|
The Hub : Tamil Films | Hello Guest, Login to post. |
Best music director
Topic started by arr on Mon Nov 8 23:35:43 2004. | [Full View] |
From: Sandeep on Tue Nov 9 9:22:11 2004. | [Full View] |
From: arr on Wed Nov 10 4:04:41 2004. | [Full View] |
From: Sandeep on Wed Nov 10 8:55:37 2004. | [Full View] |
From: arr on Fri Nov 12 2:08:27 2004. | [Full View] |
From: arr on Fri Nov 12 2:12:34 2004. | [Full View] |
From: Reena on Sun Nov 14 0:28:43 2004. | [Full View] |
From: Surya on Sun Nov 14 20:26:51 2004. | [Full View] |
From: Reena on Sun Nov 14 22:43:33 2004. | [Full View] |
From: Surya on Mon Nov 15 22:22:00 2004. | [Full View] |
From: arr on Mon Nov 15 23:42:48 2004. | [Full View] |
Surya wrote: |
Harish's Uyirin Uyire in kaaka Kaaka was mindblowing! |
From: arr on Mon Nov 15 23:46:36 2004. | [Full View] |
Reena wrote: |
Poo Vasam Purapadum from Anbe Sivam - - - romantic songs. |
From: Surya on Tue Nov 16 1:51:10 2004. | [Full View] |
From: camille sundram on Tue Nov 16 13:48:36 2004. | [Full View] |
From: Surya on Tue Nov 16 15:21:06 2004. | [Full View] |
From: arr on Thu Nov 18 0:03:38 2004. | [Full View] |
Surya wrote: |
ARR is good. His music is at its peak in Mani Rathnam movies though. Bombay, Aitha Ezhuthu, Kannathil Muthamittal.
8) |
From: Surya on Thu Nov 18 16:28:14 2004. | [Full View] |
From: Reena on Thu Nov 18 23:28:24 2004. | [Full View] |
From: jai_iyappan on Mon Nov 22 5:07:04 2004. | [Full View] |
From: Reena on Mon Nov 22 16:11:30 2004. | [Full View] |
From: Sathya on Tue Nov 23 14:27:49 2004. | [Full View] |
From: Sathya on Tue Nov 23 14:30:30 2004. | [Full View] |
From: Reena on Tue Nov 23 17:02:44 2004. | [Full View] |
From: Sathya on Tue Nov 23 17:14:41 2004. | [Full View] |
From: Sandeep on Tue Nov 23 17:25:41 2004. | [Full View] |
Sathya wrote: |
Reena,
You have to consider the real lifestyle of some people. Like that might have been a bit too violent and unneccery for you, but it might be something very believable to others, who grew up in that circle. |
From: Sathya on Tue Nov 23 17:33:37 2004. | [Full View] |
From: Sandeep on Tue Nov 23 17:52:07 2004. | [Full View] |
Sathya wrote: |
What do you mean Sandeep? The way they showed the violence? |
From: Sathya on Tue Nov 23 17:53:49 2004. | [Full View] |
From: Sandeep on Tue Nov 23 17:58:35 2004. | [Full View] |
Sathya wrote: |
YOu mean that screenplay? How they first showed Kothalan's flashback, where Kamal was shown as the bad guy, and then later Virumaandi's flashback, where the truth is shown?
I thought that was nice. But that's just me. ![]() |
From: Sathya on Tue Nov 23 18:01:02 2004. | [Full View] |
From: Surya on Tue Nov 23 18:25:19 2004. | [Full View] |
From: Sathya on Tue Nov 23 18:27:04 2004. | [Full View] |
Surya wrote: |
Sathya,
Based on what you've said here, and othe threads, Are you a shrink? IF I can use that term. ![]() |
From: Querida on Tue Nov 23 22:27:01 2004. | [Full View] |
From: Sandeep on Wed Nov 24 11:32:26 2004. | [Full View] |
From: Sandeep on Wed Nov 24 11:33:51 2004. | [Full View] |
Sathya wrote: |
Excatly, actually, I was longing to analyze some of these charecters. Why were they so violent? There were many issues, which cuold have been dealt in a different way. Why were they so aggressive. its like the people in the Black and Mexican Ghettos here. |
From: Querida on Wed Nov 24 21:39:32 2004. | [Full View] |
Sandeep wrote: |
Queridas punch line:
"I write because I don’t know what I think until I read what I say. " One question do you edit what you write once you understand what you where thinking ![]() |
From: Surya on Thu Nov 25 13:24:37 2004. | [Full View] |
Querida wrote: |
Sathya is so lucky to have the compliment that i've always wanted ![]() ![]() ![]() |
From: arr on Mon Dec 6 5:30:36 2004. | [Full View] |
From: arr on Mon Dec 6 5:33:23 2004. | [Full View] |
From: Surya on Tue Dec 7 20:50:56 2004. | [Full View] |
From: Querida on Tue Dec 7 22:09:21 2004. | [Full View] |
From: jangofett on Wed Dec 8 5:06:20 2004. | [Full View] |
From: Querida on Wed Dec 8 16:01:35 2004. | [Full View] |
jangofett wrote: |
It's a bit difficult to compare among the composers. It's all relative. ARR has got nothing to proof now. He has achieved everything that Ilayairaja did and also did so much more. In the era of 90s, ARR is without peer. The whole bunch of composers like Deva, Vidyasaagar, KR, YSR and others have followed the rules set by ARR. They have not broken it but ARR broke Ilayaraja's norm when he came in 1992. Ilayairaja was indeed the master in the 80s and ARR is isai arasan in 90s. For me, personal choice is ARR because I grew up in the 90s listening to his music. He's more relevant to me than Ilaiyaraja. |
From: Surya on Wed Dec 8 21:52:22 2004. | [Full View] |
From: Surya on Sun Dec 12 3:14:54 2004. | [Full View] |
From: Querida on Sun Dec 12 19:52:08 2004. | [Full View] |
From: Surya on Mon Dec 13 0:41:38 2004. | [Full View] |
From: Ghlli on Wed Dec 15 20:51:50 2004. | [Full View] |
From: Surya on Wed Dec 15 21:57:06 2004. | [Full View] |
From: arr on Thu Dec 16 4:01:45 2004. | [Full View] |
From: Surya on Thu Dec 16 20:28:05 2004. | [Full View] |
From: arr on Tue Dec 21 1:22:47 2004. | [Full View] |
Surya wrote: |
ARR,
Yeah Yuvan Shankar Raja is very good, I like him. ![]() Regards. 8) |
From: suressh on Thu Dec 23 8:06:44 2004. | [Full View] |
From: suressh on Thu Dec 23 8:19:20 2004. | [Full View] |
From: Surya on Tue Dec 28 16:32:37 2004. | [Full View] |
From: soccer_gal on Wed Dec 29 1:49:27 2004. | [Full View] |
From: Akash on Wed Dec 29 2:34:08 2004. | [Full View] |
From: Akash on Wed Dec 29 2:43:51 2004. | [Full View] |
From: arr on Tue Jan 4 1:17:25 2005. | [Full View] |
From: arr on Tue Jan 4 1:19:35 2005. | [Full View] |
From: slperson1 on Tue Jan 4 9:24:58 2005. | [Full View] |
From: Surya on Tue Jan 4 13:21:45 2005. | [Full View] |
From: slperson1 on Tue Jan 4 14:20:12 2005. | [Full View] |
From: Surya on Wed Jan 5 15:43:30 2005. | [Full View] |
From: dilipkumar on Thu Jan 6 6:30:27 2005. | [Full View] |
From: arr on Wed Jan 12 6:44:15 2005. | [Full View] |
Surya wrote: |
Yes, I agree. But see ARR has gotten to where he is now after years of expierence. And YSR, even though he is much younger, is already coming a bit close to ARR with his "Youthful" tracks. If YSR had the expierence that ARR has now, I think that YSR would be much better than ARR. My opinion is that YSR has more Potencial than ARR does. Just an opinion. ![]() Regards. 8) |
From: visu on Wed Jan 12 8:50:13 2005. | [Full View] |
From: NOV on Thu Jan 13 12:51:41 2005. | [Full View] |
From: vincent on Wed Apr 6 9:31:08 2005. | [Full View] |
From: gorgeous gaayini on Tue Apr 12 14:56:16 2005. | [Full View] |
From: Pras on Tue Apr 12 16:28:31 2005. | [Full View] |
From: m_23_bayarea on Tue Apr 12 16:50:32 2005. | [Full View] |
From: Pras on Tue Apr 12 17:04:29 2005. | [Full View] |
m_23_bayarea wrote: |
ARR is my favorite. But right now, I think Harris Jayaraj is just mind-blowing. Oh man, Kaaka Kaaka was unbelievable... |
From: Miss Chennai on Tue Apr 12 21:07:12 2005. | [Full View] |
Pras wrote: | ||
ya but Ilayaraaja is the best ![]() |
From: Pras on Tue Apr 12 23:53:59 2005. | [Full View] |
Quote: |
ya, if only ARR is not around |
From: Nerd on Wed Apr 13 0:05:12 2005. | [Full View] |
From: vincent on Wed Apr 13 1:08:56 2005. | [Full View] |
Pras wrote: | ||
IR is here to stay, ARR can just jump around ![]() |
From: cucushock on Wed Apr 13 7:36:53 2005. | [Full View] |
From: karthik_sa2 on Wed Apr 13 16:03:14 2005. | [Full View] |
From: interz on Thu Apr 14 6:42:26 2005. | [Full View] |
From: Ghlli on Wed Feb 15 19:32:39 2006. | [Full View] |
From: m_23_bayarea on Wed Feb 15 21:19:03 2006. | [Full View] |
From: kidils on Wed Feb 15 23:00:19 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Kollywoodfan on Thu Feb 16 0:02:47 2006. | [Full View] |
From: joe on Thu Feb 16 0:08:59 2006. | [Full View] |
From: kidils on Thu Feb 16 0:58:13 2006. | [Full View] |
Kollywoodfan wrote: |
kidils I agree...YSR is recycling his old tunes...and the sound stale...Of course not horrible...
I love HJ...now, his songs are amazing |
From: m_23_bayarea on Thu Feb 16 16:17:10 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Ramakrishna on Thu Feb 16 16:22:09 2006. | [Full View] |
From: m_23_bayarea on Thu Feb 16 16:24:56 2006. | [Full View] |
Ramakrishna wrote: |
Why Harris Jeyaraj has not been included in the poll.Whereas those nonsense Vidyasagar and Bharadwaj are included. |
From: Fire on Thu Feb 16 16:28:33 2006. | [Full View] |
From: m_23_bayarea on Thu Feb 16 16:37:18 2006. | [Full View] |
From: interz on Thu Feb 16 17:50:38 2006. | [Full View] |
From: m_23_bayarea on Thu Feb 16 17:55:37 2006. | [Full View] |
interz wrote: |
dude, m bayarea isnt it too late to post that news??? |
From: m_23_bayarea on Fri Feb 17 13:14:51 2006. | [Full View] |
From: m_23_bayarea on Fri Feb 17 13:16:09 2006. | [Full View] |
From: m_23_bayarea on Sat Feb 18 13:36:39 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Ramakrishna on Sat Feb 18 13:39:34 2006. | [Full View] |
m_23_bayarea wrote: |
All ARR and Ajith fans .... Tis time to rejoice ..... ![]() ![]() ![]() __________________________________________________ MUSIC REVIEW : GODFATHER Rahman proves why he is the Godfather of music “I’ll make you an offer you can’t refuse”, said Marlon Brando famously in the cult classic movie Godfather. Now, we aren’t going to the extent of comparing K.S. Ravikumar’s upcoming movie of the same name (starring Ajith and Asin) with arguably the greatest movie of all time (let’s reserve judgment after we have actually seen the film). However, as far as Rahman’s music is concerned, he really has given a score you can’t ignore, if not refuse. But we are getting ahead of ourselves here… 1. Ilamai (Aslam, Tanvi, Shalini) The album kicks off with arguably the pick of the lot, Ilamai. This is a very feel-good, fast paced track that immediately makes you shake your head and tap your feet to its infectious beats. No doubt, this is the track that the youth will make their own, and I can just foresee it being blasted off loudspeakers in cars and FM stations. Rahman’s vintage style is evident in this track’s catchy rhythms. As it has almost become a tradition with all his albums, we also get to hear a remix version of the song by Blaaze. However, the rather-too-short remix does not capture the magic of the original – plus Blaaze’s technically “compressed” voice in the background does get rather annoying. 2. Theeyil Vizhundathey (AR Rahman) The next song features Rahman himself lending his voice to Theeyil Vizhundathey. This very somber piece of music has heavy Arabic influences, and Rahman’s modulating voice appropriately captures the soulful mood required for the song. But after a few listens, you tend to have the nagging feeling that you have heard a similar song in his own Alaipayuthe. 3. Kaatril (SPB, Sadhana Sargam, Bharadwaj) Kaatril is a track that features Sadhana Sargam in a very polished performance, along the incomparable voice of S.P. Balasubramanium. This is one of those tracks that you might just ignore on the first listen, but as nearly always with most of his albums, this song “grows” on you after a while. 4. Thothapuram (Kalpana, Sonukakar, Leon James, Peer Mohamed, Ranjith) Somehow, the song Thothapuram, on the flip side, disappoints – it doesn’t quite strike me as anything out of the ordinary. We have heard songs of this nature a lot of times before in Tamil films, and there is nothing much to talk about. Of course, it is fairly good, but you don’t normally expect Rahman to give “fairly good” songs. 5. Innisai (Naresh, Mahathi) After Ilamai, the other song which is truly worth Rahman’s name is Innisai. This song features beautifully orchestrated Indian classical music, given a Rahman-esque touch – and that is enough to tell you that this track works big time. The very feel of this song is grandiose and extravagant, and I have the feeling that this track would sound even better when watched on the big screen. Innisai also comes with a remix adaptation, and surprisingly, even the remix is wonderful on the ears. 6. Kamma Karaiyil (Naresh, Sowmiya) We have Kamma Karaiyil as the final track of the album. This is the sort of “street-smart” song that we have seen so often in Vijay-starrers – however, Vijay didn’t have the luxury to have a genius like Rahman scoring his music. Therefore, even though this genre is well-known, the song is pretty nice to hear – familiar, but refreshingly different. A great way to close a memorable album. The trouble with reviewing a Rahman album is that you always have to redefine what “good” is. Impressive as that may sound, that’s not always a good thing. We have seen the maestro delivering some of the most unforgettable tracks that Indian cinema has ever heard, so even when he lets his guard down just a tiny little bit, you feel the difference immediately. So even though Godfather is an otherwise superior album, some purists may argue that it does not reach the elite standard that Rahman has set for himself. That may be true, but compared to the kind of film music that is churned out week after week, Rahman is still leagues ahead of them. This year’s super success with the sublimely beautiful Rang de Basanti showed that Rahman has still not lost his touch – and now Godfather proves it once again. |
From: m_23_bayarea on Sat Feb 18 14:01:27 2006. | [Full View] |
From: terminator on Sat Feb 18 15:32:33 2006. | [Full View] |
From: terminator on Sun Feb 19 5:23:55 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Ramakrishna on Sun Feb 19 9:29:34 2006. | [Full View] |
terminator wrote: |
ARR us missed the Repeat King,
Laalaa lalalala S A Rajukumar. |
From: rashid2raj on Sun Feb 19 9:41:11 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Ramakrishna on Sun Feb 19 9:42:42 2006. | [Full View] |
rashid2raj wrote: |
Definetely ARR is the best!! ![]() ![]() ![]() |
From: trisha_krish on Sun Feb 19 9:44:10 2006. | [Full View] |
Ramakrishna wrote: | ||
Tamilnadu is proud of him ![]() |
From: great on Sun Feb 19 9:47:17 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Scale on Sun Feb 19 9:50:38 2006. | [Full View] |
From: trisha_krish on Sun Feb 19 9:57:59 2006. | [Full View] |
great wrote: |
Nithya, cute avtaar ![]() |
From: Aryaz on Sun Feb 19 10:25:21 2006. | [Full View] |
From: great on Sun Feb 19 10:37:21 2006. | [Full View] |
Aryaz wrote: |
Ilayrja - a real master...but he is restricted to Tamilnadu...
ARR - also a real master.....for him sky is the limit....currently he has no comparison! |
From: lancelot on Sun Feb 19 10:47:51 2006. | [Full View] |
great wrote: | ||
good joke ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
From: great on Sun Feb 19 10:53:02 2006. | [Full View] |
lancelot wrote: | ||||
![]() ![]() hehe ![]() |
From: lancelot on Sun Feb 19 10:56:28 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Scale on Sun Feb 19 10:56:34 2006. | [Full View] |
From: great on Sun Feb 19 11:02:55 2006. | [Full View] |
Scale wrote: |
Mistakes are painful when they happen....but..years later a collection of mistakes
is called ... Experience |
From: Shakthiprabha on Sun Feb 19 12:41:37 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Lambretta on Sun Feb 19 14:08:15 2006. | [Full View] |
Surya wrote: |
ARR is good. His music is at its peak in Mani Rathnam movies though. Bombay, Aitha Ezhuthu, Kannathil Muthamittal.
8) |
From: Lambretta on Sun Feb 19 14:10:36 2006. | [Full View] |
Shakthiprabha wrote: |
IR songs are SOUL REACHING |
From: kanya_kris on Sun Feb 19 20:23:38 2006. | [Full View] |
From: kb on Sun Feb 19 20:36:46 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Ghlli on Sun Feb 19 20:48:10 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Sanguine Sridhar on Sun Feb 19 21:32:37 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Scale on Mon Feb 20 1:00:38 2006. | [Full View] |
Beckham wrote: |
I dont know why you guyz compare two masters ![]() But without any electronic instruments,Computers,Softwares a God gave thousands of best tunes... IR a master. Innoruthan porandhu varanum... ![]() Ilamayenum Poongaatru... Vai garayil Vaigai karayil.... Raasathi Unna.... Malayorum veesum kaatru.... Thendral vandhu theendum podhu.... Hmmm.... ![]() |
From: terminator on Mon Feb 20 1:07:16 2006. | [Full View] |
From: terminator on Mon Feb 20 1:19:42 2006. | [Full View] |
kanya_kris wrote: |
My goodness. ARR getting more votes than IR..
My favourite is IR.. Several of IR songs are everlasting. Total number of movies IR worked as MD > Total number of songs ARR tuned. It is totally unfair. ![]() |
From: swathy on Mon Feb 20 1:24:16 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Scale on Mon Feb 20 1:25:02 2006. | [Full View] |
terminator wrote: |
M S V > I R > A R R |
From: terminator on Mon Feb 20 4:49:44 2006. | [Full View] |
Scale wrote: |
Absolutely stunning melodies. 1. Raasathi (TT) (No Instruments at all with fem chorus & SH vocals) 2. Kadhalan Bit songs (Minimal Instruments) 3. Uyire (Min Instruments) 4. Thoda Thoda (Min Instruments) 5. Thenkizhakku Cheemayile 6. Kadhal Rojave (Underplayed w/ instruments) 7. Karuthamma title track (kunjaramma song) 8. Oru Naal Oru Pozhudhu (Andhimantharai) Many in HINDI. Listen to Zubeida, Tehzeeb (3), WATER.... Do you need anything with instruments none can even dream about it. ARR is the MASTER of composing at different GENRES. ![]() |
From: Sanguine Sridhar on Mon Feb 20 8:02:02 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Shakthiprabha on Mon Feb 20 8:34:49 2006. | [Full View] |
Lambretta wrote: | ||
Yup, no doubt! ![]() ![]() Btw, rite now listening to the song "Ninaivo oru paravai" from Sigappu Rojakkal (1978), one of the early films w/ IR's music! I jus love the interludes/background music in his compositions! ![]() |
From: Shakthiprabha on Mon Feb 20 8:40:37 2006. | [Full View] |
From: great on Mon Feb 20 9:31:33 2006. | [Full View] |
Shakthiprabha wrote: |
I would like to MENTION my fav (oldtime) MUSIC DIRECTORS HERE.
M.S.Vishwanathan/ramamoorthy M.S.Vishwanathan K.V.Mahadevan Sudharshanam AM.Raja HamsalEkha VEdha T.RAjendar K.Bhagyaraj Lakshmikant pyarE laal Gangai amaran Ilaiyaraja A.R.Rehmaan Harris Jayaraj. |
From: Scale on Mon Feb 20 9:33:05 2006. | [Full View] |
Beckham wrote: |
Cool Scale,
I am a big ARR fan too (Hope you know that ![]() ![]() |
From: nilavupriyan on Mon Feb 20 9:41:42 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Thirumaran on Mon Feb 20 9:48:48 2006. | [Full View] |
From: great on Mon Feb 20 9:50:38 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Thirumaran on Mon Feb 20 9:55:15 2006. | [Full View] |
great wrote: |
Thiru, are u sure 900 is the correct number bcoz anjali was his 600th movie ![]() |
From: Scale on Mon Feb 20 10:06:54 2006. | [Full View] |
Thirumaran wrote: |
I heard within 25 minutes [/b]he finalised all the songs for Chinna Thambi. |
From: selvakumar on Mon Feb 20 10:10:08 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Shakthiprabha on Mon Feb 20 10:25:48 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Thirumaran on Mon Feb 20 10:26:46 2006. | [Full View] |
Scale wrote: | ||
U heard,rite? ![]() |
From: great on Mon Feb 20 10:27:14 2006. | [Full View] |
Shakthiprabha wrote: |
Great,,,
I dont like SA.RAJKUMAR much. Sirpi........ hmm....... Can u list some hit songs of S.A.R and sirpi or others. |
From: nilavupriyan on Mon Feb 20 10:27:28 2006. | [Full View] |
From: alwarpet_andavan on Mon Feb 20 10:28:28 2006. | [Full View] |
Shakthiprabha wrote: |
Great,,,
I dont like SA.RAJKUMAR much. Sirpi........ hmm....... Can u list some hit songs of S.A.R and sirpi or others. |
From: Fire on Mon Feb 20 10:30:14 2006. | [Full View] |
From: alwarpet_andavan on Mon Feb 20 10:30:23 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Fire on Mon Feb 20 10:32:12 2006. | [Full View] |
alwarpet_andavan wrote: |
Why has nobody mentioned Srikanth Deva? |
From: selvakumar on Mon Feb 20 10:32:24 2006. | [Full View] |
alwarpet_andavan wrote: |
Why has nobody mentioned Srikanth Deva? |
From: great on Mon Feb 20 10:32:37 2006. | [Full View] |
alwarpet_andavan wrote: |
Why has nobody mentioned Srikanth Deva? |
From: Shakthiprabha on Mon Feb 20 10:36:02 2006. | [Full View] |
From: alwarpet_andavan on Mon Feb 20 10:36:52 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Shakthiprabha on Mon Feb 20 10:41:18 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Fire on Mon Feb 20 10:41:42 2006. | [Full View] |
alwarpet_andavan wrote: |
Fire, Selva and Great,
Srikanth Deva-va kokka? Can IR or ARR give a swashbuckling "Ennatha Solvenungo"?? Or the lilting original melody "Chennai Senthamizh"??? TELL, TELL, TALK ME!!! |
From: selvakumar on Mon Feb 20 10:42:19 2006. | [Full View] |
alwarpet_andavan wrote: |
Fire, Selva and Great,
Srikanth Deva-va kokka? Can IR or ARR give a swashbuckling "Ennatha Solvenungo"?? Or the lilting original melody "Chennai Senthamizh"??? TELL, TELL, TALK ME!!! |
From: Thirumaran on Mon Feb 20 10:42:19 2006. | [Full View] |
From: selvakumar on Mon Feb 20 10:43:12 2006. | [Full View] |
Fire wrote: | ||
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
From: great on Mon Feb 20 10:43:17 2006. | [Full View] |
alwarpet_andavan wrote: |
Fire, Selva and Great,
Srikanth Deva-va kokka? Can IR or ARR give a swashbuckling "Ennatha Solvenungo"?? Or the lilting original melody "Chennai Senthamizh"??? TELL, TELL, TALK ME!!! |
From: Shakthiprabha on Mon Feb 20 10:43:40 2006. | [Full View] |
From: great on Mon Feb 20 10:45:02 2006. | [Full View] |
Shakthiprabha wrote: |
I mentioned THIRU.
T.R is a great music director. ![]() |
From: Ramakrishna on Mon Feb 20 10:45:06 2006. | [Full View] |
alwarpet_andavan wrote: |
Fire, Selva and Great,
Srikanth Deva-va kokka? Can IR or ARR give a swashbuckling "Ennatha Solvenungo"?? Or the lilting original melody "Chennai Senthamizh"??? TELL, TELL, TALK ME!!! |
From: alwarpet_andavan on Mon Feb 20 10:47:02 2006. | [Full View] |
Fire wrote: |
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
From: Thirumaran on Mon Feb 20 10:48:03 2006. | [Full View] |
Shakthiprabha wrote: |
I mentioned THIRU.
T.R is a great music director. ![]() |
From: great on Mon Feb 20 10:49:12 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Shakthiprabha on Mon Feb 20 10:55:35 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Scale on Mon Feb 20 10:56:20 2006. | [Full View] |
Thirumaran wrote: | ||||
Nice one. By the way, the following links says the same. http://www.behindwoods.com/features/Topten/legends/tamil-cinema-legend-1.html http://www.geocities.com/ilaiyaragam/titbits.htm ![]() |
Quote: |
Sithiram Pesudhadi
A.R.Rahman composed and recorded the western classical piece “Waltz of Romance” for Lagaan in just one night. Satyajit Bhatkal in his book “Spirit of Lagaan”, admires the genius of A.R.Rahman for making such a piece with just a single keyboard which sounds like that of played by a 50 piece orchestra. |
From: great on Mon Feb 20 10:58:34 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Scale on Mon Feb 20 11:02:17 2006. | [Full View] |
alwarpet_andavan wrote: |
Fire, Selva and Great,
Srikanth Deva-va kokka? Can IR or ARR give a swashbuckling "Ennatha Solvenungo"?? Or the lilting original melody "Chennai Senthamizh"??? TELL, TELL, TALK ME!!! |
From: Shakthiprabha on Mon Feb 20 11:03:41 2006. | [Full View] |
From: great on Mon Feb 20 11:04:18 2006. | [Full View] |
From: great on Mon Feb 20 11:06:41 2006. | [Full View] |
Scale wrote: | ||
A_A, Ennatha solla The greatest fusion anyone can ever think his Salomiya version of JUNOON's Saiyonee.... |
From: Shakthiprabha on Mon Feb 20 11:11:51 2006. | [Full View] |
From: great on Mon Feb 20 11:13:24 2006. | [Full View] |
Shakthiprabha wrote: |
what do u mean?
who tried junoon's sayonee? |
From: Shakthiprabha on Mon Feb 20 11:15:27 2006. | [Full View] |
From: great on Mon Feb 20 11:17:29 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Shakthiprabha on Mon Feb 20 12:55:40 2006. | [Full View] |
From: terminator on Mon Feb 20 13:09:06 2006. | [Full View] |
alwarpet_andavan wrote: |
Fire, Selva and Great,
Srikanth Deva-va kokka? Can IR or ARR give a swashbuckling "Ennatha Solvenungo"?? Or the lilting original melody "Chennai Senthamizh"??? TELL, TELL, TALK ME!!! |
From: m_23_bayarea on Mon Feb 20 15:37:08 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Ghlli on Mon Feb 20 19:36:40 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Nerd on Mon Feb 20 20:31:46 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Ghlli on Mon Feb 20 20:44:01 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Nerd on Mon Feb 20 20:48:41 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Alien on Mon Feb 20 22:15:23 2006. | [Full View] |
great wrote: | ||||
saiyonee.....whos next ![]() Deva tried this is kannethirae thondrinal * prashant and simran...... karuvadu etc etc will come in the lyrics , shot in goa next version by genius S.a.rajkumar in TMT ........ innisai padi varam |
From: great on Mon Feb 20 22:44:50 2006. | [Full View] |
vasanth_luv wrote: | ||||||
Thatz not "innisai paadi varum" , but "Megamai vanthu pOgirEn" and Salomiaa or something in KannethirEy thOndrinaaL |
From: Alien on Mon Feb 20 22:51:04 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Sanguine Sridhar on Mon Feb 20 22:53:45 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Alien on Mon Feb 20 22:55:20 2006. | [Full View] |
Beckham wrote: |
Harris Jeyaraj!! He is impressive.No doubt that he leads the recent MD's list. |
From: alwarpet_andavan on Tue Feb 21 5:11:11 2006. | [Full View] |
Ghlli wrote: |
i never heard about him....yea yea i'm bad on direcotrs and music directors, i dont know much...so which films did he do songs for??? |
From: Fire on Tue Feb 21 5:17:23 2006. | [Full View] |
vasanth_luv wrote: | ||
Yes, I second u beckham ![]() |
From: selvakumar on Tue Feb 21 5:25:41 2006. | [Full View] |
Fire wrote: | ||||
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
From: Fire on Tue Feb 21 5:28:02 2006. | [Full View] |
selvakumar wrote: | ||||||
For others: plagiarize, UK USUALLY plagiarise verb [I or T] to use another person's idea or a part of their work and pretend that it is your own: http://dictionary.cambridge.org/define.asp?key=60393&dict=CALD coz there is some spelling mistake in the post.. NO offense meant Fire maapillai.. |
From: selvakumar on Tue Feb 21 5:29:56 2006. | [Full View] |
Fire wrote: |
selva anne just solleenrnthaa podume , dictionary link ellam thareengale.... |
From: rajasaranam on Tue Feb 21 6:37:57 2006. | [Full View] |
From: alwarpet_andavan on Tue Feb 21 6:44:28 2006. | [Full View] |
From: gganesh on Wed Feb 22 5:20:51 2006. | [Full View] |
From: m_23_bayarea on Wed Feb 22 9:47:23 2006. | [Full View] |
From: r_o_j_a on Wed Feb 22 9:47:57 2006. | [Full View] |
From: interz on Wed Feb 22 11:26:06 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Shakthiprabha on Wed Feb 22 11:47:02 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Ramakrishna on Wed Feb 22 11:51:02 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Scale on Wed Feb 22 12:08:42 2006. | [Full View] |
interz wrote: |
does it?? cant we ( or I) favourize other mds more than mr rahumaaan |
From: Shakthiprabha on Wed Feb 22 12:14:52 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Sanjeevi on Wed Feb 22 12:45:01 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Shakthiprabha on Wed Feb 22 12:50:13 2006. | [Full View] |
From: terminator on Wed Feb 22 13:04:42 2006. | [Full View] |
Sanjeevi wrote: |
hmmm
ithana flop koduthum ARR niraiya votes vangiyirukkaru ![]() |
From: Ramakrishna on Wed Feb 22 13:06:31 2006. | [Full View] |
terminator wrote: | ||
Floppa ? ![]() |
From: Shakthiprabha on Wed Feb 22 13:29:30 2006. | [Full View] |
From: lancelot on Wed Feb 22 13:38:32 2006. | [Full View] |
Sanjeevi wrote: |
hmmm
ithana hit koduthum ARR niraiya votes vangiyirukkaru ![]() |
From: Sanjeevi on Wed Feb 22 13:48:31 2006. | [Full View] |
lancelot wrote: | ||
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() hehe ![]() |
From: lancelot on Wed Feb 22 13:51:54 2006. | [Full View] |
Sanjeevi wrote: | ||||
hei lance ![]() neenga ellam hit nu vachu kitta ithana hit koduthum ARR ivvalavu than votes vangiyirukkaru ![]() ![]() ![]() |
From: MADDY on Wed Feb 22 18:59:57 2006. | [Full View] |
From: gorgeous gaayini on Wed Feb 22 19:38:33 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Kollywoodfan on Wed Feb 22 19:42:26 2006. | [Full View] |
From: gorgeous gaayini on Wed Feb 22 19:43:13 2006. | [Full View] |
Kollywoodfan wrote: |
Wow ur original id!! Awesome!! ![]() ![]() ![]() |
From: m_23_bayarea on Thu Feb 23 12:28:36 2006. | [Full View] |
From: m_23_bayarea on Thu Feb 23 13:11:57 2006. | [Full View] |
From: m_23_bayarea on Tue Feb 28 12:41:00 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Ramakrishna on Tue Feb 28 12:42:33 2006. | [Full View] |
m_23_bayarea wrote: |
Yuvan rocks with `Pattiyal` audio
Tuesday, 28 February , 2006, 09:16 The audio launch of S.G.Films ‘Punnagaipoove’ Geeta’s Pattiyal directed by Vishnuvardhan turned out to be an evening of young guns at the GRT Grand Days in Chennai on Monday (Feb 27). It was a very informal function with no big stars, lengthy speeches, lighting of kuthuvilakku and the usual screening of songs. The lead cast of Arya, Bharath, Pooja and Padmapriya along with Vishnuvardhan and producer Geeta were mingling with the guests and the media in a casual manner. It was also a reunion of sorts for the young guns of Kollywood who played the recent Cricket match like Captain Abbas, Vikraant, Jeeva, Ramesh, Srikanth, Simbu, Ramana, Arun Kumar, Vishal with Madhumita, Pa Vijay and Kalyan master. However the star of the evening was none other than music director Yuvan Shankar Raja who preferred to maintain his usual cool style. But the cynosure of all eyes was ‘Punnagaipoove’ Geeta who was referred as the most beautiful and vibrant producer of Kollywood, who herself looked more glamourous than her leading ladies! And in one word the music of Yuvan rocks in Pattiyal. Vishuvardhan- Yuvan team has a winner after last year’s Arindhum Ariyamalum. |
From: m_23_bayarea on Fri Mar 3 14:52:55 2006. | [Full View] |
From: THALABATHY on Sat Mar 4 2:59:33 2006. | [Full View] |
From: great on Sat Mar 4 5:02:51 2006. | [Full View] |
THALABATHY wrote: |
EVRY 1 KNOW LA
MY VOTE GOES TO "THE MUSIC" |
From: interz on Sat Mar 4 9:00:08 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Scale on Sat Mar 4 9:20:47 2006. | [Full View] |
From: njv on Mon Mar 6 13:34:29 2006. | [Full View] |
interz wrote: |
ILayaraja is just part of music like E R RaguMean, Yuvan Thonguraja, Hari rice Jeyraj , Vidyasa Sakar, not music itself!!!!!!!! |
From: Shakthiprabha on Mon Mar 6 14:01:41 2006. | [Full View] |
From: interz on Mon Mar 6 18:44:33 2006. | [Full View] |
From: great on Mon Mar 6 22:36:13 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Shakthiprabha on Tue Mar 7 3:06:27 2006. | [Full View] |
From: m_23_bayarea on Thu Mar 9 13:24:23 2006. | [Full View] |
From: m_23_bayarea on Sat Mar 11 14:14:28 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Kollywoodfan on Sat Mar 11 14:14:56 2006. | [Full View] |
From: m_23_bayarea on Sat Mar 11 14:16:24 2006. | [Full View] |
Kollywoodfan wrote: |
back from the library?? ![]() |
From: interz on Sat Mar 11 14:18:44 2006. | [Full View] |
Quote: |
he is still the king of Tamil cinema music.
|
From: m_23_bayarea on Sat Mar 11 14:21:33 2006. | [Full View] |
interz wrote: | ||
but you and i have to admit ARR is king of Indian Movie Music ![]() |
From: Justice on Sat Mar 11 14:22:59 2006. | [Full View] |
interz wrote: | ||
but you and i have to admit ARR is king of Indian Movie Music ![]() |
From: Shakthiprabha on Sat Mar 11 14:24:39 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Justice on Sat Mar 11 14:32:17 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Shakthiprabha on Sat Mar 11 15:06:06 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Priyankak on Sat Mar 11 15:52:38 2006. | [Full View] |
From: swathy on Sun Mar 12 7:31:43 2006. | [Full View] |
Justice wrote: | ||||
he may be king as u say but IR is the GOD ![]() |
From: swathy on Sun Mar 12 7:35:21 2006. | [Full View] |
From: selvakumar on Sun Mar 12 7:40:05 2006. | [Full View] |
swathy wrote: |
I request the author of the thread to remove the first name from this poll as he belongs to the legend category . |
From: interz on Sun Mar 12 13:14:17 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Scale on Sun Mar 12 13:17:46 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Shakthiprabha on Sun Mar 12 13:41:04 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Scale on Mon Mar 13 1:55:14 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Kollywoodfan on Tue Mar 14 0:46:25 2006. | [Full View] |
From: m_23_bayarea on Tue Mar 14 1:16:54 2006. | [Full View] |
Kollywoodfan wrote: |
Where is Harris Jeyaraj?? ![]() ![]() |
From: Kollywoodfan on Tue Mar 14 1:22:11 2006. | [Full View] |
m_23_bayarea wrote: | ||
I guess your question, and the author of this thread's not naming HJ, answers the title of this thread .... ![]() ![]() |
From: Scale on Tue Mar 14 2:45:47 2006. | [Full View] |
From: selvakumar on Tue Mar 14 3:19:35 2006. | [Full View] |
Scale wrote: |
Baseless conclusions. ![]() p/s: I am biased verymuch towards a r r but definetly not a "hatred" of any MD. |
From: Scale on Tue Mar 14 3:31:50 2006. | [Full View] |
From: selvakumar on Tue Mar 14 4:08:59 2006. | [Full View] |
Scale wrote: |
edhukku kooda serndhu vurulura. ![]() ![]() |
From: Kollywoodfan on Tue Mar 14 13:43:43 2006. | [Full View] |
From: m_23_bayarea on Tue Mar 14 14:06:39 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Scale on Wed Mar 15 2:55:03 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Kollywoodfan on Wed Mar 15 13:23:49 2006. | [Full View] |
Scale wrote: |
Kolly, Uyirile is a sweet melody, haunting vocals(Maha & Srini) with simple orchestration. Good Pick. I spotted it on the first listening itslef. Keep going! MOD pls include HJ as well.
My request, HJ pls forget ARR, "Rhythm-programming", string instruments (there are many others)& a mix of classical interludes . YSR froget remix, re-hash, take guidance from IR for eternal melodies. ARR stop composing for movies. |
From: Scale on Thu Mar 16 1:01:21 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Scale on Thu Mar 16 1:02:13 2006. | [Full View] |
From: m_23_bayarea on Thu Mar 16 17:42:47 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Kollywoodfan on Thu Mar 16 17:43:49 2006. | [Full View] |
From: m_23_bayarea on Thu Mar 16 17:56:11 2006. | [Full View] |
Kollywoodfan wrote: |
GO for it!! HJ is the man!! ![]() |
From: Thirumaran on Thu Mar 16 17:59:10 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Ramakrishna on Thu Mar 23 11:40:16 2006. | [Full View] |
From: m_23_bayarea on Thu Mar 23 12:57:08 2006. | [Full View] |
From: m_23_bayarea on Thu Mar 23 13:35:59 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Kollywoodfan on Thu Mar 23 17:59:39 2006. | [Full View] |
From: m_23_bayarea on Thu Mar 23 18:00:35 2006. | [Full View] |
Kollywoodfan wrote: |
HR rocks! |
From: Kollywoodfan on Thu Mar 23 18:02:58 2006. | [Full View] |
From: m_23_bayarea on Thu Mar 23 18:03:44 2006. | [Full View] |
Kollywoodfan wrote: |
his every song is a chartbuster...and each one rightfully deserves the title!! |
From: Kollywoodfan on Thu Mar 23 18:04:47 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Raikkonen on Thu Mar 23 22:10:36 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Kollywoodfan on Thu Mar 23 23:01:21 2006. | [Full View] |
Raikkonen wrote: |
I hate HJ....
I like Imaan Mattu Mattu, super ghana song with Vijay and Priyanka |
From: Raikkonen on Thu Mar 23 23:05:35 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Kollywoodfan on Thu Mar 23 23:08:27 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Raikkonen on Thu Mar 23 23:09:56 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Kollywoodfan on Thu Mar 23 23:12:33 2006. | [Full View] |
Raikkonen wrote: |
Ok |
From: Raikkonen on Thu Mar 23 23:14:08 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Kollywoodfan on Thu Mar 23 23:21:11 2006. | [Full View] |
Raikkonen wrote: |
Enakku epdi Perarasuvo
Apdi ugalukku HJ I take in that manner |
From: Raikkonen on Thu Mar 23 23:26:53 2006. | [Full View] |
From: kidils on Fri Mar 24 0:41:01 2006. | [Full View] |
From: rami on Fri Mar 24 3:05:28 2006. | [Full View] |
Sandeep wrote: |
I was really split between Ilayaraja and Rahman. But Rahman got my vote because he has more range that Ilayaraja. While Ilayaraja seems to limit himself to one style (folk i feel) Rahman uses indian, western, even some african folk styles in his music. And thats why his popurality is not just limited to south india, or one generation |
From: rami on Fri Mar 24 3:06:24 2006. | [Full View] |
From: m_23_bayarea on Fri Mar 24 12:51:25 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Raikkonen on Sat Mar 25 12:01:32 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Raikkonen on Mon Mar 27 1:21:36 2006. | [Full View] |
From: m_23_bayarea on Mon Mar 27 1:27:22 2006. | [Full View] |
Raikkonen wrote: |
HJ king of copy |
From: Raikkonen on Mon Mar 27 1:27:58 2006. | [Full View] |
From: m_23_bayarea on Mon Mar 27 1:29:24 2006. | [Full View] |
Raikkonen wrote: |
Sorry bay..
Ive changed to Copycat Thalayan |
From: Raikkonen on Mon Mar 27 1:31:25 2006. | [Full View] |
From: villan007 on Mon Mar 27 1:32:07 2006. | [Full View] |
m_23_bayarea wrote: | ||
![]() ![]() ![]() NTR happens to be my friend ... Illa naaa !!! ![]() ![]() |
From: m_23_bayarea on Mon Mar 27 1:33:16 2006. | [Full View] |
villan007 wrote: |
illa na .... ![]() rendu kolai vizhuma ![]() ![]() ![]() |
From: Raikkonen on Mon Mar 27 1:34:32 2006. | [Full View] |
From: m_23_bayarea on Mon Mar 27 1:36:29 2006. | [Full View] |
Raikkonen wrote: |
i like
Devisri Prasad, Imaan, Manisharma, Srikanth Deva.. U fancy them? Bay? |
From: Raikkonen on Mon Mar 27 1:36:55 2006. | [Full View] |
From: villan007 on Mon Mar 27 1:37:03 2006. | [Full View] |
Raikkonen wrote: |
i like
Devisri Prasad, Imaan, Manisharma, Srikanth Deva.. U fancy them? Bay? |
From: Raikkonen on Mon Mar 27 1:41:20 2006. | [Full View] |
From: m_23_bayarea on Mon Mar 27 9:07:33 2006. | [Full View] |
From: gorgeous gaayini on Mon Mar 27 12:50:16 2006. | [Full View] |
From: m_23_bayarea on Mon Mar 27 13:03:17 2006. | [Full View] |
gorgeous gaayini wrote: |
Well done on your 5000 posts bay anna! ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
From: Kamalan on Mon Mar 27 14:18:47 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Sanjeevi on Mon Mar 27 14:54:07 2006. | [Full View] |
Kamalan wrote: |
i am listening to the mahanadi album for the past 5 to 6 hours continously....... i cant stop it...... its soooooooooooooooooo good.... illayaraaja pola varaathu...... illayaraaja is the best.... if IR and kamal come together, then they will take us to heaven...... |
From: gorgeous gaayini on Mon Mar 27 15:23:33 2006. | [Full View] |
From: interz on Mon Mar 27 16:06:27 2006. | [Full View] |
From: manmadan on Mon Mar 27 16:17:35 2006. | [Full View] |
From: gorgeous gaayini on Mon Mar 27 17:47:28 2006. | [Full View] |
From: manmadan on Mon Mar 27 18:01:52 2006. | [Full View] |
gorgeous gaayini wrote: |
OOOOOOOOOOOO I LOVE YUVAN SHANKAR RAJAS SONGS...THEY R SOO GOOD...WELL MOST THE TIME... |
From: captain on Mon Mar 27 18:09:15 2006. | [Full View] |
From: gorgeous gaayini on Mon Mar 27 18:11:54 2006. | [Full View] |
From: m_23_bayarea on Wed Mar 29 13:01:56 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Thirumaran on Wed Mar 29 13:06:15 2006. | [Full View] |
captain wrote: |
YSR is the MAN at the moment ![]() |
From: Sanjeevi on Wed Mar 29 13:07:04 2006. | [Full View] |
From: interz on Wed Mar 29 17:41:24 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Ghlli on Wed Mar 29 17:44:39 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Kollywoodfan on Wed Mar 29 19:32:17 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Raikkonen on Wed Mar 29 23:10:52 2006. | [Full View] |
From: captain on Wed Mar 29 23:12:45 2006. | [Full View] |
Ghlli wrote: |
hmmm i liked the boom boom song the best in tht movie! ![]() |
From: Ghlli on Thu Mar 30 11:49:02 2006. | [Full View] |
captain wrote: | ||
and the total album was awesome ![]() ![]() |
From: m_23_bayarea on Thu Mar 30 13:09:25 2006. | [Full View] |
From: m_23_bayarea on Thu Mar 30 15:50:29 2006. | [Full View] |
From: njv on Thu Mar 30 16:10:46 2006. | [Full View] |
m_23_bayarea wrote: |
Harris Jeyaraj going Tollywood
IndiaGlitz [Thursday, March 30, 2006] After Yuvan Shankar Raja, it's now Harris Jeyaraj's turn to venture to Tollywood. Following the success of his tunes in Ghajini and Anniyan, Haris has won fans not just in Tamil Nadu but also Telugu filmdom. |
From: m_23_bayarea on Thu Mar 30 16:12:34 2006. | [Full View] |
njv wrote: | ||
HJ will also be composing music for Ghajni remake in Hindi, *ing Amir Khan. HJ goes national now. Wonder when he will score music for Lord of the rings. |
From: Raikkonen on Thu Mar 30 22:43:28 2006. | [Full View] |
From: interz on Fri Mar 31 8:54:00 2006. | [Full View] |
From: captain on Fri Mar 31 9:00:04 2006. | [Full View] |
From: m_23_bayarea on Fri Mar 31 10:39:50 2006. | [Full View] |
From: m_23_bayarea on Fri Mar 31 14:30:07 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Raikkonen on Sun Apr 2 14:36:27 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Ramakrishna on Sun Apr 2 14:37:15 2006. | [Full View] |
Raikkonen wrote: |
Deva is the best... |
From: Raikkonen on Sun Apr 2 14:38:39 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Ramakrishna on Sun Apr 2 14:40:08 2006. | [Full View] |
Raikkonen wrote: |
Ada Thenisai Thendral Deva |
From: Raikkonen on Sun Apr 2 14:41:14 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Ramakrishna on Sun Apr 2 14:42:32 2006. | [Full View] |
Raikkonen wrote: |
adapavvi..
Ipditha nee adress pannuviya? |
From: svaisn on Sun Apr 2 16:04:23 2006. | [Full View] |
Raikkonen wrote: |
Deva is the best... |
From: m_23_bayarea on Sun Apr 2 17:02:52 2006. | [Full View] |
Ramakrishna wrote: | ||
Oh.... that Katipudi Deva. |
From: Raikkonen on Sun Apr 2 22:27:02 2006. | [Full View] |
From: m_23_bayarea on Sun Apr 2 22:30:44 2006. | [Full View] |
Raikkonen wrote: |
Best of Ghana...
He rocks in BGM of Kushi |
From: Raikkonen on Sun Apr 2 22:31:39 2006. | [Full View] |
From: m_23_bayarea on Sun Apr 2 22:33:13 2006. | [Full View] |
Raikkonen wrote: |
Guess what Badsha and Annamalai are my fav Rajni movies ever... |
From: Raikkonen on Sun Apr 2 22:34:11 2006. | [Full View] |
From: interz on Mon Apr 3 6:56:35 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Kailash on Mon Apr 3 7:30:36 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Renault on Mon Apr 3 8:17:29 2006. | [Full View] |
From: m_23_bayarea on Wed Apr 5 12:15:49 2006. | [Full View] |
From: m_23_bayarea on Tue Apr 18 7:07:24 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Hulkster on Tue Apr 18 8:22:56 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Kamalan on Tue Apr 18 8:38:15 2006. | [Full View] |
Hulkster wrote: |
Music Director poll leh maestroku ellam enna velai?...Maestro Illayaraja has proven himself in all types of music especially WCM and jazz and indian folk music, has composed a symphony consisting of five movements and running at the length of over an hour in one month and is critically acclaimed for his musical pieces how to name it and nothing but wind all over the world. His orchestration and instrumentation is one of the best in the world or perhaps the best and is probably the fastest ever music composer in the world.
Illayarajavae oru maestro(meaning master = best in india)...approm unnum enna best MD?...please do not list Illayaraja in best MD poll. |
From: Hulkster on Tue Apr 18 9:27:55 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Kamalan on Tue Apr 18 9:31:32 2006. | [Full View] |
Hulkster wrote: |
Nandri kamalan...unmaiyai thaan pa sonnein veru unnum ellei...mattavanga tappa ninaichikathaenge...![]() |
From: vj_itv on Tue Apr 18 9:52:09 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Ghlli on Tue Apr 18 14:23:48 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Thirumaran on Tue Apr 18 14:26:23 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Kamalan on Tue Apr 18 14:38:21 2006. | [Full View] |
Thirumaran wrote: |
IR is the best Music Director TN had ever produced ![]() |
From: Ghlli on Tue Apr 18 14:53:58 2006. | [Full View] |
From: girishk14 on Wed Apr 19 3:28:00 2006. | [Full View] |
From: m_23_bayarea on Wed Apr 19 11:30:15 2006. | [Full View] |
From: m_23_bayarea on Wed Apr 19 21:18:23 2006. | [Full View] |
From: imsai on Wed Apr 19 21:29:14 2006. | [Full View] |
From: m_23_bayarea on Wed Apr 19 21:51:28 2006. | [Full View] |
wizard wrote: |
I've seen it bay area, that was awesome. |
From: Kollywoodfan on Wed Apr 19 22:34:40 2006. | [Full View] |
From: vaidy on Thu Apr 20 12:50:13 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Kamalan on Thu Apr 20 12:54:00 2006. | [Full View] |
vaidy wrote: |
Here vaidy again. Great to see votes being polled for music directors ha ha.
MSV didn't find a place there because obviously he is a creator and not a director!!!! Caught all of you! Long Live MSV and his Immortal melodies. |
From: Kamalan on Thu Apr 20 13:08:18 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Djpak on Thu Apr 20 13:25:39 2006. | [Full View] |
Kamalan wrote: | ||
![]() |
From: Thunderbird on Fri Apr 21 0:41:06 2006. | [Full View] |
Djpak wrote: |
Sure sure ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() IR have been md many years then ARR and not get the big international succes, like Isai Puyal ARR ![]() Load of rings musical in europa and amerika And allways compressed music to MANI RATNAM who is known many place round the world ![]() Actually Arr is rocking India with the recent one: Rang De Basanti ![]() |
From: psychiatrist on Fri Apr 21 2:08:15 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Thunderbird on Fri Apr 21 2:14:27 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Hulkster on Fri Apr 21 2:33:30 2006. | [Full View] |
From: m_23_bayarea on Fri Apr 21 16:34:54 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Kollywoodfan on Fri Apr 21 20:48:08 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Thunderbird on Fri Apr 21 23:13:49 2006. | [Full View] |
From: kb on Fri Apr 21 23:34:03 2006. | [Full View] |
From: m_23_bayarea on Sat Apr 22 14:44:23 2006. | [Full View] |
Kollywoodfan wrote: |
Hmm...His paatiyal was also good...but still I feel the best, besides ARR and all, is HJ! ![]() |
From: girishk14 on Sat Apr 22 22:55:00 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Sanguine Sridhar on Sat Apr 22 23:14:05 2006. | [Full View] |
girishk14 wrote: |
I seriously don't understand why Illayaraja is so famous. Ar Rahman is thousand times better and I like all his albums. But..what hits has Illayaraja given recently? ![]() |
From: girishk14 on Sat Apr 22 23:22:53 2006. | [Full View] |
Sanguine Sridhar wrote: | ||
Hmmm Girish!! You should have born a bit earlier!! Your fav hero is Jeeva is it ![]() |
From: Sanguine Sridhar on Sat Apr 22 23:26:10 2006. | [Full View] |
girishk14 wrote: | ||||
Ok..I am only 14 years old. I can appreciate AR Rahman but what is so great about Illayaraja. Why is it he has recieved 50 votes. What is his recent hit? My favourite actors are Jeeva, Surya and Madhavan... |
From: Hulkster on Sat Apr 22 23:39:14 2006. | [Full View] |
Sanguine Sridhar wrote: | ||||||
Don worry Girish all those 50 are ruthless idiots which includes me!! ![]() ![]() |
From: kidils on Sun Apr 23 0:14:06 2006. | [Full View] |
Quote: |
Ok..I am only 14 years old. |
From: Hulkster on Sun Apr 23 0:18:34 2006. | [Full View] |
From: kidils on Sun Apr 23 0:33:54 2006. | [Full View] |
From: thamizhvaanan on Sun Apr 23 0:38:06 2006. | [Full View] |
Hulkster wrote: |
Age should not be a factor in appreciating music in what it truly is...im 19 and im a IR fan and also partly a ARR fan....we are gifted to have both of them here in TFM but to say ARR is thousand times better than IR shows that your yet to listen to IR's music.
Disclaimer: Listen to music and understand the various forms like baroque,WCM,folk,fusion,jazz and then listen to IR cos his music has various songs in each and every section of music. |
From: kb on Sun Apr 23 0:42:10 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Alien on Sun Apr 23 0:43:38 2006. | [Full View] |
thamizhvaanan wrote: |
![]() ![]() PS: I know a lotta ppl who dont like IRs music and i dont know why. I thot IRs music even at its worst state of appreciation should sound like 'likeable candy tunes'. they say it sounds boring, thinking back i had the same thots b4 |
From: thamizhvaanan on Sun Apr 23 0:46:47 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Hulkster on Sun Apr 23 0:51:47 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Sanjeevi on Sun Apr 23 4:26:45 2006. | [Full View] |
From: villan007 on Sun Apr 23 4:31:59 2006. | [Full View] |
Sanjeevi wrote: |
-deleted- |
From: thamizhvaanan on Sun Apr 23 7:23:48 2006. | [Full View] |
From: psychiatrist on Sun Apr 23 7:53:37 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Hulkster on Sun Apr 23 8:54:46 2006. | [Full View] |
From: thamizhvaanan on Sun Apr 23 12:55:00 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Hulkster on Sun Apr 23 20:45:58 2006. | [Full View] |
From: thamizhvaanan on Mon Apr 24 0:44:41 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Djpak on Mon Apr 24 5:59:01 2006. | [Full View] |
Thunderbird wrote: | ||
how many places? ![]() mallika srewat is internationaly known ![]() ![]() ARR is internationaly known ![]() ![]() |
From: Thunderbird on Mon Apr 24 6:11:07 2006. | [Full View] |
Djpak wrote: |
ARR = Aishwarya ![]() IR = Rani muherji |
From: girishk14 on Tue Apr 25 6:08:10 2006. | [Full View] |
From: m_23_bayarea on Tue Apr 25 11:45:14 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Ramakrishna on Wed Apr 26 11:22:18 2006. | [Full View] |
From: m_23_bayarea on Wed Apr 26 12:01:44 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Raikkonen on Wed Apr 26 12:03:21 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Ramakrishna on Fri Apr 28 9:27:15 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Ramakrishna on Fri Apr 28 11:10:50 2006. | [Full View] |
From: m_23_bayarea on Fri Apr 28 14:05:33 2006. | [Full View] |
From: njv on Fri Apr 28 15:20:54 2006. | [Full View] |
m_23_bayarea wrote: |
* Man, I thought this GHAJINI Hindi remake would open new doors for Harris in Bollywood ... Looks like his wait continues !! ![]() ![]() * Aamir loves ARR !!! It's become a blockbuster combination ... ![]() ![]() * It'll be interesting to see ARR score for the same movie in a diff language ... Not that I waana compare his BGM and songs with Harris', but still .... ![]() ![]() |
From: interz on Fri Apr 28 16:08:21 2006. | [Full View] |
From: m_23_bayarea on Fri Apr 28 16:12:23 2006. | [Full View] |
njv wrote: |
I think Hindi ppl wait for new sound continues. |
njv wrote: |
I don think HJ is dying here.
|
njv wrote: |
I Hope #3 doesnt happen. If it does, ARR will be the looser for various reasons. #1, remake never succeeded. #2, ppl will always like the original movie (no matter what) and music (no matter what). #3 ARR hasnt done music for thriller yet. |
From: Thirumaran on Fri Apr 28 16:12:49 2006. | [Full View] |
interz wrote: |
Have heard hindi version of Vasegara once, dont know who the credit goes to?? did some hindi music directors copy that song?? or was minnale released in hindi??? |
From: m_23_bayarea on Fri Apr 28 16:14:39 2006. | [Full View] |
interz wrote: |
Have heard hindi version of Vasegara once, dont know who the credit goes to?? did some hindi music directors copy that song?? or was minnale released in hindi??? |
From: m_23_bayarea on Fri Apr 28 16:16:31 2006. | [Full View] |
Thirumaran wrote: |
They remade the movie minnalae as "Rehna hai Tere dil mein" with the same team as in tamil Maddy - Goutham - Harris.. ![]() Even the vaseegara song in Hindi sung bu Bombay Jayasri.. |
From: Thirumaran on Fri Apr 28 16:18:55 2006. | [Full View] |
From: MADDY on Fri Apr 28 22:17:55 2006. | [Full View] |
njv wrote: |
I think Hindi ppl wait for new sound continues |
njv wrote: |
#1, remake never succeeded. #2, ppl will always like the original movie (no matter what) and music (no matter what). #3 ARR hasnt done music for thriller yet. |
From: Scale on Sat Apr 29 1:37:47 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Hulkster on Sat Apr 29 1:40:59 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Shakthiprabha on Sat Apr 29 1:54:44 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Hulkster on Sat Apr 29 2:05:57 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Ramakrishna on Sat Apr 29 8:06:05 2006. | [Full View] |
From: girishk14 on Sat Apr 29 8:10:15 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Ramakrishna on Sat Apr 29 8:13:52 2006. | [Full View] |
From: girishk14 on Sat Apr 29 8:22:20 2006. | [Full View] |
Ramakrishna wrote: |
deiiiiiiiii thread owner,
ARR and IR ivanga rendu perayum thookkudaaaaa ![]() ![]() |
From: interz on Sat Apr 29 9:46:53 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Thunderbird on Sat Apr 29 10:36:26 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Hulkster on Sun Apr 30 4:32:59 2006. | [Full View] |
From: m_23_bayarea on Mon May 1 22:05:10 2006. | [Full View] |
From: NOV on Mon May 1 22:17:15 2006. | [Full View] |
Shakthiprabha wrote: |
thats great. most of the MDs wont stand for another 10 years. Whilst ilayaraja rocked for more than 40 yers ![]() |
From: Thirumaran on Mon May 1 22:19:37 2006. | [Full View] |
NOV wrote: | ||
Can we please board the machine to go back to the future? ![]() |
From: m_23_bayarea on Tue May 2 13:42:12 2006. | [Full View] |
From: m_23_bayarea on Thu May 4 13:44:19 2006. | [Full View] |
From: m_23_bayarea on Tue May 16 13:11:26 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Unicorn on Tue May 16 13:12:44 2006. | [Full View] |
Thunderbird wrote: |
now Ajith vijay fight is stopped ( at-least permanently) but navin will try to set the fire often ![]() |
From: Unicorn on Tue May 16 13:15:13 2006. | [Full View] |
Hulkster wrote: |
Navin?...hmm avanai adukka yenukku oru plan irukku...athukku peru....IGNORANCE..avan thread ullae post pennatha mathiri paarthaal ellamae sugama pogum...you can respond to his good posts though. |
From: girishk14 on Wed May 17 0:04:28 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Professionalchap on Fri Jun 2 6:11:32 2006. | [Full View] |
From: alwarpet_andavan on Fri Jun 2 7:52:49 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Thirumaran on Fri Jun 2 10:40:12 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Aravind_06 on Sun Jun 4 8:43:25 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Ramakrishna on Sun Jun 4 10:09:38 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Scale on Tue Jun 6 1:53:05 2006. | [Full View] |
Ramakrishna wrote: |
Its a tie |
From: sick31 on Wed Jun 7 21:19:52 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Thirumaran on Wed Oct 18 15:08:07 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Nerd on Wed Oct 18 15:09:21 2006. | [Full View] |
From: m_23_bayarea on Wed Oct 18 15:39:31 2006. | [Full View] |
Nerd wrote: |
Oh boy what a close competition ![]() IR with 60 and ARR with 59 ![]() |
From: Nerd on Wed Oct 18 15:42:38 2006. | [Full View] |
From: m_23_bayarea on Wed Oct 18 15:43:35 2006. | [Full View] |
Nerd wrote: |
Create a new handle bay ![]() ![]() |
From: Thirumaran on Wed Oct 18 15:45:31 2006. | [Full View] |
m_23_bayarea wrote: | ||
Yeah whatever !! You know I HATE it !!! ![]() |
From: Nerd on Wed Oct 18 15:47:32 2006. | [Full View] |
From: m_23_bayarea on Wed Oct 18 15:51:45 2006. | [Full View] |
Nerd wrote: |
Can u pls enlighten me TM.. A PM will do ![]() |
From: Thirumaran on Wed Oct 18 15:52:48 2006. | [Full View] |
m_23_bayarea wrote: | ||
Copy me on those PMs TM !! ![]() |
From: m_23_bayarea on Wed Oct 18 15:54:09 2006. | [Full View] |
From: raaja_rasigan on Sun Oct 22 16:29:56 2006. | [Full View] |
From: ranarajan on Fri Oct 27 16:18:23 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Wibha on Fri Oct 27 19:27:27 2006. | [Full View] |
From: m_23_bayarea on Fri Oct 27 22:32:14 2006. | [Full View] |
Wibha wrote: |
ARR Rocksssssssssss |
From: MADDY on Sat Oct 28 2:37:53 2006. | [Full View] |
ranarajan wrote: |
ARR AND HJ MUSIC IS MORE MASS....IT DOESNT STAY FOR A LONG TIME....BUT ILLAYARAJA'S ARE GEMS ...I STILL LISTEN TO ONNADAVIDU FROM VIRUMANDI |
From: kamalfan on Sat Oct 28 3:33:03 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Sanjeevi on Sat Oct 28 3:33:59 2006. | [Full View] |
MADDY wrote: |
wow, naan kaanbadhu kanava nenava ....ARR leading IR in a poll and that too in our hub |
MADDY wrote: |
i really hope no ARR fan has multiple ids and voted in that way......i know ppl. do get inspired from recent local body elections...... ![]() ![]() |
From: joe on Sat Oct 28 3:37:51 2006. | [Full View] |
From: nilavupriyan on Sat Oct 28 4:20:03 2006. | [Full View] |
joe wrote: |
Netru Illai Naalai illai
Eppavum AVAR Raja Kottai illai kodiyum illai Appavum AVAR RAJA |
From: nilavupriyan on Sat Oct 28 4:22:20 2006. | [Full View] |
kamalfan wrote: |
Two geniuses...
ARR - with the times, sometimes avant-garde but Ilaiyaraaja is BEYOND time - timeless! Raaja da man.... Its a tie again ![]() |
From: cancer on Sat Oct 28 4:39:45 2006. | [Full View] |
nilavupriyan wrote: | ||
arrs tune doesnt seem to be good on first hearing...but rocks after few hearing...then again gets bored after months! raja's songs attracts on first hearing(only he can produce tunes that can attract us within first few secs)..and dont bore even after years! thats raja! |
From: Aandavan on Sat Oct 28 4:41:03 2006. | [Full View] |
cancer wrote: | ||||
This what everybody telling, ARR songs get bored after some months... ![]() but There are lot of ARR songs, i never get bore to hear those songs again and again... do u want me to post those songs ![]() |
From: cancer on Sat Oct 28 4:48:18 2006. | [Full View] |
Aandavan wrote: |
the percentage is less for ARR... |
From: nilavupriyan on Sat Oct 28 4:49:43 2006. | [Full View] |
From: raaja_rasigan on Sat Oct 28 5:00:04 2006. | [Full View] |
nilavupriyan wrote: | ||
raja kaiya vecha...adhu raanga ponadhilla |
From: Aandavan on Sat Oct 28 5:01:57 2006. | [Full View] |
nilavupriyan wrote: |
the amount of songs is very less...
tell me one song in gentleman except "en veetu thottathil"which we could hear now...they became big hits that time! in mudhalvan...how many play mudhalvan songs in their players.....even jeans..."anbe anbve" is freshh...how abt haira haira hairabba or columbus....how many play them? how abt kadhal desam-"enai kanavillaye" is yet good to hear...but remaining songs???got bored! do we hear akkadanu naanga from Indian...even the smash hit "telephaone manipole" is not that good! there are some movies like uyire,alaipayuthey,thiruda thiruda,kannathil muthamitaal or roja(oops all are maniratnam movies) are very fresh even now! |
From: cancer on Sat Oct 28 5:22:04 2006. | [Full View] |
nilavupriyan wrote: |
the amount of songs is very less...
tell me one song in gentleman except "en veetu thottathil"which we could hear now...they became big hits that time! |
nilavupriyan wrote: |
in mudhalvan...how many play mudhalvan songs in their players..... |
nilavupriyan wrote: |
how abt kadhal desam-"enai kanavillaye" is yet good to hear...but remaining songs???got bored! |
nilavupriyan wrote: |
there are some movies like uyire,alaipayuthey,thiruda thiruda,kannathil muthamitaal or roja(oops all are maniratnam movies) are very fresh even now! |
From: raaja_rasigan on Sat Oct 28 5:24:29 2006. | [Full View] |
cancer wrote: |
duet,en swasa kaatre, uzhavan,rhytm,may maadham,kandu konden kandu konden,jodi,ratchkan,Pudiya mugam,sangamam.... innum niraya songs irukku.... ![]() |
From: great on Sat Oct 28 11:22:31 2006. | [Full View] |
kamalfan wrote: |
Two geniuses...
ARR - with the times, sometimes avant-garde but Ilaiyaraaja is BEYOND time - timeless! Raaja da man.... Its a tie again ![]() |
From: ArulprakasH on Sat Oct 28 11:28:53 2006. | [Full View] |
From: sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar on Sat Oct 28 11:39:22 2006. | [Full View] |
From: m_23_bayarea on Sun Oct 29 12:41:15 2006. | [Full View] |
sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar wrote: |
baradwaaj irukkura listla Harris Jeyaraj kku idam illayaa?? EKSI EKSI |
From: Aandavan on Mon Oct 30 8:06:50 2006. | [Full View] |
From: VillageGimp on Mon Oct 30 8:23:59 2006. | [Full View] |
From: m_23_bayarea on Mon Oct 30 8:57:56 2006. | [Full View] |
Aandavan wrote: |
http://www.maduraimachan.com/?p=935
here is a great collection of pics of the greatest musician ever in the history of movies.. |
From: Tia on Mon Oct 30 9:28:54 2006. | [Full View] |
From: raaja_rasigan on Mon Oct 30 10:31:38 2006. | [Full View] |
Aandavan wrote: |
http://www.maduraimachan.com/?p=935
here is a great collection of pics of the greatest musician ever in the history of movies.. |
From: Aandavan on Sun Nov 5 21:51:50 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Aandavan on Sun Nov 5 21:54:14 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Aandavan on Sun Nov 5 22:12:17 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Aandavan on Mon Nov 6 6:20:32 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Tia on Mon Nov 6 13:06:31 2006. | [Full View] |
From: rocketboy on Mon Nov 6 13:10:17 2006. | [Full View] |
Tia wrote: |
definetely i can post atleast another 1000 songs better than that! it aint my typa song thts all ![]() ![]() |
From: MADDY on Mon Nov 6 13:11:30 2006. | [Full View] |
Tia wrote: |
definetely i can post atleast another 1000 songs better than that! it aint my typa song thts all ![]() ![]() |
From: great on Mon Nov 6 13:14:42 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Aandavan on Mon Nov 6 13:15:43 2006. | [Full View] |
Tia wrote: |
definetely i can post atleast another 1000 songs better than that! it aint my typa song thts all ![]() ![]() |
From: MADDY on Mon Nov 6 13:18:35 2006. | [Full View] |
great wrote: |
Maddy, when can we expect Guru songs ![]() |
From: Ramakrishna on Mon Nov 6 13:32:25 2006. | [Full View] |
From: great on Mon Nov 6 13:32:57 2006. | [Full View] |
MADDY wrote: |
wow, xpectations are huge for Guru it seems..... ![]() |
From: Tia on Mon Nov 6 13:40:48 2006. | [Full View] |
From: imsai on Mon Nov 6 13:43:10 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Tia on Mon Nov 6 13:44:59 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Aandavan on Mon Nov 6 14:04:01 2006. | [Full View] |
Tia wrote: |
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mlnYd9f8-hY
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wbUwIX57QRE http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B3k24NFezLY http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ny9UtOvh7IA I like these songs better ![]() ![]() the kidz taste! ![]() |
From: Tia on Mon Nov 6 14:06:35 2006. | [Full View] |
From: nilavupriyan on Mon Nov 6 14:42:54 2006. | [Full View] |
Tia wrote: |
definetely i can post atleast another 1000 songs better than that! it aint my typa song thts all ![]() ![]() |
From: imsai on Mon Nov 6 14:43:57 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Tia on Mon Nov 6 18:14:56 2006. | [Full View] |
From: ajithfederer on Mon Nov 6 22:44:47 2006. | [Full View] |
nilavupriyan wrote: | ||
yedhu.. ringa ringa roses johny johny yes papa twinkle twinkle litlle star maadhiriya ![]() |
From: villan007 on Mon Nov 6 22:52:56 2006. | [Full View] |
Tia wrote: |
no jack and jill went up the hill mathiri ![]() |
From: Tia on Tue Nov 7 16:05:47 2006. | [Full View] |
From: ajaybaskar on Wed Nov 8 1:34:41 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Sanjeevi on Wed Nov 8 1:38:36 2006. | [Full View] |
Tia wrote: |
I liked those songs better than that old song ![]() |
From: MADDY on Thu Nov 9 2:58:41 2006. | [Full View] |
ajaybaskar wrote: |
ARR is the best!!! He is good both in classical and western music.. I luv him |
From: bulb_mani on Thu Nov 9 3:10:48 2006. | [Full View] |
From: bulb_mani on Thu Nov 9 3:21:05 2006. | [Full View] |
From: kb on Thu Nov 9 3:21:19 2006. | [Full View] |
From: MADDY on Thu Nov 9 3:22:27 2006. | [Full View] |
bulb_mani wrote: |
Why no one is talking about Harris jeyaraj? ![]() I like his music... very youthful and pleasant... and he is best when it comes to BGM --> Samurai , KK , Minnale, Totti Jeya, Anniyan... all the BGM rocks ![]() |
From: bulb_mani on Thu Nov 9 3:25:35 2006. | [Full View] |
MADDY wrote: | ||
bulb....yaarappa nee??? ![]() ![]() ![]() |
From: nilavupriyan on Thu Nov 9 3:54:46 2006. | [Full View] |
bulb_mani wrote: | ||||
Mani...Bulb Mani ![]() maddy yes i love this hub and the people in it.... its just amazing. Do you like Harris Jeyaraj? He is my favourite music director ![]() |
From: bulb_mani on Thu Nov 9 9:25:37 2006. | [Full View] |
kb wrote: |
how was ghajini BGM ![]() |
From: MADDY on Thu Nov 9 10:37:54 2006. | [Full View] |
bulb_mani wrote: |
Do you like Harris Jeyaraj? He is my favourite music director ![]() |
From: bulb_mani on Thu Nov 9 10:45:34 2006. | [Full View] |
MADDY wrote: | ||
i listen to a lot of HJ's songs......more than YSR's songs......thats abt it.......he needs to do a lot more i guess.......wat u say?? |
From: Aandavan on Thu Nov 9 14:15:57 2006. | [Full View] |
From: MADDY on Thu Nov 9 14:24:19 2006. | [Full View] |
From: romio on Thu Nov 9 14:31:57 2006. | [Full View] |
From: bulb_mani on Thu Nov 9 14:44:35 2006. | [Full View] |
From: nilavupriyan on Thu Nov 9 14:46:23 2006. | [Full View] |
bulb_mani wrote: |
Yuvan gives his best in SELVA films and now recently somewhat good music for VISHNUVARDAN.
HARRIS rocks with GAUTHAM and JEEVA AR RAHMAN rocks with SHANKER and MANIRATHNAM I wonder what could be the reason for this director specific performance. ![]() |
From: bulb_mani on Thu Nov 9 14:48:23 2006. | [Full View] |
nilavupriyan wrote: | ||
ilayaraja than indha paagupadu illama.....maniratnam padamo ramarajan padamo ...music hitu ![]() |
From: nilavupriyan on Thu Nov 9 14:50:19 2006. | [Full View] |
From: bulb_mani on Thu Nov 9 14:51:53 2006. | [Full View] |
nilavupriyan wrote: |
because those directors have good taste of music! |
From: nilavupriyan on Thu Nov 9 14:53:31 2006. | [Full View] |
bulb_mani wrote: | ||
Good reason ![]() Is there anything apart from this like PAYSCALE? or the pay for music directors is same for all films? |
From: bulb_mani on Thu Nov 9 14:58:18 2006. | [Full View] |
nilavupriyan wrote: | ||||
nono..its what the director takes.. may be it can be an issue for deva...50 lakhs..take from backstreet boys...20 lakhs from saudi arabian album 5 lakhs---unaku sondhama pOtta podhum |
From: Tia on Thu Nov 9 17:07:28 2006. | [Full View] |
Sanjeevi wrote: | ||
It seems you are really a looooosu penn (not only for simbu ![]() ![]() |
From: m_23_bayarea on Thu Nov 9 21:11:10 2006. | [Full View] |
MADDY wrote: |
ARR is 2 votes clear of IR.......guys, for me this is the biggest surprise in my 2 yr hub life and 4 yr TFM page life..... ![]() |
From: imsai on Thu Nov 9 21:18:52 2006. | [Full View] |
From: m_23_bayarea on Thu Nov 9 21:35:28 2006. | [Full View] |
imsai wrote: |
That's a surprise because IR is known as the pillar of tamil music. Do you disagree? |
From: romio on Thu Nov 9 23:37:40 2006. | [Full View] |
From: MADDY on Fri Nov 10 0:19:57 2006. | [Full View] |
nilavupriyan wrote: |
ilayaraja than indha paagupadu illama.....maniratnam padamo ramarajan padamo ...music hitu ![]() |
From: Sanjeevi on Fri Nov 10 0:43:57 2006. | [Full View] |
From: vasanth2006 on Fri Nov 10 5:40:17 2006. | [Full View] |
Sanjeevi wrote: |
![]() ![]() |
From: bulb_mani on Fri Nov 10 5:51:43 2006. | [Full View] |
From: great on Fri Nov 10 8:50:06 2006. | [Full View] |
Sanjeevi wrote: |
![]() ![]() |
From: MADDY on Fri Nov 10 12:13:07 2006. | [Full View] |
great wrote: | ||
No Karthik Raja in the list ![]() |
From: Ramakrishna on Fri Nov 10 12:16:26 2006. | [Full View] |
MADDY wrote: | ||||
no Bavadharini and PremG also....... ![]() ![]() ![]() |
From: Sanjeevi on Fri Nov 10 12:20:26 2006. | [Full View] |
From: bulb_mani on Fri Nov 10 12:21:15 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Ramakrishna on Fri Nov 10 12:21:48 2006. | [Full View] |
bulb_mani wrote: |
Harris is the best ![]() |
From: MADDY on Fri Nov 10 12:23:35 2006. | [Full View] |
Sanjeevi wrote: |
![]() BTW MADDY why yr is pallai kadiching on IR family? ![]() |
From: Ramakrishna on Fri Nov 10 12:24:43 2006. | [Full View] |
MADDY wrote: | ||
its not IR family Sanjeevi, i hate the "vaarisu thing".......even if ARR does it, i'll equally hate his kids too........i believe this is going to be the biggest problem in the coming years.....irunga irunga, unga manager-oda dhanda pulla unga Team leada vandha theriyum...... ![]() |
From: bulb_mani on Fri Nov 10 12:28:20 2006. | [Full View] |
Ramakrishna wrote: | ||
sorry wrong thread |
From: ajaybaskar on Sat Nov 11 3:01:21 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Wibha on Sat Nov 11 3:03:53 2006. | [Full View] |
bulb_mani wrote: |
Please vote for HARRIS i find only my vite for him ![]() |
From: bulb_mani on Sat Nov 11 5:40:06 2006. | [Full View] |
Wibha wrote: | ||
harris=copy cat ![]() |
From: Amarshiva on Mon Nov 13 15:41:57 2006. | [Full View] |
From: bulb_mani on Mon Nov 13 15:53:00 2006. | [Full View] |
Amarshiva wrote: |
My vote for Harris J... ![]() |
From: m_23_bayarea on Mon Nov 13 16:16:56 2006. | [Full View] |
Amarshiva wrote: |
My vote for Harris J... ![]() |
From: Sanjeevi on Tue Nov 14 11:53:03 2006. | [Full View] |
m_23_bayarea wrote: | ||
There was a discussion around that when this thread was created ... I'm sure Harris would have garnered a lot of votes had his name been included at the time of this thread's creation !! ![]() |
From: Ramakrishna on Tue Nov 14 12:01:51 2006. | [Full View] |
Sanjeevi wrote: | ||||
yeh, you would have voted for HJ and hence ARR count .... ![]() ![]() |
From: bulb_mani on Tue Nov 14 12:11:20 2006. | [Full View] |
From: nilavupriyan on Tue Nov 14 12:49:31 2006. | [Full View] |
Ramakrishna wrote: | ||||||
mannu maathiri pesapdaathu. There is IR also in the poll. Whats the guarantee that IR's votes wudn't have come down too? |
From: m_23_bayarea on Tue Nov 14 16:57:42 2006. | [Full View] |
Sanjeevi wrote: | ||||
yeh, you would have voted for HJ and hence ARR count .... ![]() ![]() |
From: imsai on Tue Nov 14 22:18:36 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Wibha on Tue Nov 14 22:23:41 2006. | [Full View] |
bulb_mani wrote: | ||||
![]() Harris is the best ![]() |
From: m_23_bayarea on Tue Nov 14 22:26:36 2006. | [Full View] |
From: ursganesh on Tue Nov 14 23:05:12 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Thirumaran on Wed Nov 15 0:33:24 2006. | [Full View] |
m_23_bayarea wrote: |
It's always celebrities with less number of fans that have to take all the mockery .. That's the culture of this HUB !!! ![]() ![]() ![]() |
From: joe on Wed Nov 15 0:37:05 2006. | [Full View] |
From: MADDY on Wed Nov 15 4:58:02 2006. | [Full View] |
Thirumaran wrote: |
IR -- My all time favourite.
Then comes ARR, MSV, YSR.. As of now YSR is the most popular MD ![]() |
From: Thirumaran on Wed Nov 15 5:01:39 2006. | [Full View] |
MADDY wrote: | ||
sorry dude, that was a year b4.....2006 was HJ's year.......bulb and bay --> happy?? i guess u1 is going nowhere.......he has refused to work in kireedom also...... btw, enga aaloda "akka payyan" is also coming strongly....... ![]() |
From: MADDY on Wed Nov 15 5:09:19 2006. | [Full View] |
Thirumaran wrote: |
That does not prove anything. Going by your way, he had been asked for doing that movie. Does that say something ![]() |
From: Thirumaran on Wed Nov 15 5:19:49 2006. | [Full View] |
MADDY wrote: |
after being 10 yrs in the industry and getting such offers is not a big thing......but to do it perfectly and giving a hit is wat is important....... watever, IR fans may argue that ysr is the most popular, whole world knows that none of u1's songs in the last 2 yrs have overtaken "suttum vizhi" & "paartha mudhal" or a "munbe vaa"'s popularity..... |
From: selvakumar on Wed Nov 15 5:25:01 2006. | [Full View] |
Thirumaaran wrote: |
And the songs of Pattiyal and PP are mass hits. |
From: MADDY on Wed Nov 15 5:28:12 2006. | [Full View] |
Thirumaran wrote: |
These kind of assumption, i am not sure why people make ![]() If some Kamal make nagative comments on SOK/Varalaaru it is because they are kamal fans and they dont want those movies to be hit. ![]() There may be few. but not everyone like that ![]() Shall i say u hate YSR because u are ARR fan ? ![]() By the way had u not heard the song "theepidikka" "aarariraaro".. And the songs of Pattiyal and PP are mass hits. Even the song "Loosu Pennae" where without a good voice still became a big hit ![]() All these came in past 2 years only ![]() |
From: joe on Wed Nov 15 5:32:12 2006. | [Full View] |
From: MADDY on Wed Nov 15 5:35:31 2006. | [Full View] |
joe wrote: |
I know lot of IR fans (including me) ,but none of them support YSR just because he is IR's son ![]() |
From: selvakumar on Wed Nov 15 5:37:21 2006. | [Full View] |
MADDY wrote: |
yes i hate YSR but not bcos i'm a ARR fan but bcos he has used a gr8 man's name to survive in the industry and is after all a star-kid , who are very low in my ratings...... |
From: selvakumar on Wed Nov 15 5:38:21 2006. | [Full View] |
MADDY wrote: |
.infact one of our hub's very own IR fan claimed that if IR is like Lord Shiva then YSR and KR are like "Murugan and Pillayar" ![]() |
From: Thirumaran on Wed Nov 15 6:06:35 2006. | [Full View] |
MADDY wrote: |
i didnt say u were a IR fan ![]() yes i hate YSR but not bcos i'm a ARR fan but bcos he has used a gr8 man's name to survive in the industry and is after all a star-kid , who are very low in my ratings...... boss, do u mean to say that Pattiyal, PP were bigger musical hits than Ghajini, VV, SOK??? boss, when u claim that YSR is the most popular MD, his songs shuld have been chartbusting......it wasnt....simple, it was HJ's songs which were chart busters....... |
From: selvakumar on Wed Nov 15 6:09:49 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Thirumaran on Wed Nov 15 6:13:05 2006. | [Full View] |
MADDY wrote: |
yes i hate YSR but not bcos i'm a ARR fan but bcos he has used a gr8 man's name to survive in the industry and is after all a star-kid , who are very low in my ratings...... |
From: joe on Wed Nov 15 6:17:28 2006. | [Full View] |
Thirumaran wrote: | ||
So if a father is Policeman/Military man their son shd never be like them. They shd not have ambition like their father? Is it so? ![]() Do u have any info that IR produced movie to launch their sons/ recommended to Producers ![]() It is the talent that matters not the person is following the way his/her ancestors does ![]() |
From: selvakumar on Wed Nov 15 6:18:23 2006. | [Full View] |
Thirumaran wrote: |
It is the talent that matters not the person is following the way his/her ancestors does ![]() |
From: joe on Wed Nov 15 6:22:50 2006. | [Full View] |
From: selvakumar on Wed Nov 15 6:26:29 2006. | [Full View] |
joe wrote: |
Selva,
You are saying YSR can come to this level only because he is son of IR .I agree he had more opertunity in all aspects ..But assume if a really deserve genius(not YSR) born to another genius ,when will you accept ? what is the line ? Or You will never accept no matter How much they achive ,just because he born to so and so ? ![]() |
From: Thirumaran on Wed Nov 15 6:34:28 2006. | [Full View] |
selvakumar wrote: |
Thiru anna,
I don't think Maddy referred to that part. He just said that HJ songs are much popular than YSR songs. Whether the movie has a popular star cast or not is entirely a different thing ! |
From: joe on Wed Nov 15 6:36:59 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Thirumaran on Wed Nov 15 6:48:15 2006. | [Full View] |
selvakumar wrote: |
Listen.. If YSR proved him with his first movie itself with that, then it is fine. He took so much time and then he got some offers. It was after TI only he became popular ! ![]() For a relatively new MD, this cannot be expected..Remember KR too got popular banners and directors ! Relate this to a person like IMAAN / HJ ! and you will get my point ! |
From: Raghu on Wed Nov 15 6:48:24 2006. | [Full View] |
From: MADDY on Wed Nov 15 7:48:21 2006. | [Full View] |
Thirumaran wrote: |
His first movie Aravindan was quite popular ![]() ![]() |
From: selvakumar on Wed Nov 15 7:59:44 2006. | [Full View] |
MADDY wrote: |
After Aravindan, he didnt give a hit for 3 years.....still he could come again and compose for a top star's movie like Ajith in Dheena........honestly, u tell me, if HJ or ARR or VS had given duds after duds for 3 yrs, would they have got a chance to compose for a top hero??? i'm sorry, but i feel very strong abt this topic......cos when some work so hard for success, these guys are having life so easy.......u know, ARR used to rent music instruments to make ends meet.....he dropped out of school for lack of money......IR used to perform on streets with his brothers..........i'll never respect any vaarisu, even if i do, i wont place him above someone who has come from outside, simply bcos of the difference in effort that they take......sorry if i'm hurting someone.... ![]() |
From: nilavupriyan on Wed Nov 15 8:04:54 2006. | [Full View] |
From: selvakumar on Wed Nov 15 8:09:04 2006. | [Full View] |
nilavupriyan wrote: |
I really admire vikram and ajith for that cause....infact they undergone some difficulties in their life along with non filmi background ...finally achieved! |
From: MADDY on Wed Nov 15 8:11:26 2006. | [Full View] |
selvakumar wrote: |
![]() ![]() I remember reading CHIRANJEEVI'S interview in AV sometime back. he said he used to reach T.NAGER from TRIPLICANE by walk ! ![]() Needless to say how RK suffered in the initial years. I heard in one interview in vijay tv that RK won't eat at all for some days due to lack of money ! ![]() Man, TRUE GOLDEN PERIOD OF TF was in those times.. where people from humble background excelled ! |
From: selvakumar on Wed Nov 15 8:13:26 2006. | [Full View] |
joe wrote: |
Selva,
I noticed sometimes MADDY sounds like all varisus are not deserved and all non-varisus are great. Varisungrathunala mattum illama unmaiyile thiramai ullavanga irukkalam .avangala varisungura perala ignore pannurathum thappu. |
From: selvakumar on Wed Nov 15 8:15:54 2006. | [Full View] |
MADDY wrote: |
thats true selva.......but again, ppl. get what they deserve........if they want only a YSR and not a ARR or IR or MSV-TKR, then they will get YSR only.......if they dont want a Shivaji, Kamal, Rajini or Ajith they will get the "entire heroes list" of tamil films today......i'm actually tired abt this arguement........ ![]() |
From: nilavupriyan on Wed Nov 15 8:17:37 2006. | [Full View] |
selvakumar wrote: | ||
Pretty much agree.. Romba kasta pattureekngala MADDY indha arguement la ! ![]() Yes.. Your entire post deserves a ![]() |
From: selvakumar on Wed Nov 15 8:19:24 2006. | [Full View] |
nilavupriyan wrote: |
I really admire vikram and ajith for that cause....infact they undergone some difficulties in their life along with non filmi background ...finally achieved! |
From: nilavupriyan on Wed Nov 15 8:20:46 2006. | [Full View] |
selvakumar wrote: | ||
enga THALA innum Kasta pattukittu thaan irukkaar Vikky.. indha visayathula.. evvalavu Hard work panninaalum inga apprecation kedaikirathu ![]() ![]() ![]() Remember how he was forgotten when people didn't even care to ask abt him when he met with the accident ! ![]() |
From: selvakumar on Wed Nov 15 8:24:58 2006. | [Full View] |
nilavupriyan wrote: |
the important point is ...there could have been a ir or arr orrajni or kamal or ajith who are in non-filmi background...when people with film background dominate the industry...how could they get chance! |
From: m_23_bayarea on Wed Nov 15 8:51:49 2006. | [Full View] |
MADDY wrote: |
sorry dude, that was a year b4.....2006 was HJ's year.......bulb and bay --> happy?? i guess u1 is going nowhere.......he has refused to work in kireedom also......
|
From: bulb_mani on Wed Nov 15 12:27:52 2006. | [Full View] |
From: nilavupriyan on Wed Nov 15 12:28:48 2006. | [Full View] |
bulb_mani wrote: |
All of u vote for HARRIS... idhu ECHARIKAI ILLAI>.. KATTALAI...KATTALAi...KATTALai...KATTAlai...KATTalai...KATtalai...KAtalai...Katalai... ![]() ![]() ![]() |
From: bulb_mani on Wed Nov 15 12:29:35 2006. | [Full View] |
nilavupriyan wrote: | ||
appa seekiram poyi kattupa |
From: Thirumaran on Thu Nov 16 2:11:42 2006. | [Full View] |
From: MADDY on Thu Nov 16 5:39:01 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Thirumaran on Thu Nov 16 6:16:47 2006. | [Full View] |
From: MADDY on Thu Nov 16 14:23:07 2006. | [Full View] |
Thirumaran wrote: |
Maddy,
I was not trying to convince you ![]() ![]() By the way, I dont think i was saying SOK as flop and trying convincing you on that ![]() Anyhow no hard feelings if any. We are sharing our views. Have fan as usual ![]() |
From: m_23_bayarea on Thu Nov 16 21:56:18 2006. | [Full View] |
MADDY wrote: |
no prob.....actually, its me, who should keep quiet on the "vaarisu" issue......i have said this a million times, ppl. dont accept it, then i have to keep quiet......i'll try to throw this thing out of my system.... ![]() |
From: Thirumaran on Fri Nov 17 0:32:11 2006. | [Full View] |
MADDY wrote: |
no prob.....actually, its me, who should keep quiet on the "vaarisu" issue......i have said this a million times, ppl. dont accept it, then i have to keep quiet......i'll try to throw this thing out of my system.... ![]() |
From: MADDY on Fri Nov 17 6:21:21 2006. | [Full View] |
Thirumaran wrote: |
no please. Then it will look like i had convinced u on this issue ![]() |
From: bulb_mani on Fri Nov 17 6:22:51 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Aandavan on Fri Nov 17 6:28:54 2006. | [Full View] |
bulb_mani wrote: |
Harris doesnt copy ARR ![]() ![]() |
From: bulb_mani on Fri Nov 17 6:33:22 2006. | [Full View] |
Aandavan wrote: | ||
|
From: bulb_mani on Fri Nov 17 6:43:56 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Aandavan on Fri Nov 17 6:55:09 2006. | [Full View] |
bulb_mani wrote: |
[b][size=18]
Gone are the Days Of Ilaiyaraja? I think Yes ![]() |
From: selvakumar on Fri Nov 17 7:25:27 2006. | [Full View] |
bulb_mani wrote: |
HArris is superb... but ARR is jack of all trades... Folk , Classical , Ghazal,, western....wow ARR is different and Harris is different... Even harris tried his hand at classical in anniyan --> " Iyengar Veetu Alage" but it failed to click but look at ARR's Innisai... its superb.
ARR is great but still i like HARRIS ![]() ![]() |
From: m_23_bayarea on Fri Nov 17 10:27:22 2006. | [Full View] |
MADDY wrote: |
bay, harris.... ![]() ![]() ![]() |
From: joe on Fri Nov 17 11:34:59 2006. | [Full View] |
Aandavan wrote: | ||
![]() |
From: Hulkster on Fri Nov 17 11:45:22 2006. | [Full View] |
From: bulb_mani on Fri Nov 17 12:06:33 2006. | [Full View] |
From: m_23_bayarea on Fri Nov 17 12:11:08 2006. | [Full View] |
bulb_mani wrote: |
To me my all time favourite would remain AR Rahman... Ilaiyaraja's music attracts me but not as much as that of ARR's coz i feel ARR has much more vareity than IR and my taste i so ![]() But in modern times... HARRIS is best... especially his youthful numbers are incomparable even with ARR's... but Harris seems to be somewhat repetitive unlike ARR who produces distinct albums... |
From: bulb_mani on Fri Nov 17 12:14:05 2006. | [Full View] |
From: joe on Fri Nov 17 12:15:23 2006. | [Full View] |
bulb_mani wrote: |
i feel ARR has much more vareity than IR |
From: m_23_bayarea on Fri Nov 17 12:18:15 2006. | [Full View] |
bulb_mani wrote: |
But bay many liked Kaaka Kaaka over Boys at that time... but it was injustice to ARR's most youthful album coz the movie flopped!!!
|
From: Aandavan on Fri Nov 17 12:19:45 2006. | [Full View] |
joe wrote: | ||
![]() ![]() ![]() |
From: m_23_bayarea on Fri Nov 17 12:20:27 2006. | [Full View] |
Aandavan wrote: | ||||
![]() |
From: kb on Fri Nov 17 12:22:34 2006. | [Full View] |
joe wrote: | ||
![]() ![]() ![]() |
From: bulb_mani on Fri Nov 17 12:24:33 2006. | [Full View] |
joe wrote: | ||
![]() ![]() ![]() |
From: Aandavan on Fri Nov 17 12:26:59 2006. | [Full View] |
m_23_bayarea wrote: | ||||||
![]() |
From: m_23_bayarea on Fri Nov 17 12:28:15 2006. | [Full View] |
Aandavan wrote: | ||||||||
![]() |
From: joe on Fri Nov 17 12:33:02 2006. | [Full View] |
From: m_23_bayarea on Fri Nov 17 12:33:46 2006. | [Full View] |
From: kb on Fri Nov 17 12:34:09 2006. | [Full View] |
m_23_bayarea wrote: |
Joe, do you think IR is better than MSV ?? ![]() |
From: bulb_mani on Fri Nov 17 12:35:49 2006. | [Full View] |
From: joe on Fri Nov 17 12:36:24 2006. | [Full View] |
m_23_bayarea wrote: |
Joe, do you think IR is better than MSV ?? ![]() |
From: villan007 on Fri Nov 17 12:36:53 2006. | [Full View] |
kb wrote: | ||
100% |
From: m_23_bayarea on Fri Nov 17 12:37:20 2006. | [Full View] |
From: m_23_bayarea on Fri Nov 17 12:37:48 2006. | [Full View] |
villan007 wrote: | ||||
100% aama va illai 100% illaya ? ![]() ![]() |
From: bulb_mani on Fri Nov 17 12:38:17 2006. | [Full View] |
m_23_bayarea wrote: |
Instead of saying one is better than the other (since they all belong to different generations and audience), how abt this list ??
60s and early 70s - MSV Late 70s and 80s - IR 90s - ARR Post 2000 - Harris !! ![]() |
From: c4ramesh on Fri Nov 17 12:38:32 2006. | [Full View] |
m_23_bayarea wrote: |
Instead of saying one is better than the other (since they all belong to different generations and audience), how abt this list ??
60s and early 70s - MSV Late 70s and 80s - IR 90s - ARR Post 2000 - Harris !! ![]() |
From: m_23_bayarea on Fri Nov 17 12:39:15 2006. | [Full View] |
c4ramesh wrote: |
Post 2000 I think, YSR is better. |
From: bulb_mani on Fri Nov 17 12:39:25 2006. | [Full View] |
From: c4ramesh on Fri Nov 17 12:40:56 2006. | [Full View] |
m_23_bayarea wrote: | ||
OK !!! That's a whole diff discussion .. I donno much abt YSR, so I'll pass !! ![]() |
From: bulb_mani on Fri Nov 17 12:42:05 2006. | [Full View] |
From: kb on Fri Nov 17 12:44:26 2006. | [Full View] |
villan007 wrote: | ||||
100% aama va illai 100% illaya ? ![]() ![]() |
From: m_23_bayarea on Fri Nov 17 12:48:44 2006. | [Full View] |
c4ramesh wrote: | ||||
Thats ok, ever1 have diff opinions.... ![]() |
From: great on Fri Nov 17 12:49:37 2006. | [Full View] |
From: joe on Fri Nov 17 12:55:06 2006. | [Full View] |
From: NOV on Sat Nov 18 4:09:19 2006. | [Full View] |
kb wrote: | ||
|
kb wrote: |
![]() |
From: bulb_mani on Sat Nov 18 4:14:47 2006. | [Full View] |
NOV wrote: | ||||||
![]() |
From: Scale on Sat Nov 18 4:22:24 2006. | [Full View] |
From: NOV on Sat Nov 18 4:25:41 2006. | [Full View] |
bulb_mani wrote: |
idhula sirikaradhuku ena iruku ![]() |
From: MADDY on Sat Nov 18 4:47:49 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Nakeeran on Sat Nov 18 4:55:01 2006. | [Full View] |
joe wrote: |
I always feel like one music director who is really underrated and not given due place,he is KV MahaDevan..
Most of his movies,mostly people mistaken as it is done by MSV.. Eg: Thiilana Mohanambal ,Thiruvilayadal ![]() KV mahadevan did many MGR movies,people took it as MSV ![]() |
From: Nakeeran on Sat Nov 18 4:57:05 2006. | [Full View] |
MADDY wrote: |
joe and other IRish guys - for a lay man like me, its the sound which we understand and not tunes/orchestration/arrangements/ludes.......on basis of sound, ARR surely has more variety than IR......ARR has bought out the central asian sounds and look at the knowledge this guy has on Hindustani music,qawalis, North Indian folk music.....it will put a pucca North Indian to shame......
i'm not knowledgable enuf to comment abt IR's variety but for me "yedho yedho ennam(punnagai mannan)" and "Kalyana maalai(PPA)" were the same genre on basis of sound......cos both had the same table base, similar vocals.......but until my father pointed out the WCM ludes in Kalyana Maalai, i thot they were the same songs and hence i can conclude that IR is pretty monotonous....... hope you got my point...... ![]() |
From: joe on Sat Nov 18 5:07:22 2006. | [Full View] |
Nakeeran wrote: | ||
Joe sir KVM and MSV followed different composing styles . Wonder how did u conclude like this ! ![]() And noone got confused on Thillana or Thiruvilayadal caz they were typical KVM style compos. So where lies the confusion ? Let me clarify futher - Listen to MGR songs composed by KVM and MSV. Both are different styles. Even the orchestration was diff. between the 2 But someone who can be called the king of western orchestration and king of rerecording, its ISAINYANI IMHO ![]() When it comes to fusion, its Isaipuyal ARR |
From: great on Sat Nov 18 5:13:28 2006. | [Full View] |
Scale wrote: |
![]() great, unga emoticon language enakku puriyala. Is MSV & ARR same in your opinion? /Dign Do you have my earlier avatar (cartoon walkking - gif) which I have deleted it accidently? /End Dign |
From: bulb_mani on Sat Nov 18 5:19:15 2006. | [Full View] |
NOV wrote: | ||
![]() that was meant for kb ![]() |
From: Nakeeran on Sat Nov 18 5:21:49 2006. | [Full View] |
Quote: |
My point is KVM as MD and Vaali as Lyricist were taken for granted.
I am sure still majority of the people beleive "Tharai mel pirakka vaiththan" ,"Aththai madi meththaiyadi" ,"Maathavi pon mayilal thogai virithaL" should be written by Kannadasan ,instead of Vaali in reality |
From: bulb_mani on Sat Nov 18 5:24:10 2006. | [Full View] |
From: joe on Sat Nov 18 5:24:46 2006. | [Full View] |
From: VENKIRAJA on Sat Nov 18 5:33:32 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Nakeeran on Sat Nov 18 5:36:45 2006. | [Full View] |
joe wrote: |
Nakeeran,
What about "Kan pona pokkile kaal pogaklama" ,I bet 90% of people think it is kannadasan ![]() |
From: Nakeeran on Sat Nov 18 5:37:52 2006. | [Full View] |
bulb_mani wrote: |
Why DEVA is not in the list ![]() |
From: bulb_mani on Sat Nov 18 5:38:28 2006. | [Full View] |
From: bulb_mani on Sat Nov 18 5:39:26 2006. | [Full View] |
Nakeeran wrote: | ||
If you jumble the alphabets, U will get VEDA ![]() |
From: great on Sat Nov 18 5:39:32 2006. | [Full View] |
joe wrote: |
Nakeeran,
What about "Kan pona pokkile kaal pogaklama" ,I bet 90% of people think it is kannadasan ![]() |
From: joe on Sat Nov 18 5:41:26 2006. | [Full View] |
Nakeeran wrote: | ||
God ! Is it Valee's ? ![]() |
From: m_23_bayarea on Sat Nov 18 10:07:32 2006. | [Full View] |
bulb_mani wrote: |
U all consider DEVA to be worthless? ![]() ![]() |
From: Hulkster on Sun Nov 19 0:44:23 2006. | [Full View] |
bulb_mani wrote: | ||||
IR's songs almost have same kind of "something" ... that may be instrumentation or tune or raagam or whatever... i dont like him except for a few albums... Imagine IR scoring For BOYS , SOK , JEANS, ![]() ![]() ![]() ARR rulez... but still i like HARRIS ![]() ![]() |
From: ajaybaskar on Thu Nov 23 3:42:59 2006. | [Full View] |
From: NOV on Thu Nov 23 4:07:23 2006. | [Full View] |
ajaybaskar wrote: |
If music is a kingdom, IR is the king. But if music is a religion, then ARR is the god.. |
From: leosimha on Thu Nov 23 4:19:51 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Aandavan on Thu Nov 23 4:20:52 2006. | [Full View] |
leosimha wrote: |
Guru songs by ARR are too good...listen to it.... |
From: Wibha on Thu Nov 23 4:24:15 2006. | [Full View] |
Aandavan wrote: | ||
![]() |
From: great on Thu Nov 23 4:30:01 2006. | [Full View] |
Aandavan wrote: | ||
![]() |
From: selvakumar on Thu Nov 23 4:40:06 2006. | [Full View] |
NOV wrote: | ||
![]() |
From: Sanguine Sridhar on Thu Nov 23 4:46:53 2006. | [Full View] |
selvakumar wrote: | ||||
Deva is the GOD OF KINGS ! (etho naanum konjam add pannikiraen) |
From: great on Thu Nov 23 4:48:10 2006. | [Full View] |
Sanguine Sridhar wrote: |
Bur Srikanth Deva is the King Kong ![]() |
From: bulb_mani on Thu Nov 23 4:49:25 2006. | [Full View] |
From: selvakumar on Thu Nov 23 4:50:05 2006. | [Full View] |
Sanguine Sridhar wrote: |
Bur Srikanth Deva is the King Kong ![]() |
From: selvakumar on Thu Nov 23 4:50:56 2006. | [Full View] |
bulb_mani wrote: |
Their looks dont matter to us... they ar MDs and not hero...
Srikanth Deva is Ok very much similar to Deva... But Deva has given some memorable hits.... though he has copied a lot ![]() |
From: great on Thu Nov 23 4:53:40 2006. | [Full View] |
From: bulb_mani on Thu Nov 23 4:53:57 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Sanguine Sridhar on Thu Nov 23 4:55:20 2006. | [Full View] |
great wrote: |
Aasai music ![]() ![]() |
From: NOV on Thu Nov 23 4:57:51 2006. | [Full View] |
Sanguine Sridhar wrote: |
oru vela pazhaya english pop albuthula irrundhu suttu irrupaaro? ![]() |
From: bulb_mani on Thu Nov 23 4:57:56 2006. | [Full View] |
From: Sanguine Sridhar on Thu Nov 23 4:59:23 2006. | [Full View] |
From: NOV on Thu Nov 23 4:59:58 2006. | [Full View] |
NOV wrote: |
konja naal poru thalaiva is ee adichaan copy of MSV's thannan thanimaiyilE |
From: bulb_mani on Thu Nov 23 5:00:17 2006. | [Full View] |
NOV wrote: | ||
konja naal poru thalaiva is ee adichaan copy of MSV's thannan thanimaiyilE |
From: selvakumar on Thu Nov 23 5:00:18 2006. | [Full View] |
bulb_mani wrote: |
Kannai Kasakum SOORIYANE? ![]() ![]() U mean Merke Uditha Sooriyane from citizen ,? ![]() |
From: bulb_mani on Thu Nov 23 5:01:19 2006. | [Full View] |
From: bulb_mani on Thu Nov 23 5:02:44 2006. | [Full View] |
From: imsai on Thu Nov 23 5:03:31 2006. | [Full View] |
From: NOV on Thu Nov 23 5:03:34 2006. | [Full View] |
bulb_mani wrote: |
His music for Kadhal Kottai , Red , Citizen , Aasai , Mugavai were all hits... and are still being played in Music Channels ![]() |
From: NOV on Thu Nov 23 5:04:18 2006. | [Full View] |
Sanguine Sridhar wrote: |
thanna thanimayile enna movie? |
From: Sanguine Sridhar on Thu Nov 23 5:04:59 2006. | [Full View] |
From: bulb_mani on Thu Nov 23 5:06:05 2006. | [Full View] |
NOV wrote: | ||
keechu kiliyE - dr. alban (enemies) oh nenje nenje - backstreet boys (get down) poo virinjadhu - the things you do thilothama - ofra haza |
From: selvakumar on Thu Nov 23 5:06:41 2006. | [Full View] |
imsai wrote: |
copy adichaalum, sothappama adichaaru. angae thaan avar irukiraaru ![]() |
Quote: |
thilothama - ofra haza |
From: NOV on Thu Nov 23 5:07:17 2006. | [Full View] |
imsai wrote: |
copy adichaalum, sothappama adichaaru. angae thaan avar irukiraaru ![]() |
From: Sanguine Sridhar on Thu Nov 23 5:09:33 2006. | [Full View] |
From: NOV on Thu Nov 23 5:09:34 2006. | [Full View] |
Sanguine Sridhar wrote: |
poo virinjachu yeah i know...that the thing you do!! super copy ![]() gaana mattum thaan orginal-a? ![]() |
From: bulb_mani on Thu Nov 23 5:10:23 2006. | [Full View] |
From: imsai on Thu Nov 23 5:12:11 2006. | [Full View] |
From: bulb_mani on Thu Nov 23 5:14:39 2006. | [Full View] |
imsai wrote: |
![]() |
From: bulb_mani on Thu Nov 23 5:18:26 2006. | [Full View] |
From: MADDY on Thu Nov 23 6:47:41 2006. | [Full View] |
bulb_mani wrote: | ||
Tlephone Manipol is heavily influenced by ALL THAT SHE WANTS by ACE OF BASE ![]() |
From: bulb_mani on Thu Nov 23 6:49:31 2006. | [Full View] |
From: NOV on Thu Nov 23 10:01:56 2006. | [Full View] |
imsai wrote: |
![]() |
From: MADDY on Thu Nov 23 10:39:35 2006. | [Full View] |
NOV wrote: | ||
from 100% copies like pennalla pennalla oodhappoo to bit copies lke uppu karuvaadu. ![]() older MDs like GR, MSV, KVM etc - their copies are maybe one here and one there, but nevertheless copies. |
From: NOV on Thu Nov 23 11:01:41 2006. | [Full View] |
MADDY wrote: |
NOV , emadhu kadavulin isayil enna pizhai kandeer, yendru satru koora mudiyuma??? ![]() |
MADDY wrote: |
i dont think ARR has copied the tunes..........theres no need for such a huge genius........though some of his tunes resemble MSV's tunes which is out of influence of MSV's tunes on him and not intent to copy.......
|
From: MADDY on Thu Nov 23 11:31:40 2006. | [Full View] |
NOV wrote: | ||||
![]()
![]() lhave you listened to pesumani muththu rojaakkal from neela malargal? or andru oomai pennallO from paarththaal pasi theerum? |
From: villan007 on Thu Nov 23 12:19:11 2006. | [Full View] |
leosimha wrote: |
Guru songs by ARR are too good...listen to it.... |
From: bulb_mani on Fri Nov 24 5:34:21 2006. | [Full View] |
Quote: |
G V Prakash is rising up fast
IndiaGlitz [Friday, November 24, 2006] G V Prakash, the young music composer, is the latest sensation in Kollywood. Nephew of A R Rehman, G V Prakash's tunes in Veyyil have caught everyone with awe. Director Shankar, heaping appreciation on the young lad for his excellent work, said he is sure to go places and establish a name for himself. Prakash has come up with six songs in Veyyil, which are quite different from each other. The audio is already a big hit in Tamil Nadu. Also the audio of Veyyil's Telugu version was out in Andhra Pradesh recently and it is creating waves there. As a result G V Prakash is now flooded with offers. He has accepted to work in nearly a half-a-dozen movies including Ajith's Kireedom to be produced by Suresh Balaji Films. |
From: TamilMoon on Fri Nov 24 6:16:35 2006. | [Full View] |
From: bulb_mani on Sat Nov 25 1:12:01 2006. | [Full View] |
From: bulb_mani on Sat Nov 25 2:22:39 2006. | [Full View] |
From: ajaybaskar on Mon Nov 27 5:10:05 2006. | [Full View] |
MADDY wrote: | ||||||
lemme listen to them and get back to u.....any links for these songs to start with?? |
From: NOV on Mon Nov 27 20:28:04 2006. | [Full View] |
ajaybaskar wrote: |
Maddy, the raagas r the same. nothing else. I can point out a lot of songs of IR which has the same raagas. Moderator yaen ippadi partiala nadanthukkiraro? |
From: ajaybaskar on Fri Dec 1 5:14:53 2006. | [Full View] |
From: MADDY on Sat Mar 17 6:26:06 2007. | [Full View] |
From: Shakthiprabha on Sat Mar 17 7:47:01 2007. | [Full View] |
From: A.ANAND on Fri Mar 23 6:12:49 2007. | [Full View] |
From: raaja_rasigan on Fri Mar 23 10:21:52 2007. | [Full View] |
A.ANAND wrote: |
very nice topic ![]() 2 perume 2 kangal mathiri enakku,2 kannula entha kannu venum inna ennatha sollarathu????!!!raja 'suriyan' mathiri rahman 'katru'mathiri ![]() |
From: selvakumar on Mon Mar 26 6:48:15 2007. | [Full View] |
From: RPB on Mon Mar 26 6:55:06 2007. | [Full View] |
From: thineshan54321 on Fri Apr 6 22:56:29 2007. | [Full View] |
From: thinkfloyd on Fri Apr 6 23:08:47 2007. | [Full View] |
From: Hulkster on Fri Apr 6 23:43:35 2007. | [Full View] |
From: thineshan54321 on Sun Apr 8 19:16:52 2007. | [Full View] |
From: Hulkster on Sun Apr 8 21:12:31 2007. | [Full View] |
From: thineshan54321 on Sun Apr 8 21:39:19 2007. | [Full View] |
From: lavanya22rit on Mon Apr 9 4:33:15 2007. | [Full View] |
From: Sanjeevi on Mon Apr 9 4:39:24 2007. | [Full View] |
From: thimuru on Mon Apr 9 4:45:40 2007. | [Full View] |
selvakumar wrote: |
Listened to "YANNI's Nightingale" ! To be precise, I don't have much music knowledge.
When I listened to this, I felt like getting drenched in the musical rain. The Chinese Flute + Violin + Keyboard combo creates the magic here. wowww.... What a Feel ? I think few people (like me) judge the talent by merely looking at the TFM world and thereby remaining as perfect "KInathu ThalavalaigaL". Outside there is much more. I really donno whether our music directors have given music like this. But we should blame the TF world for restricting them to the FILM MUSIC WORLD alone ! |
From: thimuru on Mon Apr 9 4:47:32 2007. | [Full View] |
lavanya22rit wrote: |
Consider tamil movies:
----Nayantaara has co-starred with Super star, next (so called) super star, little super star, supreme star, ultimate star, etc (Surya, Rajini, Ajith, Vijay, Simbu, Sarath.....) ----But Aishwarya rai has acted only with mohanlal and mammooty(not major stars in TN), abbas and prasanth(flop stars). ----Nayantara has been a part of many hits and blockbusters like CM(record breaking blockbuster), Ayya, Sivakasi, Vallavan, Gajini, etc in her short career so far. ----But Aish managed just one blockbuster (jeans), one super hit(kandukonden * 2) and one utter flop (Iruvar) in the last 10 years. ----Nayantaara has acted in more tamil movies and more popular among tamil audience Based on the above facts if one concludes that Nayantaara is overall better than Aish then he wud also conclude IR is better than ARR. |
From: MADDY on Mon Apr 9 4:55:51 2007. | [Full View] |
From: MADDY on Mon Apr 9 4:57:27 2007. | [Full View] |
lavanya22rit wrote: |
Consider tamil movies:
----Nayantaara has co-starred with Super star, next (so called) super star, little super star, supreme star, ultimate star, etc (Surya, Rajini, Ajith, Vijay, Simbu, Sarath.....) ----But Aishwarya rai has acted only with mohanlal and mammooty(not major stars in TN), abbas and prasanth(flop stars). ----Nayantara has been a part of many hits and blockbusters like CM(record breaking blockbuster), Ayya, Sivakasi, Vallavan, Gajini, etc in her short career so far. ----But Aish managed just one blockbuster (jeans), one super hit(kandukonden * 2) and one utter flop (Iruvar) in the last 10 years. ----Nayantaara has acted in more tamil movies and more popular among tamil audience Based on the above facts if one concludes that Nayantaara is overall better than Aish then he wud also conclude IR is better than ARR. |
From: thinkfloyd on Mon Apr 9 5:16:35 2007. | [Full View] |
MADDY wrote: |
dei asst. directorgala.....note pannungappa note pannungappa......pinranga paa pinraanga paa....... ![]() |
From: Sanguine Sridhar on Mon Apr 9 5:16:43 2007. | [Full View] |
From: smith on Mon Apr 9 7:03:46 2007. | [Full View] |
From: thimuru on Mon Apr 9 7:14:16 2007. | [Full View] |
smith wrote: |
IR & ARR - no comparison. IR's melodies in the 80s are still being heard today, but how many listen to ARR's songs, say from Indian or Jeans today? |
From: selvakumar on Mon Apr 9 7:29:25 2007. | [Full View] |
smith wrote: |
IR & ARR - no comparison. IR's melodies in the 80s are still being heard today, but how many listen to ARR's songs, say from Indian or Jeans today? |
From: lavanya22rit on Mon Apr 9 7:48:12 2007. | [Full View] |
thinkfloyd wrote: | ||
Yedho vanja pugazhchila solraanga, aana enna nu purila... Avanga yaara pugazhndhu pesaraanga, yar better nu solraangannu purila.. Ore conpeesan ![]() |
From: lavanya22rit on Mon Apr 9 7:49:37 2007. | [Full View] |
selvakumar wrote: | ||
Count me.. I am a big fan of the 90's. We never grew with IR songs. We had DEVA and ARR. Trust me : Deva was more popular at that time than anyone else and ofcourse ARR was at his peak ! I can mention many songs of ARR. My favorite album is UYIRAE. But at the same time, I never give up listening to the melodies / Kuthus / Sentiment songs of IR even now ![]() |
From: selvakumar on Mon Apr 9 7:52:28 2007. | [Full View] |
thinkfloyd wrote: | ||
Yedho vanja pugazhchila solraanga, aana enna nu purila... Avanga yaara pugazhndhu pesaraanga, yar better nu solraangannu purila.. Ore conpeesan ![]() |
From: thamizhvaanan on Mon Apr 9 7:54:33 2007. | [Full View] |
MADDY wrote: |
dei asst. directorgala.....note pannungappa note pannungappa......pinranga paa pinraanga paa....... |
From: selvakumar on Mon Apr 9 7:55:20 2007. | [Full View] |
lavanya22rit wrote: |
Its really funny that some people say that the guy who WAS number 1 in TN is better than the guy who IS number 1 in India. |
From: thamizhvaanan on Mon Apr 9 8:09:29 2007. | [Full View] |
selvakumar wrote: |
Listened to "YANNI's Nightingale" ! To be precise, I don't have much music knowledge.
When I listened to this, I felt like getting drenched in the musical rain. The Chinese Flute + Violin + Keyboard combo creates the magic here. wowww.... What a Feel ? I think few people (like me) judge the talent by merely looking at the TFM world and thereby remaining as perfect "KInathu ThalavalaigaL". Outside there is much more. I really donno whether our music directors have given music like this. But we should blame the TF world for restricting them to the FILM MUSIC WORLD alone ! |
From: dinesh2002 on Mon Apr 9 8:10:28 2007. | [Full View] |
smith wrote: |
IR & ARR - no comparison. IR's melodies in the 80s are still being heard today, but how many listen to ARR's songs, say from Indian or Jeans today? |
From: NOV on Mon Apr 9 8:40:16 2007. | [Full View] |
From: selvakumar on Mon Apr 9 8:48:18 2007. | [Full View] |
NOV wrote: |
lets all agree that the best MD ever is MSV. ![]() and bet you, even IR and ARR will drink to that. ![]() |
From: Sanjeevi on Mon Apr 9 8:51:22 2007. | [Full View] |
From: NOV on Mon Apr 9 9:01:08 2007. | [Full View] |
From: dinesh2002 on Mon Apr 9 9:18:05 2007. | [Full View] |
NOV wrote: |
why this unnecessary fights? ![]() lets all agree that the best MD ever is MSV. ![]() and bet you, even IR and ARR will drink to that. ![]() |
From: NOV on Mon Apr 9 9:24:18 2007. | [Full View] |
From: selvakumar on Mon Apr 9 9:25:07 2007. | [Full View] |
NOV wrote: |
selva, why laugh when you dont know who he is? ![]() there are still many things for you to discover. so please have an open mind. |
From: thinkfloyd on Mon Apr 9 9:36:12 2007. | [Full View] |
NOV wrote: |
selva, why laugh when you dont know who he is? ![]() there are still many things for you to discover. so please have an open mind. |
From: Sanguine Sridhar on Mon Apr 9 9:42:59 2007. | [Full View] |
From: nemesis786 on Mon Apr 9 9:44:46 2007. | [Full View] |
From: NOV on Mon Apr 9 9:49:00 2007. | [Full View] |
selvakumar wrote: |
![]() |
From: joe on Mon Apr 9 9:59:02 2007. | [Full View] |
From: dinesh2002 on Mon Apr 9 10:02:54 2007. | [Full View] |
NOV wrote: |
![]() you are 20 or 40? |
From: ajaybaskar on Mon Apr 9 10:04:56 2007. | [Full View] |
nemesis786 wrote: |
Best music Director ![]() I would say it is yuvan as he is able to bring in techno beats n modern music and also score well for mass masala films as well as village subjects. For sure Yuvan is the heir to ARR who was the heir to IR ![]() |
From: MADDY on Mon Apr 9 11:33:15 2007. | [Full View] |
selvakumar wrote: |
NOwadays, I see HJ coming close to that when we are moving to a period in which LYRICS are ra**ed with music !
and I do know a man called M.S.Viswanaathan who has given amazing numbers to MGR in his films ![]() ![]() |
From: great on Mon Apr 9 11:42:23 2007. | [Full View] |
MADDY wrote: |
2. saami - kalyanam dhaan katti kittu odi polama?? ahhaaa idhu allavo, lyrics-ukku mukkyathuvam kudupadhu |
From: MADDY on Mon Apr 9 11:46:29 2007. | [Full View] |
great wrote: | ||
MD alone cannot be blamed for the crappy lyrics. What does Producer and Director are doing the tunes are picked by director, lyrics also chosen by directors. |
From: nemesis786 on Mon Apr 9 11:49:25 2007. | [Full View] |
From: great on Mon Apr 9 11:51:10 2007. | [Full View] |
MADDY wrote: |
no great, i'm not at all blaming HJ here........infact i enjoyed the song a lot ![]() ![]() |
From: VENKIRAJA on Mon Apr 9 11:54:03 2007. | [Full View] |
nemesis786 wrote: |
Minnale , 12B , Remo Song , Ghajini , Kaaka Kaaka are unbeatable albums. ![]() |
From: selvakumar on Mon Apr 9 11:55:15 2007. | [Full View] |
NOV wrote: | ||
![]() well, if you must know, both of them have tremendous respect for him and have fallen at his feet to get his blessings. ![]() |
From: VENKIRAJA on Mon Apr 9 11:57:36 2007. | [Full View] |
selvakumar wrote: | ||||
That is pretty much expected. I will certainly respect someone who have already done enough things and have accomplished a lot, irrespective of their talent, limitations, short-comings etc ![]() Coming to the point : Many of u people are forcing me to bash MSV time and again ![]() ![]() To prove him, "IR and ARR is not required - TN people are enough" ![]() Someo of Newton's theories were clearly disproved by Einstein. That is how "Growth and New Things" will come in. We should embrace such things and should accept that someone started it while others surpassed them ![]() That doesn't mean EINSTEIN will disrepect Newton's works ![]() |
From: Sanguine Sridhar on Mon Apr 9 11:59:26 2007. | [Full View] |
From: thimuru on Mon Apr 9 12:58:01 2007. | [Full View] |
Sanguine Sridhar wrote: |
Yesterday I was listening 'Aararai Kodi Pergalil' song from 'Anbe Aaruyire' what an Intro song! ![]() And also I was listening to 'Kuliridhu' from the movie Tajmahal.Beautiful melody. Always Ilayaraja is my pick but... A.R.Rehaman surpassed Ilayaraja in one thing, 'Sincearity'. Now read my first two lines, will justify my point. |
From: m_23_bayarea on Mon Apr 9 14:19:16 2007. | [Full View] |
From: Nakeeran on Mon Apr 9 14:35:15 2007. | [Full View] |
selvakumar wrote: |
[quote="NOV:
Coming to the point : Many of u people are forcing me to bash MSV time and again ![]() ![]() |
From: joe on Mon Apr 9 20:47:40 2007. | [Full View] |
Nakeeran wrote: |
MSV oru trend setter saar . Neenga ennenaa avaru avaroda age groupukku dhaan isai amaitharunnu oru pudhu Newton theory vudreenga ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
From: rajeshkrv on Mon Apr 9 21:00:41 2007. | [Full View] |
From: rajeshkrv on Mon Apr 9 21:03:31 2007. | [Full View] |
From: NOV on Mon Apr 9 21:20:41 2007. | [Full View] |
From: joe on Mon Apr 9 21:35:55 2007. | [Full View] |
NOV wrote: |
jokes aside, the first trendsetter for tamil film music was G Ramanathan. He was followed by MSV-TKR and then MSV solo. IR took over the mantle in the 70s while Rahman had his reign from the 90s.
|
From: joe on Mon Apr 9 21:59:21 2007. | [Full View] |
From: Hulkster on Mon Apr 9 22:04:17 2007. | [Full View] |
From: joe on Mon Apr 9 22:06:44 2007. | [Full View] |
From: MADDY on Mon Apr 9 22:18:47 2007. | [Full View] |
joe wrote: |
For others who have no idea about G.Ramanathan ,he was the MD of VeeraPandiya kattabomman ,for which He won best music director award at Cairo asian african film festival ,along with NT who won best actor award. |
From: MADDY on Mon Apr 9 22:25:24 2007. | [Full View] |
From: great on Mon Apr 9 22:26:35 2007. | [Full View] |
From: Hulkster on Mon Apr 9 22:29:34 2007. | [Full View] |
From: MADDY on Mon Apr 9 22:44:54 2007. | [Full View] |
From: thinkfloyd on Mon Apr 9 23:13:58 2007. | [Full View] |
From: joe on Mon Apr 9 23:18:03 2007. | [Full View] |
From: Nerd on Mon Apr 9 23:30:21 2007. | [Full View] |
From: joe on Mon Apr 9 23:32:09 2007. | [Full View] |
Nerd wrote: |
I seldom listen to other MD songs ![]() |
From: Nerd on Mon Apr 9 23:33:01 2007. | [Full View] |
joe wrote: |
Apart from these ,most of the people always forget another great MD ,none other than KV Mahadevan ,who has done many MGR and NT movies ,which were mostly mistaken as done by MSV. |
From: joe on Mon Apr 9 23:35:31 2007. | [Full View] |
Nerd wrote: | ||
I fall in this category, joe ![]() |
From: thinkfloyd on Mon Apr 9 23:42:25 2007. | [Full View] |
joe wrote: |
Nlla sonneenga Thinkfloyd! ![]() People..People..People... ![]() |
From: MADDY on Mon Apr 9 23:54:14 2007. | [Full View] |
thinkfloyd wrote: |
Just wanted to add this:
I see many people slotting IR under *folk*, *village* with WCM. This is like saying SPB is good (only) for title songs or 'famous' for title songs. ippo naama pesara 'global', 'fusion' etc etc terms ellam varathukku munnadiye IR had straddled all those genres. (Yes, it was done even before IR but not as prolific as IR). |
From: lavanya22rit on Tue Apr 10 0:26:36 2007. | [Full View] |
From: Hulkster on Tue Apr 10 0:37:50 2007. | [Full View] |
From: Jabroni on Tue Apr 10 0:43:23 2007. | [Full View] |
From: Jabroni on Tue Apr 10 0:44:54 2007. | [Full View] |
From: thimuru on Tue Apr 10 0:50:46 2007. | [Full View] |
Jabroni wrote: |
lavanya sisteru
karakaatakaaran padam paartha ngabagam illayo? `adiyE manam nillunnA nikkAdhedi', 'thaNNiththotti thEdi vandha kannukkutty', 'mArugO mArugO' asai nooru vagai -- Adutha varisu Yei atha athorama variya -- Payangangal mudivadhillai Rakkama kaiyai thatthu is latino spiced up with WCM all the way Machanai Paartheengala mEgam karukkaiyiLe from vaidhEhi kaathirundhaal |
From: thinkfloyd on Tue Apr 10 0:52:56 2007. | [Full View] |
Jabroni wrote: |
lavanya sisteru
karakaatakaaran padam paartha ngabagam illayo? `adiyE manam nillunnA nikkAdhedi', 'thaNNiththotti thEdi vandha kannukkutty', 'mArugO mArugO' asai nooru vagai -- Adutha varisu Yei atha athorama variya -- Payangangal mudivadhillai Rakkama kaiyai thatthu is latino spiced up with WCM all the way Machanai Paartheengala mEgam karukkaiyiLe from vaidhEhi kaathirundhaal |
From: thinkfloyd on Tue Apr 10 0:55:38 2007. | [Full View] |
lavanya22rit wrote: |
I bet no one can find even ONE such POWER-PACKED FOLK song ever...even from IR |
From: thimuru on Tue Apr 10 0:56:13 2007. | [Full View] |
From: kb on Tue Apr 10 1:03:44 2007. | [Full View] |
From: thinkfloyd on Tue Apr 10 1:06:13 2007. | [Full View] |
kb wrote: |
oooroma aaathupakkam thennanthoppu.. gud song ![]() ![]() |
From: joe on Tue Apr 10 1:09:09 2007. | [Full View] |
From: kb on Tue Apr 10 1:13:36 2007. | [Full View] |
From: joe on Tue Apr 10 1:15:32 2007. | [Full View] |
kb wrote: |
at first i thought the songs are becoming a great hit because of the singers.. coz their voice only we are hearing and beats ,instruments are just a support..
after some time.. i heard some songs by very gud singers like SPB,hariharan,shreya ghosal etc etc... for growing music directors like srikanthdeva etc etc the song was horrible to listen.. they couldnt keep up the beats and grip in the song.. now i know MD is soul of music ![]() ![]() |
From: NOV on Tue Apr 10 2:01:53 2007. | [Full View] |
From: joe on Tue Apr 10 2:12:43 2007. | [Full View] |
From: NOV on Tue Apr 10 2:16:48 2007. | [Full View] |
From: joe on Tue Apr 10 2:34:56 2007. | [Full View] |
NOV wrote: |
actually Joe, any kind of comparison is futile. do you seriously think any tom dick or harry is going to change his opinion based on what he reads in discussion boards. . |
Quote: |
sometimes it works the other way and from being pro someone they become anti another one, because of the severe criticism. |
From: MADDY on Tue Apr 10 2:51:52 2007. | [Full View] |
joe wrote: |
Mostly No .But eventhough they don't agree openly ,they may change their opinion levels due to more info they get |
From: thinkfloyd on Tue Apr 10 3:03:20 2007. | [Full View] |
NOV wrote: |
actually Joe, any kind of comparison is futile. do you seriously think any tom dick or harry is going to change his opinion based on what he reads in discussion boards.
some things can be categorised, like MSV is a good MD, IR is a good MD, ARR is a good MD. But best? sometimes it works the other way and from being pro someone they become anti another one, because of the severe criticism. |
From: thimuru on Tue Apr 10 3:11:06 2007. | [Full View] |
thinkfloyd wrote: | ||
aahaa, soltaaru ba thalaivar.. note pannungada note pannungada... ![]() Maybe you should be the first person to put all this 'lecture' to practice when you post in ARR/Sivaji threads... What others say are "opinions", "subjective", "nobody is going to change one's opinion"... but when you say it, its the "truth" (as your highness recently proclaimed in an ARR thread)... ellarukkum hypocrisy irukku aana indha alavukka! ![]() |
From: NOV on Tue Apr 10 3:15:28 2007. | [Full View] |
MADDY wrote: |
........b4 coming into TFM page, i always used to see IR as a "dappankutthu" guy ![]() ![]() |
From: Sanjeevi on Tue Apr 10 3:18:13 2007. | [Full View] |
From: selvakumar on Tue Apr 10 3:18:22 2007. | [Full View] |
NOV wrote: | ||
I am proud of you Maddy. You will certainly come up in life. ![]() |
From: thimuru on Tue Apr 10 3:19:21 2007. | [Full View] |
NOV wrote: | ||
I am proud of you Maddy. You will certainly come up in life. ![]() |
From: selvakumar on Tue Apr 10 3:19:58 2007. | [Full View] |
Sanjeevi wrote: |
Enna oru poll statistics ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() 41 + 42 + 1 + 0 + 8 + 1 + 1 + 0 = 94 |
From: thimuru on Tue Apr 10 3:20:27 2007. | [Full View] |
Sanjeevi wrote: |
Enna oru poll statistics ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() 41 + 42 + 1 + 0 + 8 + 1 + 1 + 0 = 94 |
From: selvakumar on Tue Apr 10 3:21:48 2007. | [Full View] |
Sanjeevi wrote: |
Enna oru poll statistics ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() 41 + 42 + 1 + 0 + 8 + 1 + 1 + 0 = 94 |
From: thimuru on Tue Apr 10 3:23:28 2007. | [Full View] |
From: joe on Tue Apr 10 3:28:26 2007. | [Full View] |
MADDY wrote: | ||
true ![]() ![]() ![]() |
From: MADDY on Tue Apr 10 3:36:45 2007. | [Full View] |
NOV wrote: | ||
I am proud of you Maddy. You will certainly come up in life. ![]() |
From: Nakeeran on Tue Apr 10 4:38:38 2007. | [Full View] |
From: selvakumar on Tue Apr 10 9:35:09 2007. | [Full View] |
Quote: |
![]() ![]() yanpa, unga bias,prejudicekku ellam oru limit-ae illaya?? |
Quote: |
HJ-1. 12b - he made sukhwindra sing for "raja medayila" which was a part of tamil valarpu thittam???
2. saami - kalyanam dhaan katti kittu odi polama?? ahhaaa idhu allavo, lyrics-ukku mukkyathuvam kudupadhu enbadhu.... ![]() 3. KK - oru ooril song has major english lyrics and not to forget the "kannum kannum nokia" which also had lots of english lyrics..... |
Quote: |
yaenpa, tunes mattum englishkaaran paathu copy adipaanga aana lyrics mattum thamizhthanama irundhutta, support pannuveenga ,appadidhaane??? ![]() |
Quote: |
see, all this fuss about tamil getting killed in songs is pretty unfound.......
(i hope u'll defend HJ here and not offend Sudhir,ARR,Maniratnam,Madhavan,rajinikanth, and who else?? ![]() ![]() |
From: selvakumar on Tue Apr 10 9:45:19 2007. | [Full View] |
joe wrote: |
MGR Movies ---------------------- Adimai Penn Vettai Kaaran Maatukkara Velan Kaanji Thalaivan (Selva's favourite) Neethikku Pin Paasam VivaSaayi En Annan Pattikattu Ponnaiah |
From: Nakeeran on Tue Apr 10 9:47:34 2007. | [Full View] |
From: Sanjeevi on Tue Apr 10 9:49:34 2007. | [Full View] |
thimuru wrote: | ||
![]() ![]() |
From: selvakumar on Tue Apr 10 9:52:34 2007. | [Full View] |
Nakeeran wrote: |
Selva Sir
Dharmam thalai kaakum is by KVMahadevan ! And mind U even Adimai penn is by KVM only . Vataa |
From: Sanjeevi on Tue Apr 10 9:53:48 2007. | [Full View] |
From: Sanjeevi on Tue Apr 10 9:55:20 2007. | [Full View] |
From: selvakumar on Tue Apr 10 9:57:37 2007. | [Full View] |
Sanjeevi wrote: |
My father is biggest AM Raja fan
according to him AMR is/was best |
Quote: |
a kannadigan would say Hamsaleka is better than ARR |
From: Nakeeran on Tue Apr 10 10:04:50 2007. | [Full View] |
From: Sanjeevi on Tue Apr 10 10:09:50 2007. | [Full View] |
From: MADDY on Tue Apr 10 10:16:01 2007. | [Full View] |
From: Nakeeran on Tue Apr 10 10:19:38 2007. | [Full View] |
From: selvakumar on Tue Apr 10 10:27:34 2007. | [Full View] |
From: MADDY on Tue Apr 10 10:28:14 2007. | [Full View] |
Sanjeevi wrote: |
And a kannadigan would say Hamsaleka is better than ARR beware |
From: NOV on Tue Apr 10 10:30:57 2007. | [Full View] |
Sanjeevi wrote: |
Therinthavargal innum athigam kooralam ![]() |
From: MADDY on Tue Apr 10 10:46:47 2007. | [Full View] |
selvakumar wrote: |
Maddy,
Neenga sonnathu Unmai thaan !! I also hate vulgar lyrics. But adha music aala ethukku maraikkanum.. Vulargarity PAAMAALAI soodurathukkaa !! ![]() ![]() FYI, even though the lyrics of "Anbe Anbe" songs were vulgar, I still love the song ![]() ![]() and I do hate "Sakkarai Inikirai Sakkarai" irrespective of the music and lyrics ! and even very few songso f HJ too belong to this category. ![]() ![]() ![]() Maddy - FYKI, I am one among the people who expects good lyrics and that is only a sufficient condition for me if not a necessary condition ![]() Maddy - Roja la irundae kodukkuraanglaah ![]() ![]() ![]() P.S: en adi manasula yaar irukkuraanga appadinkirathu kitta thaatta neraya perukku theriyum ![]() |
From: selvakumar on Tue Apr 10 10:50:34 2007. | [Full View] |
Quote: |
n ARR's case its always like this - as u move away from tamil mainland, u'll get to see some of his unbelivable HC fanatics Very Happy
selva |
From: selvakumar on Tue Apr 10 10:57:50 2007. | [Full View] |
Quote: |
but i have my reservations on the plaigarism that is on display here......u wanna pick the lyrics of a particular MD's songs and u wanna pick on "chewing" issue on that same MD and many are following that.......why are u not pointing fingers at others who are doing the same thing,( infact can be ssaid that they are following the first one??? Banging Head ) yen avaraukku "important" deepavali padam release edhavaadhu release aagapogudha, which u cant oppose??? Wink |
Quote: |
The way you handle young playback singers is sometimes irritating. MadhuSree's voice in "Kannan Varum Neram" is Banging Head "enna aaeelaaaaaguuuuu" "Renduuu viliiigalll" |
From: selvakumar on Tue Apr 10 11:39:15 2007. | [Full View] |
thinkfloyd wrote: |
Just wanted to add this:
I see many people slotting IR under *folk*, *village* with WCM. This is like saying SPB is good (only) for title songs or 'famous' for title songs. ippo naama pesara 'global', 'fusion' etc etc terms ellam varathukku munnadiye IR had straddled all those genres. (Yes, it was done even before IR but not as prolific as IR). |
From: Sanjeevi on Tue Apr 10 13:58:10 2007. | [Full View] |
selvakumar wrote: |
That is the basic tamilian tendency. For many years, I thought "Kilakku Seemaiyilae" was by IR and "Raasayya" was by "Arr" ![]() |
selvakumar wrote: |
IF someone utters DEVA, for many "his Gaana songs" will come to their find forgetting all his melodies. ![]() Aaayiram per vanthaalum engala thirutha mudiyaathu ![]() |
From: Sanjeevi on Tue Apr 10 14:05:57 2007. | [Full View] |
From: ajithfederer on Tue Apr 10 14:11:11 2007. | [Full View] |
Sanjeevi wrote: |
what else? |
From: Ramakrishna on Tue Apr 10 14:16:04 2007. | [Full View] |
Sanjeevi wrote: |
After ARR showed a way to beat IR, Deva picked up with westernised form (lifting music from western side) Even crop MDs like Sirpi, SAR had given huge hits (Ullathai allitha thool kilapichu) after ARR. I mean ARR opened a way. |
From: Sanjeevi on Tue Apr 10 14:24:50 2007. | [Full View] |
Ramakrishna wrote: | ||
Can u elaborate on this Sanjeevi sir? ![]() |
From: Ramakrishna on Tue Apr 10 14:26:38 2007. | [Full View] |
Sanjeevi wrote: | ||||
I mean... ARR introduced a new form of music to TN (ofcourse to India) and we know it was succesfull. But it boosted to somebody that they went wrong way (kurukku wazhi) like Deva, Sirpi, etc (even vidyasagar, he copied arabic musics a lot) by direct lifting western, arabic and other music I didn't say ARR copied but other copied a lot after ARR success |
From: thilak4life on Tue Apr 10 15:04:45 2007. | [Full View] |
Sanjeevi wrote: |
When coming to Deva, we can split him as two ![]() when he was in first portion, he was not so famous, in-fact his songs were re-cycled version of IR tunes/music. Everybody treating (or hating) him as a xerox machine. After ARR showed a way to beat IR, Deva picked up with westernised form (lifting music from western side) and gave very famous hits like Aasai, Neerukku neer, Batsha, Annamalai (Inspiration - IR songs), Vaali. And he became one of successful MD. Even crop MDs like Sirpi, SAR had given huge hits (Ullathai allitha thool kilapichu) after ARR. I mean ARR opened a way. |
From: Nerd on Tue Apr 10 15:13:46 2007. | [Full View] |
thilak4life wrote: |
IR's music is eternal while in few more years, almost every kid(music director) can compose the way ARR does(mixing). |
From: kb on Tue Apr 10 15:17:30 2007. | [Full View] |
From: thinkfloyd on Tue Apr 10 22:32:59 2007. | [Full View] |
thilak4life wrote: |
Well said. Except a slight variation, IR can never be beaten or was beaten, if it means someone became more famous and sold records then its flawed to say the least. IR's music is eternal while in few more years, almost every kid(music director) can compose the way ARR does(mixing). Then the same people will study IR's interludes and see how he could use his Violin and bass guitar to heavenly proportions. The sense of nostalgia vibrates through your mind and the sensation is unparalleled. Like what Sanjeevi said, I most definitely agree about IR's exemplary Western Classical music (WCM) and Classic/Carnatic fusion. The experimentation he has done, can never be equaled. Some of the younger gen lads are ignorant about Maestro, so it's of no use talking to them. They should experience that for themselves and realize what we're talking about. Actually I listen to ARR too. But I think Maestro is undeniably the best of all Music directors we've ever had. |
From: A.ANAND on Tue Apr 10 23:49:36 2007. | [Full View] |
Sanjeevi wrote: | ||||
I mean... ARR introduced a new form of music to TN (ofcourse to India) and we know it was succesfull. But it boosted to somebody that they went wrong way (kurukku wazhi) like Deva, Sirpi, etc (even vidyasagar, he copied arabic musics a lot) by direct lifting western, arabic and other music I didn't say ARR copied but other copied a lot after ARR success |
From: thimuru on Tue Apr 10 23:56:26 2007. | [Full View] |
A.ANAND wrote: | ||||||
![]() |
From: smith on Wed Apr 11 1:07:33 2007. | [Full View] |
From: thimuru on Wed Apr 11 1:14:35 2007. | [Full View] |
smith wrote: |
Sari..vidungappa...
edhukku intha sandai? Ellarum othukara madri oru per solren.. best music director : Shankar Ganesh. |
From: joe on Wed Apr 11 1:16:43 2007. | [Full View] |
From: Sanjeevi on Wed Apr 11 1:18:33 2007. | [Full View] |
thilak4life wrote: |
Well said. Except a slight variation, IR can never be beaten or was beaten, if it means someone became more famous and sold records then its flawed to say the least. |
From: Sanjeevi on Wed Apr 11 1:20:20 2007. | [Full View] |
joe wrote: |
I think Shankar Ganesh -MGR combo also good! ![]() |
From: Sanjeevi on Wed Apr 11 1:23:42 2007. | [Full View] |
MADDY wrote: |
1. ARR Yahoo group owner - Bangalorean
2. ARR orkut group owner - Bangalorean 3. and the man who has been fighting "hopelessly" for ARR's cause in this HUB/old TFM page for 5years, urs truly is also bangalorean and kannadiga ![]() |
From: lavanya22rit on Wed Apr 11 1:31:26 2007. | [Full View] |
MADDY wrote: | ||
![]() ![]() sanjeevi, on a serious note ARR has his some of his most HC fanatics from Karnataka: ![]() 1. ARR Yahoo group owner - Bangalorean 2. ARR orkut group owner - Bangalorean 3. and the man who has been fighting "hopelessly" for ARR's cause in this HUB/old TFM page for 5years, urs truly is also bangalorean and kannadiga ![]() in ARR's case its always like this - as u move away from tamil mainland, u'll get to see some of his unbelivable HC fanatics ![]() selva |
From: joe on Wed Apr 11 1:36:36 2007. | [Full View] |
lavanya22rit wrote: |
debates are always on among the northies whether he is the BEST EVER MD in india
but its a pity that some ppl say hes not the best in TN |
From: thinkfloyd on Wed Apr 11 1:37:52 2007. | [Full View] |
From: lavanya22rit on Wed Apr 11 1:45:54 2007. | [Full View] |
Sanjeevi wrote: |
IR is a complete musician, no one can beat him
1) Natural songs (mannin isai) - no comments ![]() 2) Wester classic - noway to near him 3) Indian classic / karnatic - i think only KVM can equal him, others? 4) Light music - only MSV can equal (or beat?) him 5) Experimentation - only ARR is near to him 6) Melting music - no comments (listen to nee partha of hey ram) 7) BGM area - who will equivalent him? (yuvan is improving) what else? |
From: ajaybaskar on Wed Apr 11 1:51:17 2007. | [Full View] |
From: lavanya22rit on Wed Apr 11 1:53:21 2007. | [Full View] |
joe wrote: | ||
Do northies consider IR when the pick best EVER MD ? If not ,it just Best Ever MD they know ..If northies don't even know best ever MD of tamil ,it is not tamil's fault. ![]() |
From: nemesis786 on Wed Apr 11 1:58:05 2007. | [Full View] |
From: ajaybaskar on Wed Apr 11 2:26:43 2007. | [Full View] |
nemesis786 wrote: |
In that case even ARR is losing ground in tamil now to Yuvan and Harris , though media reported boys audio to have been sold for some record number of units wasnt it Kaaka Kaaka that made more impact? Minnale, 12B, Kaadhal Konden, Ghajini, 7G Rainbow COlony, Pattiyal, Arindum Ariyamalum, Manmadan, VV, etc
made more impact than any of ARR's albums ![]() That doesnt mean ARR is lesser to newbies like yuvan or harris? ! ![]() I think same applies to IR and ARR too ![]() |
From: lavanya22rit on Wed Apr 11 2:31:21 2007. | [Full View] |
nemesis786 wrote: |
In that case even ARR is losing ground in tamil now to Yuvan and Harris , though media reported boys audio to have been sold for some record number of units wasnt it Kaaka Kaaka that made more impact? Minnale, 12B, Kaadhal Konden, Ghajini, 7G Rainbow COlony, Pattiyal, Arindum Ariyamalum, Manmadan, VV, etc
made more impact than any of ARR's albums ![]() That doesnt mean ARR is lesser to newbies like yuvan or harris? ! ![]() I think same applies to IR and ARR too ![]() |
From: ajaybaskar on Wed Apr 11 2:38:38 2007. | [Full View] |
lavanya22rit wrote: | ||
If others have started to make more impact than ARR then: 1. their remuneration shud have become more than ARR 2. bigger projects should have gone to them instead of ARR 3. they should have become a better choice for popular directors and producers ahead of ARR 4. they should have reached a wider audience than ARR 5. one of them should have scored music for sivaji and broken all audio records instead of ARR but none of the above mentioned happened till now. FYKI....ARR inflicted ALL the above mentioned BLOWS to IR with just ONE album in 1992. |
From: nemesis786 on Wed Apr 11 2:43:18 2007. | [Full View] |
From: Hulkster on Wed Apr 11 3:14:13 2007. | [Full View] |
From: thimuru on Wed Apr 11 3:58:27 2007. | [Full View] |
lavanya22rit wrote: | ||
But the so called complete musician lost his TOP SLOT (16 yrs) to an UNKNOWN ROOKIE with just ONE album in 1992. |
From: ajaybaskar on Wed Apr 11 4:00:43 2007. | [Full View] |
From: thimuru on Wed Apr 11 4:03:05 2007. | [Full View] |
ajaybaskar wrote: |
YSR/HJ rock TN more than ARR? Yaru sonnadhu? ARR is the best.. |
From: smith on Wed Apr 11 4:05:19 2007. | [Full View] |
From: ajaybaskar on Wed Apr 11 4:08:46 2007. | [Full View] |
From: lavanya22rit on Wed Apr 11 4:09:26 2007. | [Full View] |
thimuru wrote: | ||||
why did bradman retire? why did vijay yesudas sings more songs than yesudas now? why did yuvan/HJ rock TN more than ARR? why did MGR/shivaji films release in second release theatres while simbu films release in good theatres? ![]() ellathukum oru time period irukku! even in 90s IR gave sethu,barathi,kadhalukku mariyadhai,hey raam etc! IR dominated TN for nearly 20 years! ARR could nt! if at all u should compare...compare the work of raja from 1976 and the work of arr from 1992! |
From: ajaybaskar on Wed Apr 11 4:12:52 2007. | [Full View] |
From: thimuru on Wed Apr 11 4:15:03 2007. | [Full View] |
lavanya wrote: |
"why did bradman retire?" -----did anyone achive more than what bradman did ?????????? "why did vijay yesudas sings more songs than yesudas now?" -----did vijay yesudas is more successful than yesudas ??? "why did yuvan/HJ rock TN more than ARR? " -----why do ARR rock india more than ANYYONE else ???? "why did MGR/shivaji films release in second release theatres while simbu films release in good theatres? ellathukum oru time period irukku!" -----Was simbu favoured ahead of MGR/Sivaji at the same time ????.....but ARR was favoured AHEAD of IR in the even-playing field....mind u IR was still doing many films till 2000 "IR dominated TN for nearly 20 years! ARR could nt!" IR dominated TN between 1976 and 1992 (16 yrs) ARR is the DOMINANT MD IN INDIA since 1992 and there is no distant second for him yet |
From: ajaybaskar on Wed Apr 11 4:17:51 2007. | [Full View] |
From: lavanya22rit on Wed Apr 11 4:22:02 2007. | [Full View] |
thimuru wrote: |
who said rahman rules tamilfilm world now? ![]() |
From: Scale on Wed Apr 11 4:29:32 2007. | [Full View] |
From: A.ANAND on Wed Apr 11 4:37:55 2007. | [Full View] |
From: MADDY on Wed Apr 11 4:38:06 2007. | [Full View] |
From: MADDY on Wed Apr 11 4:41:29 2007. | [Full View] |
From: swathy on Wed Apr 11 5:04:24 2007. | [Full View] |
MADDY wrote: |
thimuru, just one question:
do u accept that ARR was no.1 in 90's and IR was no.2?? if not, then y r u expecting us to accept that YSR and HJ rule over ARR now?? ![]() |
From: MADDY on Wed Apr 11 5:36:52 2007. | [Full View] |
swathy wrote: | ||
maddy i have a question on what basis you give numbers to MDs ? |
From: lavanya22rit on Wed Apr 11 5:47:41 2007. | [Full View] |
MADDY wrote: |
TAKE A BOW - LAVANYA ![]() its not easy to argue with 4-5 IR fans at a time in this place and u r doing that exceedingly well..... ![]() when we have ARR's music behind us, we need not bow down to any accusation/charges/complaints from others........keep going Lavanya ![]() (my lame excuse again - stuck with work ![]() ![]() |
From: smith on Wed Apr 11 6:05:19 2007. | [Full View] |
From: swathy on Wed Apr 11 6:13:55 2007. | [Full View] |
lavanya22rit wrote: | ||
Maddy....defending ARR is not so difficult comparing ARR with IR is like comparing the president of a country with a governor of a state |
From: thilak4life on Wed Apr 11 6:25:23 2007. | [Full View] |
thinkfloyd wrote: |
Vaanga Thilak Vaanga! ![]() Film News Anandan madhiri Film 'Book' Thilak ivar. He is a movie buff and an ardent fan of Aandavar |
From: lavanya22rit on Wed Apr 11 6:29:19 2007. | [Full View] |
smith wrote: |
Lavanya,
U have a terrific sense of humour. Comparing ARR with IR is like holding a torch next to the sun. |
From: thilak4life on Wed Apr 11 6:30:18 2007. | [Full View] |
From: Pras on Wed Apr 11 6:32:34 2007. | [Full View] |
lavanya22rit wrote: | ||
Maddy....defending ARR is not so difficult comparing ARR with IR is like comparing the president of a country with a governor of a state |
From: selvakumar on Wed Apr 11 6:36:01 2007. | [Full View] |
thilak4life wrote: | ||
Thanks Bala. Bala-va pathi oru vari-la sola moodiyadu. He is an open encyclopedia. I am sure most of you would agree. I like this interface better than Orkut communities. You don't have to go to different communities to discuss. |
From: lavanya22rit on Wed Apr 11 6:39:40 2007. | [Full View] |
thilak4life wrote: |
Ignorant people sharing a moment of bliss. Whoops!
BTW, it was fun reading some of the posts. MTV-watching AD-ridden Generation has taken over. Wow! Comparing ARR to IR, is like comparing Chopin(Frederic) to Mozart. And that's a big compliment to ARR. |
From: thilak4life on Wed Apr 11 6:42:17 2007. | [Full View] |
From: selvakumar on Wed Apr 11 6:43:04 2007. | [Full View] |
smith wrote: |
Lavanya,
U have a terrific sense of humour. Comparing ARR with IR is like holding a torch next to the sun. |
From: lavanya22rit on Wed Apr 11 6:43:21 2007. | [Full View] |
Pras wrote: | ||||
lavanya, i would say, governor of a small village ... and the governor is none other than your ARR ... |
From: Sanjeevi on Wed Apr 11 6:43:29 2007. | [Full View] |
lavanya22rit wrote: |
comparing ARR with IR is like comparing the president of a country with a governor of a state |
From: selvakumar on Wed Apr 11 6:46:45 2007. | [Full View] |
From: swathy on Wed Apr 11 6:50:25 2007. | [Full View] |
lavanya22rit wrote: |
How many ppl know abt IR outside south india ??? Does he have the reach of ARR ?? |
From: selvakumar on Wed Apr 11 6:56:06 2007. | [Full View] |
swathy wrote: |
Thats because of the media. Nothing more than that. Further we agree IR is not good in marketing. He is just a musician. |
From: lavanya22rit on Wed Apr 11 6:56:44 2007. | [Full View] |
swathy wrote: | ||
Thats because of the media. Nothing more than that. Further we agree IR is not good in marketing. He is just a musician. |
From: Nakeeran on Wed Apr 11 7:07:27 2007. | [Full View] |
swathy wrote: | ||
Thats because of the media. Nothing more than that. Further we agree IR is not good in marketing. He is just a musician. |
From: smith on Wed Apr 11 7:19:56 2007. | [Full View] |
From: MADDY on Wed Apr 11 7:21:18 2007. | [Full View] |
From: Nakeeran on Wed Apr 11 7:23:40 2007. | [Full View] |
From: Sanjeevi on Wed Apr 11 7:30:54 2007. | [Full View] |
lavanya22rit wrote: |
How many ppl know abt IR outside south india ??? Does he have the reach of ARR ?? |
From: lavanya22rit on Wed Apr 11 7:31:57 2007. | [Full View] |
smith wrote: |
It is not the range of music. Roja was released in hindi & also it happened to be a maniratnam's film.
That helped ARR get a foothold there. Subsequently he became famous bcos he did many hindi films. IR was too busy to commit himself to hindi films. He did do few music films but those tunes were largely taken from his tamil fims. If ARR too had confined himself only to south films, he would not have become this popular. It has nothing to do with new direction, range etc., these are just flowery words, that's all. |
From: thilak4life on Wed Apr 11 7:35:57 2007. | [Full View] |
From: joe on Wed Apr 11 7:36:45 2007. | [Full View] |
MADDY wrote: |
i felt ARR maybe marginally crossed IR sometimes (escaaaappppu) |
From: nemesis786 on Wed Apr 11 7:38:11 2007. | [Full View] |
From: thilak4life on Wed Apr 11 7:39:25 2007. | [Full View] |
From: lavanya22rit on Wed Apr 11 7:39:36 2007. | [Full View] |
Sanjeevi wrote: |
fortunately ARR had Maniratnam to promote him in hindi unfortunately IR had no dir like Maniratnam Think what would be happened if IR continued to work with Maniratnam ini Roja, Bombay, etc? |
From: thimuru on Wed Apr 11 7:45:10 2007. | [Full View] |
lavanya22rit wrote: | ||
IR was the music director for Mani for all his movies rite from pagal nilavu before roja. IR had some memorable hits with mani....but they were just gud enough for tamil audience and its the other way regarding promotion....mani set his foot strongly in NI mainly due to ARR's music |
From: smith on Wed Apr 11 7:50:00 2007. | [Full View] |
From: Nakeeran on Wed Apr 11 7:52:21 2007. | [Full View] |
From: thimuru on Wed Apr 11 7:54:52 2007. | [Full View] |
Nakeeran wrote: |
Thimiru
Edho avasarapattu post seyura pole. Himesh is basically a Hindi film music director. Hence no wonder he is popular there. But ARR is basically from South & hence someone achieving such a level of popularity there is astounding feat Vartaaa |
From: nemesis786 on Wed Apr 11 7:56:39 2007. | [Full View] |
From: Nakeeran on Wed Apr 11 7:59:31 2007. | [Full View] |
From: thilak4life on Wed Apr 11 8:01:26 2007. | [Full View] |
From: Nakeeran on Wed Apr 11 8:02:30 2007. | [Full View] |
nemesis786 wrote: |
Comparing IR with ARR is like Comparing Sivaji with Kamal! |
From: nemesis786 on Wed Apr 11 8:06:26 2007. | [Full View] |
thilak4life wrote: |
Comparing IR with ARR is like Comparing Sivaji with Kamal!
Non sequitur and illogical, to say the least.. Visual medium let alone acting can never be compared/metaphored with music. IT sounds even more naive than what Lavanya said. A better comparison: Comparing IR with ARR is like comparing Pink Floyd to the teen-pop bands like Backstreet DOGS. |
From: thimuru on Wed Apr 11 8:07:10 2007. | [Full View] |
Nakeeran wrote: |
Ada kadavule !
Thimirungna - You mentioned that Himesh is more popular in Hindi. I had to remind u that he is already a HIndi music composer but for someone like ARR who is from SOuth to be so popular CRAZE is an achievement which IR could not do it. Ennappa idhu enna unga aalu threadaa . ennavellam post seivadharku. Konjam moolai venum thambi anything regarding music ![]() |
From: Jabroni on Wed Apr 11 9:36:10 2007. | [Full View] |
From: Jabroni on Wed Apr 11 9:38:25 2007. | [Full View] |
selvakumar wrote: | ||
![]() Dude, Both these guys have achievements which can easily place them as "STARS GLITTERING IN THE SKY". You are comparing them with a torch and sun so that you can view the sun through the torch you have. ARR is perceived as someone close to a GOD by NI people dude ! Check ur facts right ! may be : IF we comeout of TN and our inner feelings we shall accept it ! -- and btw, I do accept that ARR had a bad patch in the past few years and that doesn't mean he was out ! ![]() ![]() |
From: thilak4life on Wed Apr 11 10:27:59 2007. | [Full View] |
nemesis786 wrote: | ||
How it cant be compared? My analogy is very much clear that you guys are comparing someone from an older gen with a relatively newer one! Both have different genres of music whihc cant be compared! Even i can blindly justify , as you did, that IR and ARR can never be compared because audible medium cannot be compared while Kamal and Sivaji can be because same kind of stories or with little difference are being made with some changes that too in same format!! Would you accept it? Being logical is different from sounding to be logical! ![]() ![]() |
From: thamizhvaanan on Wed Apr 11 10:35:34 2007. | [Full View] |
Quote: |
Comparing IR with ARR is like comparing Pink Floyd to the teen-pop bands like Backstreet DOGS. |
From: thamizhvaanan on Wed Apr 11 10:43:33 2007. | [Full View] |
Quote: |
What did I justify? All I said was, IR's pattern of music works with me. I rate him high. Please scroll your mouse a little up and read my posts. I never said something like, they can never be compared. Lesser mortals compare and kill their time doing it. Sometimes, they enjoy and derive pleasure doing it. Even I am one among them. "Even i can blindly justify , as you did, that IR and ARR can never be compared because audible medium cannot be compared" Would you throw some light on this issue? I said, our tastes are built on exposure. That doesn't blindfold you from making a comparison. I said, opinions/tastes like 'ARR is the best' or 'IR is the best' are constructed by the external factors more than you per se. It's not something you choose. It's something that just happened. "Kamal and Sivaji can be because same kind of stories or with little difference are being made with some changes that too in same format!! Would you accept it?" I would accept that people compare them both. I would however take a broader look and say KH is better because of the naivety in the storyline in those olden days. The dramatic-opera kind of stage performances from Sivaji pales in comparison. Music on the other hand, is very different. "Being logical is different from sounding to be logical!" May I know the subtlety of that statement. My neurons fail to burn up what you meant to say. If you tried to be sarcastic, well it fails to cause an effect. Maybe I lack intellectual sarcasm and sense of humor that you have. It sounds rhetorical to me. Overall, I can make out that you're comparing artists from different generations in Films and music. Come on, It makes all the difference! Music is eternal, it doesn't have a storyline, it doesn't need a cast, it doesn't need images, doesn't have to cater to a particular generation and what not. The way you look at both the cases are different. The comparisons themselves doesn't sound illogical. But to draw similarities or metaphors between the two comparisons does. |
From: selvakumar on Wed Apr 11 10:46:56 2007. | [Full View] |
Jabroni wrote: |
You conveniently overlooked what lavanya wrote and is advicing smith. I am confused why do you use the word 'hypocrisy' more often. |
From: thilak4life on Wed Apr 11 10:50:34 2007. | [Full View] |
thamizhvaanan wrote: | ||
![]() ![]() If there is any MD to emulate pink floyd in IFM, IMHO it is ARR. Teen pop bands??? ![]() |
From: thilak4life on Wed Apr 11 10:57:24 2007. | [Full View] |
thamizhvaanan wrote: | ||
|
From: thamizhvaanan on Wed Apr 11 11:07:02 2007. | [Full View] |
From: Nerd on Wed Apr 11 11:07:20 2007. | [Full View] |
thilak4life wrote: | ||
Thanks Bala. Bala-va pathi oru vari-la sola moodiyadu. He is an open encyclopedia. I am sure most of you would agree. |
From: thamizhvaanan on Wed Apr 11 11:13:07 2007. | [Full View] |
Quote: |
haha, Intention served! Effect evoked. |
From: thilak4life on Wed Apr 11 11:13:49 2007. | [Full View] |
Nerd wrote: | ||||
adRa sakka adRa sakka adRa sakka.. keLambittaanigayyaa keLamibbaainga.. ![]() Digression ends. IR : Pink Floyd :: ARR: Backstreet dogs ![]() Well this won't tarnish ARR in any way and this probably is the dumbest metaphor I have seen for quite sometime ![]() I agree that IR is much better than ARR but that metaphor or whatever is indeed pukeworthy ![]() |
From: thilak4life on Wed Apr 11 11:17:31 2007. | [Full View] |
thamizhvaanan wrote: | ||
![]() thanks for the confession ![]() |
From: thilak4life on Wed Apr 11 11:20:42 2007. | [Full View] |
From: Nerd on Wed Apr 11 11:26:43 2007. | [Full View] |
thilak4life wrote: |
Nerd,
Out of the ten posts I posted, go pick the one where I digressed and use it for digressing further. Then moan about digression. age-old cliched logic ..Carry on! |
From: thamizhvaanan on Wed Apr 11 11:31:56 2007. | [Full View] |
thilak4life wrote: | ||||
yeah I atleast confess. But you can live being a hypocrite for nitpicking to support what you believe and digest something dumber. Please carry on. |
From: thilak4life on Wed Apr 11 11:53:17 2007. | [Full View] |
thamizhvaanan wrote: | ||||||
![]() ![]() |
Nerd wrote: | ||
I don't know where did I MOAN ![]() ![]() |
From: raaja_rasigan on Wed Apr 11 12:22:36 2007. | [Full View] |
From: sivank on Wed Apr 11 13:55:30 2007. | [Full View] |
From: Sanjeevi on Wed Apr 11 13:57:37 2007. | [Full View] |
From: Nakeeran on Wed Apr 11 14:08:40 2007. | [Full View] |
sivank wrote: |
I know I am completely out of time eventhough I am not that old I still think G. Ramanathan was the best music director to this day. Raja is great, A.R.R. is vry good still G.R was the best. |
From: Nakeeran on Wed Apr 11 14:10:55 2007. | [Full View] |
Sanjeevi wrote: |
Yaarumae MKT pathi solla mattengurangalae
is he a MD or only singer? ![]() |
From: NOV on Wed Apr 11 20:33:55 2007. | [Full View] |
sivank wrote: |
I know I am completely out of time eventhough I am not that old I still think G. Ramanathan was the best music director to this day. Raja is great, A.R.R. is vry good still G.R was the best. |
From: NOV on Wed Apr 11 20:36:19 2007. | [Full View] |
From: rajeshkrv on Wed Apr 11 20:43:16 2007. | [Full View] |
From: Hulkster on Wed Apr 11 21:21:41 2007. | [Full View] |
lavanya22rit wrote: |
How many ppl know abt IR outside south india ??? Does he have the reach of ARR ?? |
From: joe on Wed Apr 11 21:29:08 2007. | [Full View] |
From: swathy on Wed Apr 11 23:02:56 2007. | [Full View] |
From: thimuru on Thu Apr 12 0:17:33 2007. | [Full View] |
hulk wrote: |
Before ARR reached the global audience...IR already took the western world by storm with his HTNI and NBW and then his symphony...if not why should a westerner call IR to record india 24 hours album instead of ARR in 1996?..or that he was called up to do the music for india hosting the miss world paegantry? And to cap it all off his thiruvasagam was done with his close friend laslo kovacs, stephen schwartz whose pocahontas lyrics won him an academy award and richard king whose mixing is world famous...even the angelica festival where IR went and showed indian music was a result of a request of the italian organiser who loved IR's style of music alot....and he has recognition in US as he has received his doctorate there as well. |
From: MADDY on Thu Apr 12 3:37:53 2007. | [Full View] |
Hulkster wrote: |
but i am happy that they recognised ARR and i must admit he did not adamantly stick to his own style of musicmaking and tried to make it all-appreciative to get the NI's hearts while IR would not sacrifice his style just to please NI audience. |
From: thimuru on Thu Apr 12 3:41:47 2007. | [Full View] |
MADDY wrote: | ||
FYI, ARR's style of music has never been different in north......infact, he composed for a very few direct hindi movies in 90's......all others were "dubbed" from tamil........also, his direct hindi movies carried a lot of songs with a southie or a tamil feel......ex: yaaro sun lo sara (rangeela), mere sare suro me(kabhi na kabhi), shabba shabba(daud) are some of examples which comes to my mind now which were predominantly southie sounds.....its just that he mastered Hindustani music and other north indian folk types and gave their music better than their own people......wich i still consider ARR's biggest achievement.......synchronising ur work to multi-cultural tastes is no joke buddy........ ![]() he never bent for anyone or anything......when u have talent of that magnitude, u neednt........ ![]() |
From: Hulkster on Thu Apr 12 3:42:10 2007. | [Full View] |
MADDY wrote: |
..its just that he mastered Hindustani music and other north indian folk types and gave their music better than their own people......wich i still consider ARR's biggest achievement.......synchronising ur work to multi-cultural tastes is no joke buddy........ ![]() he never bent for anyone or anything......when u have talent of that magnitude, u neednt........ ![]() |
From: MADDY on Thu Apr 12 3:53:29 2007. | [Full View] |
From: MADDY on Thu Apr 12 4:02:39 2007. | [Full View] |
From: lavanya22rit on Thu Apr 12 4:23:02 2007. | [Full View] |
Hulkster wrote: |
Before ARR reached the global audience...IR already took the western world by storm with his HTNI and NBW and then his symphony...if not why should a westerner call IR to record india 24 hours album instead of ARR in 1996?..or that he was called up to do the music for india hosting the miss world paegantry? And to cap it all off his thiruvasagam was done with his close friend laslo kovacs, stephen schwartz whose pocahontas lyrics won him an academy award and richard king whose mixing is world famous...even the angelica festival where IR went and showed indian music was a result of a request of the italian organiser who loved IR's style of music alot....and he has recognition in US as he has received his doctorate there as well. |
Hulkster wrote: |
IR may not have a NI reach..but his songs have been copied over and made some copycat MDs famous there....they can appreciate songs copied from IR into hindi but not the original composer...certainly hypocritical audience they have there... |
Hulkster wrote: |
but i am happy that they recognised ARR and i must admit he did not adamantly stick to his own style of musicmaking and tried to make it all-appreciative to get the NI's hearts while IR would not sacrifice his style just to please NI audience. |
Hulkster wrote: |
No offense to ARR but he got through from tamil to hindi and then to global...IR without too much media publicity went from tamil and straight to global...that shows how recognised his talent is... ![]() |
From: Pras on Thu Apr 12 4:26:24 2007. | [Full View] |
Quote: |
How many ppl know abt IR outside south india ??? Does he have the reach of ARR ?? |
From: lavanya22rit on Thu Apr 12 4:29:01 2007. | [Full View] |
thimuru wrote: | ||||
absolutely!...but when he does tamil songs he must change his style!nowadays in his tamil songs ...there is so much north indian smell...do u disagree? |
From: Pras on Thu Apr 12 4:30:09 2007. | [Full View] |
From: lavanya22rit on Thu Apr 12 4:39:02 2007. | [Full View] |
Pras wrote: |
IR never had global recognition ? ![]() just two facts : - Conferred the Cultural Doctorate in Philosophy of Music, in April, 1994, by the World University Round Table, Arizona, U.S.A. - Bestowed with the honorary citizenship and presented with the key to the Teanech Township, by Mr. John Abraham, Mayor of Township of Teanech, New Jersey, U.S.A., in June, 1994 |
From: lavanya22rit on Thu Apr 12 4:41:29 2007. | [Full View] |
Pras wrote: | ||
lavaniya, i thought u were speaking about music, and not about how many stage shows ARR and IR have made outside india ![]() |
From: Pras on Thu Apr 12 4:43:07 2007. | [Full View] |
lavanya22rit wrote: | ||||
So u want to talk abt PURE music ???? I guess everyone knows that IR doesnt have a strong base (formal or theoretical knowledge) on carnatic music or anyother form of music which ARR does possess. |
From: Pras on Thu Apr 12 4:46:08 2007. | [Full View] |
Quote: |
ARR has also recieved such awards and accolades (u want me to list out ????) outside.....but there is a difference between recognized by a FEW ppl outside and getting a market outside. |
From: thimuru on Thu Apr 12 4:56:23 2007. | [Full View] |
lavanya22rit wrote: | ||
ARR has also recieved such awards and accolades (u want me to list out ????) outside.....but there is a difference between recognized by a FEW ppl outside and getting a market outside. |
From: swathy on Thu Apr 12 4:58:10 2007. | [Full View] |
lavanya22rit wrote: | ||||
So u want to talk abt PURE music ???? I guess everyone knows that IR doesnt have a strong base (formal or theoretical knowledge) on carnatic music or anyother form of music which ARR does possess. |
From: lavanya22rit on Thu Apr 12 4:58:40 2007. | [Full View] |
Pras wrote: | ||
i never said ARR never had anything, but you were speaking about recognition .... when FEW people like this give a doctorate to someone, it is usually not because they are the lone people to like his music ![]() |
From: MADDY on Thu Apr 12 4:58:44 2007. | [Full View] |
thimuru wrote: | ||||
yeah... 1.list the accolades attained by arr outside INDIA 2.what are ll his albums which reached greatly outside india(apart from NRI indians...I mean foriegners) any data u possess regarding his success 0utside India? really i like to know...because it makes me proud as a tamilian! ![]() pin kurippu:those few people are not kuppan suppan ![]() |
From: thimuru on Thu Apr 12 4:58:51 2007. | [Full View] |
swathy wrote: | ||||||
![]() |
From: thimuru on Thu Apr 12 5:00:54 2007. | [Full View] |
From: kamalsurya on Thu Apr 12 5:02:45 2007. | [Full View] |
From: MADDY on Thu Apr 12 5:05:21 2007. | [Full View] |
thimuru wrote: |
MADDY...i dint commit anythig abt symphony!
![]() pras has mentioned two great accolades! ur point on global audience outside India and accolades outside india!...give us some facts!..because it makes us proud really 1.list the accolades attained by arr outside INDIA 2.what are ll his albums which reached greatly outside india(apart from NRI indians...I mean foriegners) any data u possess regarding his success 0utside India? |
From: kamalsurya on Thu Apr 12 5:12:24 2007. | [Full View] |
lavanya22rit wrote: |
Good...blame the audience when ur favourite is not good enough to attract them with his music. Can u pls explain why the "hypocritical audience" appreciate ARR ???? |
From: selvakumar on Thu Apr 12 5:14:33 2007. | [Full View] |
From: MADDY on Thu Apr 12 5:33:36 2007. | [Full View] |
selvakumar wrote: |
ARR's present global recognition ||| IR's NI Recognition ! |
From: thimuru on Thu Apr 12 5:34:37 2007. | [Full View] |
MADDY wrote: | ||
can i get a equivalent of "Bombay Dreams" for IR in this aspect.... ![]() |
From: lavanya22rit on Thu Apr 12 5:36:13 2007. | [Full View] |
thimuru wrote: |
1.list the accolades attained by arr outside INDIA 2.what are ll his albums which reached greatly outside india(apart from NRI indians...I mean foriegners) any data u possess regarding his success 0utside India? really i like to know...because it makes me proud as a tamilian! ![]() |
thimuru wrote: |
pin kurippu:those few people are not kuppan suppan ![]() |
From: MADDY on Thu Apr 12 5:38:53 2007. | [Full View] |
thimuru wrote: | ||||
bombay dreams? i guess its just made for NRI people out there! did it really make an impact on global audience |
From: thimuru on Thu Apr 12 5:40:52 2007. | [Full View] |
Quote: |
1.His first movie album Roja was listed in TIME magazine's "Top 10 Movie Soundtracks of All Time".
2.“Inside Man” featuring Denzel Washington had A.R. Rahman’s Chaiyya Chaiyya as the score for the opening and ending credits. 3.On May 23rd 2006, a two-disc album soundtrack, titled Introducing A. R. Rahman, was released by Times Square Records, featuring 25 songs he composed from Tamil film soundtracks spanning 1993-2001. The compilation soundtrack was well received. In addition to this, Rahman performed at the Hollywood Bowl amphitheatre in July of 2006, with Indian singers Sukhwinder Singh, Hariharan and Sadhana Sargam, as well as American performing groups Raagapella and Global Rhythms, to a sell out crowd. 4.A. R. Rahman has been nominated for the following awards: Laurence Olivier Awards (UK) 2003 - Laurence Olivier Theatre Award for Best New Musical - Bombay Dreams Dora Mavor Moore Awards (Canada) 2006 - General Theatre Division - Outstanding Musical Direction - The Lord of the Rings musical |
From: selvakumar on Thu Apr 12 5:43:09 2007. | [Full View] |
MADDY wrote: | ||
can i get a equivalent of "Bombay Dreams" for IR in this aspect.... ![]() |
From: MADDY on Thu Apr 12 5:44:37 2007. | [Full View] |
thimuru wrote: | ||
lavanya....as u said these are also given to arr by the so called pundits ![]() |
From: lavanya22rit on Thu Apr 12 5:44:40 2007. | [Full View] |
kamalsurya wrote: |
Biography of Illayaraja http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ilayaraaja
Ilaiyaraaja's composition Rakkama Kaiya Thattu from the movie Thalapathi (1991) was amongst the songs listed in a BBC World Top Ten music poll Biography of Rahman http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_R_Rahman His first movie album Roja was listed in TIME magazine's "Top 10 Movie Soundtracks of All Time Some excerpts from the article.Both this guys have done India and esp South India proud. ![]() |
From: thimuru on Thu Apr 12 5:46:58 2007. | [Full View] |
lavanya22rit wrote: | ||
BBC top 10 That was just a contemporary Top 10 popular at that time TIME magazine's Top 10 is an ALL time Top 10 Thats the difference between IR and ARR !!!!!!! |
From: thimuru on Thu Apr 12 5:49:46 2007. | [Full View] |
From: lavanya22rit on Thu Apr 12 5:53:26 2007. | [Full View] |
thimuru wrote: | ||
lavanya....as u said these are also given to arr by the so called pundits ![]() |
From: lavanya22rit on Thu Apr 12 5:55:05 2007. | [Full View] |
kamalsurya wrote: | ||
As once RGV pointed out he said the Northies were too scared of Illayaraja. If he came into the picture at that time into Bollywood then all the other MDs wouldn't have a chance,it was NI who purposly denied him.Just as the case was with Kamal, he was too good for those buggers. |
From: thimuru on Thu Apr 12 5:55:57 2007. | [Full View] |
From: thimuru on Thu Apr 12 5:59:07 2007. | [Full View] |
lavanya22rit wrote: | ||||
The same obstacle was there for ARR too.....but ARR overcame that thru sheer brilliance but IR succumbed to it |
From: thimuru on Thu Apr 12 6:14:19 2007. | [Full View] |
From: selvakumar on Thu Apr 12 6:31:28 2007. | [Full View] |
thimuru wrote: |
oru chinna doubtu!
why this thread allowed here ...as it belongs to current topics section in music section! ![]() |
From: lavanya22rit on Thu Apr 12 6:34:43 2007. | [Full View] |
thimuru wrote: |
ir is so busy here itself...no music director must have been as busy as ir in their life! ![]() |
From: raaja_rasigan on Thu Apr 12 6:37:31 2007. | [Full View] |
selvakumar wrote: | ||
Hey !! It was created to get the inputs from the members of this section of the hub who have less music knowledge and how they perceive the MDs ![]() |
From: lavanya22rit on Thu Apr 12 6:39:08 2007. | [Full View] |
thimuru wrote: |
thats what im asking...who are those audience..NRI or foriegners!
give me some facts abt its success... so far i have heard that the albums have been made for nris mainly! |
From: Pras on Thu Apr 12 6:43:52 2007. | [Full View] |
Quote: |
“Inside Man” featuring Denzel Washington had A.R. Rahman’s Chaiyya Chaiyya as the score for the opening and ending credits. The songs being considered for an Oscar in Original Song Category have been released by the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences and three of A.R. Rahman’s songs feature in the list. A.R. Rahman’s 3 songs have made it to the list of songs being considered”Chun, Chun” (Water), Khalbali and Luka Chuppi (Rang De Basanti) |
From: lavanya22rit on Thu Apr 12 6:45:16 2007. | [Full View] |
thimuru wrote: |
ir is so busy here itself...no music director must have been as busy as ir in their life! ![]() |
From: Pras on Thu Apr 12 6:45:38 2007. | [Full View] |
lavanya22rit wrote: | ||
May be u havent heard abt lord of the rings !!!!!!! |
From: selvakumar on Thu Apr 12 6:48:29 2007. | [Full View] |
Pras wrote: |
great ![]() all hindi songs ... you mean all those accolades for ARR or for Bollywood influence overseas ? ![]() here, in europy, bollywood is a well known industry ... sharuk, amir etc, are stars ... but they don't know about ARR ... nobody ... when i say nobody, IT IS NOBODY ! that's quite normal that bollywood sound tracks are used in english movies ![]() |
From: Nakeeran on Thu Apr 12 6:51:00 2007. | [Full View] |
From: kamalsurya on Thu Apr 12 6:51:24 2007. | [Full View] |
From: nemesis786 on Thu Apr 12 6:51:53 2007. | [Full View] |
Nakeeran wrote: |
ARR is India's GLOBAL BRAND EQUITY on music
like the brand Infosys / Tisco/ Titan / Reliance brands. Kannugallaa lets appreciate this and admire that someone from TN is being admired in a wider perspective. I havent seen a NATIONAL ALBUM like THAI MANNE VANAKKAM till now from any SI composer. ARR hats off . ![]() |
From: thimuru on Thu Apr 12 6:53:25 2007. | [Full View] |
selvakumar wrote: | ||
![]() A person who is fan of Amir will know how much he prefers ARR for his projects ! Don't tell me that your friendswho like Amir doesn't know about anything about the MD of RDB etc ![]() BTW, Is it quite normal that english movie gurus are addicted to using bollywood sound tracks? ![]() ![]() BTW, I agree with you on onething. that is on bombay dreams. Hope others remember my comments on BD and TSO ![]() |
From: Pras on Thu Apr 12 6:56:04 2007. | [Full View] |
selvakumar wrote: | ||
![]() A person who is fan of Amir will know how much he prefers ARR for his projects ! Don't tell me that your friendswho like Amir doesn't know about anything about the MD of RDB etc ![]() BTW, Is it quite normal that english movie gurus are addicted to using bollywood sound tracks? ![]() ![]() BTW, I agree with you on onething. that is on bombay dreams. Hope others remember my comments on BD and TSO ![]() |
From: Pras on Thu Apr 12 6:57:13 2007. | [Full View] |
thimuru wrote: | ||||
he may be refering foriegners selva...we know the hero of harry potter...but the music director?...andha maadhiri i guess! am i right pras? ![]() |
From: Pras on Thu Apr 12 7:01:32 2007. | [Full View] |
From: nemesis786 on Thu Apr 12 7:05:14 2007. | [Full View] |
From: ajaybaskar on Thu Apr 12 7:06:17 2007. | [Full View] |
From: nemesis786 on Thu Apr 12 7:09:27 2007. | [Full View] |
From: thimuru on Thu Apr 12 7:10:04 2007. | [Full View] |
ajaybaskar wrote: |
1. Does IR get the same package as that of ARR?
2. Y do HQ directors like Mani, Shankar opt for ARR instead of others? 3. Y does ARR's music fetch up gud price values among all the MDs in India? 4. Above all, The Head weight factor has not affected ARR till date, in spite of him being the king of IMI for more than 15+ yrs. Now tell? Who is the best? |
From: ajaybaskar on Thu Apr 12 7:10:27 2007. | [Full View] |
Pras wrote: |
vante mataram :
1. Maa Tujhe Salaam 2. Revival (Vande Matarm) 3. Gurus Of Peace 4. Masoom 5. Tauba Tauba 6. Only You 7. Missing (Vande Matarm) 8. Thai Mannai Vanakkam (Tamil) 9. Musafir only one tamil song ... ARR targeted hindi people alone with that album ... is it that you call a "NATIONAL ALBUM " ? |
From: nemesis786 on Thu Apr 12 7:11:30 2007. | [Full View] |
ajaybaskar wrote: |
Hindi is the National language of India. So wats wrong in calling it a National album. Do u expect ARR to compose the songs in all Indian Languages? Be proud that ppl from 28 different countries listened Vande mataram. Thats the reach of ARR. Dont degrade his effort for the sake of arguments..Please.. |
From: ajaybaskar on Thu Apr 12 7:12:23 2007. | [Full View] |
thimuru wrote: | ||
1.package? 2.why do bala,selvaragavan,aamir,vishnuvardhan(the best among younger directors) went for yuvan instead of arr ipdi kooda ketkalam ![]() 3. point taken 4.head weight yaaruku?(hehe)..apdiye irundh than enna ippo ![]() |
From: Pras on Thu Apr 12 7:12:41 2007. | [Full View] |
From: thimuru on Thu Apr 12 7:13:22 2007. | [Full View] |
From: lavanya22rit on Thu Apr 12 7:15:20 2007. | [Full View] |
Pras wrote: | ||
great ![]() all hindi songs ... you mean all those accolades for ARR or for Bollywood influence overseas ? ![]() here, in europy, bollywood is a well known industry ... sharuk, amir etc, are stars ... but they don't know about ARR ... nobody ... when i say nobody, IT IS NOBODY ! that's quite normal that bollywood sound tracks are used in english movies ![]() |
From: kamalsurya on Thu Apr 12 7:18:20 2007. | [Full View] |
thimuru wrote: |
imho
aamir,selvaragavan is better than shankar! regarding maniratnam...lets wait...these guys are still young |
From: Pras on Thu Apr 12 7:20:50 2007. | [Full View] |
ajaybaskar wrote: | ||
Hindi is the National language of India. So wats wrong in calling it a National album. Do u expect ARR to compose the songs in all Indian Languages? Be proud that ppl from 28 different countries listened Vande mataram. Thats the reach of ARR. Dont degrade his effort for the sake of arguments..Please.. |
From: ajaybaskar on Thu Apr 12 7:20:50 2007. | [Full View] |
Pras wrote: |
1. Does IR get the same package as that of ARR? - Nope, better ! BTW, what do you mean by package ?
2. Y do HQ directors like Mani, Shankar opt for ARR instead of others? - Mani's first choice is always IR, only difference of opinion ! Shanker thargets youth people, he needs heavy drum beats as background, he won't go for a soft, melodious IR ! 3. Y does ARR's music fetch up gud price valuesamong all the MDs in India? - cos he is paired with giants like mani and shanker ! 4. Above all, The Head weight factor has not affected ARR till date, in spite of him being the king of IMI for more than 15+ yrs. -and ? ![]() Now tell? Who is the best? - Ilayaraaja ! |
From: lavanya22rit on Thu Apr 12 7:21:30 2007. | [Full View] |
Pras wrote: |
vante mataram :
1. Maa Tujhe Salaam 2. Revival (Vande Matarm) 3. Gurus Of Peace 4. Masoom 5. Tauba Tauba 6. Only You 7. Missing (Vande Matarm) 8. Thai Mannai Vanakkam (Tamil) 9. Musafir only one tamil song ... ARR targeted hindi people alone with that album ... is it that you call a "NATIONAL ALBUM " ? |
From: Pras on Thu Apr 12 7:24:30 2007. | [Full View] |
From: ajaybaskar on Thu Apr 12 7:26:01 2007. | [Full View] |
Pras wrote: | ||||
i am proud to be a tamizhan, not u ? ARR used bollywood as a tremplin to get into the international level ... Kamal could have easily done that too, i am sure, but he want to get tamil movies to international level, angathaniya nikkiran namma aalu ! |
From: lavanya22rit on Thu Apr 12 7:27:44 2007. | [Full View] |
Pras wrote: | ||||
i am proud to be a tamizhan, not u ? ARR used bollywood as a tremplin to get into the international level ... Kamal could have easily done that too, i am sure, but he want to get tamil movies to international level, angathaniya nikkiran namma aalu ! |
From: lavanya22rit on Thu Apr 12 7:28:40 2007. | [Full View] |
From: thimuru on Thu Apr 12 7:30:06 2007. | [Full View] |
lavanya22rit wrote: | ||||||
unga aalu ippo veetla thaniya ukkaanthuttu irukaaru (courtesy: ARR) ROTFL |
From: thimuru on Thu Apr 12 7:36:52 2007. | [Full View] |
lavanya22rit wrote: |
IR's son is becoming popular by adapting ARR's style......its a bitter fact for IR fans. |
From: lavanya22rit on Thu Apr 12 7:48:21 2007. | [Full View] |
From: raaja_rasigan on Thu Apr 12 8:05:23 2007. | [Full View] |
thimuru wrote: | ||
using westernized sounds is arr style? ![]() |
From: raaja_rasigan on Thu Apr 12 8:09:50 2007. | [Full View] |
lavanya22rit wrote: |
ARR toppled IR in 1992 when he was literally RULING TFM.....that too he was fresh from two magnonimous chartbusters thalapathy(1991) and devarmagan(1992)
ARR didn take over the mantle from IR after IR's era....but the fact is ARR ended IR's era thru sheer class and took tamil film music to a different plane. |
From: thamizhvaanan on Thu Apr 12 8:46:18 2007. | [Full View] |
lavanya22rit wrote: |
I guess everyone knows that IR doesnt have a strong base (formal or theoretical knowledge) on carnatic music or anyother form of music which ARR does possess. |
From: thamizhvaanan on Thu Apr 12 8:49:05 2007. | [Full View] |
raaja_rasigan wrote: |
"puriyaadha padalgalum
kadithu thuppiya vaarthaigalum mandai idiyai irukkum sathamaana osaiyum" |
From: raaja_rasigan on Thu Apr 12 9:07:42 2007. | [Full View] |
thamizhvaanan wrote: | ||
![]() |
From: Jabroni on Thu Apr 12 9:08:07 2007. | [Full View] |
ajaybaskar wrote: |
1. Does IR get the same package as that of ARR?
2. Y do HQ directors like Mani, Shankar opt for ARR instead of others? 3. Y does ARR's music fetch up gud price valuesamong all the MDs in India? 4. Above all, The Head weight factor has not affected ARR till date, in spite of him being the king of IMI for more than 15+ yrs. Now tell? Who is the best? |
From: Jabroni on Thu Apr 12 9:20:47 200 |