|
The Hub : Tamil Films Archived | Hello Guest, Login to post. |
WHICH DIRECTOR'S COMBO WITH KAMAL HAASAN U CHERISH MOST?
Topic started by Alien on Sun Feb 19 22:12:18 2006. |
Poll |
From: ajithfederer on Sun Feb 19 22:13:38 2006. |
From: Alien on Sun Feb 19 22:15:19 2006. |
From: ajithfederer on Sun Feb 19 22:16:52 2006. |
From: great on Sun Feb 19 22:22:10 2006. |
From: Justice on Sun Feb 19 22:23:02 2006. |
From: Alien on Sun Feb 19 22:23:22 2006. |
From: Sanguine Sridhar on Sun Feb 19 22:24:58 2006. |
From: Alien on Sun Feb 19 22:26:57 2006. |
great wrote: |
its hard to select from the above combo mentioned, all the films with above mentioned dir are amazing hey u missed Nammavar dir forgot his full name its sethu............ |
From: great on Sun Feb 19 22:31:34 2006. |
From: kanya_kris on Sun Feb 19 22:34:33 2006. |
From: joe on Sun Feb 19 23:50:15 2006. |
From: Thirumaran on Mon Feb 20 0:00:56 2006. |
From: Sinthiya on Mon Feb 20 1:22:11 2006. |
From: sandiyar_k on Mon Feb 20 1:23:19 2006. |
From: joe on Mon Feb 20 2:15:31 2006. |
From: P_R on Mon Feb 20 3:16:33 2006. |
From: terminator on Mon Feb 20 4:07:38 2006. |
Thirumaran wrote: |
I think it was BharathiRaja who first brought great talents from Kamal through movies like 16 vayathinilae and Sigappu Rojakkal..
So i go for him. |
From: Tirupathi on Mon Feb 20 4:09:10 2006. |
From: gganesh on Mon Feb 20 5:06:36 2006. |
From: alwarpet_andavan on Mon Feb 20 5:25:31 2006. |
From: Fire on Mon Feb 20 5:26:39 2006. |
From: alwarpet_andavan on Mon Feb 20 5:39:14 2006. |
From: sandiyar_k on Mon Feb 20 6:24:47 2006. |
From: selvakumar on Mon Feb 20 6:29:59 2006. |
sandiyar_k wrote: |
KAMAL only can pick GOOD KAMAL from him
KAMAL is the Genius.. Even his guru KB told, i am not at the stage to direct kamal, becoz he is very far from me..i only need to learn from him... so KAMAL is the best director for KAMAL |
From: Alien on Mon Feb 20 8:39:26 2006. |
Prabhu Ram wrote: |
When you can't answer the question you twist the question
Direction is everything and nothing. The genius start when pen hits paper. So the screenwriter and director are quite intertwined. And in cases where the screenwriter is a self-confessed ghost director and taskmaster much of the filmmaking can be attributed to him. Considering: MMKR Thevar Magan Guna Mahanadhi Hey Ram Aalavandhaan Anbe Sivam Virumaandi Mumbai Xpress I vote for Kamalhassan. |
From: selvakumar on Mon Feb 20 8:56:13 2006. |
From: nilavupriyan on Mon Feb 20 9:29:09 2006. |
From: kannannn on Mon Feb 20 10:02:27 2006. |
nilavupriyan wrote: |
kamal!
he is the mentor behind guna,mahanadhi,kuridhipunal and anbe sivam he is the director of hey raam and virumaandi! next choice would be singeetham...excellent director.. aboorva sagodharargal,pesum padam,micheal madhana kamarajan....wonderful movies! |
From: nilavupriyan on Mon Feb 20 10:05:47 2006. |
kannannn wrote: | ||
That's what I had in mind too . In fact Singeetham comes a very close second. Kamal himself said in an interview that it was his meeting with Singeetham at a Filmfare award function that led to their long standing collaboration and he is the director in whose work he interferes least. Starting with Raaja Paarvai till MMKR they have set the benchmark against which future films will be judged ('is this comedy as good as MMKR?', 'is this double action flick as good as Aboorva Sagodharargal?'). |
From: Shakthiprabha. on Mon Feb 20 12:57:32 2006. |
From: Sinthiya on Mon Feb 20 20:16:30 2006. |
From: Alien on Mon Feb 20 22:30:43 2006. |
From: ranjit_g on Tue Feb 21 16:35:08 2006. |
From: ranjit_g on Tue Feb 21 16:37:51 2006. |
kannannn wrote: |
That's what I had in mind too . In fact Singeetham comes a very close second. Kamal himself said in an interview that it was his meeting with Singeetham at a Filmfare award function that led to their long standing collaboration and he is the director in whose work he interferes least. Starting with Raaja Paarvai till MMKR they have set the benchmark against which future films will be judged ('is this comedy as good as MMKR?', 'is this double action flick as good as Aboorva Sagodharargal?'). |
From: Justice on Tue Feb 21 17:40:23 2006. |
From: nickraman on Tue Feb 21 19:25:59 2006. |
From: m_23_bayarea on Tue Feb 21 20:18:44 2006. |
Justice wrote: |
Kamal never interfers with anyone. He may give advices but the directors are more than willing to listen to the one and only genius in Tamil Cinema now. |
From: m_23_bayarea on Tue Feb 21 20:19:11 2006. |
nickraman wrote: |
He and Rao are the cinema of today, not like Vijay and Perarsu's repeat filler stories. |
From: Justice on Tue Feb 21 22:30:45 2006. |
m_23_bayarea wrote: |
Ajith says, "Ha ha ha ha ha !!! CITIZENNNNN" |
From: Tirupathi on Wed Feb 22 3:48:17 2006. |
From: Fire on Wed Feb 22 3:50:08 2006. |
Tirupathi wrote: |
Kamal + Perarasu = alwarpettai |
From: terminator on Wed Feb 22 3:56:25 2006. |
Fire wrote: | ||
|
From: Navin on Wed Feb 22 3:58:14 2006. |
terminator wrote: | ||||
nakkalukku solran. Neenge yean ippadi avatarla kobapaduringa.. |
From: Justice on Wed Feb 22 4:17:04 2006. |
From: ranjit_g on Wed Feb 22 11:28:16 2006. |
Justice wrote: |
Kamal never interfers with anyone. He may give advices but the directors are more than willing to listen to the one and only genius in Tamil Cinema now. |
Quote: |
He and Rao are the cinema of today, not like Vijay and Perarsu's repeat filler stories. |
From: ranjit_g on Wed Feb 22 11:32:22 2006. |
joe wrote: |
Balachandar ---------- Arangetram Avargal Mootru mudichu Aval oru thodar kathai Apoorva ragangal Varumaiyin Niram sivappu Unnai mudiyum thambi Punnahai Mannan Marosarithra Ek du Je kelie |
From: njv on Wed Feb 22 11:32:31 2006. |
ranjit_g wrote: |
who asked u to brong in vijay and perarasu here?anyway the last 2 movies of vijay+perarasu have been super duper hits.but wht abt KK and ME?who is this rao?what is he without kamal in tamil cinema? |
From: great on Wed Feb 22 11:33:38 2006. |
ranjit_g wrote: |
who asked u to brong in vijay and perarasu here?anyway the last 2 movies of vijay+perarasu have been super duper hits.but wht abt KK and ME?who is this rao?what is he without kamal in tamil cinema? |
From: Tirupathi on Wed Feb 22 11:34:59 2006. |
From: Justice on Wed Feb 22 17:13:01 2006. |
ranjit_g wrote: |
who told u kamla never interferes with anyone?even die hard kamal fans have admitted that he interferes. |
Quote: |
who asked u to brong in vijay and perarasu here?anyway the last 2 movies of vijay+perarasu have been super duper hits.but wht abt KK and ME?who is this rao?what is he without kamal in tamil cinema? |
From: ranjit_g on Thu Feb 23 1:14:53 2006. |
Justice wrote: |
I'm a die hard fan and I don't admit that
what are you trying to prove here or are you saying your favourites don't interfere? Whatever Kamal does are better than your sivakasi not a hit, so stop exaggerating as if it was a super hit also enough of your rubbish here, get to ur threads |
From: Justice on Thu Feb 23 1:17:20 2006. |
ranjit_g wrote: |
i didnt want 2 bring perarasu and vijay here.but since someone mentioned abt them i had 2.i dnt like perarasu either.anyway sivakasi is a super hit.sivakasi and thiruppachi r among the top 5 grossers of 2005 behind CM,anniyan and ghajini |
From: njv on Thu Feb 23 1:33:17 2006. |
From: ranjit_g on Thu Feb 23 1:50:05 2006. |
From: selvakumar on Thu Feb 23 3:18:16 2006. |
njv wrote: |
Guys its simple. If you are good at something and you see mistake happening, you will correct the folks. Its human nature. Since Kamal "knows" stuff, he attempt to correct (interfere?). Those who dont know that stand on the corner playing video games. |
From: sandiyar_k on Thu Feb 23 6:24:19 2006. |
ranjit_g wrote: | ||
do u think kamal never interfered in movies like guna,mahanadi,anbe sivam and MX?u can think whatever u like,but i am pretty sure that he interferes. i didnt want 2 bring perarasu and vijay here.but since someone mentioned abt them i had 2.i dnt like perarasu either.anyway sivakasi is a super hit.sivakasi and thiruppachi r among the top 5 grossers of 2005 behind CM,anniyan and ghajini |
From: Alien on Thu Feb 23 6:36:49 2006. |
njv wrote: |
Guys its simple. If you are good at something and you see mistake happening, you will correct the folks. Its human nature. Since Kamal "knows" stuff, he attempt to correct (interfere?). Those who dont know that stand on the corner playing video games. |
njv wrote: |
BTW SSRao is one of THE talented director in India and only KH understood from kollywood. Rest of them are generations below to understand directors like SSRao, KV and the likes.
|
From: joe on Thu Feb 23 6:49:46 2006. |
From: sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar on Thu Feb 23 8:48:30 2006. |
joe wrote: |
Friends,
what are the non-kamal starred SSR directed movies? I really don't know even one. |
From: Tirupathi on Thu Feb 23 10:10:55 2006. |
From: alwarpet_andavan on Thu Feb 23 10:21:10 2006. |
From: great on Thu Feb 23 10:25:43 2006. |
alwarpet_andavan wrote: |
Aandavar irundha A movie kuda classy-a irukkum.
Unga range Parangimalai Jothi theatre "bit" varaikkum dhaan-nu enakku theriyum. Ungalukku Visay-Perarasu orgy dhaan othu varum! |
From: Rajkamal on Thu Feb 23 11:26:20 2006. |
sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar wrote: | ||
not even one of his movies without kamal is a hit, only one i remember in Little John - Jyothika acted in it |
From: ranjit_g on Thu Feb 23 12:56:03 2006. |
sandiyar_k wrote: |
Involvement kamal made on GUNA,MAHANADHI, AS and MX gave great quality cinema !!!! |
Quote: |
before starting SIVAJI what Rajini did with SHANKAR ????? KAMAL always thinking as FUTURISTIC !!!! if your rajini didn't compete with him, don't call it as interfere |
From: Justice on Thu Feb 23 18:04:41 2006. |
ranjit_g wrote: |
all top heroes tell their views to the director,but once the movie is started they give it all to the director.but in kamal's case his interference continues even after the shooting commences.there is a lot of difference.
what do u mean by thinking futuristic?he thought futuristic and MX,AS etc flopped at the BO. rajini didnt compete with kamal?dont u remember wht happened when CM and MX released 2gether? |
From: alwarpet_andavan on Fri Feb 24 6:20:27 2006. |
From: Girish11 on Fri Feb 24 19:24:56 2006. |
From: P_R on Sat Feb 25 5:44:56 2006. |
Girish11 wrote: |
Nice topic.
My most favourite Kamal movies are Mahanadhiand Guna so my votes go to Sandhana Barathi, Yes, probably it is true that Kamal has played a big hand in these movies but even if SB's input is 20%, still it is the combination of these two which has produced these gems. So my vote is for a Kamal's movie with Santhana Barathi. Further, one can never be sure about how much SB's contribution is, only people who made the movie will know it. I have not seen any other movie of SB except Kadamai Kanniyam Kattupaadu which is a good movie too. So I will not ignore SB as a non contributor. |
From: Girish11 on Sat Feb 25 10:46:23 2006. |
Prabhu Ram wrote: |
Long Time ! I also enjoyed Santhanabarathi's Vietnam Colony. Prabhu-Koundamani backed by Crazy Mohan. It was a remake of a Malayalam film. I don't think he has directed anything after that. He was the associate director in Hey Ram (I am not sure about Virumaandi, informed hubbers confirm). Kamal,who is notoriously sparing in praise, once said: "Barathikkum enakkum oru varaimurai ellam kidayaathu. avar direct pannaa naan associate-a kooda work pannuvEn." Though one may be quite sure that's never going to happen, it is indicator that Santhanabarathi cannot be clubbed with Sundar C. |
From: Nerd on Sat Feb 25 13:10:18 2006. |
Quote: |
SB except Kadamai Kanniyam Kattupaadu which is a good movie too. |
From: P_R on Sat Feb 25 16:11:23 2006. |
Girish11 wrote: |
If I am not mistaken, earlier, SB and P.Vasu used to work together under the name of Barathi-Vasu right? |
From: Aravind_06 on Sun Feb 26 10:03:23 2006. |
From: Sinthiya on Sun Feb 26 23:29:50 2006. |
From: Shakthiprabha. on Mon Feb 27 4:59:28 2006. |
From: Cinefan on Mon Feb 27 5:04:23 2006. |
kasi_sce wrote: | ||
KKK by SB thats news to me. Thats a terrific movie, produced by rajkamal I think. |
From: villan007 on Mon Feb 27 5:08:21 2006. |
Shakthiprabha wrote: |
Sinthiya
WHY do u say its a SAD movie? He and his wife LIVED an excellent life. Its a happy reminiscence. With that he deceases to join her (assumably) I cherished the COMPLETENESS in the movie. |
From: Shakthiprabha. on Mon Feb 27 5:29:28 2006. |
From: villan007 on Mon Feb 27 5:32:37 2006. |
From: Shakthiprabha. on Mon Feb 27 5:35:04 2006. |
From: Kumar on Mon Feb 27 5:35:29 2006. |
From: breadpuli on Mon Feb 27 6:16:11 2006. |
From: Alien on Mon Feb 27 22:24:09 2006. |
From: rachel on Mon Feb 27 22:45:17 2006. |
From: Alien on Mon Feb 27 22:48:41 2006. |
rachel wrote: |
forrest gump-tom hanks |
From: rachel on Mon Feb 27 22:53:11 2006. |
vasanth_luv wrote: | ||
Wow, u've seen it & liked it ! Just kidding ...Thatz my most fav of alltime .... |
From: Alien on Mon Feb 27 22:57:58 2006. |
rachel wrote: |
...but funny movie... |
From: rachel on Mon Feb 27 23:00:51 2006. |
vasanth_luv wrote: | ||
|
From: Alien on Mon Feb 27 23:06:44 2006. |
From: rachel on Mon Feb 27 23:10:06 2006. |
vasanth_luv wrote: |
I knew very well, that u can perceive things like that only ... Thats why I was first surprised to know u liked Forrest Gump.. but later ur reason was "funny movie" .....U didn't disappoint me ......
U didn't get the morals of those movies .... Did I ever say u my top 10 of Kamal ?? ..... so better ....... |
From: Alien on Mon Feb 27 23:11:19 2006. |
rachel wrote: |
you like movies where hero acts as dumb |
From: Alien on Mon Feb 27 23:16:19 2006. |
rachel wrote: |
tell me your top 10 kamal movies..i want to know ur taste.. |
From: rachel on Mon Feb 27 23:18:27 2006. |
vasanth_luv wrote: | ||
.. If then I shud like many super heroes' movies .... Sorry no more on this ... |
From: Justice on Mon Feb 27 23:20:22 2006. |
From: rachel on Mon Feb 27 23:20:56 2006. |
vasanth_luv wrote: | ||
Its tough to narrow down now .... But I tell u ... Dhevar Magan , Sippikkul muthu, Salangai Oli, Virumaandi, Mahanathi, Hey ram, MMKR, Anbe Sivam, Guna, Aboorva Sagodharargal ..... Not really in order ...... Sorry rachel, If i was rude ... |
From: njv on Mon Feb 27 23:22:53 2006. |
rachel wrote: | ||||
i don't remember watching all these movies..but virumandi was good...(he acted as innocent again). hey ram again he acted as innocent.. |
From: Alien on Mon Feb 27 23:25:12 2006. |
rachel wrote: |
how can u say 'sorry no more on this' after mentioning 'many super heroes' |
From: rachel on Mon Feb 27 23:25:19 2006. |
Justice wrote: |
rachel... you are better off with watching cartoon... these movies are for big guys like vasanth, me.. and many other guys who have got brain.... not for you... so... ... |
From: Justice on Mon Feb 27 23:26:52 2006. |
vasanth_luv wrote: |
Justice , I rem once u said Sippikkul muthu is one of ur fav Kamal movie .. ... (If u've not seen Forrest Gump, watch it too .....) |
From: rachel on Mon Feb 27 23:27:11 2006. |
vasanth_luv wrote: | ||
Sorry, lets leave this ... I didn't mean anybody other than who a Kamal fan would say & Vijay Kanth ..... I take my words back ... so truce other ppl ... Justice , I rem once u said Sippikkul muthu is one of ur fav Kamal movie .. ... (If u've not seen Forrest Gump, watch it too .....) Rachel, Very few r super heroes in real life & none like our tamil heroes would want u to believe like ... |
From: Alien on Mon Feb 27 23:30:20 2006. |
rachel wrote: |
i don't understand this... i'm sure you'd say 'no more' |
From: rachel on Mon Feb 27 23:30:20 2006. |
njv wrote: | ||||||
Rachel do you see movies at all? You call Forrest Gump as funny and KH in Virumaandi as innocent. Hmm... |
From: rachel on Mon Feb 27 23:31:34 2006. |
vasanth_luv wrote: | ||
I won't say "no more" here ... prolli u didn get me ... thats ok.... forget it ... Justice ..... |
From: Justice on Mon Feb 27 23:31:56 2006. |
rachel wrote: |
i've watched them...but they are not my type of movies though... but forest gump is good...i like tom hanks movies. in virumandi kamal acted as dumb because he didn't realise pasupathy was villain... |
From: Alien on Mon Feb 27 23:33:23 2006. |
rachel wrote: |
i won... |
From: njv on Mon Feb 27 23:33:37 2006. |
Justice wrote: | ||
sure perarasu films will satisfy you... even his vadugu film will be be good for ya |
From: rachel on Mon Feb 27 23:34:09 2006. |
Justice wrote: | ||
sure perarasu films will satisfy you... even his vadugu film will be be good for ya |
From: Justice on Mon Feb 27 23:35:10 2006. |
njv wrote: |
Justice I dont know if you know this, but Perarasu is indeed a very good film. After watching the preview of perarasu, thala (ajith) asked the director to direct his next film. Its unfortunate that its not getting released. Remember Vijayakanth acted in Ramana and went on becoming a super duper hit (and a good one too). |
From: Justice on Mon Feb 27 23:36:16 2006. |
rachel wrote: |
you arenot going to watch thipupathi |
From: rachel on Mon Feb 27 23:42:21 2006. |
Justice wrote: | ||
I meant director perarasu.... anyway this is a news to me... ... but hope Ajith doesn't act in it |
From: rachel on Mon Feb 27 23:44:51 2006. |
Justice wrote: | ||
I watch Ajith movies... I don't care about directors.... but if perarsu direct one more Ajith movie, I won't watch it but you like perarasu |
From: njv on Mon Feb 27 23:45:55 2006. |
Justice wrote: | ||
I meant director perarasu.... anyway this is a news to me... ... but hope Ajith doesn't act in it |
From: Justice on Mon Feb 27 23:46:33 2006. |
rachel wrote: |
i don't like him..but i want ajith to do atleast 1 movie with him...his movie will give ajith larger than life image |
From: Sinthiya on Mon Feb 27 23:50:51 2006. |
Shakthiprabha wrote: |
well I always tend to THINK from the point of view of the person who LIVED the life. HE HAS lived to the fullest. HE DYING is natural. (ofcourse sad for the kith and kins ). Howover old mom and dad are......... WE STILL WISH........ THEY WOULD ETERNALLY BE WITH US u made my heart weigh now |
From: njv on Mon Feb 27 23:52:18 2006. |
From: rachel on Mon Feb 27 23:55:13 2006. |
njv wrote: |
Most of the directors listed above worked only with 1 or 2 movies only with KH except KB. KB is my real choice, though I am not a big fan of KB.
I like KH to work with Bala and Selvaragavan too and hope it happens soon. |
From: ranjit_g on Wed Mar 1 13:59:15 2006. |
rachel wrote: | ||
i think kamal'll choose selvaragavan than bala |
From: Justice on Wed Mar 1 14:52:37 2006. |
rachel wrote: | ||
i think kamal'll choose selvaragavan than bala |
From: Alien on Tue Mar 28 21:53:07 2006. |
From: great on Tue Mar 28 22:03:13 2006. |
From: Kollywoodfan on Tue Mar 28 22:25:31 2006. |
great wrote: |
wow Alien , salagai oli still |
From: great on Tue Mar 28 22:26:47 2006. |
Kollywoodfan wrote: | ||
I know, it's great!! |
From: Alien on Wed Mar 29 0:31:45 2006. |
From: alwarpet_andavan on Wed Mar 29 6:06:14 2006. |
great wrote: |
how about my Hey raam still |
From: selvakumar on Wed Mar 29 6:48:55 2006. |
From: Alien on Wed Mar 29 21:27:24 2006. |
From: Raikkonen on Wed Mar 29 23:27:17 2006. |
From: selvakumar on Fri Mar 31 2:13:09 2006. |
Alien wrote: |
Good analysis Selva keep going ...
... Kaathala Kaathala was a bad film of SSRao- KH .... (though, I wouldn't mind watching it 4 the comedy) ... BTW, what was K.Viswanath - Kamal 3rd film , Subha sangalpam (Paasa valai )about ? |
From: joe on Fri Mar 31 4:04:40 2006. |
From: Alien on Fri Mar 31 9:56:24 2006. |
joe wrote: |
Yes,'Paasavalai' was average in box office whereas original telugu 'Subha sangalbam' was a super hit.I think in this movie Ilayaraja was missing ,Maragatha mani did music. |
From: joe on Fri Mar 31 10:22:19 2006. |
From: Alien on Fri Mar 31 10:30:32 2006. |
joe wrote: |
but something missing without K.Viswanath - IR combo...It is a must watch movie for die-hard kamal fans. |
From: Thirumaran on Fri Mar 31 10:35:07 2006. |
joe wrote: |
Paasavalai..I watched this movie on release day at chennai..It was a class movie..But full of tragedies ..Director K.viswanath himself acted in important role .Heroine is Aamni ,who did an excellent job .Kamal as usual rock in acting..Music also was good ,but something missing without K.Viswanath - IR combo...It is a must watch movie for die-hard kamal fans. |