Vedic Siva enters Tamil- How?
Bismala wrote
////When you say Hart did not say and I quote Prof.Hart you run away, or say that is his opinion.//
Prof Hart can say whatever he wants and so can the others. What we can accept we do. What we cannot, well sorry. There is no such thing as "He is a prof, so he must be believed". An Islamic prof said that Islam is the truth. So according to you, since he is a prof, you would readily become a Muslim and give up your research on anthaNar, iyer, vEtham etc. I learnt from other professors and not Hart. Hart is not my prof. Sorry.
// Prof.Burrows was the incharge of Lexicon project i.e., a Head of Many Linguistic Scholars and also consult many before publishing.//
He has done what he could. There were also professors in Nalanda University. But they could not produce the atom bomb.
They did not know it, just like your grand dad did not know what you know and vice-versa.//
- I do not understand a single point of what you are Conveying- but making clear that your Position is “I am not amenable to any Scientific Views, My Views could be wrong, My mind is closed, but keep giving more evidences, so that I would use all my tricks to misinterpret it and make world feel that Tamils are Hypocrites””
Friend Where is Sivalingam worship or The Name “Siva” in Sangam Tamil Lit. Silapathikarm tells us about Triupathi where Lord Vishnu is worshiped in Standing Posture (.¿¢ýÈ ¾¢Õ째¡Äõ) and SriRangam as Lying Posture(¸¢¼ó¾¡ý …ÂÉõ- ÀûÇ¢¦¸¡ñ¼ ¾¢Õ§¸¡Äõ), ThiruMurugatrupadai gives the various Murugan Temples, but no Lingam is mentioned.
I look History only from the Evidences and not Blind Superstition and I understand your Arrogance of Intelligence which is without any base, and the root of Siva as per International Scholars-for all to see-from
Colin Renfrew, Professor of Archaeology at Cambridge, in his famous work, Archaeology and Language: The Puzzle of Indo-European Origins, Cambridge University Press, 1988,
”The words Shiva and Shambhu are not derived from the Tamil words civa (to redden, to become angry) and cembu (copper, the red metal), but from the Sanskrit roots si (therefore meaning “auspicious, gracious, benevolent, helpful, kind”) and sam (therefore meaning “being or existing for happiness or welfare, granting or causing happiness, benevolent, helpful, kind”), and the words are used in this sense only, right from their very first occurrence.”
Maraimalai Aadigal’s said- Óì¸ñ½ý, º¨¼Âý, Á½¢Á¢¼üÈ¡ý ±ýÛõ ¾Á¢ú áü ¦ÀÂ÷¸Ç¡Öõ "¯Õò¾¢Ãý", "º¢Åý" ±ýÛõ żëü ¦ÀÂ÷¸Ç¡Öõ ÌÈ¢ôÀ¢¼ôÀð¼ ÓØÓ¾ü ¸¼×û º¢Å¦ÀÕÁ¡§É ±ýÀÐ «í¨¸Âí¸É¢ §À¡ø ¿ýÌ Å¢Ç¹¸¡ ¿¢ü̦Áý¸. -Àì 129 ¾Á¢Æ÷ Á¾õ. Maraimalaiar agrees here Siva from Sanskrit source.
The word Kerala, comes from Sanskrit – Keralam, rather in full- for Coconut- it is Nariyal Keralam- and the earliest written source- Asoka’s inscriptions refer them as Keralo Putras.
Gouravas are referred as by that name or equivalent in Sangam to Manimekhalai and your meaningless breaking to Guru does not help, please do not spoil Tamil.
The dating of Tamil usage and Sanskrit Usage and the Literatire are “Well Established”, and international Linguists agree that Sanskrit is the Eldest Sister (for Many Mother) to Latin and Greek and Germanic Groups and Tamil uses One Third of words burrowed from Sanskrit and half that from its Branches Prakrit and Pali. Now picking this Burrowed words and showing its usage in world languages for Tamil does not make Any Good to Tamil.
Please allow me to quote from Sangam to Bakthi Movement to show Saivite Tamil Lit.
By Attacking Personally You have not allowed anybody to give the Historic evolcution of Saivam in Tamilnadu.
Devapriya