புலவன் கொண்டு வந்த பாட்டிற்கு இச்சபையில் குற்றம் கூறியவன் எவன்? மன்னன்: அவன் இவனென்ற ஏக வசனம் வேண்டாம். அவையடக்கத்துடன் கேட்டால் அதற்கு தக்க பதில் கூறுவார்கள். சிவன்: அப்படியானால் மன்னரைவிட மற்றவருக்கு இங்கு அதிகாரமோ? மன்னன்: இது அரச சபை அன்று. தமிழ் திருச்சபை. இங்கே சகலருக்கும் சம உரிமை உண்டு. சிவன்: அதனால்தான் தருமி கொண்டு வந்த பாட்டில் தவறு கண்டீர்களோ? நக்கீரன்: ஆம். பழுதுள்ள பாட்டாய் இருந்ததால் பரிசுக்கு அருகதை இல்லையென்று தடுத்துக் கூறியவன் நான்தான்! சிவன்: யார் இந்தக் கிழவன்? செண்: முத்தமிழ்ச் சங்கத்தின் தலைமைப் புலவர் நக்கீரர். சிவன்: ஆ கீரன்! தமிழ்ச் சங்கத்தின் தலைவன் என்ற ஆணவத்திலேதான் பாட்டிலே குறை கண்டீரோ? என்ன குற்றம் கண்டீர்? நக்கீரன்: முதற்கண் பாட்டை இயற்றியது யார்? அதற்கு பதில் தேவை. சிவன்: யாம்! யாம்! இயற்றினோம்! நக்கீரன்: எழுதிய நீர் வராமல் அதை இன்னொருவரிடம் கொடுத்து அனுப்பியதற்கு காரணம்? சிவன்: அது நடந்து முடிந்த கதை. தொடங்கிய பிரச்சினைக்கு வாரும்! நக்கீரன்: புலவருக்கு முதலில் பொய்யுரை தேவை இல்லை. அதைத்தாம் புரிந்து கொள்ள வேண்டும். சிவன்: புரிந்தது, புரியாதது, தெரிந்தது, தெரியாதது, பிறந்தது, பிறவாதது அனைத்தும் அறிவோம். அதுபற்றி உமது அறிவுரை தேவை இல்லை. எல்லாம் எமக்கு தெரியும். நக்கீரன்: எல்லாம் தெரிந்துவிட்டால் எழுதும் பாட்டிலே பிழை இருக்காதென்று அர்த்தமா? அது பற்றி யாம் குற்றம் கூறக் கூடாதா? சிவன்: கீரன்... என் பாட்டில் குற்றம் கூறுகிறாராம்! கூறும். கூறிப்பாரும். மன்னன்: புலவர்களே! சாந்தமாக உரையாடுங்கள். புலமைக்கு சர்ச்சை தேவைதான். ஆனால் அது சண்டையாக மாறிவிடக் கூடாது. சிவன்: சண்டையும், சச்சரவும் புலவர்களின் பரம்பரைச் சொத்து. அதை மாற்ற யாராலும் இயலாது. சற்று பொறுத்திருந்து பாரும்! நக்கீரரே எமது பாட்டில் எங்கு குற்றம் கண்டீர்? சொற்சுவையிலா? அல்லது பொருட்சுவையிலா? நக்கீரன்: சொல்லில் குற்றமில்லை. இருந்தாலும் அது மன்னிக்கப்படலாம். பொருளில்தான் குற்றமிருக்கிறது.

  
  

• From: joe on Tue May 22 10:45:54 2007.

  [Full View]

  This monumental epic adventure detailing the various incarnations of lord Shiva, was a phenomenal musical and a showcase of rare acting talent. Every single dialogue in this movie is a bible to any Tamil movie lover. Though this film contained some immortal scenes like the impersonation by the poet Darumi(a lifetime performance by nagesh), the musical duel between panapathrar(TR Mahalingam) and Hemanadha Bagavadhar(Baliah), the wordily duel between lord Shiva and the court poet Nakeeran go high on rating. The poet finds fault with poetry written by the lord himself. In response, lord Shiva opens his 3rd eye indication who he is. But Nakeeran, in his love for the language, says that despite showing the 3rd eye, a fault remains a fault. Yet another unmatched performance by Late Sivaji
  
  http://www.fusionrental.com/view_media_details.php?type=movie&mediaId=1149&languageId=7
  
  

• From: Raghu on Tue May 22 10:47:29 2007.

  [Full View]

  Nakeeran wrote:

  Raghu sir Is it wrong if someone sings through throat !? I presume you are a musical expert . Thats why U are coming up with such an expert comment . Pl enlighten us with technical explanation on this. And U have rating Dr. BMK better . can you list some 20 songs of BMK in cinema . Not carnatic songs. Besides, how do you rate Dr. SPB better than TMS ? What yardstick you are applying for this ? ( I am not supporting both but curious to know from you )

  
  
  Nakeeran sir,
  
  I am singer as well, but not professionaly trained like Dr.KJY, Dr.BMK, Dr.PBS, Dr.SS.Givendarajan, TMS, ..etc etc.. but more like Dr.SPB sir
  
  IMHO, Dr.SPB stands above all, including the GREATM.rafi, Kishore Kumar and Ghantasala sir, simply based on DEEP rich voice and the VERSTAILE factor.
  
  If you dont believe the fact i am singer, pls pm me, i will send you some songs via email.
  
  Thanks
  
  

• From: joe on Tue May 22 10:49:10 2007.

  [Full View]

  Digital ThiruviLayadal
  
  http://blog.360.yahoo.com/blog-30FexsUyc68Y3Ztx3WgzbNAEmQ--?cq=1&p=78
  
  Just for fun
  
  

• From: shobana_in on Tue May 22 10:49:13 2007.

  [Full View]

  raghu is right
  
  spb voice is both romantic and manly
  
  

• From: Murali Srinivas on Tue May 22 10:49:22 2007.

  [Full View]

  joe wrote:

  Friends, Before production of the movie 'ThiruviLayadal' ,NT was told ,according to Purana ,Siva peruman kannai imaikka maattar ..and throughout the movie NT made sure he never close his eyes even for a fraction of second unless he sleeps ..if you guys watch this movie again ,you can notice this ..This speaks volume of NT's dedication and professionalism

  
  
  Dear Joe,
  
  Just as Groucho said you have single handedly written all that was there to be told about this great epic. Regarding the eyelids, I have strained myself watching especially the " Siva Thandavam" scene and everytime I would end up battering my eyelids while the Emperor of Acting would have simply kept his eyes open throughout. Thanks for bringing out this nuance which many people are not aware of.
  
  Regards
  
  

• From: Nakeeran on Tue May 22 10:50:18 2007.

  [Full View]

  Raghu sir
  
  No need to send PM on this as you have already opened a pandora's box by calling TMS as someone who sings through the nose .
  
  Take it that he used to sing through the nose. Is it a great fundamental error according to nuances of music if someone sings through the nose ?
  
  I believe that you are a singer. No issues.
  
  

• From: Nakeeran on Tue May 22 10:53:35 2007.

  [Full View]

  Murali Srinivas wrote:

  joe wrote: Friends, Before production of the movie 'ThiruviLayadal' ,NT was told ,according to Purana ,Siva peruman kannai imaikka maattar ..and throughout the movie NT made sure he never close his eyes even for a fraction of second unless he sleeps ..if you guys watch this movie again ,you can notice this ..This speaks volume of NT's dedication and professionalism Dear Joe, Just as Groucho said you have single handedly written all that was there to be told about this great epic. Regarding the eyelids, I have strained myself watching especially the " Siva Thandavam" scene and everytime I would end up battering my eyelids while the Emperor of Acting would have simply kept his eyes open throughout. Thanks for bringing out this nuance which many people are not aware of. Regards

  
  
  Murali Sar
  
  In a lighter vein , just look at the song Paatum naane again . Especially after he stops singing midway. And he in his own style oru kan adipaaru ... and then Naan asaindhaal asayum akilamellame !
  
  

• From: Sanjeevi on Tue May 22 10:55:22 2007.

  [Full View]

  I don't know how many times i've heard the dialogs of this movie right from my birth
  
  

• From: joe on Tue May 22 10:56:42 2007.

  [Full View]

  Guys,
  Request you to back to discussion on ThiruViLayadal
  
  

• From: joe on Tue May 22 11:02:27 2007.

  [Full View]

  Murali Sir,
  Thanks for your visit here and nice words
  
  

• From: Raghu on Tue May 22 11:02:50 2007.

  [Full View]

  joe wrote:

  சிவன்: இப்ப புலவன் கொண்டு வந்த பாட்டிற்கு இச்சபையில் குற்றம் கூறியவன் எவன்? மன்னன்: அவன் இவனென்ற ஏக வசனம் வேண்டாம். அவையடக்கத்துடன் கேட்டால் அதற்கு தக்க பதில் கூறுவார்கள். சிவன்: அப்படியானால் மன்னரைவிட மற்றவருக்கு இங்கு அதிகாரமோ? மன்னன்: இது அரச சபை அன்று. தமிழ் திருச்சபை. இங்கே சகலருக்கும் சம உரிமை உண்டு. சிவன்: அதனால்தான் தருமி கொண்டு வந்த பாட்டில் தவறு கண்டீர்களோ? நக்கீரன்: ஆம். பழுதுள்ள பாட்டாய் இருந்ததால் பரிசுக்கு அருகதை இல்லையென்று தடுத்துக் கூறியவன் நான்தான்! சிவன்: யார் இந்தக் கிழவன்? செண்: முத்தமிழ்ச் சங்கத்தின் தலைமைப் புலவர் நக்கீரர். சிவன்: ஆ கீரன்! தமிழ்ச் சங்கத்தின் தலைவன் என்ற ஆணவத்திலேதான் பாட்டிலே குறை கண்டீரோ? என்ன குற்றம் கண்டீர்? நக்கீரன்: முதற்கண் பாட்டை இயற்றியது யார்? அதற்கு பதில் தேவை. சிவன்: யாம்! யாம்! இயற்றினோம்! நக்கீரன்: எழுதிய நீர் வராமல் அதை இன்னொருவரிடம் கொடுத்து அனுப்பியதற்கு காரணம்? சிவன்: அது நடந்து முடிந்த கதை. தொடங்கிய பிரச்சினைக்கு வாரும்! நக்கீரன்: புலவருக்கு முதலில் பொய்யுரை தேவை இல்லை. அதைத்தாம் புரிந்து கொள்ள வேண்டும். சிவன்: புரிந்தது, புரியாதது, தெரிந்தது, தெரியாதது, பிறந்தது, பிறவாதது அனைத்தும் அறிவோம். அதுபற்றி உமது அறிவுரை தேவை இல்லை. எல்லாம் எமக்கு தெரியும். நக்கீரன்: எல்லாம் தெரிந்துவிட்டால் எழுதும் பாட்டிலே பிழை இருக்காதென்று அர்த்தமா? அது பற்றி யாம் குற்றம் கூறக் கூடாதா? சிவன்: கீரன்... என் பாட்டில் குற்றம் கூறுகிறாராம்! கூறும். கூறிப்பாரும். மன்னன்: புலவர்களே! சாந்தமாக உரையாடுங்கள். புலமைக்கு சர்ச்சை தேவைதான். ஆனால் அது சண்டையாக மாறிவிடக் கூடாது. சிவன்: சண்டையும், சச்சரவும் புலவர்களின் பரம்பரைச் சொத்து. அதை மாற்ற யாராலும் இயலாது. சற்று பொறுத்திருந்து பாரும்! நக்கீரரே எமது பாட்டில் எங்கு குற்றம் கண்டீர்? சொற்சுவையிலா? அல்லது பொருட்சுவையிலா? நக்கீரன்: சொல்லில் குற்றமில்லை. இருந்தாலும் அது மன்னிக்கப்படலாம். பொருளில்தான் குற்றமிருக்கிறது.

  
  
  execllent work Joe anNe,
  
  I love one bit so much. which is as follows
  
  
  Shivaji :Nakeera Nandra ennai paar, naan ezhuthiya paatu Kotramma
  
  
  Nakeeran: Netrikan thirapinum kutram kutrame
  
  excellent excellent
  
  

• From: NOV on Tue May 22 20:28:55 2007.

  [Full View]

  Days of masculine voice ended with TMS. Now feminine voices rule, unfortunately beginning with SP Bala himself.
  of course there have been singers like Malaysia Vasudevan and Shankar Mahadevan, but they do not sing as much as the regular feminine voiced singers.
  
  

• From: groucho070 on Tue May 22 22:38:24 2007.

  [Full View]

  NOV wrote:

  Days of masculine voice ended with TMS. Now feminine voices rule, unfortunately beginning with SP Bala himself. of course there have been singers like Malaysia Vasudevan and Shankar Mahadevan, but they do not sing as much as the regular feminine voiced singers.

  
  
  You gotta be kidding me, NOV. SPB's earlier effort is more like that of PBS and ALR. Now, are their voice feminine? What if we take one step back and look at AMR.
  
  SPB can go any direction he wants. Check out the songs he sang for NT. Pottu Vaitha Mugamoo. You call that feminine? Or Ellorum Paadunggal in Naan Vazhavaippen.
  
  Or even the songs he sang for Rajini and Kamal.
  
  Oh well. I adore SPB. I think he is the greatest as of now. Period. So, I am biased. So, forgive me NOV, if I got emotional.
  
  
  Umaramesh,
  
  Thanks for mentioning that I did not mention KVM. I shall rectify that immediately .
  
  Here I go: KVM.
  
  

• From: Madavan on Tue May 22 22:41:38 2007.

  [Full View]

  SPB is the best singer ever to walk tamil cinema. And he is the most versatile.
  
  Anyway I always thought TMS's voice was too femine and he sang through his nose and ears
  
  

• From: Shakthiprabha on Tue May 22 23:01:32 2007.

  [Full View]

  எங்கே
  
  எங�கே
  நக�கீரன�: எங�கே நீர� கொண�ட� வந�த தமிழ�ப� பாட�டைக� கூற�ம�.
  
  சிவன�: "கொங�க�தேர� வாழ�க�கை அஞ�சிறைத� த�ம�பி
  காமம� செப�பாத� கண�டத� மொழிமோ
  பயிலியத� கழிய நட�பின�
  மயிலியல� சறியியற�ற� அறிவை கூந�தலின�
  அறியவ�ம� உளவோ நீ அறிய�ம� பூவே"
  
  - இத� தான� எமத� செய�ய�ள�
  
  நக�கீரன�: இதன� உட�கர�த�த�
  
  சிவன�: தலைவன�, தலைவியின� காதலில� மெய� மறந�த�,
  "� த�ம�பி இனத�தை சேர�ந�த உயர�ந�த ஜாதி வண�டே
  நீ கண�ட மலர�களில� இம�மங�கையின� கூந�தலைப� போல�
  மணம�ள�ள மலர�ம� உண�டோ" என�ற� கேட�பதைப� போல� பாடியிர�க�கிறேன�.
  
  நக�கீரன�: இதன� மூலம� நீங�கள� தெரிவிக�க�ம� கர�த�த�
  
  சிவன�: ஹ .. ஹ... ப�ரியவில�லை!! இயற�கையிலேயே பெண�ணின� கூந�தல�க�க� மணம� உண�ட� என�பத� தான� எமத� தீர�ப�ப�
  
  நக�கீரன�: ஒர�க�கால�ம� இர�க�க ம�டியாத�, வாசனாதி திரவியங�களை பூசிக�கொள�வதினால�ம�, தொடர�ந�த� மலர�களை சூடிக�கொள�வதினால�ம� தான� ஒர� பெண�ணின� கூந�தல�க�க� மணம� இர�க�க ம�டிய�மே தவிர, இயற�கையிலேயே வெற�ங�கூந�தல�க�க� ஒர� கால�ம� மணம� இர�க�க ம�டியாத�.
  
  சிவன�: தேவலோகப� பெண�கள�க�க�?
  
  நக�கீரன�: ஈரேழ� பதினான�க� லோகப� பெண�கள�க�க�ம� அதே கதி தான�.
  
  சிவன�: உமத� நாக�கில� இர�ந�த� உலவ�கிறாளே கலைமகள� அவள�க�க�ம� அதே அப�படித�தானோ!
  
  நக�கீரன�: கலைமகள� என�ன, நான� அன�றாட�ம� வழிபட�ம� ஈசன�க�க� இடப�பக�கம� அம�ர�ந�திர�க�கிறாளே அன�னை மலைமகள�, உமையவள� அவள�க�க�ம� அதே விதிப�படித�தான�.
  
  சிவன�: உண�மையாக
  
  நக�கீரன�: உண�மையாக
  
  சிவன�: நிச�சயமாக
  
  நக�கீரன�: நிச�சயமாக
  
  சிவன�: உமத� தமிழ� மீத� ஆணையாக
  
  நக�கீரன�: எமத� தமிழ�ப� ப�லமை மீத� ஆணையாக.
  
  சிவன�: நக�கீரா... நன�றாக என�னைப� பார�! நான� எழ�திய தமிழ�ப� பாட�ட� க�ற�றமா
  
  நக�கீரன�: (மனதில�:... ஆண�டவா! இறைவா! ) ப�லவரே... நீரே ம�க�கண� ம�தல�வன�ம� ஆக�க. உமத� நெற�றிக ஒர� கண�ணை திறந�த� காட�டியபோத�ம�, உமத� நெற�றியெலாம� கண�ணாக�கி ச�ட�ட போத�ம� க�ற�றம� க�ற�ற�மே.
  
  நெற�றிக�கண� திறப�பின�ம� க�ற�றம� க�ற�றமே!
  
  சிவன�: சங�கதனை கீர� கீர� என�ற� அற�க�க�ம� நக�கீரனோ எம� கவியை ஆராய�ந�த� சொல�லத� தக�கவன� (sigh...shivaji's voice worth a million here)
  
  நக�கீரன�: சங�கற�ப�பதெங�கள� க�லம�... சங�கரனார�கேத� க�லம�?!
  சங�கை அறிந�த�ண�ட� வாழ�வோம�...ஹரனே உம�மைப� போல� இரந�த�ண�ட� வாழ�வதில�லை.
  
  சிவன�: நக�கீரா....
  
  (ஆண�டவா... இறைவா...
  ஆதிய�ம� நீயே
  அந�தம�ம� நீயே
  ஊழிய�ம� நீயே....)
  
  

• From: Shakthiprabha on Tue May 22 23:10:01 2007.

  [Full View]

  what can I say about the movie!!!
  
  Its NO.1 MOVIE in my fav all time list, which stays CLOSE to my heart.
  
  I breathed Shivaji... through out. I became shivaji fan, BECAUSE of this movie.
  
  When I was a kid, such was t he impact , that, I was visualising lord shiva in the form of shivaji
  
  Songs... STEAL my h eart.
  
  "பார�த�தா பச� மரம�
  பட�த�த� விட�டா நெட�மரம�...."
  
  one of the best philosophical song.
  
  "ஒன�றானவன�
  உர�வில� இரண�டானவன�.."
  
  kbs at her best.
  
  Ive never seen a movie more than 3 times (that too veryyyyyyyy rarely if I really like a movie I see it repeatedly)
  
  Ive seen
  
  MMKR 8 times
  aaril irunthu aruvathu varai 5 times
  (record acc to me)
  
  but the amazing record is yet to come...
  
  IVE SEEN THIRUVILAIYAADAL...
  
  25 TIMES till now
  
  I can see 200 TIMES or more too..... and never get tired.
  
  His style, walk, grace.... simply too good.
  
  I can WRITE THE DIALOGUES of this movie byheart.
  
  Such movies talk about HOW MYTHOLOGICAL OR BHAKTHI MOVIES should be made... not like how its made t hese days with graphics and indecent dances and portraying arrogance / evil/ voodo instead of concentrating more on bhakthi.
  
  
  
  

• From: groucho070 on Tue May 22 23:16:57 2007.

  [Full View]

  Shakthiprabha wrote:

  Such movies talk about HOW MYTHOLOGICAL OR BHAKTHI MOVIES should be made... not like how its made t hese days with graphics and indecent dances and portraying arrogance / evil/ voodo instead of concentrating more on bhakthi. [/tscii]

  
  
  I missed this part. I agree with SP here. It's a Bakthi movie with quality content. These days, it's the package, the wrapper that looks glossy. The rest is terrible. Just badly made B-grade monster movies without any grace.
  
  

• From: Shakthiprabha on Tue May 22 23:17:24 2007.

  [Full View]

  Nagesh-stays in our mind
  savithri-did a good job
  muthuraman/devika/manorama/balaiyya/other stars-did th eir job well
  
  SHIVAJI- LIVES in this movie
  
  What more can be said. The song paattum naanE... he would play the role of almost all musicians. If we watch carefully, each one would have unique mannerisms while performing for the song.
  
  Person who says "jathi" would even look out and relax (so naturally) when others are performing.
  
  MINUTE CARE.
  METICULOUS details done with DEDICATION.
  
  The more I talk, I get an urge to watch this movie... again.
  
  

• From: Shakthiprabha on Tue May 22 23:20:31 2007.

  [Full View]

  Songs remind me...
  
  T.R.M wowwwwwwwww... what voice!
  
  "இசைத் தமிழ் நீ செய்த அரும் சாதனை"
  
  The pitch he lifts, is difficult even for best singers to take it up high without faultering.
  
  TMS awesome.
  KBS shines.
  BALAMURALIKRISHNA mesmerises.
  ...
  
  

• From: Shakthiprabha on Tue May 22 23:23:17 2007.

  [Full View]

  Balaiya would have done his ultimate movie when he crosses his leg with utmost pride
  
  "இசை தெய்வம் நானடா"...
  
  the song would end with a sharp abrupt note/beat, with him lifting his head high and mighty towards the king.
  
  One cant help smiling.
  
  ThiruviLaiyaadal.
  
  A FEAST which can SATE all OUR SENSES.
  
  

• From: Badri on Tue May 22 23:25:51 2007.

  [Full View]

  Shakthiprabha wrote:

  Balaiya would have done his ultimate movie when he crosses his leg with utmost pride "இசை தெய்வம் நானடா"... the song would end with a sharp abrupt note/beat, with him lifting his head high and mighty towards the king. One cant help smiling.

  
  
  Yes, and BMK's singing (with an arrogant touch) complements Balaiya's action!!!
  
  

• From: Sanguine Sridhar on Tue May 22 23:34:31 2007.

  [Full View]

  When he starts the song "Paatum Naane...." for the first time, you can see the majestic body language by NT.
  
  "Koothum isayiyum kootrin murayum
  Kaatum ennidam kadhai solla vandhaayo?..!!"
  
  "Naan asaindhal asayum agilamellame
  arivaai manidha un aanavam peridhaa?"
  
  
  
  ...and in that Dharumi-Sivan scene
  
  "Serndhe irrupadhu?"
  
  "Varumayum Pulamayum..." and NT points Nagesh
  
  Naagesh ..." Ahemm...seri seri.."
  
  
  
  

• From: NOV on Tue May 22 23:35:27 2007.

  [Full View]

  groucho070 wrote:

  Oh well. I adore SPB. I think he is the greatest as of now. Period. So, I am biased. So, forgive me NOV, if I got emotional

  But of course Rakesh. Dont I know you?
  
  I agree that AMR, ALR, PBS all had soft voices. But then again, they were never mainstream singers like TMS and SPB.
  After TMS, only SPB ruled TFM and thus my statement of TMS being the last of the masculine voices.
  
  I love SPB as much as you (and maybe even more especially in the humility section) but then we have to call a spade, a spade havent we?
  
  

• From: ajithfederer on Tue May 22 23:43:43 2007.

  [Full View]

  http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=paVn36tNRA4&mode=related&search=
  
  http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vV_I21NjXeU&mode=related&search=
  
  http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_X4zc0BeXno&mode=related&search=
  
  
  
  

• From: kalnayak on Wed May 23 0:14:11 2007.

  [Full View]

  Selva,
  
  'Neenga Yaarunga'nnu kaettathula, apdi agivittathu. No apologies and I feel sorry for misunderstanding your words. The problem was due to my browser.
  
  Regarding Thiruvilaiyaadal - I doubt even Telugu cinema has produced such a great puranic movie. In general I had a feeling that very good puranic movies were made only in Telugu during peak NTR & ANR period. This movie proved Tamil Film Industry is not less in glory of making grand puranic movies. Many have mentioned about various features that make this movie a great. In the nineties also this film was running to packed houses for months in ordinary towns of Tamilnadu. I have watched this movie a large number of times and currently I have a CD of this movie to watch whenever I wish. Its greatness is due to many factors - APN, KVM, BMKrishna, TMS, PSuseela, TRMahalingam, Nagesh, Paliah, Devika, Muthuraman, Savithri etc. and above all NT SivajiGanesan as Lord S(h)iva.
  
  Many of u might be knowing that when Sirkaali Govindarajan was asked to sing the 'Orunaal pothuma' song, he denied stating that he didn't like his song to lose to TMS's 'Paatum Naane' song, but BMKrishna didn't think like that - both the songs are great. I like TRMahalingam's 'Isai Thamizh ...' song very much.
  
  I had a strong feeling that even some more stories of Thiruvilayadarpuranam could have been made as sequels to this film with same set of (main) actors. Current cine industry can just use the name of the film but not dared to do remake this.
  
  

• From: joe on Wed May 23 0:35:13 2007.

  [Full View]

  Nanri Ajithfederer!
  
  

• From: joe on Wed May 23 1:01:22 2007.

  [Full View]

  kalnayak wrote:

  Current cine industry can just use the name of the film but not dared to do remake this.

  
  
  Hmm..People may complain I am going overboard when I say this
  
  I usually think about what if an actor named 'Ganesan' was not born in Tamil Nadu ..I couldn't imagine what if movies like ThiruviLayadal, Kattabomman ,Karnan can't have ganesan .Infact I can't even get a picture of it.
  
  There may be actors good enough in Voice modulation and proficiency in Tamil ,but they lack in look,Gambeeram ,Midukku etc ..Some others may have good look ,gambeeram ,but lack in Tamil pronounciation and modulation.. But How unique we have had an actor with all these qualities to almost maximum ..When I think about it ,I always feel that Ganesan is a gift of GOD for us Tamils (Sorry ! I am emotional).
  
  Ingivanai Yaam peRave enna thavam seithu vittom!
  
  

• From: umaramesh on Wed May 23 3:54:28 2007.

  [Full View]

  Thanks for mentioning that I did not mention KVM. I shall rectify that immediately .
  
  Here I go: KVM.
  
  romba /romba thanks.
  
  

• From: Raghu on Wed May 23 5:55:19 2007.

  [Full View]

  Mookala padirathu Masculine -na
  
  TMS, MV, and MOST of the hindi singers these days all should be masculine singers
  
  Masculine defines - Bass, bass means how much bass or deepness you have at note 1, ie 'Muthalank kattai' there are 8 kattai's in a Human vocal range, while male singers bass range from 1-4, females singers range from 4-8.
  
  If u want to know about DEEP voices, pls listen to Shankaraparanam songs, listen to 'Thulli thulli' song from Sirpikuzh Muthu song!
  
  where Dr.SPB would sing 'aaa' from 4th kattai to 1st kattai. that DEEPNESS can not be beaten by any other singers, only close contender to Dr.SPB in this aspect is Dr.BMK and Kishore Kumar.
  
  can some one tell me a song which TMS sang in a very deep voice?
  
  

• From: Shakthiprabha on Wed May 23 6:30:50 2007.

  [Full View]

  joe wrote:

  I usually think about what if an actor named 'Ganesan' was not born in Tamil Nadu ..I couldn't imagine what if movies like ThiruviLayadal, Kattabomman ,Karnan can't have ganesan .Infact I can't even get a picture of it. There may be actors good enough in Voice modulation and proficiency in Tamil ,but they lack in look,Gambeeram ,Midukku etc ..Some others may have good look ,gambeeram ,but lack in Tamil pronounciation and modulation.. But How unique we have had an actor with all these qualities to almost maximum ..When I think about it ,I always feel that Ganesan is a gift of GOD for us Tamils (Sorry ! I am emotional). Ingivanai Yaam peRave enna thavam seithu vittom!

  
  
  
  
  

• From: Roshan on Wed May 23 6:32:56 2007.

  [Full View]

  Can any one post the entire dialogues of Sivaji - Nagesh sequence (the questions and answers ) ?
  
  >> Dig <<
  
  SPB is the BEST - far ahead of any singer in the Indian film history. Atha challenge paNNuRathaivida periya comedy ethuvum illai
  
  >> end dig <<<
  
  

• From: Shakthiprabha on Wed May 23 8:52:49 2007.

  [Full View]

  Roshan,
  
  Here is the question ans sequence, as much as I can recollect...
  
  
  சிவன்:
  உனக்கு பரிசு வேண்டுமா இல்லையா...
  
  தருமி : வேணுமே....
  
  உங்களுக்கு வேண்டாமா...
  
  தருமி : சத்தியமா....
  
  
  
  தருமி :நிச்சயமா...
  
  
  
  தருமி : உண்மையாகவா...
  
  ...
  
  நாடகத்தையே நடத்துபவன் நடிக்க முடியுமாப்பா..
  
  தருமி : என்னது என்னது...
  
  அந்த பரிசின் மீது பற்றில்லை நீ வாங்கிக்கொள் என்றேன்...
  
  தருமி : ஹைய்யோ இப்பொ புரியுது... புதுசா பாட்டெழுதி பழகற..அதை நேரா எடுத்துட்டு போன எப்டி உதைபாங்களோ என்ன பண்ணுவாங்களோன்னு பயபடறீங்க...
  
  ஹஹ... என் திறமை மீது நம்பிக்கை இல்லையேல் என்னை பரிட்சித்துப் பாரேன்...உனக்குத் திறமை இருந்தால்..
  
  தருமி : என்கிட்ட...என்கிட்ட மோதப்பாக்கறயா... தொபார்.. பார்வைக்கு சுமாரா இருப்பேன்... ஆனால் என் புலமையைப் பத்தி உனக்கு தெரியாது...
  
  ஹ்ம்ம்... கேள்விகளை நீ கேட்கிறாயா அல்லது நான் கேட்கட்டுமா
  
  தருமி : வேண்டாம்... வேண்டாம். எனக்கு எனக்கு கேட்க மட்டும் தான் தெரியும்.
  
  கேளும்.
  
  தருமி : சற்று பொறும்.
  
  கேளும்
  
  தருமி : பிரிக்க முடியாதது என்னவோ
  
  தமிழும் சுவையும்
  
  தருமி : பிரிய கூடாதது
  
  எதுகையும் மோனையும்
  
  தருமி : சேர்ந்தே இருப்பது
  
  வறுமையும் புலமையும்
  
  தருமி : சேராதிருப்பது
  
  அறிவும் பணமும்
  
  தருமி : சொல்லக்கூடாதது
  
  பெண்ணிடம் ரகசியம்.
  
  தருமி : சொல்லக்க்கூடியது
  
  உண்மையின் தத்துவம்
  
  தருமி : பார்க்கக்கூடாதது
  
  பசியும் பஞ்சமும்
  
  தருமி : பார்த்து ரசிப்பது
  
  கலையும் அழகும்
  
  தருமி : கலையிற் சிறந்தது
  
  இயல் இசை நாடகம்
  
  தருமி : நாடகம் என்பது
  
  நடிப்பும் பாட்டும்
  
  தருமி : பாட்டுக்கு
  
  நாரதன்
  
  தருமி : வீணைக்கு
  
  வாணி
  
  தருமி : அழகுக்கு
  
  முருகன்
  
  
  தருமி : சொல்லுக்கு
  
  அகத்தியன்
  
  தருமி : வில்லுக்கு
  
  விஜயன்
  
  தருமி : ஆசைக்கு
  
  நீ
  
  தருமி : அறிவுக்கு
  
  நான்
  
  ஐய்யா ஆளை விடு எனக்கு தெரிஞ்சது அவ்வளவு தான்!
  
  
  
  

• From: Roshan on Wed May 23 8:56:49 2007.

  [Full View]

  Great SP
  
  Thanks so much
  
  

• From: Shakthiprabha on Wed May 23 9:03:57 2007.

  [Full View]

  
  
  PLEASURE IS MINE
  
  

• From: Nakeeran on Wed May 23 9:09:25 2007.

  [Full View]

  SP Akka ! Brilliant memory ! Eppadi full dialogues kodukureenga fm memory.
  
  Neenga great dhaankaa . Engeyou irukka vendiyavanga. Che che.
  
  

• From: joe on Wed May 23 9:44:37 2007.

  [Full View]

  SP
  
  

• From: Raghu on Wed May 23 9:56:43 2007.

  [Full View]

  Roshan wrote:

  Can any one post the entire dialogues of Sivaji - Nagesh sequence (the questions and answers ) ? >> Dig << SPB is the BEST - far ahead of any singer in the Indian film history. Atha challenge paNNuRathaivida periya comedy ethuvum illai >> end dig <<<

  
  
  Indeed, Dr.SPB rulzzz all the way.........
  
  

• From: Murali Srinivas on Wed May 23 9:58:14 2007.

  [Full View]

  Almost all the songs of this movie got mentioned except " Podhigai Malai Uchiyile Purapadaum Thendral " a superb melody and happens to be a favourite of mine (in spite of NT not being a part of this song) and especially the saranam
  
  Vaan Parakkum Kodiyinile;
  
  Meen Parakkum Maduraiyile
  
  a lovely number by PBS and SJ (Credit to Kannadasan & KVM also)
  
  Regards
  
  PS: On the sidelines Thenisai Thendral Deva had taken this song, mixed it with Mullai Malar mele from UP and "created" Thennai Mara Thoppukulle Kuyile Kuyile for a Sathyaraj - Banupriya movie.
  
  

• From: NOV on Wed May 23 9:59:22 2007.

  [Full View]

  Raghu, thulli thulli is the worst example of good singing. SPB practically struggles to sing in low pitch.
  Listen to the song again, if you want.
  
  Anyway, I dont wish to continue arguing. I maintain my stand and the rest is up to you.
  
  

• From: Shakthiprabha on Wed May 23 10:00:26 2007.

  [Full View]

  af... requested continuation of this.
  
  Morning I posted the same, guess, there was font problem...
  
  so here is the continuation of MY MOST FAVOURITE SCENE IN TAMIZH CINEMA....
  
  

  joe wrote:

  சிவன்: இப்ப புலவன் கொண்டு வந்த பாட்டிற்கு இச்சபையில் குற்றம் கூறியவன் எவன்? மன்னன்: அவன் இவனென்ற ஏக வசனம் வேண்டாம். அவையடக்கத்துடன் கேட்டால் அதற்கு தக்க பதில் கூறுவார்கள். சிவன்: அப்படியானால் மன்னரைவிட மற்றவருக்கு இங்கு அதிகாரமோ? மன்னன்: இது அரச சபை அன்று. தமிழ் திருச்சபை. இங்கே சகலருக்கும் சம உரிமை உண்டு. சிவன்: அதனால்தான் தருமி கொண்டு வந்த பாட்டில் தவறு கண்டீர்களோ? நக்கீரன்: ஆம். பழுதுள்ள பாட்டாய் இருந்ததால் பரிசுக்கு அருகதை இல்லையென்று தடுத்துக் கூறியவன் நான்தான்! சிவன்: யார் இந்தக் கிழவன்? செண்: முத்தமிழ்ச் சங்கத்தின் தலைமைப் புலவர் நக்கீரர். சிவன்: ஆ கீரன்! தமிழ்ச் சங்கத்தின் தலைவன் என்ற ஆணவத்திலேதான் பாட்டிலே குறை கண்டீரோ? என்ன குற்றம் கண்டீர்? நக்கீரன்: முதற்கண் பாட்டை இயற்றியது யார்? அதற்கு பதில் தேவை. சிவன்: யாம்! யாம்! இயற்றினோம்! நக்கீரன்: எழுதிய நீர் வராமல் அதை இன்னொருவரிடம் கொடுத்து அனுப்பியதற்கு காரணம்? சிவன்: அது நடந்து முடிந்த கதை. தொடங்கிய பிரச்சினைக்கு வாரும்! நக்கீரன்: புலவருக்கு முதலில் பொய்யுரை தேவை இல்லை. அதைத்தாம் புரிந்து கொள்ள வேண்டும். சிவன்: புரிந்தது, புரியாதது, தெரிந்தது, தெரியாதது, பிறந்தது, பிறவாதது அனைத்தும் அறிவோம். அதுபற்றி உமது அறிவுரை தேவை இல்லை. எல்லாம் எமக்கு தெரியும். நக்கீரன்: எல்லாம் தெரிந்துவிட்டால் எழுதும் பாட்டிலே பிழை இருக்காதென்று அர்த்தமா? அது பற்றி யாம் குற்றம் கூறக் கூடாதா? சிவன்: கீரன்... என் பாட்டில் குற்றம் கூறுகிறாராம்! கூறும். கூறிப்பாரும். மன்னன்: புலவர்களே! சாந்தமாக உரையாடுங்கள். புலமைக்கு சர்ச்சை தேவைதான். ஆனால் அது சண்டையாக மாறிவிடக் கூடாது. சிவன்: சண்டையும், சச்சரவும் புலவர்களின் பரம்பரைச் சொத்து. அதை மாற்ற யாராலும் இயலாது. சற்று பொறுத்திருந்து பாரும்! நக்கீரரே எமது பாட்டில் எங்கு குற்றம் கண்டீர்? சொற்சுவையிலா? அல்லது பொருட்சுவையிலா? நக்கீரன்: சொல்லில் குற்றமில்லை. இருந்தாலும் அது மன்னிக்கப்படலாம். பொருளில்தான் குற்றமிருக்கிறது.

  
  
  நக்கீரன்: எங்கே நீர் கொண்டு வந்த தமிழ்ப் பாட்டைக் கூறும்.
  
  சிவன்: "கொங்குதேர் வாழ்க்கை அஞ்சிறைத் தும்பி
  காமம் செப்பாது கண்டது மொழிமோ
  பயிலியது கழிய நட்பின்
  மயிலியல் சறியியற்று அறிவை கூந்தலின்
  அறியவும் உளவோ நீ அறியும் பூவே"
  
  - இது தான் எமது செய்யுள்
  
  நக்கீரன்: இதன் உட்கருத்து
  
  சிவன்: தலைவன், தலைவியின் காதலில் மெய் மறந்து,
  "ஏ தும்பி இனத்தைச் சேர்ந்த உயர்ந்த ஜாதி வண்டே
  நீ கண்ட மலர்களில் இம்மங்கையின் கூந்தலைப் போல்
  மணமுள்ள மலரும் உண்டோ" என்று கேட்பதைப் போல் எழுதியிருக்கிறேன்.
  
  நக்கீரன்: இதன் மூலம் நீங்கள் தெரிவிக்கும் கருத்து
  
  சிவன்: ஹ ஹ புரியவில்லை!! இயற்கையிலேயே பெண்ணின்
  கூந்தலுக்கு மணம் உண்டு என்பது தான் எமது தீர்ப்பு
  
  நக்கீரன்: ஒருக்காலும் இருக்க முடியாது, வாசனாதி திரவியங்களை பூசிக்கொள்வதினாலும், தொடர்ந்து மலர்களை
  சூடிக்கொள்வதினாலும் தான் ஒரு பெண்ணின் கூந்தலுக்கு மணம் இருக்க முடியுமே தவிர, இயற்கையிலேயே வெறுங்கூந்தலுக்கு ஒரு காலும் மணம் இருக்க முடியாது.
  
  சிவன்: தேவலோகப் பெண்களுக்கு?
  
  நக்கீரன்: ஈரேழு பதினான்கு லோகப் பெண்களுக்கும் அதே கதி தான்.
  
  சிவன்: உமது நாக்கில் இருந்து உலவுகிறாளே கலைமகள்
  அவளுக்கு அப்படித்தானோ!
  
  நக்கீரன்: கலைமகள் என்ன, நான் அன்றாடம் வழிபடும் ஈசனுக்கு இடப்பக்கம் அமர்ந்திருக்கிறாளே அன்னை மலைமகள், உமையவள் அவளுக்கும் அதே விதிப்படித்தான்.
  
  சிவன்: உண்மையாக
  
  நக்கீரன்: உண்மையாக
  
  சிவன்: நிச்சயமாக
  
  நக்கீரன்: நிச்சயமாக
  
  
  சிவன்: உமது தமிழ் மீது ஆணையாக
  
  நக்கீரன்: எமது தமிழ்ப் புலமை மீது ஆணையாக
  
  சிவன்: நக்கீரா... நன்றாக என்னைப் பார்! நான் எழுதிய தமிழ்ப் பாட்டு குற்றமா
  
  நக்கீரன்: (மனதில்... ஆண்டவா.! இறைவா!) புலவரே... நீரே முக்கண் முதல்வனும் ஆகுக. உமது நெற்றியில் ஒரு கண் திறந்து காட்டிய போதும், உமது நெற்றியெல்லாம் கண்ணாக்கிச்
  சுட்ட போதிலும் குற்றம் குற்றமே.
  
  நெற்றிக் கண் திறப்பினும் குற்றம் குற்றமே
  
  சிவன்: சங்கதனை கீர் கீர் என்று அறுக்கும் நக்கீரனோ எம்
  கவியை ஆராய்ந்து சொல்லத் தக்கவன் (sigh ... shivaji's voice
  worth a million here)
  
  நக்கீரன்: சங்கறுப்பதெங்கள் குலம்...சங்கரனார்க்கேது குலம்!!
  சங்கை அறிந்துண்டு வாழ்வோம்...ஹரனே உம்மைப் போல்
  இரந்துண்டு வாழ்வதில்லை.
  
  சிவன்: நக்கீரா...
  
  (ஆண்டவா...இறைவா... ஆதியும் நீயே... அந்தமும் நீயே.. ஊழியும் நேயே....)
  
  

• From: Raghu on Wed May 23 10:00:30 2007.

  [Full View]

  Nakeeran wrote:

  SP Akka ! Brilliant memory ! Eppadi full dialogues kodukureenga fm memory. Neenga great dhaankaa . Engeyou irukka vendiyavanga. Che che.

  
  
  summa google-a irunthu copy-paneetangappa,
  
  just joking SP acca
  
  

• From: Shakthiprabha on Wed May 23 10:03:28 2007.

  [Full View]

  raghu,
  
  I need not google for the MOST FAVOURITE MOVIE OF MINE.
  
  I generally am forgetful, this movie, however as I said is etched in my soul.
  
  

• From: joe on Wed May 23 10:10:32 2007.

  [Full View]

  SP,
  Again wow!
  
  

• From: Roshan on Wed May 23 10:17:02 2007.

  [Full View]

  NOV wrote:

  Raghu, thulli thulli is the worst example of good singing. SPB practically struggles to sing in low pitch. Listen to the song again, if you want.

  
  
  
  
  
  

  Quote:

  Anyway, I dont wish to continue arguing. I maintain my stand and the rest is up to you.

  
  
  Reppeatu.. with 'I' replaced by 'we' and 'my' replaced by 'our'
  
  

• From: Roshan on Wed May 23 10:20:05 2007.

  [Full View]

  SP
  
  Coooool - ungaL sEvai intha thread-ku thEvai
  
  

• From: ajithfederer on Wed May 23 10:23:20 2007.

  [Full View]

  Thanks sp akksss and joe
  
  

• From: joe on Wed May 23 10:29:19 2007.

  [Full View]

  SP,
  //உமது நெற்றியெல்லாம் கண்ணாக்கிச்
  சுட்ட போதிலும் குற்றம் குற்றமே. //
  
  இது
  
  உமது உடம்பெல்லாம் கண்ணாக்கிச்
  சுட்ட போதிலும் குற்றம் குற்றமே.
  
  என்றிருக்க வேண்டும்.
  
  உங்கள் அருமையான முயற்சிக்கு மீண்டுமொருமுறை நன்றி!
  
  

• From: Shakthiprabha on Wed May 23 11:14:38 2007.

  [Full View]

  JOE,
  
  I had that doubt, I mean I felt.. something did not gel there
  
  thanks for the correction
  
  

• From: Raghu on Wed May 23 11:58:46 2007.

  [Full View]

  NOV wrote:

  Raghu, thulli thulli is the worst example of good singing. SPB practically struggles to sing in low pitch. Listen to the song again, if you want. Anyway, I dont wish to continue arguing. I maintain my stand and the rest is up to you.

  
  
  
  
  Joke of the century.....
  
  

• From: Raghu on Wed May 23 12:01:44 2007.

  [Full View]

  Shakthiprabha wrote:

  raghu, I need not google for the MOST FAVOURITE MOVIE OF MINE. I generally am forgetful, this movie, however as I said is etched in my soul.

  
  
  maam,
  
  I was just joking
  
  vartaa
  
  

• From: Shakthiprabha on Wed May 23 12:41:29 2007.

  [Full View]

  Raghu,
  
  That was just an information, I wanted to share. I knew u were joking
  
  

• From: Thirumaran on Thu May 24 1:35:16 2007.

  [Full View]

  SP
  
  

• From: Sanguine Sridhar on Thu May 24 2:03:04 2007.

  [Full View]

  KM.... super work!
  
  

• From: NOV on Thu May 24 2:04:23 2007.

  [Full View]

  SPA,
  
  appadaa, varusaiyaa moonu mod vandhu jay pOttachu
  
  

• From: ksen on Thu May 24 3:37:00 2007.

  [Full View]

  Raghu wrote:

  can some one tell me a song which TMS sang in a very deep voice?

  
  
  How about 'Yaar andha nilavu'
  The bass in TMS' voice just reverberates in you
  
  Sorry for the dign
  
  

• From: Raghu on Thu May 24 6:34:05 2007.

  [Full View]

  ksen wrote:

  Raghu wrote: can some one tell me a song which TMS sang in a very deep voice? How about 'Yaar andha nilavu' The bass in TMS' voice just reverberates in you Sorry for the dign

  
  
  summa lolu panaathenga sir, ithellam deep voice-na ishwaraa
  
  
  
  nonetheless TMS is a VERY VERY GODD SINGER, no doubt
  
  

• From: Raghu on Thu May 24 6:37:14 2007.

  [Full View]

  Selva machi,
  
  few suggestions for your next movie discussions
  
  1) Karnan
  2) Salanghai Oli
  3) 6-il irunthu 60 vathu varai
  4) Sirpikuzh muthu
  5) Engo keata Kural
  6) Sri ragavendra
  7) Mouna Raagam
  
  ...
  
  

• From: Nakeeran on Thu May 24 6:58:33 2007.

  [Full View]

  Raghu wrote:

  ksen wrote: Raghu wrote: can some one tell me a song which TMS sang in a very deep voice? How about 'Yaar andha nilavu' The bass in TMS' voice just reverberates in you Sorry for the dign summa lolu panaathenga sir, ithellam deep voice-na ishwaraa nonetheless TMS is a VERY VERY GODD SINGER, no doubt

  
  
  Raghu Saar,
  
  Unga alavukku enakku Isai nyanam kidayadhu. But I can quote another song MADIMEEDHU THALAIVAITHU ..VIDIYUMVARAI THOONGUVOM Another TMS beauty ! Kettu paarunga Sir.
  
  But it may not match with your high expectations. Sorry sir.
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Thu May 24 7:34:49 2007.

  [Full View]

  Raghu machi,
  Please send your nominations through PM. I would prefer a single movie to be nominated at a time. FYI, Salangai Oli had been discussed already in this thread. I will soon list the movie that were discussed in the first post
  
  

• From: Roshan on Thu May 24 7:44:27 2007.

  [Full View]

  >> dig <<
  
  Nakeeran,
  
  Madi meethu thalai vaithu is not a great or extra ordinary song in terms of singing or pitching. But I agree with ksen on 'yaar antha nilavu'. It was something different from TMS and a very good attempt at singing on a lower note ( infact in one of his interviews TMS said, he initially found difficult to take up the challenge and had to do a lot of home work for this song). The song as a whole is a perfect composition. But still 'thulli thulli' stands out on any day
  
  I have posted my comments on this particular song in 'songs that had an emotional impact' thread this morning.
  
  
  << end dig >>
  
  

• From: Raghu on Thu May 24 9:45:56 2007.

  [Full View]

  NakeeRa ; Nandraha ennai paar, naan paninina post kutrama (joking)
  
  Dr.SPB is UNBEATABLE in every single DEPAERTMENT!!!
  
  every one else looks ORDINARY compared to his GREATNESS
  
  

• From: leosimha on Thu May 24 9:51:55 2007.

  [Full View]

  Raghu wrote:

  NakeeRa ; Nandraha ennai paar, naan paninina post kutrama (joking) Dr.SPB is UNBEATABLE in every single DEPAERTMENT!!! every one else looks ORDINARY compared to his GREATNESS

  
  
  Raghu,
  
  Yes, Dr. SPB is great. Even I am a fan of Dr. SPB's voice....but TMS is also great in his own way. SO lets stop dig here before the hubber joe becomes mod joe....
  
  

• From: joe on Thu May 24 9:58:17 2007.

  [Full View]

  leosimha wrote:

  SO lets stop dig here before the hubber joe becomes mod joe....

  
  
  Arumaiya sonneenga
  
  

• From: lavanya22rit on Thu May 24 10:06:29 2007.

  [Full View]

  This is the only movie which i never got bored even after watching more than 20 times !!!!
  IMO credit goes Sivaji, APN, BMK, KVM in the same order
  
  

• From: rajeshkrv on Thu May 24 10:09:55 2007.

  [Full View]

  ThiruVilayadal - Mythology Stories can be told interestingly by APN only ..
  
  that too his comb with NT is always a treat
  
  thiruvilayadal is one such movie which you can watch at all ages at all time
  
  wonderful pick
  
  

• From: Raghu on Thu May 24 10:16:39 2007.

  [Full View]

  lavanya22rit wrote:

  This is the only movie which i never got bored even after watching more than 20 times !!!! IMO credit goes Sivaji, APN, BMK, KVM in the same order

  
  
  Indeed,
  
  

• From: leosimha on Thu May 24 10:40:43 2007.

  [Full View]

  //dig//
  
  Please Please Please, can you let me know about KVM?
  
  //dig//
  
  I completely agree that Thiruvilaiyaadal is an EVERGREEN movie, can be seen umpteen number of times...Sivaji has excelled the limits in this movie...
  
  

• From: Raghu on Thu May 24 11:05:32 2007.

  [Full View]

  leosimha wrote:

  //dig// Please Please Please, can you let me know about KVM? //dig// I completely agree that Thiruvilaiyaadal is an EVERGREEN movie, can be seen umpteen number of times...Sivaji has excelled the limits in this movie...

  
  
  Leoshima,
  
  enpa, K.V.Mahadevan patri theriyaathaa?? ,
  Shankaraparanam paadalghal theriyumma??
  
  

• From: joe on Thu May 24 22:20:15 2007.

  [Full View]

  Raghu wrote:

  lavanya22rit wrote: This is the only movie which i never got bored even after watching more than 20 times !!!! IMO credit goes Sivaji, APN, BMK, KVM in the same order Indeed,

  
  
  You missed bold for APN ,which is quite surprise
  
  APN was the captain of the ship ,he not only directed ,but wrote the dialogues which became eternal.
  
  

• From: Shakthiprabha on Thu May 24 23:02:05 2007.

  [Full View]

  YES,
  
  APN's role cannot be dismissed easily.
  
  

• From: leosimha on Fri May 25 2:39:21 2007.

  [Full View]

  Raghu wrote:

  leosimha wrote: //dig// Please Please Please, can you let me know about KVM? //dig// I completely agree that Thiruvilaiyaadal is an EVERGREEN movie, can be seen umpteen number of times...Sivaji has excelled the limits in this movie... Leoshima, enpa, K.V.Mahadevan patri theriyaathaa?? , Shankaraparanam paadalghal theriyumma??

  
  
  yes....I know K.V.Mahadevan.............yesterday I was scratching my head a lot till I lost some hair and then found out that K.V.M is none other than K.V.Mahadevan. (Hmm..what to do? I am not in the habit of remembering acronyms, I can remember only Full Names)
  
  Shankarabharanam Songs are simply superb.
  
  

• From: leosimha on Fri May 25 2:43:32 2007.

  [Full View]

  joe wrote:

  Raghu wrote: lavanya22rit wrote: This is the only movie which i never got bored even after watching more than 20 times !!!! IMO credit goes Sivaji, APN, BMK, KVM in the same order Indeed, You missed bold for APN ,which is quite surprise APN was the captain of the ship ,he not only directed ,but wrote the dialogues which became eternal.

  
  
  yes, ofcourse. A.P.Nagarajan can't be ignored.
  
  

• From: leosimha on Fri May 25 2:46:45 2007.

  [Full View]

  Joe,
  
  Has the movie "Karnan" been discussed here? Another Classic which is worth discussing. Another evergreen movie which I love watching umpteen number of times. Then who can forget the movie "RajaRaja Chozhan". Classics of Sivaji.
  
  Please don't be shocked. The movie which I missed a lot on seeing is "Veera Pandiya Kattabomman". These films are worth discussing.
  
  

• From: joe on Fri May 25 3:42:45 2007.

  [Full View]

  Leo,
  Don't worry .Our friend Selva will note down your recommendations and will put those in proper order.
  
  

• From: groucho070 on Fri May 25 3:49:55 2007.

  [Full View]

  leosimha wrote:

  yes....I know K.V.Mahadevan.............yesterday I was scratching my head a lot till I lost some hair and then found out that K.V.M is none other than K.V.Mahadevan. (Hmm..what to do? I am not in the habit of remembering acronyms, I can remember only Full Names) Shankarabharanam Songs are simply superb.

  
  
  Join the club.
  
  KVM scored for most of APN's picture, including the excellent Saraswathy Sabatham, Thiruvarutchelvar, Kandhan Karunai, to name a few. Strangely APN picked Kunnakudi Vaithiyanathan for MGR's Navarathinam. I think the biggest contributor to the movie's flop is KV's inept music.
  
  Before you hardcore-Carnatic fans throw rotten tomatoes at me, I think KV is a fine musician who is a king in his own arena. But not cinema...(though he was good in Deivam).
  
  While Thiruvilayadal is a classic, I somehow tend to revisit Saraswathy Sabatham more often. I don't know why. Maybe because of my mom's name. Maybe I am pro-education.
  
  

• From: joe on Fri May 25 3:57:54 2007.

  [Full View]

  groucho070 wrote:

  While Thiruvilayadal is a classic, I somehow tend to revisit Saraswathy Sabatham more often. I don't know why.

  
  
  Interestingly ,saraswathi sabatham is one of Super Star Rajini's most favourite movies..He mentioned in many occassions and I remember he used one scene in baba also.
  
  

• From: lavanya22rit on Fri May 25 4:14:44 2007.

  [Full View]

  joe wrote:

  Raghu wrote: lavanya22rit wrote: This is the only movie which i never got bored even after watching more than 20 times !!!! IMO credit goes Sivaji, APN, BMK, KVM in the same order Indeed, You missed bold for APN ,which is quite surprise APN was the captain of the ship ,he not only directed ,but wrote the dialogues which became eternal.

  
  
  Infact i can even rearrange its as APN, Sivaji, BMK, KVM.....kudos to APN for providing us this evergreen classic
  
  

• From: lavanya22rit on Fri May 25 4:15:59 2007.

  [Full View]

  joe wrote:

  groucho070 wrote: While Thiruvilayadal is a classic, I somehow tend to revisit Saraswathy Sabatham more often. I don't know why. Interestingly ,saraswathi sabatham is one of Super Star Rajini's most favourite movies..He mentioned in many occassions and I remember he used one scene in baba also.

  
  
  Sivaji's expressions as narathar was just awesome.
  
  

• From: groucho070 on Fri May 25 4:17:37 2007.

  [Full View]

  Thiruvilayadal is episodic. It's a delight to see many facets of Sivan/NT...and the stories are great platform for many wonderful talents.
  
  But in SS, there is a central issue. What is greater. The whole movie is a debate about values. Educations wins them all and it's so valid till today. There is also a kelvi/bathil session, but not as powerful as Thiruvilayadal.
  
  So, Thiruvilayadal is a great pleasure for all senses...but SS is more intellectual. But unfortunately, I find GG was miscast in SS. Should have gotten someone else, like Muthuraman. As good as GG is, playing a Veeran is not his forte.
  
  SS came after Thiruvilayadal, right Joe?
  
  

• From: lavanya22rit on Fri May 25 4:22:06 2007.

  [Full View]

  groucho070 wrote:

  Thiruvilayadal is episodic. It's a delight to see many facets of Sivan/NT...and the stories are great platform for many wonderful talents. But in SS, there is a central issue. What is greater. The whole movie is a debate about values. Educations wins them all and it's so valid till today. There is also a kelvi/bathil session, but not as powerful as Thiruvilayadal. So, Thiruvilayadal is a great pleasure for all senses...but SS is more intellectual. But unfortunately, I find GG was miscast in SS. Should have gotten someone else, like Muthuraman. As good as GG is, playing a Veeran is not his forte. SS came after Thiruvilayadal, right Joe?

  
  
  
  But while watching the movie i felt they desperately tried to recreate the magic of thiruvilayadal....but just missed it by a whisker
  
  

• From: Murali Srinivas on Fri May 25 6:13:20 2007.

  [Full View]

  groucho070 wrote:

  There is also a kelvi/bathil session, but not as powerful as Thiruvilayadal. SS came after Thiruvilayadal, right Joe?

  
  
  
  GRoucho,
  
  While in Thiruvilayadal everybody (NT,Nagesh & APN) scored, in SS NT would have swept away the entire group consisting of GG,KRV and ERS (ERSahadevan) in that question answer session. In fact the chemistry of the scene would itself change when the following dialogues are uttered.
  
  KRV: Andha Pulavarai Azhaithu Vaarungal
  
  GG: Yaar andha Pulavan?
  
  KRV: Varuvar Parungal
  
  With this the camers would shift to the entrance and NT dressed in all splendour would just majestically walk in. Man! You are again tempting me.
  
  Your second querry, yes. While Thiruvilayadal got released in July 1965, SS got released in August 1966.
  
  Regards
  
  

• From: groucho070 on Fri May 25 6:21:27 2007.

  [Full View]

  Thank you, Murali-Sar,
  
  What tempting? I was expecting you to recreate that magical moment.
  
  
  Arrrr.......okay, okay, I will try to get that movie (my mom, Mrs. Saraswathy, hijacked that VCD and never returned) and will post a review on NT's thread.
  
  The reason for the Q/A session in SS is different from Thiruvilayadal. In SS it's more about show of power by the other two. Okay, I'lll talk about it later. I am digressing.
  
  

• From: Raghu on Fri May 25 6:23:37 2007.

  [Full View]

  some how i LOVED, Karnan, Thiruvilaiyadal, and thiruvarut chelvar more than SS
  
  selva Machi
  
  lets discuss KARNAN after this
  plsssssssssssssssssssssssssss
  plssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssss
  plssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssss
  
  
  
  
  
  
  

• From: Shakthiprabha on Fri May 25 10:36:36 2007.

  [Full View]

  Oh I know, why THIRUVILAIYAADAL is better than SS.
  
  ThiruviLaiyaadal FOCUSES on shivaji and his multiple persona in acting.
  
  SS, has so many others with equal choice.
  
  Since we get to see MORE OF SHIVAJI in THIRUVILAIYAADAL, impact is more too.
  
  Even otherwise,
  
  thiruvarutchelvar had shivaji as prime cast for most roles, YET... DID NOT HAVE THE MAGIC of thiruvilaiyaadal.
  
  
  
  why?
  
  

• From: joe on Fri May 25 10:40:55 2007.

  [Full View]

  Shakthiprabha wrote:

  thiruvarutchelvar had shivaji as prime cast for most roles, YET... DID NOT HAVE THE MAGIC of thiruvilaiyaadal. why?

  
  
  The Reason is ...
  
  Thiruvarutchelvar was a serious movie with pure Pakthi ,where as ThiruviLayadal is collection of interesting episodes of Lord siva ,with humour added with that.
  
  IMO ,ThiruviLayadal is not Pakthi padam .. the name ThiruVILAYADL itself shows the difference
  
  

• From: Murali Srinivas on Fri May 25 10:44:02 2007.

  [Full View]

  SP,
  
  Thiruvilayadal depicted Lord Siva and his vilayadal puranas which people had read/heard of but T.Selvar dealt with the stories of Nayanmars which were not so popular and so the identification was less with TVSelvar?
  
  Just my thinking
  
  Regards
  
  

• From: Shakthiprabha on Fri May 25 10:56:59 2007.

  [Full View]

  hmmm...
  
  I think I agree with MURALI SRINIVAS.
  
  though what joe said could not be dismissed.
  
  may be a lil of this and lil of that
  
  

• From: Raghu on Fri May 25 11:22:03 2007.

  [Full View]

  Murali Srinivas wrote:

  SP, Thiruvilayadal depicted Lord Siva and his vilayadal puranas which people had read/heard of but T.Selvar dealt with the stories of Nayanmars which were not so popular and so the identification was less with TVSelvar? Just my thinking Regards

  
  
  but Murali sir, 63 Gnayanmarhal are the one of the BASIS of Shaivism right? then how can the Majority of Shaivites from INDIA be ignorant of this?
  
  

• From: Murali Srinivas on Sat May 26 1:30:05 2007.

  [Full View]

  Dear Raghu,
  
  I think you are residing outside TN/India. Here though majority of them are Shaivaties as you said, it is a fact that most of them are not aware of nayanmars except say the top 4 (Appar, Sundarar, Sambandar and Manickavasagar) whom we call as Saiva smaya kuravargal.
  
  Since TVSelvar dealt with other nayanmars though it covered Sundarar, Appar and Sambandar(though in small measure), the people had difficulty in identifying with their plight.
  
  This was a 100 day movie. Though what I am going to say is nothing connected with the identification factor now, at that time (during release of the movie) bakthi films by NT- APN combo started releasing at regular intervals which could also have a played a part in the way the people recd the movies. If you check
  
  Thiruvilayadal -1965 July
  
  Saraswathy Sabatham - 1966 August
  
  Kandhan Karunai - 1967 January
  
  Thiruvarutselvar - 1967 July
  
  Thirumal Perumai - 1968 February.
  
  The level of success gradually started decreasing and Thirumal Perumai was he one out of the above 5 which could not complete a 100 day run. In fact it was not a success at all.
  
  This was the basis of my posting.
  
  Regards
  
  

• From: Nakeeran on Sat May 26 4:04:36 2007.

  [Full View]

  Watch the mind blowing PAATUM NAANE BHAVAMUM NAANE here :
  
  http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QyJhodhw1q4&eurl=
  
  Amazing display of variety in the final part of the song when 5 guys compete with each other & that mutual appreciation for each others' play !
  
  Superb camera work and fantastic acting !
  
  

• From: tacinema on Sat May 26 10:02:15 2007.

  [Full View]

  Good pick this week - Thiruvilaiyaadal; one of the greatest mythological movies that NT, along with APN, carved out. In my opinion, this movie was a showcase of team work with seemingly no ego attahed from all artists involved. You can see this factor throughout the movie - see how Nagesh dominates in first vilaiyaadal, T S Balaiah's equal role in fourth vilaiyaadal and KB Sundarambal breezes easily during beginning and ending of the movie. The movie has got some finest acting from everyone - a reason why it became a blockbuster and an all-time favourite.
  
  If we were to take a poll on favourite vilaiyaadal, then I am sure the first episode (with Nagesh) would be an easy winner. But I may differ here; in my opinion, the fourth vilaiyaadal (paana pathirar part) is more versatile and more challenging than Nagesh-NT vilaiyaadal.
  
  Another thing I mesmerized is APN's creativity - the way Nagesh character was shaped and made it one of the best comedies in history, in contrast to the original purana where Dharumi is depicted as a poor poet who is a very devoted bhakta of Lord Shiva.
  
  There have been a lot of discussion in this thread on different characters: NT, Savithri, Nagesh, and so on. But I am not sure why no one discussed about K B Sundarambal's role - a simple and very effective Avvaiyar role. Especially when she tries to teach Lord Muruga during beginning of the movie and at the end, when she comes back to see the reunion of Muruga with parents. If you like tamil literature, you would simple love her tamil diction. Her tamil diction is richer, more sophisticated - especially at the end, when Savithri asks KBS to dedicate a poem to Lord Shiva using numerals: OneRu, Rendu, Moondru ena varasai paduthi paadu. A simple treat to movie lovers. Do you know KBS was the first artists who was offered 1 lac Rupees for a role in Avvaiyar movie, made by Gemini Studios? I believe she accepted the offer and donated that money to national freedom movement!!
  
  Somehow, I feel APN as Nakeerar did not gel well with the character. The dialogue part of the argument was very sharp but in my view, APN did not deliver the dialogues very effectively. Any takers? Did APN act in any other movie?
  
  

• From: tacinema on Sat May 26 10:27:02 2007.

  [Full View]

  Murali: I may not agree with your statement that people were well aware of Lord Shiva's thiruvilayadal and that contributed to the success of the movie. A common tamilian wont have a chance to know about the purana, except as a high school student, you read it in the poem. I always feel that the thiruvilayadal purana became more popular and reached the mass after the movie was released. In addition, a common tamilian does not have a chance to learn about 63 Nayanmars, unless you are willing to learn about tamil Saiva history.
  
  In my view, the reason why Thiruvilaiyadal was more successful than any other NT's purana movie was that Thiruvilayadal has got all necessary ingradients to become a major success:such as fine acting, good narration and above all, best comedy. These are the very factors that other purana movies lagged - SS does not have a good comedy part.
  
  Commercial apsect of Thiruvilaiyadal has more surprising elements: During its re-release the movie was a major success. It run for 3 weeks in late 80s at Madurai Chintamani and the fans welcomed in a big way with banners, floral arrangements, and fire crackers. During that time, this theatre released three NT movies with major success: Thangasurangam, Thiruvilayadal and Thillana mohanambal. In addition, the nadigarthilagam.com website claims that a woman fan of NT in chennai saw thiruvilayadal for all 175 days (must be 175 times at least) it ran at Shanthi theater.
  
  

• From: Murali Srinivas on Mon May 28 2:05:44 2007.

  [Full View]

  tac,
  
  Good points you have written about Thiruvilayadal especially about KBS and her songs.
  
  Regarding my posting, I was in fact replying to SP about the identification factor. She was wondering why TVSelvar did not became a rage and I had told her that nayanmar stories are not as popular as Lord Shiva's vilayadal puranams which you had also stated. I do agree the way Thiruvilayadal was made contributed to it's roaring success.
  
  That's what I had pointed out in my reply to Raghu that when APN repeated the treatment and that too at regular intervals, the sequels could not repeat the Super success story of Thiruvilayadal.
  
  Regards
  
  

• From: MADDY on Tue May 29 22:50:30 2007.

  [Full View]

  next coming up -> the tale of victory of Amanjikarai over America .....TM , please make the announcement.....i cant wait
  
  

• From: Shakthiprabha on Tue May 29 23:39:41 2007.

  [Full View]

  oh wowwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwww
  
  waiting
  
  

• From: joe on Wed May 30 1:34:35 2007.

  [Full View]

  On behalf of Selvakumar ,Let me announce the movie of the week.
  
  Minnale
  
  The Star Cast:
  Madhavan, Reema, Abbas, Nagesh, Vivek, Kitty, Fathima Babu and Others
  
  The Crew:
  Lyrics : Valee / Thamarai
  Camera : Rajasekhar
  Editor : Suresh Urs
  Music : Harris Jeyaraj
  Director : Gautham
  Executive Producer : Dr. J. Murali Manohar
  Associate Producer : J. Jayakumar
  Produced by : Cee (I) TV Entertainment Limited
  
  http://www.galatta.com/OfficialSites/minnale/html/index.htm
  
  

• From: Wibha on Wed May 30 1:36:21 2007.

  [Full View]

  
  
  

• From: Rocky_ on Wed May 30 1:47:48 2007.

  [Full View]

  I didn't like this movie much the first time I saw it. Also Reema Sen was Ugly IMO. The Make up was horrible.
  
  But then I saw it a 2nd time on Sun TV. I liked it a lot better.
  
  I LOVE Vivek's Intro Scene!
  
  

• From: Wibha on Wed May 30 1:55:12 2007.

  [Full View]

  The first time i saw it
  Oh mama mama song was cut in the CD and i was eagerly waiting for it......... i loved the movie except for vaseegara song
  
  Madhavan's role and acting is awesome
  
  abbas the movie was too good............ vivek
  
  

• From: Rocky_ on Wed May 30 2:05:41 2007.

  [Full View]

  Abbas That's exactly what he was. Just a
  
  Have u seen how Saif played that role in the Hindi Version?
  
  IMO Saif did a better job, and fit the role better.
  
  But then again, I'm a Saif Ali Khan fan so I liked it better.
  
  

• From: MADDY on Wed May 30 2:06:18 2007.

  [Full View]

  Thanks Joe........ ...
  
  Maddy maddy oh ho Maddy defined minnale ...also, my nickname was derived from this movie...
  
  

• From: Wibha on Wed May 30 2:07:31 2007.

  [Full View]

  Rocky_ wrote:

  Abbas That's exactly what he was. Just a Have u seen how Saif played that role in the Hindi Version? IMO Saif did a better job, and fit the role better.

  
  
  saif was AWESOME
  
  and maddy is fat in hindi cha he lost the chocolate boy look in RHTDM............but in minnalea he was amazingggggggg........
  
  

• From: Rocky_ on Wed May 30 2:10:19 2007.

  [Full View]

  
  
  Vivek was also another hero for the film!
  
  The Credit for the Film's Sucess should also go to him.
  
  

• From: lavanya22rit on Wed May 30 4:07:15 2007.

  [Full View]

  Maddy and Vivek did a wonderful job....but the major credit shud go to the debutant Harris Jayaraj.....without those songs the movie wudnt have turned out to be watchable.....Maddy's acting was superb as always thou
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Wed May 30 4:33:15 2007.

  [Full View]

  Thanks a lot Joe !
  
  Advance Birthday wishes to R.Madhavan
  
  ---------
  Minnale
  ---------
  
  "Minnal velichathula oru ponna paarthaen
  Nenjai apadiyae poo pola, koithu sendraal
  Uthattil aval peyarudanum, udalil aval uyirudanum alainthen
  Megamaa allathu Vaanamaa endru thavithaal antha venmathi
  Iruthiyil en vaanathai adainthaal andha azhagiya thee"
  
  Minnalae - Balaji review
  
  When a movie is saddled with a familiar story, no surprises and predictableproceedings, it is upto the director to fashion the movie in a way that keepsthe viewer in his seat. And in that respect, debutante director Gautham has beensuccessful. He packages a love triangle in an entertaining package with a charminglead pair, a little bit of mixed identities and a believable romance and providesMadhavan a chance to redeem himself in front of his fans, who may have abandoned him afterEnnavale.
  
  Rajesh(Madhavan) and Samuel(Abbas), poles apart in personalities, are sworn enemiesin college and part the same way. Rajesh falls in love with Reena(Reema Sen) butlearns later that she is all set wed Rajiv, who lives in the US and is supposed to arrive in a week to see her. Rajesh shows up at her doorstep as Rajiv(whom she hasnever seen) and proceeds to steal her heart in the five days he spends with her. Thegig is up for Rajesh when Rajiv, none other than his old enemy Sam, arrives fromthe US. A shellshocked and cheated Reena now hates him while Rajiv gets ready towed her.
  
  At the heart of the movie is the eternally famous love triangle of two men beingin love with the same girl. So the onus lies on the director to fashion enough interesting situations to help us forget this basic premise of the movie. He doesthis through some interesting characterisations and a youthful romance. The directordoesn't take the easy way out by making Abbas the bad guy. He is as good as(in somecases, even better than) Madhavan and this makes the love triangle slightly interesting. The meetings between Madhavan and Reema after she knows the truth are marked by some sharp dialogs and Reema's character gains some respect during thesescenes. But the stale climax follows every cliche that usually closes out such a love triangle faithfully and is a disappointment.
  
  Ofcourse, with the majority of the movie dealing with Madhavan taking Ajith's place,suspension of disbelief is an essential part of enjoying these portions. Questionslike why Reema's parents are never seen until absolutely necessary are not likely notto be answered even by the director and the sheer number of coincidences needed for the ploy to work(they care of just one - disconnecting the telephone to Reema's house)constantly reminds you that none of this can be taken seriously. On the other hand,the romance is handled well with the right amount of charm and minimum fuss and sentiments. The scenes where the couple go out to eat and Madhavan's attempt togive her a surprise on her birthday are cute and funny.
  
  Vivek raises some laughs as Madhavan's friend. He has his best lines during theconversation with the lorry driver and then the police after his accident. Thedirector has attempted to portray a grandfather-grandson relationship that is moreof a friendship but goes overboard as the movie goes on. Nagesh's urging of Madhavanto find a girl is funny initially but his reactions to Madhavan and his friends gangingup on Abbas and his other advice after Reema rejects Madhavan do not ring true and worse, decrease the respect his character earns until then.
  
  Madhavan discards(not completely though) his loverboy role in his first two films to play a rowdy character.Surprisingly, the role suits him well and he is impressive during the initial altercationswith Abbas. (Is his stylish way of lighting the matchstick at various places an attemptto earn him some male fans too?!). Reema Sen looks really cute and pretty and acts welltoo. Abbas has an extended cameo and is adequate. Music is by newcomer Harris Jayaraj,A.R.Rehman's assistant, and the influence is obvious, especially in the backgroundmusic. Vaseegara... is the pick of the songs though the picturisation does notdo full justice to it. Verenna... and Venmathiye... are the other goodsongs.
  
  

• From: swathy on Wed May 30 4:33:22 2007.

  [Full View]

  Other than vivek's comedy and songs, I didn't like anything in this movie.
  
  Reema's reaction on seeing abbas
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Wed May 30 4:36:17 2007.

  [Full View]

  MADDY wrote:

  Thanks Joe........ ... Maddy maddy oh ho Maddy defined minnale ...also, my nickname was derived from this movie...

  
  
  
  There is only one person who can use that title and that is R.Madhavan only !
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Wed May 30 4:41:52 2007.

  [Full View]

  swathy wrote:

  Other than vivek's comedy and songs, I didn't like anything in this movie. Reema's reaction on seeing abbas

  
  
  Reema sen ah neraya college pasanga climax la ---- panni irundha appreciate panni irupeengaloe ?
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Wed May 30 4:43:59 2007.

  [Full View]

  lavanya22rit wrote:

  Maddy and Vivek did a wonderful job....but the major credit shud go to the debutant Harris Jayaraj.....without those songs the movie wudnt have turned out to be watchable.....Maddy's acting was superb as always thou

  
  
  Well said. Sema debut !
  All the songs were good except Oh mama.
  
  I love Ivan Yaaro , Aeh Theeyae , Nenjai poo pol koithaval, Ore nyabagan !
  I didn't like Vaseegara that much at first
  
  

• From: Raikkonen on Wed May 30 4:46:32 2007.

  [Full View]

  This is the movie that made me a fan of Madhavan and Vivek.. Reema Sen was pretty in the movie, but unfortunately (fortunate?) she fizzled after that.... But Abbas stole the show (for my money).. probably his best movie to date.....
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Wed May 30 4:52:55 2007.

  [Full View]

  Rocky_ wrote:

  Reema Sen was Ugly IMO. The Make up was horrible.

  
  
  :anger: IMO, that was the only movie in which she was pretty.
  
  

• From: villan007 on Wed May 30 5:51:21 2007.

  [Full View]

  subbuni , naan rajeshlEndhu bangalore pesuren
  
  

• From: swathy on Wed May 30 5:52:59 2007.

  [Full View]

  selvakumar wrote:

  swathy wrote: Other than vivek's comedy and songs, I didn't like anything in this movie. Reema's reaction on seeing abbas Reema sen ah neraya college pasanga climax la ---- panni irundha appreciate panni irupeengaloe ?

  
  
  climaxla enna?
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Wed May 30 5:53:26 2007.

  [Full View]

  villan007 wrote:

  subbuni , naan rajeshlEndhu bangalore pesuren

  
  
  
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Wed May 30 5:54:11 2007.

  [Full View]

  though this movie was a neatly executed version of Kaadhal Mannan, I love this movie equally. It was too good and I must say that
  
  I loved this movie mroe than Alaipaayuthey !
  
  

• From: Roshan on Wed May 30 6:11:39 2007.

  [Full View]

  Swathy sonnA maathiri - only songs and Vivek were enjoyable. Enakku Reemavai pidikaathu
  
  There is this scene where Madhavan, Vivek and friends will be seated in a circle and Vivek will be giving ideas how to approach Reema. Ideas solluRathOda - he will kalachify every body in that group. He would do it in a very casual way and the whole scene (quite a lengthy one) would be spine breaking When ever I see it on TV I wonder how difficult it would have been for Madhavan to maintain seriousness through out that scene.
  
  700 spare partsla oDatha vandiyAdA intha elumicha pazhathula oDa pOguthu
  
  appadiyE Kamal sir maathiri get up-a maathittE iru - ponnu kedekkAttiyum - oru Oscar-aavathu kedekkum
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Wed May 30 6:22:12 2007.

  [Full View]

  Roshan wrote:

  700 spare partsla oDatha vandiyAdA intha elumicha pazhathula oDa pOguthu appadiyE Kamal sir maathiri get up-a maathittE iru - ponnu kedekkAttiyum - oru Oscar-aavathu kedekkum

  
  
  
  That one was too good.
  another one:
  
  Madhavan will be showing the cup (that was used by Reema) to ALL ! Everyone will be congratulating him and vivek will say
  
  "Dei.. Ithukku nee ava saapitta elaya edhuthuttu vanthu kazhuvi FRAME pottu vachi irukkalaam.
  
  elaarum kaadhalikku SELA vaikuraan.. nee ELAI vachathaa irukatuum ! "
  
  

• From: Roshan on Wed May 30 6:35:41 2007.

  [Full View]

  
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Wed May 30 6:40:22 2007.

  [Full View]

  I donno really !
  Why Madhavan stopped giving movies like Minnalae after this !
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Wed May 30 6:43:07 2007.

  [Full View]

  swathy wrote:

  climaxla enna?

  
  
  >
  
  

  MADDY wrote:

  next coming up -> the tale of victory of Amanjikarai over America .....TM , please make the announcement.....i cant wait

  
  

• From: selvakumar on Wed May 30 6:49:49 2007.

  [Full View]

  http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Minnale
  
  http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0357905/usercomments
  
  Author: sidhu from Hamburg
  

  Quote:

  The hero who is allergic to girls during the first few scenes.On a rainy night he sees a girl dancing in the rain and he sees her face when lightning strikes(minnal in tamil and hence the name). He falls in love with her but he finds out that she is engaged to someone else and he pretends as her fiancée and makes her fall in love with him. She finds out eventually and now has to choose between the two. My favorite tamil movie and all the songs are great. The song vaseegara is excellent with the vocals. I would recommend this movie for people in their teens.

  
  
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Wed May 30 6:53:09 2007.

  [Full View]

  http://www.chennaionline.com/moviereviews/tammov101.asp
  
  Director: Gautham
  Cast: Madhavan, Abbas, Rima Sen, Vivek, Nagesh, Kitty, Janaki.
  
  Rajesh and Samuel (Madhavan - Abbas) are college-mates and bitter rivals. They have their gangs, each indulging in one-upmanship. Samuel goes abroad for higher studies while Rajesh takes up a job. Rajesh, on a trip to Bangalore, comes across Reena and is smitten by her charm. To his pleasant surprise he sees her again in Chennai and tries to plan his moves to get closer to her. But there is a hitch. Reena is engaged to Rajiv from the U.S. But, all being fair in love and war, Rajesh is persuaded by his friend Chockalingam (Vivek) and grandpa Subbuni (Nagesh) to impersonate Rajiv and enter Reena's life. Rajesh gets to spend five blissful days with Reena, who reciprocates his love till Rajiv appears on the scene and Reena discovers Rajesh's duplicity. Rajesh too gets a rude shock when he discovers that Rajiv is none other than his old college rival Samuel. How the matter is resolved forms the rest of the story.
  
  It is a debutant's work and Gautham (ad film-maker, and an apprentice to directors Rajiv Menon and G.B. Vijay) shows promise. In a stylish way he has tried to give a new look to the eternal love-triangle story. He has succeeded partly, for the film is fairly engaging. The first half is fun and frolic with Vivek largely responsible for keeping the proceedings alive. The second half could have been trimmed a little.
  
  Madhavan has improved his dialogue delivery and it is a role that suits him. Abbas reveals maturity, particularly in handling the later scenes. Rima is confident and has an impish charm. Harris Jairaj (Jingles composer) has scored some top-of-the-chart songs. Unfortunately their impact is marred by some unimaginative picturisation. The impact one felt on hearing them on the audio (like the melodious - 'Vaseegara…') is sadly missing in the visuals.
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Wed May 30 6:58:34 2007.

  [Full View]

  http://www.dhool.com/phpBB2/viewtopic.php?t=2197
  
  Film : Minnale
  singer: Harish ragavendra , timmy
  lyrics : Vaali
  music : harris
  song : ye theeye
  
  Eh theeye azhagiye theeye ennai vaalthughiraiye
  Oru haikoo kavithai vizhighalil nee paada paada
  Oru hypertension thalaikeruthe
  naanum vaada
  PaavaighaL unnakoru allergy adda
  AvaLai paarthadhum unnakulle energyadaa
  Ennai yetho seithu vitaaL
  Common babe don’t do this babe
  Nenjai poo pol koidhu vitaaL
  Don’t you ever do this
  Don’t you ever do this babe
  
  Varave illai urrakam atharkum illai erakkam
  Imaighal ondraghe epothum seraamal
  Idaiyai nindraiye ithu nyayamma
  Bp erri pochu illa ratham
  Nenjil kaadhal polle oru yutham
  Addi artha rathiri sunnu mathiri veppam thakudhadi kannil
  Ennil minnal thakave theeyum kaatrum ondru sernthatho unnil…
  Nee ennai suttethum analil ittadhum
  inthamathilum poo poo pothum…
  
  Eh hei…azhagiye theeye ennai vaalthughiraiye
  Oru haikoo kavithai vizhighalil nee paada paada
  Oru hypertension thalaikeruthenaanum vaada
  Never do this to me…don’t ever do this to me ….babe
  Un peyar solli solli ennaiyai naan maranthen
  Un minnal paarvaiyil en uyir naan tholaithen
  
  Udhathil unthan peyarthan…udalil unthan uyirthan…
  nilathil nindralum neeyengu sendralum
  Naan unnai thodargindra nizhal allava…
  Kaathal pithu yeri manam thatta
  Avalai sekku polle nee sutha
  Unnai konjam konjamai thunda thundamai kondru pottuthu enna
  Kodi minnal kaatiye thegham yaavum
  Minnal polleve minnum
  Naan ennai en idam illai endruthan penne un idam vanthen theda
  hey theeyeazhagiye theeye….ennai vaatuughiraiye..
  Oru haikoo kavithai vizhighalil neethan paada paada
  Oru hypertension thalaikeruthe…naanum vaada
  Paavaighal unnakoru allergy adda…
  Avalai paarthathum unnakulle energy adda…
  Ennai yetho seithu vitaaL .
  
  

• From: Roshan on Wed May 30 7:02:48 2007.

  [Full View]

  Selva,
  
  Venmathi VenmathiyE nillu is also nice. Lyrics nallA irukkum. Athuvum VaaliyOdathA?
  
  I know 'VaseegarA' was from Thamarai but other songs I dont know
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Wed May 30 7:06:22 2007.

  [Full View]

  Roshan wrote:

  Selva, Venmathi VenmathiyE nillu is also nice. Lyrics nallA irukkum. Athuvum VaaliyOdathA? I know 'VaseegarA' was from Thamarai but other songs I dont know

  
  
  Not sure Roshan. I know about Azhagiya Theeyae only.
  
  Anyway,
  here is one of the reviews available @ mouthshut on the album
  
  http://www.mouthshut.com/review/Minnale_Album-48033-1.html
  
  

  Quote:

  Let me start by saying I’m really surprised that there nobody on MS has yet reviewed the songs of Minnale. And I take great pride in being the first to write about it...(coz all the songs are awesome!!) The director of this movie is Gautham, for whom this was a debut movie. The music director is Harris Jeyaraj, who too made his debut. He used to be(I believe he still is) AR Rahman’s assistant. People said that HJ had copied some of ARR’s tunes, but whether or not that’s true, a man has to be credited for giving excellent music, and Harris Jeyaraj deserves every bit of praise for that. The five songs in the album are: Hey Azhagiye Theeye -- Harish Raghavendra, Timmy A song that the hero sings about the heroine, calling her a beautiful fire that sautes him and about how she makes him feel. Nice tappy number. Oh Mama Mama Mama -- Shanker Mahadevan, Tippu A song that talks about enjoying life and being playful. ’Oh Sunday Monday Tuesday Ezhunaalum tension freeya’ meaning ’All 7 days free from tension’... Shanker Mahadevan sings it very well, showing he can sing songs of any mood or calibre. Ore Nyabagam -- Devan A very small song sung by Devan. Very soothing number that sets the pace for the next song (and the super hit of the album) Vaseegara Ore Nyabagam means ’only one memory’ but it can also be taken to mean ’so many memories’. I guess the hero means his only memories are those of the heroine. Vaseegara -- Bombay Jayashree The MEGA Hit song! Bombay Jayashree renders it beautifully, at the pitch she’s very comfortable in. The flute interluds are very good too. A perfect song, with no errors to pinpoint. A lot of Hindi movie buffs too prefer this tamil rendition to the hindi version. I don’t know what the song means in Hindi but it’s pretty nice in Tamil. Since I expect a lot of you would want to hum along, I’m going to give the lyrics and translation of the song. This was the first song Thamarai wrote lyrics for, I believe. I also think it was the first time a lady wrote lyrics in a Tamil movie. This is the only song she’s written; the rest are written by Valee. Venmathiye Nillu -- Roopkumar Rathod My personal favourite. Roopkumar sings it beautifully, and you won’t even realise he doesn’t know tamil, when you hear the song. Pronunciation is good and he sings it with a lot of passion. It’s a sad song that the hero sings, when he is determined to forget the heroine who hates him now after finding him out to be an imposter. It’s awesome and the lyrics are excellent. I could hear this song and Vaseegara all day and not get bored. Verenna Verenna Vaendum -- Unni Krishnan, Harini It’s a pretty good song, with very good lyrics, but it’s not as sensational as Venmathiye or Vaseegara and doesn’t carry the tone set by those two lovely songs. Lyrics and translation of Vaseegara: Just remember that no song sounds great translated, so don’t judge the lyrics by how they sound in English! vaseegara en nenjinikka un pon madiyil thoonginaal pothum Oh charismatic one, for my heart to be happy it’s enough if I sleep in your golden lap. adhae kaNam en kaNNuranga mun jenmangaLin yaekkangaL theerum That very second I will fall asleep and all my previous births’ desires will be fulfilled. naan naesippathum swasippathum un dhayavaal thaanae My loving and breathing are all because of your favour yaengugiraen yaengugiraen un ninaivaal naanae naan... I’m yearning...I’m yearning...in your memory... adai mazhai varum athil nanaivomae Heavy rain will come...and we’ll get wet in it kuLir kaaichchalodu snegam We’ll catch a cold and flu oru porvaikkuL iru thookkam Two slumbers under one blanket kuLu kuLu poigaL solli ennai velvaay By flattering me with lies you will win me adhu therindhum kooda anbae But even though I know it, my darling manam adhaiyaedhaan edhirpaarkkum That is still what my heart will expect engaeyum pogaamal dhinam veettilaeye nee vaendum Without going anywhere, I want you at home everyday sila samayam viLaiyaattaay un aadaikkuLae naan vaendum Sometimes playfully I want to be inside your clothes (vaseegaraa...) dhinamum nee kuLiththathum ennai thaedi Everyday after you take a bath you’ll search for me en selai nuniyaal undhan thalai thudaippaayae adhu kavidhai and with my saree’s pallu you’ll wipe your hair...that’s poetry(meaning romantic) thirudan pole pathungiyae thideer endru pinnaalirundhu ennai nee aNaippaayae adhu kavidhai Like a thief you will hide secretly and suddenly come behind me and hug me...that’s poetry... yaaraenum maNi kaettaal adhai solla kooda theriyaadhe If someone asks me the time I won’t even know how to answer kaathalenum mudiveliyil gadigaara neram kidaiyaadhe In the garden called love there are no clocks or time... (vaseegaraa...) I also translated ’Venmathiye Nillu’ but am not able to add it here, so I’ve put it up in the comments section. I took quite some effort writing the lyrics and translating them, so I really hope you like them!! Do drop in your comments; they’ll be much appreciated. Thankyou.

  
  

• From: Roshan on Wed May 30 7:43:17 2007.

  [Full View]

  Quote:

  Vaseegara -- Bombay Jayashree The MEGA Hit song! Bombay Jayashree renders it beautifully, at the pitch she’s very comfortable in. The flute interluds are very good too. A perfect song, with no errors to pinpoint. A lot of Hindi movie buffs too prefer this tamil rendition to the hindi version. I don’t know what the song means in Hindi but it’s pretty nice in Tamil. Since I expect a lot of you would want to hum along, I’m going to give the lyrics and translation of the song. This was the first song Thamarai wrote lyrics for, I believe. I also think it was the first time a lady wrote lyrics in a Tamil movie. This is the only song she’s written; the rest are written by Valee

  
  
  Thanks Selva - Sariyaathaan irukkumnu nenekirEn. And how come I forgot to mention the short and cute number - iru vizhi unathu.... naan adikadi munu munukkum paadal
  
  
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Wed May 30 9:05:23 2007.

  [Full View]

  Roshan wrote:

  Thanks Selva - Sariyaathaan irukkumnu nenekirEn. And how come I forgot to mention the short and cute number - iru vizhi unathu.... naan adikadi munu munukkum paadal [/tscii]

  
  
  Even I love "Iru vizhi unathu". Good one with ample scope for Abbas.(Actually the Hindi version RHTDM had a diff song which was later on used by HJ for KK - Ondra renda aasaigal).
  
  In the movie, dialogues were good. I donno why GM went to "reduce the length of the dialogues" in his later movies.
  
  
  

• From: Shakthiprabha on Wed May 30 12:19:25 2007.

  [Full View]

  I can watch this movie.... for
  
  MADHAVAN
  
  his INNOCENT EXPRESSIONS
  his GRACE
  his STYLE
  his MACHOISM
  his SMILE
  his MANNERISM
  his LOOKS..
  
  phew
  
  I became madhavan's fan AFTER WATCHING this movie (than alaipaayuthE)
  
  Reema sen- A PERFECT PAIR for madhavan. CHEMISTRY IS AMAZING.
  
  VIVEK- wow
  
  "Vaazha ilai echa thattu tumbler elaam frame pottu maatunga"
  
  THE BEST SCENE is................
  
  with a HEP move... he would remove his jacket and get down on his knee (typical romantic move)
  
  "en per rajesh, naan america illai.. local aminjikarai..."
  
  WOULD STEAL heart, with a every screen prescence.
  
  Song..
  
  "venmathi venmathiyE nillu..."
  
  would linger in any music lover's mind.
  
  All songs are tellably good.
  
  Had it been with any other heroine, I DONT THINK I OWULD HAVE enjoyed this movie TO THIS extent.
  
  REEMA SEN - MADHAVAN
  
  whoa
  
  not to leave out ABBAS... good enough.
  
  "Avalukku unna thaan pudichirukaam... oru 5 days la nee enna win pannitta illai"
  
  "I am a better man than u ...... anyday"
  
  TRUE to his word, HE WOULD BE A BETTER MAN .
  
  

• From: kb on Wed May 30 12:21:49 2007.

  [Full View]

  i love this movie.. everything was perfect..
  
  love,music,comedy
  
  

• From: Hey Ram on Wed May 30 12:31:16 2007.

  [Full View]

  Take out vivek and the music, it was a bad film..Can watch it once..but twice?? no. Scenes were lifted from many films from the golden era.. Can't resist thiking this way.. Nagesh advising him to go to her(Reema's) house as abbas.. reminded me of the same person sending Kamal to Meena's house in Avvai Sanmuhi.. not trying to take away any credit from the film..but it's just me.. I got this feeling.. Awesome lyrics by the lyricists(Vaali or Thamarai?? both vaazhga).. The songs were pushed a step higher due to maddy's presense.. He gave commendable facial expressions for venmathiye venmathiye.. I once saw him on a stage, where he performed the very song..very impressive.. He got stamina.
  
  

• From: joe on Wed May 30 13:42:31 2007.

  [Full View]

  I liked only..
  
  1.Vivek comedy
  2.Songs
  3.Madhavan's cool acting
  
  

• From: Movie Cop on Wed May 30 14:13:24 2007.

  [Full View]

  Minnale was a perfect, feel good, candyfloss entertainer.
  One of those movies that you could watch several times without getting bored. Songs were all top class! GM’s debut movie and not a bad one at that for someone’s first film. Screenplay was hilarious and had the right mix of humor and drama. The comedy track of Vivek & Co. along with Maddy was hilarious. Though the climax was "cinematic" but still was taken with conviction! A movie that gave Madhavan the nick name "Maddy" and more importantly guaranteed him the "Heartthrob" status
  
  My favourite scene of Minnale: Maddy goes out with Reema Sen in a "Auto Rickshaw". Reema Sen will ask Maddy how far is Chicago from Seattle since here relative lives in Chicago. Maddy will tell her that “car-la pona oru mani nerathulle pogalaam… Fligh-la pona... flight take-off agurathuku munaadiye land-agithum…”
  Then Maddy will ask Reema Sen “Unga ooru Autorickshaw-le thaagama iruntha kudika beer can’s ellam illaya”?
  
  A perfect entertainer for all seasons that you could watch with your friends/family!
  
  

• From: crajkumar_be on Wed May 30 14:26:52 2007.

  [Full View]

  Hey Ram wrote:

  Scenes were lifted from many films from the golden era.. Can't resist thiking this way.. Nagesh advising him to go to her(Reema's) house as abbas.. reminded me of the same person sending Kamal to Meena's house in Avvai Sanmuhi..

  
  Avvai Shanmughi-ye original kidayaadhu...
  
  

• From: Movie Cop on Wed May 30 14:28:15 2007.

  [Full View]

  Shakthiprabha wrote:

  I became madhavan's fan AFTER WATCHING this movie (than alaipaayuthE)

  
  SP!
  AP was more serious but entertainment-wise Minnale was better than AP. You could watch Minnale several times w/o getting bored!
  
  

  Shakthiprabha wrote:

  "en per rajesh, naan america illai.. local aminjikarai..."

  
  Typical Madras college pasanga dialogue! The confrontations between Maddy & Abbas were cute!
  
  

• From: Nerd on Wed May 30 15:12:58 2007.

  [Full View]

  My most favorite GM movie
  
  The movie I enjoyed the most in theaters (apart from thalaivar movies, of course) for inexplicable reasons
  
  Maddy was terrific, as SP mentioned reema sen-maddy chemisty was awesome. Superb songs, one of the best ever from harris, superb comedy, racy screenplay and a dull climax is how I would summarize the movie. Terrific entertainer
  
  

• From: Wibha on Wed May 30 19:36:01 2007.

  [Full View]

  Shakthiprabha wrote:

  I can watch this movie.... for MADHAVAN his INNOCENT EXPRESSIONS his GRACE his STYLE his MACHOISM his SMILE his MANNERISM his LOOKS.. .

  
  
  he's too cute........... i've watched this movie 30 times
  
  they used to put this on Raj tv regularly and i used to watch it
  
  REEMA sen
  
  HJ- all songs were awesome except vaseegara........... venmathi venmathi
  
  ABBAS and MADDY clashes
  
  selva anna
  
  

• From: kannannn on Wed May 30 19:39:31 2007.

  [Full View]

  Hey Ram wrote:

  Take out vivek and the music, it was a bad film..

  
  Vivek was very good. "Vandhuttangaya map poda"..
  
  

• From: Kollywoodfan on Wed May 30 19:52:33 2007.

  [Full View]

  Nerd wrote:

  My most favorite GM movie The movie I enjoyed the most in theaters (apart from thalaivar movies, of course) for inexplicable reasons Maddy was terrific, as SP mentioned reema sen-maddy chemisty was awesome. Superb songs, one of the best ever from harris, superb comedy, racy screenplay and a dull climax is how I would summarize the movie. Terrific entertainer

  
  
  Same here but barring the dragging church sequence, I thought that climax in the airport was quite exhilirating! Maddy and Reema was so cute and Vivek was in his BEST form! Essentially a very simple story but the presentation was refreshing! The perfect example of a memorable, romantic comedy
  
  

• From: littlemaster1982 on Wed May 30 20:34:27 2007.

  [Full View]

  Wibha wrote:

  Shakthiprabha wrote: I can watch this movie.... for MADHAVAN his INNOCENT EXPRESSIONS his GRACE his STYLE his MACHOISM his SMILE his MANNERISM his LOOKS.. . he's too cute........... i've watched this movie 30 times they used to put this on Raj tv regularly and i used to watch it REEMA sen HJ- all songs were awesome except vaseegara........... venmathi venmathi ABBAS and MADDY clashes selva anna

  
  
  
  
  

• From: m_23_bayarea on Wed May 30 22:38:49 2007.

  [Full View]

  Awesome movie! Very happy and entertaining movie... Had a very nice story, beautiful screenplay, awesome songs, excellent comedy, and above all, wonderful performances from Maddy, Reema Sen, and Vivek! Gowtham and Harris had a kick-ass debut with this movie! Personally for me, the last movie that I saw with my friends before leaving India, very close to my heart, cos it always kindles all kinds of memories in me!
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Mon Jun 4 8:50:31 2007.

  [Full View]

  MOUNA RAAGAM
  
  
  A movie review by Balaji Balasubramaniam
  Cast: Mohan, Revathi, Karthik, V.K.Ramaswamy
  Music: Ilaiyaraja
  Direction: Manirathnam
  
  
  
  Nowadays we see new directors enter the film world with huge first efforts only to stumble on their subsequent offerings. Not so with Manirathnam. Neither Pagal Nilavu nor Idhayakoyil gave us a hint as to what was coming next from him. While both those were good films, they were hardly what one would call classics. It was Mouna Raagam that made us sit up and take notice of him as a director. It is a beautiful film with memorable characters, good performances, subtle sentiments, great photography and an amazing soundtrack. Almost every frame of the movie oozes with class and the movie features several ideas that have since become trademark Manirathnam touches but were a breath of fresh air back when the movie was released in 1986.
  
  Divya(Revathi) is a playful girl who is unwillingly pushed into marriage with Chandrakumar(Mohan), a personal manager in Delhi. Her dissatisfaction with the marriage is painfully obvious as she hurts him with every word and action and Chandrakumar's accomodating character has no effect on her. A divorce is what she asks for as her first gift after the wedding! When pressed for a reason for her behavious, she reveals to him her brief romance with Manohar(Karthik) that ended in tragedy. Seeing no change in her, Chandrakumar offers her the divorce papers but the court stipulates that a couple must have lived together for atleast a year before the divorce can be given. So they decide to stay together as husband and wife until they can finalise the divorce.
  
  If there is one segment in Mouna Raagam that never fails to charm, it is Revathi's flashback that introduces Karthik. While almost every romantic hero in Manirathnam's films since then has had shades of Karthik's Manohar, the character here captivates us even more since it is fresh and original. His "Mr. Chandramouli routine" and his antics in the bus and the library are cute and charming. The role made Karthik probably the first Tamil heartthrob since Kamalhassan and laid the foundation for his long stay in Kodambakkam.
  
  The other two main characters in the movie are no less endearing. Revathi's Divya is the perfect college girl, scared of marriage with someone unknown and unable to forget her past love. Her gradual transformation after the marriage and her aching for acceptance from Mohan are believable. Mohan is the perfect contrast to Karthik as the calm and patient husband who is ready to give Divya the leeway she needs to come to grips with the marriage. His comments about not caring about her past and his handling of her request for divorce are softly done. Its no wonder that every girl who saw Mouna Raagam when it was released came out wishing for a boyfriend like Karthik and a husband like Mohan!
  
  The movie doesn't feature the abrupt dialogs that Manirathnam has since become famous for and instead, has several sharp lines that serve to convey the emotions of the characters clearly. Revathi's scathing comments bring out her undisguised hatred of married life and Mohan uttering the same lines to her later, effectively makes her realise the enormity of the lines and his feelings when she uttered them. In the same way, Karthik's dialogs(like his comment about the others at the library) convey his fun-loving nature. Revathi's father is a nice mixture of sternness and love. His explanation of his situation to Revathi when she says 'no' to the wedding and his later request to Mohan to keep her happy are moving.
  
  Comedy has never been Manirathnam's strongpoint but his brief forays into it here are much better here than the long, vulgar comedy tracks in Agni Natchathiram and Idhayathai Thirudaathey. Revathi teaching the Sardarji the wrong tamil phrases initially seems mean-spirited but V.K.Ramaswamy's bafflement when he hears them raise some laughs. There is also a sense of closure and a moment of poignancy when the Sardarji responds using the same wrong phrase after Revathi thanks him for his help.
  
  Mohan underplays his role well to portray the affectionate husband. Revathi is the star of the show whether she is laughing at Karthik's antics or crying over Mohan's ignoring her. She looks very pretty and her face easily conveys all the emotions the character goes through. Easily one of the best performances of the talented actress' career. Karthik was starting his second innings after a long gap and quite a comeback it turned out to be. He looks handsome and his dialog delivery suits the playful nature of the character well. Ilaiyaraja continued his habit of providing Manirathnam with chartbusting numbers. Chinna Chinna... gets my vote for one of the best combinations of song and picturisation in tamil cinema. The colorful dresses, the simple dance steps and the photography aid the already catchy song. The melodious Nilaave Vaa... is soulfully rendered by SPB as is Panivizhum Iravu.... Meaningful lyrics are the strength of Mandram Vandha.... P.C.Sriram was the other behind-the-scenes artist whose work was noticed in Mouna Raagam. The lights and soft shadows in the indoor scenes are as beautiful as the shots of the Taj Mahal in the evening light.
  
  Mouna Raagam stands as the one of the best melodies in tamil cinema.
  
  
  
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Mon Jun 4 9:04:02 2007.

  [Full View]

  BELATED BIRTHDAY WISHES TO
  ISAI GYANI "ILAYARAJA"
  
  Sir,
  Please do continue, in mesmerizing us with your musical breeze !
  
  
  BELATED BIRTHDAY WISHES TO
  MANI RATHNAM
  
  Sir,
  Please do continue in providing many more movies that can make every TN person feel proud whenever he moves out of TN
  
  
  
  MANY MORE HAPPY RETURNS OF THE DAY TO
  
  Dr. S.P Bala Subramanian
  
  Sir,
  Please continue to rule the hearts of people like me and several other TN people with your wonderful voice !
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Mon Jun 4 9:05:17 2007.

  [Full View]

  http://manismagic.iespana.es/mouna.htm
  
  Very Good Article
  
  

• From: raaja_rasigan on Mon Jun 4 9:33:16 2007.

  [Full View]

  Best part of Mounaragam:
  
  Iaignani
  
  Vaali's lyrics
  
  karthik & Mohan ...... both should be equally credited....
  
  karthik for over acting but still lovable
  
  Mohan for under acting
  
  

• From: Shakthiprabha on Mon Jun 4 9:38:47 2007.

  [Full View]

  Lovely movie, which is almost akin to reality.
  Realistic storyline and touch.
  
  IMO, karthik did not over act, BUT JUST did a STEAL SHOW.
  
  WOULD write more later ...
  
  

• From: Roshan on Mon Jun 4 9:38:58 2007.

  [Full View]

  selvakumar wrote:

  MANY MORE HAPPY RETURNS OF THE DAY TO Dr. S.P Bala Subramanian Sir, Please continue to rule the hearts of people like me and several other TN people with your wonderful voice !

  
  
  
  Thanks Selva for this I was thinking of posting my wishes to SPB in the film section but didnt know where to post it. Thanks once again
  
  Many happy returns to the LEGEND and a GREAT HUMAN BEING - SPB Sir !!! May the Almighty bless you with more and more success, happiness and good health
  
  

• From: raaja_rasigan on Mon Jun 4 9:39:28 2007.

  [Full View]

  The questions which come to my mind whenever i c the film:
  
  1. A college girl... doesn't speak proper english ... revathy talking to sardharji in delhi
  
  2. The climax.... when revathy goes , saying that she is not interested in divorce.... Mohan goes in search of her in the railway station..... even if she goes, he could simply call his in laws & explain them the situation...... maybe the climax is shot in that way for making the viewers feel for their union
  
  

• From: Shakthiprabha on Mon Jun 4 9:42:53 2007.

  [Full View]

  raaja rasigan,
  
  there is one more such dumb question from my mind...
  
  Mohan would be hurt and revathy would desperately try to admit him at hosp
  
  who is he? woh kaun hai... how is he related etc would be asked.
  
  SHE WOULD NOT ANSWER ALL THOSE in any sensible english or hindi sentences. ... but PULL OUT HER THAALI AND SAY..
  
  "en purushan!!!!"
  
  
  
  WHAT A PATHETIC TRY to create a SENTI HUS-WIFE TOUCH
  
  

• From: Nerd on Mon Jun 4 9:44:24 2007.

  [Full View]

  raaja_rasigan wrote:

  The questions which come to my mind whenever i c the film: 1. A college girl... doesn't speak proper english ... revathy talking to sardharji in delhi That is because, the sardarji cant speak english. Remember in another scene in the hospital, revathi speaks proper english 2. The climax.... when revathy goes , saying that she is not interested in divorce.... Mohan goes in search of her in the railway station..... even if she goes, he could simply call his in laws & explain them the situation...... maybe the climax is shot in that way for making the viewers feel for their union Gaaaawd.. After almost a year, mohan comes to know that revathi has actually started loving him. Will he freaking wait for another week to be with her

  
  
  One of the best thamizh movies ever made, my most favorite MR movie. Will write more later!
  
  

• From: MazhaiKuruvi on Mon Jun 4 9:44:51 2007.

  [Full View]

  selvakumar wrote:

  BELATED BIRTHDAY WISHES TO MANI RATHNAM Heartfelt condolences to Manirathnam on his recent loss. May God give you and your family the strength and the healing.

  
  

• From: Shakthiprabha on Mon Jun 4 9:44:59 2007.

  [Full View]

  raaja_rasigan wrote:

  2. The climax.... when revathy goes , saying that she is not interested in divorce.... Mohan goes in search of her in the railway station..... even if she goes, he could simply call his in laws & explain them the situation...... maybe the climax is shot in that way for making the viewers feel for their union

  
  
  A very valid question, WHICH STRIKES ME in almost EVERY movie, which has railway or airport climax!
  
  what the hell!! cant u ring up or talk to them once they reach and LET THEM KNOW U STILL CARE OR LOVE THEM and get them back in NEXT TRAIN.........
  
  
  
  tamizh movie (indian movie) directors!!!!!!!!!!!!!
  
  
  
  

• From: crajkumar_be on Mon Jun 4 9:50:12 2007.

  [Full View]

  MazhaiKuruvi wrote:

  Heartfelt condolences to Manirathnam on his recent loss. May God give you and your family the strength and the healing.

  
  ?????
  
  

• From: MazhaiKuruvi on Mon Jun 4 9:55:07 2007.

  [Full View]

  raaja_rasigan wrote:

  The questions which come to my mind whenever i c the film: 1. A college girl... doesn't speak proper english ... revathy talking to sardharji in delhi

  
  
  Are you really surprised by this?? This is very common in many colleges across India. It is in a way the failure of our system of education that produces such graduates. Most of them can write very well, but can hardly speak proper English.
  
  

• From: MazhaiKuruvi on Mon Jun 4 9:57:55 2007.

  [Full View]

  crajkumar_be wrote:

  MazhaiKuruvi wrote: Heartfelt condolences to Manirathnam on his recent loss. May God give you and your family the strength and the healing. ?????

  
  
  He lost his brother in a freak accident a week or 2 ago, I think he slipped and fell down a cliff while visiting somewhere up north with his family.
  
  

• From: raaja_rasigan on Mon Jun 4 10:00:39 2007.

  [Full View]

  MazhaiKuruvi wrote:

  raaja_rasigan wrote: The questions which come to my mind whenever i c the film: 1. A college girl... doesn't speak proper english ... revathy talking to sardharji in delhi Are you really surprised by this?? This is very common in many colleges across India. It is in a way the failure of our system of education that produces such graduates. Most of them can write very well, but can hardly speak proper English.

  
  
  u r point may be true.. but u all trying to justify bcoz the director is Maniratnam...... even though i too like him more than many others...
  
  

• From: shobana_in on Mon Jun 4 10:01:22 2007.

  [Full View]

  raaja_rasigan
  
  do u think all college girls speak proper english in india?
  
  

• From: Murali Srinivas on Mon Jun 4 10:03:20 2007.

  [Full View]

  As rightly pointed out MR came to be recogonised with this MR. Everybody was good. PC's name in titles started to get the applause after this movie. Other than the famous Yamuna riverside -Taj Mahal rear side, the initial scenes like rain and the camera capturing the bucket full of water thrown by Revathi from the terrace over his brother were all superb.
  
  Dialogues were sharp.
  
  VKR: Un Pondatti mudhal mudhale enna ketta? Athai Vangi koduthiya?
  
  Mohan: Vaangi Kodukka Poren
  
  VKR: Ennathu?
  
  Mohan: Divorce.
  
  Effect would be tremendous.
  
  Regards
  
  

• From: crajkumar_be on Mon Jun 4 10:04:22 2007.

  [Full View]

  MazhaiKuruvi wrote:

  He lost his brother in a freak accident a week or 2 ago, I think he slipped and fell down a cliff while visiting somewhere up north with his family.

  
  Oh
  
  

• From: shobana_in on Mon Jun 4 10:04:39 2007.

  [Full View]

  vkr rocked
  
  

• From: raaja_rasigan on Mon Jun 4 10:06:39 2007.

  [Full View]

  Ilayaraaja's BGM.....
  
  he used 2 different kinds of music... one for karthik... fast beats as per his character &
  
  main theme music...
  
  No need to say about the songs...... beautiful.....
  kaadhugalai thunburuthaadha padalgal......
  endrum alukkadha, azhiyaadha padalgal
  
  

• From: shobana_in on Mon Jun 4 10:09:18 2007.

  [Full View]

  there is a flute piece in panivizhum iravu....
  
  wow...
  
  

• From: raaja_rasigan on Mon Jun 4 10:16:22 2007.

  [Full View]

  one more powerful dialogue:
  
  First night for Mohan - Revathy:
  
  Revathy is hesitant to go inside.
  
  Her mother says something.
  
  Revathy replies, " idhuva naalu naalaikku munnadi ippadi enna anupi veppiya" (something like this)
  
  ------------------------------------------------------------
  
  another nice one:
  
  When Mohan says that, he too was not interested in the marriage... but he changed his mind when revathy said the same thing to him
  
  

• From: crajkumar_be on Mon Jun 4 10:23:12 2007.

  [Full View]

  An eminently watchable film which never bores you.
  
  One of Ilaiyaraaja's very best and the BGM is a cult, a legend
  
  The Karthik-Revathy romance is one of the memorable (there are very few realistic romances in Tamil anyway) ones in Tamil - before the cliches started
  
  V.K Ramasamy rocked as usual
  
  Some of the dialogues were memorable, like the ones between Revathy and her mom in the penn paarkum padalam scene
  
  While its true that many college-goers aren't fluent in English, its difficult to believe Revathy can't put together a simple sentence in English given her educational and social background (Econometrics, no less!).
  A woman who can't speak English for nuts spends time reading in a city library? Well, she might have been reading a Tamil book, or reading != speaking etc, one can counter but that doesn't sound convincing.
  Similar to Velu Naicker not knowing a word of Hindi after living most of his life in Mumbai - that was even more atrocious.
  Forget English, the way she looks at the buildings in Delhi you might mistake her for Kovai Sarala in singappooor...
  
  Another thing i couldn't quite get was the perception of two different characters in Revathy. She has lost her lover recently in front of her eyes and yet you don't even remotely see the sense of loss or pain in her before the flashback. OK, she has been putting on a "front " to really hide her feelings but that looked like a little contrived way to set the audience up for the twist in the flashback.
  A resigned facade, or even a cold exterior would have been more natural rather than a free-spirited singing-and-dancing-in-the-rain look.
  
  Cribs apart, this was a very good entertainer from a mainstream magician Mani Sir.
  
  P.S:
  Nerd,
  I may be wrong about Revathy not speaking a sentence in English but when does she speak English in the hospital? Don't recollect as its been a while since i watched the film.
  
  

• From: Shakthiprabha on Mon Jun 4 10:26:55 2007.

  [Full View]

  raaja_rasigan wrote:

  one more powerful dialogue: First night for Mohan - Revathy: Revathy is hesitant to go inside. Her mother says something. Revathy replies, " idhuva naalu naalaikku munnadi ippadi enna anupi veppiya" (something like this)

  
  
  "epdimma epdi!...
  
  rendu naalaikku munnadi ipdi evan koodavavathu anupiruppiya!"
  
  ONE OF THE MOST REVOLUTIONARY and sensible dialogue in tamizh cinema.
  
  

• From: crajkumar_be on Mon Jun 4 10:28:49 2007.

  [Full View]

  Shakthiprabha wrote:

  "epdimma epdi!... rendu naalaikku munnadi ipdi evan koodavavathu anupiruppiya!" ONE OF THE MOST REVOLUTIONARY and sensible dialogue in tamizh cinema.

  
  Absolutely
  
  

• From: Shakthiprabha on Mon Jun 4 10:29:52 2007.

  [Full View]

  some nice romantic dialogues can never slip one's mind.
  
  __
  
  revathy: neeya?
  
  karthik: aamam.
  
  revathy: watchman partha kazhutha pidichu veliya thalliduvaan.
  
  karthik: mudiyavE mudiyathu... muLLangi bathai mathiri sOLaiya 10 rubai kuduthu vanthirukken
  
  revathy: enna venum
  
  karthik: pesanam
  
  revathy: elaarum parka poraanga
  
  Karthik : mataanga... elaaraiyum book padikka sollirukken
  
  __
  
  so interestingly naughty!!
  
  

• From: Shakthiprabha on Mon Jun 4 10:32:16 2007.

  [Full View]

  karthik: no kolai koLLai onnly thiruttu.
  
  revathy: would give an innocent yet naughty glance
  
  karthik: enna thirudinannu kekkanam
  
  revathy: enna thirudina
  
  karthik: un ithayathai
  
  revathy: kewl look
  
  karthik: vetkam thaangaamal thanks endraal
  
  revathy : thanks ... coffee kku
  
  __
  
  Routine dialogue... very usual one, BUT THE EXPRESSIONS AND the way ITS PASSED ON BETWEEN the duo makes it special to watch
  
  

• From: crajkumar_be on Mon Jun 4 10:32:26 2007.

  [Full View]

  "4 mani, 4 o clock..4 mani, 4 o clock.. akka kettukunga, thangachi kettukkunga"
  
  

• From: Shakthiprabha on Mon Jun 4 10:34:53 2007.

  [Full View]

  She would be so pissed off, with his dare devil approach... he would casually approach her...
  
  ___
  
  "kadala sappadariya"
  
  enna inimE parkka varaatha nnu sollitu poga thaan vanthen.
  
  unakku bayam!
  
  .... ('what the hell' kinda look from her)
  
  ennai parthu en style en personality parthu bayam!!
  
  illai
  
  appo prove pannu
  
  epdi
  
  en kooda coffee sapdu
  
  __
  
  those days these dialogues were too famous amidst high school and coll girls / guys
  
  

• From: kannannn on Mon Jun 4 10:36:03 2007.

  [Full View]

  One of my two favourite Mani movies, the other being Nayagan. The dialogues were crisp and just right before becoming ridiculously short in later movies.
  
  What can I say about the BGM? Piano ivvalavu nalla use panna inoruthan porandhu varanum. And there is something about trumpets and IR ('Mandram vandha' in this movie).
  
  CR, if I am right, Revathi does speak English in the hospital: "My husband is bleeding in the car. He is dying.."
  
  But I do agree that the flashback came without warning. In a way it is cheating the viewers.
  
  

• From: raaja_rasigan on Mon Jun 4 10:36:10 2007.

  [Full View]

  Shakthiprabha wrote:

  karthik: no kolai koLLai onnly thiruttu. revathy: would give an innocent yet naughty glance karthik: enna thirudinannu kekkanam revathy: enna thirudina karthik: un ithayathai revathy: kewl look karthik: vetkam thaangaamal thanks endraal revathy : thanks ... coffee kku __ Routine dialogue... very usual one, BUT THE EXPRESSIONS AND the way ITS PASSED ON BETWEEN the duo makes it special to watch

  
  
  i can't recall the dialogues exactly...... but the dialogues in this movie played a big part...... still it is fresh to hear
  
  karthik inside the bus: namma vandidhaan nandhi maadhiri munnadi nikkudhe
  
  

• From: crajkumar_be on Mon Jun 4 10:44:37 2007.

  [Full View]

  kannannn wrote:

  CR, if I am right, Revathi does speak English in the hospital: "My husband is bleeding in the car. He is dying.."

  
  Oh, then i stand corrected and Nerd's explanation makes sense and has more credence (Sardarji doesn't know English)
  
  

  kannannn wrote:

  What can I say about the BGM? Piano ivvalavu nalla use panna inoruthan porandhu varanum. And there is something about trumpets and IR ('Mandram vandha' in this movie).

  
  Right from the title, the BGM just freakin flows. What perfect synergy between the director and music director!
  
  Other notable BGMs'
  - The veena/sitar, tabla bit in the penn paarkum padalam
  - The first fight. Starts with a modern beat and then breaks into latino strumming joined by trumpets/horns(?)
  - Of course, the Karthik-Revathy immortal track and the variations of it. Piano piece, then the slow paced violin version with acoustic drums
  - the Chase: Karthik escaping from the Jeep. IR literally brings out the tension with the violin
  - The Revathy-Mohan matchups. Veena and tabla again
  
  Songs:
  Every song is a classic.
  My favorite is a toss up between "Mandram Vandha" and "Chinna chinna". One can do a thesis on Ilaiyaraaja's usage of the bass guitar (like none less than SPB would testify) and "Chinna Chinna" would be a good place to start with.
  Very few people (in the world) have used bass as a counterpoint to the main melody in the way IR does. Its typical in jazz but in IR's songs its something different and at a different level. The pallavi starts with the bass lines played on a high note rather than as a rhythm backing up the main melody
  
  

• From: joe on Mon Jun 4 10:45:25 2007.

  [Full View]

  Poda Dai Madaya
  
  

• From: kannannn on Mon Jun 4 11:20:41 2007.

  [Full View]

  crajkumar_be wrote:

  Right from the title, the BGM just freakin flows. What perfect synergy between the director and music director! Other notable BGMs' - The veena/sitar, tabla bit in the penn paarkum padalam - The first fight. Starts with a modern beat and then breaks into latino strumming joined by trumpets/horns(?) - Of course, the Karthik-Revathy immortal track and the variations of it. Piano piece, then the slow paced violin version with acoustic drums - the Chase: Karthik escaping from the Jeep. IR literally brings out the tension with the violin - The Revathy-Mohan matchups. Veena and tabla again

  
  Thanks for reminding . Must watch the movie again.
  
  

  crajkumar_be wrote:

  Songs: Every song is a classic. My favorite is a toss up between "Mandram Vandha" and "Chinna chinna". One can do a thesis on Ilaiyaraaja's usage of the bass guitar (like none less than SPB would testify) and "Chinna Chinna" would be a good place to start with. Very few people (in the world) have used bass as a counterpoint to the main melody in the way IR does. Its typical in jazz but in IR's songs its something different and at a different level. The pallavi starts with the bass lines played on a high note rather than as a rhythm backing up the main melody

  
  Yes, I too remember SPB prasing IR's Guitar talents . Chinna Chinna also has great interludes - flute giving way to violin . My least favourite is "Nilave Vaa.."
  
  

• From: Nerd on Mon Jun 4 11:24:53 2007.

  [Full View]

  If I am not wrong, she does speak some english before showing her thaali to the hospital receptionist
  
  And yeh the ohO mEgam vanthathO and the first scene of the movie dint blend with the story at all. Actually thats the only complaint I have about the movie!
  
  

• From: Roshan on Mon Jun 4 11:41:26 2007.

  [Full View]

  Shakthiprabha wrote:

  raaja_rasigan wrote: one more powerful dialogue: First night for Mohan - Revathy: Revathy is hesitant to go inside. Her mother says something. Revathy replies, " idhuva naalu naalaikku munnadi ippadi enna anupi veppiya" (something like this) "epdimma epdi!... rendu naalaikku munnadi ipdi evan koodavavathu anupiruppiya!" ONE OF THE MOST REVOLUTIONARY and sensible dialogue in tamizh cinema.

  
  
  
  
  

• From: swathy on Mon Jun 4 11:41:41 2007.

  [Full View]

  When I watched the movie for the first time, I dunno the meaning of divorce.
  
  It was boring for me , the only scene I enjoyed was poda madaya scene.
  
  Beautiful movie strongly supported by IR.
  
  recently it was remade in kannada with shivarajkumar playing karthik's role.
  
  

• From: littlemaster1982 on Mon Jun 4 11:43:17 2007.

  [Full View]

  swathy wrote:

  When I watched the movie for the first time, I dunno the meaning of divorce. It was boring for me , the only scene I enjoyed was poda madaya scene. Beautiful movie strongly supported by IR. recently it was remade in kannada with shivarajkumar playing karthik's role.

  
  
  
  
  

• From: crajkumar_be on Mon Jun 4 11:44:06 2007.

  [Full View]

  swathy wrote:

  recently it was remade in kannada with shivarajkumar playing karthik's role.

  
  
  
  

• From: kannannn on Mon Jun 4 11:47:06 2007.

  [Full View]

  swathy wrote:

  When I watched the movie for the first time, I dunno the meaning of divorce. It was boring for me , the only scene I enjoyed was poda madaya scene. Beautiful movie strongly supported by IR. recently it was remade in kannada with shivarajkumar playing karthik's role.

  
  Idhe velaiya pochu. They are on a crusade to massacre good movies. Recently they also remade Devar Magan with Upendra. Of all people, Shivrajkumar
  
  

• From: joe on Mon Jun 4 11:50:43 2007.

  [Full View]

  kannannn wrote:

  Recently they also remade Devar Magan with Upendra.

  
  
  who did NT's role?
  
  

• From: littlemaster1982 on Mon Jun 4 11:52:52 2007.

  [Full View]

  Old Kannada Hero MP Ambarish
  
  

• From: joe on Mon Jun 4 11:56:28 2007.

  [Full View]

  littlemaster1982 wrote:

  Old Kannada Hero MP Ambarish

  
  
  
  
  Devar magan -lollu saba episode maathiri irunthirukkum..illa?
  
  

• From: littlemaster1982 on Mon Jun 4 11:57:51 2007.

  [Full View]

  <digr>
  
  athai vida mosam-nu kelvipatten
  
  <end. digr>
  
  
  
  

• From: rocketboy on Mon Jun 4 12:08:20 2007.

  [Full View]

  littlemaster1982 wrote:

  Old Kannada Hero MP Ambarish

  
  
  <dig>
  
  Nothing to do with the movie. But this guy is a pakka #$%@# He was the one of those guys who raked up the pent up emotions of Kannadigas against Tamils .
  <sorry for the digression>
  
  

• From: MuratuKaalai on Mon Jun 4 12:09:13 2007.

  [Full View]

  rocketboy wrote:

  littlemaster1982 wrote: Old Kannada Hero MP Ambarish <dig> Nothing to do with the movie. But this guy is a pakka 'pyar -dhin- jao-gendh'. He was the one of those guys who raked up the pent up emotions of Kannadigas against Tamils . Mavanae nee vaadi TNukku unakku irukku di <sorry for the digression>

  
  
  paper rocket vidura boy summa kida veena racism n linguism pesadha
  
  

• From: joe on Mon Jun 4 12:13:33 2007.

  [Full View]

  Guys,
  Lets end digression and back to Mouna ragam.
  
  

• From: Roshan on Mon Jun 4 12:19:42 2007.

  [Full View]

  One of my most favourite MR movies ( other favourites are Nayagan, Iruvar and Kannthil Muthamittaal).
  
  Eventhough Karthik' role had been a highly acclaimed one and the sequences of Karthik were quite bubbly, energetic, fun and entertaining - for me it was Mohan who led the show right till the end. One of the very few - best underplayed roles ever While giving the credit to MR for the splendid characterisation and Mohan for his career best performance - we shouldnt forget - S N Surendhar - the dubbing artist. His voice modulation was the key factor in bring in all that life to that role.
  
  Mohan to Revathy - kozhantha poRakkumpOthu yEn theriyumA azhuthu... yEnnaa athukku ellAmE puthusu.. intha ulagam, suththi ullavanga ...etc etc... SN Surendhar was the man there - and in many other scenes too.
  
  
  
  

  CR wrote:

  ]The Karthik-Revathy romance is one of the memorable (there are very few realistic romances in Tamil anyway) ones in Tamil - before the cliches started

  
  
  It was nice and realistic but Revathy suddenly agreeing for a register marriage - wasnt that realistic to me. Konjam childish and meethi cinemaathanam.
  
  
  

  Quote:

  Some of the dialogues were memorable, like the ones between Revathy and her mom in the penn paarkum padalam scene

  
  
  Yeah in addition most of the dialogues between Mohan and Revathy. Eg: the one I have quoted earlier and when Mohan speaks out after listening to Revathy's flashback.
  
  
  

  Quote:

  While its true that many college-goers aren't fluent in English, its difficult to believe Revathy can't put together a simple sentence in English given her educational and social background (Econometrics, no less!). A woman who can't speak English for nuts spends time reading in a city library? Well, she might have been reading a Tamil book, or reading != speaking etc, one can counter but that doesn't sound convincing.

  
  
  Wonder why this 'English Speaking' became an issue here. It was not at all noticeable in the film and it was quite natural the way she speaks with Sardharji. How ever much one is fluent - it's not the case when you speak with a person who doesnt know the language at all. MR made it realistic. That's all.
  
  And as Nerd mentioned - at the hospital she first speaks in English but quite naturally the Delhi hospital staff will respond in Hindhi. Only then she pulls out her Thali out of sheer frustration. The scene also indicates that Revathi had accepted Mohan as her husband without knowing herself.
  
  
  

  Quote:

  Another thing i couldn't quite get was the perception of two different characters in Revathy. She has lost her lover recently in front of her eyes and yet you don't even remotely see the sense of loss or pain in her before the flashback. OK, she has been putting on a "front " to really hide her feelings but that looked like a little contrived way to set the audience up for the twist in the flashback. A resigned facade, or even a cold exterior would have been more natural rather than a free-spirited singing-and-dancing-in-the-rain look.

  
  
  
  I do agree completely ! Athu konjam uruthalaavE irukkum kadaisi vara. But it was 1000 times better compared to what Priyadarshan did with Trisha's character in 'lesA lesA"
  
  

• From: Roshan on Mon Jun 4 12:29:33 2007.

  [Full View]

  >> Dig <<
  
  YaaruppA antha Sivrajkumar ? Unga emotions ellaam pArthA - I consider myself lucky not knowing him >> dig <<
  
  

• From: shobana_in on Mon Jun 4 12:39:08 2007.

  [Full View]

  Roshan wrote:

  >> Dig << YaaruppA antha Sivrajkumar ? Unga emotions ellaam pArthA - I consider myself lucky not knowing him >> dig <<

  
  
  there is a dialogue in mouna ragam.
  
  karthik would say something like revathi is fearing that she would fall for his charm and smartness.
  
  karthik sonna OK......sivaraj kumar
  
  raj kumar payyanthan andha sivaraj kumar.
  
  avaru "amarkalam" padathayum remake pannirukaru.
  
  

• From: Roshan on Mon Jun 4 12:42:36 2007.

  [Full View]

  crajkumar_be wrote:

  Right from the title, the BGM just freakin flows. What perfect synergy between the director and music director! Other notable BGMs' - The veena/sitar, tabla bit in the penn paarkum padalam - The first fight. Starts with a modern beat and then breaks into latino strumming joined by trumpets/horns(?) - Of course, the Karthik-Revathy immortal track and the variations of it. Piano piece, then the slow paced violin version with acoustic drums - the Chase: Karthik escaping from the Jeep. IR literally brings out the tension with the violin - The Revathy-Mohan matchups. Veena and tabla again

  
  
  Pinnureenga CR It's really amazing to see how you pay so much attention to the BGM score ithukkAgavE marupadiyum oru thadava padatha pAkanumpOla irukku
  
  

  Quote:

  Songs: Every song is a classic. My favorite is a toss up between "Mandram Vandha" and "Chinna chinna". One can do a thesis on Ilaiyaraaja's usage of the bass guitar (like none less than SPB would testify) and "Chinna Chinna" would be a good place to start with.

  
  
  Same here Infact the moment Selva changed the title - I first thought of writing about the songs but then again I couldnt infer as to what is my most favourite between these two Panivizhum iravu is also lovely
  
  
  

  Quote:

  Very few people (in the world) have used bass as a counterpoint to the main melody in the way IR does. Its typical in jazz but in IR's songs its something different and at a different level. The pallavi starts with the bass lines played on a high note rather than as a rhythm backing up the main melody

  
  
  Marupadiyum pinnureenga I am curious.. have you learned music CR?
  
  

• From: Roshan on Mon Jun 4 12:44:40 2007.

  [Full View]

  shobana_in wrote:

  . avaru "amarkalam" padathayum remake pannirukaru.

  
  
  satham illAtha thanimai kEttEn - paatta enna paNNaanga ?
  
  

• From: raaja_rasigan on Mon Jun 4 12:51:13 2007.

  [Full View]

  Roshan wrote:

  shobana_in wrote: . avaru "amarkalam" padathayum remake pannirukaru. satham illAtha thanimai kEttEn - paatta enna paNNaanga ?

  
  
  satham illama manasukulla padittanga
  
  

• From: Roshan on Mon Jun 4 12:57:28 2007.

  [Full View]

  ok ok let us not digress.. back to Mouna Ragam
  
  

• From: rajeshkrv on Mon Jun 4 18:41:20 2007.

  [Full View]

  wonderful movie
  Kudos to MR to make mohan act with less dialouges(ofcourse no mike)
  
  karthik's cameo was well appreciated and he did full justice to the angry-charming lover boy
  
  Mani-Ir team was awesome
  
  

• From: Wibha on Mon Jun 4 19:45:01 2007.

  [Full View]

  wow i love this movie
  
  karthik makes the movie his attitude and dialogue
  
  mohan err
  
  REVATHI
  
  songs
  
  a good entertainment
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Tue Jun 5 1:21:32 2007.

  [Full View]

  crajkumar_be wrote:

  swathy wrote: recently it was remade in kannada with shivarajkumar playing karthik's role.

  
  
  I am one of those unlucky chaps who saw the Kannada remake of this movie when all the tamil channels were blocked here and when I was locked in my PG room !
  Vera onnumae panna mudiyaama paartha padam. Sivarajkumar in Karthik role (It was an inch by inch remake though)
  
  I can only explain what I felt with a single dialogue
  
  Sivarajkumar to Revathy's character : "unakku payam.. ennoda azhagu ( ) smartness personality ya paarthu enga enna kaathalichiduviyonnu payam" (kannada version I donno. I hope many won't expect that here)
  
  
  Plus - remake of Amarkalam (Again inch by inch remake) !
  
  

• From: Roshan on Tue Jun 5 1:32:57 2007.

  [Full View]

  selvakumar wrote:

  Plus - remake of Amarkalam (Again inch by inch remake) !

  
  
  Selva,
  
  Satham illAthan thanimai - song and song sequence eppadi pannAnga - atha mattum konjam sollidunga
  
  

• From: ajithfederer on Tue Jun 5 1:33:53 2007.

  [Full View]

  enak erkanavae ingae thookam varalai
  

  Roshan wrote:

  selvakumar wrote: Plus - remake of Amarkalam (Again inch by inch remake) ! Selva, Satham illAthan thanimai - song and song sequence eppadi pannAnga - atha mattum konjam sollidunga

  
  

• From: selvakumar on Tue Jun 5 1:37:10 2007.

  [Full View]

  Roshan wrote:

  Selva, Satham illAthan thanimai - song and song sequence eppadi pannAnga - atha mattum konjam sollidunga

  
  
  I didn't see that song. I actually tried my level best to skip this movie during a few scenes. So, missed few parts. I saw 50% and less said is better Whatever I saw was 100% DITTO of the original !
  
  

• From: joe on Tue Jun 5 1:53:25 2007.

  [Full View]

  Whenever somebody ask me "What do you think Mani's best movie?' ,I always have a dialama between Nayagan and MounaRagam.
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Tue Jun 5 1:59:43 2007.

  [Full View]

  joe wrote:

  Whenever somebody ask me "What do you think Mani's best movie?' ,I always have a dialama between Nayagan and MounaRagam.

  
  
  
  I love "Idayathai Thirudaathey" a lot ! ( Telling this, though I love mahendran a lot ) But Nayagan had Mani's trademark written and so do MR
  
  --
  
  I can only say : Mani Rathnam (None can b eat this fellow as far as song picturisation is concerned ) + Isai Gyani Ilayaraja + SPB ( Mandran VAntha)
  
  and not to forget KAARTHIK !
  
  

• From: raaja_rasigan on Tue Jun 5 2:02:45 2007.

  [Full View]

  I think, Alaipayudhe - Madhavan character is an extended version of Mouna Ragam - Karthik
  
  There will be similar scenes b/w Alaipayudhe & Mouna Ragam & one that comes in my mind is the Bus scene.
  
  (Karthik & Revathy) (Maddy & shalu) inside the Bus.
  
  Also the way both express their love is similar.
  
  

• From: Roshan on Tue Jun 5 2:11:14 2007.

  [Full View]

  raaja_rasigan wrote:

  I think, Alaipayudhe - Madhavan character is an extended version of Mouna Ragam - Karthik There will be similar scenes b/w Alaipayudhe & Mouna Ragam & one that comes in my mind is the Bus scene. (Karthik & Revathy) (Maddy & shalu) inside the Bus. Also the way both express their love is similar.

  
  
  And finally agreeing to go ahead with a 'ragasiya register marriage' is way too similar
  
  Many movies following Mouna Ragam had Karthik type characters but Mohan's was something very different and one of the hardly made roles.
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Tue Jun 5 2:11:33 2007.

  [Full View]

  Roshan wrote:

  Thanks Selva for this I was thinking of posting my wishes to SPB in the film section but didnt know where to post it. Thanks once again Many happy returns to the LEGEND and a GREAT HUMAN BEING - SPB Sir !!! May the Almighty bless you with more and more success, happiness and good health

  
  
  Roshan,
  I posted my wishes HERE as well
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Tue Jun 5 2:34:57 2007.

  [Full View]

  One of the scenes that I posted in KAADHAL IN TAMIL CINEMA sometime back
  
  

  nilavupriyan wrote:

  in sethu when vikram proposes to heroine... "rendu kaiya thatuna than satham varum etc etc...." in mouna ragam..."indha chaina kuduthutu polamnuthan vandhEn....aana ippothan theriyudhu..hey..nee romba azhaga irukka unna enakku romba pidichirukku"

  
  
  Nilavu.. ya.. both the scenes are awesome.. esp the second one..
  
  The narration
  ---------------
  
  karthick: excuse me.. maam.. naan divya(not sure abt name) kitta pesanum..
  
  mam: ethukku!!
  
  karthick: divya appavukku accident aahi avara hospitalla sethurukkoem..
  
  mam: divya ..u can go!!
  
  revathi: appakka accident ah!!
  
  karthick: aamaa!!
  
  revathi: entha hospital!!
  
  karthick: mm..(thinks for a while).. inga thaan!! govt hospital
  
  revathi: Poi........
  
  karthick: aenn...???
  
  revathi: enga appa thiruvannamalai poi rendu naal aachu!!!
  
  karthick: oh athu appa unga thaathaava irukumoe
  
  revathi: enga thatha naan perakkum pothae uyiroda illa!! (karthick stares at her in desperation)
  
  revathi: ido paar!! innaikku class ah vittu kooti vantha!! naalaikku veliya polaam apadinnu solluva!! piragu nee romba azhaga irukkannu solluva!!
  apuram.. naan unna love pannuraennu solluva.. idellam enakku pidikaathu.. get out!!
  
  karthick: (suddenly holds her hands)..he will put the gold chain in her hand.. revathi - with surprise, she will look at it.
  
  karthick: idu thaane un chain!! ida koduthittu polaam nu thaan vanthaen
  
  aana inga vantha piragu thaan therinjathu"
  
  revathi: enna...
  
  karthick: with super smile, nee romba azhaga irukannu.. I like u.. I like u very much..
  
  karthick enna charm.. revathi will be spellbound with this one..
  
  excellant scene!!
  
  

• From: Roshan on Tue Jun 5 2:55:19 2007.

  [Full View]

  selvakumar wrote:

  Roshan wrote: Thanks Selva for this I was thinking of posting my wishes to SPB in the film section but didnt know where to post it. Thanks once again Many happy returns to the LEGEND and a GREAT HUMAN BEING - SPB Sir !!! May the Almighty bless you with more and more success, happiness and good health Roshan, I posted my wishes HERE as well

  
  
  Thanks Selva.. ippathaan pArthEn. But good that you posted your wishes here as well
  
  

• From: Nakeeran on Tue Jun 5 5:09:59 2007.

  [Full View]

  Beautiful movie ! though the core theme resembles Mahendran's nenjanthai killadhe
  
  Superb music by Isainyani
  
  Karthik thunders ( the character being brief may be )
  
  Mohan - mikeless !
  
  revathy - Nice acting.
  
  However, one hitch ? Revathy being shown as a cheerful girl despite the loss of her lover Karthik . Quite unrealistic ?
  
  

• From: sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar on Tue Jun 5 5:39:39 2007.

  [Full View]

  crajkumar_be wrote:

  One can do a thesis on Ilaiyaraaja's usage of the bass guitar (like none less than SPB would testify) and "Chinna Chinna" would be a good place to start with. Very few people (in the world) have used bass as a counterpoint to the main melody in the way IR does. Its typical in jazz but in IR's songs its something different and at a different level. The pallavi starts with the bass lines played on a high note rather than as a rhythm backing up the main melody

  
  
  A Bass guitar note runs in the background, as S.Janaki sings chinna chinna...CR, is this what u mention?
  
  

• From: crajkumar_be on Tue Jun 5 6:17:19 2007.

  [Full View]

  sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar wrote:

  A Bass guitar note runs in the background, as S.Janaki sings chinna chinna...CR, is this what u mention?

  
  adhe dhaan. Usually, the bass will just 'follow' the main tune/melody but in many IR songs, it will be a kind of an aggressive "lead" along with the vocals.
  Probably the best example of that is "Thumbi Vaa"
  
  

• From: Raghu on Tue Jun 5 6:29:51 2007.

  [Full View]

  Selva Machi,
  
  Thanks for considering my request and start off with Mouna Raagam.
  
  what a film, i can watch this film every day, without any hestiation at all.
  
  here are the key points which made this film successfull in y humble opinion
  
  1) MR
  2) Dr.IR and DR.SPB (nilaavee vaa) Oh boy, i can just die listening to it, that is Dr.SPB 4 u !!!
  3) Karthick- very talented actor, but he choses the romantic hero role always, hence he failed miserabley
  4) Revathy/ one of the FINEST actress from kerala
  5) Mohan - did a very good job, normaly dr.IR/Dr.SPB and the mike saves him in most of the film , bur here he done a very decent job!
  
  

• From: raaja_rasigan on Tue Jun 5 6:39:56 2007.

  [Full View]

  Raghu wrote:

  5) Mohan - did a very good job, normaly dr.IR/Dr.SPB and the mike saves him in most of the film , bur here he done a very decent job!

  
  
  This time S.N.Surendhar's soft voice saved him along with IR & SPB & his calmness in acting
  
  

• From: Roshan on Tue Jun 5 6:53:34 2007.

  [Full View]

  crajkumar_be wrote:

  sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar wrote: A Bass guitar note runs in the background, as S.Janaki sings chinna chinna...CR, is this what u mention? adhe dhaan. Usually, the bass will just 'follow' the main tune/melody but in many IR songs, it will be a kind of an aggressive "lead" along with the vocals. Probably the best example of that is "Thumbi Vaa"

  
  
  CR, you are yet to answer my question ?
  
  

• From: Raghu on Tue Jun 5 6:54:40 2007.

  [Full View]

  raaja_rasigan wrote:

  Raghu wrote: 5) Mohan - did a very good job, normaly dr.IR/Dr.SPB and the mike saves him in most of the film , bur here he done a very decent job! This time S.N.Surendhar's soft voice saved him along with IR & SPB & his calmness in acting

  
  
  but S.N.Surendhar always lends his voice for Mohan right?
  
  I know Dr.SPB has done few times.
  
  

• From: Roshan on Tue Jun 5 6:56:34 2007.

  [Full View]

  raaja_rasigan wrote:

  This time S.N.Surendhar's soft voice saved him along with IR & SPB & his calmness in acting

  
  
  Yes !! half the credit if not more should go to S N Surendhar !
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Tue Jun 5 7:01:18 2007.

  [Full View]

  swathy wrote:

  It was boring for me , the only scene I enjoyed was poda madaya scene. Beautiful movie strongly supported by IR.

  
  
  
  
  

• From: raaja_rasigan on Tue Jun 5 8:00:47 2007.

  [Full View]

  Raghu wrote:

  raaja_rasigan wrote: Raghu wrote: 5) Mohan - did a very good job, normaly dr.IR/Dr.SPB and the mike saves him in most of the film , bur here he done a very decent job! This time S.N.Surendhar's soft voice saved him along with IR & SPB & his calmness in acting but S.N.Surendhar always lends his voice for Mohan right? I know Dr.SPB has done few times.

  
  
  yes u r right, But in this movie, the voice for mohan is apt & u can't say that some one has dubbed for him.....
  
  the voice modulation neatly syncs with the character
  
  

• From: dsath on Tue Jun 5 8:28:40 2007.

  [Full View]

  It is my favorite movie ever.
  Almost everything i wish to say has been told already.
  
  

• From: crajkumar_be on Tue Jun 5 9:13:33 2007.

  [Full View]

  Roshan wrote:

  CR, you are yet to answer my question ?

  
  </Dig>
  Oh, sorry, miss pannitten
  
  kathukka ellam onnum illa.. ellam aaruva kolaru dhaan (meesical family aana enakku onnum theriyadhu )
  
  Appetite undu, music kekkardhu romba pidikkum.. music therinjavanga kitta adha pathi kathukka pidikkum... oru passion
  </Dig>
  
  

• From: Roshan on Tue Jun 5 12:50:15 2007.

  [Full View]

  crajkumar_be wrote:

  Roshan wrote: CR, you are yet to answer my question ? </Dig> Oh, sorry, miss pannitten kathukka ellam onnum illa.. ellam aaruva kolaru dhaan (meesical family aana enakku onnum theriyadhu )

  
  
  Good to know that
  
  
  

  Quote:

  Appetite undu, music kekkardhu romba pidikkum.. music therinjavanga kitta adha pathi kathukka pidikkum... oru passion </Dig>

  
  
  Even I like but music therinjavangala inga thEdi pidikkiRathu romba kashtam
  
  

• From: nickraman on Tue Jun 5 18:52:15 2007.

  [Full View]

  One my favorite movies, which I saw for the first time over at videoduniya.com. Mohan as Chandrakuma "CK" was outstanding. I better watch his Idhaya Kovil then. Revathi was also the highlight, especially her scenes with the tamil-teaching with the sardar.
  
  IR of course, the reel star of the film. I still want that damn background score of his! It's hard to find now these days!
  
  I heard this is one of the turning points of MR's career as a director.
  
  

• From: Nerd on Tue Jun 5 23:46:16 2007.

  [Full View]

  I checked that hospital scene one more time. She DOES speak proper english. My husband is bleeding, four guys beat him up, its an emergency...
  
  My most favorite mohan scene in this movie is the scene in which revathi's dad says, maapLa, unga kalyaaNathula enna kuRai vechEnnu theriyala, adhu edhuvA irunthAlum ennai mannichurunga, en ponnu chinna ponnu etc.., Mohan will not say a single word but his expressions would be top-notch and the explanation he gives for his weird behaviour in the next scene is
  
  

• From: sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar on Wed Jun 6 1:11:41 2007.

  [Full View]

  crajkumar_be wrote:

  kathukka ellam onnum illa.. ellam aaruva kolaru dhaan

  
  
  roshan, he actually has a very good musical taste \ knowledge in carnatic\Jazz\Western and filmi music. I have lot to learn \ get from him. He already helped me in getting basics in Jazz.....Great Guy
  
  

• From: Roshan on Wed Jun 6 2:19:59 2007.

  [Full View]

  sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar wrote:

  crajkumar_be wrote: kathukka ellam onnum illa.. ellam aaruva kolaru dhaan roshan, he actually has a very good musical taste \ knowledge in carnatic\Jazz\Western and filmi music. I have lot to learn \ get from him. He already helped me in getting basics in Jazz.....Great Guy

  
  
  I could sense it Aana as usual romba thannadakkamA bathil solli iruthaar
  
  
  And Sakala,
  
  Where were you all these days? Hub pakkam varala konja nAlA.
  
  

• From: buddysathi on Wed Jun 6 2:43:14 2007.

  [Full View]

  Mr.Chandramouli is the best part!
  
  

• From: sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar on Wed Jun 6 2:45:23 2007.

  [Full View]

  Roshan wrote:

  And Sakala, Where were you all these days? Hub pakkam varala konja nAlA.

  
  
  Roshan, somehow time kidaikkavillai, as usual work, but i try to visit atleast twice a week. during dasa release, 24 Hrs humming thaan
  
  

• From: Nakeeran on Wed Jun 6 2:47:26 2007.

  [Full View]

  sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar wrote:

  Roshan wrote: And Sakala, Where were you all these days? Hub pakkam varala konja nAlA. Roshan, somehow time kidaikkavillai, as usual work, but i try to visit atleast twice a week. during dasa release, 24 Hrs humming thaan

  
  
  Hi Sakakals
  
  Your avtar is a bit confusing. Looks like that Prem who invested his all wealth to act alongside Kushboo in sandyar ! Also looks like Shivaji !
  
  

• From: shobana_in on Wed Jun 6 2:48:21 2007.

  [Full View]

  Nakeeran wrote:

  sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar wrote: Roshan wrote: And Sakala, Where were you all these days? Hub pakkam varala konja nAlA. Roshan, somehow time kidaikkavillai, as usual work, but i try to visit atleast twice a week. during dasa release, 24 Hrs humming thaan Hi Sakakals Your avtar is a bit confusing. Looks like that Prem who invested his all wealth to act alongside Kushboo in sandyar ! Also looks like Shivaji !

  
  
  apdiya...adhuku edhuku padam edukanum..loosu paya
  
  

• From: Nakeeran on Wed Jun 6 2:49:31 2007.

  [Full View]

  Thimiru
  
  Appo Kushboo was damn popular I think. Ellarukkum oru aasai dhaane !
  
  

• From: sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar on Wed Jun 6 2:50:03 2007.

  [Full View]

  its the Bachelor Of Social Service, in my avatar
  [namma aalu athula MASS ngurathu vera vishayam ]
  
  MAster of Social Service
  
  

• From: shobana_in on Wed Jun 6 2:50:18 2007.

  [Full View]

  Nakeeran wrote:

  Thimiru Appo Kushboo was damn popular I think. Ellarukkum oru aasai dhaane !

  
  
  nayamana pechu
  
  

• From: ajaybaskar on Wed Jun 6 3:12:20 2007.

  [Full View]

  A film that had brought a new dimension to cameo roles..
  
  

• From: kannannn on Wed Jun 6 5:48:15 2007.

  [Full View]

  Roshan wrote:

  sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar wrote: crajkumar_be wrote: kathukka ellam onnum illa.. ellam aaruva kolaru dhaan roshan, he actually has a very good musical taste \ knowledge in carnatic\Jazz\Western and filmi music. I have lot to learn \ get from him. He already helped me in getting basics in Jazz.....Great Guy I could sense it Aana as usual romba thannadakkamA bathil solli iruthaar

  
  I second that..
  
  

• From: Prabhu Ram on Wed Jun 6 6:46:31 2007.

  [Full View]

  A highly enjoyable film from MR.
  
  The dialogues were the strong point of the film. Not traditionally filmi but natural and (thus) memorable.....even the lighter ones:
  
  VKR: Yen yA, kalyAnathukku 10 naal leave kuduthaa...moonu naalile vandhu nikkire......kalyAnam mudinja aachaa..honeymoon-nu onnu irukkE !
  Mohan: Union negoatiation-nu onnu irukkE
  VKR: unakkellAm evan yA poNNu kuduthAn
  
  
  

• From: Roshan on Wed Jun 6 10:07:33 2007.

  [Full View]

  PR
  
  Neengathaan sari dialogues quote pannurathukku
  
  BTW, who penned the dialogues for Mouna Ragam?
  
  
  P.S : Nice signature PR
  
  

• From: raaja_rasigan on Wed Jun 6 11:03:46 2007.

  [Full View]

  Roshan wrote:

  PR Neengathaan sari dialogues quote pannurathukku BTW, who penned the dialogues for Mouna Ragam? P.S : Nice signature PR

  
  
  it should be Maniratnam himself
  
  

• From: littlemaster1982 on Wed Jun 6 13:29:42 2007.

  [Full View]

  it's Maniratnam only
  
  

• From: m_23_bayarea on Wed Jun 6 13:32:58 2007.

  [Full View]

  * Very mellow and a nice romantic story!
  
  * Beautiful and subtle screenplay!
  
  * Amazing songs and BGM!
  
  * Superb acting performances by the leads!
  
  * Awesome Direction from the legend!
  
  The movie is called MOUNA RAAGAM...
  
  
  
  

• From: Prabhu Ram on Wed Jun 6 14:46:16 2007.

  [Full View]

  Roshan wrote:

  PR Neengathaan sari dialogues quote pannurathukku BTW, who penned the dialogues for Mouna Ragam? P.S : Nice signature PR

  
  
  
  Dialogues by MR himself. I always quote Mouna Ragam to anyone who says MR is all about unnaturally minimal dialogue.
  
  Plenty of nice ones in this film. In the second half, Revathi is slowly drawn towards him and Mohan is getting emotionally defensive because her departure is imminent (or atleast he doesn't want to make the first move). She keeps trying to get close by being playful while he remains aloof. They are walking around the house and she turns off the music system that he turned on. He will erupt:
  "Will you stop it ! Kuzhandhai maadhiri nadanthukkarathukkum oru ellai irukku. Un ishtathukku eppidi nadandhukkalaam yaarum kEkka maattaangannu ninaichiyA ? Well, there is a limit and this is it."
  
  After that he will call his travel agent and book her ticket home the next day. He will be fuming even when he is talking to his agent. Revathi would be too stunned to react and too proud to retract. The outburst had little to do with her actions but emotions bouncing off unexpected channels.
  
  Beautifully conceived, written and executed scene.
  
  

• From: Nerd on Wed Jun 6 15:10:14 2007.

  [Full View]

  And beautifully narrated as well
  
  

• From: vidhyavd on Thu Jun 7 14:37:39 2007.

  [Full View]

  shobana_in wrote:

  Roshan wrote: >> Dig << YaaruppA antha Sivrajkumar ? Unga emotions ellaam pArthA - I consider myself lucky not knowing him >> dig << there is a dialogue in mouna ragam. karthik would say something like revathi is fearing that she would fall for his charm and smartness. karthik sonna OK......sivaraj kumar

  
  
  Yes
  
  

• From: great on Thu Jun 7 14:42:17 2007.

  [Full View]

  Mouna Raagam and Nayagan combination DVD ,original, is just 65 Rs available in all leading store !!!!
  
  Mouna raagam is one of favourite MR movie . IR BGM and
  
  

• From: VENKIRAJA on Thu Jun 7 14:56:03 2007.

  [Full View]

  yaar antha sivaraj kumar?
  
  

• From: vidhyavd on Thu Jun 7 15:02:48 2007.

  [Full View]

  Shivraj kumar photo : Click the link below
  
  Click here to see included image.
  
  http://www.imagehosting.com/show.php/745926_shiv.jpg.html
  
  

• From: raaja_rasigan on Fri Jun 8 3:14:01 2007.

  [Full View]

  vidhyavd wrote:

  Shivraj kumar photo : Click the link below Click here to see included image. http://www.imagehosting.com/show.php/745926_shiv.jpg.html

  
  
  Dhoolma....
  
  azhagunna azhagu kollai azhagu
  
  

• From: sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar on Fri Jun 8 3:57:02 2007.

  [Full View]

  Inspite of the too-low volume speakers in Mani's film, VKR is a pleasant exception, he was as same as he was in other films. Mai didnt add any changes to the typical VKR characterisation, but still VKR didnt seemed out-of-blend along with otehr characters....
  
  

• From: crajkumar_be on Fri Jun 8 4:32:44 2007.

  [Full View]

  <Dig>
  While we are on the digression about Shivrajkumar, let me just add this:
  While Jayam Ravi was an apt choice for the fighter role in M.Kumaran, i thought the Telugu hero (forgot the name) was a joke in the original. That was until i saw a scene from the Kannada remake, which if i'm not wrong was starring SRK
  </Dig>
  
  Kostin:
  1) Apart from MR, did Mani Sir write the dialogues for any other film?
  2) If not, i wonder why...
  
  

• From: raaja_rasigan on Fri Jun 8 4:40:15 2007.

  [Full View]

  crajkumar_be wrote:

  <Dig> While we are on the digression about Shivrajkumar, let me just add this: While Jayam Ravi was an apt choice for the fighter role in M.Kumaran, i thought the Telugu hero (forgot the name) was a joke in the original. That was until i saw a scene from the Kannada remake, which if i'm not wrong was starring SRK </Dig> Kostin: 1) Apart from MR, did Mani Sir write the dialogues for any other film? 2) If not, i wonder why...

  
  
  Thalabathi
  Agni natchathiram
  
  I guess these 2 had Mani's style of dialogues
  
  

• From: Roshan on Fri Jun 8 4:47:26 2007.

  [Full View]

  vidhyavd wrote:

  Shivraj kumar photo : Click the link below Click here to see included image. http://www.imagehosting.com/show.php/745926_shiv.jpg.html

  
  
  My day is gone
  
  

• From: lavanya22rit on Fri Jun 8 4:53:41 2007.

  [Full View]

  raaja_rasigan wrote:

  vidhyavd wrote: Shivraj kumar photo : Click the link below Click here to see included image. http://www.imagehosting.com/show.php/745926_shiv.jpg.html Dhoolma.... azhagunna azhagu kollai azhagu

  
  
  But still he cant match our own young commander !!!
  
  

• From: raaja_rasigan on Fri Jun 8 4:58:29 2007.

  [Full View]

  lavanya22rit wrote:

  But still he cant match our own young commander !!!

  
  
  Who is that
  
  

• From: vidhyavd on Fri Jun 8 12:41:58 2007.

  [Full View]

  raaja_rasigan wrote:

  vidhyavd wrote: Shivraj kumar photo : Click the link below Click here to see included image. http://www.imagehosting.com/show.php/745926_shiv.jpg.html Dhoolma.... azhagunna azhagu kollai azhagu

  
  
  
  
  

• From: Prasanna on Sat Jun 9 10:18:31 2007.

  [Full View]

  rr even bombay had those dialogs but it involved only arvind swamy and m k
  
  
  

• From: Prasanna on Sat Jun 9 11:29:07 2007.

  [Full View]

  this was the only movie wer mohan was made toact. the credit goes to mani
  he never opens his mouth wide and also never holds a mike in his hand
  
  

• From: joe on Mon Jun 11 21:49:07 2007.

  [Full View]

  Selva,
  Time for next 'Movie of the week'.
  
  

• From: Nerd on Tue Jun 12 1:01:39 2007.

  [Full View]

  Before that, let me add this:
  
  I absolutely loved mohan's house in that movie. From the huge doors to the cozy bed, everything was *perfect*
  
  

• From: Roshan on Tue Jun 12 1:16:15 2007.

  [Full View]

  Nerd wrote:

  Before that, let me add this: I absolutely loved mohan's house in that movie. From the huge doors to the cozy bed, everything was *perfect*

  
  
  Yes !! Plus the garden and lighting too were nice and pleasant.
  
  

• From: Prabhu Ram on Tue Jun 12 1:32:46 2007.

  [Full View]

  Nerd wrote:

  Before that, let me add this: I absolutely loved mohan's house in that movie. From the huge doors to the cozy bed, everything was *perfect*

  enakku verum sengal cement pOdhum
  
  Closely followed by the house in Anjali. A dining table with people squatting on the floor ! An aesthetic revolution by itself
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Tue Jun 12 1:37:41 2007.

  [Full View]

  Thanks for the reminder Joe romba somberi aayitten illa
  --
  
  Next Movie is about a "Theeraatha vilayaattu pillai"
  
  

• From: joe on Tue Jun 12 1:41:00 2007.

  [Full View]

  selvakumar wrote:

  Thanks for the reminder Joe romba somberi aayitten illa -- Next Movie is about a "Theeraatha vilayaattu pillai"

  
  
  NetriKan?
  
  

• From: Prabhu Ram on Tue Jun 12 1:41:01 2007.

  [Full View]

  selvakumar wrote:

  Thanks for the reminder Joe romba somberi aayitten illa -- Next Movie is about a "Theeraatha vilayaattu pillai"

  Manmadha Leelai ?
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Tue Jun 12 1:41:41 2007.

  [Full View]

  Joe -
  
  PR - No
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Tue Jun 12 1:44:20 2007.

  [Full View]

  http://www.rajinifans.com/Review/Netrikan.asp
  
  NetriKann
  
  Cast :
  
  Rajnikanth
  Lakshmi
  Sarita
  Koundamani
  Vijayashanthi
  Menaga
  
  SP Muthuraman is a person who has directed lots of movies starring Thanga Thalaivar Super Star Rajinikanth, its even the fact that he was in lime light just because he has directed lots of Rajini/Kamal Movies. Enjoy my review of the classic movie "Netrikkan" starring Rajinikanth in dual role (Father and Son). Others include homely "Old" aunty Lakshmi, "Amruthanjan commercial fame" Saritha, Gowndamani, Menaka and great Goluttu female Super fighter Vijayashanthi as Super Star's Sister. Sarath Babu and Thengai Srinivasan have acted in "Gowrava Vedam" guys you know what Gourava vendam means - acting without taking any money!!! Directed by SP Muthuraman, Story and Dialogs Visu SCREEN PLAY BY K.B. the great. Lyrics by "Kavi Arasar" and Isai @ Ilayaraja. Produced by K.B's Kavithalayam (now rechristened Kavithalaya).
  
  STORY:
  
  The story is about the weakness (what else gals) of a very successful Enterpreneur/Multi Milloinaire Chakaravarthy (Father Rajini) with a little bit of self pride on his achievements who is the Bill Gates of yester years in the Textile City of Tamil Nadu (Coimbatore). He is a great womeniser (perhaps his only weakness) a typical Sabala Case who is capable of picking up any cute chicks. At heart he is too good a person he treats his employees well, highly charitable. He has a son (Santhosh Chakaravarthy) and a daughter Sangeetha (who else the great goluttu super fighter (Vijayashanthi) and an OFFICIAL wife Meenakshi (Lakshmi). Radha (Saritha) gets introduced as a candidate for PRO (Public Relations Officer) interview and eventually gets selected and she is sent to Hong Kong for training. Our Sabala Chakaravarthy goes to hong kong and rapes her. In the meanwhile his son gets to know his weakness and starts reforming him. Later Radha joins Santhosh and his mother in this "Critical" mission. The rest of the story is how they reform chakaravarthy a highly perverted, influencial person with little bit of typical Tamil Movie Masala!!!!
  
  Rajinikanth
  
  He has done a great job as ever in this movie. Both father and son are either extremes and performing the character of the Perverted Sabala case in the previous shot and the same person doing the character of a pious person in the next shot is extremely difficult job. I would say he has lived the father role. The peak performance of the super star is exhibited in every inch of the movie and the self pride he shows is at its best when he says "Nee Yuvarajana nan chakaravarthy da" and accomplishes What he wanted.
  
  Saritha
  
  She has done a great job as a person got raped by her boss. But in the last scene too much of sentiments and cries which was irritating to some extent. Lakshmi As usual lots of cries for her in this movie as every one knows she is too good at doing it. So it requires no special comments. Goundamani
  
  OOOOPs.... no one to get beaten by him in this movie so he had to show some real stuff in comedy and he did a great job in doing it. Dominating others many a times irritates the viewers. In this movie he has acted without his usual slang and beating senthil for no reason. His performance was at its peak when he corners charavarthy and says samandhi nan kilabukku(club) poi pillieeeds (Billiyards) veladaporen.
  
  Thengai
  
  Though he comes for only one scene as a doctor he did a great job he comes as Dr. "Kopparai Thengai Srinivasan" with a large pattai on his forehead a striped shirt and tie with a panja dhothy. The way he delivers dialogs and they way he responds to Rajini and the way he drives Rajini out of his clinic was really great. His performance was simply superb and its worth mentioning.
  
  Sarath Babu
  
  Though his character demanded some amount of acting he failed to do. It was a just a come and go for him. Menaka
  
  I am sure no body will be knowing this female to my knowledge she has acted as a heroine only in this movie. For those who want to findout who she is watch "Ramanin Moganam Song". Just she comes and goes with little bit of weeping and nail biting here and there of course on her fingers.
  
  COMMENTS:
  
  Punching Scenes
  
  In our view every scene Charavarthy appears is a punching scene. OOOOPs then the whole movie sans the songs/Typical Tamil Cinema Masala and romance becomes a punching scene. Anyway to highlight few good ones.
  
  1. The time chakaravarthy gets up is 7:30 in the morning (with an alarm clock) as soon as he opens his eyes, sees a porn poster in his room, Kalailla muzhikkaradhe oru two piece ponnoda poster. One servant comes with a variety of juices (bed juice have u ever heard of) on a trolly and the tray on the trolly contains porn poster, the way he keeps the empty glass back on the tray....it was really excellent then another servant comes with a tray full of cigars and another guy comes and crackles his knuckles (Kalla sodakku eduthu vida oru aal!!). He exhibited a great style when he flicks his left knee and the pillow which was on his leg falls on the bed!!!!! One has to see the number of desses/shoes/watches/googles Charavarthy has in his room. I was shocked to see that.
  
  2. On the other hand his son gets up at 5 in the morning as soon as he wakes up, sees Thiruppathi Venki (Those who don't know Venki he is Ammu's husband) very rich god. He has a very simple life style, not venki our Hero Santhosh.
  
  

• From: Roshan on Tue Jun 12 1:45:09 2007.

  [Full View]

  Prabhu Ram wrote:

  Nerd wrote: Before that, let me add this: I absolutely loved mohan's house in that movie. From the huge doors to the cozy bed, everything was *perfect* enakku verum sengal cement pOdhum Closely followed by the house in Anjali. A dining table with people squatting on the floor ! An aesthetic revolution by itself

  
  
  Yes PR - I liked it. Thanks for reminding
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Tue Jun 12 1:46:22 2007.

  [Full View]

  I had this movie for a long time since I received better nominations during this period without any overlap between the other choices. (e.g. mullum malarum)
  
  Finally, listing it !
  
  

• From: Roshan on Tue Jun 12 1:48:23 2007.

  [Full View]

  selvakumar wrote:

  http://www.rajinifans.com/Review/Netrikan.asp NetriKann Cast : Rajnikanth Lakshmi Sarita Koundamani Vijayashanthi << Heroine >>

  
  
  It was Menaga
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Tue Jun 12 1:54:11 2007.

  [Full View]

  Thanks Roshan ! Have edited my Intro post !
  
  / dig Has she acted in any other films ? Few e.g. ? / dig
  
  --
  
  Third Eye
  
  Pros: Rajini,Characterisation,Music,Dialogues
  Cons: Under developed love sequence of rajini,fights
  
  
  I have watched this movie umpteen number of times and somehow I never get tired of rajini in this movie.Watching this movie, I feel that by rajini’s decision to switch over as a hero, tamil film world has lost an excellent
  villain. Rajini can look evil without any loud mouthed dialogues as was evident in movies like moondru mudichu,netrikann and more recently in chandramukhi ( as vettaiyan raja).
  Well the story goes like this.....Chakravarthy is a self made crorepathi in coimbatore. His family consists of wife Meenakshi(Lakshmi), son Santhosh( Rajini) and daughter sangeetha(Vijaya shanthi). Chakravarthy is devoted to his family but he has a weakness for women. He is highly promiscuous which his children are unaware.But when his son comes to know of this trait, he takes it upon himself to correct his father. So Chakravarthy escapes to hongkong where he meets radha (saritha) , his employee whom he had sent to hongkong for training. He takes advantage and rapes. Coming back, he is infuriated by the changes done by ’’General Manager’’ only to find that radha is the GM. Worse, she is also his daughter-in-law. Santhosh and Radha together push him to the edge. What happens next forms the rest of the story.
  Although its a kind of cliche’d story, the strength like in the acting of rajinikanth. He has differentiated between the arrogant,promiscuous short tempered father and obedient,patient and virtuous son. I simply lived chakravarthy, Rajini was first class. My personal favourites are the initial scenes showing the difference between the father and the son, the scene where he talks to radha after molesting her with radha repeating the same thing to him later, the scene where he talks to sarath babu requesting him not to marry his daughter.
  Music is by Ilayaraaja. BGM’s are good.Special mention to the BGM where chakravarthy confronts radha.Songs are also good. I liked Maapillaikku maaman manasu and theeradha vilaiyattu pillai.
  Dialogues are by Visu. Excellent dialogues.
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Tue Jun 12 1:57:10 2007.

  [Full View]

  Intha review konjam harsh ah irukkira maari irukku
  
  http://www.mouthshut.com/review/Netrikann-46241-1.html
  
  Pros: BGM,story,Rajni as Chakravarthy
  Cons: Fight scenes,unnecessary songs
  
  “Netrikannai thurappinum kutram kutrame” (Even if you open your third eye, a mistake is a mistake) This is a famous dialogue from the film “Thiruvilaiyadal” .Nakkeran,the great Tamil poet confronts Lord Shiva(enacted by Shivaji) by sticking to his stand and saying that he feels that even though a mistake is committed by God himself,he would say in His face that it is a mistake and that he
  is not afraid of His (Lord Shiva) anger.But,does this movie justify this title? Let us see…
  Chakravarthy(Rajni) is a millionare in coimbatore who has a model family – a devoted son, wife and daughter. His business is flourishing and he has his family in the board of directors for the company.He is very attached to his family. But he has one major weakness: women. His wife(played by Lakshmi) is very timid and even though she knows his weakness,she is not able to control him. His son(also played by Rajni) is very attached to his father .But when he comes to know that his father is a womanizer ,he slowly realizes that he has to take charge.Till now,he had played the role of an obedient son.But now he has to mend the ways of his father.So he tries to control him.But Chakravarty breaks free and goes to Hong Kong.An employee(Saritha) comes to see him.Chakravarty takes advantage of the situation and violates her. When he comes back to Coimbatore ,he is surprised to see Saritha as GM who has been appointed by the board of directors. But the major shock is that he comes to know that Saritha and his son are married!
  
  The rest of the story deals with how Chakravarthy handles this embarrassing situation and how he realizes his mistakes. Chakravarthy is a dream role for Rajni.He has done full justice to this role.The contrast between Chakravarthy and his son is well brought out in the first few scenes. Lakshmi is really good as a docile and timid wife. Maneka does the role of the other Rajni’s lover. Kaundamani, Sarath Babu are also there in the movie and are ok.
  
  But why is the movie titled “Netrikann”(third eye) ? Chakravarty’s son ,when he comes to know that his father is a womanizer,teaches a lesson to his father. He is not afraid to say straight on his father’s face that he had committed a mistake.Even though Chakravarty threatens him and asks him to behave like a son,his son refuses and makes him understand his mistakes.One can compare the father character to Shiva and the son character to Nakkeeran.So,I guess “Netrikann” title is apt.
  Ilayaraja’s BGMs are really good and the song “Ramanin Mohanam”(lyrics by Kannadasan) stands out.But the film is not without any flaws.Rajni could have avoided over-acting in some places.Some of the songs are unnecessary and the visuals are cheap. Maneka falls for Rajni in the first scene itself which is not at all believable.In the fight scenes,it is evident that a dupe( and not Rajni) is fighting.That could have been easily avoided. In spite out of all these flaws, it is an enjoyable movie and can be watched. Rajni fans,I am sure,would have a whale of time watching this movie.
  
  

• From: rockydeva on Tue Jun 12 1:58:11 2007.

  [Full View]

  Netrikan one of the best movies of RAJINIKANTH.... shown a new diamension of his acting skills
  
  

• From: Roshan on Tue Jun 12 1:58:42 2007.

  [Full View]

  selvakumar wrote:

  [tscii] / [b">dig Has she acted in any other films ? Few e.g. ? / dig

  
  
  Yeah she has but I am unable to recollect the names right now. PR will know I am sure
  
  

• From: selvakumar on Tue Jun 12 2:03:34 2007.

  [Full View]

  I remember many films in which RK played -ve roles. But this one is a diff one indeed. Neatly balanced with 2 roles. Father being arrogant, stylish and an opportunist. Son being obedient, humble.
  
  I love the scene in which Son rajini will be explaining about the greatness of Lord Rama whereas Father rajini will start dreaming about Rama's Father Dasarathan
  
  And the sequence
  "Theeraatha vilayaattu pillai"
  
  RK : "Namakkum 60 thinaayiram pondaatigal irunthaa eppadi irukkum"
  
  

• From: joe on Tue Jun 12 2:05:02 2007.

  [Full View]

  Menaka is predominantly malayalam actress,did very few tamil,Telugu movies ..currently she is acting in Malayalam TV serials.
  
  

• From: Roshan on Tue Jun 12 2:29:31 2007.

  [Full View]

  I like the song "Raamanin mOganam... Janaki manthiram KJJ and SJ
  
  

• From: seran on Tue Jun 12 3:05:17 2007.

  [Full View]

  Thanks Selva, for choosing a SS movie during Sivaji release.
  
  Indha vaaran Rajini Vaaram
  
  

• From: Raghu on Tue Jun 12 4:59:59 2007.

  [Full View]

  Father Rajni DONS the movie, RAJNI as sarcastic VILLIAN is UNBEATABLE