The song Jab dil jale aana... from the movie Chitchor is mentioned under Kalyan and Yaman at different sites. But in the movie itself, Amol Palekar says it is in Malkauns!!!
So which is correct??
Printable View
The song Jab dil jale aana... from the movie Chitchor is mentioned under Kalyan and Yaman at different sites. But in the movie itself, Amol Palekar says it is in Malkauns!!!
So which is correct??
Rajesh: It is kalyaNi(carnatic)
Its quivalent is yaman(hindustani).
But..
http://www.geocities.com/Vienna/Strasse/1364/songs.html says kalyaN.
http://www.geocities.com/ResearchTriangle/Facility/4118/rmic/rmic.1992.03.04.html
says kalyaN(hindustani) is kalyaNi(carnatic).
what is the raga of the song 'Vaishnava Janato' as sung in the movie Hey Ram?
and 'Radha Kaise Na Jale' from Lagaan? Is it Anandha Bhairavi?
Saketh@Atlanta
IMO
'Vaishnava Janato' in Hey Ram is Yaman(Kalyani)
'Radha Kaise Na Jale' is Bhimpalas(Abheri)
Anyone watched Monsoon wedding, i need to find out about a song.
i wanna know where will i find the song humain tumse pyaar kitna from film kudarat.
Megh & Megh Malhar
Here are two raaga lists that list them separately.
http://www.musicalnirvana.com/raga/h...agas.html#Raga List
http://www.ee.iitb.ernet.in/www/hraga.html
Megh(Hindusthani) is madhyamavathi
Does anyone know what is the carnatic equivalent of Megh Malhar? Any compisitions in it?
http://www.sawf.org/newedit/edit10302000/musicarts.asp
This "Saarang family" article has one sample that differentiates Megh and mahdmath Saarang, clearly showing that megh is madhyamavathi.
http://www.geocities.com/promiserani2/hcragatable.html
this site lists Madhyamavathy===madhmathsarang.
madhmadh Sarang = megh in swarams.
The sample(in Hindhi) discusses the difference. From swarams point of view, both are madhyamavathi.
First he sings madhmath Sarang(more of ma->ri prayogam), second Megh(all swarams independent).
ghanana ghanana - Lagaan is Megh Malhar.
(derived from kaapi).
Riaz: humain tumse pyaar kitna from film kudarat is in Bharavi.
(Carnatic equivalent - Sindhu Bhairavi).