|
The Hub : Tamil Films | Hello Guest, Login to post. |
Bala's Naan Kadavul - 2
Topic started by MrJudge on Mon Jan 5 6:35:41 2009. |
From: rajasaranam on Mon Jan 5 6:50:28 2009. |
From: SoftSword on Mon Jan 5 6:54:26 2009. |
rajasaranam wrote: |
Reservation (Berthla seat Poattachu) ![]() |
From: viraajan on Mon Jan 5 6:58:08 2009. |
From: SoftSword on Mon Jan 5 7:01:30 2009. |
viraajan wrote: |
![]() He has reserved that space to make his first post!!! Appadithaane? ![]() |
From: Thirumaran on Mon Jan 5 7:05:37 2009. |
From: sarna_blr on Mon Jan 5 7:06:02 2009. |
From: Thirumaran on Mon Jan 5 7:09:25 2009. |
From: equanimus on Mon Jan 5 7:25:59 2009. |
From: MrJudge on Mon Jan 5 7:28:41 2009. |
sarna_blr wrote: |
Naan Kadavul is (please vote after the movie release)
1.. Great, seen it once and will see again 2.. Ok movie, can watch it once padam release aanadhukkappuram vote podanumaa ![]() ![]() |
From: Cinemarasigan on Mon Jan 5 7:49:42 2009. |
MrJudge wrote: | ||
padam release Avarathukku munnAdiyE padam parthirinthAlum vote pOdalAm ![]() ![]() |
From: rajasaranam on Mon Jan 5 7:54:32 2009. |
From: crajkumar_be on Mon Jan 5 7:57:34 2009. |
rajasaranam wrote: |
Enjoy ![]() ![]() |
From: viraajan on Mon Jan 5 8:27:00 2009. |
From: viraajan on Mon Jan 5 8:29:22 2009. |
rajasaranam wrote: |
Enjoy ![]() ![]() |
From: Anban on Mon Jan 5 8:29:43 2009. |
From: rajasaranam on Mon Jan 5 8:37:50 2009. |
viraajan wrote: |
![]() You've saved my time!! Nandri hai ![]() |
From: directhit on Mon Jan 5 8:44:39 2009. |
rajasaranam wrote: | ||
I knew many people are trying to decipher the lyrics 'namakku konjame konjam (KV'la Padichathaala) samskrutham theriyum' Hence I tried my hands on it but it proved difficult and took hour to write down the lyrics, especially the chants that come second is very difficult. hope there are no mistakes ![]() |
From: SoftSword on Mon Jan 5 8:45:04 2009. |
From: Sanjeevi on Mon Jan 5 8:46:15 2009. |
From: rajasaranam on Mon Jan 5 9:01:27 2009. |
From: SoftSword on Mon Jan 5 9:09:17 2009. |
rajasaranam wrote: |
SS & directhit,
Meanings of few words are evading me. Need to refer to a good dictionary. If possible by tomorrow meaning will be posted. ![]() |
From: Cinemarasigan on Mon Jan 5 9:52:28 2009. |
rajasaranam wrote: | ||
I knew many people are trying to decipher the lyrics 'namakku konjame konjam (KV'la Padichathaala) samskrutham theriyum' Hence I tried my hands on it but it proved difficult and took hour to write down the lyrics, especially the chants that come second is very difficult. hope there are no mistakes ![]() |
From: Cinemarasigan on Mon Jan 5 9:57:02 2009. |
Sanjeevi wrote: |
Wov second thread ![]() I think this is first for a film without a star actor |
From: steveaustin on Mon Jan 5 10:01:12 2009. |
rajasaranam wrote: |
ஹர ஹர ஹர ஹர ஹர ஹர ஹர ஹர மஹாதேவ் |
From: viraajan on Mon Jan 5 10:04:46 2009. |
From: viraajan on Mon Jan 5 10:06:39 2009. |
steveaustin wrote: | ||
RS Thankyou very much. If possible, please try to post all other songs too. Wow! What a great man!!!!! IR - Really the musical God..... ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() Sorry. I am out of words......... Still listening to nAn kadavul songs from January 2, 2009.... |
From: steveaustin on Mon Jan 5 10:09:35 2009. |
viraajan wrote: |
Me too.... very emotional ![]() Salangai Oli -ya marandhutteengala Steve ![]() |
From: viraajan on Mon Jan 5 11:11:33 2009. |
rajasaranam wrote: |
ஓம் நமஸ்வாமாயச ருத்ராய ஜநமஸ்தமரயச ருடாய ஜனமஷரிங்காயதபஸ்துபதஜே ஜநமஹுக்ராயச பீமாய ஜனமோ ஹக்ரே வதாய சதுரே வதாய ஜனமோ ஹந்த்ரே ஸஹமியதெ தனமோ வ்ருக்ஷே ப்யோஹரிகேஷே ப்யோநமஸ்தராய நமஸ்ஷம்பவே தம யோபவேச்ச நமஷங்கராய தபயஷ்கராய தனமஷிவாய தஷிமதவாதச்சா.... |
Quote: |
கால த்ரிகால நேத்ர த்ரிநேத்ர சூழ திரிசூல காத்ரம் |
From: jaiganes on Mon Jan 5 13:00:24 2009. |
From: HonestRaj on Mon Jan 5 13:04:45 2009. |
From: irir123 on Mon Jan 5 18:50:19 2009. |
From: Nerd on Tue Jan 6 0:18:16 2009. |
irir123 wrote: |
where can I order NK album online ?? thx in advance |
From: rajasaranam on Tue Jan 6 1:50:15 2009. |
viraajan wrote: | ||||
Feeling it difficult to follow it ![]() There seems to be few mistakes ;ere.. ![]() ![]()
I think, its சூல ![]() |
From: MrJudge on Tue Jan 6 3:14:28 2009. |
From: MrJudge on Tue Jan 6 3:17:21 2009. |
steveaustin wrote: |
I am sorry. Loss of words. My mind have been emptied by the magic of IR...... Now nothing in my mind.... Only nAn kadavul songs echoing..... Even while typing this, I am still listening Bitchai pAthiram...... It's just like I am a mad...... No words to describe my emotions now...... I have been just washed away by the nAn kadavul Tsunami...... |
From: viraajan on Tue Jan 6 5:05:47 2009. |
From: SoftSword on Tue Jan 6 5:08:20 2009. |
From: crajkumar_be on Tue Jan 6 5:11:58 2009. |
From: SoftSword on Tue Jan 6 5:35:32 2009. |
crajkumar_be wrote: |
Oh, time for a list-a? ![]() In my mind, without doubt Thiruvasagam is the best album of IR in the last decade or two. Infact, its right at the top of Raaja's best ever. |
From: kamalsurya on Tue Jan 6 5:45:11 2009. |
viraajan wrote: | ||
I have never got exposure to mantras on Lord Shiva except Om NamaShivaya! This is the 1st time i'm hearing Rudhras.... It does create a vibration. Powerful indeed!!! |
From: viraajan on Tue Jan 6 7:44:45 2009. |
From: Plum on Tue Jan 6 7:50:02 2009. |
From: MrJudge on Tue Jan 6 8:35:43 2009. |
From: MrJudge on Tue Jan 6 8:36:44 2009. |
crajkumar_be wrote: |
Oh, time for a list-a? ![]() In my mind, without doubt Thiruvasagam is the best album of IR in the last decade or two. Infact, its right at the top of Raaja's best ever. |
From: ajaybaskar on Tue Jan 6 8:40:07 2009. |
viraajan wrote: |
pongal release i believ ![]() |
From: Sanjeevi on Tue Jan 6 8:55:57 2009. |
From: Sanjeevi on Tue Jan 6 8:57:01 2009. |
MrJudge wrote: |
I mean.. a movie soundtrack, tell me which one betters NK. |
From: SoftSword on Tue Jan 6 9:02:49 2009. |
MrJudge wrote: | ||
I mean.. a movie soundtrack, tell me which one betters NK. |
From: SoftSword on Tue Jan 6 9:04:22 2009. |
Sanjeevi wrote: |
My Quick Review of music album
Though IR is very good in 'Amma un pillai' he didn't succeed the level he achieved previously in Ak our prem kahani, Shiva (hindi) and Cheeni kum. I meant in reproducing his old song again. But I like that song. Om Sivoaham is wonderful song in the genre it sits. It is 'Kannil Paarvai' which is my pick of album since it gives 'the feel' to me. I wonder how the albums gives unique feel though one song (tune) composed some 20+ years before and with another 10 year old song. That is one of the reasons of victory of this album. But at the same time on the whole I am slightly disppointed since no 'Ilangaathu veesuthey' kind of song (I was expected). I read somewhere NK will have fun scenes same like Pithamagan had. If Bala can put humour why should not give place for a feel free song like 'Ilangaathu veesuthey'?. |
From: MrJudge on Tue Jan 6 9:34:28 2009. |
Sanjeevi wrote: | ||
Hey Raam |
From: MrJudge on Tue Jan 6 9:37:11 2009. |
SoftSword wrote: | ||||
Sethu... and ya, Hey Ram as well... |
From: Sanjeevi on Tue Jan 6 9:37:34 2009. |
From: rajasaranam on Tue Jan 6 9:46:39 2009. |
Plum wrote: |
RS, ungalaiye religion-udaya vilimila kondu vara Rajavale dhaan mudiyum. Innum ketkalai NK - Mumbai-le enge kidaikkum theriyale. Aanal, indha statement by you tells me about what to expect |
From: rajasaranam on Tue Jan 6 9:49:57 2009. |
MrJudge wrote: | ||
I mean.. a movie soundtrack, tell me which one betters NK. |
From: viraajan on Tue Jan 6 10:14:24 2009. |
Sanjeevi wrote: |
BTW I could relate some songs to some older songs
Amma Un pilla - Mani oosai kettu ezhunthu (Payanangal Mudivathillai) Om Sivoaham - Isaiyil Thodanguthamma (Hey Raam) |
From: SoftSword on Tue Jan 6 10:16:35 2009. |
Sanjeevi wrote: |
BTW I could relate some songs to some older songs
Amma Un pilla - Mani oosai kettu ezhunthu (Payanangal Mudivathillai) Om Sivoaham - Isaiyil Thodanguthamma (Hey Raam) |
From: viraajan on Tue Jan 6 10:19:07 2009. |
From: SoftSword on Tue Jan 6 10:21:01 2009. |
MrJudge wrote: | ||||||
sEthu had 'kAnak karunkuyilE'..though it was good, a non-sense song. In NK all songs have 'jeevan' just like pre-92 songs of IR. |
From: Vivasaayi on Tue Jan 6 10:24:17 2009. |
From: viraajan on Tue Jan 6 10:25:06 2009. |
SoftSword wrote: |
and just cos it had this song, u cannot underrate this album... which had two out of the world master pieces... "enge sellum" and vaarthai thavari vittai"... |
From: SoftSword on Tue Jan 6 10:27:39 2009. |
viraajan wrote: | ||
![]() You missed "Maalai en vedhanai" song.... One of the best love songs with fantastic lyrics ![]() |
From: Nerd on Tue Jan 6 10:32:23 2009. |
From: Plum on Tue Jan 6 10:52:57 2009. |
From: Avadi to America on Tue Jan 6 11:30:00 2009. |
Nerd wrote: |
Apart from raamar aaaNdaalum, pollAdha madhana baaNam was irritating too (except the last minute which was divine). Hey Raam BGM was out of the world though. Avathaaram, kAdhalukku mariyAthai, virumaaNdi, Bharathi etc. And there were numerous movies in which at least two songs were superb. |
From: MrJudge on Tue Jan 6 12:59:10 2009. |
rajasaranam wrote: |
avathaaram, Guru(mal.), heyram |
From: MrJudge on Tue Jan 6 13:04:12 2009. |
SoftSword wrote: |
i cant agree that song to be a non-sense... even if thats the case, the situation needed that song... and i liked the way the fight sequence overlap the end of this song... and just cos it had this song, u cannot underrate this album... which had two out of the world master pieces... "enge sellum" and vaarthai thavari vittai"... and i remember one more song in that album... kaadhalenna kaadhalenna katthirikkaayaa.... acc to me thats the non-sense song... |
From: MrJudge on Tue Jan 6 13:06:04 2009. |
Nerd wrote: |
Apart from raamar aaaNdaalum, pollAdha madhana baaNam was irritating too (except the last minute which was divine). Hey Raam BGM was out of the world though. Avathaaram, kAdhalukku mariyAthai, virumaaNdi, Bharathi etc. And there were numerous movies in which at least two songs were superb. |
From: Cinemarasigan on Tue Jan 6 13:33:40 2009. |
MrJudge wrote: | ||
Yes, the best in any Indian cinema...It was so subtle and so good. |
From: directhit on Tue Jan 6 21:28:53 2009. |
From: Nerd on Wed Jan 7 0:34:49 2009. |
From: equanimus on Wed Jan 7 2:45:47 2009. |
From: PoonaiKutty on Wed Jan 7 2:52:17 2009. |
From: rajasaranam on Wed Jan 7 3:22:29 2009. |
Nerd wrote: |
ஜெயமோகன் நான் கடவுள் பற்றி - அருமை அருமை! ![]() |
From: crajkumar_be on Wed Jan 7 4:20:58 2009. |
Vivasaayi wrote: |
pithamagan had two great songs
adada agangara and ilangaathu veesuthey! one was grand and scintillating while the other one had a breeze effect. |
From: sarna_blr on Wed Jan 7 4:21:03 2009. |
From: crajkumar_be on Wed Jan 7 4:22:07 2009. |
From: viraajan on Wed Jan 7 4:22:16 2009. |
From: sarna_blr on Wed Jan 7 4:25:29 2009. |
viraajan wrote: |
Naan Kadavul is slated for a Pongal release.
http://www.behindwoods.com/tamil-movie-news-1/jan-09-02/naan-kadavul-07-01-09.html |
From: viraajan on Wed Jan 7 4:32:16 2009. |
From: Prabhu Ram on Wed Jan 7 5:07:31 2009. |
rajasaranam wrote: | ||
|
From: Sanjeevi on Wed Jan 7 5:15:49 2009. |
From: Sanjeevi on Wed Jan 7 7:07:53 2009. |
Nerd wrote: |
ஜெயமோகன் நான் கடவுள் பற்றி - அருமை அருமை! ![]() |
From: Anban on Wed Jan 7 8:22:06 2009. |
crajkumar_be wrote: | ||
I liked Ilangaathu and Piraye Piraye more than the others |
From: MrJudge on Wed Jan 7 8:28:28 2009. |
crajkumar_be wrote: |
Judge,
Ippo irukkara mana nilaila endha mudivum edukkaradhu nalladhilla ![]() Unarchi thaakkamum vegamum korayattum.... ![]() |
From: A_Ajith on Wed Jan 7 17:01:41 2009. |
viraajan wrote: |
Special addition to Naan Kadavul!
January 7, 2009 Naan Kadavul's audio album now has a recent addition, a gift of sorts by Maestro Ilayaraja. After the movie's composition was over, Ilayaraja seems to have felt the urge to add another song on Lord Shiva in the movie. The new song penned and sung by the maestro himself, will be featured in the film's title track. Most of the other songs, written by Vaali, have already won wide acclaim from the music critics and lovers alike. Especially the goose-bump inducing Sanskrit number seems to be on its way topping the charts, aver music buffs. Naan Kadavul is slated for a Pongal release. http://www.behindwoods.com/tamil-movie-news-1/jan-09-02/naan-kadavul-07-01-09.html ![]() ![]() |
From: A_Ajith on Wed Jan 7 17:07:28 2009. |
From: directhit on Wed Jan 7 22:34:24 2009. |
Prabhu Ram wrote: |
Anyway, interesting interview. JM impressive as always. Looking forward to that "lonely" scene. |
From: rajasaranam on Thu Jan 8 1:38:53 2009. |
From: directhit on Thu Jan 8 1:40:29 2009. |
rajasaranam wrote: |
directhit,
Sorry Iam not able to take out sometime to complete the translation ![]() |
From: rajasaranam on Thu Jan 8 1:43:07 2009. |
Quote: |
"ஹாலிவுட் சினிமாவின் ஒரே ஒரு ஜீனியஸ் சார்லி சாப்ளின்" என்று சொன்னாராம் பெர்னார்ட்ஷா. தமிழ் சினிமாவின் ஒரே ஒரு ஜீனியஸாக யாரைச் சொல்வீர்கள்?
" இளையராஜா " அரசு கேள்வி - பதில்கள், குமுதம் 14.01.2009 |
From: HonestRaj on Thu Jan 8 2:44:40 2009. |
Quote: |
"ஹாலிவுட் சினிமாவின் ஒரே ஒரு ஜீனியஸ் சார்லி சாப்ளின்" என்று சொன்னாராம் பெர்னார்ட்ஷா. தமிழ் சினிமாவின் ஒரே ஒரு ஜீனியஸாக யாரைச் சொல்வீர்கள்?
" இளையராஜா " அரசு கேள்வி - பதில்கள், குமுதம் 14.01.2009 |
From: directhit on Thu Jan 8 2:48:10 2009. |
From: complicateur on Thu Jan 8 2:51:26 2009. |
From: directhit on Thu Jan 8 2:54:03 2009. |
From: rajasaranam on Thu Jan 8 4:00:59 2009. |
From: rajasaranam on Thu Jan 8 4:02:36 2009. |
complicateur wrote: |
The lyrics are wrong in one part certainly. The lines are
VyOmakEsa mahAsEna JanakA, Panchavakra Parasuhastha Namaha. VyOmakesA - The one whose hair is as dark as eternal space. |
From: Hulkster on Thu Jan 8 7:39:17 2009. |
Quote: |
Alex ♪ராஜாவின் @ராஜ் கமல் they say naan kadavul audio has a addition song is it true mods clarify.....please Yes 2 more songs inculded by Raaja sir after shoot (during RR session ) 1. TITLE song abt Lord shiva (one more song abt L Siva ) Penned and Sung by Raajasir 2. One Hindi Song (surprise package ) ...sung by Udit Narayanan ( first time in Tamil movie ) hindustani Gazals Styles |
From: steveaustin on Thu Jan 8 7:54:22 2009. |
From: steveaustin on Thu Jan 8 7:58:04 2009. |
From: MrJudge on Thu Jan 8 8:05:43 2009. |
steveaustin wrote: |
Two climax for 'Naan Kadavul'
http://www.indiaglitz.com/channels/tamil/article/44121.html |
From: complicateur on Thu Jan 8 13:35:05 2009. |
From: Cinemarasigan on Thu Jan 8 14:34:10 2009. |
rajasaranam wrote: | ||
CharuNiveditha Thavirththu Ellarkkum intha unmai therinjirikku ![]() |
From: MrJudge on Fri Jan 9 1:32:37 2009. |
From: HonestRaj on Fri Jan 9 2:41:58 2009. |
From: Sanjeevi on Fri Jan 9 4:17:42 2009. |
From: directhit on Fri Jan 9 4:22:13 2009. |
HonestRaj wrote: |
http://www.dailythanthi.com/thanthiepaper/912009/MDSG254552_CBE_ALL.jpg ![]() |
From: irir123 on Fri Jan 9 6:02:14 2009. |
HonestRaj wrote: |
http://www.dailythanthi.com/thanthiepaper/912009/MDSG254552_CBE_ALL.jpg ![]() |
From: thamiz on Fri Jan 9 13:32:10 2009. |
From: complicateur on Fri Jan 9 21:19:18 2009. |
Prabhu Ram wrote: |
Anyway, interesting interview. JM impressive as always. Looking forward to that "lonely" scene. |
From: Prabhu Ram on Fri Jan 9 21:49:24 2009. |
complicateur wrote: |
Another article on the title. |
Quote: |
நண்பர் மூச்சுவாங்கினார் |
complicateur wrote: |
(aaLkoottaththil thaniyE). |
From: complicateur on Fri Jan 9 23:30:25 2009. |
From: ajaybaskar on Fri Jan 9 23:33:06 2009. |
Sanjeevi wrote: |
Since Satyam is not screening 'Villu', Naan Kadavul is relasing for Pongal? any info? |
From: Prabhu Ram on Fri Jan 9 23:37:13 2009. |
complicateur wrote: |
//dig. PR: Yes it is a malayALam movie. Scripted by M.T.Vasudevan Nair end dig.//
Yes I was surprised that Stun Siva wasn't reused after the effort with creating the realistic sounds with the meat in PithAmagan. |
From: directhit on Fri Jan 9 23:58:35 2009. |
complicateur wrote: |
Another article on the title. |
From: rajasaranam on Sat Jan 10 3:20:22 2009. |
From: sourav on Sat Jan 10 3:35:51 2009. |
From: rajasaranam on Sat Jan 10 4:01:52 2009. |
sourav wrote: |
nk patthi mattum pesuna nallarukkum.... |
From: viraajan on Sat Jan 10 4:06:35 2009. |
sourav wrote: |
nk patthi mattum pesuna nallarukkum.... |
From: sourav on Sat Jan 10 4:19:34 2009. |
From: A_Ajith on Sun Jan 11 9:28:30 2009. |
From: mareen on Sun Jan 11 16:25:11 2009. |
From: bimmer on Sun Jan 11 18:21:10 2009. |
From: Prabhu Ram on Sun Jan 11 18:25:33 2009. |
Quote: |
(please vote after the movie release) |
From: Anban on Mon Jan 12 3:12:40 2009. |
Prabhu Ram wrote: | ||
![]() |
From: MrJudge on Mon Jan 12 3:42:24 2009. |
mareen wrote: |
already 4 votes ![]() |
From: sourav on Mon Jan 12 3:47:00 2009. |
MrJudge wrote: | ||
7 votes now.. ![]() |
From: MrJudge on Mon Jan 12 3:48:14 2009. |
sourav wrote: |
we can add poll at anytime... |
From: sourav on Mon Jan 12 3:51:04 2009. |
MrJudge wrote: | ||
No, we can't as far as I know. |
From: MrJudge on Mon Jan 12 4:02:16 2009. |
sourav wrote: | ||||
![]() |
From: sourav on Mon Jan 12 4:09:32 2009. |
MrJudge wrote: |
![]() |
From: NOV on Mon Jan 12 4:11:38 2009. |
From: jaiganes on Mon Jan 12 8:33:39 2009. |
From: A_Ajith on Mon Jan 12 17:30:34 2009. |
From: jaiganes on Mon Jan 12 19:45:26 2009. |
From: MrJudge on Mon Jan 12 23:30:47 2009. |
NOV wrote: |
Let me see what I can do... ![]() |
From: Nerd on Thu Jan 15 15:43:33 2009. |
From: cujoo on Thu Jan 15 16:47:25 2009. |
Nerd wrote: |
Naan Kadavul
Bala's Naan Kadavul has risen above all definitions and views. |
From: Cinemarasigan on Fri Jan 16 14:51:13 2009. |
cujoo wrote: | ||
When they are releasing the Movie ??? |
From: thamiz on Fri Jan 16 15:15:14 2009. |
From: Anban on Fri Jan 16 16:29:36 2009. |
From: MrJudge on Sat Jan 17 1:31:07 2009. |
Anban wrote: |
is Naan Kadavul going to clash with Nandalaala??
oh no. that will be unfortunate.. my money is on Nandhalala if it happens... |
From: MrJudge on Sat Jan 17 2:16:55 2009. |
From: jaiganes on Sat Jan 17 2:20:30 2009. |
MrJudge wrote: | ||
I am not able to choose between the two but NL has an edge over NK. My guess is NK will have authentic tamil flavor and people outside TN will not be able to understand and appreciate it as much as NL. I believe Mysskin has the potential to take tamil movies globally. |
From: Hulkster on Sat Jan 17 8:23:36 2009. |
From: MrJudge on Sat Jan 17 9:16:06 2009. |
jaiganes wrote: |
Quite the contrary on the tamil flavor part.
The songs dont sound international - they sound very thamizh - hitting the soft spot of thamizh ethos. Naan Kadavul is the all india thingy. the theme of NK is quite universal. I agree that Mysskin has it in him to take thamizh culture globally. |
From: ajaybaskar on Mon Jan 19 9:43:42 2009. |
From: jaiganes on Mon Jan 19 10:05:45 2009. |
From: ajaybaskar on Mon Jan 19 10:37:33 2009. |
From: irir123 on Mon Jan 19 14:50:34 2009. |
From: Anban on Mon Jan 19 16:33:13 2009. |
irir123 wrote: |
why do all our trailers have this irritating digitized "shhhsk" kind of sounds accompanying the intro titles ??!
uggh and eeks - dont our people know the meaning for the word 'subtlety' ? ellamey, ippadi anaavasiyamaana thadabudalaagathhaan irukkanumaa ? |
From: jaiganes on Mon Jan 19 17:09:21 2009. |
From: A_Ajith on Mon Jan 19 17:13:52 2009. |
From: irir123 on Tue Jan 20 10:11:01 2009. |
Anban wrote: | ||
gud question.. but bala is far from subtlety .. his movies arent loud but he keeps on showing off his "offbeat" attitude.. |
From: steveaustin on Tue Jan 20 10:36:21 2009. |
From: directhit on Tue Jan 20 21:13:08 2009. |
From: Nerd on Wed Jan 21 1:22:28 2009. |
From: Nerd on Wed Jan 21 1:23:51 2009. |
From: rajasaranam on Thu Jan 22 1:32:21 2009. |
From: sarna_blr on Thu Jan 22 1:41:10 2009. |
Nerd wrote: |
Bala’s Naan Kadavul in Telugu
Esther Sunita [January 20, 2009, 5:02:33 PM] Bala's magnum opus Naan Kadavul is all set to hit screens very soon. Starring Arya and Pooja, the movie has been in the making for over two years. Veteran music composer Ilayaraja is the man behind the haunting tunes of this interesting film. The audio of this film was released on January 1, 2009. Naan Kadavul is now being dubbed into Telugu, titled Nenu Devudu. Bala is already famous in Andhra for Pithamagan,which was dubbed into Telugu as Siva Putrudu, starring Vikram, Suriya, Laila and Sangitha. Nenu Devudu, will be another controversial film, with as much abuse as praise being heaped on it, going by the publicity stills and trailers of the film. Judging by Arya's unkempt look, which he's been sporting for over 2 years, the film will be dealing with the occult and the shadowy world of sadhus on the banks of the river Ganga. |
From: directhit on Thu Jan 22 1:53:59 2009. |
From: rajasaranam on Thu Jan 22 5:49:29 2009. |
directhit wrote: |
RS - its easy to look at the e-paper instead
today's ad : http://www.dailythanthi.com/thanthiepaper/2212009/MDSG255676.jpg |
From: Nerd on Thu Jan 22 12:11:59 2009. |
From: thamiz on Thu Jan 22 12:38:17 2009. |
From: jaiganes on Thu Jan 22 19:14:25 2009. |
thamiz wrote: |
Bimmer: IMHO, Bala likes to show human animals and bring the worst out of human beings in a worst possible way! Let us take any of his movies, it is true. That is what he loves about! ![]() |
From: MrIndia on Thu Jan 22 23:26:09 2009. |
From: Nerd on Thu Jan 22 23:31:49 2009. |
From: jaiganes on Fri Jan 23 3:02:17 2009. |
From: MrJudge on Fri Jan 23 3:09:40 2009. |
jaiganes wrote: |
ellarume collectionukkaaga alayum bodhu onnu rendu paer awardku alayaradhu thappillainnen |
From: joe on Fri Jan 23 3:14:47 2009. |
jaiganes wrote: |
ellarume collectionukkaaga alayum bodhu onnu rendu paer awardku alayaradhu thappillainnen |
From: jaiganes on Fri Jan 23 3:27:24 2009. |
From: steveaustin on Sat Jan 24 11:50:17 2009. |
From: steveaustin on Sat Jan 24 11:52:28 2009. |
From: jaiganes on Sun Jan 25 16:31:54 2009. |
From: steveaustin on Mon Jan 26 9:00:30 2009. |
From: Sid_316 on Mon Jan 26 9:32:33 2009. |
jaiganes wrote: |
The dark bald guy getting thrashed - is he the same guy who got it from Chiththan in Pithamagan in the jail riot scene? |
From: Nerd on Mon Jan 26 21:17:24 2009. |
From: NOV on Tue Jan 27 7:16:10 2009. |
From: joe on Tue Jan 27 7:30:52 2009. |
From: crajkumar_be on Tue Jan 27 7:32:24 2009. |
From: joe on Tue Jan 27 7:34:34 2009. |
crajkumar_be wrote: |
நான் கடவுள் பாடல்கள் வணிக ரகமில்லை |
From: crajkumar_be on Tue Jan 27 7:37:09 2009. |
From: joe on Tue Jan 27 7:45:25 2009. |
From: crajkumar_be on Tue Jan 27 8:00:16 2009. |
From: rajasaranam on Tue Jan 27 8:44:49 2009. |
Quote: |
அன்புள்ள ஜெ
நான் கடவுள் படம் எப்போது வெளிவருகிறது? அதைப்பற்றி நான் உங்களிடம் பேசவேண்டும். உங்கள் எண் தேவை சண்முகம் அன்புள்ள சண்முகம் நான் கடவுள் பிப்ரவரி 5 ஆம் தேதி வெளிவருவதாக இப்போது உறுதிசெய்யப்பட்டிருக்கிறது. நான் கடவுள் குறித்து அனேகமாக எல்லாவற்ரையும் இந்த பேட்டியிலே சொல்லியிருக்கிறேன் என்று எண்ணுகிறேன் http://www.behindwoods.com/features/Interviews/interview-5/naan-kadavul/jayamohan.html |
From: Cinemarasigan on Tue Jan 27 10:05:12 2009. |
From: podaskie on Tue Jan 27 10:40:27 2009. |
From: steveaustin on Tue Jan 27 12:31:13 2009. |
From: jaiganes on Tue Jan 27 12:44:31 2009. |
Nerd wrote: |
விரைவில்....
Feb 6th I assume. Texas-la release pannunga please.. ![]() |
From: Nerd on Tue Jan 27 13:27:48 2009. |
jaiganes wrote: | ||
Nerd - texasla enge? |
From: HonestRaj on Tue Jan 27 13:29:57 2009. |
Nerd wrote: | ||||
|
From: jaiganes on Tue Jan 27 13:34:54 2009. |
From: Nerd on Tue Jan 27 13:39:52 2009. |
From: steveaustin on Wed Jan 28 13:06:57 2009. |
From: steveaustin on Wed Jan 28 13:12:28 2009. |
From: steveaustin on Thu Jan 29 12:04:05 2009. |
From: Avadi to America on Thu Jan 29 14:07:18 2009. |
From: Nerd on Thu Jan 29 21:36:09 2009. |
From: directhit on Thu Jan 29 23:14:44 2009. |
From: jaiganes on Fri Jan 30 1:01:59 2009. |
From: dell_gt on Fri Jan 30 3:46:53 2009. |
From: complicateur on Fri Jan 30 3:54:50 2009. |
Nerd wrote: |
Feb 6 Confarmdunga. ThuNdu pOttura vENdiyathudhAn ![]() |
From: thamiz on Fri Jan 30 12:46:00 2009. |
jaiganes wrote: |
vayithula puli karaikkudhuppa.
|
From: thamiz on Fri Jan 30 12:51:08 2009. |
From: app_engine on Fri Jan 30 12:55:17 2009. |
From: Nerd on Fri Jan 30 12:57:10 2009. |
From: thamiz on Fri Jan 30 13:04:06 2009. |
From: Mahen on Sun Feb 1 0:41:16 2009. |
From: NOV on Sun Feb 1 10:11:22 2009. |
From: Mahen on Sun Feb 1 10:32:11 2009. |
From: thilak4life on Sun Feb 1 10:44:04 2009. |
From: NOV on Sun Feb 1 10:44:48 2009. |
Mahen wrote: |
OMG...I cant believe it...Nov, eppadi spot pannige? First time for a tamil movie rite? |
From: Mahen on Sun Feb 1 10:50:11 2009. |
NOV wrote: | ||
![]() ![]() will you also sponsor the ticket for this movie? ![]() |
From: MrJudge on Mon Feb 2 5:52:32 2009. |
From: dell_gt on Mon Feb 2 8:20:23 2009. |
Quote: |
Mahen wrote:
OMG...I cant believe it...Nov, eppadi spot pannige? First time for a tamil movie rite? me too... spot pannuradhu easy... see previous page. first time ever for a tamil movie. will you also sponsor the ticket for this movie? |
From: avven on Mon Feb 2 10:49:22 2009. |
From: thamiz on Mon Feb 2 15:02:23 2009. |
From: irir123 on Mon Feb 2 19:56:48 2009. |
From: directhit on Mon Feb 2 21:02:55 2009. |
From: thamiz on Mon Feb 2 22:53:45 2009. |
irir123 wrote: |
thamiz - what exactly is your point/are you driving at ? |
From: sarna_blr on Tue Feb 3 0:01:54 2009. |
From: Mahen on Tue Feb 3 0:56:55 2009. |
From: sarna_blr on Tue Feb 3 1:25:28 2009. |
From: crajkumar_be on Tue Feb 3 10:33:52 2009. |
Quote: |
Naan Kadavul fever begins worldwide!
By Moviebuzz | Tuesday, 03 February , 2009, 12:06 Bala, the man who revolutionized Tamil cinema with three trendsetters- Sethu, Nanda, Pithamagan is back after nearly five years with his magnum opus Njaan Kadavul, releasing this Friday (Feb 6) worldwide. The man who made stars out of Vikram and Surya is now all set to make Arya a star. The film is releasing worldwide in 235 screens, the highest ever for a Bala film. In Chennai city the film is opening in 9 screens, with advance booking starting on Wednesday. There is huge expectation regarding the film all over Tamilnadu, and the best of distributors are backing the project which has also managed to get good screens. Says a leading distributor in Madurai, the home town of Bala: " We are expecting the film to take the kind of opening a star film will take." The overseas prints of the film has been dispatched from Chennai on Saturday night. Pyramid Saimira is releasing this movie in USA with 5 prints across all major cities on Feb 6th weekend. The prints will be moved to next circle of cities, the following week. Says Jayavel Murugan who is distributing the film for Pyramid Saimira: " There is huge expectations riding on Bala and his Naan Kadavul as the previous three movies of Bala were super hits in US. This film is also seeped in realism and everyone knows that it was in production for last three years and lot of trouble and passion has gone into the film. All online tickets are now open for booking in USA and the first round of booking were awesome". The US first week schedule as follows Movie city , Edison , NJ Serratheaters, Bayarea, CA Norwalk, Los Angeles, CA Novi , Detroit , MI Funasia in Dallas and Houston, Texas. |
From: steveaustin on Tue Feb 3 10:47:14 2009. |
From: joe on Tue Feb 3 11:07:26 2009. |
From: app_engine on Tue Feb 3 12:19:58 2009. |
From: app_engine on Tue Feb 3 12:31:31 2009. |
From: jaiganes on Tue Feb 3 12:34:54 2009. |
app_engine wrote: |
This is from rediff :
========= You mean to say that without learning yoga, you started sheershasan straight away? Yes, I wanted to learn it as fast as I could. For the first few days, I had huge neck problems because I had no idea how to do it properly. I was very lucky I didn't break my neck. Because I was an athlete, I am flexible and could do padmasan without any difficulty. After some time, I became an expert in sheershasana also. ============= If he does not place both feet on the opposite thighs (like we see in the photograph), he can obviously "do padmasan without any difficulty" ![]() |
From: app_engine on Tue Feb 3 12:39:42 2009. |
From: jaiganes on Tue Feb 3 12:41:48 2009. |
app_engine wrote: |
>>'artha padmasana' <<
ok, does it mean 'half padmAsanA' ? padamum 'artha kiNaRu' thANdAmal irundhAl sari ![]() |
From: app_engine on Tue Feb 3 12:55:46 2009. |
From: app_engine on Tue Feb 3 12:59:43 2009. |
From: thamiz on Tue Feb 3 13:35:17 2009. |
From: NOV on Tue Feb 3 20:13:32 2009. |
From: Movie Cop on Tue Feb 3 20:41:23 2009. |
NOV wrote: |
-NK story removed- |
From: NOV on Tue Feb 3 20:48:41 2009. |
From: Movie Cop on Tue Feb 3 20:53:33 2009. |
NOV wrote: |
OK sridhar, story has been removed. ![]() |
From: NOV on Tue Feb 3 20:55:43 2009. |
From: Movie Cop on Tue Feb 3 21:00:05 2009. |
NOV wrote: |
anyway sridhar, I will enjoy if its truly funny. Bala was good at comedy in Pithamagan. Even in Nandha, the lodukku paandi character was good. ![]() |
From: directhit on Tue Feb 3 21:08:26 2009. |
joe wrote: |
Anoops,
Singapore releasing theatres info irukka? ![]() |
From: Nerd on Tue Feb 3 23:12:14 2009. |
From: littlemaster1982 on Tue Feb 3 23:13:13 2009. |
From: viraajan on Tue Feb 3 23:13:36 2009. |
Nerd wrote: |
Sathyam has special shows on the weekends. USA showtimes yengeyAvadhu yaarAvadhu pArthA post pannunga.. |
From: viraajan on Tue Feb 3 23:14:44 2009. |
From: Nerd on Tue Feb 3 23:16:07 2009. |
From: omega on Tue Feb 3 23:26:06 2009. |
Nerd wrote: |
Indiaglitz innum pOdala naansanss.. Seems only one print for the Texas area. I want to know if it releases in Dallas this weekend or not.. Sila pala plans pannanum.. ![]() |
From: Nerd on Tue Feb 3 23:28:26 2009. |
From: MrJudge on Wed Feb 4 1:25:52 2009. |
app_engine wrote: |
If he does not place both feet on the opposite thighs (like we see in the photograph), he can obviously "do padmasan without any difficulty" ![]() |
From: equanimus on Wed Feb 4 3:27:21 2009. |
littlemaster1982 wrote: |
Indiaglitz-la poduvaangale ![]() |
From: k_vanan on Wed Feb 4 4:39:45 2009. |
From: app_engine on Wed Feb 4 9:47:24 2009. |
directhit wrote: |
used to wonder how this organizations put some baseless case on movies etc - inga yoga pose kku adichukkaradha paatha dhaan puriyudhu ![]() |
From: app_engine on Wed Feb 4 9:50:58 2009. |
MrJudge wrote: |
Arya was talking about the padmAsanam done in the sirasAnam pose coming in the beginning of the trailer. |
From: MrJudge on Wed Feb 4 12:36:30 2009. |
From: thamiz on Wed Feb 4 12:53:24 2009. |
MrJudge wrote: |
app_engine;
padmAsanam is a basic one in yogA and I don't think Bala would do that kind of mistake (doing arai padmAsanam and calling it padmaAsanam).. |
From: MrJudge on Wed Feb 4 14:11:29 2009. |
thamiz wrote: |
How do you want to call the one Arya does in the still otherwise? ![]() |
From: SoftSword on Wed Feb 4 14:12:39 2009. |
From: littlemaster1982 on Wed Feb 4 14:13:02 2009. |
equanimus wrote: | ||
LM, Any details about when booking opens at PVR Bangalore? I went to PVR yesterday, didn't really see any "coming up" poster. Is it even releasing? |
From: equanimus on Wed Feb 4 15:40:58 2009. |
littlemaster1982 wrote: | ||||
It is releasing on 6th for sure. I saw posters in my area. PVR bookings would start tomorrow most probably. |
From: vasanth2006 on Wed Feb 4 22:04:13 2009. |
From: MrJudge on Thu Feb 5 9:49:01 2009. |
From: Prabhu Ram on Thu Feb 5 9:50:57 2009. |
From: Nerd on Thu Feb 5 9:58:57 2009. |
From: jaiganes on Thu Feb 5 12:18:16 2009. |
From: Nerd on Thu Feb 5 12:58:33 2009. |
From: jaiganes on Thu Feb 5 13:27:40 2009. |
From: irir123 on Thu Feb 5 14:08:56 2009. |
From: Nerd on Thu Feb 5 14:23:41 2009. |
From: irir123 on Thu Feb 5 15:53:23 2009. |
From: Guess_Me on Thu Feb 5 15:55:53 2009. |
From: thamiz on Thu Feb 5 16:22:13 2009. |
From: Guess_Me on Thu Feb 5 16:25:24 2009. |
From: thamiz on Thu Feb 5 16:28:12 2009. |
Guess_Me wrote: |
Actually he is a Vijay and Vikram fan |
From: sarna_blr on Thu Feb 5 16:50:16 2009. |
Guess_Me wrote: |
A friend of mine caught Naan Kadavul's preview show at Sathyam Cinemas, Chennai. The show started at 10.15 PM and finished just now. He said Simbu was also there for the show.
Now, abt the movie, he said it is not as good as Pithamagan (to quote his words, "it is not even 25% that of Pithamagan"). First half is really slow. The climax is absolutely stunning. Arya and Pooja rocked. There are some heavy cuts by the Censor Board towards the climax which reduces the intensity. Overall he said he was disappointed. But that is his opinion. You guys might like it. |
From: Nerd on Thu Feb 5 17:05:19 2009. |
From: MrIndia on Thu Feb 5 18:13:04 2009. |
From: jaiganes on Thu Feb 5 18:21:40 2009. |
From: irir123 on Thu Feb 5 18:23:06 2009. |
From: sarna_blr on Thu Feb 5 18:24:27 2009. |
jaiganes wrote: |
@Guess ME
Ilaiyaraaja BGM eppadi? konjam kaettu solreengala? |
From: jaiganes on Thu Feb 5 18:28:27 2009. |
From: Hulkster on Thu Feb 5 19:22:37 2009. |
From: Nerd on Thu Feb 5 21:50:49 2009. |
Quote: |
Galatta's verdict: Still weighing the points, will decide in a couple of days when the uneasy feeling in the stomach settles! |
From: complicateur on Thu Feb 5 22:02:06 2009. |
Nerd wrote: | ||
|
From: MrJudge on Thu Feb 5 22:33:37 2009. |
complicateur wrote: | ||||
nallA keLappurAngaiyyA beethiya! |
From: sarna_blr on Thu Feb 5 22:37:33 2009. |
complicateur wrote: | ||||
nallA keLappurAngaiyyA beethiya! |
From: MrJudge on Thu Feb 5 22:44:35 2009. |
From: thamiz on Thu Feb 5 22:56:11 2009. |
sarna_blr wrote: | ||||||
u meen street ![]() |
From: sarna_blr on Thu Feb 5 23:06:51 2009. |
thamiz wrote: | ||||||||
வீதி இல்லை பீதி = பயம் |
From: Nerd on Thu Feb 5 23:08:43 2009. |
From: Guess_Me on Thu Feb 5 23:10:49 2009. |
jaiganes wrote: |
@Guess ME
Ilaiyaraaja BGM eppadi? konjam kaettu solreengala? |
From: sarna_blr on Thu Feb 5 23:14:47 2009. |
Nerd wrote: |
sarna, "beedhi" is vadivElu special. He says that in some movie which I could not recollect. |
Nerd wrote: |
OK, makkaLE ellArum spoiler illAmal review post pannunga, plis ![]() |
From: thamiz on Thu Feb 5 23:15:00 2009. |
From: MrJudge on Thu Feb 5 23:34:15 2009. |
From: viraajan on Thu Feb 5 23:37:59 2009. |
From: MrJudge on Thu Feb 5 23:39:27 2009. |
From: MrJudge on Fri Feb 6 0:14:37 2009. |
K wrote: |
http://truetamilans.blogspot.com/2009/02/blog-post_06.html |
From: Nerd on Fri Feb 6 0:27:49 2009. |
MrJudge wrote: |
Naan Kadavul Premiere Show - Images |
From: podaskie on Fri Feb 6 0:29:32 2009. |
Nerd wrote: | ||
http://www.behindwoods.com/hindi-tamil-galleries/naan-kadavul-premiere/Naan-Kadavul-24.html இந்த ரெண்டு அம்மணிங்க யாரு? |
From: Vivasaayi on Fri Feb 6 0:33:44 2009. |
podaskie wrote: | ||||
i think they r actress ![]() |
From: viraajan on Fri Feb 6 0:39:57 2009. |
Nerd wrote: | ||
http://www.behindwoods.com/hindi-tamil-galleries/naan-kadavul-premiere/Naan-Kadavul-24.html இந்த ரெண்டு அம்மணிங்க யாரு? |
From: complicateur on Fri Feb 6 0:51:00 2009. |
Nerd wrote: | ||
http://www.behindwoods.com/hindi-tamil-galleries/naan-kadavul-premiere/Naan-Kadavul-24.html இந்த ரெண்டு அம்மணிங்க யாரு? |
From: Cinemarasigan on Fri Feb 6 1:06:44 2009. |
sarna_blr wrote: | ||
![]() ![]() however, I am watching tomorrow morning ![]() |
From: Nerd on Fri Feb 6 1:10:06 2009. |
complicateur wrote: |
Swathi (Vaanmanthi) and Vimala Raman (Poi) |
From: sarna_blr on Fri Feb 6 1:35:14 2009. |
Cinemarasigan wrote: | ||||
Patthuttu vandhu Seekkiram post pannunga... |
From: Cinemarasigan on Fri Feb 6 1:48:55 2009. |
sarna_blr wrote: | ||
Patthuttu vandhu Seekkiram post pannunga... |
From: k_vanan on Fri Feb 6 2:06:51 2009. |
From: MrJudge on Fri Feb 6 2:26:14 2009. |
k_vanan wrote: |
http://sify.com/movies/tamil/review.php?id=14852479&ctid=5&cid=2429 |
From: Cinemarasigan on Fri Feb 6 2:27:42 2009. |
k_vanan wrote: |
http://sify.com/movies/tamil/review.php?id=14852479&ctid=5&cid=2429 |
From: MrJudge on Fri Feb 6 2:29:37 2009. |
From: MrJudge on Fri Feb 6 2:48:19 2009. |
K wrote: |
http://cablesankar.blogspot.com/2009/02/blog-post_06.html |
From: viraajan on Fri Feb 6 3:14:00 2009. |
From: joe on Fri Feb 6 3:14:59 2009. |
From: avven on Fri Feb 6 3:19:22 2009. |
MrJudge wrote: | ||
verdict mARi mARi varuthu ![]() |
From: podaskie on Fri Feb 6 3:35:46 2009. |
From: MrJudge on Fri Feb 6 3:43:59 2009. |
avven wrote: | ||||
neen-ga padatha parthu mudivu pannunga, nalla iruka illeayanu..avanga reviews parthu en confuse avaringa.. |
From: MrIndia on Fri Feb 6 3:45:20 2009. |
From: MrJudge on Fri Feb 6 3:46:14 2009. |
From: sourav on Fri Feb 6 3:49:32 2009. |
MrJudge wrote: |
podaskie:
suththa loosA irukkeenga.... I just glanced a few words from your last post....suddenly sensed the spoiler and skipped it. Luckily I didn't read the last line. |
From: Ramakrishna on Fri Feb 6 3:49:43 2009. |
From: MrJudge on Fri Feb 6 3:50:10 2009. |
From: joe on Fri Feb 6 3:53:12 2009. |
sourav wrote: | ||
![]() |
From: MrJudge on Fri Feb 6 3:54:58 2009. |
From: joe on Fri Feb 6 3:56:21 2009. |
MrJudge wrote: |
NOV:
Can you please add the poll to this thread again? |
From: MrJudge on Fri Feb 6 3:56:47 2009. |
joe wrote: | ||||
me too ![]() |
From: joe on Fri Feb 6 3:56:54 2009. |
From: viraajan on Fri Feb 6 3:57:50 2009. |
MrJudge wrote: |
podaskie:
suththa loosA irukkeenga.... I just glanced a few words from your last post....suddenly sensed the spoiler and skipped it. Luckily I didn't read the last line. |
From: MrIndia on Fri Feb 6 4:01:05 2009. |
MrJudge wrote: |
MrIndia;
How do you rate this when compared to other Bala movies? Better than PM or Nandha? |
From: MrJudge on Fri Feb 6 4:04:29 2009. |
joe wrote: |
http://www.luckylookonline.com/2009/02/blog-post_06.html |
From: MrJudge on Fri Feb 6 4:07:16 2009. |
MrIndia wrote: |
those movies are too commercial when compared to this ![]() you will be disturbed for sure. this is more like a well shot documentary with raja sir's amazing bgm. their is some witty dialogue here and there. mirugama irruku. sensors have played their part.. movie is missing something near the climax. |
From: Vivasaayi on Fri Feb 6 4:09:23 2009. |
From: sarna_blr on Fri Feb 6 4:30:13 2009. |
Cinemarasigan wrote: |
Hyd or Blr? |
From: crajkumar_be on Fri Feb 6 4:32:08 2009. |
MrIndia wrote: |
Just came from the movie...
Kadavul 1: Raja sir is the hero of the movie. cant imagine seeing this without his re-recording. songs are inplace.. |
Ramakrishna wrote: |
Music is tooo good |
From: steveaustin on Fri Feb 6 4:35:20 2009. |
joe wrote: |
கொண்டாட்ட சூழலுக்கான படம் இது இல்லை என்றாலும் இயக்குனர் பாலா பல்லக்கில் வைத்து தமிழர்களால் கொண்டாடப்பட வேண்டியவர். ஹேராமுக்குப் பிறகு இசையும், இயக்கமும் தமிழ் சினிமாவின் குறிப்பிடத்தக்க மைல்கல்லை எட்டியிருக்கிறது.
இக்கட்டான சூழலில் தமிழ் சினிமாவை ரட்சிக்க வந்திருக்கிறார் கடவுள்! http://www.luckylookonline.com/2009/02/blog-post_06.html |
Quote: |
இளையராஜாவின் இசை படத்தின் பல காட்சிகளை நடத்திச் செல்கிறது. வசனங்கள் இல்லாத இடத்திலும் யாரோ பேசிக்கொண்டிருப்பது போன்றே, கதை சொல்லிக் கொண்டிருப்பது போன்றே ஒரு பிரமை. கோல்டன் க்ளோப், ஆஸ்கர் விருதுகள் தரும் கம்முனாட்டிகள் குழுவுக்கு இப்படி ஒரு மேதை இங்கே இருப்பதாவது தெரியுமா என்பதே சந்தேகம். மேஸ்ட்ரோவுக்கு இணை மேஸ்ட்ரோ மட்டுமே.
இயக்குனர் பாலா பல்லக்கில் வைத்து தமிழர்களால் கொண்டாடப்பட வேண்டியவர். ஹேராமுக்குப் பிறகு இசையும், இயக்கமும் தமிழ் சினிமாவின் குறிப்பிடத்தக்க மைல்கல்லை எட்டியிருக்கிறது. |
From: crajkumar_be on Fri Feb 6 4:41:36 2009. |
MrIndia wrote: |
I wont recommend the movie for women and children.
|
From: Anban on Fri Feb 6 4:49:43 2009. |
From: Sanguine Sridhar on Fri Feb 6 4:57:13 2009. |
Anban wrote: |
my bro is raving abt the movie and the music .. he just finished watching the FDFS.. the WOM is not that good it seems.. oh no.. they didnt release the movie in pune.. ![]() |
From: joe on Fri Feb 6 5:04:24 2009. |
Sanguine Sridhar wrote: | ||
![]() |
From: SoftSword on Fri Feb 6 5:06:54 2009. |
From: sarna_blr on Fri Feb 6 5:10:49 2009. |
SoftSword wrote: |
u guys remember the wom for sethu in its first week of release??? |
From: joe on Fri Feb 6 5:11:08 2009. |
crajkumar_be wrote: | ||
indha padam pera kettale woippu kaduppaidraanga, and because of that i not watch the movie today.. pengal thirundhanum! ![]() |
From: Kalyasi on Fri Feb 6 5:11:56 2009. |
From: MrJudge on Fri Feb 6 5:23:43 2009. |
crajkumar_be wrote: | ||
indha padam pera kettale woippu kaduppaidraanga, and because of that i not watch the movie today.. pengal thirundhanum! ![]() |
From: SoftSword on Fri Feb 6 5:23:49 2009. |
crajkumar_be wrote: | ||
indha padam pera kettale woippu kaduppaidraanga, and because of that i not watch the movie today.. pengal thirundhanum! ![]() |
From: Hulkster on Fri Feb 6 5:27:55 2009. |
From: MrJudge on Fri Feb 6 5:33:16 2009. |
From: Roshan on Fri Feb 6 5:40:53 2009. |
Quote: |
கோல்டன் க்ளோப், ஆஸ்கர் விருதுகள் தரும் கம்முனாட்டிகள் குழுவுக்கு இப்படி ஒரு மேதை இங்கே இருப்பதாவது தெரியுமா என்பதே சந்தேகம். மேஸ்ட்ரோவுக்கு இணை மேஸ்ட்ரோ மட்டுமே. |
From: Hulkster on Fri Feb 6 5:42:34 2009. |
From: viraajan on Fri Feb 6 5:44:01 2009. |
From: Hulkster on Fri Feb 6 5:46:21 2009. |
From: viraajan on Fri Feb 6 5:50:02 2009. |
Hulkster wrote: |
The word confusing is enough to override the verdict. One fella said predictable other saying confusing....ada chey..naaney poi paarkiren..reviews nambi pirojanam ellei. |
From: Roshan on Fri Feb 6 5:57:23 2009. |
Hulkster wrote: |
Vidunga..he is just a hardcore fan like me...is it important to talk about this now....more important is the film. Unnum reviews irukka? |
From: Hulkster on Fri Feb 6 6:14:03 2009. |
From: SoftSword on Fri Feb 6 6:17:37 2009. |
Hulkster wrote: |
From what people say three songs only in the movie.
1) Pichai Paathiram 2) Om Sivoham 3) Title sanskrit song not in the album |
From: Hulkster on Fri Feb 6 6:20:28 2009. |
From: Roshan on Fri Feb 6 6:24:50 2009. |
Hulkster wrote: |
Well nothing wrong it seems...there are bound to be people who will get critical of one's success...keithu vittu poga vendiyethu thaan.
Majority seem to agree that it is a very dark film possibly exploring more about good vs evil rather than the underdog to millionaire style of slumdog millionaire. Phew that relieves me of the fear that it might have been similar to SDM. |
From: crajkumar_be on Fri Feb 6 6:30:42 2009. |
Roshan wrote: |
Nalla comedy ![]() ![]() |
From: Hulkster on Fri Feb 6 6:31:29 2009. |
From: Roshan on Fri Feb 6 6:35:45 2009. |
crajkumar_be wrote: | ||
I think Hulk is referring to the alleged similarity between SDM and NK that was reported in some blogs.. |
From: Hulkster on Fri Feb 6 6:41:43 2009. |
From: Cinemarasigan on Fri Feb 6 6:44:23 2009. |
viraajan wrote: |
My bro saw it today.
Says that the story is bit confusing... and overall the movie does not live up to the expectation ![]() ![]() |
From: Roshan on Fri Feb 6 6:45:56 2009. |
Hulkster wrote: |
The thing is, even if it was in production way before SDM it did not release before SDM and so even if it releases the chances of it being successful will be reduced. As much as we all know the people who have little access to media will not know this and think that NK was inspired by SDM after watching it on first hand. Anyway lets switch off the matter as the film is not similar to SDM. |
From: Hulkster on Fri Feb 6 6:46:37 2009. |
From: SoftSword on Fri Feb 6 6:57:40 2009. |
Cinemarasigan wrote: | ||
Bala movies ellatthukkum ippadithaan, Indha maadhiri padangal "pattha udane pidikkaadhu", paakka paakka thaan pidikkum". |
From: MrJudge on Fri Feb 6 7:19:02 2009. |
From: Sanguine Sridhar on Fri Feb 6 7:19:16 2009. |
From: MrJudge on Fri Feb 6 7:22:16 2009. |
raja_fan wrote: |
http://news.chennaivision.com/index.php/2009/02/nan-kadavul-review/ "...Nan Kadavul is no doubt Kollywood’s journey to international cinema. Bala has made the film raw and riveting, making it an authentic milestone in his career. " |
From: leosimha on Fri Feb 6 7:41:39 2009. |
Kalyasi wrote: |
I am going to PVR for 4.15 pm show... any hubbers who are watching the movie @ PVR same time? |
From: Cinemarasigan on Fri Feb 6 8:40:07 2009. |
SoftSword wrote: | ||||
appo bala next movie with dhanush.. |
From: Anban on Fri Feb 6 8:57:02 2009. |
Anban wrote: |
my bro is raving abt the movie and the music .. he just finished watching the FDFS.. the WOM is not that good it seems.. oh no.. they didnt release the movie in pune.. ![]() |
From: Anban on Fri Feb 6 8:59:45 2009. |
Roshan wrote: | ||
It obviously makes us suspect the credibility of his views. Adhaan highlight paNNEn. Yuckylook'nu pEra mAthinA poruthamA irukkum. He needs to get a life definitely. |
From: Anban on Fri Feb 6 9:04:28 2009. |
Roshan wrote: | ||
Innumoru disgruntled soul ! What a cheap mentality :yuck: |
From: crajkumar_be on Fri Feb 6 9:25:14 2009. |
From: Nerd on Fri Feb 6 9:49:01 2009. |
From: Kalyasi on Fri Feb 6 10:01:50 2009. |
From: joe on Fri Feb 6 10:03:36 2009. |
From: Sanjeevi on Fri Feb 6 10:20:56 2009. |
From: irir123 on Fri Feb 6 10:26:48 2009. |
Nerd wrote: |
Lacks Punch - Rediff. But the reviewer has given 3/5 ![]() Thanks to all these Internet reviews I will have company to watch the film tomorrow. Sify's review is the clincher ![]() |
From: joe on Fri Feb 6 10:27:57 2009. |
From: Nerd on Fri Feb 6 10:38:32 2009. |
From: thamiz on Fri Feb 6 11:16:44 2009. |
joe wrote: |
கொண்டாட்ட சூழலுக்கான படம் இது இல்லை என்றாலும் இயக்குனர் பாலா பல்லக்கில் வைத்து தமிழர்களால் கொண்டாடப்பட வேண்டியவர். ஹேராமுக்குப் பிறகு இசையும், இயக்கமும் தமிழ் சினிமாவின் குறிப்பிடத்தக்க மைல்கல்லை எட்டியிருக்கிறது.
இக்கட்டான சூழலில் தமிழ் சினிமாவை ரட்சிக்க வந்திருக்கிறார் கடவுள்! |
From: sarna_blr on Fri Feb 6 11:30:00 2009. |
Kalyasi wrote: |
Just now back from the movie....
Though I don't like director bala personally for obvious reasons... NK is an outstanding masterpiece from Bala Far Better than Pithamagan and Sethu... I had similar views about Pithamagan as Sridhar.... Maybe Sridhar u will like this one... BGM was mindblowing!!! Subtle Comedies were too good!! This movie is nothing but a hardcore reality of a world that exists and is not known to us.... Many will not like it esp women and children... so commercially it might fail at the box-office but the aspiring directors who see this film will defly join the lists of Ameer, Sasikumar, Ram and the list continues!! To those who didn't understand the concept of this movie... "Its all about mercy killing" |
From: MrJudge on Fri Feb 6 12:56:37 2009. |
From: MrJudge on Fri Feb 6 13:01:11 2009. |
From: MrJudge on Fri Feb 6 13:09:31 2009. |
thamiz wrote: |
This guy always talks like he is the authority of Tamil film directions and music! ![]() I am sure he knows no knowledge of music or whatsoever but he has a BIG MOUTH which helps him make LOTS OF NOISES like this ! ![]() |
From: sarna_blr on Fri Feb 6 13:24:24 2009. |
MrJudge wrote: |
I am so excited.... much much better than Pithamagan. |
From: MrJudge on Fri Feb 6 13:26:40 2009. |
Anban wrote: | ||||
![]() many of us are slaves of westernised products(Hindian products included).. we dont have enough self respect to respect our kind of products too.. such ppl among us have lost their individuality long ago.. |
From: MrJudge on Fri Feb 6 13:29:59 2009. |
sarna_blr wrote: | ||
is it ![]() ![]() |
From: Nerd on Fri Feb 6 13:32:03 2009. |
From: sarna_blr on Fri Feb 6 13:34:41 2009. |
MrJudge wrote: | ||||
Yes, the best from Bala. Sarna, this movie is kind of untouched territory in tamil may be in indian cinema also. Only Bala can direct this kind of film, engeyO pOittAr in this movie. |
From: joe on Fri Feb 6 13:35:25 2009. |
From: MrJudge on Fri Feb 6 13:40:14 2009. |
Nerd wrote: |
Theater response epdi? Silapala idathula standing ovation-nu kelvippatten.. |
From: Nerd on Fri Feb 6 13:43:01 2009. |
From: irir123 on Fri Feb 6 13:43:37 2009. |
joe wrote: |
Glad to see postive reviews ![]() Bala padam thoRkanumnu inga niRaya per pray pannuranga ..Bala box office-la thoRkalaam ..aana Bala-ngra kalainjan avvaLavu seekiram thoRkka maattan ![]() |
From: omega on Fri Feb 6 13:44:25 2009. |
MrJudge wrote: |
OMG.... saw the movie... The best from Bala till date ![]() |
From: MrJudge on Fri Feb 6 13:45:21 2009. |
joe wrote: |
Glad to see postive reviews ![]() Bala padam thoRkanumnu inga niRaya per pray pannuranga ..Bala box office-la thoRkalaam ..aana Bala-ngra kalainjan avvaLavu seekiram thoRkka maattan ![]() |
From: joe on Fri Feb 6 13:48:49 2009. |
From: Anban on Fri Feb 6 13:49:52 2009. |
MrJudge wrote: | ||||||
Anban, Watch this movie at any cost in theater. Again and again Raja proves why he is the best for original scores in India. vEra entha kombanAlum intha mAthiri isai pOda mudiyAthu, Raja's trademark throughout the movie but it is not spoiling the experience. He hasn't lost his individuality yet. ![]() |
From: MrJudge on Fri Feb 6 13:54:30 2009. |
joe wrote: |
MrJudge,
Bala padathai miss pannuratha ..No way ![]() ![]() |
From: joe on Fri Feb 6 13:56:19 2009. |
MrJudge wrote: | ||
padam singapore vanthuduchchA? |
From: MrJudge on Fri Feb 6 13:58:30 2009. |
From: app_engine on Fri Feb 6 14:05:48 2009. |
MrJudge wrote: |
app_engine:
Arya has done proper padmAsanam in couple of places. ![]() |
From: Mahen on Fri Feb 6 14:26:57 2009. |
From: thamiz on Fri Feb 6 14:30:21 2009. |
Mahen wrote: |
'terrible and mindless'.... ![]() ![]() http://www.bharatstudent.com/cafebharat/news.php?id=39907&cat=3&dt=2009-02-06 |
From: Nerd on Fri Feb 6 14:31:30 2009. |
From: MrJudge on Fri Feb 6 14:35:29 2009. |
Mahen wrote: |
'terrible and mindless'.... ![]() ![]() http://www.bharatstudent.com/cafebharat/news.php?id=39907&cat=3&dt=2009-02-06 |
From: Mahen on Fri Feb 6 14:35:53 2009. |
Nerd wrote: |
Telugucinema and greatandhra carry similar reviews. |
From: MrJudge on Fri Feb 6 14:38:53 2009. |
From: MrJudge on Fri Feb 6 14:40:36 2009. |
From: MrIndia on Fri Feb 6 14:41:21 2009. |
From: Nerd on Fri Feb 6 14:41:31 2009. |
From: complicateur on Fri Feb 6 14:42:30 2009. |
MrJudge wrote: |
censor konjam siththu vElaiya kAttitAnga |
From: MrJudge on Fri Feb 6 14:43:37 2009. |
From: MrJudge on Fri Feb 6 14:51:50 2009. |
complicateur wrote: | ||
enna central govt. enna state govt. ![]() |
From: complicateur on Fri Feb 6 14:55:27 2009. |
MrJudge wrote: | ||||
Not even one scene explaining their rituals (the disturbing one I mean) on screen. A few cuts were clearly visible in the later part of the second half. Also I don't think in India it is possible to release a director's cut in DVD. ![]() |
From: thamiz on Fri Feb 6 14:57:42 2009. |
Nerd wrote: |
Telugucinema and greatandhra carry similar reviews. |
From: bimmer on Fri Feb 6 14:58:06 2009. |
From: bimmer on Fri Feb 6 14:59:37 2009. |
Mahen wrote: |
'terrible and mindless'.... ![]() ![]() http://www.bharatstudent.com/cafebharat/news.php?id=39907&cat=3&dt=2009-02-06 |
From: thamiz on Fri Feb 6 15:00:17 2009. |
bimmer wrote: |
From Sify "Bala can ask Danny Boyle (Slumdog Millionaire director) to take a walk" ---Are you kidding me. What the heck . |
From: thamiz on Fri Feb 6 15:00:56 2009. |
bimmer wrote: | ||
Very True...Perfect review for a Mindless Movie |
From: bimmer on Fri Feb 6 15:02:55 2009. |
MrIndia wrote: |
nobody can question BALAs talent.. but is TN developed to divide movies into R rated,PG etc. will they get enough profit if only certain set of audience watch it. at the end its all money and business.
some families brought kids to the theatre and obviously they were not comfortable. I appreciate BALA for his efforts .. wish this movie is a success and producers are encouraged to take such cult movies. |
From: bimmer on Fri Feb 6 15:08:31 2009. |
thamiz wrote: | ||||
You liked other bala movies, bimmer? ![]() |
From: bimmer on Fri Feb 6 15:14:42 2009. |
From: MrJudge on Fri Feb 6 15:19:47 2009. |
From: MrJudge on Fri Feb 6 15:20:54 2009. |
From: bimmer on Fri Feb 6 15:32:16 2009. |
MrJudge wrote: |
bimmer:
nandhA is better than pithAmagan for you. For me it is just the opposite. So tastes differ, and Bala can't satisfy everybody ![]() May be this is my taste, I would rate nAn kadavul as the best from him. If only Censor had given him some more freedom, he would've made it complete by inserting more darkness which is vital for the climax that I feel missing the punch little bit at the end. |
From: MrJudge on Fri Feb 6 15:36:30 2009. |
bimmer wrote: |
I just felt the Punch missing in the whole movie ![]() ![]() |
From: bimmer on Fri Feb 6 15:38:17 2009. |
MrJudge wrote: | ||
May be you looked the whole movie for punches. I didn't expect that much punches but only in appropriate place like climax and I loved the movie. |
From: thamiz on Fri Feb 6 15:42:52 2009. |
bimmer wrote: |
Thamizh Sethu and Nandha are one of my all-time favourites..I have watched both these movies 1/2 a dozen times. Pithamagan was Nothing GR8 IMO...Surya was the one who made the movie watchable.. Naan Kadavul...The concept is confusing...OMG Is this reality..It is so disturbing and BALA has over-exagerated the Screenplay to a large extent. This movie may be different to People and may appreciate the movie...But to me It made no sense. as far as the BO Is concerned "Forget about it", the movie will soon be in the Producers Inbox or "ulaga tholaikatchigalil Mudhan murayaga" Kind. |
From: podaskie on Fri Feb 6 16:23:55 2009. |
From: mareen on Fri Feb 6 16:26:58 2009. |
From: thamiz on Fri Feb 6 17:04:34 2009. |
From: A_Ajith on Fri Feb 6 17:28:26 2009. |
From: Anban on Fri Feb 6 18:51:47 2009. |
thamiz wrote: | ||
Thanks, bimmer! ![]() |
From: Anban on Fri Feb 6 18:53:09 2009. |
From: Movie Cop on Fri Feb 6 18:56:29 2009. |
Anban wrote: |
Naan kadavul has been released in pune :shocked:
Oh my Kamal, i cant believe this.. i m going to the movie in 4 hrs time.. i am not gonna sleep. . ![]() |
From: bimmer on Fri Feb 6 19:20:16 2009. |
Anban wrote: | ||||
|
From: Anban on Fri Feb 6 19:21:40 2009. |
From: thamiz on Fri Feb 6 19:39:13 2009. |
Anban wrote: |
40.32 crore loss to its distributors as the CLASSIC did.. |
From: thamiz on Fri Feb 6 19:40:42 2009. |
Anban wrote: |
NK is like once in a life time offbeat movie.. |
From: bimmer on Fri Feb 6 21:24:29 2009. |
thamiz wrote: | ||
Yeah once in a life time for sure! ![]() |
From: bimmer on Fri Feb 6 21:26:03 2009. |
Anban wrote: |
bimmer, comparing billa with this movie is total stupidity..
billa is a good masala movie.. NK is like once in a life time offbeat movie.. |
From: joe on Fri Feb 6 21:53:22 2009. |
From: sarna_blr on Fri Feb 6 21:55:43 2009. |
bimmer wrote: |
Can anyone tell me why Bala should be considered a First league director??? |
From: MADDY on Fri Feb 6 21:56:09 2009. |
Anban wrote: |
NK is like once in a life time offbeat movie.. |
From: bimmer on Fri Feb 6 22:52:27 2009. |
sarna_blr wrote: | ||
idhu therinju enna panna pOreenga ![]() |
From: MrJudge on Fri Feb 6 22:54:22 2009. |
bimmer wrote: | ||||
Ethu Sir Offbeat... Intha List Kooda compare panraingala 1. Hey Ram 2. Anbe Sivam 3. Paruthiveeran 4. Thavamai Thavamirunthu NK is now where in this league..Just because One wants to show difference...Bala has totally screwed up the Movie... Can anyone tell me why Bala should be considered a First league director??? he is not |
From: sarna_blr on Fri Feb 6 22:55:39 2009. |
bimmer wrote: |
.Bala va pathi oru Bigraphy ezhuthalamey nu yosichen...
|
From: VENKIRAJA on Fri Feb 6 22:59:43 2009. |
sarna_blr wrote: | ||
idhula enna kanjaththanam ![]() ![]() |
From: thamiz on Fri Feb 6 23:00:09 2009. |
bimmer wrote: | ||||
Ethu Sir Offbeat... |
From: MrJudge on Fri Feb 6 23:03:41 2009. |
thamiz wrote: | ||
Yeah once in a life time for sure! ![]() |
From: joe on Fri Feb 6 23:17:17 2009. |
sarna_blr wrote: | ||
idhula enna kanjaththanam ![]() ![]() |
From: sgokulprathap on Fri Feb 6 23:51:01 2009. |
joe wrote: | ||||
Ellorum siringappa ![]() |
From: Vivasaayi on Fri Feb 6 23:59:13 2009. |
From: MADDY on Sat Feb 7 0:01:03 2009. |
Vivasaayi wrote: |
The movie is getting extreme positive reviews |
From: steveaustin on Sat Feb 7 0:14:02 2009. |
From: joe on Sat Feb 7 0:29:23 2009. |
From: MADDY on Sat Feb 7 1:16:05 2009. |
Ramakrishna wrote: |
Saw the movie....
The movie is good in parts. First half is just ok. Second half starts off well but gets predictable later Climax ![]() Music is tooo good |
From: Kalyasi on Sat Feb 7 1:27:58 2009. |
MADDY wrote: | ||
most honest review...... |
From: cancer on Sat Feb 7 1:31:39 2009. |
MADDY wrote: | ||
most honest review...... |
From: MADDY on Sat Feb 7 1:31:56 2009. |
Kalyasi wrote: | ||||
Maddy paathacha? |
From: MrJudge on Sat Feb 7 1:55:51 2009. |
From: MrJudge on Sat Feb 7 1:58:55 2009. |
From: Kalyasi on Sat Feb 7 1:59:43 2009. |
MrJudge wrote: |
padam OK appadinnu sonnA honest review-vA? athu avarOda opinion. I enjoyed it so much, that is my opinion. Not because of being a Bala/Ilayraaja fan I praise this movie, I honestly loved the film. ![]() |
From: villan007 on Sat Feb 7 2:01:22 2009. |
MADDY wrote: | ||
understandable |
From: villan007 on Sat Feb 7 2:05:55 2009. |
Anban wrote: |
Oh my Kamal, |
From: vasanth2006 on Sat Feb 7 2:09:31 2009. |
From: MADDY on Sat Feb 7 2:15:27 2009. |
MrJudge wrote: |
Looking forward to Anban's opinion, he should be back in couple of hours. |
From: MrJudge on Sat Feb 7 2:15:38 2009. |
Kalyasi wrote: |
Even I was disappointed with Nandha and Pithamagan... But this one is something special from bala.... Something unexplored!! |
From: MrJudge on Sat Feb 7 2:17:28 2009. |
MADDY wrote: | ||
without watching the movie, he said it is a "once in a lifetime" movie - which is why i said they were not honest opinions......... |
From: MADDY on Sat Feb 7 2:20:55 2009. |
MrJudge wrote: |
I am confident he will say the same again. |
From: MrJudge on Sat Feb 7 2:24:32 2009. |
vasanth2006 wrote: |
2) Censor cuts ![]() |
From: MrJudge on Sat Feb 7 2:27:13 2009. |
From: MrJudge on Sat Feb 7 2:29:44 2009. |
MADDY wrote: | ||
i knew this 2 yrs back |
From: Sanjeevi on Sat Feb 7 2:34:33 2009. |
MrJudge wrote: | ||||
Good for you man, you knew things even before they happen. ![]() |
From: Sanjeevi on Sat Feb 7 2:38:19 2009. |
From: MADDY on Sat Feb 7 2:39:07 2009. |
Sanjeevi wrote: | ||||||
hub vijay (atm) |
From: MrJudge on Sat Feb 7 2:41:39 2009. |
Sanjeevi wrote: |
I won't expect any message or scientific logic from bala movies because they give real life feel. The treatment and the way he handles his characters are mindblowing. Even I liked Nandha, the last in bala's best movies for its treatment. |
From: Sanjeevi on Sat Feb 7 2:42:15 2009. |
From: MADDY on Sat Feb 7 2:46:02 2009. |
Sanjeevi wrote: |
yeah enakku innaikku sappitta vazhaipazam inikkumnu 5 varusham munnadiyae theriyum |
From: MrJudge on Sat Feb 7 2:51:45 2009. |
From: MADDY on Sat Feb 7 3:05:35 2009. |
Quote: |
நான் கடவுள்.
முக்கிய அறிவிப்பு: இந்த விமர்சனத்தைப் படித்தால், 'நான் கடவுள்' படம் பார்க்கும் போது சுவாரசியம் குறைந்துவிடும் என எண்ணி தயவுகூர்ந்து படிக்காமல் இருக்க வேண்டாம். கண்டிப்பாய் படியுங்கள். ஏன் இப்படிச் சொல்கிறேன் எனப் படம் பார்த்தபின்னோ அல்லது இந்தப் பதிவைப் படித்த பின்னோ தெரியும். ஒரு பார்வை: நல்ல கதை. அகோரி கிகோரியென புதுப் பெயர்கள். அட்டகாசமாய் உயரமாய் ஆர்யா. படம் பிய்க்கும் என நினைத்தால், தலையைப் பிய்க்க வைக்கிறது. படம் முழுவதும் ஆர்யா இந்தியில் பேசுகிறார் (திட்டுகிறார்) அல்லது சமஸ்கிருதத்தில் மந்திரம் சொல்கிறார்.கஞ்சா குடிக்கிறார். மொத்தம் எட்டு காட்சிகளில் வருகிறார் ஆர்யா. பாவம், விக்ரம் மாதிரி, சூர்யா மாதிரி 'பாலா படத்தில் நடித்தால் பெரியாளா ஆயிருவோம்!' என்ற கனவோடு நடித்தவரின் தலையில் கல்லைப் போட்டிருக்கிறார் பாலா. இந்தப் படம் பார்த்தால் தான் தெரிகிறது, விக்ரமையும் சூர்யாவையும் பெரிய நடிகர்கள் ஆக்கியது பாலா அல்ல, அவர்கள் தான் தெரியாத்தனமாய் பாலாவை பெரிய ஆள் ஆக்கித் தொலைத்திருக்கிறார்கள். (அந்தப் பாவம் அவர்களை விடவே விடாது!!) ஆர்யாவுக்கு நடிக்க சுத்தமாய் வாய்பில்லை. கஞ்சா குடித்துவிட்டு கரகர குரலில் தொண்டைப் புற்றுநோய் வந்தவர் போல் கத்தவிட்டிருக்கிறார் பாலா. ஆர்யாவைப் பார்த்தாலே நமக்கு பாலா மீது கோபமும் ஆர்யா மீது பாவமும் வருகிறது. படத்தில் எங்கு காணினும் பிதாமகனின் அழுகிப்போன வாடை. பழைய பாடல்களைப் போட்டு பழைய நடிகர்கள் வேடத்தில் பிச்சையெடுக்கும் சிலரை காவல் நிலையத்தில் ஆடவிட்டுருக்கிறார், சிம்ரனும் சூர்யாவும் ஆடியதைப் போல. ஆர்யாவைக் கண்டு போலீசுகாரர்கள் மிரளுகிறார்கள், விக்ரமைக் கண்டு பிதாமகனில் மிரண்டதைப் போல. சண்டைகாட்சிகளும் பிதாமகனையே நினைவூட்டுகின்றன. படத்தின் பிரதான பங்கேற்பாளர்கள் (நடிகர்கள் எனச் சொல்வதில் சற்றும் மனமில்லை எனக்கு) பிச்சைக்காரர்கள். அதுவும் சாதாரணமாய் தென்படுபவர்கள் இல்லை, பொதுவாக நாம் நூறு பிச்சைக்காரர்களைப் பார்த்தால் அதில் ஒரு இரண்டு பேர் மிகவும் கொரூரமாகவும், பார்க்கவே பயம் வரவழைப்பவர்களாகவும்,அருவெறுப்பாகவும் இருப்பார்களே அதைப்போலத்தான் இந்தப்படத்தில் பாலா காட்டியுள்ள அத்தனைப் பிச்சைக்காரர்களுமே இருக்கிறார்கள். மிகவும் கொடூரமான முறையில் மிகவும் 'க்ளோசப்' (CLOSE UP)யில் அவர்களை படம் முழுதும் காட்டியுள்ளார். அவர்களும் நகைச்சுவை என்ற பெயரில் பாலா சொல்லிக்கொடுத்த கருமங்களை பேசிக்கொண்டு தாங்களாகவே பல நிமிடங்கள் சிரித்துக்கொள்கிறார்கள், காமிரா அவர்கள் முகத்தில் மெதுவாக பயணிக்கிறது, நமக்கு வயிற்றை புரட்டுகிறது, பயமாய் இருக்கிறது. ஊனமுற்றவர்களை பல இல்லங்களில் இருந்து அழைத்துவந்து அசிங்கப்படுத்தியுள்ளார் பாலா. அவர்களைப் பார்த்தாலே காசு கொடுத்து படம் பார்க்க வந்த நம் மீதும், பாலாவை நம்பி வந்த அவர்கள் மீதும் பாவமாய் இருக்கிறது. பூஜா பாவப்பட்ட நடிகை. ஒரு நடிகையை எவ்வளவு அருவெறுப்பாக, அசிங்கமாக காட்டமுடியுமோ அப்படிக்காட்டியுள்ளார்கள். படத்தில் அவர் மட்டுமே கொஞ்சம் நடித்திருக்கிறார். ஆனால் வேண்டுமென்றே திணிக்கப்பட்ட அவரின் 'மேக்கப்'ஆல் நம்மால் அவரின் நடிப்பை ரசிக்கமுடியவில்லை. அதுவும் கடைசி காட்சியில் வாந்தி வருகிறது. திடீர் திடீர் என்று பழைய படப் பாடல்கள் சம்பந்தமேயில்லாமல் படத்தில் ஒலிக்கின்றன. யாராவது பாடுகிறார்கள், அல்லது வானொலியில் ஒலிக்கிறது. படத்தில் தமிழ் மிகவும் கொஞ்சமாக வருகிறது. அப்படியே வந்தாலும் பின்ணணி இசை வசனங்களைத் தின்கிறது. ஆர்யா அதில் தனக்கு தமிழ் தெரிந்தாலும், என்ன கண்றாவிக்காக தமிழர்களான சக சாமியார்களிடமும் தன் குடும்பத்தாரிடமும் இந்தி பேசுகிறார் என விளங்கவில்லை. படத்தில் என்ன நடக்குது என சுதாரிக்கும் முன் இடைவேளை வந்துவிடுகிறது. இது ஒரு கிறுக்குப்பிடித்த, குரூரமான, வக்கிரமான படமென்றால் அது மிகையாகாது. பாலாவினுள் இருந்த கலைஞனின் தலையில் சேதுவுக்குப் பின் 'கணம்' புகுந்து விட்டது. தான் என்ன எடுத்தாலும் உலகம் பாராட்டும் என்ற நினைப்போ என்னவோ!!தான் நினைத்த போது மட்டும், பொழுது போகவில்லையென்றால் மட்டும் 'நான் கடவுள்' படப்பிடிப்புக்குப் போக வைத்திருக்கிறது. திரைக்கதையே எழுதாமல் மனதில் தோன்றிய கொடூரங்களையெல்லாம் கோர்வையேயில்லாமல் படமாய் எடுக்கவைத்திருக்கிறது. இனி தயவுசெய்து பாலா சினிமா எடுப்பதை மறுபரிசீலனை செய்வது நலம். அல்லது அவரை தேவையில்லாமல் புகழ்ந்து தொலைத்த பாலு மகேந்திரா, மணிரத்னம் போன்றவர்களுக்கெல்லாம் அசிங்கம். நான் கடவுள் படத்தைப் பார்த்துத் தொலைத்த கடுப்பில் தான் இளையராஜா, 'நான் கடவுள்' பாடல் வெளியீட்டிற்கு வரவில்லையோ என்னமோ! அஜீத்தை தாக்கவேண்டிய புயல், பாவம் ஆர்யாவை ஆட்கொண்டுவிட்டது. அஜீத் தப்பித்தார். ஆனால் மக்களே நான் எல்லாவற்றையும் பொறுத்துக்கொள்கிறேன், ஆனால் இந்தப் படத்தையும் புகழ்ந்து தள்ளி விமர்சனம் எழுதியுள்ள சில இணையங்களின் வக்கிர புத்தியை தான் என்னால் சகிக்க முடியவில்லை!! தயவு செய்து பார்த்துவிடாதீர்கள் இந்தப் படத்தை. முக்கியமாக குழந்தைகளுடனும், வயதானவர்களுடனும், கர்ப்பிணிப் பெண்களுடனும், இதயம் பலவீனமானவர்களுடனுமோ போய்விடாதீர்கள்,. ஆபத்தில் முடியும். |
From: MADDY on Sat Feb 7 3:07:09 2009. |
Quote: |
நான் கடவுள்.
முக்கிய அறிவிப்பு: இந்த விமர்சனத்தைப் படித்தால், 'நான் கடவுள்' படம் பார்க்கும் போது சுவாரசியம் குறைந்துவிடும் என எண்ணி தயவுகூர்ந்து படிக்காமல் இருக்க வேண்டாம். கண்டிப்பாய் படியுங்கள். ஏன் இப்படிச் சொல்கிறேன் எனப் படம் பார்த்தபின்னோ அல்லது இந்தப் பதிவைப் படித்த பின்னோ தெரியும். ஒரு பார்வை: நல்ல கதை. அகோரி கிகோரியென புதுப் பெயர்கள். அட்டகாசமாய் உயரமாய் ஆர்யா. படம் பிய்க்கும் என நினைத்தால், தலையைப் பிய்க்க வைக்கிறது. படம் முழுவதும் ஆர்யா இந்தியில் பேசுகிறார் (திட்டுகிறார்) அல்லது சமஸ்கிருதத்தில் மந்திரம் சொல்கிறார்.கஞ்சா குடிக்கிறார். மொத்தம் எட்டு காட்சிகளில் வருகிறார் ஆர்யா. பாவம், விக்ரம் மாதிரி, சூர்யா மாதிரி 'பாலா படத்தில் நடித்தால் பெரியாளா ஆயிருவோம்!' என்ற கனவோடு நடித்தவரின் தலையில் கல்லைப் போட்டிருக்கிறார் பாலா. இந்தப் படம் பார்த்தால் தான் தெரிகிறது, விக்ரமையும் சூர்யாவையும் பெரிய நடிகர்கள் ஆக்கியது பாலா அல்ல, அவர்கள் தான் தெரியாத்தனமாய் பாலாவை பெரிய ஆள் ஆக்கித் தொலைத்திருக்கிறார்கள். (அந்தப் பாவம் அவர்களை விடவே விடாது!!) ஆர்யாவுக்கு நடிக்க சுத்தமாய் வாய்பில்லை. கஞ்சா குடித்துவிட்டு கரகர குரலில் தொண்டைப் புற்றுநோய் வந்தவர் போல் கத்தவிட்டிருக்கிறார் பாலா. ஆர்யாவைப் பார்த்தாலே நமக்கு பாலா மீது கோபமும் ஆர்யா மீது பாவமும் வருகிறது. படத்தில் எங்கு காணினும் பிதாமகனின் அழுகிப்போன வாடை. பழைய பாடல்களைப் போட்டு பழைய நடிகர்கள் வேடத்தில் பிச்சையெடுக்கும் சிலரை காவல் நிலையத்தில் ஆடவிட்டுருக்கிறார், சிம்ரனும் சூர்யாவும் ஆடியதைப் போல. ஆர்யாவைக் கண்டு போலீசுகாரர்கள் மிரளுகிறார்கள், விக்ரமைக் கண்டு பிதாமகனில் மிரண்டதைப் போல. சண்டைகாட்சிகளும் பிதாமகனையே நினைவூட்டுகின்றன. படத்தின் பிரதான பங்கேற்பாளர்கள் (நடிகர்கள் எனச் சொல்வதில் சற்றும் மனமில்லை எனக்கு) பிச்சைக்காரர்கள். அதுவும் சாதாரணமாய் தென்படுபவர்கள் இல்லை, பொதுவாக நாம் நூறு பிச்சைக்காரர்களைப் பார்த்தால் அதில் ஒரு இரண்டு பேர் மிகவும் கொரூரமாகவும், பார்க்கவே பயம் வரவழைப்பவர்களாகவும்,அருவெறுப்பாகவும் இருப்பார்களே அதைப்போலத்தான் இந்தப்படத்தில் பாலா காட்டியுள்ள அத்தனைப் பிச்சைக்காரர்களுமே இருக்கிறார்கள். மிகவும் கொடூரமான முறையில் மிகவும் 'க்ளோசப்' (CLOSE UP)யில் அவர்களை படம் முழுதும் காட்டியுள்ளார். அவர்களும் நகைச்சுவை என்ற பெயரில் பாலா சொல்லிக்கொடுத்த கருமங்களை பேசிக்கொண்டு தாங்களாகவே பல நிமிடங்கள் சிரித்துக்கொள்கிறார்கள், காமிரா அவர்கள் முகத்தில் மெதுவாக பயணிக்கிறது, நமக்கு வயிற்றை புரட்டுகிறது, பயமாய் இருக்கிறது. ஊனமுற்றவர்களை பல இல்லங்களில் இருந்து அழைத்துவந்து அசிங்கப்படுத்தியுள்ளார் பாலா. அவர்களைப் பார்த்தாலே காசு கொடுத்து படம் பார்க்க வந்த நம் மீதும், பாலாவை நம்பி வந்த அவர்கள் மீதும் பாவமாய் இருக்கிறது. பூஜா பாவப்பட்ட நடிகை. ஒரு நடிகையை எவ்வளவு அருவெறுப்பாக, அசிங்கமாக காட்டமுடியுமோ அப்படிக்காட்டியுள்ளார்கள். படத்தில் அவர் மட்டுமே கொஞ்சம் நடித்திருக்கிறார். ஆனால் வேண்டுமென்றே திணிக்கப்பட்ட அவரின் 'மேக்கப்'ஆல் நம்மால் அவரின் நடிப்பை ரசிக்கமுடியவில்லை. அதுவும் கடைசி காட்சியில் வாந்தி வருகிறது. திடீர் திடீர் என்று பழைய படப் பாடல்கள் சம்பந்தமேயில்லாமல் படத்தில் ஒலிக்கின்றன. யாராவது பாடுகிறார்கள், அல்லது வானொலியில் ஒலிக்கிறது. படத்தில் தமிழ் மிகவும் கொஞ்சமாக வருகிறது. அப்படியே வந்தாலும் பின்ணணி இசை வசனங்களைத் தின்கிறது. ஆர்யா அதில் தனக்கு தமிழ் தெரிந்தாலும், என்ன கண்றாவிக்காக தமிழர்களான சக சாமியார்களிடமும் தன் குடும்பத்தாரிடமும் இந்தி பேசுகிறார் என விளங்கவில்லை. படத்தில் என்ன நடக்குது என சுதாரிக்கும் முன் இடைவேளை வந்துவிடுகிறது. இது ஒரு கிறுக்குப்பிடித்த, குரூரமான, வக்கிரமான படமென்றால் அது மிகையாகாது. பாலாவினுள் இருந்த கலைஞனின் தலையில் சேதுவுக்குப் பின் 'கணம்' புகுந்து விட்டது. தான் என்ன எடுத்தாலும் உலகம் பாராட்டும் என்ற நினைப்போ என்னவோ!!தான் நினைத்த போது மட்டும், பொழுது போகவில்லையென்றால் மட்டும் 'நான் கடவுள்' படப்பிடிப்புக்குப் போக வைத்திருக்கிறது. திரைக்கதையே எழுதாமல் மனதில் தோன்றிய கொடூரங்களையெல்லாம் கோர்வையேயில்லாமல் படமாய் எடுக்கவைத்திருக்கிறது. இனி தயவுசெய்து பாலா சினிமா எடுப்பதை மறுபரிசீலனை செய்வது நலம். அல்லது அவரை தேவையில்லாமல் புகழ்ந்து தொலைத்த பாலு மகேந்திரா, மணிரத்னம் போன்றவர்களுக்கெல்லாம் அசிங்கம். நான் கடவுள் படத்தைப் பார்த்துத் தொலைத்த கடுப்பில் தான் இளையராஜா, 'நான் கடவுள்' பாடல் வெளியீட்டிற்கு வரவில்லையோ என்னமோ! அஜீத்தை தாக்கவேண்டிய புயல், பாவம் ஆர்யாவை ஆட்கொண்டுவிட்டது. அஜீத் தப்பித்தார். ஆனால் மக்களே நான் எல்லாவற்றையும் பொறுத்துக்கொள்கிறேன், ஆனால் இந்தப் படத்தையும் புகழ்ந்து தள்ளி விமர்சனம் எழுதியுள்ள சில இணையங்களின் வக்கிர புத்தியை தான் என்னால் சகிக்க முடியவில்லை!! தயவு செய்து பார்த்துவிடாதீர்கள் இந்தப் படத்தை. முக்கியமாக குழந்தைகளுடனும், வயதானவர்களுடனும், கர்ப்பிணிப் பெண்களுடனும், இதயம் பலவீனமானவர்களுடனுமோ போய்விடாதீர்கள்,. ஆபத்தில் முடியும். |
From: Sid_316 on Sat Feb 7 3:07:40 2009. |
From: MrJudge on Sat Feb 7 3:09:36 2009. |
Sid_316 wrote: |
NK is good.. but very dark and disturbing.. Ilayaraja is god! ![]() |
From: MrJudge on Sat Feb 7 3:13:44 2009. |
MADDY wrote: |
Lots of spoilers in the review below
I DO NOT ENDORSE ALL VIEWS OF THIS BLOGGER http://enathasolla.blogspot.com/2009/02/blog-post.html |
From: viraajan on Sat Feb 7 3:50:15 2009. |
From: Anban on Sat Feb 7 4:02:51 2009. |
MrJudge wrote: |
Looking forward to Anban's opinion, he should be back in couple of hours. |
From: Anban on Sat Feb 7 4:03:48 2009. |
MADDY wrote: | ||
without watching the movie, he said it is a "once in a lifetime" movie - which is why i said they were not honest opinions......... |
From: MADDY on Sat Feb 7 4:10:07 2009. |
Anban wrote: | ||||
|
From: thilak4life on Sat Feb 7 4:12:03 2009. |
Sid_316 wrote: |
NK is good.. but very dark and disturbing.. Ilayaraja is god! ![]() |
From: viraajan on Sat Feb 7 4:30:19 2009. |
From: Anban on Sat Feb 7 4:36:40 2009. |
MADDY wrote: | ||||||
i still dont see the connection between "unique" or "first time" with "once in lifetime" i think u r just trying to hype this film just looking at IR's name |
From: MADDY on Sat Feb 7 4:45:32 2009. |
Anban wrote: |
lol ..didnt u see my review for movies like MX or maaya kannaadi |
From: Vivasaayi on Sat Feb 7 4:48:02 2009. |
MADDY wrote: | ||
//tell me the last movie where kamal 'acted' badly - see MX is bad movie but did kamal act bad?? also, tell me last IR album which u found soul-less.....everyone have their own biases - lets agree that and understand it and move on.....// |
From: thilak4life on Sat Feb 7 4:48:42 2009. |
From: viraajan on Sat Feb 7 4:53:13 2009. |
thilak4life wrote: |
Interesting views, Vidhya. Thanks. |
From: MrJudge on Sat Feb 7 5:43:37 2009. |
viraajan wrote: |
Negative points:
Why does Bala need 2+ years to make this movie? (108 heroines change pannina aagathaan seiyum ![]() |
From: Nasc on Sat Feb 7 6:02:20 2009. |
bimmer wrote: | ||||
Ethu Sir Offbeat... Intha List Kooda compare panraingala 1. Hey Ram 2. Anbe Sivam 3. Paruthiveeran 4. Thavamai Thavamirunthu NK is now where in this league..Just because One wants to show difference...Bala has totally screwed up the Movie... Can anyone tell me why Bala should be considered a First league director??? he is not |
From: Nasc on Sat Feb 7 6:12:53 2009. |
bimmer wrote: |
I have mentioned the Bad qualities of NK...But there are some good credits to the Movie as well.
Ilayaraja...U are the best...had anybody else scored music and BGM (hARRIS) The movie would be a Uruvam Part 2. The camera...wonderful. Arya is good...But Pooja OMG...She has the real caliber and Guts..I could not imagine ""Bhavna doing this role"". |
From: Mahen on Sat Feb 7 6:20:13 2009. |
From: karthik_sa2 on Sat Feb 7 6:38:23 2009. |
From: njv on Sat Feb 7 7:22:12 2009. |
From: MADDY on Sat Feb 7 7:23:38 2009. |
From: Vivasaayi on Sat Feb 7 7:25:32 2009. |
MADDY wrote: |
watching the naan kadavul thirai vimarsanam on kalaignar tv.........EXtreeeeeeemmmmmeeeee visuals......my mom refused to watch the thrai vimarsanam show even and walked off to kitchen after seeing 5 mins of scenes ![]() ![]() |
From: njv on Sat Feb 7 7:26:25 2009. |
MADDY wrote: |
watching the naan kadavul thirai vimarsanam on kalaignar tv.........EXtreeeeeeemmmmmeeeee visuals......my mom refused to watch the thrai vimarsanam show even and walked off to kitchen after seeing 5 mins of scenes ![]() ![]() |
From: Prabhu Ram on Sat Feb 7 7:33:55 2009. |
From: viraajan on Sat Feb 7 7:38:17 2009. |
MrJudge wrote: | ||
Why should we worry about the time he took to finish it? We have directors in the same Kollywood who take 1 year to 1.5 years to complete some pathetic masala flicks. Also do you think it will be easy to get those handicapped people act as they shown in the movie? Even normal kids will take lot of takes to complete their scenes. Unless you have patience it is very very difficult to work with these people. That should be the reason for this much delay. I don't think any other director can even dream about taking a movie of this kind. IMO, the wait is worth. |
From: MADDY on Sat Feb 7 7:38:46 2009. |
njv wrote: |
IR - He has to be first. Oscar and GC dont have enough credentials to award this man. The whole world need to find a new way to award and respect him. |
njv wrote: |
CM, PM, Collectors & others involved in the crime business - If u cant fix the problems highlighted in this movie, ungal pinaththai puzhu poochchi kooda thingaamal pogattum. |
From: kannannn on Sat Feb 7 7:41:01 2009. |
Prabhu Ram wrote: |
Contrive, cover drive edhu vENA sollunga......naan indha padaththai paaththE aagaNum. |
From: MADDY on Sat Feb 7 7:43:11 2009. |
Prabhu Ram wrote: |
kambleet opposite reaksan to Maddy for the thirai vimarsanam - therinjiadhu dhaanE.
I was expecting to be underimpressed because of all the hype here. As late as this afternoon I was feeling pretty unenthusiastic about the film. But the scenes on TV and the pichchAi pAththiram song was damn damn impressive. Now, I can't wait to see the film. Contrive, cover drive edhu vENA sollunga......naan indha padaththai paaththE aagaNum. |
From: viraajan on Sat Feb 7 7:43:30 2009. |
From: viraajan on Sat Feb 7 7:45:52 2009. |
From: MADDY on Sat Feb 7 7:52:33 2009. |
njv wrote: |
Forget about music, IR etc. Let they all be junk. Just watch it for the underlying message. Something that you and I can do to fix the issue to some extend. Please. |
From: MrIndia on Sat Feb 7 7:52:36 2009. |
njv wrote: |
Saw the movie yday. Probably the best movie i have seen in the past few years.
IR - He has to be first. Oscar and GC dont have enough credentials to award this man. The whole world need to find a new way to award and respect him. Disappointed to see the songs missing, but the movie is sharp and crisp. |
From: Vivasaayi on Sat Feb 7 7:54:32 2009. |
MADDY wrote: |
exactly, infact i share the same disgust with Bala - who has exploited their situation to make a commercial movie and make money out of it......... |
From: MADDY on Sat Feb 7 8:06:30 2009. |
Vivasaayi wrote: | ||
obviously u havent seen the previous program on the movie A lady - one among those people it seems - told how good bala took care of them and they were so fond of bala. there is a footage where he was taking them on his lap and behaving so normal,whom u say when watched on screen form extreme images. ![]() i just asked what looked extreme for u - he just showed people who still live in our country and u r not answering for it ![]() |
From: viraajan on Sat Feb 7 8:06:37 2009. |
From: Vivasaayi on Sat Feb 7 8:08:05 2009. |
From: Prabhu Ram on Sat Feb 7 8:09:09 2009. |
From: Renault on Sat Feb 7 8:10:30 2009. |
From: MADDY on Sat Feb 7 8:12:39 2009. |
viraajan wrote: |
Slum people-a kaamichu SDM movie edukkalam. Abandoned orphans-a vachu edukka koodatha? ![]() |
From: Vivasaayi on Sat Feb 7 8:14:39 2009. |
viraajan wrote: |
Slum people-a kaamichu SDM movie edukkalam. Abandoned orphans-a vachu edukka koodatha? ![]() Betw, Bala has made this movie FOR them. It sheds lights on lives of those people. |
From: Vivasaayi on Sat Feb 7 8:15:28 2009. |
Prabhu Ram wrote: |
nEththu oru aaL padam paathuttu, innum edhuvum ezhudhaama thread-ai etti etti paathukkitturukkAr.... ![]() |
From: MrJudge on Sat Feb 7 8:28:54 2009. |
Prabhu Ram wrote: |
nEththu oru aaL padam paathuttu, innum edhuvum ezhudhaama thread-ai etti etti paathukkitturukkAr.... ![]() |
From: MrJudge on Sat Feb 7 8:30:59 2009. |
Prabhu Ram wrote: |
kambleet opposite reaksan to Maddy for the thirai vimarsanam - therinjiadhu dhaanE.
I was expecting to be underimpressed because of all the hype here. As late as this afternoon I was feeling pretty unenthusiastic about the film. But the scenes on TV and the pichchAi pAththiram song was damn damn impressive. Now, I can't wait to see the film. Contrive, cover drive edhu vENA sollunga......naan indha padaththai paaththE aagaNum. |
From: Roshan on Sat Feb 7 8:35:54 2009. |
Prabhu Ram wrote: |
kambleet opposite reaksan to Maddy for the thirai vimarsanam - therinjiadhu dhaanE.
I was expecting to be underimpressed because of all the hype here. As late as this afternoon I was feeling pretty unenthusiastic about the film. But the scenes on TV and the pichchAi pAththiram song was damn damn impressive. Now, I can't wait to see the film. Contrive, cover drive edhu vENA sollunga......naan indha padaththai paaththE aagaNum. |
From: steveaustin on Sat Feb 7 8:38:53 2009. |
From: Kalyasi on Sat Feb 7 8:48:01 2009. |
From: viraajan on Sat Feb 7 8:49:24 2009. |
MADDY wrote: | ||
haha - i'm into familiar territories after a long time - me against 10 IR fans ![]() unga baashai-laye pesuren - neenga(adhavadhu unga sanga urupinargal) SDMa critcise pannumbodhu, naa NK movie criticise panna koodaadha ![]() ![]() |
From: MrJudge on Sat Feb 7 8:52:06 2009. |
Kalyasi wrote: |
all my friends who saw the movie called me and told "naasam da machaan, vaaippe illa" |
From: MrJudge on Sat Feb 7 8:55:17 2009. |
From: MrJudge on Sat Feb 7 9:07:07 2009. |
MrIndia wrote: | ||
y u cant appreciate an indian getting to this height.. unnecessary digressions.. Raja sir has done a outstanding job.. only maestro only god .. ithellem vendaamey. enaala mudiyum apidigaradhu... thannambikai ennala mattum mudiyum apidungaradhu ... thala ganam ![]() |
From: MrJudge on Sat Feb 7 9:29:22 2009. |
viraajan wrote: |
When you take such a huge time to complete a movie, don't you think that the movie should come out extraordinarily? Would you really say that he has given a complete movie now? or an extraordinary movie? A big NO!! |
From: viraajan on Sat Feb 7 10:09:27 2009. |
MrJudge wrote: | ||
Definitely the movie looks like not a complete one. The reason is: no scenes involved describing the agOris, not even in dialogues. Luckily we have got the info through the internet and we read about them, so we could connect to the character and understand. But what about the regular people who don't know or didn't read anything about agOris. For them the film will look more incomplete/ not convincing. The culprit is Censor Board. |
From: MrJudge on Sat Feb 7 10:16:59 2009. |
viraajan wrote: |
That is my complaint too. Arya's character has not been told well. We understood easily. But regular movie goers may not understand. This is one big flaw. But OTOH, Arya has been portrayed as an ordinary Saamiyar but not a Agori (eating human flesh). So regular movie goers would think that he comes as a saamiyar.
But there was a lil explanation given about arya's character at the start. ![]() ![]() |
From: viraajan on Sat Feb 7 10:20:17 2009. |
From: thilak4life on Sat Feb 7 10:20:59 2009. |
From: MrJudge on Sat Feb 7 10:22:34 2009. |
viraajan wrote: |
No judge. There was a clear explanation (even tho little) given at the start. I guess you've missed it. ![]() I can explain it here. But it may become a spoiler ![]() |
From: MrJudge on Sat Feb 7 10:23:08 2009. |
thilak4life wrote: |
Eq, Expecting your review man. |
From: thilak4life on Sat Feb 7 10:24:02 2009. |
Quote: |
Contrive, cover drive edhu vENA sollunga......naan indha padaththai paaththE aagaNum. |
From: thilak4life on Sat Feb 7 10:24:47 2009. |
MrJudge wrote: | ||
avar thAn etti etti pAkkuravarA? ![]() |
From: MrJudge on Sat Feb 7 10:27:39 2009. |
thilak4life wrote: | ||||
![]() |
From: viraajan on Sat Feb 7 10:30:05 2009. |
MrJudge wrote: | ||
I didn't miss anything that came in tamil. But what I meant was I don't think anywhere it was said that an agOri eats human flesh. |
From: irir123 on Sat Feb 7 11:07:49 2009. |
MADDY wrote: | ||
Lots of spoilers in the review below
I DO NOT ENDORSE ALL VIEWS OF THIS BLOGGER http://enathasolla.blogspot.com/2009/02/blog-post.html
|
From: kamalsurya on Sat Feb 7 11:15:14 2009. |
From: Anban on Sat Feb 7 11:15:41 2009. |
MrJudge wrote: |
Anban-na innum kAnOm? ![]() TIME interview session pOittArA? |
From: viraajan on Sat Feb 7 11:18:13 2009. |
From: Anban on Sat Feb 7 11:18:29 2009. |
kamalsurya wrote: |
Verdict: Thumbs up for for the potraying cinema with such realism and for courage to do such a flim. Thumbs down on failing to potray the main character adequtely. |
From: viraajan on Sat Feb 7 11:22:13 2009. |
Anban wrote: | ||
this is what some of my friends told.. well, why should we ASSUME that rudran is the main character of the movie?? did bala ever say so?? |
From: kamalsurya on Sat Feb 7 11:26:34 2009. |
Anban wrote: | ||
this is what some of my friends told.. well, why should we ASSUME that rudran is the main character of the movie?? did bala ever say so?? |
From: joe on Sat Feb 7 11:35:47 2009. |
From: Kalyasi on Sat Feb 7 11:41:57 2009. |
joe wrote: |
Just back from theatre..
Simply OutStanding |
From: directhit on Sat Feb 7 11:52:52 2009. |
From: joe on Sat Feb 7 11:55:05 2009. |
directhit wrote: |
Joe - u were in theatre ![]() ![]() |
From: Kalyasi on Sat Feb 7 11:55:39 2009. |
directhit wrote: |
Joe - u were in theatre ![]() ![]() and ppl who saw the film - was it only 2:15 mts ![]() ![]() |
From: directhit on Sat Feb 7 11:56:13 2009. |
From: Kalyasi on Sat Feb 7 11:58:37 2009. |
directhit wrote: |
oh ok, yaaravadhu india la pathavanga sollunga - was there only siva om and pichai pathiram songs in the movie ![]() ![]() |
From: Ramakrishna on Sat Feb 7 11:59:56 2009. |
directhit wrote: |
oh ok, yaaravadhu india la pathavanga sollunga - was there only siva om and pichai pathiram songs in the movie ![]() ![]() |
From: equanimus on Sat Feb 7 12:02:10 2009. |
Prabhu Ram wrote: |
nEththu oru aaL padam paathuttu, innum edhuvum ezhudhaama thread-ai etti etti paathukkitturukkAr.... ![]() |
From: directhit on Sat Feb 7 12:11:58 2009. |
From: MrJudge on Sat Feb 7 12:12:30 2009. |
Anban wrote: |
heart broken..devastated....disappointed..
thank god, i slept in the morning.. |
From: MrJudge on Sat Feb 7 12:20:18 2009. |
From: MrJudge on Sat Feb 7 12:20:55 2009. |
joe wrote: |
Just back from theatre..
Simply OutStanding |
From: MrJudge on Sat Feb 7 12:21:47 2009. |
From: directhit on Sat Feb 7 12:21:48 2009. |
From: MrJudge on Sat Feb 7 12:25:13 2009. |
directhit wrote: |
judge - i loved that dialogue the old guy says after the mallu guy takes off that kid abt god - dont think any other dir other than bala wud keep it in a tamil film |
From: directhit on Sat Feb 7 12:26:13 2009. |
From: directhit on Sat Feb 7 12:28:37 2009. |
Guess_Me wrote: | ||
Sorry guys. He is not exactly the kind of person who pays attention to BGM and other technical stuff. He is a Vijay fan (no offense to Vijay fans) who purely looks for entertainment. He liked Pithamagan and Sethu but was disappointed with Naan Kadavul. He liked Pokkiri, hated Kuruvi, says Villu is just ok. So you get a picture now. |
From: MrJudge on Sat Feb 7 12:30:37 2009. |
directhit wrote: |
censor ithana koduma panniye its so hardhitting ![]() ![]() ![]() |
From: directhit on Sat Feb 7 12:31:46 2009. |
From: joe on Sat Feb 7 12:31:54 2009. |
From: Kalyasi on Sat Feb 7 12:32:10 2009. |
directhit wrote: | ||||
![]() ![]() |
From: directhit on Sat Feb 7 12:35:07 2009. |
From: MrJudge on Sat Feb 7 12:38:24 2009. |
directhit wrote: |
mm rite dhaan - hope he releases a full DVD version ![]() ![]() |
From: directhit on Sat Feb 7 12:39:21 2009. |
From: joe on Sat Feb 7 12:40:54 2009. |
directhit wrote: |
movie is NC16 - so kids not allowed and |
From: directhit on Sat Feb 7 12:43:06 2009. |
From: MrJudge on Sat Feb 7 12:43:32 2009. |
joe wrote: |
Together with two friends ,i brought my wife and son (since he is just 3 years old and he will sleep only) ..But the person in counter said children not at all allowed .. (He said this is the first tamil movie with NC 16 ,previously few movies got PG 16 (Parental guidence) ..So my wife also had to return back with my son ![]() |
From: equanimus on Sat Feb 7 12:43:49 2009. |
directhit wrote: |
loved the scene where the old man talks abt god ![]() |
From: directhit on Sat Feb 7 12:46:45 2009. |
equanimus wrote: | ||
The greatest moment in the film IMO. kaNNula thaNNi vandhuduchchu. (There were a few other scenes too when my eyes welled up.) |
From: MrJudge on Sat Feb 7 12:49:44 2009. |
equanimus wrote: | ||
The greatest moment in the film IMO. kaNNula thaNNi vandhuduchchu. (There were a few other scenes too when my eyes welled up.) |
From: joe on Sat Feb 7 12:51:10 2009. |
From: directhit on Sat Feb 7 12:52:05 2009. |
From: complicateur on Sat Feb 7 12:53:51 2009. |
equanimus wrote: |
ivangaLap paththi unakku ennadA nAn padam edukkaRadhu 'nu solRA mAdhiri oru feeling. |
From: MrJudge on Sat Feb 7 12:54:03 2009. |
joe wrote: |
DH,
1952 Parasakthi.. அம்பாள் சிலைக்கு பின்னால் ஒளிந்து கொண்டு... நடிகர் திலகம் : அடேய் பூசாரி! பூசாரி : யாரு ? அம்பாளா பேசுறது ? நடிகர் திலகம் : அம்பாள் எந்த காலத்திலடா பேசினாள் அறிவுகெட்டவனே! |
From: directhit on Sat Feb 7 12:54:10 2009. |
From: joe on Sat Feb 7 12:57:42 2009. |
directhit wrote: |
Joe, i think the intensity and language is very very different in this movie and in the one i mentioned. though being a 52 film its to be appreciated. but what they showed here is what ANY PERSON wud react to in real life and NO PERSON wud show in a film ![]() |
From: viraajan on Sat Feb 7 13:02:30 2009. |
From: jaaze on Sat Feb 7 13:05:17 2009. |
directhit wrote: |
namma oorla ye U/A - ivanunga alambal thaangala ![]() ![]() |
From: joe on Sat Feb 7 13:05:29 2009. |
From: directhit on Sat Feb 7 13:05:43 2009. |
From: jaaze on Sat Feb 7 13:06:46 2009. |
directhit wrote: |
VR - why dont u put the spoilers in white font atleast ![]() |
From: viraajan on Sat Feb 7 13:07:18 2009. |
directhit wrote: |
VR - why dont u put the spoilers in white font atleast ![]() |
From: joe on Sat Feb 7 13:08:04 2009. |
From: directhit on Sat Feb 7 13:08:16 2009. |
From: jaaze on Sat Feb 7 13:11:30 2009. |
directhit wrote: |
neenga dhanam theatre kku poi patheengala ![]() |
From: joe on Sat Feb 7 13:16:03 2009. |
From: directhit on Sat Feb 7 13:17:39 2009. |
directhit wrote: |
why was there 'thanks to yugi sethu' in the title card? |
From: Sid_316 on Sat Feb 7 13:18:58 2009. |
joe wrote: |
மகாநதிக்கு பிறகு இந்த அளவுக்கும் மனதை பாதித்த படம் வேறு எதுவுமில்லை |
From: jaaze on Sat Feb 7 13:19:38 2009. |
directhit wrote: | ||
|
From: jaaze on Sat Feb 7 13:21:16 2009. |
From: directhit on Sat Feb 7 13:24:48 2009. |
jaaze wrote: |
Was there any applause for any significantly touching scene (or the climax if it is) cos I heard there were standing ovations in India.. |
From: joe on Sat Feb 7 13:32:03 2009. |
From: jaaze on Sat Feb 7 13:33:42 2009. |
From: directhit on Sat Feb 7 13:33:45 2009. |
From: jaaze on Sat Feb 7 13:34:24 2009. |
directhit wrote: |
Joe ![]() ![]() ![]() |
From: directhit on Sat Feb 7 13:36:36 2009. |
From: A_Ajith on Sat Feb 7 13:37:14 2009. |
From: A_Ajith on Sat Feb 7 13:38:25 2009. |
From: joe on Sat Feb 7 13:41:29 2009. |
A_Ajith wrote: |
Aarya has been wasted! Not enough footage. |
From: directhit on Sat Feb 7 13:43:24 2009. |
From: crajkumar_be on Sat Feb 7 13:48:19 2009. |
From: jaaze on Sat Feb 7 13:49:02 2009. |
directhit wrote: |
aana avarukku villain _________________ Academy Ruler (AR) Rahman |
From: jaaze on Sat Feb 7 13:52:12 2009. |
From: directhit on Sat Feb 7 13:55:51 2009. |
steveaustin wrote: |
Saw the movie today. This is purely my opinion about Naan Kadavul.
Amazing and breathtaking!!!! This is the best ever film from BALA so far. Truly portrayed the another world which I have not seen ever before. For me, certainly the film starts new era in Tamil Film Industry. IMO, this movie sets new benchmark in TFI. A pure raw product. No commercial ingredients. BALA & IR ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() POOJA breathtaking. ARYA dazzles. Every one including technicians behind the screens played their part very well. Dynamic team effort. Kudos to Bala for providing a good movie. But he may face lot of problems from Human Rights Commission. |
From: VENKIRAJA on Sat Feb 7 13:58:06 2009. |
crajkumar_be wrote: |
nanbargale,
Aandavar padangala thavira vera endha padathayum naan indha alavukku edhirpaarthadhillai. Glad to hear the overwhelming feedback (though IMO Bala has never made a great film - good films with great and ordinary moments). In any case i havent read any detailed review as a matter of 'principle'. Really looking forward to watching the film for Raasaappu and Bala Judge, Nachunu, ulladha sollunga. How is the BGM? (first half, second half ellam)? |
From: joe on Sat Feb 7 13:59:41 2009. |
From: A_Ajith on Sat Feb 7 13:59:51 2009. |
From: jaaze on Sat Feb 7 14:00:10 2009. |
joe wrote: |
Despite running in 5 screens ,Golden Mill 8.30 show is full and the whole crowd is of the age group 25-40 ,only two females ..the whole crowd are NRI ,i don't find any locals. |
From: joe on Sat Feb 7 14:03:40 2009. |
From: A_Ajith on Sat Feb 7 14:09:02 2009. |
Quote: |
On looking back, there are a few things that could have been righted in the movie. Like a little more of an explanation of why it all happens. It all seems a little too sudden sometimes. The sudden appearance of Rudra. The sudden weaving in of the beggars’ tales. The sudden correlation between them and him. How does he establish himself as someone like a sorcerer, etc., etc. Plus, most of Hindi and Sanksrit words should have had Tamil and/ or English subtitles to keep the audience in the loop of things. There is much violence (cruelly creative, we say!) that leaves you queasy (the scenes where Thandavam unleashes his terrible anger on his hapless beggars and on Hamsavalli). Add to this the freak-show quality of constant streams of differently-abled people shown on screen and the mindless and ruthlessly expressed cruelty of Thandavam and others; and you wonder what audiences is Naan Kadavul really made for – the mass audience, the “hat-ke” parallel cinema lovers or a mixture of both? Well, it’s certainly not for the faint-hearted. |
From: Prabhu Ram on Sat Feb 7 14:09:19 2009. |
equanimus wrote: |
kaNNula thaNNi vandhuduchchu. (There were a few other scenes too when my eyes welled up.) |
From: MrJudge on Sat Feb 7 14:32:37 2009. |
joe wrote: |
மகாநதிக்கு பிறகு இந்த அளவுக்கும் மனதை பாதித்த படம் வேறு எதுவுமில்லை |
From: MrJudge on Sat Feb 7 14:52:35 2009. |
crajkumar_be wrote: |
nanbargale,
Aandavar padangala thavira vera endha padathayum naan indha alavukku edhirpaarthadhillai. Glad to hear the overwhelming feedback (though IMO Bala has never made a great film - good films with great and ordinary moments). In any case i havent read any detailed review as a matter of 'principle'. Really looking forward to watching the film for Raasaappu and Bala Judge, Nachunu, ulladha sollunga. How is the BGM? (first half, second half ellam)? |
From: bimmer on Sat Feb 7 15:01:45 2009. |
MrJudge wrote: | ||
nichchayamA....(athanudan Sethu, Pithamagan, PV climaxesayum sollalAm) Bala has cleverly added the humour side of them to keep it going which was missing in Mahanathi. konjam nambikkai irukku tamilnAttu rasigargaL appreciate pannuvAngannu. |
From: MrJudge on Sat Feb 7 15:05:39 2009. |
bimmer wrote: | ||||
Enna Koduma...Comparing This Movie to Mahanadi ![]() ![]() ![]() IMHO NK is nothing more than a Mindless film. |
From: Anban on Sat Feb 7 15:08:36 2009. |
directhit wrote: |
Raja BGM ordinary in the first half till the scene jus before the interval - from that and in second half ![]() ![]() ![]() |
From: Anban on Sat Feb 7 15:09:52 2009. |
MrJudge wrote: | ||
![]() |
From: MrJudge on Sat Feb 7 15:15:15 2009. |
Anban wrote: | ||
![]() ![]() |
From: MrJudge on Sat Feb 7 15:17:27 2009. |
Anban wrote: | ||||
![]() |
From: Anban on Sat Feb 7 15:19:59 2009. |
MrJudge wrote: | ||||
NK padaththula varRa original score mAthiri Raaja pOttuttE irunthA pOthum atleast for one film every year, global recognition vEnAm oru maNNum vEnAm. |
From: Anban on Sat Feb 7 15:37:41 2009. |
From: Anban on Sat Feb 7 15:38:17 2009. |
From: equanimus on Sat Feb 7 15:41:48 2009. |
MrJudge wrote: | ||
Yes, thanks for bringing it up, the essence is same in different words. |
directhit wrote: |
Joe, i think the intensity and language is very very different in this movie and in the one i mentioned. |
From: irir123 on Sat Feb 7 15:43:25 2009. |
From: Thirumaran on Sat Feb 7 16:17:53 2009. |
From: equanimus on Sat Feb 7 16:30:17 2009. |
irir123 wrote: |
there was lot of hype abt how the Kasi Kumbh mela was picturised in a natural way - were those scenes chopped as well ? |
From: equanimus on Sat Feb 7 16:35:17 2009. |
complicateur wrote: | ||
![]() |
Prabhu Ram wrote: |
Thanks eq. Your post underlines the uneasy fear I have been harbouring for a while now. |
crajkumar_be wrote: |
nanbargale,
Aandavar padangala thavira vera endha padathayum naan indha alavukku edhirpaarthadhillai. |
From: njv on Sat Feb 7 18:08:58 2009. |
MrJudge wrote: |
Definitely the movie looks like not a complete one. The reason is: no scenes involved describing the agOris, not even in dialogues. Luckily we have got the info through the internet and we read about them, so we could connect to the character and understand. But what about the regular people who don't know or didn't read anything about agOris. For them the film will look more incomplete/ not convincing. The culprit is Censor Board. oru chinna clear illAtha vishyamum irukku but need to think about it later. |
From: complicateur on Sat Feb 7 18:25:04 2009. |
equanimus wrote: |
Complicateur, I'm not sure if I put it across well. I felt that Bala got lost in the world he tried to capture and his filmmaking self got into a state of ennui (vis-a-vis the sheer meaninglessness of making a coherent film of this). I'm struggling to "get" the film myself frankly. Looking forward to your thoughts. |
From: njv on Sat Feb 7 18:47:19 2009. |
Anban wrote: |
Now I come to the man behind Naan Kadavul.He lives throughout the film.He has done a 1000 films and still people doubt his longevity. Here he answers one and all. He adds soul to the proceedings right from where he comes up with the Sanskrit song in the initial credits. The songs ‘Om Sivom’ and ‘Pichai paathiram’ get the emotions out of you to praise the composer. It is so unfortunate that the songs ‘Amma un pillai’ and ‘Kannil Paarvai’ haven’t been picturised. The background music is even more mesmerizing and sends you to a state of ecstasy -I am not sure if these adjectives are enough. The music elevates the scenes- each and every one- to a higher pedestal.Well, he is a genius and let me stop here.His name is Ilaiyaraja! That’s that!
|
From: directhit on Sat Feb 7 21:44:12 2009. |
Anban wrote: | ||
![]() ![]() |
Anban wrote: |
appo oscar vaangura alavukku illayaa ?? |
From: dell_gt on Sat Feb 7 22:00:40 2009. |
From: directhit on Sat Feb 7 23:00:06 2009. |
njv wrote: |
E.g. Rudran fight with family to get dead body |
From: viraajan on Sat Feb 7 23:27:52 2009. |
directhit wrote: | ||
njv, idhu eppo ![]()
|
From: kamalsurya on Sat Feb 7 23:50:10 2009. |
From: MrJudge on Sun Feb 8 0:30:50 2009. |
directhit wrote: | ||
njv, idhu eppo ![]()
|
From: steveaustin on Sun Feb 8 1:39:03 2009. |
From: joe on Sun Feb 8 1:52:41 2009. |
From: jaiganes on Sun Feb 8 2:08:51 2009. |
From: Nerd on Sun Feb 8 2:53:50 2009. |
jaiganes wrote: |
@nerd
where are you? did u see it? |
From: MrJudge on Sun Feb 8 2:58:56 2009. |
From: MrJudge on Sun Feb 8 3:00:44 2009. |
From: MrJudge on Sun Feb 8 3:03:46 2009. |
From: joe on Sun Feb 8 3:04:15 2009. |
Nerd wrote: |
Though 98% of the scenes were good, I felt the movie as a complete package was not *that* great. |
From: MrJudge on Sun Feb 8 3:06:01 2009. |
Anban wrote: | ||
|
From: MrJudge on Sun Feb 8 3:20:19 2009. |
equanimus wrote: |
MrJudge/Joe,
The emotions of the two scenes are vastly different. The scene in parAsakthi is radical vis-a-vis the sociopolitical situation, and more importantly, overtly satiricial (about the bourgeois, the fatalistic mindset etc.). But here, the strains of emotion is something very different. There's no human "other" to mock at, so to say. The manner in which 'God' is represented itself underlines the distinction. The old man here can't help but direct his seething and helpless anger about this misery at "that b*stard." It's a greatly moving moment. |
From: Nerd on Sun Feb 8 3:20:32 2009. |
From: MrJudge on Sun Feb 8 3:24:08 2009. |
joe wrote: | ||
Nerd, Don't you think ,it is more than what can be done under Tamil cinema curcumstances ? Intha maathiri oru padam ivvaLavu effort pottu edukka ippothaikku Bala-vai vitta vera yaarala mudiyum? |
From: raja_fan on Sun Feb 8 3:24:12 2009. |
From: joe on Sun Feb 8 3:27:15 2009. |
From: MrJudge on Sun Feb 8 3:36:56 2009. |
Nerd wrote: |
Judge, honestly I don't know and i can't think of a single director who has made at least 4 films without giving a dud (Even Mahendran has given quite a few). This man Bala is something ![]() |
Nerd wrote: |
Did anyone else find that sadhu (in kasi) who talks in broken tamizh bloody irritating ![]() |
From: MrJudge on Sun Feb 8 3:42:21 2009. |
From: viraajan on Sun Feb 8 3:46:31 2009. |
From: MrJudge on Sun Feb 8 3:46:59 2009. |
raja_fan wrote: |
The emotions of the old man in NK is taking privilege ( Urimai ) with his beloved God. |
From: directhit on Sun Feb 8 3:58:27 2009. |
From: directhit on Sun Feb 8 4:08:16 2009. |
steveaustin wrote: |
Finally, it is not BALA's Naan kadavul. Here I can say that BALA himself is Naan Kadavul (as a creator). |
From: jaaze on Sun Feb 8 4:38:28 2009. |
From: ThalaNass on Sun Feb 8 5:17:03 2009. |
From: njv on Sun Feb 8 6:33:20 2009. |
MrJudge wrote: | ||||
me too.. ![]() |
From: njv on Sun Feb 8 6:37:21 2009. |
joe wrote: |
Raja_fan,equ
Leave the parasakthi thingi..I didn't compare both and its concept ..Just mentioned it just to show that even before 56 years back there were bold dialogues. |
From: Prabhu Ram on Sun Feb 8 6:37:41 2009. |
njv wrote: |
Doubl Thumbsup icon work aagala. Enna koduma moderator idhu |
From: directhit on Sun Feb 8 6:39:26 2009. |
njv wrote: | ||||||
Doubl Thumbsup icon work aagala. Enna koduma moderator idhu. |
From: njv on Sun Feb 8 6:48:38 2009. |
steveaustin wrote: |
Yesterday, I have experienced Naan Kadavul. ...
On the flip side, the climax scenes seems to be discontinuous because of Censors. Some of the Hindi / Sanskrit dialogues might have been subtitled in Tamil for the rural and some sections of urban audiences. Few scenes may be devoid of logic. But it can be forgiven for the hard work of BALA. |
From: directhit on Sun Feb 8 6:50:35 2009. |
njv wrote: |
also the malayalee broker when he goes to pick up kids for the first time, he looks at a girl who just got married. The dialogue was delivered in Mayalalam, but really if one understand it, just that dialogue is equivalent to whole Mahanadhi movie. |
From: Nerd on Sun Feb 8 10:27:39 2009. |
directhit wrote: | ||
![]() |
From: Hulkster on Sun Feb 8 10:39:33 2009. |
From: Hulkster on Sun Feb 8 10:42:23 2009. |
Nerd wrote: |
Question: What made Arya's mom forget Arya? She says something like avan thirumba varamAttAn.. What exactly did AryA tell her in the scene before that? |
From: crajkumar_be on Sun Feb 8 11:48:37 2009. |
Quote: |
To put it across, It is Rudran (The liberator, the one who has realised himself) hearing the pain of these people and gives them death(mercy killing but in this film context, moksham) and at the same time establishes good over evil( the murder of the villain) |
From: crajkumar_be on Sun Feb 8 11:54:53 2009. |
From: crajkumar_be on Sun Feb 8 12:03:18 2009. |
From: joe on Sun Feb 8 12:16:11 2009. |
crajkumar_be wrote: |
The mimicry scenes were ![]() ![]() |
joe wrote: |
After 'Kannai Nampaathe unnai yeematrum' song..
நடிகர் திலகம் அண்ணன் எம்.ஜி.ஆரிடம் " அண்ணே! எவ்வளவோ நல்ல கருத்தெல்லாம் சொன்னீங்க.. உங்களுக்கு ஓட்டு போட்டாங்களே தவிர அதை கேட்டு ஒரு பயலும் திருந்தல்லியே" After "Oru kinnaithai yenthukiRen' song.. எம்.ஜி.ஆர் தம்பி நடிகர் திலகத்திடம் " தம்பி கணேசா ..உன்னோட நடிப்பையெல்லாம் சரியா சொல்லீக் கொடுக்காம போயிட்டியே ..இப்ப உள்ள நண்டு சிண்டு நடிகனெல்லாம் நடிப்புண்ணு பண்ணுற அலம்பல்.." ![]() ![]() ![]() |
From: A_Ajith on Sun Feb 8 12:16:58 2009. |
From: A_Ajith on Sun Feb 8 12:21:08 2009. |
From: Vivasaayi on Sun Feb 8 12:21:37 2009. |
From: Nerd on Sun Feb 8 12:38:04 2009. |
joe wrote: | ||||
|
From: Nerd on Sun Feb 8 12:41:35 2009. |
From: A_Ajith on Sun Feb 8 12:42:28 2009. |
From: crajkumar_be on Sun Feb 8 12:56:04 2009. |
A_Ajith wrote: |
really IR's BGM is terrific. |
From: A_Ajith on Sun Feb 8 13:00:07 2009. |
crajkumar_be wrote: | ||
A_A, Meengal nalla neendhum nu solra madhiri idhu ![]() BGM na adhu Raaja dhaan. Any day of any calendar week/month/year. Matter over |
From: Movie Cop on Sun Feb 8 13:08:27 2009. |
crajkumar_be wrote: |
Down with the pseudo cool urbane crowd ![]() PVR, Inox paruppunga tholla thaala mudiyala pa. padam arambikkarakku munnave smart-alecky comments thodangiyiruchu. What did they expect to see in this movie, i don't know. Or are they trying to hide their "vulnerability"? Bala "ups" his two middle fingers to this crowd ![]() P.S: Elite and thara center crowds are irritating at different times in different ways When i went to my seat a group of 3 were having a conversation like this: P1: "Pattu irukka padathula?" P2: "Paattu edho rendo edho irukku aana nalla irukkaadhu" ![]() |
From: MumbaiRamki on Sun Feb 8 13:19:19 2009. |
From: MrJudge on Sun Feb 8 13:32:32 2009. |
crajkumar_be wrote: |
And no "With The Grand Music Of Maestro" card this time ![]() |
From: irir123 on Sun Feb 8 13:55:12 2009. |
Movie Cop wrote: | ||
![]() <Dig> Haven't seen NK yet but had a similar experience while watching VA! There are lots of "smart a$$ vettiyans" who enter the theatre with those annoying comments spoiling others concentration... Me and my friend almost ended up blasting the folks who sat behing our row during VA! Without understanding the "context" of the movie or understanding the tone of characterization, silla vettiyans theatre-la remba mokkai comments poduranunge... If these folks have "baed" comprehensive/apprehensive skills why go for such movies in the first place... ![]() |
From: MrJudge on Sun Feb 8 14:03:45 2009. |
From: A_Ajith on Sun Feb 8 14:03:47 2009. |
From: MrJudge on Sun Feb 8 14:07:08 2009. |
Hulkster wrote: | ||
He told her that he has separated himself from worldly ties and that he is in the process of being enlightened. Says that he is no more interested in the family ties. |
From: MrJudge on Sun Feb 8 14:10:05 2009. |
A_Ajith wrote: |
Yuvan BGM kooda supera irukum ![]() |
From: A_Ajith on Sun Feb 8 14:11:11 2009. |
MrJudge wrote: | ||
nichchayamA Raaja aLavukku deep-A irukkAthu. If you don't believe me, just watch Sethu/Pithamgan and nandhA, you can see the difference. His scores are not a match for Bala's themes. Raaja is the only choice. |
From: MrJudge on Sun Feb 8 14:14:54 2009. |
A_Ajith wrote: |
Judge adhu ellam subjectku etha madhiri, who can forget PUDUPETTAI's DARK AND DEADLY BGM!?!?!? |
From: Nerd on Sun Feb 8 14:17:12 2009. |
MrJudge wrote: |
njv:
Here in India the scene you were talking about Rudran fighting for a dead body in the opening scenes wasn't showed. Can you please let me know where exactly it comes and what happens (if not here atleast in PM)? Thanks. |
From: A_Ajith on Sun Feb 8 14:17:52 2009. |
From: MrJudge on Sun Feb 8 14:23:11 2009. |
Nerd wrote: | ||
I dint see such a scene in the US either. May be it was part of the Om sivOham song ![]() |
From: MrJudge on Sun Feb 8 14:25:58 2009. |
A_Ajith wrote: |
But IR's BGM for this movie's action scenes took me back to his Thalapathi Nayagan days!
Was superb na? Especially during that Malayalee Arya Fight Wow |
From: A_Ajith on Sun Feb 8 14:26:07 2009. |
From: A_Ajith on Sun Feb 8 14:28:00 2009. |
From: MrJudge on Sun Feb 8 14:28:10 2009. |
A_Ajith wrote: |
Yes its a part of Om Siva Om song.
He will hit few people during the song. In trailer his guru will wake him up and say "Rudran, Naash Karo Dushton Ko" that did not come in movie at all. |
From: MrJudge on Sun Feb 8 14:30:07 2009. |
A_Ajith wrote: |
Damn on censor boards. They cut some scenes towards the climax i guess.
They let girls dance and allow vulgar lyrics. But they have cut arya's dialogues in court, Judge asks him what u did to the malayalee, arya says "Saptiten" (i've eaten him). That scene also has been cut i guess coz of cannibalism. |
From: A_Ajith on Sun Feb 8 14:31:10 2009. |
From: Mahen on Sun Feb 8 14:35:40 2009. |
A_Ajith wrote: |
Damn on censor boards. They cut some scenes towards the climax i guess.
They let girls dance and allow vulgar lyrics. But they have cut arya's dialogues in court, Judge asks him what u did to the malayalee, arya says "Saptiten" (i've eaten him). That scene also has been cut i guess coz of cannibalism. What does arya say when he sees the villian and the malayalee, some dushton nigra something can anyone explain why he attacks them? |
From: MrJudge on Sun Feb 8 14:40:13 2009. |
A_Ajith wrote: |
Judge u have any idea what Arya says upon seeing the malayalee and the villian.
Why does he attack them? I can;t understand the reason |
From: Anban on Sun Feb 8 14:41:08 2009. |
A_Ajith wrote: |
Damn on censor boards. They cut some scenes towards the climax i guess.
They let girls dance and allow vulgar lyrics. But they have cut arya's dialogues in court, Judge asks him what u did to the malayalee, arya says "Saptiten" (i've eaten him). That scene also has been cut i guess coz of cannibalism. What does arya say when he sees the villian and the malayalee, some dushton nigra something can anyone explain why he attacks them? |
From: MrJudge on Sun Feb 8 14:44:07 2009. |
Mahen wrote: |
Btw, what arya did to the villains?? ![]() ![]() |
From: Mahen on Sun Feb 8 15:01:47 2009. |
MrJudge wrote: | ||
The malayalee guy was taken to the bush after he was dead but nothing showed after that. I think he ate his flesh and that was what he says in the court but the dialogue was muted. Thandavam was killed and he was lying on top of a rock. |
From: vasanth2006 on Sun Feb 8 15:02:15 2009. |
MrJudge wrote: |
njv:
Here in India the scene you were talking about Rudran fighting for a dead body in the opening scenes wasn't showed. Can you please let me know where exactly it comes and what happens (if not here atleast in PM)? Thanks. |
From: vasanth2006 on Sun Feb 8 15:02:48 2009. |
A_Ajith wrote: | ||||
Yuvan BGM kooda supera irukum ![]() |
From: vasanth2006 on Sun Feb 8 15:09:43 2009. |
MrJudge wrote: | ||
I don't know hindi/sanskrit.... so no idea. But the priest in Kasi explains to his dad that Agoris will identify the evil force by consciousness. That might be the reason he attacks them. |
From: A_Ajith on Sun Feb 8 15:15:24 2009. |
From: vasanth2006 on Sun Feb 8 15:18:06 2009. |
From: vasanth2006 on Sun Feb 8 15:25:56 2009. |
From: A_Ajith on Sun Feb 8 15:37:05 2009. |
vasanth2006 wrote: |
I
And If you expect more of aghoris concept, then you will disappoint.... because this movie is not completely based on aghoris... |
From: crajkumar_be on Sun Feb 8 15:49:39 2009. |
From: bimmer on Sun Feb 8 17:48:25 2009. |
vasanth2006 wrote: |
I knew Bala is a good director.... But I thought Bala is a overrated director....
I feel I was wrong.... After seeing NK, I am realising his direction skills.... Definitely he is thinking out of the box.... I respect him.... I am sure the popcorn crowd will critisize this movie.... Even they can not understand this people's life...... but this movie shows exactly about their life.... And If you expect more of aghoris concept, then you will disappoint.... because this movie is not completely based on aghoris... After seeing PV, I couldn't see that movie second time.... But I am eager to see this movie second time...... |
From: bimmer on Sun Feb 8 17:55:42 2009. |
joe wrote: | ||
Nerd, Don't you think ,it is more than what can be done under Tamil cinema curcumstances ? Intha maathiri oru padam ivvaLavu effort pottu edukka ippothaikku Bala-vai vitta vera yaarala mudiyum? |
From: irir123 on Sun Feb 8 20:33:18 2009. |
From: directhit on Sun Feb 8 21:01:41 2009. |
MrJudge wrote: | ||||
'inimE avan ingE varamAttAn....avan oru suyumbu' appadinnu kEttathA nyabagam. |
From: directhit on Sun Feb 8 21:03:41 2009. |
Nerd wrote: | ||
I dint see such a scene in the US either. May be it was part of the Om sivOham song ![]() |
From: directhit on Sun Feb 8 21:11:22 2009. |
From: joe on Sun Feb 8 21:26:56 2009. |
crajkumar_be wrote: |
characters ellam kan munnadiye nikkaranga ![]() i think this is one of the boldest, gutsiest and most honest films ever made in tamil in the lines of andha naal, aval appadithaan, guna, mahanadhi and hey ram. in fact it may not be the best among them (far from it) but i think its the most courageous. |
From: joe on Sun Feb 8 22:07:26 2009. |
bimmer wrote: | ||||
Ippidi usupethiye odamba ranakalam akarangale... ![]() ![]() ![]() |
From: bimmer on Sun Feb 8 22:35:25 2009. |
joe wrote: | ||||||
Summa vasanam pesuRathukku pathila ennoda keLvi-kku straight-a pathil sollunga paarpom ![]() |
From: joe on Sun Feb 8 22:45:40 2009. |
From: sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar on Sun Feb 8 23:06:07 2009. |
From: joe on Sun Feb 8 23:09:25 2009. |
From: sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar on Sun Feb 8 23:13:29 2009. |
From: joe on Sun Feb 8 23:15:06 2009. |
sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar wrote: |
naan padame paarkavillai, athu en karuthum illai ![]() |
From: bimmer on Sun Feb 8 23:22:36 2009. |
joe wrote: |
Bimmer,
IMO ,I can understand why 3 years has been taken ,well justified with extrodinary visuals ,which are almost unimaginable by most of the Tamil directors. I don't want to go into details on changing cast and i don't mind also ..As a fan ,I damn care about it ,i care about only the final product. As you said ,let us agree to disagree..For me ,Bala is someone extradionary. |
From: irir123 on Sun Feb 8 23:32:27 2009. |
From: kamalsurya on Mon Feb 9 0:15:46 2009. |
Quote: |
Just two simple requests: make sure you release an unedited version of NK on DVD and next time around, ensure that your efforts and vision don’t get compromised in the hands of the censor board. |
From: villan007 on Mon Feb 9 1:04:58 2009. |
From: joe on Mon Feb 9 1:21:11 2009. |
From: viraajan on Mon Feb 9 1:21:55 2009. |
From: Nerd on Mon Feb 9 1:25:46 2009. |
directhit wrote: |
adhukku munnadi Arya wud say something to her in sanskrit - not sure what, enakku adhoda kadaisi vaartha edho tamizh ketta vartha madhiri kettuchu ![]() |
From: joe on Mon Feb 9 1:28:03 2009. |
From: Roshan on Mon Feb 9 1:45:53 2009. |
From: Roshan on Mon Feb 9 1:48:03 2009. |
From: crajkumar_be on Mon Feb 9 3:15:48 2009. |
Nerd wrote: | ||
naan inga dhAn dochu theater, onniyumE puriyalai-nu nenachEn.. Arya vaaice was not clear in many places.. akkam pakkathula kEttu purinjikittEn, but that dialogue eluded us. suyambu - self formed. As in, he knows everything, he does not need any guidance esra.. |
From: MrJudge on Mon Feb 9 3:15:54 2009. |
From: joe on Mon Feb 9 3:21:15 2009. |
crajkumar_be wrote: | ||||
He refers to 'thoomai'(?) and asks her 'thoomai na enna nu theriyuma?' |
From: MrJudge on Mon Feb 9 3:24:41 2009. |
From: equanimus on Mon Feb 9 3:27:14 2009. |
crajkumar_be wrote: | ||||
He refers to 'thoomai'(?) and asks her 'thoomai na enna nu theriyuma?' |
From: crajkumar_be on Mon Feb 9 3:28:50 2009. |
joe wrote: | ||||||
எனக்கும் 'சுயம்பு'-ன்னு கேட்டதாகத் தான் ஞாபகம். btw, தொம்மை -ன்னா கையாலாகாதவன் -ன்னு அர்த்தம் ![]() |
From: crajkumar_be on Mon Feb 9 3:35:32 2009. |
equanimus wrote: | ||||||
'thUmai' means menstrual blood. [Not sure if one can mention such things here in this forum, but arththam theriyAmal kuRippiduvadhaRku, viLakki viduvadhu mEl enRu thOnRiyadhu.] |
From: MrJudge on Mon Feb 9 3:36:32 2009. |
equanimus wrote: |
'thUmai' means menstrual blood. [Not sure if one can mention such things here in this forum, but arththam theriyAmal kuRippiduvadhaRku, viLakki viduvadhu mEl enRu thOnRiyadhu.] |
From: crajkumar_be on Mon Feb 9 3:39:11 2009. |
From: viraajan on Mon Feb 9 3:43:55 2009. |
From: crajkumar_be on Mon Feb 9 3:44:45 2009. |
viraajan wrote: |
I heard the dialogue very clearly. But dint know the meaning ![]() But the moment Arya says it, her expression changes and she leaves immediately ![]() |
From: viraajan on Mon Feb 9 3:46:05 2009. |
crajkumar_be wrote: | ||
Same here but what exactly did you hear? |
From: crajkumar_be on Mon Feb 9 3:47:14 2009. |
From: viraajan on Mon Feb 9 3:48:13 2009. |
From: joe on Mon Feb 9 3:50:39 2009. |
crajkumar_be wrote: |
Thank Heavens. For a moment or three i was afraid my hearing was deserting me at this ripe young age! ![]() |
Quote: |
Still, i don't understand the exact meaning of the conversation |
From: directhit on Mon Feb 9 3:53:23 2009. |
crajkumar_be wrote: | ||||
He refers to 'thoomai'(?) and asks her 'thoomai na enna nu theriyuma?' |
From: rajasaranam on Mon Feb 9 3:54:36 2009. |
MrJudge wrote: |
enna innum 'rajasaranam'-a kANOm? |
From: equanimus on Mon Feb 9 4:01:01 2009. |
From: joe on Mon Feb 9 4:04:22 2009. |
equanimus wrote: |
Bala and others,
Yes he does say that. That's why I clarified the meaning. He says a two-liner (presumably from a siththar pAdal given Bala's interest in siththar pAdalgaL) which essentially means it's after all the mother's menstrual blood that becomes two hands, two legs and two ears. Ok, I googled for the exact verses and got it. “ஐயிரண்டு திங்களாய் அடங்கிநின்ற தூமையே கையிரண்டு காலிரண்டு காதிரண்டு மானதே!’’ This is what Rudhran says in the film. The versions I found online differ only slightly ("தூமைதான்") from this. |
From: joe on Mon Feb 9 4:05:21 2009. |
From: rajasaranam on Mon Feb 9 4:07:21 2009. |
From: rajasaranam on Mon Feb 9 4:08:22 2009. |
From: crajkumar_be on Mon Feb 9 4:10:03 2009. |
From: crajkumar_be on Mon Feb 9 4:15:52 2009. |
From: viraajan on Mon Feb 9 4:18:04 2009. |
equanimus wrote: |
Bala and others,
Yes he does say that. That's why I clarified the meaning. He says a two-liner (presumably from a siththar pAdal given Bala's interest in siththar pAdalgaL) which essentially means it's after all the mother's menstrual blood that becomes two hands, two legs and two ears. Ok, I googled for the exact verses and got it. “ஐயிரண்டு திங்களாய் அடங்கிநின்ற தூமையே கையிரண்டு காலிரண்டு காதிரண்டு மானதே!’’ This is what Rudhran says in the film. The versions I found online differ only slightly ("தூமைதான்") from this. |
From: viraajan on Mon Feb 9 4:19:00 2009. |
crajkumar_be wrote: |
The performance of the actor who played Thandavam, was stunning |
From: equanimus on Mon Feb 9 4:19:22 2009. |
rajasaranam wrote: |
'aayirandu thingalaay ulliruntha thumaiyae
kairandu kaalirandu kannirandu aanathen' |
From: crajkumar_be on Mon Feb 9 4:21:50 2009. |
From: steveaustin on Mon Feb 9 4:22:31 2009. |
rajasaranam wrote: |
படம் பார்த்த பின் ஒரு நன்பர் கேட்டார் நல்லா இருக்கா நல்லா இல்லையா என்று...படத்தில் ஒரு காட்சியில் 'ருத்ரன்' கோவில் தீபத்தில் தன் கஞ்சா குழலை பற்ற வைப்பார், அப்பொழுது ஒரு சக சாமியார் கேட்பார் 'சாமி நெருப்ப அசுத்த படுத்திட்டீங்களே' என்று. ருத்ரன் திருப்பி கேட்பான் ' நெருப்புக்கு என்னடா சுத்தம் அசுத்தம்' என்று. பாலாவின் 'னான் கடவுள்' படம் நெருப்பு போல்! |
From: joe on Mon Feb 9 4:22:51 2009. |
crajkumar_be wrote: |
The performance of the actor who played Thandavam, was stunning |
From: equanimus on Mon Feb 9 4:29:37 2009. |
crajkumar_be wrote: |
Eq,
Second time already paathutteengala? |
joe wrote: | ||
In Audio launch function Vikram mentioned a name and said "அவர் இங்கே கீழே உக்கார்ந்திருக்கார் .பிதாமகன் -ல நான் அவரை அடிக்குற மாதிரி சீன்-ல நாம இவ்வளவு பவர்புள்-ளாவா அடிச்சோம் -ன்னு நினைக்குற மாதிரி போய் விழுவார் .அவ்வளவு நடிப்பு .அவருக்கு இந்த படத்தில் பாலா முக்கியமான கேரக்டர் கொடுத்திருக்கார்" did he mentioned about this guy? ![]() |
From: rajasaranam on Mon Feb 9 4:42:19 2009. |
equanimus wrote: | ||
A small correction: He says "kaNNiraNdu" and not "kAdhiraNdu." Actually I was very sure about it myself, but I finally deferred to the version I found online. But now that Rajasaranam has also quoted it, I'm sure I heard it right. Here are the two related pages. (The latter page does say it is "kaNNiraNdu.")
Rajasaranam, It is 'AnadhE' and not 'AnadhEn?' It's more like a matter-of-fact statement about what human life is after all. |
From: raja_fan on Mon Feb 9 5:38:26 2009. |
From: Kalyasi on Mon Feb 9 5:50:48 2009. |
rajasaranam wrote: | ||||
konjam confessana thaan irukku, let me check in the print version ... read it more than 10 years back. 'AnadhE' seems more meaningful |
From: Kalyasi on Mon Feb 9 5:56:08 2009. |
From: crajkumar_be on Mon Feb 9 5:57:50 2009. |
Kalyasi wrote: |
Bala anna on friday @ PVR the crowd was decent!! |
From: Kalyasi on Mon Feb 9 5:58:30 2009. |
From: Kalyasi on Mon Feb 9 6:02:00 2009. |
crajkumar_be wrote: | ||
PVR la full yesterday 4PM show, i went to Inox, Jayanagar. All i heard as WOM was negative ![]() |
From: joe on Mon Feb 9 6:06:44 2009. |
Kalyasi wrote: |
itha thaan ukkanthu 3 varusama eduthaana |
From: crajkumar_be on Mon Feb 9 6:08:06 2009. |
joe wrote: | ||
Padathula graphics-lam ethiripaarthiruppanunga pola ![]() |
From: joe on Mon Feb 9 6:16:18 2009. |
crajkumar_be wrote: | ||||
Actually 6-pack, 8-pack edhirpaarthirundhaalum indha padathula irukku |
From: rajasaranam on Mon Feb 9 7:32:55 2009. |
Quote: |
தவறாக புரிந்து கொள்ளப்படும் சினிமா, சரியாக புரிந்து கொள்ளப்படும் வாழ்க்கையை விட அபாயகரமானது! ருத்ரனின் ஆன்மிக கருத்துக்ககளை பாலாவின் மீது ஏற்றி பார்க்கும் சினிமா பார்வையை எங்கிருந்து பயின்றிர்கள் என்பதை தெளிவுபடுத்தவும். பாலா ஒரு ‘filmmaker’ அவ்வளவே. அவர் எடுக்கும் சினிமாக்கள் சாதாரணர்களை விடுத்து வேற்று மனிதர்களை பற்றி பேசுவது. வாழ்க்கையிலிருந்தே தன் கதை மாந்தர்களை தேர்ந்தெடுத்தாலும் அவர் அதில் அதிதங்களை நோக்கி நகர்பவர். இந்த படம் பேசுவது ‘வாழ்க்கை அவலமாய் இருக்கும் ஒருத்திக்கும், வாழ்க்கையை தனகங்காரத்தால் வென்றெடுத்த ஒருவனுக்கும்’ நேரும் பரிமாற்றம் பற்றி. சரி அப்படியே ஆன்மிக புரிதலோடுதான் படம் எடுக்க வேண்டும் என்றால் எந்த புரிதலோடு துவங்குவது? த்வைதம், அத்வைதம், சாங்கியம், மிமாம்சம், சமணம், இஸ்லாம், பௌத்தம், கிருத்துவம்… என நீ..ளு..ம்.. இந்த பட்டியலிலிருந்து எதை தேர்வு செய்வது? மற்றெல்லா ஆன்மிக புரிதலுமே ஒன்றை மட்டும் புரிந்தவர்க்கு தவறு தானே? ஆப்படியாயின் ருத்ரனின் (அல்லது பாலாவின் - உங்கள் பார்வையில்) புரிதல் தவறு என்று சொல்ல நமக்கு என்ன அருகதை இருக்கிறது? இந்த படம் என்ன வகையான மன பிம்பங்களை நம்முள்ளே தோற்றுவிக்கிறது அல்லது கட்டமைக்கிறது என்பதை மட்டும் பார்க்க வேண்டும். என்னுடன் வந்து நண்பன் சொன்னான் ‘ருத்ரன் அந்த வில்லன்களை அடித்து துவம்சம் செய்யும் காட்சியை இன்னும் பிரமாதமாக எடுத்து இருக்கலாம் என்று’. நான் கேட்டேன் ‘எப்படி ‘பாட்சா’ ‘சாமி’ போன்ற படங்களில் கொஞ்சம் கொஞ்சமா உருவேத்திகிட்டே போயி நச்சுன்னு அடிப்பாங்களே அந்த மாதிரியா’ என்று? ‘Exactly’ என்றான் அவன். ‘As a film maker Bala has succeeded in alienating yourself from ‘Rudran’, as alienated ‘Rudran’ is from the mainstream society’ . பிதாமகன்’இல் இருந்த சித்தனுடனான அந்த ‘emotional connection’ஐ அறுத்து எறிந்து அவர் அடுத்த கட்டத்துக்கு நகர்ந்து விட்டார் என்றேன். அடுத்து என்ன செய்வார் பாலா என பொறுத்திருந்து பார்க்க வேண்டும். மற்றபடி நமக்கெல்லாம் ‘பேரரசு’ படம்தாங்க பெஸ்ட்டு. குத்து பாட்டு, தொப்புள் டான்ஸ், தொடை தட்றது, பன்ச் டயலாக்குன்னு களை கட்டும்ள்ள. ‘நான் கடவுள்’ காமிக்கிற உலகத்த விட்டு, ‘திருவண்ணாமலை’ ஆக்ஷன் ஜோதில கலந்து கூத்தடிக்கலாம் வாங்க. |
From: joe on Mon Feb 9 8:06:52 2009. |
From: Prabhu Ram on Mon Feb 9 8:10:30 2009. |
From: Vivasaayi on Mon Feb 9 8:22:46 2009. |
crajkumar_be wrote: | ||||
He refers to 'thoomai'(?) and asks her 'thoomai na enna nu theriyuma?' |
From: rajasaranam on Mon Feb 9 10:00:41 2009. |
From: directhit on Mon Feb 9 10:03:24 2009. |
rajasaranam wrote: |
joe,
Ippadiye Vimarsanam senjukitte etho oru link'la amsavalliya, Thaandavan yaen Rape pannalannu kaetta oru blog'la seruppadi koduthuttu vanthen...entha blognnu nyabagam illai. Engaiyavathu paarththa sollunga ![]() |
From: joe on Mon Feb 9 10:07:09 2009. |
rajasaranam wrote: |
joe,
Ippadiye Vimarsanam senjukitte etho oru link'la amsavalliya, Thaandavan yaen Rape pannalannu kaetta oru blog'la seruppadi koduthuttu vanthen...entha blognnu nyabagam illai. Engaiyavathu paarththa sollunga ![]() |
From: directhit on Mon Feb 9 10:09:17 2009. |
From: irir123 on Mon Feb 9 10:16:10 2009. |
From: Nerd on Mon Feb 9 10:17:43 2009. |
crajkumar_be wrote: |
All i heard as WOM was negative |
From: Srimannarayanan on Mon Feb 9 10:36:31 2009. |
From: joe on Mon Feb 9 10:40:57 2009. |
From: crajkumar_be on Mon Feb 9 10:42:12 2009. |
irir123 wrote: |
I have a strong suspicion that besides the inclusion of "Bitchai pathiram" IR also had a big role in the kind of sanskrit verses that were used throughout the movie (given IR's deep knowledge of Sanskrit I wudnt be surprised if tat were the case) |
From: Nerd on Mon Feb 9 10:42:20 2009. |
Srimannarayanan wrote: |
Nerd
Where did you see the movie ? Trichy or Texas? |
From: crajkumar_be on Mon Feb 9 10:46:57 2009. |
rajasaranam wrote: |
joe,
Ippadiye Vimarsanam senjukitte etho oru link'la amsavalliya, Thaandavan yaen Rape pannalannu kaetta oru blog'la seruppadi koduthuttu vanthen...entha blognnu nyabagam illai. Engaiyavathu paarththa sollunga ![]() |
From: directhit on Mon Feb 9 10:47:13 2009. |
From: crajkumar_be on Mon Feb 9 10:48:28 2009. |
From: joe on Mon Feb 9 10:50:01 2009. |
crajkumar_be wrote: | ||
enakkum indha doubt. Who was/were the main influence/contributors with the Sanskrit verses/philisophy(?) in the film. I'm not familiar with Jeyamohan's writings. |
From: Nerd on Mon Feb 9 10:51:39 2009. |
From: irir123 on Mon Feb 9 11:21:28 2009. |
From: bimmer on Mon Feb 9 11:22:34 2009. |
MrJudge wrote: |
bimmer;
There are lot of flaws in the movie and there are lot of questions we can ask about the character Rudran. Agreed, but the main plot is about the beggars, I don't think I could find a flaw in their part, could you? let me know. |
From: vatsa400 on Mon Feb 9 12:00:27 2009. |
From: jaiganes on Mon Feb 9 12:51:11 2009. |
From: MrJudge on Mon Feb 9 14:06:28 2009. |
directhit wrote: |
I guess villain's name is thandavaN ![]() |
From: MrJudge on Mon Feb 9 14:08:48 2009. |
From: Avadi to America on Mon Feb 9 14:33:22 2009. |
From: Avadi to America on Mon Feb 9 14:41:51 2009. |
From: sarna_blr on Mon Feb 9 15:00:23 2009. |
From: sarna_blr on Mon Feb 9 15:12:44 2009. |
From: crajkumar_be on Mon Feb 9 15:15:11 2009. |
sarna_blr wrote: |
atlast watched telugu dubbed version ![]() I think no other director can do such a spine-tingling movie ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
From: littlemaster1982 on Mon Feb 9 15:17:34 2009. |
From: sarna_blr on Mon Feb 9 15:19:10 2009. |
littlemaster1982 wrote: |
Most disturbing film I've ever seen. |
From: sarna_blr on Mon Feb 9 15:23:37 2009. |
From: littlemaster1982 on Mon Feb 9 15:29:08 2009. |
sarna_blr wrote: |
wts the meaning of U/A |
From: littlemaster1982 on Mon Feb 9 15:31:49 2009. |
equanimus wrote: | ||
The greatest moment in the film IMO. kaNNula thaNNi vandhuduchchu. (There were a few other scenes too when my eyes welled up.) |
From: littlemaster1982 on Mon Feb 9 16:04:05 2009. |
crajkumar_be wrote: | ||
PVR la full yesterday 4PM show, i went to Inox, Jayanagar. All i heard as WOM was negative ![]() |
From: crajkumar_be on Mon Feb 9 16:06:57 2009. |
littlemaster1982 wrote: |
WOM is not encouraging. My friend advised me not to watch the film. Tonight's show had just around 30 people ![]() |
From: littlemaster1982 on Mon Feb 9 16:11:37 2009. |
crajkumar_be wrote: | ||||||||
No, his mom tells his sister that he is a svayambu but im referring to the conversation between Arya and his mother. P.S: Adhukulla enakku kaadhu javvu vittukucha? ![]() |
Quote: |
தாய்மையையையுமே இப்படி மாறுபட்ட கோணத்தில் பொருத்திப்பார்த்து சுயம்புவாகிய கதாபாத்திர அமைப்பு சொல்லிக்காட்டும் சித்தர் பாடல் எதுவென்று தேடிப்பார்க்கவேண்டும். வசனத்தை இன்னொரு முறை கேட்டு அந்தப் பாடல் வரிகளை இணையத்தில் தேடிப்பார்க்கவேண்டும், கிடைக்கவில்லையென்றால் தெரிந்தோர்களிடம் விசாரித்துப் பார்க்கவேண்டும். தமிழ்த்திரையில் தாயை நிறுத்திவைத்து இப்படிக் கேள்வி கேட்ட கதாபாத்திரம் எதுவுமே கிடையாது. 'தந்தை தவறு செய்தான் தாயும் இடங்கொடுத்தாள் வந்து பிறந்துவிட்டோம் வெறும் பந்தம் வளர்த்து விட்டோம்' என்று தத்துவம் பாடித்தான் கண்ணதாசனும் பிறப்பை எள்ளி நகையாடியிருக்கிறார். எந்த ஒரு மோசமான பாத்திரப்படைப்பாக இருந்தாலும் அந்தக் கதாபாத்திரம் தமிழ்த் திரையில் சந்திக்கும் தாய்மையின் உயரங்கள் அதிகம், தமிழ்த் திரை ரசிகனுக்கும் தாய்மைக்குமான மனவெழுச்சித் தொடர்பும் அதிகம். இந்த வசனத்தை தமிழ்த் திரையும் பெண்ணியவாதிகளும் எப்படி அணுகப் போகிறார்களென்பதைப் பொறுத்திருந்து பார்க்கவேண்டும். படம் வெற்றி பெற்றால், இந்த வசனத்தை எதிர்த்து பெண்ணியவாதிகள் தங்கள் கருத்தை முன்வைக்க வாய்ப்புகள் இருக்கின்றன. படம் தோல்வியுற்றால், அது பேசப்படாமலே போய்விடும். வாலியின் புதுக்கவிதைப் புத்தகத்திலிருந்து சில வரிகளை வசனங்களில் கையாண்டிருப்பதை பாலசந்தர் அவர்கள் தனது அக்னி சாட்சி படத்தில் பெயர் காட்டும்போது குறிப்பிட்டிருப்பார். பாலா + ஜெயமோகன் இருவரும் படத்தில் கையாளப்படும் சித்தர் பாடல் வரிகளை எங்கிருந்து எடுத்தாண்டிருக்கிறார்கள் என்பதை பெயர் காட்டும்போதே குறிப்பிட்டார்களென்றால் நன்றாக இருக்கும்போலத் தோன்றுகிறது. தாய்மை குறித்து மாறுபட்ட கருத்தை முன்வைக்கும் சித்தர் பாடல் யாருடைய வரிகள் என்பதற்காக (சித்தர் பாடல்களில் போதிய வாசிப்பனுபவம் இல்லாமல்) இப்பொழுது மண்டையை உடைத்துக்கொள்ளவேண்டிய அவசியம் இருந்திருக்காது. படத்தில் சொல்லப்படும் சித்தர் பாடலின் முன்பின் வரிகளைப் படித்துப் பார்த்து இது உண்மையிலேயே தாய்மையின் மீது மாறுபட்ட பார்வையை வைக்கிறதா அல்லது பரவலாக சொல்லப்படும் பாரதி பாடலான 'மெல்லத் தமிழினி சாகும்' வகையறாவைச் சேர்ந்த தேவையானதை மட்டுமே வெட்டி ஒட்டும் பணியா என்பதை தெளிவாக்கிக்கொள்ளவேண்டிய கட்டாயத்திற்கு நம்மை ஆட்படுத்தியிருக்கிறார் வசனம் எழுதியிருக்கும் ஜெயமோகன் அய்யா அவர்கள். சல்தாஹை. இன்னொரு முறை படத்தைப் பார்த்தால் அந்தப் பாடல் வரிகளை எழுதிவைத்து பின்னர் தேடிப் பார்க்கவேண்டும். இந்த வசனத்திற்குப் பின்னரே ருத்ரனின் தாய் அவனைத் தனது பாசக்கட்டிலிருந்து நீக்குகின்றாள். |
From: littlemaster1982 on Mon Feb 9 16:12:43 2009. |
crajkumar_be wrote: | ||
Vaazhga Jananayagam varuga Marudhanayagam ![]() PVR-a? |
From: directhit on Mon Feb 9 21:42:01 2009. |
MrJudge wrote: | ||
No, it is thAndavam only. While he was shown for the first time and he gets out of the white colour sumo, the windsheild has a sticker saying 'thandavam & co' in Tamil. |
From: littlemaster1982 on Mon Feb 9 22:22:02 2009. |
directhit wrote: | ||||
![]() ![]() LM - links in prev pages by equa and expln's by RS had some info on that. |
From: directhit on Mon Feb 9 22:39:06 2009. |
From: littlemaster1982 on Mon Feb 9 22:52:04 2009. |
From: irir123 on Mon Feb 9 23:02:49 2009. |
From: joe on Mon Feb 9 23:45:02 2009. |
From: PoonaiKutty on Mon Feb 9 23:45:14 2009. |
littlemaster1982 wrote: | ||||||
Anoop, Read Rs' explanation. But I'm not clear about it yet. And yeah, his name is 'Thaandavan' only. I'm sure. |
From: viraajan on Mon Feb 9 23:54:39 2009. |
PoonaiKutty wrote: |
Andha Aalayum andha madhiri madathayum pathappuram oonu mudivu pannittein .. inimel endha pichakaranukkum kaasu podaradhunnu ... naan oruthi podathadhunaala paavam anikku indha Thandavan madhiri aalunga kitta enna madhiri odha vaanguvaangalo ![]() ![]() |
From: directhit on Mon Feb 9 23:56:24 2009. |
From: joe on Tue Feb 10 0:02:03 2009. |
From: joe on Tue Feb 10 0:39:08 2009. |
From: Nerd on Tue Feb 10 0:42:16 2009. |
irir123 wrote: |
have anyone seen PASI (featuring yesteryear Shobha) was it as painfully visualised as NK ? |
From: joe on Tue Feb 10 0:45:56 2009. |
Nerd wrote: |
I still can't get over the film and its been 48 hours. |
From: Kalyasi on Tue Feb 10 0:52:44 2009. |
joe wrote: | ||
Same here ![]() |
From: rajasaranam on Tue Feb 10 1:04:33 2009. |
MrJudge wrote: |
rajasaranam;
Thanks for your points. ![]() athukkuLla 3 thadavai pAththAchchA? |
From: jaiganes on Tue Feb 10 1:11:16 2009. |
From: PoonaiKutty on Tue Feb 10 1:11:38 2009. |
directhit wrote: |
ippadiyellam podadheenga - appuram Bala padam pichai poduvadhai thoondi vidugiradhu nu edhanaa oru loosu case podum!! |
From: PoonaiKutty on Tue Feb 10 1:16:43 2009. |
rajasaranam wrote: | ||
he he he... anegama innaikku 4th time going ![]() |
From: joe on Tue Feb 10 1:23:13 2009. |
PoonaiKutty wrote: |
cos in these s'pore theatres one can see all the ppl's reaction in the row infront of u ![]() |
From: directhit on Tue Feb 10 1:25:30 2009. |
Nerd wrote: |
Watching pitchai pAthiram song on youtube. The little one whistling at a girl was a masterstroke. I remember laughing my guts out - I badly needed to do that, the last few scenes before that were extremely painful. And them measuring the coins on a scale towards the end of the song was shocking to say the least. I still can't get over the film and its been 48 hours. |
From: rajasaranam on Tue Feb 10 1:35:28 2009. |
From: Prabhu Ram on Tue Feb 10 1:37:38 2009. |
From: directhit on Tue Feb 10 1:37:50 2009. |
From: rajasaranam on Tue Feb 10 1:43:11 2009. |
jaiganes wrote: |
pavee rajasaranam.
nadaththu. un kaattil adai mazhai dhaan po. innum dharisanam kidaikkaadha ennai pondrorukku, kadavul enna karunai kaatuvaaro theriyalai. |
From: joe on Tue Feb 10 1:43:33 2009. |
From: directhit on Tue Feb 10 1:45:45 2009. |
From: joe on Tue Feb 10 1:47:21 2009. |
directhit wrote: |
joe - UT blocked at aapees. vootukku poi parkaren. which song is this? i saw pitchaipathiram the two days back - it was same |
From: directhit on Tue Feb 10 1:51:55 2009. |
From: jaiganes on Tue Feb 10 1:57:01 2009. |
joe wrote: | ||
Pichai paathiram song thaan. Later part varra sila visuals naan theatre-la paakkatha maathiri irukku ![]() |
From: rajasaranam on Tue Feb 10 1:59:58 2009. |
Prabhu Ram wrote: |
paramasivam
akilAndam jeevanandam panchAtcharam - doesn't get more noun than that btw thaNdavan, thANdavam reNdum noun dhaan. naan innum padam pArkkalai...podhuvA solrEn |
From: joe on Tue Feb 10 2:18:13 2009. |
rajasaranam wrote: |
BTW how does Thandavam becomes a noun? isn't it an action! |
From: SoftSword on Tue Feb 10 2:46:23 2009. |
joe wrote: | ||
It is a name of an action..'kopam' is a noun ,'kopi' is verb. |
From: Prabhu Ram on Tue Feb 10 2:46:25 2009. |
From: Prabhu Ram on Tue Feb 10 2:48:34 2009. |
From: equanimus on Tue Feb 10 2:50:11 2009. |
From: Prabhu Ram on Tue Feb 10 2:54:18 2009. |
From: joe on Tue Feb 10 2:57:14 2009. |
Prabhu Ram wrote: |
கோபி என்பதும் பெயர்ச்சொல் தான். வினைச்சொல் அல்ல. கோபித்தல் தான் வினை - pardon the pun.
|
From: rajasaranam on Tue Feb 10 3:00:57 2009. |
Prabhu Ram wrote: |
கோபி என்பதும் பெயர்ச்சொல் தான். வினைச்சொல் அல்ல. கோபித்தல் தான் வினை - pardon the pun.
Anyway, I got what RS is saying. |
From: joe on Tue Feb 10 3:01:14 2009. |
Prabhu Ram wrote: |
கோபித்தல் தான் வினை |
From: Prabhu Ram on Tue Feb 10 3:01:46 2009. |
From: rajasaranam on Tue Feb 10 3:01:52 2009. |
joe wrote: | ||
பெயர்ச்சொல் 'கோபி' -யும் 'கோபப்படு' எனும் அர்த்ததில் வரும் வினைச்சொல் 'கோபி' -யும் ஒன்றல்ல என நினைக்கிறேன். 'கோபி' என பெயர் சூட்டுவது கோபியர்களின் கண்ணன் நினைவாக அன்றி 'கோபப்படு' என்னும் அர்த்ததில் அல்ல என நினைக்கிறேன். |
From: joe on Tue Feb 10 3:03:46 2009. |
Prabhu Ram wrote: |
விட்டால் ஆலூ கோபி, கோபி பாலைவனம் என்று இறங்கிவிடுவோம் போல இருக்கே ![]() |
From: rajasaranam on Tue Feb 10 3:04:46 2009. |
From: joe on Tue Feb 10 3:05:51 2009. |
From: littlemaster1982 on Tue Feb 10 3:06:29 2009. |
Prabhu Ram wrote: |
Okay, let me steer it back to NK. Was Stun Siva missed ? How was Super SubbarAyan's work ?
(naanga evvaLO periyA social matter pEsittu irukkOm, enna kElvi kEkkure ?) |
From: joe on Tue Feb 10 3:07:51 2009. |
rajasaranam wrote: |
Joe,Vinaiyum-ethirvinaiyum inga post panna MOD's ellam kOchupaanga ![]() |
From: PoonaiKutty on Tue Feb 10 3:15:36 2009. |
From: MrJudge on Tue Feb 10 3:19:28 2009. |
joe wrote: |
'தாண்டவம்' .'தாண்டவன்' இரண்டுமே பெயர்ச்சொல்லாக இருக்கலாம் ..'சிவன்' ,'சிவம்' இரண்டும் பெயர்ச்சொல்லாக இருக்கலாம் என்பது போல ..எனக்கூறி இந்த வழக்காடு மன்றத்தை நிறைவு செய்கிறேன். ![]() |
From: equanimus on Tue Feb 10 3:20:31 2009. |
Prabhu Ram wrote: |
eq, it is about concept vs. description. Whether both can be names. |
Prabhu Ram wrote: |
btw the etymology of subrahmanian is loaded with vettukkuththu potential. |
Prabhu Ram wrote: |
Ok |